DOCSLIB.ORG

Physical Activity, Body (Dis)Satisfaction and Mental Health in the Transgender Population

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Physical Activity, Body (Dis)Satisfaction and Mental Health in the Transgender Population Physical activity, body (dis)satisfaction and mental health in the transgender population by Bethany Alice Jones Doctoral Thesis Submitted in partial fulfilment of the requirements for the award of Doctor of Philosophy of Loughborough University December 2017 © Bethany Alice Jones, 2017 Acknowledgments Acknowledgments I would firstly like to thank my supervisors Dr Emma Haycraft, Professor Jon Arcelus and Dr Walter Bouman for their continuous support, guidance and sharing of expert knowledge. You have made this experience truly enjoyable and have inspired me to continue to help people. Special thanks to all the participants, patients and staff at the Nottingham Centre for Transgender Health for generously giving their time and making the research that comprises this thesis possible. Thank you also to the tightly knitted PhD student community within the School of Sport, Exercise and Health Sciences at Loughborough University. It has been invaluable being able to share the highs and lows of this journey together. I would also like to thank my partner, Tom, for always believing in me even when I haven’t. You have supported me from day one and have always taken a genuine interest in my work. Thank you for always celebrating my achievements with me. Finally, I would like to thank my family, Mum, Dad and Will, for not only supporting me on this journey but all the journeys before this that have made this PhD thesis possible. I hope I have made you all proud and continue to do so; this work is dedicated to you. I Abstract Abstract Background and aims: Prior to gender affirming medical interventions, transgender people often experience high levels of body dissatisfaction and poor mental health in comparison to the cisgender (i.e., non-transgender) population. Body dissatisfaction and poor mental health have been associated with eating disorder psychopathology within the cisgender population. Transgender people are therefore an important group to target for intervention development. Participating in physical activity and/or sport within the cisgender population has been associated with body satisfaction and mental well-being. The overarching aim for the research reported on in this thesis was therefore to explore the role of body (dis)satisfaction, mental health and medical transition on physical (in)activity and eating disorder symptoms within the transgender population. Studies that have evaluated gender affirming medical interventions have been limited by the outcome tools used and therefore this thesis also aimed to develop and validate a new measure to assess intervention and treatment outcomes. Participants: Treatment seeking transgender people were invited to take part in all of the empirical studies reported on in this thesis. For some studies, transgender people from the community and/or cisgender participants were also recruited. Main findings: Despite being motivated, many transgender people reported having negative experiences engaging in physical activity and/or sport due to numerous internal and external barriers. Many of these barriers are directly or indirectly related to body dissatisfaction. Cross-sex hormones appeared to increase physical activity participation, possibly by alleviating body dissatisfaction and increasing mental well-being. It was also found that body dissatisfaction played a key role in the existence of eating disorder symptoms. Transgender people who had taken cross-sex hormones reported lower levels of eating disorder symptoms, possibly due to an increase in body satisfaction. Finally, this thesis successfully developed a new outcome measure in collaboration with transgender people and experts working in transgender healthcare. This measure was named the Gender Congruence and Life Satisfaction Scale (GCLS) and was found to be valid and reliable. Implications: Spreading awareness of the barriers that transgender people face in relation to physical activity and sport engagement may help this population to become more active. II Abstract Being more active is important for transgender people as it may have body image and mental health benefits. Cross-sex hormones appear to be crucial in reducing body dissatisfaction and increasing mental well-being. Possibly because of this, physical activity levels are higher among people who have taken cross-sex hormones. Additionally, cross-sex hormones also appear to reduce eating disorder symptoms. However, the research in this thesis is cross- sectional. Future research should adopt a longitudinal research design, particularly now that a new tool to evaluate intervention and treatment outcomes (the GCLS) has been developed. This tool is likely to make important advances in research which will contribute towards increasing the well-being of the transgender population. III Table of contents Table of contents Acknowledgments ............................................................................................... I Abstract ............................................................................................................... II Table of contents .............................................................................................. IV List of tables ................................................................................................... XIII List of figures ................................................................................................... XV List of appendices .......................................................................................... XVI Publications and conference proceedings .................................................. XVII Glossary of key terms used within this thesis ............................................. XXI Chapter 1.............................................................................................................. 