DOCSLIB.ORG

Feyerabend and Science Writes, "There Is No Valid Reason for Astron- Omers

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Feyerabend and Science Writes, universes are equally possible," Abdelkader Feyerabend and Science writes, "there is no valid reason for astron- omers ... to confine their attention exclu- ively to the study" of Copernican cosmology. Martin Gardner He is convinced that "the only way to ascer- tain conclusively which of the two vastly dif- Professor Feyerabend complains that I fo- of the Big Bang, may or may not be fruitful ferent universes is our actual one is by pierc- cused on his minor assertions, ignoring his (compelling evidence is too thin). But ing the earth vertically to a depth of 12,742 main arguments. Let me reply first with a astrology? Or the efficacy of rain dances? kilometers, a project which does not seem fable. Feyerabend repeatedly likens the science to be possible in the foreseeable future." Suppose an English professor of a dis- community to the Roman Catholic church I am not sure that drilling through the tinguished American university writes a big in the inflexibility of its dogmas. I can think earth would decide conclusively between the book about poetry, most of it devoted to the of no comparison less apt. The speed with two theories—there are clever ways to get sensible thesis that cultural forces strongly which modern science can overturn old around an unfavorable result by modeling condition literary tastes. A poet with a high dogmas and the zeal with which it tries to the cosmos in various kinds of closed reputation in one age is forgotten in the next, falsify present dogmas are awesome devel- hyperspace— but that is beside the point. The while poets considered minor are elevated to opments in human history. It was not until point is, does Feyerabend think Abdelkader top rank. We should, therefore, be humble 1980 that the Pope initiated an inquiry to is crazy? in our enthusiasms and recognize the ab- determine if the Inquisition acted properly If so, why? If the geocosmos is un- sence of ironclad rules for distinguishing be- in condemning Galileo. Einstein abandoned worthy of empirical testing, on what basis tween good poetry and doggerel. Dante and Newtonian physics, and quantum theory dis- is such a value judgment made? Should the Shakespeare are incommensurable. In carded classical causality, in just a few geocosmos be taught in Muslim universities poetry, anything goes. decades. How soon does Feyerabend expect as a serious and incommensurable rival to Mixed into these commonplace obser- the Roman church to discard the virgin birth Copernican cosmology? If not, why does vations are remarks in which the professor and the immaculate conception? Feyerabend think fundamentalist crea- berates his colleagues for their contemptuous Last week I was favored with a copy of tionism, with its flood theory of fossils, neglect of Edgar Guest and Ella Wheeler a paper by a Muslim scientist, Mostafa A. should be taught here in state-supported Wilcox. Why, he asks, are there no college Abdelkader, of Alexandria, scheduled to ap- schools? If the geocosmos doesn't go, why courses and Ph.D. theses devoted to the pear in a journal called Speculations in doesn't it go? And if it doesn't, what is wrong work of these two popular bards? Footnotes Science and Technology.* It is titled: "A with saying that competing theories are com- disclose that he has been reading Guest with Geocosmos: Mapping Outer Space into a mensurable, and that, although scientific gusto. On the book's flyleaf, under the Hollow Earth." No, it is not a joke. Mr. "truth" is pragmatic and hence fallible, there author's photograph, are these immortal Abdelkader revives an old hypothesis that the are excellent grounds for ruling out astrology lines by Eddie: earth is hollow and we live on the inside of as worthy of research. What is wrong with the shell, but he defends it with remarkable maintaining that there is such a thing as "well If it's worth while and you're sure of the sophistication. First he performs a geometri- founded knowledge," or that the history of right of it, cal inversion of conventional spacetime that scientific theories displays rational progress Stick to it, boy and make a real fight of it! exchanges every point believed by establish- of a sort qualitatively unlike progress in ment cosmologists to lie outside the earth metaphysics and the arts? Can you blame a reviewer for ignoring with a point inside. Then he adjusts all Feyerabend accuses me of statistical the book's broad conventional arguments to physical laws accordingly. Straight rays of fudging when I say that "most philosophers" concentrate on the author's eccentric tastes? light become circular arcs, and the speed of do not buy his extreme relativism. It is true Similarly with Feyerabend. Of course any- light decreases as it gets closer to the center that I cited only four thinkers (Feyerabend thing goes in science if this means that stan- of the hollow earth. All galaxies hitherto con- forgot about Thomas Kuhn and Ernest dards, theories, and observing instruments sidered enormous become microscopic ob- Nagel), but I know many other philosophers constantly change and that there is no way jects inside, much smaller than the moon. personally who, although they have not to foresee how they will change. It is hard to Everything appears to us exactly as we in fact published anything about Feyerabend, have predict, Bohr once said, especially the future. see it. The great merit of this inside-out a much lower opinion of him than I have. And who today wants to deny that social and cosmology, the Egyptian scientist maintains, If Feyerabend doubts my "most," let him hire political forces play roles in shaping science? is that it relieves us of the anxiety of believ- an impartial pollster to sample the opinions Everything human beings do is something ing in a universe of such fantastic size that of one hundred leading philosophers. In view human beings do, and therefore is part of our earth becomes infinitesimal. of his repeated insistence that all living culture. These are views John Dewey took It is not easy to see how the geocosmos philosophers of science except himself are in- for granted. And Russell and Carnap and can be falsified. Indeed, its logical consis- competent, it seems odd that he would ex- Popper. But it does not follow from these tency raises deep questions about the role of pect the outcome of such a poll to contradict views that competing theories are incommen- convention in cosmology. "Since both my estimate. surable and that "everybody's judgment is as Although there is nothing in Feyera- good as everybody else's." *Speculations in Science and Technology is an bend's response that he has not said over and It is here, where Feyerabend pushes his Australian journal, now in its sixth year, "devoted over and over again, I am surprised by the relativism to extremes, that he starts to ped- to speculative papers in the physical, mathematical, uncharacteristic mildness of his ad hominem biological, medical and engineering sciences." dle nonsense. We all know that a wild theory, Fey- remarks tossed my way. It makes it a plea- erabend is on its editorial board. such as Alan Guth's new inflationary model sure to exchange banter with him. • Summer 1983 59 .
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Mount Shasta Annotated Bibliography Chapter 18
    Mount Shasta Annotated Bibliography Chapter 18 Legends: Other This section contains a number of unrelated entries, including material about the oft-mentioned bell legends, the little people legends, and UFO legends. Some miscellaneous entries, arguably termed legends, include an entry about two Alaskan mountains named for Mt. Shasta, and an entry for the 1930s' slang phrase "From Mt. Shasta." Some of the materials exhibit a rare originality, especially Caroling's comic-book styled Mount Shasta and the Galaxy People. This section also includes a number of miscellaneous entries which in one way or another convey the mystic and spiritual expectations of some visitors to Mt. Shasta. The [MS number] indicates the Mount Shasta Special Collection accession numbers used by the College of the Siskiyous Library. [MS2156]. Avenell, Bruce K. Mount Shasta: The Vital Essence, A Spiritual Explorers Guide. Escondido: Eureka Society, 1999. 154 pp. Subtitle: To the Natural and Man-Made Consciousness-Enhancing Structures on Mt. Shasta The author recounts spiritual lessons and experiences from several decades of travel to Mount Shasta. Sand Flat, Grey Butte, Panther Meadows, etc, are described as special places. The author has a spiritual communication with a spiritual being named Duja, on Mt. Shasta and elsewhere. The book begins: 'A small group of very dedicated people, The Eureka Society has been coming to Mt. Shasta, California, for thirty years. They come to communicate with a spiritual being with whom many of them have had spiritual experiences while camping, hiking, and meditating on the mountain.' (p. ix). 'Although Duja, or any of the spirit beings on the mountain for that matter, may appear to be standing still she must have complete control of attitude, conscious focus, mental velocity and be monitoring the expenditure of energy necessary for you to see her.
