DOCSLIB.ORG

Edmond Vanmarie the University of Leeds Department of Sociology and Social Policy Division of History and Philosophy of Science

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Edmond Vanmarie the University of Leeds Department of Sociology and Social Policy Division of History and Philosophy of Science Re-presenting herbal medicine as phytotherapy: a strategy of professionalisation through the formation of a 'scientific' medicine. Edmond VanMarie Submitted in accordancewith the requirementsfor the degree of PhD The University of Leeds Department of Sociology and Social Policy & Division of History and Philosophy of Science in the School of Philosophy Submitted in March 2002 The candidate confirms that the work submitted is his own and that appropriate credit has been given where reference has been made to the work of others. Acknowledgments This work is not solely mine. Without the willingness of many medical herbalists to give me their considerationand time I would not have had their responsesto consider and analyse. For that I reiterate my personal thanks and record them here. Mention must also be made of the institutional representatives who were most helpful, and special thanks to the medical herbalists in the Leeds area who were also helpful in refining and clarifying my thoughts at the beginning of research. Any work of this nature can never be done alone. Financially, the assistance of a Research Scholarship from the University of Leeds gave me the opportunity to pursue this research. Cognitively, discussion with fellow researchers at conferences and less formal meetings has been most welcome. Finally (and motivationally), without the very patient support and guidance of Drs. Geof Mercer and Graeme Gooday I would not have maintained a clear thread of thought: I have been fortunate in having supervisors who performed their duties in the most literal meaning of 'supervisor' - keeping a watchful eye over all, seeing much more than I could, and quietly suggesting the optimum course of action. Notwithstanding the above any errors and omissions are solely mine. Abstract Previous research into complementary and alternative medicine has failed to accord each form of alternative medical intervention individual significance. This research considers medical herbalism in Britain and investigates the re-presentation of its knowledge within a scientific framework as a strategy in a process of professionalisation. Data were gathered from herbalists' own statements that provided the answers to how? and why? this occurred. Whilst it is suggestedthat much science is heavily influenced by its social and cultural enviromnent, the tenacious portrayal of biomedicine as science is taken as accepted orthodoxy. Dolby's model, whereby unorthodox science assumes the features of orthodox science to become accepted as science, is forwarded as an explanation of how herbal medicine has been re-presented as phytotherapy and therefore 'scientific'. The influences of the sociocultural enviromnent and the sociopolitical enviromnent on herbalism's recognition and acceptance by both the state and conventional medicine are suggested as explanations of why phytotherapy has been promoted by some herbalists. It is noted that such transformative measures have not radically affected the professional practice of medical herbalists, nor are they universally welcomed. The anomaly between institutional education of herbalism in terms of phytotherapy and the continuing practice of herbalism as a 'tradition' is noted. The relative identities of identity herbal institutions practitioners - with a cultural - and - with a social for discontinuity between institutional identity - is suggested as the explanation the knowledge and actual practice. It is also argued that medical herbalists have an element of altruism in their practice that is noteworthy beyond an assumed professional service orientation. Herbalists' differences of view regarding the acceptability of promoting phytotherapy as a route to recognition and acceptance appear to be subordinated by fears and anxieties about possible future govermnent legislation and EU harmonisation regulations. Chapter 5- Professional Practise III Practice Statistics III Beyond the mechanics otpractise 115 Practise and Kno 125 Communi4y and Culture 133 Community identibý and cultural 136 Chapter 6- The Sociopolitical Environment 141 Governmen 141 Herbalism in Professional Politics 145 Herbalism in State Politics 154 Fears and Anxieties 164 Chapter 