Al Qaeda Weapons of Mass Destruction Threat: Hype Or Reality? by Rolf Mowatt-Larssen Foreword by Graham Allison
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
AL QAEDA WEAPONS OF MASS DESTRUCTION THREAT: HYPE OR REALITY? UraniumSpecific Intelligence Approach Government AbuMeans By Rolf Mowatt-Larssen Bombs Destruction Another Biol 1996 Purchase Na Leade Construct Pr Islamic Home Organizations Foreword by Graham Allison tu od However re uc Sufaat la In Ali January Involved e nd va Hi Ef Re Future Ne sion rs Gr Op Pres In Afghanist Even In Strategic ligiou gh Deputy Oil fo te ConfirmedHouse te Di hi er rn ogical Tw Around rn w rt id ou ffic s In Iran at at at p Ca te KSM La en io io ives rn mp ul na Libya na In te o p t aign at dividu Ma t l March l Scale University io Chie Weapo Fo Egyptian Development Fo te Ra Fe na Ne Acco Means 2003 Saudi Associated Pa La In Control Ef Russ Ne Anthr br Cr Jemaah Specific Ma Memb un Isamuddin an CEO al rials un uf l Moussaoui Yo Mahmood Ba te Sudan UTN ua Re Ca op Am LaboratoIdenry tified Bomb Gi Years Ne fo Te Continue rv kast ding ry ligiou ding Leader Like Officials di Dust 9/11 Leve Documents xt n ve w Approach ll f Passed Raid B iewe rr es rk on Khabab ian t Se De Sm Al-Mas J Gr De Interests Cr In Tox Kin Member ed Re tw United y n Might rdin Bo rt iha Ayman ly or Ca Even Pakistan’s sed co Po Begin De Su Radical Op Libi al te n at r g Cr er 28 Earl op mb ls Be Probably De gdo Achieve s Di ax Di Egyptian Us ist v te nd l Fatwa rn er h er Tw UK in Iran st op an po bway or d Meet Led elo ntial vice Grouou p’s m Purchase Yo a ins rt ffic g ri at House vice ed mp Iraqi Around at Deputy Arrested ive y g Like s Several KSM io y Later Iraq k i N Capture Intent rt Better rk ul na p et Russ Related In wo Strike ly Littl o Scie p rk’ Led te t l Nuclear g ty s Ne Hi i 1998 ed Scale Khan rv il Bi Re Continue Threa Za ntists ib Re Sa Meet Ce DegrGlo ee Moussaoui ss e iewe KillinPo ia gh po Associated tw po ntra AQ ly n Weapo Inc Bu r ba wa rt Time Leader rt Te Documents ud sh ts n 200 l or l in Po rr lud in Assessment Threa Se De Al-Mas Ji De Kingdo HE United g or Za co ha g Scie hiri Ma is at n k e U Ab Acco Ce ist v nd i 2 h Assessment Ba on Ne Time Khan d Novemb te du elo ntral Bi ntists 2002 m 2001 a ri Laboratory Cr Re ts wa Training N Di HE Littl rials et n Probably op l w Pl Iraq x AQ or 200 U rt Better Duste La p k sed Ce rdin po t Might ’s 1998 Novemb Identified Utilizing e hiri Libi Related y UK anning Op din’ Hard Isamuddin Training Begin We ll Bo Passed Pres Mo T rt r Pr 1 mb CEO ll er Sudan r Fa Planning er Utilizing Progr He Co a Degree Am od s in g d Ex hd Home Se Iran Fe at Inc g Bu e T lp Know ha ed Us uc Po Ara Order Years ni ake Putin br S id on Na m Re Killing Za Cit sh Se a Provides l Radical Op urse tremists ives e l te er ua Putin or lud ed Ayman Us la tu en am mme Chemical In In g ntial er n Planned ptem ry ly Gi s Ra Associates Strategic Russ nd rq po Considering re Construct dividu at Confirmed Rici Probability In Rai Duty e t s Fa Strike Ab ve Littl y NotablyJeAQ maah in Dut ive uf cl bi Cit Arrest va Intelligence Sa Intent Se Leade Afghanist Officials hd We Fi Possibility Managed n Activity 28 du Ce d Fi aw d sion rt ia Military ni Know Ara T y rs Arrested T n be Just rs al ll g r ud e a Bomb Rai ake Future or At Fi l a ll Later Su Subsequently 1996 t Bo t d y ud Oi Large Uranium Named i r Purposes Camps rs s n UraniuAli m e d Spain Cyanide Januarymb l bway t Po in Za Pl Ca Tox s Destruction Iran Ma CountriesTies Ji U.S. bi rs Involved Kandahar Ji mp Mo He States is Scie Assessment Interests g te i Crude Putin anning Also Threa aign Za Organizations t Hambali a Confirmed wa Poisons lp on hi rials Well ins Programs Chie ntists UTN Another Us Help Found ha Glo Ca Libya Pakistan rq November ack Bayazid In p Large KnownFahd Ab an States Lieutenants CIA Part Co Progr dividu ll mme ts La Mohammed hiri Targets in ba du Threat Te ed Activity aw te f Ties Notably Ahmed l Hard Intent urse Planned PurposesCamps Control l AbuHowever g StrikeCourse Weapons MilitaryNamedKandahar al d am SufaatIslamicAugust i September rr SummeWM r Future Av In Subsequently Detained Using Produce s Take Bi Mu Also Seniors In Av Ev Cyanide