    [Show full text]
  • Lost Continents and the Hollow Earth: I Remember Lemuria and the Shaver Mystery Pdf, Epub, Ebook
    LOST CONTINENTS AND THE HOLLOW EARTH: I REMEMBER LEMURIA AND THE SHAVER MYSTERY PDF, EPUB, EBOOK David Hatcher Childress, Richard Shaver | 280 pages | 25 Feb 2015 | Adventures Unlimited Press | 9780932813633 | English | Kempton, IL, United States Lost Continents and the Hollow Earth: I Remember Lemuria and The Shaver Mystery PDF Book Gene and Randall present a Paracast favorite, author and researcher Kevin D. Mar 3, Jun 4, Is Mason Reynolds real? We shall land you in exactly seven minutes! In that case, we might be able to travel the same path, but with a different view of reality. In the myths and traditions of the subterranean world it is often said that the world's surface was yet to suffer a terrible world war Third World War , which would though be ended by earthquakes, other natural disasters and a switching of the poles and the deaths therefrom of two thirds of humanity. Allen, Gene and other long-time researchers, including Rick Hilberg, were pioneers of the teen Ufology movement in the early s. The sub-cities were created as refuges for the people and as safe havens for sacred records, teachings and technologies that were cherished by these ancient cultures. The discussion begins by remembering their first meetings and ongoing association with Steiger, and segues into the seldom-revealed limitations of writing books covering the UFO genre and similar subjects. We welcome investigative writer and researcher Peter Robbins. In comparison, "The Return of Sathanas" is more polished and conventional, though still laced with the oddities and ideosyncrasies of the previous work.
    [Show full text]
  • Edmond Halley's Extravagant Hypothesis
    “We have Adventured to Make the Earth Hollow”: Edmond Halley’s Extravagant Hypothesis Peter W. Sinnema University of Alberta This essay revisits Edmond Halley’s schema of a multi-sphered, hollow earth, presented to the Royal Society in 1691 as a hypothetical resolution to the problem of magnetic variation. I open my investigation with a reading of Michael Dahl’s ªnal portrait of the great astronomer (1736), which enig- matically reproduced a diagram of the hollow earth that Halley had ap- pended to his original “Account [. .] of the Internal Parts of the Earth” in the Philosophical Transactions. My essay has the goal of enhancing our ap- preciation not only of Halley’s aptitudes as a theorist of the earth sciences, but as the dexterous practitioner of a language felicitously attuned to the early development of that ªeld. I provide a comprehensive exposition of Halley’s self-styled “Extravagant” hypothesis and argue that his attachment to it was sustained by his adherence to the tenet of a divinely ordained, natural economy. I also position Halley’s “Account” as the originary moment of a lit- erary sub-genre—the hollow earth fantasy or romance—that ºourished in England and America in his wake. Today, Dahl’s painting gestures simul- taneously to Halley’s conception of a habitable inner earth and to a literary tradition that embraced that idea as its central imaginary novelty. 1. Halley’s Enigmatic Legacy Portrait In 1736, an 80-year-old Edmond Halley, digniªed by the academic robes of his alma mater, Queens College Oxford, sat down at the brush of trans- planted Swedish artist Michael Dahl for his ªnal ofªcial portrait.1 (Fig.
    [Show full text]
  • Archons (Commanders) [NOTICE: They Are NOT Anlien Parasites], and Then, in a Mirror Image of the Great Emanations of the Pleroma, Hundreds of Lesser Angels
    A R C H O N S HIDDEN RULERS THROUGH THE AGES A R C H O N S HIDDEN RULERS THROUGH THE AGES WATCH THIS IMPORTANT VIDEO UFOs, Aliens, and the Question of Contact MUST-SEE THE OCCULT REASON FOR PSYCHOPATHY Organic Portals: Aliens and Psychopaths KNOWLEDGE THROUGH GNOSIS Boris Mouravieff - GNOSIS IN THE BEGINNING ...1 The Gnostic core belief was a strong dualism: that the world of matter was deadening and inferior to a remote nonphysical home, to which an interior divine spark in most humans aspired to return after death. This led them to an absorption with the Jewish creation myths in Genesis, which they obsessively reinterpreted to formulate allegorical explanations of how humans ended up trapped in the world of matter. The basic Gnostic story, which varied in details from teacher to teacher, was this: In the beginning there was an unknowable, immaterial, and invisible God, sometimes called the Father of All and sometimes by other names. “He” was neither male nor female, and was composed of an implicitly finite amount of a living nonphysical substance. Surrounding this God was a great empty region called the Pleroma (the fullness). Beyond the Pleroma lay empty space. The God acted to fill the Pleroma through a series of emanations, a squeezing off of small portions of his/its nonphysical energetic divine material. In most accounts there are thirty emanations in fifteen complementary pairs, each getting slightly less of the divine material and therefore being slightly weaker. The emanations are called Aeons (eternities) and are mostly named personifications in Greek of abstract ideas.