1 General introduction ........................................................................................................... 1 1.1. Introduction ................................................................................................................... 1 1.2. Who are transgender people? ...................................................................................... 1 1.3. The global prevalence of being transgender ............................................................... 3 1.4. Diagnostic classification for transgender people: Revisions and current debates .. 5 1.5. The treatment pathway in the National Health Service: A UK perspective ........... 7 1.5.1. Referral to a transgender health service ................................................................... 8 1.5.2. Waiting time at transgender health services after referral ....................................... 8 1.5.3. Stage of transition at the point of referral ................................................................ 8 1.5.4. Initial assessment at a transgender health service .................................................... 9 1.5.5. Ongoing assessment at a transgender health service ............................................. 10 1.5.6. Cross-sex hormone treatment ................................................................................ 10 1.5.6.1. Cross-sex hormone treatment: Testosterone .................................................... 11 1.5.6.2. Cross-sex hormone treatment: Oestrogen ........................................................ 11 1.5.6.3. Testosterone blockers....................................................................................... 12 1.5.7. Surgical interventions ............................................................................................ 12 1.5.7.1. Surgical interventions for people assigned female at birth .............................. 12 1.5.7.2. Surgical interventions for people assigned male at birth ................................. 13 1.5.8. Aftercare ................................................................................................................ 13 1.6. Support organisations for transgender people within the UK................................ 13 1.7. Mental health within the transgender population ................................................... 14 IV Table of contents 1.7.1. General mental health ............................................................................................ 14 1.7.2. Body dissatisfaction and disordered eating............................................................ 15 1.7.3. Alleviation of mental health problems and body dissatisfaction ........................... 16 1.7.3.1. Gender affirming medical interventions .......................................................... 16 1.7.3.2. Physical activity and sport ............................................................................... 17 1.7.4. Physical health of the transgender population ....................................................... 18 1.7.5. Limitations of the extant transgender physical activity, body dissatisfaction and mental health literature .................................................................................................... 18 1.7.5.1. Measurement issues ......................................................................................... 18 1.7.5.2. Sample issues ................................................................................................... 19 1.8. Chapter summary ....................................................................................................... 20 1.9. Initial aims of the thesis .............................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Briefing Book
    BRIEFING BOOK A REQUEST TO CONGRESS AND THE ADMINISTRATION TO SAFEGUARD GIRLS’ AND WOMEN’S SPORT & INCLUDE TRANSGENDER ATHLETES The Women’s Sports Policy Group acknowledges the complexity of this issue. We are committed to transparency and continual refinement of our work. The most recent update of this Briefing Book will be posted at https://womenssportspolicy.org/references/ as the first document at the top of the page. Prepared by The Women’s Sports Policy Working Group (Revised as of February 27, 2021) https://womenssportspolicy.org/ Contact: Donna Lopiano for additional information as needed ([email protected] or call 516-380-1213) SAFEGUARDING GIRLS’ AND WOMEN’S SPORTS AND INCLUDING TRANSGENDER ATHLETES TABLE OF CONTENTS Page Women’s Sports Policy Working Group 3 Supporters 4 Specific Request 5 The Issue 5 The Resolution 7 Definitions 17 Frequently Asked Questions About Science and Sex 18 About Current Law on Sex and Sport 34 About Policy 37 2 | P a g e WOMEN'S SPORTS POLICY WORKING GROUP Donna de Varona, OLY. Two-time Olympic gold medalist in swimming. In 1965, UPI and AP voted her outstanding woman athlete in the world after she set 18 world records and fastest times. de Varona was a sports broadcasting pioneer as the youngest and one of the first women to work in the industry. As an Emmy recipient, she used her visibility to advise and advocate for the protection and promotion of Title IX as well as for the Ted Stevens Olympic and Amateur Sports Act. As the first President and Chair of the Board of the Women’s Sports Foundation, she helped build the organization into a sustainable, influential entity.
