W. JOSEPH CAMPBELL Media Myth Alert

W. JOSEPH CAMPBELL

Media Myth Alert

DEBUNKING, DISTORTION, FACT-CHECKING, GETTING IT WRONG, HISTORY, HURRICANE KATRINA, MEDIA, MEDIA-DRIVEN MYTHS

10 years on: News media shy from revisiting flawed Katrina coverage

In Anniversaries, Error, Hurricane Katrina, Media myths, Newspapers, Television on August 25, 2015 at 1:23 pm

(hps://mediamythalert.ﬁles.wordpress.com/2010/08/noaa_katrina3.jpg) Katrina, 10 years ago

I call it the “myth of superlative reporting (hps://mediamythalert.wordpress.com/2010/09/01/katrina- and-the-myth-of-superlative-reporting/),” the notion that in the aftermath of Hurricane Katrina’s onslaught 10 years ago, journalists bravely held powerful oﬃcials accountable for their inept responses to a storm blamed for the deaths of 1,800 people (hp://www.cnn.com/2013/08/23/us/hurricane-katrina- statistics-fast-facts/).

Dan Rather (hp://www.slate.com/articles/news_and_politics/assessment/2004/09/dan_rather.html), the former CBS News anchorman, gave voice to the “myth of superlative reporting,” describing (hp://www.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0509/20/lkl.01.html) Katrina coverage as “one of the quintessential great moments in television news,” ranking “right there with the Nixon/Kennedy debates, the Kennedy assassination, Watergate coverage, you name it.”

A quintessential great moment is was not. The reporting of Katrina, as I wrote in my 2010 media-mythbusting book, Geing It Wrong (hp://www.amazon.com/Geing-Wrong-Greatest-Misreported-Journalism/dp/0520262093/ref=sr_1_22? ie=UTF8&s=books&qid=1256005472&sr=1-22), “was in important respects ﬂawed and exaggerated. On crucial details, journalists erred badly, and got it wrong” in describing horrors the storm supposedly unleashed across New Orleans after making landfall east of the city on August 29, 2005.

Journalists reported snipers ﬁring at medical personnel, I noted. They reported shots were ﬁred at helicopters, halting evacuations from the Convention Center in New Orleans. They told of bodies being stacked like cordwood inside the Convention Center.

News reports also spoke of roving gangs that terrorized occupants of the Louisiana Superdome, where many people had taken shelter. The reports said children were victims of sexual assault, that one seven- year-old was raped and her throat was slit. They reported that sharks were plying the ﬂooded streets of New Orleans.

None of those reports, as it turned out, was veriﬁed or substantiated.

“If anyone rioted,” said a bipartisan congressional report (hps://books.google.com/books? id=Fa4GehG1h0YC&pg=PA360&lpg=PA360&dq=%22if+anyone+rioted+it+was+the+media%22&source=bl DJ9KBOE&hl=en&sa=X&ved=0CCAQ6AEwATgKahUKEwio28ft2MTHAhWKOj4KHfWbD_s#v=onepage about Katrina, “it was the media.

“Many stories of rape, murder, and general lawlessness were at best unsubstantiated, at worst simply false.”

Erroneous and over-the-top reporting (hps://mediamythalert.wordpress.com/2010/08/22/nbcs-katrina- retrospective-sidesteps-media-failings/), I wrote in Geing It Wrong (hp://www.wsj.com/articles/SB10001424052748704535004575349633765738968), “had the cumulative the eﬀect of painting for America and the rest of the world a scene of surreal violence and terror, something straight out of Mad Max or Lord of the Flies.”

Which was rather how Maureen Dowd (hps://mediamythalert.wordpress.com/2015/02/09/maureen- dowd-misremembers-the-cronkite-moment/) characterized Katrina’s aftermath in her New York Times column (hp://www.nytimes.com/2005/09/03/opinion/united-states-of-shame.html), published September 3, 2005, under the headline, “United States Of Shame”: (hps://mediamythalert.ﬁles.wordpress.com/2015/08/screen-shot-2015- 08-23-at-3-39-57-pm.png)

“America,” she wrote, “is once more plunged into a snake pit of anarchy, death, looting, raping, marauding thugs, suﬀering innocents, a shaered infrastructure, a gued police force, insuﬃcient troop levels and criminally negligent government planning. But this time it’s happening in America.”

Far more measured and perceptive was her Times (hps://mediamythalert.wordpress.com/2010/12/27/two-myths-and-todays- new-york-times/) colleague, Jim Dwyer (hp://topics.nytimes.com/top/reference/timestopics/people/d/jim_dwyer/index.html), whom Brian Thevenot quoted this way, in a searching critique (hp://ajrarchive.org/Article.asp?id=3998) of the coverage of Katrina:

“I just thought that some of the reports were so garish, so untraceable and always seemed to stop short of having actual witnesses to the atrocities … like a galloping mythical nightmare had taken control.”