GoveTo rnment Million Security Hambali ai Ca en Case n Senior Groups Intelligence Member Poisons s ai Major la 200 p Pakistan’s sa HE ts fo su Extremists cl La or Note la D bl alit U Re August Fatwa b One Evid ecemb din’ Osama Co Action bl ud Nuclear e Arrest po y rm Probability 2 Activit Posed e re America Ma rt Utilizing is s Iraqi en in Attack D Achieve Ce er in Wo Mass Arrested Highly AKA One Spain Duty ce at Progr m Provides g ll g Efforts y La y Anthr Leve In Pa Report rld Radiological Lieutenants CIA Ex io Pl Pl Efforts Part va Associates Action di Later sion kast Earl ls Ma of Al Qae tremists Possible Gas n Development Khabab Mass ot ot Weapo n ss D Al QaeAmericada Wo Major ax y Just Ahmed Chemical Group’s Killing Memb an am da Chro da estructi March rld Security Experiments Attempt ns Role Interest Saudi i Detained Several Ca of 9/11 Capture University er Large no Radiological on Ayman mp June Summer Managed s l ogy Material Million Planned Construct Case Order January 2010 Russ Strategic Acquire Posed ia D Military Ca U.S. ecemb Groups su Destroy alit y er Belfer Center for Science and International Affairs Harvard Kennedy School 79 JFK Street Cambridge, MA 02138 Fax: (617) 495-8963 Email: [email protected] Website: http://belfercenter.org Design and Layout Tim Duffy Copyright 2010 President and Fellows of Harvard College Printed in the United States of America AL QAEDA WEAPONS OF MASS DESTRUCTION THREAT: HYPE OR REALITY? By Rolf Mowatt-Larssen Foreword by Graham Allison January 2010 FOREWORD by Graham Allison How serious is the threat of weapons of mass destruction (WMD) terrorism? When asked, “What is the single most serious threat to American national security?” President George W. Bush answered: nuclear terrorism. On this issue, President Obama agrees with his predecessor. In his words, “The single most important national security threat we face is nuclear weapons falling into the hands of terrorists.” The only Secretary of Defense to have served under both Republican and Democratic presidents, Secretary Robert Gates, was asked recently, “What keeps you awake at night?” He responded: “It’s the thought of a terrorist ending up with a weapon of mass destruction, especially nuclear.” Skeptics, however, abound. They say that WMD terrorism is far beyond the capability, and even the intent of terrorist groups such as al Qaeda. Some claim that the likelihood of a non-state actor acquiring such weapons is virtually zero. The individual in the U.S. intelligence community who is widely recognized as the leading analyst of WMD terrorism is Rolf Mowatt-Larssen. After more than three decades in public service in CIA operations, and most recently Director of Intelligence and Counterintelligence at the U.S. Department of Energy, he retired in January 2009. Mowatt-Larssen has now compiled a comprehensive chronology that addresses the skeptics head-on, by presenting, in unclassified form, al Qaeda’s roughly 15-year quest to acquire WMD. By assembling the best publically- available evidence in an authoritative, readable account, he offers a must-read advance in our understanding of the threat. This record provides an essential grounding for serious thought about how to combat a defining threat of the 21st Century. This chronology teaches us four important lessons. First, al Qaeda’s top leadership has demonstrated a sustained commitment to buy, steal or construct WMD. In 1998, Osama bin Laden declared that “acquiring WMD for the defense of Muslims is a religious duty.” In December 2001, bin Laden’s Deputy Ayman Zawahiri stated, “If you have $30 million, go to the black market in the central Asia, contact any disgruntled Soviet scientist and a lot of dozens of smart briefcase bombs are available.” A few months later, al Qaeda announced its goal to “kill four million Americans.” Second, al Qaeda was prepared to expend significant resources to cultivate a WMD capability even during the planning phases of 9/11. In the years leading up to September 2001, we see that bin Laden’s organization never lost its focus on WMD, even while 2 Al Qaeda Weapons of Mass Destruction Threat: Hype or Reality? coordinating the 9/11 attacks, orchestrating the simultaneous bombings of the U.S.