    [Show full text]
  • Polar Media and the Nazi Occult
    UC Irvine Plenaries: After Media — Embodiment and Context Title Cold Culture: Polar Media and the Nazi Occult Permalink https://escholarship.org/uc/item/7nz0j5p5 Author Krapp, Peter Publication Date 2009-12-12 Peer reviewed eScholarship.org Powered by the California Digital Library University of California Cold Culture: Polar Media and the Nazi Occult Peter Krapp UC Irvine Film and Media / Visual Studies ZOT 2435, Irvine CA 92697, USA +1 (949) 824 3031 [email protected] ABSTRACT image, the most widely distributed image, and the most often The inaccessibility of the North and South Pole makes them a reproduced image ever: that of Planet Earth, taken by the crucible for persistent questions of access and data visualization astronauts of Apollo 17 on December 7th, 1972. “When you get that characterize the information age. Arctic and Antarctic have 250,000 miles from earth and look back the earth is really become increasingly topical in popular cinema as well as in media beautiful. You can see the roundness, you can see from the arts. As representations of polar regions grapple with the fictions snowcap of the North Pole to the ice caps of the South Pole. You that mark representations of science, they illustrate the perils and can see across continents. You look for the strings that are holding 1 perks of polar travel in the age of digital media. This essay sets this earth up and you look for the fulcrum and it doesn't exist.” out to trace representations of the Arctic and Antarctic in media American minimalist composer Terry Riley was commissioned by history.
    [Show full text]
  • Drawing on the Victorians Eries in Victorian Studies S Series Editors: Joseph Mclaughlin and Elizabeth Miller Katherine D
    Drawing on the Victorians eries in Victorian Studies S Series editors: Joseph McLaughlin and Elizabeth Miller Katherine D. Harris, Forget Me Not: The Rise of the British Literary Annual, 1823–1835 Rebecca Rainof, The Victorian Novel of Adulthood: Plot and Purgatory in Fictions of Maturity Erika Wright, Reading for Health: Medical Narratives and the Nineteenth-Century Novel Daniel Bivona and Marlene Tromp, editors, Culture and Money in the Nineteenth Century: Abstracting Economics Anna Maria Jones and Rebecca N. Mitchell, editors, Drawing on the Victorians: The Palimpsest of Victorian and Neo-Victorian Graphic Texts Drawing on the Victorians The Palimpsest of Victorian and Neo-Victorian Graphic Texts edited by Anna Maria Jones and Rebecca N. Mitchell with an afterword by Kate Flint ohio university press athens Ohio University Press, Athens, Ohio 45701 ohioswallow.com © 2017 by Ohio University Press All rights reserved To obtain permission to quote, reprint, or otherwise reproduce or distribute material from Ohio University Press publications, please contact our rights and permissions department at (740) 593-1154 or (740) 593-4536 (fax). Printed in the United States of America Ohio University Press books are printed on acid-free paper ƒ ™ 27 26 25 24 23 22 21 20 19 18 17 5 4 3 2 1 Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data available upon request. Names: Jones, Anna Maria, 1972- editor. | Mitchell, Rebecca N. (Rebecca Nicole), 1976- editor. Title: Drawing on the Victorians : the palimpsest of Victorian and neo-Victorian graphic texts / edited by Anna Maria Jones and Rebecca N. Mitchell ; with an afterword by Kate Flint.
