Protecting the Integrity of Sport Competition
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Sorbonne_ICSS_Cover_V2.pdf 1 07/05/2014 10:49 Protecting the Integrity of Sport Competition C M Y The Last Bet for Modern Sport CM MY CY CMY K An executive summary of the Sorbonne-ICSS Integrity Report Sport Integrity Research Programme, 2012-14 International Centre for Sport Security P.O. Box 64163, Doha - Qatar Phone: +974 4430 8000 Fax: +974 4430 8001 Email: [email protected] www.theicss.org Protecting the Integrity of Sport Competition The Last Bet for Modern Sport An executive summary of the Sorbonne-ICSS Integrity Report Sport Integrity Research Programme, 2012-14 Published May 2014 © 2014 University Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne and the International Centre for Sport Security (ICSS). All rights reserved. No part of this publication may be reproduced, stored in a retrieval system, or transmitted in any form or by any means, electronic, mechanical, photocopying, recording or otherwise without the permission of the publisher. The information contained in this publication is believed to be correct at the time of going to press. While care has been taken to ensure that the information is accurate, the publishers can accept no responsibility for any errors or omissions or for changes to the details given. Readers are cautioned that forward-looking statements including forecasts are not guarantees of future performance or results and involve risks and uncertainties that cannot be predicted or quanti!ed and, consequently, the actual performance of companies mentioned in this report and the industry as a whole may di"er materially from those expressed or implied by such forward-looking statements. Authors: University Paris 1 Panthéon-Sorbonne and the International Centre for Sport Security (ICSS) Publisher: Sorbonne-ICSS Research Programme on Ethics and Sports Integrity Design and production: SportBusiness Communications CONTENTS 1. WHAT IS THE SIZE OF THE PROBLEM OF THE MANIPULATION OF SPORTS COMPETITIONS? 3 The recurrence of Acts of Manipulation of Sports Competitions: A Worldwide Phenomenon Threatening the Foundations of Modern Sport 4 Persons Involved: Athletes and other Perpetrators 5 The Localisation of Cases of Manipulation of Sports Competitions: Europe and Asia Particularly Targeted 5 2. WHICH CONTEXTUAL FACTORS EXPLAIN THE DEVELOPMENT OF THE MANIPULATION OF SPORTS COMPETITIONS? 7 The Increasing Weight of Sport in the Global Economy 8 The Advent of a Global Sports Market 8 The Parallel Development of a Transnational Market of Sports Bets of an Estimated Amount Between €200 and €500 Billion (Amounts Bet) 9 The Abuses Associated with the Globalisation of Sports and Sports Bets 10 3. WHAT IS THE IMPACT OF THE INTERNET ON THE SPORTS BETTING MARKET? 11 An Evolution or a Revolution? 12 The E"ects of Public Regulation on the Sports Betting Market 14 The Dynamics of the Sports Betting Market 19 4. WHAT ARE THE RISKS TO THE INTEGRITY OF SPORTS COMPETITIONS THAT CAN BE ASSOCIATED WITH THE DEVELOPMENT OF SPORTS BETS? 25 Illegal Gambling, Tax Havens and High-Frequency Transactions 26 5. WHERE DOES THE FIGHT AGAINST ILLEGAL BETS CURRENTLY STAND? 31 Mobilisation and Results: an Undeniable Correlation 32 Monitoring the Fluctuation of Odds: an Easily Circumvented Anti-Manipulation Test 32 Protecting the Integrity of Sport Competition The Last Bet for Modern Sport iii 6. WHAT ARE THE FORMS OF MANIPULATION OF SPORTS COMPETITIONS? 35 A Classi!cation of Cases of the Manipulation of Sports Competitions 36 7. WHAT LESSONS CAN BE LEARNED FROM ANALYSIS OF THE ECONOMIC RATIONALE OF A COMPETITION’S PARTICIPANTS? 41 Identifying the Actors Involved, their Interests and their Risks (Athletes, Sports Entities, Bettors, Betting Operators and Regulatory Authorities) 42 Identifying the Economic Rationale of Stakeholders 45 Recommendations Based on an Analysis of the Economic Rationale of Participants 47 8. WHAT ARE THE ETHICAL CHALLENGES INVOLVED CONCERNING THE MANIPULATION OF SPORTS COMPETITIONS AND COMBATING THIS PRACTICE? 49 Sports Ethics: From the Need For Rules to Controversies on the Values that Form their Basis 50 The Di$culties in Implementing the Ethical Prescriptions Brought to Light by the Social and Practical Dimensions of Sports Practice 51 The Contribution of Institutional Ethics to Sport: Identifying the Responsibilities and Suggesting Remedies 51 Are there Speci!c Conditions for the Promotion of Ethics in the Sporting World? 52 9. WHAT WERE THE HISTORICAL POSITIONS TAKEN BY SPORTS INSTITUTIONS WITH REGARD TO ETHICS? 55 The Sporting Rule, Fair Play and Chivalry in Sport 56 Olympism, the IOC, the Olympic Movement 57 International Federations and the IOC: an Intertwined History 59 10. WHAT ARE THE REACTIONS TO THE PHENOMENON OF THE MANIPULATION OF SPORTS COMPETITIONS? 