7- Conclusion 168 Bibliography 176 List of Abbreviations 189 Appendix 190 I Re-presenting herbal medicine as phytotherapy: a strategy of professionalisation through the formation of a 'scientific' medicine. ChapterI- IntrooUction Medical herbalism has, perhaps, the longest history of medical strategies though it seems to have declined in credibility since the more scientific principles associatedwith biochemistry and pathology gained acceptancein and around the 19th. century. In more recent times it survived as common knowledge of folklore and 'old wives' tales' though there have always been a number of practitioners regarding it as a specialised knowledge for medical applications. The contemporary prevailing belief is that herbal medicine is a synergistic use of specific plant parts (often in combination with other specific plant parts) that aid the body's own natural healing forces to be effective. In common with several other medical strategies, herbalism seeks to treat the individual: the individual as a person with a physiological environment, a social and familial environment, an emotional environment, a mode of life, and a history - in short, it could be describedas an holistic approach. Within recent decades herbal medicine has had a resurgence of interest and popularity amongst many people. This research has two specific aims, the first is to record some of the recent history of herbal medicine and analyse current attitudes to herbal medicine expressed by herbal practitioners as individuals and expressed by professional associations as discrete communities of herbal practitioners. The second aim is to 2 integrate considerations of herbal medicine as a knowledge system and as a professional practice in Britain. The knowledge of herbal medicine has an ancient history but in recent decades has become subject to re-formulation and re-presentation by some herbalists who have apparently sought to relate herbal medicine to the sciences' of biomedicine and pharmacology. Herbal medicine as a practice also has an ancient history that has become estranged from orthodox concepts of primary medical strategies. The temporal nature of relocating herbal medicine as a knowledge and as a practice cannot occur in isolation from social existence within a society. Social existence is continually (though often imperceptibly) changing; such a process of change is influenced and shaped by many things including politics, economy, culture and religion. These same factors have also contributed to the location of herbal medicine within contemporary British society. Elements of the sociopolitical enviromnent and the sociocultural enviromnent will be argued to be strongly influential in representing herbal medicine in a more scientific form as phytotherapy, and strongly influential in the professional practice of herbalism. Thus this research aims to be more of an analytic description than a theoretical explanation of herbal medicine's popularity, efficacy, or continued existence. It follows earlier work by Whitelegg (1994) referring to paradigm changes in science in relation to alternative medicine and the work of Cant and Sharma (I 996a) which considered adjustments to homeopathic knowledge amongst horneopaths as a strategy of professionalisation. With some other forms of complementary and alternative medicine (hereafter termed CAM, following Coates & Jobst 1998), herbalism is still generally considered to be outside the mainstream orthodox strategies of healthcare that may be termed medical 3 science. Such unorthodox therapies and medical strategieshave been characterisedin four categories by Pietroni (1991). Firstly, complete systems (e.g. herbalism, homeopathy, naturopathy, Ayurvedic) have a comprehensive theoretical background and are able to treat most presenting conditions. They very often have their own explanation for causes of disease and mechanisms for cure and their own unique treatment approaches. Secondly, therapeutic strategies (e.g. massage, reflexology, aromatherapy) assist in the ease of discomfort and the promotion of perceptions of well-being. A third category, the self-care approach, gives the patient skills in practices to take care of themselves,,for example, yoga, meditation, and relaxation therapy. The fourth category relates to alternative diagnostic methods that may be used by orthodox practitioners, homeopaths, herbalists, nutritionists (e.g. iridology and muscle-testing). Although some sociological research has been done regarding various alternative therapies (including