Late Quaternary History of Colluvial Deposition and Erosion in Hollows, Central California Coast Ranges
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Late Quaternary history of colluvial deposition and erosion in hollows, central California Coast Ranges STEVEN L. RENEAU Earth and Environmental Sciences Division, M.S. D462, Los Alamos National Laboratory, Los Alamos, New Mexico 87545 WILLIAM E. DIETRICH Department of Geology and Geophysics, University of California, Berkeley, California 94720 DOUGLAS J. DONAHUE | National Science Foundation Regional Facility for Radioisotope Analysis, University of Arizona, Tucson, A. J. TIMOTHY JULL J Arizona 85721 MEYER RUBIN U.S. Geological Survey, National Center 971, Reston, Virginia 22092 ABSTRACT side slopes and noses where contours are straight workers have proposed that the deposition of and convex, respectively. The concave topog- coarse permeable debris in hollows leads to sta- Colluvial deposits in hollows are the pre- raphy forces colluvial debris to converge toward bility, and subsequent erosion of weathered bed- dominant source of debris flows in many the axes of hollows, resulting in long-term depo- rock on the adjoining side slopes and noses mountainous areas, and the depositional his- sition (for example, Dietrich and others, 1986; results in topographic inversion. This model has tory of hollows can provide insight into land- Reneau and others, 1989). Landslides in the col- been proposed for colluvial deposits in the Ap- slide frequency and long-term hillslope proc- luvial deposits are the primary source of debris palachian Mountains and in Texas (Bryan, esses. Detailed study of colluvial deposits in flows in many mountainous areas, and the initial 1940; Mills, 1981). 20 hollows in the northern San Francisco Bay landslides and subsequent erosion by debris These conceptual models are not mutually area, California, reveals diverse histories of flows supply much sediment to stream channels exclusive, and each may be partially correct in erosion and deposition. Basal radiocarbon (for example, Pierson, 1977; Dietrich and explaining the evolution of hollows in a region. ages range from 1 to 29 ka and document Dunne, 1978; Lehre, 1981,1982; Okunishi and Detailed knowledge of the depositional history deposition of colluvium throughout this pe- lida, 1981; Dietrich and others, 1982; Tsuka- of hollows and the processes active at these sites riod at different sites. Ages from multiple moto and others, 1982; Reneau and Dietrich, is essential to resolve the relative importance of stratigraphic levels confirm that the deposits 1987a, 1987b). The long-term history of deposi- the above models. are cumulative and have thickened through tion and erosion in hollows is thus needed to In this paper, previous research on the deposi- the Holocene. Radiocarbon dates and strati- evaluate debris-flow hazards and the flux of sed- tional history of hollows in the western United graphic observations document unconformi- iment to streams. States is reviewed, followed by the presentation ties in hollows, reflecting incomplete evacua- Conceptual models of the evolution of collu- of detailed stratigraphic observations and chron- tion of colluvium during both Pleistocene and vial deposits in hollows are varied and have led ologic data from hollows in part of the central Holocene events and providing evidence for a to differing interpretations of the geomorphic California Coast Ranges. The research presented cycle of alternating accumulation and evacua- significance of the deposits. Several workers herein expands the earlier work of Reneau and tion of colluvium. This cycle has apparently have proposed that colluvial deposits in hollows others (1986), incorporating a greatly enlarged been affected by major climatic changes, and owe their existence to climatic changes, with data set. In particular, radiocarbon dates from the common occurrence of basal ages at ca. 9 stream incision under one climatic regime re- multiple stratigraphic levels and from different to 14 ka may record widespread slope insta- placed by colluvial deposition following a major longitudinal positions in several colluvial depos- bility during the Pleistocene-Holocene transi- climate change. Cotton and TePunga (1955) its help document the depositional history of in- tion. By analogy with modern landsliding, the postulated that a change from warmer intergla- dividual hollows in greater detail than previous- increased erosion may have been caused by cial to colder periglacial conditions led to collu- ly possible. The dating constrains the timing of an increased frequency of high-intensity vial deposition in New Zealand hollows, and past erosional events and improves the under- storms during extended periods of meridional Schlocker (1974) and Shlemon and others standing of the late Quaternary history