    [Show full text]
  • Handbook of Best Practices in Dual Career of Athletes in DC4AC Project Participating Countries
    Handbook of Best Practices in Dual Career of Athletes in DC4AC project participating countries Final version, May 2017 Handbook of Best Practices in Dual Career of Athletes in DC4AC project participating countries This project has been funded with support from the European Commission. This publication [communication] reflects the views only of the authors, and the Commission cannot be held responsible for any use which may be made of the information contained therein. 2 Handbook of Best Practices in Dual Career of Athletes in DC4AC project participating countries SUMMARY Introduction.............................................................................................................................. 5 Romania ...................................................................................................................................... 6 The situation in Romania and concerns for athletes dual career ................................................... 6 Main initiatives and legislative regulations related to DC in Romania. Best practices. .................. 7 Hungary ....................................................................................................................................... 9 Erasmus+ sport projects and European projects .......................................................................... 9 Projects of national federations or National Olympic Committee .............................................. 12 Educational ministry - government .........................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Active People Survey 5-7 Technical Report Updated to Include APS6 (July 2013)
    Active People Survey 5-7 Technical Report Updated to include APS6 (July 2013) Controlled document - Issue 4 TNS BMRB JN 260105344 March 2013 Controlled document - Issue 6 Contents 1. Overview and methodological summary ........................................ 1 2. Questionnaire design and piloting ................................................ 4 3. Sampling and respondent selection ............................................ 37 4. Fieldwork administration ........................................................... 41 5. Sample management rules and response rates ............................ 52 6. 16-25 Boost Survey ................................................................. 57 7. Data processing and weighting .................................................. 60 8. Development work ................................................................... 68 9. Appendices ............................................................................. 82 i Active People Survey 6 – Technical Report 1. Overview and methodological summary 1.1 Background, aims and objectives This document outlines the methodological and technical aspects used in the Active People Survey 5-7. The approach described in this document is predominately the same as the approach used for the previous Active People Surveys in order to provide statistically reliable measures comparable with the baseline data provided by APS1 and APS2. The Active People Survey (APS) is being carried out for Sport England, the non- departmental public body sponsored by the Department
    [Show full text]
  • Evaluation Report Pride House
    PRIDE HOUSE EVALUATION REPORT 23 July – 3 August 2014 www.pridehouseglasgow.co.uk Report v2c.indd 1 09/06/2016 12:13 Report v2c.indd 2 09/06/2016 12:13 1 Content Foreword ..............................................................................2 Introduction .........................................................................3 Key headlines ......................................................................4 History of the Pride House movement .....................6 Aims and Objectives of Pride House .........................8 Celebrate ............................................................................ 10 Promote ...............................................................................12 Welcome ............................................................................. 14 Collaborate ........................................................................ 16 Include ................................................................................. 18 Home Hosts ...................................................................... 20 A focus on LGBT sport...................................................21 Pride House volunteers team .................................... 24 The inclusive Games .....................................................30 Supporting those seeking asylum ............................32 LGBTI People of the Commonwealth ..................... 34 Patrons and Champions ...............................................35 After the Games ............................................................
    [Show full text]
  • SPORTS TASTER SESSIONS – TRY a NEW SPORT! Tuesday 14 August 2012 20:00 – Sailing Social – the Phoenix Artist Club, Charing Cross Road, WC2H 8BU
    SPORTS TASTER SESSIONS – TRY A NEW SPORT! Tuesday 14 August 2012 20:00 – Sailing Social – The Phoenix Artist Club, Charing Cross Road, WC2H 8BU Wednesday 15 August 2012 18:30 – 20:30 – Women’s Football with Hackney Women’s FC, Finsbury Park (Manor House Gate) 18:00 – 20:00 – Men’s/Mixed Football with Leftfooters FC, Regents Park 20:30 – Out For Sport’s Women’s Social - Oak Bar, 79 Green Lanes, London, N16 9BU Thursday 16 August 2012 18:45 – 21:00 – Women’s Basketball with London Cruisers, Bethnal Green Academy 19:00 – 21:00 – Women’s Volleyball with Dynamo Dykes, Hyde Park (Marble Arch tube) Friday 17 August 2012 19:00 – 21:00 – Men’s Basketball with London Cruisers, Britannia Leisure Centre, Hackney 19:45 – 21:00 – Water Polo – London Orcas (Out To Swim), Porchester Baths, Queensway Saturday 18 August 2012 09:45 – 11:00 – Running with London’s Frontrunners in Hyde Park, Meet- Imperial College’s St Mary’s Campus 12:00 – 13:30 – Kickboxing with KB Kickboxing, Piccadilly 13:00 – 14:00 – Ballroom and Latin (Dancesport), Studio LaDanza, Holloway Road 13:45 – 15:00 – Duplicate Bridge with West London Gay Bridge Group, Victoria Pub, Paddington 15:30 – 17:30 – Self Defence and Martial Arts with Ishigaki Ju Jitsu Club, Oasis Sports Centre 15:45 – 18:00 – Squash with OutPlay Squash, Old Street 18:30 – 20:00 – Swimming Taster Session – Out To Swim, Queen Mother Sports Centre, Victoria 20:00 onwards – Out For Sport Night Out - Shadow Lounge, Soho. Hosted by Soho Rowing Club. Sunday 19 August 2012 10:00 – 12:30 – Hockey with London Royals Hockey Club, John Orwell Centre, Wapping 12:45 – 15:30 – Men’s/Mixed Football with London Titans FC (11 Aside).