Bakx 1991, Saks 1992, Cant & Sharma 1995, Tovey 1997), none has specifically focused on herbalism. Any references to herbal medicine in academic literature seems to be lost in general discussions of alternative medicine as a heterogeneous whole. Apart from Griggs' (1997) scholarly recording of the history and contemporary developments of herbal medicine in Britain, analytic descriptions have been almost absent and any theoretical analysis entirely absent. It is suggested that considering CAM as a heterogeneous whole denies the subjectivity of perception of CAM therapies. If CAM, as appears to be the case, usually refers to several various therapies from acupuncture to the 'laying-on of hands' then each person's personal history and precognitive perceptions may dismiss some CAM therapies as 'worthless mumbo-jumbo'.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Plant Life Magill’S Encyclopedia of Science
    MAGILLS ENCYCLOPEDIA OF SCIENCE PLANT LIFE MAGILLS ENCYCLOPEDIA OF SCIENCE PLANT LIFE Volume 4 Sustainable Forestry–Zygomycetes Indexes Editor Bryan D. Ness, Ph.D. Pacific Union College, Department of Biology Project Editor Christina J. Moose Salem Press, Inc. Pasadena, California Hackensack, New Jersey Editor in Chief: Dawn P. Dawson Managing Editor: Christina J. Moose Photograph Editor: Philip Bader Manuscript Editor: Elizabeth Ferry Slocum Production Editor: Joyce I. Buchea Assistant Editor: Andrea E. Miller Page Design and Graphics: James Hutson Research Supervisor: Jeffry Jensen Layout: William Zimmerman Acquisitions Editor: Mark Rehn Illustrator: Kimberly L. Dawson Kurnizki Copyright © 2003, by Salem Press, Inc. All rights in this book are reserved. No part of this work may be used or reproduced in any manner what- soever or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy,recording, or any information storage and retrieval system, without written permission from the copyright owner except in the case of brief quotations embodied in critical articles and reviews. For information address the publisher, Salem Press, Inc., P.O. Box 50062, Pasadena, California 91115. Some of the updated and revised essays in this work originally appeared in Magill’s Survey of Science: Life Science (1991), Magill’s Survey of Science: Life Science, Supplement (1998), Natural Resources (1998), Encyclopedia of Genetics (1999), Encyclopedia of Environmental Issues (2000), World Geography (2001), and Earth Science (2001). ∞ The paper used in these volumes conforms to the American National Standard for Permanence of Paper for Printed Library Materials, Z39.48-1992 (R1997). Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Magill’s encyclopedia of science : plant life / edited by Bryan D.
    [Show full text]
  • ANTONY ANTONIOU (OSINT Security Analyst)
    EUROPEAN INTELLIGENCE ACADEMY (EIA) E-BOOK No. 1, MAY 2013 ANTONY ANTONIOU (OSINT Security Analyst) OPEN SOURCE INFORMATION, THE FUTURE OF INTELLIGENCE Copyright: Research Institute for European and American Studies (RIEAS) EUROPEAN INTELLIGENCE ACADEMY E-BOOK No. 1 MAY 2013 OPEN SOURCE INFORMATION, THE FUTURE OF INTELLIGENCE ANTONY ANTONIOU (OSINT Security Analyst) Preface. People from ancient times to our days had understood the importance of information and the significant role that valid information can play in all fields of human activities (politics, economy, during wars etc). References to spies, and their methods – techniques and means that they used can be found in historical texts from antiquity until today, also known theorists of war have addressed and reported (in their writings), the importance of information and the necessity of an enemy misinformation (we will mention two of them of Carl Von Clausewitz1 and Sun - Tzu2). The intelligence services began to take shape during the Second World War. Pioneers at the “intelligence field” were the Germans (in espionage, cryptography - cryptology, propaganda and generally speaking at the development of the appropriate techniques – methods and instruments – means), followed by British. Americans because of their non-participation in the war had left behind in the development of techniques and means for collecting and processing information. This changed after the Japanese attack on Pearl Harbor3 and the American entry into the war4. The USA intelligence 1 Carl Philipp Gottfried von Clausewitz (1 July 1780 – 16 November 1831): was a German-Prussian soldier and military theorist who stressed the "moral" (in modern terms, psychological) and political aspects of war.
