Bush and Gore on Oprah Winfrey, or the “Oprah-fication”1 of American Presidential Candidates by John Kares Smith, Ph.D. Professor of Communication Studies State University of New York Oswego, New York 13126
[email protected] “Let’s begin here,” Joshua Gamson begins his book, “talk shows are bad for you, so bad you could catch a cold. Turn them off, a women’s magazine suggested in 1995, and turn on Mother Teresa, since watching her ‘caring feelings’ radiate from the screen, according to psychologist Dr. David McClelland of Harvard, has been shown to raise the level of an antibody that fights colds. ‘It stands to reason,’ reasons a First magazine writer, ‘that viewing threatening, confrontational images could create an opposite reaction.’ In fact, given that talks shows ‘create feelings of frustration’ and fear, ‘shattering our trust and faith’ in our expectations of people’s behavior, and ‘give us a false perception of reality,’ it is perhaps best to watch game shows or soaps while nursing that cold. Watching daytime talk shows could conceivably send you into a decline into pathologies of all sorts: scared, angry, disgusted, convinced you are abnormal for not fitting in with the ‘cast of misfits and perverts,’ susceptible to both perversion and more colds [Gamson, p. 3]. There are many negative critics of talk shows. Gamson trots out the usual suspects: George Gerbner [“These shows are virtually destroying the goodness of America”], Harvard’s Alvin Pouissant [“It does not bode well for the future generations of young people growing up on a steady diet of this drivel”] TV Critic Tom Shales [“These shows are portraying Americans as shallow monsters”] [Gamson, 3].Gamson defends talkshows.