Please Pass the Globster

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Please Pass the Globster SI J-A 2006 pgs 5/30/06 1:41 PM Page 25 SKEPTICAL INQUIREE BENJAMIN RADFORD Please Pass the Globster Bermuda island in 1988. Controversy and “when the microscopic anatomy and and mystery surrounded the creatures for biochemical composition of the Chilean Q: What is a globster and where decades, as definitive identifications and Nantucket Blobs are compared with can I find one? eluded researchers. those of the other remains, similarities In a series of articles for his publication are manifest. Thus, there is no doubt —D. Musella The Cryptozoology Review, Canadian that they are all derived from the same marine biologist Ben Roesch examined the type of organism.” original accounts of over two dozen alleged With the application of science, one of A: A globster (or “blobster”) is a huge, sea serpent carcasses found between 1648 the world’s great mysteries of the sea has smelly, often whitish mass of flesh found and 1924. He concluded that the creatures finally been explained. The many men- on beaches throughout the world. No, “often turn out to be basking sharks, tions of globsters in books on the “unex- not tourists—dead “sea monsters.” “If sea whales, oarfish, or some other known crea- plained” will have to be revised in the cold serpents exist, why don’t we have a body?” ture.” In some especially puzzling cases— light of hard evidence and close scrutiny, asks cryptozoologist Loren Coleman, in where the information was highly suspect informing their readers that a whole sub- his field guide to sea serpents. “Well, we or especially sketchy—even a tenuous genre of “monsters” have been identified. do. Dozens and dozens of odd carcasses, identification was impossible. Yet because much of the material tends strange live catches, and huge lumps of A team of biologists led by Sidney toward mystery-mongering, it may take decaying tissue… have been recovered. Pierce began looking into the mystery and many years for the conclusions to be But what are they, exactly? Identifying tried to settle the issue. As the authors accepted and widely known. pointed out, “Wild claims, especially in often partial and decomposing remains is References no easy task.” the nonscientific literature, are regularly made that the blobs are the remains of sea Coleman, L., and P. Huyghe. 2003. The Field Guide The blobsters are obviously flesh, yet to Lake Monsters, Sea Serpents, and Other Mystery have decayed so badly that they lack monsters. For example, the Tasmanian Denizens of the Deep. New York: Penguin. bones or distinguishing features. For West Coast Monster is still referred to as a Pierce, S., S. Massey, N. Curtis, G. Smith, C. monster, although an Australian scientific Olavarria, and T. Maugel. 2004. Microscopic, many people, the huge, strange creatures biochemical, and molecular characteristics of the strongly resemble sea monsters. One clas- team . identified it as a whale. Other Chilean Blob and a comparison with the sic globster washed ashore in 1896, when relics such as the St. Augustine (Florida) remains of other sea monsters: Nothing but Sea Monster and the Bermuda Blob are whales. Biological Bulletin June, 206:125–133. giant waves tossed a massive fleshy corpse Pierce, S., G. Smith, T. Maugel, and E. Clark. 1995. on a beach at St. Augustine, Florida. The still described by some as the remains of a On the Giant Octopus (Octopus giganteus) and rubbery, six-foot-high blob was examined gigantic octopus, even though A.E. the Bermuda Blob: Homage to A.E. Verrill. Verrill—who named the St. Augustine Biological Bulletin April, 188: 219–230. by a local naturalist, who initially specu- Roesch, B. 1997–1999. A review of alleged sea ser- lated that it was likely from a giant octo- specimen sight unseen—recanted his pent carcasses worldwide. The Cryptozoology pus far larger than any previously seen. identification in favor of whale remains . Review (Parts 1–4, 2:2–3:3). Many other such blobs have washed and in spite of microscopic and biochem- ashore, including one in Chile in July ical analyses showing that they were noth- 2003 and another in Newfoundland in ing more than the collagenous matrix of Ask the Skeptic 2001. There’s also the Tasmanian West whale blubber.” In 2004, Pierce and his colleagues Heard about some dubious para- Coast Monster, the Nantucket Blob, and normal or fringe-science claim? two so-called “Bermuda Blobs,” the most examined all available globster speci- mens using electron microscopes, and Ask the skeptic! Submissions can recent of which washed ashore on be sent to: The Skeptical In- applied biochemical, molecular, and quiree, Skeptical Inquirer, P.O. DNA analyses. The conclusion: the sam- Benjamin Radford is coauthor, with Joe Box 703, Amherst NY 14226 (or Nickell, of Lake Monster Mysteries: ples matched exactly those of various [email protected]). Investigating the World’s Most Elusive species of great whales. The DNA and Creatures. molecular structure were unmistakable, SKEPTICAL INQUIRER July / August 2006 25.