    [Show full text]
  • The Press, the Documentaries and the Byrd Archives
    THE AMERICAN ARCHIVIST Archives in Controversy: The Press, the Documentaries Downloaded from http://meridian.allenpress.com/american-archivist/article-pdf/62/2/307/2749198/aarc_62_2_t1u7854068882508.pdf by guest on 01 October 2021 and the Byrd Archives Raimund E. Goerler Abstract One of the major news stories of 1996 was the discovery and analysis of Richard Byrd's diary and notebook for his North Pole flight of 1926. Byrd's claim to be die first to fly to the North Pole was challenged by his contemporaries and by later historians. The diary provided new evidence, and the news of its existence and meaning fueled stories that reached every part of the globe. Interest in Byrd also inspired producers of three documentaries. The archivist who dealt widi reporters and producers discusses die media coverage, the challenges of working with reporters and producers of documentaries, and the impact of the publicity on an archival program. n May 9,1996, the seventieth anniversary of Richard Byrd's flight to the North Pole, Ohio State University ("OSU") announced the discovery Oof a diary of the flight. The story about Byrd's diary appeared in news- papers and on television and radio across the United States and Europe, and as far away as Australia. At die end of 1996 columnist George Will ranked the story as one of the year's biggest, especially because of an interpretation of the diary that cast doubt upon Byrd's accomplishment.1 Producers also followed the Byrd story and used archival materials for three separate television documentaries. Rarely have archivists experienced such controversy over an event covered by the media.2 The publicity and the dramatic productions that followed the 1 George F.
    [Show full text]
  • Flat, Hollow &Doomed +Skeptics &Religion, Psychic Detective, MTHFR
    SKEPTICISM . SCIENCE . SOCIETY Vol 38, No 1. March 2018 The Earth Flat, Hollow & Doomed +Skeptics & Religion, Psychic Detective, MTHFR Australian Skeptics . www.skeptics.com.au Skeptic_Cover_Mar18.indd 1 8/03/2018 11:14 pm The Skeptic March 18 Skeptical Groups in Australia NSW VIC Australian Skeptics Inc – Eran Segev Australian Skeptics (Vic) Inc – Chris Guest www.skeptics.com.au GPO Box 5166, Melbourne VIC 3001 PO Box 20, Beecroft, NSW 2119 Tel: 1 800 666 996 [email protected] Tel: 02 8094 1894; Mob: 0432 713 195; Fax: (02) 8088 4735 [email protected] Skeptics’ Café – Third Monday of every month, with guest speaker. Clyde Hotel, cnr Elgin and Cardigan Sts, Carlton. Meal Sydney Skeptics in the Pub – 6pm first Thursday of each from 6pm, speaker at 8pm sharp.($4 contribution). More details month at the Occidental Hotel, York Street in the city, near on our web site www.skeptics.com.au/vic Wynyard Park (meeting second floor) Dinner meetings are held on a regular basis. Ballarat Skeptics in the Pub http://facebook.com/groups/3978112230309544 Hunter Skeptics – John Turner Tel: (02) 4959 6286 [email protected] Geelong Skeptics Society Occasional social meetings at the Cricketers Arms Hotel, Cooks Contact: James Rolton [email protected] Hill. Those on the contact list will be sent details in advance. Online group: See Facebook for details. Currently meeting at 12.30 on third Sunday of each odd-numbered Hosting the Annual Surf Coast Summer Skepticamp (February) month. Gippsland Skeptics in the Pub Blue Mountains Skeptics Interested parties contact Mark Guerin or Martin Christian Power See Facebook for details.
    [Show full text]
  • Date: April 28, 2011
    A SCIENTIFIC APPROACH TO THOMAS PYNCHON’S MASON AND DIXON INTERACTIVE QUALIFYING PROJECT REPORT: SUBMITTED TO THE FACULTY OF THE WORCESTER POLYTECHNIC INSTITUTE IN PARTIAL FULFILLMENT OF THE REQUIREMENTS FOR THE DEGREE OF BACHELOR OF SCIENCE BY CHRISTOPHER HORGAN PHYSICS DATE: APRIL 28, 2011 Abstract This paper is an analysis of how a writer of fiction with a strong sense of social and moral values uses the scientific history of the 18th century to convey his ideals in an historical novel. Through a constant showcasing of both scientific and historical embellishments, Pynchon builds his argument against the surveying of right lines upon the Earth. These lines, he believes, serve only to separate a people and allow a government to have greater control over its divided citizens. 2 Table of Contents Abstract............................................................................................................................................................................................. 2 Table of Contents ........................................................................................................................................................................... 3 Table of Figures .............................................................................................................................................................................. 5 1 Introduction ..........................................................................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Hollow Earth 101
