OTHER MINDS Magazine Issue 6, May 2009
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Issue 6, May 2009 OO THERTHER MMINDINDSS The Unofficial Role-Playing Magazine for J.R.R. Tolkien’s Middle-earth and beyond OTHER MINDS Magazine Issue 6, May 2009 Publisher Other Minds Volunteers Co-Editors Assistant Editors Thomas Morwinsky Chris Seeman Hawke Robinson Chris Wade Proof Readers Artwork Katy Koenen Catherine Karina Chmiel Neville Percy José Enrique Vacas de la Rosa Chris Seeman Production Staff Thomas Morwinsky Hawke Robinson The next Issue of Other Minds is not themed, every contribution is eligible! Submission deadline for Other Minds #7 is July 1 2009 Unless otherwise noted, every contribution in this magazine is published under the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike license (b n a) The exact license of a given contribution can be found at the beginning of each contribution. 1 “Prince of Gondolin” © Catherine Karina Chmiel Other Minds Magazine CONTENTS Editorial: MAIN FEATURES 2 Editorial: Back on track! Back on track! by Thomas Morwinsky 4 Clad in Mail by Oliver Hauss Preface the public, silent, work – the magazine 8 White Hand Rising It’s a pleasure to present you with an- would not be possible in its present form. by Lev Lafayette other Issue of Other Minds. It might be an ex- For this, I especially thank all of you. For the 10 Númenórean Longevity aggeration of feeling to describe this “rising present issue these are – in alphabetical or- by Thomas Morwinsky like a phoenix”, but the past troubles of a der – Katy Koenen, Neville “Osric” 23 The Eöldrim long hiatus and a quick Issue #5 have con- Percy and Chris Seeman. by José Enrique Vacas de la Rosa tributed to a feeling of relief to be back on Content 28 Tharbad Name Changes regular schedule again. In fact we are very Concerning content we are – as already by Chris Seeman happy about this; hence the headline. Due to mentioned – this time well endowed. In con- missing one issue, #6 comes only one and 30 Banks of the Northern Anduin trast to past issues, this time we have a by Johannes Lomborg half months after #5. This short interval stronger bias towards gaming-oriented mate- (about half our regular schedule) dominated rial. This is all the more enjoyable as we call 58 Born of Hope—An Overview all considerations for this issue, but despite ourselves also a magazine for “gaming in by José Enrique Vacas de la Rosa all this we hope to serve you a product that Tolkien’s Middle-earth”. May this trend be- 60 Book Review—“Isildur” lives up to your expectations. come a good sign concerning the balance of by Thomas Morwinsky Other Minds, Issue #6 is much bigger in “gaming” and “academic” – oriented content. volume than the last one, and in fact the big- Now, what do we have specifically this gest so far. We have eight great contribu- time? OTHER FEATURES tions, ranging from the very scholarly to the First comes Clad in Mail, Oliver 66 Fine Print and Disclaimers pure gaming, thus spanning the whole width Hauss’ extensive and precise thoughts about of our intended range. Before I go into more 67 Creative Commons License the types of weaponry and especially armour detail about the contributions themselves, let that are likely to represent typical “Middle- 70 Appendix A me speak a bit of our “unsung heroes” (or earth” war gear. He bases his conclusions Tables for “Númenórean Longevity” better “little sung”). Such are not only en- always very closely on Tolkien’s own writ- 74 Appendix B countered in the secondary world we all love ings; primarily The Lord of the Rings, The Sil- Dúnadan Longevity so much, but also in the real one that makes marillion and Unfinished Tales. Those of you by Chris Seeman this great suspension of disbelief happen. We as proficient in German may recognize this es- the editors are naturally omnipresent in say, as it has already been published in a simi- every issue (even if only for an Editorial like lar version in the Flammifer von Westernis, the this). After that, the authors of our contribu- periodical of the German Tolkien society tions are of course the primary heroes of (Deutsche Tolkien Gesellschaft; DTG). these tales. But all the people that work The second contribution of this issue is “behind the scenes” are no less essential. I an intriguing “what if” speculation set in the want to point your attention to one such a late Third and early Fourth Age. Though group – our proofreaders. When I think how being academic, White Hand Rising by often I have sent out contributions on the last Lev Lafayette does not analyze Tolkien’s minute or with at least a tight deadline to works in the “usual” way, but