    [Show full text]
  • Bbyct-133 Plant Ecology and Taxonomy
    BBYCT-133 PLANT ECOLOGY AND Indira Gandhi TAXONOMY National Open University School of Sciences VOL 2 PLANT ECOLOGY AND TAXONOMY BLOCK 3 PLANT TAXONOMY - TOOLS AND EVIDENCES 5 BLOCK 4 NOMENCLATURE AND SYSTEMS OF CLASSIFICATION 105 One of the greatest assets of a sound classification is its predictive value. Mayr (1969) PLANT ECOLOGY AND TAXONOMY In this volume 2 you are going to study about plant taxonomy. Taxonomy is the most relevant field of enquiry for modern man. Plant taxonomy is a 2 credit course which comprises of Block 3 and Block 4.Both of these blocks consist of five units each. Plant taxonomy is a fundamental science - the science of classifying plants into groups and identifying them. The progress of civilization marked a relative increase in man’s knowledge regarding plants - their identification, naming and classification on the basis of his needs. During last three centuries, plant taxonomy has developed from a completely morphology oriented static and descriptive discipline to a most dynamic area of study. The first classification of plants was thus according to their usefulness or not. When man came to realize that most of the plants are of some or other use, he classified them into herbs, shrubs and trees. This was followed by various “Natural “systems of classification. Taxonomy is related to morphology, anatomy, embryology, cytology and chemistry. In this course we have tried to establish the relationship of taxonomy with all the above given branches. Over the last few decades, the availability and usage of comparative and recombinant technology data from different species has made taxonomy more authentic and complete.
    [Show full text]
  • Logical Fallacies, Long Lost Art of Rhetoric I Cheat Sheet by Jorgejuan007
    Logical Fallacies, Long Lost Art of Rhetoric I Cheat Sheet by Jorge Juan (jorgejuan007) via cheatography.com/35958/cs/11445/ Definition Mindmap A fallacy is the use of invalid or faulty reasoning. Some fallacies are committed intenti​ onally to manipulate or persuade by deception, while others are committed uninten​ tio​ nally due to careles​ sness or ignorance Aristotle was the first to systema​ tize logical errors into a list, as being able to refute an opponent's thesis is one way of winning an argument Richard Whately defines a fallacy broadly as, "any argument, or apparent argument, which professes to be decisive of the matter at hand, while in reality it is not" https:/​ /en​ .wi​ kip​ edi​ a.or​ g/​ wik​ i/L​ ist​ _of​ _fa​ lla​ cies Formal fallacies The first principle is that you must not fool yourself and you are the Appeal to Takes something for granted because it would probably easiest person to fool probab‐​ be the case Something can go wrong Richard P. Feynman ility (premise). Therefore, something will go wrong (invalid conclus​ ion) Types of Fallacies Argument Aka fallacy fallacy, assumes that if an argument is Formal An error in logic in the argument's form. from fallaci​ ous, then the conclusion is false If P, then Q. Non Sequiturs fallacy P is a fallacious argument. Therefore, Q ​ Propositional fallacies is false Quantif​ ica​ tion fallacies Syllogi​ stic fallacies Informal Reasons other than structu​ ral, require examin‐​ ation of the argument's content Faulty general​ iza​ tions Red herring fallacies Condi​ tional or Arguments disregard or confusion questio​ nable Other systems of classif​ ica​ tion The most famous are those of Francis Bacon and J.
    [Show full text]
  • On the Shoulders of Giants.Pdf
    On the Shoulders of Giants Tommy Jensen; Timothy L. Wilson Download free books at Tommy Jensen & Timothy L. Wilson On the Shoulders of Giants 2 Download free eBooks at bookboon.com On the Shoulders of Giants 1st edition © 2014 Tommy Jensen & Timothy L. Wilson & bookboon.com ISBN 978-87-403-0751-1 3 Download free eBooks at bookboon.com On the Shoulders of Giants Contents Contents Rediscovering intellectual efforts 8 Background to this book 11 Selection of contributors and giants 12 Acknowledgement 13 Contents of this book 14 1 Georges Bataille 19 On His Shoulders (And Other Parts of the Body of Knowledge) Alf Rehn and Marcus Lindahl 2 Zygmunt Bauman 31 The Holocaust and Organization Studies Tommy Jensen 4 Click on the ad to read more Download free eBooks at bookboon.com On the Shoulders of Giants Contents 3 Reinhard Bendix 47 Work and Authority in Industry Markus Kallifatides 4 Marta B. Calás and Linda Smircich 60 Seductive Poststructuralist Re-readings of Leadership Ulla Eriksson-Zetterquist 5 Richard M. Cyert and James G. March 74 An Eye-opener and a Lifelong Love Affair Rolf A. Lundin 360° 6 Peter F. Drucker 85 Father of Management and Grandfather of Marketing Timothy L. Wilson 360° thinking. 7 Henri Fayol 95 The Man Who Designed Modern Management Karin Holmblad Brunsson thinking. 360° thinking . 360° thinking. Discover the truth at www.deloitte.ca/careers Discover the truth at www.deloitte.ca/careers © Deloitte & Touche LLP and affiliated entities. Discover the truth at www.deloitte.ca/careers © Deloitte & Touche LLP and affiliated entities. © Deloitte & Touche LLP and affiliated entities.