    [Show full text]
  • The Research Comprised of a Postal Self-Completion Survey with Young
    DISABILITY SURVEY 2000: SURVEY OF YOUNG PEOPLE WITH A DISABILITY AND SPORT Contents Page Chapter 1 Preface 3 1.1 Research Programme 3 1.2 Background and Objectives 3 1.3 Acknowledgements 14 1.4 Analysis 15 1.5 Weighting 18 1.6 Presentation and interpretation of the data 19 1.7 Finding your way around the report 19 Chapter 2 Key Findings 21 Chapter 3 Implications 32 Chapter 4 Overview 37 4.1 How many young people are taking part in sport? 38 4.2 The level of participation in sport 'at least once' in the last year 41 4.3 Sports participated in 'at least once' 42 4.4 The level of participation in sport 'frequently' in the last year 45 4.5 Sports participated part in 'frequently' 47 Chapter 5 Sport in school lessons 51 5.1 The level of participation in sport 'at least once' in lessons 52 5.2 Sports participated in 'at least once' in lessons 54 5.3 The level of participation in sport 'frequently' in lessons 59 5.4 Sports participated in 'frequently' in lessons 61 5.5 Types of sports taken part in during school time 68 5.6 Time spent on PE in a week in school (hours) 79 5.7 Time spent on PE in a week in school (days) 84 Chapter 6 Sport out of lessons 91 6.1 The level of participation in sports 'at least once' out of school lessons 92 6.2 Sports participated in 'at least once' out of school lessons 93 6.3 The level of participation in sport 'frequently' out of lessons 98 6.4 Sports done frequently out of lessons 100 6.5 Types of sports done out of lesson time 107 6.6 When sport is done out of lessons 116 6.7 Time spent on sport out of lessons
    [Show full text]
  • Equality and Sport Research January 2016
    Equality and Sport Research January 2016 Research Scotland 2 Myrtle Park Glasgow G42 8UQ 0141 424 5295 [email protected] CONTENTS Executive Summary ........................................................................ i 1. Introduction ............................................................................. 1 2. The evidence around equality and sport ................................. 6 3. Views within the sporting system ............................................ 40 4. Views of people with protected characteristics ....................... 58 5. Findings and conclusions ........................................................ 71 APPENDICES Appendix One: Survey of Staff in the Sport Sector in Scotland Appendix Two: Discussion Guide for Focus Groups with Staff Appendix Three: Equality Monitoring EXECUTIVE SUMMARY About this research This report explores equality and sport in Scotland. This research aims to help improve work within the sport sector in Scotland, in relation to advancing equality, eliminating discrimination and fostering good relations. It consolidates what we know and identifies what we need to know. It will form a building block for priorities for action around equality, for sportscotland and its partners in the sport sector. Research method The research involved four main stages. A review of existing evidence – We gathered, reviewed and created a database of existing evidence around sport and equality. We produced papers on sport and equality in relation to each protected characteristic. A survey of staff within the sport system – We issued a survey to over 1,200 staff, and 573 responded – a response rate of 46 per cent. Discussion groups with staff within the sport system – We held ten discussion groups with staff in the sport system in Scotland. These groups included staff involved at different levels and in different sporting fields and sectors. A total of 70 people took part in these groups.