The erroneous and exaggerated reporting had the important eﬀect delaying the delivery of aid to New Orleans — and of defaming the residents of a baered city, depicting them as having shed all restraint in the face of a disaster.

Lile of the flawed coverage (hp://www.freerepublic.com/focus/news/1491317/posts) has been revisited or recalled in the run-up to the 10th anniversary of Katrina’s landfall. As they did in fifth anniversary retrospectives (hps://mediamythalert.wordpress.com/2010/08/31/absent-in-looking-back-katrinas- lessons-for-the-press/), journalists have mostly shied (hp://theadvocate.com/entertainment/13261329- 123/a-look-at-how-national) from addressing the errors in their coverage and have avoided considering how that coverage offers broader insights (hps://mediamythalert.wordpress.com/2010/08/31/absent-in- looking-back-katrinas-lessons-for-the-press/) about reporting on disasters and other dramatic events (hps://mediamythalert.wordpress.com/2011/05/03/a-cautionary-note-on-early-coverage-of-dramatic- events/).

The 10th anniversary reports have instead offered conflicting assessments about how New Orleans has made a comeback (hp://www.chron.com/opinion/outlook/article/Landrieu-Post-Katrina-New-Orleans- is-on-a-roll-6459175.php), or really hasn’t (hp://www.newsweek.com/hurricane-katrina-10th- anniversary-new-orleans-ruins-photography-364563), or how impressions of the city’s recovery can sharply differ (hp://www.nytimes.com/2015/08/25/us/hurricane-katrina-new-orleans-recovery-ten- years-opinion.html?_r=0).

Heavily advertised television specials shown on ABC and Fox News skirted the wrong-headed reporting of 10 years ago, if they alluded to it at all.

ABC’s retrospective was broadcast Sunday night and was so sappy and boosterish as to be almost unwatchable.

Fox, which aired its look-back on Friday, was notably rough on Ray Nagin (hps://mediamythalert.wordpress.com/2011/08/28/not-a-joke-ray-nagin-asked-for-advice-on-hurricane- prep/), the incompetent, bloviating mayor of New Orleans 10 years ago. Nagin since has gone to federal prison on corruption convictions (hp://www.nola.com/crime/index.ssf/2014/09/ray_nagin_once_mayor_of_new_or.html) unrelated to Katrina.

It’s worth recalling how in the storm’s aftermath, Nagin went on Oprah Winfrey’s program to claim that “hundreds of armed gang members” were terrorizing Katrina evacuees inside the Louisiana Superdome.

Nagin said conditions at the Superdome had deteriorated to “an almost animalistic state” and evacuees had been “in that frickin’ Superdome for ﬁve days, watching dead bodies, watching hooligans killing people, raping people.”

Almost all of those claims were untrue: The mayor was winging it on national television, and smearing his city in the process. The Fox program alluded to some of Nagin’s exaggerations. An exception to the media’s sidestepping was a segment (hp://www.onthemedia.org/story/ﬂood- lies/#commentlist) Saturday on NPR’s On the Media show. The segment noted the ﬂawed reporting, but didn’t much explore why or how it occurred.

In her introduction, co-host Brooke Gladstone (hp://www.onthemedia.org/people/brooke-gladstone/) said of journalists covering the storm’s aftermath:

“They didn’t always speak fact. While covering Katrina’s horriﬁc aftermath, the media often perpetuated myths about what was going on in the streets and the gathering places for the displaced, like the Superdome in New Orleans.”

The broad eﬀect, of the exaggerated reporting, she said, was to paint “an apocalyptic picture that never matched reality.”

Her observations were a sequeway to an extended conversation with James A. Cobb (hp://blog.nola.com/new_orleans/2013/08/new_orleans_lawyer_james_cobb.html) Jr., the lawyer who won acquials (hp://www.washingtonpost.com/wp- dyn/content/article/2007/09/07/AR2007090702562.html) in 2007 of Sal and Mabel Mangano, owners of a nursing home in suburban New Orleans where 35 old people drowned in ﬂoodwaters released by the collapsed levees.

The Manganos both were charged with 35 counts of negligent homicide and 24 counts of cruelty.

Before the storm hit, the Manganos had decided it was safer to hunker down and not evacuate their frail and bedridden charges — and they were pilloried by the media (hp://www.cnn.com/TRANSCRIPTS/0509/12/ng.01.html) when word of the deaths of their elderly charges began to circulate.

WJC (hp://www.wjosephcampbell.com)