Der Stern Von Bethlehem , 2009 2, Frankfurt Am Main (Verlag Der Häretischen Blätter)
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Dieter Koch Astronomical Dating of the Mahābhārata War Version 1.01 Copyright © 2014 by Dieter Koch, Erlenbach, Switzerland Translation from the German original by the author himself, currently not perfect, will be edited by a native English speaker. (This version has important updates in the chapter “How Old are the Astronomical Concepts of the Mahābhārata Epic?”) 2 Contents Contents ....................................................................................................... 2 How Old are the Astronomical Concepts of the Mahābhārata Epic? .... 4 Astronomical Concepts from the Bronze Age? .................................................... 4 Vernal Point in the Lunar Mansion Kṛttikā ........................................................ 11 Vernal Point in the Lunar Mansion Rohiṇī? ...................................................... 28 Vernal Point in Bharaṇī and Aśvinī ................................................................... 31 Precession of the Equinoxes in Ancient Indien Astronomy ............................... 35 Of the Origin of the Lunar Mansions ................................................................. 52 Conclusions ........................................................................................................ 53 A Super-Conjunction ................................................................................ 55 “The seven planets flew together...” .................................................................. 56 „... like the planets beset the Moon at the end of the age“ ................................. 62 The “Gathering Together” of All Beings in their Origin.................................... 67 Phases and Types of Super-Conjunctions .......................................................... 74 The Super-Conjunction of 1198 BCE ................................................................ 77 Moon in Maghā? ................................................................................................ 78 Another Super-Conjunction at the Death of Kṛṣṇa?........................................... 81 The Traditional Kaliyuga Era .................................................................. 92 The Clustering of Planets of 3102 BCE ............................................................. 92 Revatī as Ecliptic Zero Point in Vedic Times? ................................................ 104 The Clustering of Planets of 3143 BCE ........................................................... 109 The Seven Ṛṣis and Varāhamihira’s Kaliyuga Era ............................. 119 Conjunction of the Seven Ṛṣis at the Beginning of Kaliyuga .......................... 119 Seven Ṛṣis and Seven Planets .......................................................................... 126 Super-Conjunctions at Intervals of 100 Years ................................................. 130 The Clustering of Planets of 2449 BCE ........................................................... 135 New Moon, Full Moon, Eclipses ............................................................. 137 New Moon in Jyeṣṭhā and Full Moon in the Month of Kārttika ...................... 137 Super-Conjunction with Eclipses 1198 BCE ................................................... 147 Solar and Lunar Eclipses at the Time of the Great War ................................... 150 Problems concerning the Eclipses and the Calendar in 1198 BCE .................. 164 Eclipses on the 13th of the Fortnight ............................................................... 170 Two Suns at the End of the Age ....................................................................... 191 Ketu, Dhūmaketu, and Comets ........................................................................ 196 Planetary Configurations ....................................................................... 202 Jupiter and Saturn in Viśākhā .......................................................................... 202 Saturn and Jupiter torment Rohiṇī ................................................................... 205 Mars in Jyeṣṭhā/Anurādhā ................................................................................ 208 3 Alternative Approaches I ................................................................................. 211 And another celestial configuration ................................................................. 219 Alternative Approaches II ................................................................................ 225 Duels and Conjunctions of Planets .................................................................. 229 Do the five Pāṇḍavas stand for the five planets? ............................................. 237 Bhīṣma’s Death ....................................................................................... 246 How Many Days from the Battle to Bhīṣma’s Death? ..................................... 246 Bhīṣma’s Death and the Super-conjunction of 1198 BCE ............................... 263 Alternative Approaches III .............................................................................. 264 Solar Eclipses Before and After the War ......................................................... 277 Conclusions...................................................................................................... 279 Appendices .............................................................................................. 281 A: Super-Conjunctions with New Moon 4000 BCE to 2500 CE .................... 281 B: Super-Conjunctions Without New Moon .................................................... 299 C: Cycles of Super-Conjunctions ..................................................................... 314 D: Super-Conjunctions that Fulfill some Criteria from Mahābhārata .............. 316 E: All Planets Near the Moon in the Morning Sky .......................................... 319 F: All Planets Near the Moon in the Evening Sky ........................................... 325 G: Total Solar Eclipses at Sunrise ................................................................... 334 H: Total Solar Eclipses at Sunset ..................................................................... 336 I: Annular Solar Eclipses at Sunrise ................................................................ 337 J: Annular Solar Eclipses at Sunset ................................................................. 338 K: Total and Annular Eclipses Observable in Kurukṣetra ............................... 339 L: Total and Annular Eclipses Observable in Dvārakā .................................... 391 M: Two Eclipses in a Month in the New Moon Calendar ............................... 441 N: Two Eclipses in a Month in the Full Moon Calendar ................................. 467 Bibliography ............................................................................................ 492 4 How Old are the Astronomical Concepts of the Mahābhārata Epic? Astronomical Concepts from the Bronze Age? Numerous astronomical and calendrical statements in ancient Indian texts raise the question whether these texts could not be dated on the basis of astronomical calculations. If, for example, a text says that an equinox or solstice is located in a particular lunar mansion, we cannot avoid the question for what period this statement was valid. Due to lunisolar precession, such statements can be true only for the duration of a couple of centuries. Thus we can calculate the period in which this astronomical doctrine must have emerged. Calculations of this kind are very simple and the results will not leave much room for doubt. Unfortunately, however, the dates obtained in this way are mostly totally at odds with dates that have been found on the basis of historical or linguistic considerations. For example, the astronomical and calendrical informations contained in the Mahābhārata Epic are based on a lunar mansions system that has its initial point at the lunar mansion Kṛttikā (the Pleiades). As we shall see, the reason seems to be that in ancient times the vernal equinox was located near the Pleiades and the full moon, when it took place on the autumnal equinox, also was seen near them. Now, the vernal equinox could be attributed to the Pleiades only between about 3000 and 1500 BCE, whereas current indology dates the final redaction of the Mahābhārata Epic to between 400 BCE and 400 CE. The underlying astronomical theory thus seems to be over 2000 years older than the text in which it is used. This raises the question of how this huge time gap can be explained. I do not intend to challenge the late dating of the Mahābhārata Epic and the other texts of the Vedic tradition as given by the scientific establishment. The problem should be taken seriously, though. While it is understandable that historians and indologists, who usually do not have deeper insight into astronomical and 5 calendrical issues, give less weight to archaeoastronomical arguments and even tend to disregard the whole issue, astronomical dating does weigh very heavy from the point of view of the “strict” sciences. It is therefore necessary to discuss the problem duly, as has also been pointed out by authors such as Tilak, Sengupta, Elst, and others. Let us first study a less extreme example, namely David Pingree’s statements concerning the dating of the Vedāṅgajyotiṣa, the oldest Indian astronomical treatise. According to the text, the solstices are located at the middle of Āśleṣā and the beginning of Dhaniṣṭhā. Now, while we do not know exactly where the initial points of the