of hol- flow in the upper atmosphere. The acceler- (1987) proposed that a change from a wetter lows in central California and the effects of ated discharge of colluvium from hillslopes glacial to a drier interglacial climate led to depo- regional climatic changes on hillslope erosional may have contributed to stream aggradation sition in California hollows. An alternative view processes. in diverse parts of California. is that continued accumulation of colluvium in hollows inherently leads to instability, and hol- PREVIOUS RESEARCH ON INTRODUCTION lows are thus characterized by a cycle of alter- DEPOSITIONAL HISTORY nating storage and discharge of colluvium. A OF HOLLOWS Hollows are an important part of many cyclic model, independent of climatic changes, landscapes, playing a critical role in the flux of has been proposed for sites in coastal California, Knowledge of the depositional history of hol- debris from hillslopes to streams. As defined by Oregon, Washington (for example, Pierson, lows in western North America has developed Hack and Goodlett (1960) and Hack (1965), 1977; Dietrich and Dunne, 1978; Lehre, 1981, through studies in California, Oregon, and hollows are parts of hillslopes where contours 1982; Dietrich and others, 1982), and Japan Washington during the past 15 yr. Dietrich and are concave-out from the slope, contrasting with (Okunishi and lida, 1981). In other areas, some Dunne (1978) initially described colluvial de- Geological Society of America Bulletin, v. 102, p. 969-982, 13 figs., 2 tables, July 1990. 969 Downloaded from http://pubs.geoscienceworld.org/gsa/gsabulletin/article-pdf/102/7/969/3381052/i0016-7606-102-7-969.pdf by guest on 24 September 2021 970 RENEAU AND OTHERS posits in Oregon Coast Range hollows and residence time radiocarbon ages from buried that colluvial deposits in hollows are typically proposed that they were sites of episodic land- soils. Shlemon and others (1987) also proposed cumulative, thickening over time, and that the sliding, with the landslide scars filled with that the climatic change at the onset of the Hol- period of accumulation can exceed 10,000 yr. colluvium derived from the adjacent slopes. Ob- ocene led to initial accumulation of colluvium in This overlaps with the time scale of major cli- served textural variations included an increase in former Pleistocene stream channels. A similar matic change, and clusterings of basal radiocar- gravel content toward the base of the deposits, model had previously been advanced by bon dates suggest that climatic changes have and the basal gravels were interpreted as record- Schlocker (1974) for deposits on the Marin Pe- influenced the evacuation of colluvium from ing the winnowing of fine sediment by overland ninsula, immediately north of San Francisco. hollows in some regions. Relative dating criteria flow when the deposits were thin. Subsequently, Additional radiocarbon age determinations suggest that a wide range in age of colluvium Dietrich and others (1982) reported similar have been made from hollows in coastal Oregon may be present and that unconformities record- deposits on the Olympic Peninsula in Washing- and Washington. Benda and Dunne (1987) re- ing partial evacuation are present in some ton and estimated that colluvial accumulation ported basal radiocarbon dates from recent deposits. for 1,000 to 10,000 yr was required to replace landslide scars in three Oregon Coast Range hol- the sediment evacuated in a landslide. On the lows of 1.6, 6.4, and 9.4 ka and inferred that the STUDY AREA basis of detailed observations and measurements period between successive failures in this area is of landslide scars in central California grass- thus in the range of thousands of years. Basal The study sites are within the central Califor- lands, Lehre (1981, 1982) proposed essentially radiocarbon dates from nine additional hollows nia Coast Ranges of Marin and Alameda Coun- the same model for colluvial deposits north of in the Oregon Coast Range extend from 4 to ties, in the northern San Francisco Bay area San Francisco, emphasizing the role of revegeta- >40 ka, with seven sites clustering between 4 (Fig. 1). The climate is Mediterranean, with wet tion in stabilizing debris within landslide scars and 7.5 ka (Reneau, 1988). Basal radiocarbon winters and dry summers, moderated by coastal and the role of gullying in evacuating some dates from eight hollows on the Olympic Penin- fog. Average annual rainfall ranges from about hollows. sula of Washington range from 7-13 ka and 600 to 1,000 mm/yr and is greatest at sites near- A more diverse depositional history was sug- show a clustering between 7 and 10 ka (Reneau est the coast (Rantz, 1971). Native vegetation is gested by the study of colluvial deposits in the and others, 1989). The early Holocene was a varied and includes grassland; a northern coastal