Recommended publications
  • Sea Monsters and Real Environmental Threats: Reconsidering the Famous Osborne, ‘Moha-Moha’, Valhalla, and ‘Soay Beast’ Sightings of Unidentified Marine Objects
    IMAGINARY SEA MONSTERS AND REAL ENVIRONMENTAL THREATS: RECONSIDERING THE FAMOUS OSBORNE, ‘MOHA-MOHA’, VALHALLA, AND ‘SOAY BEAST’ SIGHTINGS OF UNIDENTIFIED MARINE OBJECTS R. L. FRANCE Dal Ocean Research Group Department of Plant, Food, and Environmental Sciences, Dalhousie University Abstract At one time, largely but not exclusively during the nineteenth century, retellings of encounters with sea monsters were a mainstay of dockside conversations among mariners, press reportage for an audience of fascinated landlubbers, and journal articles published by believing or sceptical natural scientists. Today, to the increasing frustration of cryptozoologists, mainstream biologists and environmental historians have convincingly argued that there is a long history of conflating or misidentifying known sea animals as purported sea monsters. The present paper provides, for the first time, a detailed, diachronic review of competing theories that have been posited to explain four particular encounters with sea monsters, which at the time of the sightings (1877, 1890, 1905, and 1959) had garnered worldwide attention and considerable fame. In so doing, insights are gleaned about the role played by sea monsters in the culture of late-Victorian natural science. Additionally, and most importantly, I offer my own parsimonious explanation that the observed ‘sea monsters’ may have been sea turtles entangled in pre-plastic fishing gear or maritime debris. Environmental history is therefore shown to be a valuable tool for looking backward in order to postulate the length of time that wildlife populations have been subjected to anthropogenic pressure. This is something of contemporary importance, given that scholars are currently involved in deliberations concerning the commencement date of the Anthropocene Era.
    [Show full text]
  • How to Tell a Sea Monster: Molecular Discrimination of Large Marine Animals of the North Atlantic
    Reference: Biol. Bull. 202: 1–5. (February 2002) How To Tell a Sea Monster: Molecular Discrimination of Large Marine Animals of the North Atlantic S. M. CARR1,*, H. D. MARSHALL1, K. A. JOHNSTONE1, L. M. PYNN1, AND G. B. STENSON2 1Genetics, Evolution, and Molecular Systematics Laboratory, Department of Biology, Memorial University of Newfoundland, St. John’s, Newfoundland A1B 3X9, Canada; and 2Marine Mammals Section, Science, Oceans, and Environment Branch, Department of Fisheries and Oceans, PO Box 5667, St. John’s, Newfoundland A1C 5X1, Canada “Either we do know all the varieties of beings which people our planet, or we do not. If we do not know them all—if Nature has still secrets in the deeps for us, nothing is more conformable to reason than to admit the existence of fishes, or cetaceans of other kinds, or even of new species ...which an accident of some sort has brought at long intervals to the upper level of the ocean.” —Jules Verne, Twenty Thousand Leagues Under the Sea, 1870 Abstract. Remains of large marine animals that wash (1994) gives a contemporary list. Even in the first year of a onshore can be difficult to identify due to decomposition new century when the complete human genome has become and loss of external body parts, and in consequence may be known (International Human Genome Sequencing Consor- dubbed “sea monsters.” DNA that survives in such car- tium, 2001), the possibility that entirely new, previously casses can provide a basis of identification. One such crea- unknown species may unexpectedly present themselves re- ture washed ashore at St.