    [Show full text]
  • Plants Found in the Middle Parts of the State Grow Here, Excepting the Alpine Flowers
    CULTIVATION BOTANY.— Wood grows here [Concord] with great rapidity; and it is supposed there is as much now as there was twenty years ago. Walden woods at the south, and other lots towards the southwest parts of the town, are the most extensive, covering several hundred acres of light-soil land. Much of the fuel, which is consumed, is, however brought from the neighbouring towns. The most common trees are the oak, pine, maple, elm, white birch, chestnut, walnut, &c., &c. Hemlock and spruce are very rare. The ornamental trees transplanted, in this as in most other towns, do not appear to have been placed with much regularity; but as they are, they contribute much to the comfort and beauty of the town. The elm, buttonwood, horse-chestnut, and fruit trees have very properly taken the place of sickly poplars, in ornamenting the dwellings. The large elm in front of the court-house, –the pride of the common,– is almost unrivalled in beauty. It is about “three score and ten,” but is still growing with youthful vigor and uniform rapidity. Dr. Jarvis, who is familiar with the botany of Concord, informs me, that “most of the plants found in the middle parts of the state grow here, excepting the alpine flowers. The extensive low lands produce abundantly the natural families of the aroideæ, typhæ, cyperoideæ, gramineæ, junci, corymbiferæ and unbelliferæ. These genera especially abound. There are also found, the juncus militaris (bayonet rush), on the borders of Fairhaven pond; cornus florida; lobelia carinalis (cardinal flower) abundant on the borders of the river; polygala cruciata, in the east parts of the town; nyssa villosa (swamp hornbeam) at the foot of Fairhaven hill.” The cicuta Americana (hemlock) grows abundant on the intervals.
    [Show full text]
  • Learning North American Practices of Care with Western Herbalists
    Ecologies of Friendship: Learning North American Practices of Care with Western Herbalists A Dissertation Presented to the Faculty of the Graduate School of Cornell University in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree of Doctor of Philosophy By Charis Ford Boke December 2018 © 2018 Charis Ford Boke ECOLOGIES OF FRIENDSHIP: LEARNING NORTH AMERICAN PRACTICES OF CARE WITH WESTERN HERBALISTS Charis Ford Boke, Ph. D. Cornell University 2018 This ethnographic study of North American herbalists’ teaching practices is informed by nearly two years of in-depth fieldwork grounded in participant observation at “The Center,” a school of clinical herbalism in Vermont. At The Center, teachers understand human health as reliant on human relationships with what they call “obligate ecologies”—that is, the ecological others and places to which humans must practice accountability in order for all to thrive. They frame the work of accountability through language of “connection,” “communication,” and “friendship” across species, especially between plants and people. This dissertation argues that by teaching how to be a “friend to the plants,” herbalists enable students to imagine the entanglements of plants, people and environments, and then to act with reference to those relationships. Using ethnographic and historical methods to understand their direct sensory engagement with plants, I analyze their efforts to cultivate attentive relations across species as part of herbalists’ practices of care. Although the tools for critical analysis of what both “health” and “care” mean are available, provided by social and historical studies of technology and medicine, few studies to date have offered an in-depth analysis of health practitioners whose frame for teaching health care for humans also necessarily involves teaching care for relations with other-than-humans and environments.