    [Show full text]
  • TAKING US to 2014 and BEYOND Legacy Building Is a Vital Part of Glasgow 2014 Louise Martin Talks About Sportscotland’S Contribution
    Issue 7 Winter/Spring 2012 the magazine of sportscotland TAKING US TO 2014 AND BEYOND Legacy building is a vital part of Glasgow 2014 Louise Martin talks about sportscotland’s contribution JOIN THE CLUB A roadmap for world class club sport TOASTING SUCCESS Rowing champion Katherine Grainger talks about discipline, training, achievement… and the joy of two breakfasts BALANCING ACT How performance lifestyle helps athletes minimise distractions to maximise performance WORLD CLASS sportscotland has one clear focus: developing and supporting a world class sporting system at all levels. To find out more, visit www.sportscotland.org.uk A key part of our Commonwealth Games legacy commitment, We are working with community sport Midlothian Council to hubs are designed to Our target is to have establish Newbattle provide a home for 150 community sport High School as a club sport and make hubs up and running community sport hub it easier for people across the country in the local area. to get involved. by 2016. WELCOME CONTENTS 2 News round up 4 4 Taking us to 2014... and beyond Louise Martin outlines sportscotland’s preparations for Glasgow 2014 8 Toasting success Katherine Grainger MBE on her preparations for 2012 10 Join the club James Steel, Lead Manager for Club Sport, introduces the club sport framework 20 24 12 Club framework in action Real life examples of club success 14 Calling the shots A new performance programme for Scottish Curling 16 Time to skill Business offers to Work Out For Sport 17 Coaching matters Professional development for professional coaches 18 Sport your trainers! Glasgow 2014 on getting the nation into sporty shoes ’m delighted biomechanics.
    [Show full text]
  • Inclusive Sport Survey
    Inclusive Sport Survey The Sport Experiences of Lesbian, Gay, Bisexual, Transgender and Intersex People in the Australian Capital Territory April 2014 Conducted by Sport and Recreation Services, ACT Government Contact Kathy Mumberson, Play by the Rules Project Officer Email [email protected] | Phone 02 6207 7678 Acknowledgements The Inclusive Sport Survey was conducted by Kathy Mumberson, the Play by the Rules Project Officer employed by Sport and Recreation Services, ACT Government. It is one of several components of the Inclusive Sport Project that addresses discrimination, harassment and bullying in sport. An Inclusive Sport Steering Committee was formed to assist in various aspects of the project and the survey, including: research and question design, use of language, and promotion of the survey. Thanks must go to each of the committee members: Sean Acknowledgements Costello, from the ACT Human Rights Commission; Peter Hyndal, from A Gender Agenda; Keiran Rossteuscher, from ACT AIDS Action Council; and Peter Gourlay, from the Victorian Equal Opportunity and Human Rights Commission. Each committee member provided valuable input regarding important aspects of the survey and played an essential role with its successful rollout. Paul Oliver and Pete Downs from Play by the Rules partnered with Sport and Recreation Services to deliver the Inclusive Sport Project and effectively promoted the survey through their networks and on the Play by the Rules website. Dr Carolyn Symons from the Victoria University conducted the Victorian Come Out to Play Research Project, a benchmark research project and the first of its type in Australia. Carolyn and Grant O’Sullivan, also from Victoria University, provided practical Inclusive Sport Survey guidance in relation to the survey questions and promotion of these questions to the wider community.
    [Show full text]
  • Out for Sport Survey 8 1.5 Approach 8 Section 2
    tackling homophobia and transphobia in sport contents foreword introduction and background section 1. research methodology 7 1.1 Literature Review 7 1.2 LGBT Sports Groups Interviews and Focus Groups 7 1.3 Sports Sector Organisations Interviews and Questionnaires 7 1.4 Out for Sport Survey 8 1.5 Approach 8 section 2. key research findings 9 2.1 Key Statistics 9 2.2 Key Attitudinal findings 10 2.3 Key Strategic findings 11 2.4 Key Positive findings 12 section 3. the problem of homophobia & transphobia in sport 13 3.1 Perceptions of Homophobia and Transphobia in Sport 13 3.2 Homophobic and Transphobic Incidents 15 3.3 LGBT Experiences of Mainstream Sport 19 3.4 Information gaps and challenges to research around LGBT Participation 20 3.5 Barriers to LGBT Participation 23 3.6 Transgender Specific Barriers to Participation 27 3.6.1 Different Strokes Transgender swimming – case study 31 3.7 Sports-related Homophobic/transphobic school bullying 32 Margaret Smith Scott Cuthbertson Published June 2012 Nathan Gale 2 « out for sport section 4. tackling prejudice & improving participation 36 4.1 How to tackle homophobia and transphobia 37 4.2 Leadership 42 4.3 Role Models 50 4.4 Supporting and Safeguarding LGBT Young People 58 4.5 Capacity building within the LGBT sports sector 66 4.5.1 LGBT Sports Groups and SGBs 71 4.5.2 Supporting LGBT Sports Groups 74 4.6 LGBT Equality Policy and Practice in Scottish sport 76 4.6.1 Scottish Governing Bodies of Sport 77 4.6.2 The Equality Standard: A Framework for Sport 80 4.6.3 The SFA and Homophobia/Transphobia in Football 82 4.6.4 The SRU and Homophobia/Transphobia in Rugby 88 4.6.5 Working in Partnership 92 4.6.6 Local Authorities 95 section 5.