    [Show full text]
  • N: a Sea Monster of a Research Project
    Utah State University DigitalCommons@USU Undergraduate Honors Capstone Projects Honors Program 5-2019 N: A Sea Monster of a Research Project Adrian Jay Thomson Utah State University Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.usu.edu/honors Part of the English Language and Literature Commons Recommended Citation Thomson, Adrian Jay, "N: A Sea Monster of a Research Project" (2019). Undergraduate Honors Capstone Projects. 424. https://digitalcommons.usu.edu/honors/424 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Honors Program at DigitalCommons@USU. It has been accepted for inclusion in Undergraduate Honors Capstone Projects by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@USU. For more information, please contact [email protected]. N: A SEA MONSTER OF A RESEARCH PROJECT by Adrian Jay Thomson Capstone submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for graduation with UNIVERSITY HONORS with a major in English- Creative Writing in the Department of English Approved: UTAH STATE UNIVERSITY Logan, UT SPRING2019 Abstract Ever since time and the world began, dwarves have always fought cranes. Ever since ships set out on the northern sea, great sea monsters have risen to prey upon them. Such are the basics of life in medieval and Renaissance Scandinavia , Iceland, Scotland and Greenland, as detailed by Olaus Magnus' Description of the Northern Peoples (1555) , its sea monster -heavy map , the Carta Marina (1539), and Abraham Ortelius' later map of Iceland, Islandia (1590). I first learned of Olaus and Ortelius in the summer of 2013 , and while drawing my own version of their sea monster maps a thought hit me: write a book series , with teenage characters similar to those in How to Train Your Dragon , but set it amongst the lands described by Olaus , in a frozen world badgered by the sea monsters of Ortelius.
    [Show full text]
  • FEBRUARY ACTIVITY SHEET Join Eddie at the Academy to Earn Stamps and Win a Prize!
    FEBRUARY ACTIVITY SHEET Join Eddie at the Academy to earn stamps and win a prize! ACTIVITY #1 ACTIVITY #2 ACTIVITY #3 Scientist Saturday will Join us for the opening Visit our zebras in the feature fisheries biologists weekend of Mythic Creatures: Serengeti diorama on on February 23, 12–4 p.m. Dragons, Unicorns & Mermaids Level 2. Is the baby zebra Check out the exhibit February 16–18 where you can the smallest animal you What Eats What today to watch as we dissect a “kraken” see in the diorama? Learn learn more about the food at Science Live. Learn more more about baby zebras chain in a stream. with the activity on the back. below. A ZEBRA’S FIRST DAY Join Marty the Moose for story time on Mondays at 11 a.m. in the Auditorium. Throughout February, Marty will be sharing one of his favorite books, My First Day, by Steve Jenkins. You will learn all about different animals and what their life is like on the very first day they are born. You may learn some amazing facts about newborn zebras! Did you know? A baby zebra can walk just a few minutes after it is born. Baby zebras are born weighing about 65 pounds and will grow to reach about 900 pounds as an adult. How many days did it take you to learn how to walk? MEMBER Don’t forget your stamp. Get your monthly stamp at the admissions desks. If you have eight stamps, it’s time to collect your prize in the Academy Shop! ansp.org 4/13/18 5:38 PM ANS_Kids_Club_Membership_Card.indd 1 RELEASE THE KRAKEN There are legends written about a sea monster called the Kraken.