61 How did the Sports Movement Integrate the Fight against the Manipulation of Sports Competitions into a “Sports Public Policy”? 62 How did the Public Authorities React to the Threat to Public Order Embodied in the Phenomenon of the Manipulation of Sports Competitions? 63 11. HOW IS THE DUTY TO COMBAT THE MANIPULATION OF SPORTS COMPETITIONS DIVIDED BETWEEN SPORTS INSTITUTIONS AND PUBLIC AUTHORITIES? 65 Basis of the “Autonomy of the Sports Movement” 66 Ordinary Manifestations of the Autonomy of the Sporting Movement 66 Shared Responsibilities and Constraints in the Fight against the Manipulation of Sports Competitions 67 The Concrete Implementation of the Division of Responsibilities between the Public Authorities and the Sports Movement 68 iv Protecting the Integrity of Sport Competition The Last Bet for Modern Sport 12. WHAT ARE THE LIMITATIONS OF CURRENTLY AVAILABLE INSTRUMENTS FOR COMBATING THE MANIPULATION OF SPORTS COMPETITIONS? 71 An Insu$cient Cooperation at the National Level 72 Insu$cient Cooperation on the International Level 73 Nascent Multiparty Rapprochement Mechanisms 73 The Uneven E$ciency of Normative Devices Internal to Sports Institutions 76 An Unbalanced Fight between the Participants in the Manipulation of Sports Competitions and the Authorities Combating it 78 13. WHICH INSTRUMENTS SHOULD BE DEVELOPED AS A PRIORITY TO PREVENT THE MANIPULATION OF SPORTS COMPETITIONS? 83 Developing Prevention, Information and Education Instruments: the First Priority 84 Improving the Governance of Sports Organisations: A Recently Identi!ed Priority 85 Developing Regulation Instruments Applicable to Sports Betting Operators: Fighting Against Illegal and Irregular Bets, Restrictions Imposed on Betting Operators, Self-Regulation of Operators 87 Improving Tools Adopted Through the Initiative of Betting Operators and Sports Institutions 91 14. WHAT ARE THE PRIORITIES FOR THE DEVELOPMENT OF REPRESSIVE INSTRUMENTS OF MANIPULATION OF SPORTS COMPETITIONS? 93 How should Repression be Undertaken by the Disciplinary Bodies of the Sports Movement? 94 The Disciplinary Power of Sports Institutions, an Asset in the Fight Against The Manipulation of Sports Competitions 94 The Protection of the Integrity of Sports Competitions, General Objective of Disciplinary Measures 95 The Cumulative E"ect of Disciplinary Repression and Criminal Repression in the Case of the Manipulation of Sports Competition and How to Increase E$ciency 95 Adaptations of disciplinary law required to !ght against the manipulation of sports competitions 96 The Adoption of Disciplinary Sanctions: Strictness in the Case of the Manipulation of Sports Competitions 98 The Disciplinary Procedure: A Procedural Framework Su$ciently Flexible to Outwit Cunning Manipulators of Sports Competitions 100 How Can Other Private Parties Contribute to Economic Sanctions Against Violations of the Integrity of Sports? 101 How Can States and International Organisations Render More E"ective the Criminal Repression of the Manipulation of Sports Competitions? 102 The Need to Evaluate and Adjust the National Standards Applicable to the Manipulation of Sports Competitions 104 Need to Adopt an International Agreement Dedicated to Combating the Manipulation of Sports Competitions 107 Protecting the Integrity of Sport Competition The Last Bet for Modern Sport v 15. HOW TO ACHIEVE BETTER COORDINATION FOR AN EFFECTIVE FIGHT AGAINST THE MANIPULATION OF SPORTS COMPETITIONS? 111 What are the Lessons to be Learned from Existing Coordination Mechanisms for Combating Fraud in Horseracing and Doping? 112 The Horseracing Industry Implemented E"ective Mechanisms that Are not Fully Transferable to Sports 112 The Fight against Doping is Neither a Model nor an Anti-Model 113 What Lessons can be Learned from Multi-Party Regulation and Cooperation Outside the Sporting World? 115 The Creation of a Global Regime should be Based on Some Essential Principles 116 Mechanisms Borrowed from Other Frameworks Outside the Sporting World Would Amplify the E"ects of Multi-party Cooperation Already Started in the Framework of the Fight Against the Manipulation of Sports Competitions 117 16. WHAT ARE THE COMMON PRINCIPLES THAT ALL STAKEHOLDERS COMMITTED TO FIGHTING THE MANIPULATION OF SPORTS COMPETITIONS SHOULD RESPECT? 119 Respecting the Fundamental Rights of Human Beings in Procedures to Fight Against the Manipulation of Sports Competitions 120 Facilitating but also Regulating the Exchange of Information 121 17. WHO FINANCES THE FIGHT AGAINST THE MANIPULATION OF SPORTS COMPETITIONS? THE BETTING TAX EXAMPLE 125 EDITORIAL CREDITS 128 vi Protecting the Integrity of Sport Competition The Last Bet for Modern Sport LIST OF FIGURES Figure 1: Global Distribution of Reported Cases of the Manipulation of Sports Competitions Over the Last 3 Years 6 Figure 2: Countries that have become