    307-8 Winter/Spring 2013-2014 SFRA Editor A publicationRe of the Scienceview Fiction Research Association Chris Pak University of Birmingham, Edgbaston, Birmingham, B15 2TT, UK. In this issue [email protected] SFRA Review Business Managing Editor Introductions ........................................................................................................2 Lars Schmeink Universität Hamburg, Institut für Anglis- tik und Amerikanistik, Von Melle Park 6 SFRA Business 20146 Hamburg. Meanwhile, at the EC HQ . ............................................................................2 [email protected] Upcoming Joint WisCon/SFRA ..........................................................................3 Making Connections ............................................................................................4 Nonfiction Editor Dominick Grace Brescia University College, 1285 Western Feature Interview Rd, London ON, N6G 3R4, Canada An Interview with Frederick Turner ..................................................................5 phone: 519-432-8353 ext. 28244. [email protected] Feature 101 Assistant Nonfiction Editor Hollow Earth 101 ................................................................................................13 Kevin Pinkham The Nursing Profession in the Fictional Star Trek Future. ...........................23 College of Arts and Sciences, Nyack College, 1 South Boulevard, Nyack, NY 10960 Nonfiction Reviews phone: 845-675-4526845-675-4526. Parabolas of Science Fiction ...............................................................................27
    [Show full text]
  • Antarctica in Science Fiction How About
    Antarctica in Science Fiction How about revisiting some of the most important early novels about Antarctica? Poe and Coleridge turned the White Continent into a gothic locale, with their dark romantic novels. The region had set in train the ghastly experiences of Coleridge’s “Ancient Mariner”, produced the culminating horrors of Poe’s “Narrative of Arthur Gordon Pym” and spawned the hideous amorphous aliens of H.P. Lovecraft’s “At the Mountains of Madness”. Surprisingly, the first novel ever published about Antarctica, “Symzonia”, was written before the continent was actually discovered, in the year 1820. The author was a firm believer in the ‘Hollow- Earth-Theory’ and this first book belongs hence to the proto-Science-Fiction line of Antarctic literary production. John Cleves Symmes, proposed in 1820 an idea about the inside of our terrestrial globe, which includes concentric spheres and a hollow interior, which allows people to live on the inside. The inner world, illuminated by a different sun, could be accessed via both poles. His idea would inspire a long line of Science-Fiction authors dealing with Antarctica, such as Edgar Allan Poe, “Manuscript found in a bottle” (1833) and “The Narrative of Arthur Gordon Pym” (1838), Jules Verne, who would finish the story which Poe had left inconclusive in 1897, under the title “The sphinx of the ice fields”. In 1931 H.P. Lovecraft would revive the gloomy ideas presented in both books in his novel “At the mountains of madness”. Antarctica was still being described as a fantastical place with a challenging mythological geography. In her studies Elizabeth Leane (2012) identified the main ideas, which would turn into a leitmotiv in literature for almost two hundred years.
    [Show full text]
  • The Inner Earth & Realm Of
    The Inner Earth & Realm of Aghartha http://www.thenewearth.org/InnerEarth.html The Inner Earth & Realm of Aghartha Aghartha In The Hollow Earth! By Dr Joshua David Stone The biggest cover-up of all time is the fact that there is a civilization of people living in the center of Earth, whose civilization's name is known as "Aghartha". This may be hard for some of you to believe. I know it was for me at first, however, I now have an absolute knowingness of the truth of this. To begin with, the Buddhists, in their theology fervently believe in its existence. They believe it 1 of 47 6/29/2008 10:39 PM The Inner Earth & Realm of Aghartha http://www.thenewearth.org/InnerEarth.html to be a race of super men and women who occasionally come to the surface to oversee the development of the human race. They also believe that this subterranean world has millions of inhabitants and many cities, and their capital is Shamballa. The Master of this world was believed to have given orders to the Dalai Lama of Tibet, who was his terrestrial representative. His messages were being transmitted through certain secret tunnels connecting this inner world with Tibet. The famous Russian channel, Nicholas Roerich, who was a channel for the Ascended Master, El Morya, claimed that Lhasa, the capital of Tibet, was connected by a tunnel with the inner earth, Shamballa. The entrance of this tunnel was guarded by lamas who were sworn to secrecy. A similar tunnel was believed to connect the secret chambers at the base of the great pyramid at Giza, and Agartha.
    [Show full text]