    [Show full text]
  • Cetaceans of the Red Sea - CMS Technical Series Publication No
    UNEP / CMS Secretariat UN Campus Platz der Vereinten Nationen 1 D-53113 Bonn Germany Tel: (+49) 228 815 24 01 / 02 Fax: (+49) 228 815 24 49 E-mail: [email protected] www.cms.int CETACEANS OF THE RED SEA Cetaceans of the Red Sea - CMS Technical Series Publication No. 33 No. Publication Series Technical Sea - CMS Cetaceans of the Red CMS Technical Series Publication No. 33 UNEP promotes N environmentally sound practices globally and in its own activities. This publication is printed on FSC paper, that is W produced using environmentally friendly practices and is FSC certified. Our distribution policy aims to reduce UNEP‘s carbon footprint. E | Cetaceans of the Red Sea - CMS Technical Series No. 33 MF Cetaceans of the Red Sea - CMS Technical Series No. 33 | 1 Published by the Secretariat of the Convention on the Conservation of Migratory Species of Wild Animals Recommended citation: Notarbartolo di Sciara G., Kerem D., Smeenk C., Rudolph P., Cesario A., Costa M., Elasar M., Feingold D., Fumagalli M., Goffman O., Hadar N., Mebrathu Y.T., Scheinin A. 2017. Cetaceans of the Red Sea. CMS Technical Series 33, 86 p. Prepared by: UNEP/CMS Secretariat Editors: Giuseppe Notarbartolo di Sciara*, Dan Kerem, Peter Rudolph & Chris Smeenk Authors: Amina Cesario1, Marina Costa1, Mia Elasar2, Daphna Feingold2, Maddalena Fumagalli1, 3 Oz Goffman2, 4, Nir Hadar2, Dan Kerem2, 4, Yohannes T. Mebrahtu5, Giuseppe Notarbartolo di Sciara1, Peter Rudolph6, Aviad Scheinin2, 7, Chris Smeenk8 1 Tethys Research Institute, Viale G.B. Gadio 2, 20121 Milano, Italy 2 Israel Marine Mammal Research and Assistance Center (IMMRAC), Mt.
    [Show full text]
  • Historicity of Sea Turtles Misidentified As Sea Monsters
    Historicity of Sea Turtles Misidentified as Sea Monsters: A Case for the Early Entanglement of Marine Chelonians in Pre-plastic Fishing Nets and Maritime Debris Robert France Introduction The world’s oceans, even those regions far removed from human habitation1,2, have become the receptacle for discarded human waste. Today, over six million tons are jettisoned into the oceans and redistributed around the globe by currents and convergences every year3. Plastic has become the predominant element of this litter flotsam4-6 (Fig. 1), leading some to declare the problem “an ocean emergency”.7 Entanglement in maritime debris and both active and abandoned fishing gear is a serious environmental problem impacting the abundance and biodiversity of marine animals everywhere. More than two hundred species,8,9 Figure 1 Fig. 1. Flotsam, a significant portion of it plastic, displayed in the foyer of the maritime museum in Barcelona. including six of the seven species of sea turtles,10 can be caught in such material. Referred to by the ominous sobriquet of ‘ghost nets’, lost or purposely discarded fishing gear can continue their entrapment of animals for extended periods, and is an issue of particular concern.11,12 Entanglement can result in immediate death from drowning or long-term disability due to impaired swimming and the consequent ability to feed or avoid predation. Many entangled animals display wounds from the abrasion and cutting action of the debris,4 thereby increasing their risk of infection. Due to their life cycle and swimming, feeding
    [Show full text]
  • Sea Dragon Siren
    Sea Monster DEVOU R I NG M AW Sea Dragon May prioritize Heroes. Hits deal 2 damage to Heroes. 3 + 2 DESTROY GANGPLANK This Ability may be used up to 2 times per turn. Target a Gangplank within 1. Remove that Gangplank from the board, and knock all models on it Overboard. Return that gangplank to the board at the end of the round. DANGEROUS WATERS When an enemy Hero is knocked Overboard while within 3 of the Sea Dragon. Deploy the Sea Dragon into any Deal that Hero 4 damage. 8 Sea Zone. The Sea Dragon may only move into Sea Zones. Sea Monster SONG OF ACQUIESCENCE Siren This attack deals no damage. Instead, Push each Hero Hit up to 1 zone per Hit. This attack targets all Heroes in range (roll separately for each Hero). 3 + 3 SONG OF DISCORD This attack deals no damage. Hit cause STUN and SILENCE. This attack targets all enemy Heroes in range (roll separately for each Hero). 1 + 3 SONG OF DOMINION Target 1 enemy Hero within 3 zones. Immediately move them up to 2 zones and perform 1 of their attacks. That attack may target zones containing Deploy the Siren in any zone friendly models. That enemy Hero 6 gains no from KO’ing models within 1 of a Sea Zone. with this attack. Sea Monster POSEIDON’S JUDGMENT Avatar of Poseidon All friendly Heroes within 2 zones of the Avatar of Poseidon may heal up to 3. Deal all enemies Heroes within 2 zones 3 damage. LORD OF THE TIDES Draw 2 Tide Cards.