    [Show full text]
  • The History of Phytotherapy and Pharmacognosy
    HISTORY OF PHYTOTHERAPY AND PHARMACOGNOSY (compiled by Milan Nagy) PREHISTORIC EVIDENCE Where, in the eons of human evolution do we begin to chronicle the history of herba- lism? Archaeological studies at Shanidar in Iraq have shown that the eight species of pollen grains found at the burial site reveal that seven of these were plants that are still commonly used as folk medicine throughout the world. These include yarrow (Achillea), marshmallow (Althaea), groundsel (Senecio), centaury (Centaurea), ephedra and muscari. There are no de- finite reasons why Neanderthal man (ca. 60.000 B.C.) included these plants in their burial rites, but it is suggested that they were intended to "exert a beneficial effect on every impor- tant part of the body, and may have been chosen to fortify the dead man in his journey to ano- ther world." NEW STONE AGE (8,000 TO 5,000 B.C.) Transition from the paleolithic to neolithic period - from a food gathering to a food producing economy. Stone was polished, creating tools to clear trees, help farming. Lake- dwellers cultivated or gathered over two hundred different plants, among which are not a few that possess medicinal qualities: Papaver somniferum, Sambucus ebulus, Fumaria officinalis, Verbena officinalis, Saponaria officinalis, Menyanthes trifoliata., etc.. In the history of phytotherapy (herbalism), women prepared food and healing potions - women generally practiced herbalism on a day to day basis, as well as took care of the ills of other members of the family or tribal unit. However, throughout history, men compiled the remedies and wrote them down, which is why nearly all the herbals are by men.
    [Show full text]
  • Trends in the Development of Geographic Botany Author(S): Hugh M
    Trends in the Development of Geographic Botany Author(s): Hugh M. Raup Source: Annals of the Association of American Geographers, Vol. 32, No. 4 (Dec., 1942), pp. 319-354 Published by: Taylor & Francis, Ltd. on behalf of the Association of American Geographers Stable URL: http://www.jstor.org/stable/2561177 . Accessed: 25/08/2011 14:41 Your use of the JSTOR archive indicates your acceptance of the Terms & Conditions of Use, available at . http://www.jstor.org/page/info/about/policies/terms.jsp JSTOR is a not-for-profit service that helps scholars, researchers, and students discover, use, and build upon a wide range of content in a trusted digital archive. We use information technology and tools to increase productivity and facilitate new forms of scholarship. For more information about JSTOR, please contact [email protected]. Taylor & Francis, Ltd. and Association of American Geographers are collaborating with JSTOR to digitize, preserve and extend access to Annals of the Association of American Geographers. http://www.jstor.org ANNALS of the Association of American Geographers Volume XXXII DECEMBER, 1942 No. 4 Trendsin the Developmentof Geographic Botany HUGH M. RAUP CONTENTS Introduction................................................................. 319 Theophrastusto Humboldt:Floristic Plant Geography.......... .............. 320 Humboldtto Darwin ................ ........................... 324 The Effectsof Darwinismupon Plant Geography.............. ................ 327 CurrentTrends in Plant Geography: FloristicPlant Geography..........................................
    [Show full text]
  • NCB School of Herbalism & Holistic Health
    NCB School of Herbalism & Holistic Health Est. 1992 “Distance Learning the Old Fashion Way” Angelique “Sobande” Greer B.S., H.N., CNHP School Founder, Certified Holistic Nutritionist, Herbalist, Consultant, Author & Educator www.naturalchoicesbotanica.com 615.499.6849 [email protected] Nurture..Heal..Inspire..Empower..Educate .. With Kindness: I ask that each of you reading this- if you could be so kind as to not copy, reproduce or share this document for personal & business reasons without my written consent email: [email protected] . This lecture series is an ever-evolving masterpiece that started with the historical accounts and ways of my great grandmother. My personal work for this project spans over 25 years of digging through bibles, antique shows, county records, deeds, wills, history books, visiting African American elders around the globe and other people of color for their stories. This lecture series is NOT just about the herbal history of America, it is about a legacy of people who were stolen, colonized and forced to build the nation you love brick by brick, blood with tears, knowledge with hatred. As you move forward in your studies, teaching, training, sharing, exploring, visiting & learning please remember that it is imperative that healing hubs, centers, schools, conferences, workshops, apprenticeship programs and those offering information in this field be open to the vast amount of knowledge and those who have access to it. If organizations never allow new faces of black & brown hues who represent the knowledge of their people, experiences and cultures to share their history, it easily becomes lost, abandoned and misconstrued.