    [Show full text]
  • Sport for Change Full Report
    Sport for Change Research For: The Robertson Trust, Scottish Government, sportscotland and Sport for Change Network February 2017 Research Scotland www.researchscotland.org [email protected] CONTENTS Key Findings ................................................................................. i 1. Introduction ..................................................................... 1 2. What is ‘sport for change’? ............................................. 5 3. The potential impact of ‘sport for change’ ....................... 12 4. Sport for change in Scotland .......................................... 26 5. Delivering sport for change in Scotland .......................... 37 6. Contribution to policy objectives ..................................... 61 7. Strengthening the approach ........................................... 69 8. Testing our ideas ............................................................ 77 9. Key themes and recommendations ................................ 82 Appendix One: Online survey KEY FINDINGS AND RECOMMENDATIONS About the research The research explored how the ‘sport for change’ approach could be developed and supported within Scotland. It was commissioned by The Robertson Trust, Scottish Government, sportscotland and the Sport for Change Network Scotland. The research was undertaken by Research Scotland. What is sport for change? Sport for change is a term which is used in different ways to describe different things. Throughout the course of the research, we explored what sport for change
    [Show full text]
  • Organizations (Appendix D)
    SUMMARY REPORT - ORGANIZATIONS Canadian Sport Policy Renewal 2011 ARE YOU ANSWERING THIS SURVEY ON BEHALF OF: Response Chart Percentage Count Yourself (as an individual) 0% 0 Your Organization 100% 796 Total Responses 796 IN WHAT PROVINCE/TERRITORY IS YOUR ORGANIZATION BASED? Response Chart Percentage Count Alberta 21% 165 British Columbia 10% 80 Manitoba 9% 68 New Brunswick 5% 39 Newfoundland and Labrador 1% 10 Northwest Territories 2% 13 Nova Scotia 2% 17 Nunavut 4% 29 Ontario 26% 210 Prince Edward Island 5% 36 Québec 9% 72 Saskatchewan 5% 38 Yukon 2% 16 Total Responses 793 IS YOUR ORGANIZATION INVOLVED WITH SPORT? 7/4/2011 1 Prepared by Response Chart Percentage Count Yes 96% 760 No 4% 31 Total Responses 791 HOW WOULD YOU BEST DESCRIBE YOUR ORGANIZATION? Response Chart Percentage Count Publicly Funded (including 18% 145 Municipal, P/T, Federal Government) Not-for-Profit/Voluntary 47% 375 National Sport (NSO/MSO/CSC) 16% 129 Provincial/Territorial Sport 23% 185 Corporate/For Profit 1% 11 Education 11% 89 Other, please specify: 5% 41 Total Responses 791 HOW WOULD YOU BEST DESCRIBE YOUR ORGANIZATION? (OTHER, PLEASE SPECIFY:) # Response 1. multi-sport federation 2. fournisseur 3. Special Olympics 4. Tourism Bureau 5. PSO 6. Bowling 7. Regional Centre that receives an annual grant from lottery dollars offered through the Alberta Sport Recreation Parks and Wildlife Foundation 8. CSSS 9. soon to be NFP 10. Soccer Club 11. recreation Assocaition 7/4/2011 2 Prepared by 12. First Nation Advocacy 13. Privately Funded Foundation 14. private- run at no profit- community benefit driven 15.
    [Show full text]