    [Show full text]
  • Summary Writing
    UNIT 6. SUMMARY WRITING A comprehensive test of reading and writing language skills OBJECTIVES • To understand the summary question • To identify the important information in the text • To plan your response • To correctly write your answer WHAT IS A SUMMARY? To summarize means to condense a text without losing the important information, so writing a summary involves taking the essential meaning from what you read, but making it shorter. 1. UNDERSTANDING THE QUESTION • How many questions are being asked? • How many parts does the question have? • What is specifically being asked? • What information do I need to look for? 2. FINDING INFORMATION IN THE PASSAGE • Do not read quickly • Take your time and understand • Find the specific information • Only the pertinent (relevant) information •MAKE NOTES 3. PLAN YOUR RESPONSE • Write down all your notes in classifications • At least 2 classifications / main thoughts • At least 2 paragraphs • Only information from the passage • Never your own thoughts or examples 4. WRITE YOUR ANSWER • Use correct grammar • USE YOUR OWN WORDS • Some words will need to be the same • But you MUST write it differently • Do not use examples or quotes from the text •Read the question LET’S •Read the text •Find the information DO IT! •Write notes •Write your answer WRITE A SUMMARY ABOUT THE APPEARANCE AND BEHAVIOR OF THE KRAKEN AND THE EXPLANATIONS GIVEN FOR WHAT IT WAS. •What did it look like? •How did it behave? •What was it? The Kraken In this passage the writer describes a legendary sea creature that was thought to be a danger to sailors and their ships.
    [Show full text]
  • UC Berkeley Berkeley Undergraduate Journal of Classics
    UC Berkeley Berkeley Undergraduate Journal of Classics Title Sea Monsters in Antiquity: A Classical and Zoological Investigation Permalink https://escholarship.org/uc/item/67t7807d Journal Berkeley Undergraduate Journal of Classics, 1(2) ISSN 2373-7115 Author Jaffe, Alexander Publication Date 2013 Peer reviewed|Undergraduate eScholarship.org Powered by the California Digital Library University of California Sea Monsters in Antiquity: A Classical and Zoological Investigation Alexander L. Jaffe Harvard University Dept. of Organismic and Evolutionary Biology Class of 2015 Abstract: Sea monsters inspired both fascination and fear in the minds of the ancients. In this paper, I aim to examine several traditional monsters of antiquity with a multi-faceted approach that couples classical background with modern day zoological knowledge. Looking at the examples of the ketos and the sea serpent in Roman and Greek societies, I evaluate the scientific bases for representations of these monsters across of variety of media, from poetry to ceramics. Through the juxtaposition of the classical material and modern science, I seek to gain a greater understanding of the ancient conception of sea monsters and explain the way in which they were rationalized and depicted by ancient cultures. A closer look at extant literature, historical accounts, and artwork also helps to reveal a human sentiment towards the ocean and its denizens penetrating through time even into the modern day. “The Sea-monsters, mighty of limb and huge, the wonders of the sea, heavy with strength invincible, a terror for the eyes to behold and ever armed with deadly rage—many of these there be that roam the spacious seas...”1 Oppian, Halieutica 1 As the Greek poet Oppian so eloquently reveals, sea monsters inspired both fascination and fear in the minds of the ancients.