    [Show full text]
  • Matthew Wood Vitalism the History of Herbalism, Homeopathy And
    Matthew Wood Vitalism The History of Herbalism, Homeopathy and Flower Essences Reading excerpt Vitalism The History of Herbalism, Homeopathy and Flower Essences of Matthew Wood Publisher: North Atlantic Books http://www.narayana-verlag.com/b3409 In the Narayana webshop you can find all english books on homeopathy, alternative medicine and a healthy life. Copying excerpts is not permitted. Narayana Verlag GmbH, Blumenplatz 2, D-79400 Kandern, Germany Tel. +49 7626 9749 700 Email [email protected] http://www.narayana-verlag.com Samuel Thomson and the Demon Herb, Lobelia Folk Medicine and the Philosophy of Herbalism Lobelia inflata is a remedy whose excellency is equal to its nastiness. —Dr. George M. Hite1 If it is a good medicine, it is mine, and I am entitled to the credit of bringing it into use, and have paid dear for it. —Samuel Thomson2 he early settlers of colonial America relied on a variety of T medical traditions for their health care. Although there were no formal medical schools, a brief course in medicine was offered to divinity students at Harvard and Yale. Most formal doc- tors in colonial America were clergyman trained at these schools. Other students apprenticed under experienced practitioners, while some taught themselves from books. Such literate physicians con- stituted the organized medicine of the seventeenth and eighteenth centuries: they were called "book doctors." A strong tradition of folk medicine also arrived with the early settlers. Galen's four "qualities" (hot, cold, damp and dry) were known to seventeenth century housewives, as well as to doctors. This system provided a basic logic for cooking and healing with 'George M.
    [Show full text]
  • Michael Eisen's Angry, Hypocrisy Drenched Assault on Informed
    Michael Eisen's Angry, Hypocrisy Drenched Assault on Informed Consent using Massive Fallacious Reasoning while Ironically Brandishing the Banner of "Science" (c) Copyright 2012 David Dilworth (Eisen may have set a New World Record by committing Six Logical Fallacies with a Single Sentence.) The Genetically modified (GMO) food conflict surfaced in California where Food Safety proponents have put GMO food labeling on the November 2012 ballot so consumers can make an informed choice. GMO manufacturing corporations including Monsanto oppose labeling. Though I'd written a letter to a British researcher about iti the GMO campaign hadn't really caught my attention until I ran across an article, or more accurately found an article that ran over me and rational discourse. Entitled "The anti-GMO campaign's dangerous war on science"ii it is written by a genetic researcher in California named Michael Eisen claiming to support Open Science. The article caught my attention because I've been helping work for good science for a few decades, I'm aware of real attacks on science philosophy and credibility and I am a bit familiar with environmental impacts iii - so sounds good right ? Wow, was I ever in for a disturbing surprise. With deeply profound irony an "infuriated" Eisen claims he's fighting to defend science ("My vested interest here is science, and what I write here, I write to defend it"). Instead his article assaults and batters science reasoning and logic so relentlessly I had to set it aside for a few days to recover from my shocked dismay. "Well I'm angry, making sense gets in the way." "Coupling" British TV seriesiv If I'd found so much as one valid electronic breath defending science methodology, reasoning or logic in the article I wouldn't have written this.
    [Show full text]