pinpoints them and got their corrections back in very events or decisions that are capable of giving short time, I can only wonder how things the history of Middle-earth an entirely new might have gone without this kind of dedica- spin, if only some small details turned out tion. If you ever had the opportunity to read different from how the Professor had them through a text with the task of proofreading, happen. In this respect we are given a fasci- you know what I mean. It’s not only the nating view of quite different events in the grammar, style and orthography that our early Fourth Age. I am sure that both gamers “proofers” have to worry about; they also and the academic-minded will find this useful regularly point out content-related issues or for their purposes. potential problems that have not been no- Third comes a contribution from the ticed before. Without their diligent – and to writer of these lines himself. It is named 2 Issue 6, May 2009 Númenórean Longevity and deals with Rings, revolving around the story of Arathorn respectively). The proofreaders are from the the peculiar longevity enjoyed by the and Gilraen, Aragorn’s parents. US, and the UK (quite natural, since we prefer Númenóreans. First we find a comprehensive Finally, I provide the closing part of this native speakers for this). The current contribu- overview of the available sources on this sub- issue with a Book review – Isildur; this be- tors (text and artwork) range from Germany, ject, then the second part deals with the con- ing the second installment of a fan-fiction the US, Spain, Poland, Australia and Den- clusions derived therefrom. Thus it aims novel first published on the net in 1997. De- mark. Past (and hopefully future again) con- both at an academic approach in showing the pending on the further development on both tributors originated from Italy and France. complex situation, and at the same time of- the literary development about Middle-earth This truly is an international magazine! fering solutions that are useful in a game as department or the gaming market, such re- Finally returning back to Other Minds, I am well as for a better general understanding of views might become an occasional feature. In very happy about two things: First, you might the subject. It is inspired by and based on the any case, we try to stick to those publications notice a number of excellent illustrations. This essay Dúnadan longevity, published by Chris that have at least some benefit or connection makes me optimistic that we get more original Seeman in Other Hands Magazine, Issue #26. to the gaming genre. art in the future as well to illustrate Other This essay is provided in the Appendices as Minds. We are especially indebted to Cath- well. Closing thoughts erine Karina Chmiel “Kasiopeia”, who Next in line is a fascinating campaign There is some Middle-earth related news offered us high-resolution files of her superb hook from first-time contributor José Enri- that might be worth telling here as well. You illustrations. You can find her other great que Vacas de la Rosa. His idea revolves might have heard that on April 17, the makers works on Tolkien’s world on the web at around the Eöldrim, a group of Elves that of the upcoming The Hobbit movie announced http://kasiopea.art.pl. Second, this time derive their name from their first and great- that the plot of the book will be split into two five out of the eight contributions are by “first- est lord – Eöl the Dark Elf; prominent in the films. This makes an end on the speculations timers” rather than the seasoned veterans. I legends of the Elder Days. José now develops and previous announcements that one film take it as a promising sign that more and more an intriguing plot of the further fortunes of would deal with the Hobbit content, while the people see Other Minds as a means of publishing this group, right until the Third Age; the second would act as a “bridge” between The their Middle-earth–related ideas. I encourage time of most Middle-earth campaigns. If you Hobbit and The Lord of the Rings. Now all ele- all of our “new” contributors as well as those ever plan to introduce parts of the Elder ments that were alluded to and originally who still lurk in the shadows to keep up the Days into your game, this is an excellent planned for the second “bridge” movie, like the good (though sometimes unknown) work and hook for that. White Council attacking Dol Guldur, will be encourage others in offering us their ideas and Our fifth contribution continues a tradi- put in the two-part The Hobbit. making them available to a broader audience. tion started in the last issue of Other Minds.