    [Show full text]
  • USF SCIENTISTS SOLVE CHILEAN 'Blob' MYSTERY
    USF SCIENTISTS SOLVE CHILEAN 'Blob' MYSTERY TAMPA, Fla. (Jan. 8, 2004) - When a huge, unidentifiable, gelatinous blob weighing 13 tons and measuring 41 feet long and 19 feet wide washed up on a beach in Chile in July, 2003, many speculated that it was the remains of a giant sea monster. (www.cnn.com/2003/TECH/science/07/02/giant.find/). Similar, documented blobs, often thought to be the remains of giant squids, had turned up on beaches elsewhere, including one in St. Augustine, Fla. in 1896, two in Bermuda (1995 and 1997), in Tasmania in 1960 and Nantucket, Mass. in 1996. All the blobs looked pretty much the same, says Skip Pierce, professor of biology at the University of South Florida who is presenting the results of his blob bio-sleuthing today at the 2004 Annual Meeting of the Society for Integrative and Comparative Biology in New Orleans (www.sicb.org). Photograph Copyright (c) Elsa Cabrera/COC "In all cases, the blobs were thought to be possible sea monsters, but the decomposed carcasses lacked a skeleton," said Pierce. "Elsa Cabrera, director of the Center for Cetacean Conservation in Santiago, sent us samples of the 2003 Chilean blob and we compared it microscopically and genetically to preserved samples of other historical blobs, including the 1896 blob." Pierce and colleagues subjected the Chilean blob's DNA to polymerase chain reaction (PCR) tests and the blob's anatomy was looked at microscopically. "The Chilean sample was almost entirely pure collagen fibers," explained Pierce. The fibers, Pierce's team found, were totally unlike the fine structure of an octopus or squid.
    [Show full text]
  • Is the Loch Ness Monster Real? Does He Have Any Friends? in a Small Scottish Town, a Young Couple Are Invited to Relive an Old Man’S Inspirational Tale from His Youth
    Discussion Guide Is the Loch Ness Monster real? Does he have any friends? In a small Scottish town, a young couple are invited to relive an old man’s inspirational tale from his youth. As a child, Angus MacMorrow is a lonely little boy. He misses his father who is away serving his country. He longs for a best friend, to smile and feel joy, and to conquer his fear of the water. One day, wandering alone along the Scottish shore, he discovers an object the size of a rugby ball. Is it a rock? Or something else? At home, alone in his father’s workshop, he picks and prods until he uncovers the essence of his find—an egg. Overnight, the egg hatches. Angus comes face-to-face with a strange looking new best friend. He looks like a mix of toad, dragon, and horse. Angus names the critter Crusoe, after the famous castaway. Crusoe eats everything in his path and soon outgrows his bucket. Angus tries to hide Crusoe from his mom, Anne, his sister, Kirstie, the Royal Army force encamped around his home, and the mysterious new handyman, Lewis. But Angus’ secret soon escapes the workshop. Crusoe startles Lewis. But Lewis doesn’t expose Angus or his friend. Instead, he vows to help Angus care for the burgeoning beast. He tells Angus that Crusoe is a mythical creature called a Water Horse. And there is only one alive in the whole universe—Crusoe. Adventure, friendship, self-discovery, and hope follow in this exciting motion picture from Revolution Studios, Walden Media, and Beacon Pictures.
    [Show full text]
  • Sea Monsters Edited by Thea Tomaini and Asa Simon Mittman Sea Monsters
    SEA MONSTERS EDITED BY THEA TOMAINI AND ASA SIMON MITTMAN SEA MONSTERS THINGS FROM THE SEA, VOLUME 2 EDITED BY ASA SIMON MITTMAN AND THEA TOMAINI TINY COLLECTIONS SEA MONSTERS: THINGS FROM THE SEA, VOLUME 2 ©2017 Asa Simon Mittman and Thea Tomaini This work carries a Creative Commons BY-NC-SA 4.0 International license, which means that you are free to copy and redistribute the material in any medium or format, and you may also remix, transform and build upon the material, as long as you clearly attribute the work to the authors (but not in a way that suggests the authors or publishers endorses you and your work), you do not use this work for commercial gain in any form whatsoever, and that for any remixing and transformation, you distribute your rebuild under the same license. http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by-nc-sa/4.0/ This work first published in 2017 by tiny collections, an imprint of punctum books created by the Material Collective punctumbooks.com | thematerialcollective.org The Material Collective is dedicated to fostering respectful intellectual exchange and innovative scholarship in the study of the visual arts, in the academy, and in the broader, public sphere. We believe that excellent scholarship can grow out of collaboration, experimentation, and play, and we work to create spaces where scholars from many different backgrounds, both traditional and non-traditional, can come together for mutual enrichment. Tiny Collections are gatherings: thoughtfully assembled things, presented in warm light with a murmured “lookit” for introduction. Tiny Collections are the things we do, together.
    [Show full text]