Shiva Class 6 Handout 1 Shankara: the Ideal Family

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Shiva Class 6 Handout 1 Shankara: the Ideal Family The Fire That Does Not Burn: Writing with Shiva Class 6 Handout 1 Shankara: The Ideal Family Prior Readings Assigned • Menon pp 223-232; Pattanaik pp 165-177, pp 185-191 (Kartikeya) • Vanamalli pp 115-123; Chitgopenkar pp 169-178; Pattanaik pp 137-145 (Ganesha) Notes on Karttikeya • Born from Shiva—son of purusha, hyper-masculine, immune to the illusions and fears of prakriti • Symbol of martial power and authority • Shiva’s seed is thought to be powerful due to his ascetic nature—used to create an invincible war-god wielding the Vel, or divine spear • Multiple mothers and fathers—each representing particular aspects • Six heads—five senses plus discernment • Represents the objective world (as opposed to Ganesha, who represents my subjective world) • Child-nature: purity of intent, but this can also represent innate human violence • Peacock—symbol of vanity • Sometimes depicted as celibate—shunned by women because war and death and violence follow him around • Leaves Kailash to go to the South, where he is most worshipped in India • But in other instances married to Valli (a tribal woman) and Devasena (daughter of Indra) o Possible depiction of unity of indigenous and Vedic peoples o Also contrasts a love-marriage (Valli) with a marriage of political power-brokering (Devasena) Notes on Ganesha • Born from Shakti—but with an elephant head given by Shiva—Ganesha represents both material and spiritual aspirations • Yet another beheading by Shiva (after Brahma and Daksha)—but in this instance, the problem is one Shiva has unknowingly created • Created from the sweat and cells of the Goddess’s skin; represents the evolution of consciousness from matter • This primal transition is why Ganesha is always worshipped before any other god • Ganesha enters the world entirely naïve, but earns worldliness after his revival • Snake and rat are both associated with Ganesha, as are both Lakshmi (wealth goddess) and Saraswati (knowledge goddess)—thus Ganesha brings opposites together • Sometimes depicted as celibate, but more often as married to Riddhi and Siddhi (or Shubh and Labh)—goddesses of various kinds of prosperity and success o But these material aspirations come with an asterisk—the possibility of overly distracting an individual from their spiritual quest • Ganesha brings both aspects together in harmony, representing a balanced life • His elephant head represents reason, long memory, and subjective experience • Also known for writing down the Mahabharata as dictated by the sage Vyasa, using a broken piece of his tusk • Holds an axe and a noose—the former representing the ability to analyze, discern, and separate objective from subjective, animal from human, etc; and the latter representing the ability to bridge these divides and, as with Shiva’s noose, freedom from the illusion of the material world Exercise: Brains Vs Brawn The two principal sons of Shiva and Parvati, Karttikeya (also known as Skanda, Murugan, Kumara, or Subramanya) and Ganesha (also known a Ganapati or Vinayak) couldn’t be more different. Karttikeya, born only of Shiva and not of Parvati, is the hyper-masculine god of war, wielding his spear (the Vel) to lead the army of the gods and destroy evil. Ganesha is the remover of obstacles and brings prosperity and success, using his mind rather than his muscle. Write a piece that plays with the tension between these vastly different life philosophies. For example, a character could face a choice between solving a problem using brute force or mental finesse (as Karttikeya and Ganesha both did in their round-the-world race). Consider the future ramifications of each approach for the character’s social and moral positioning. Exercise: Vehicles The vehicles of the gods and goddesses can be interpreted to represent their conquered lower natures. Storl writes that “Ganesha’s mouse … is … the nervous, covetous intellect; the lion or tiger of the goddess is wanton cruelty; and Skanda’s peacock is the vanity of the victorious warrior.” Nandi, Shiva’s bull mount, may represent aggressive male sexuality. Consider in this context what animal a character might choose for a mount, and how it reflects a lower nature that character struggles with. Write a piece involving that premise, literally or metaphorically. The piece might be pure fantasy, or grounded in a real-life situation. How might the character’s and the animal’s actions and thoughts mirror or diverge from one another? Exercise: Seeing and Unseeing What does it mean to truly see something or someone? And conversely, what follows when one fails to see the truth of what one is confronted with? The Hindu concept of darshan encapsulates the idea of true seeing—for example, entering a temple to make visual contact with a linga or idol is thought to transfer divine energy to the seer. Karttikeya rides around the world on his peacock to win his race against Ganesha, while the latter simply circles Shiva and Parvati in devoted Darshan, leading to his triumph—he sees the entire universe encapsulated in them. Write a piece in which the act of seeing or failing to see plays a significant role. What downstream implications might a single failure to make appropriate darshan have in that character’s life? .
Recommended publications
  • Northern Sri Lanka Jane Derges University College London Phd In
    Northern Sri Lanka Jane Derges University College London PhD in Social Anthropology UMI Number: U591568 All rights reserved INFORMATION TO ALL USERS The quality of this reproduction is dependent upon the quality of the copy submitted. In the unlikely event that the author did not send a complete manuscript and there are missing pages, these will be noted. Also, if material had to be removed, a note will indicate the deletion. Dissertation Publishing UMI U591568 Published by ProQuest LLC 2013. Copyright in the Dissertation held by the Author. Microform Edition © ProQuest LLC. All rights reserved. This work is protected against unauthorized copying under Title 17, United States Code. ProQuest LLC 789 East Eisenhower Parkway P.O. Box 1346 Ann Arbor, Ml 48106-1346 Fig. 1. Aathumkkaavadi DECLARATION I, Jane Derges, confirm that the work presented in this thesis is my own. Where information has been derived from other sources I confirm that this has been indicated the thesis. ABSTRACT Following twenty-five years of civil war between the Sri Lankan government troops and the Liberation Tigers of Tamil Eelam (LTTE), a ceasefire was called in February 2002. This truce is now on the point of collapse, due to a break down in talks over the post-war administration of the northern and eastern provinces. These instabilities have lead to conflicts within the insurgent ranks as well as political and religious factions in the south. This thesis centres on how the anguish of war and its unresolved aftermath is being communicated among Tamils living in the northern reaches of Sri Lanka.
    [Show full text]
  • Nagapattinam District 64
    COASTAL DISTRICT PROFILES OF TAMIL NADU ENVIS CENTRE Department of Environment Government of Tamil Nadu Prepared by Suganthi Devadason Marine Research Institute No, 44, Beach Road, Tuticorin -628001 Sl.No Contents Page No 1. THIRUVALLUR DISTRICT 1 2. CHENNAI DISTRICT 16 3. KANCHIPURAM DISTRICT 28 4. VILLUPURAM DISTRICT 38 5. CUDDALORE DISTRICT 50 6. NAGAPATTINAM DISTRICT 64 7. THIRUVARUR DISTRICT 83 8. THANJAVUR DISTRICT 93 9. PUDUKOTTAI DISTRICT 109 10. RAMANATHAPURAM DISTRICT 123 11. THOOTHUKUDI DISTRICT 140 12. TIRUNELVELI DISTRICT 153 13. KANYAKUMARI DISTRICT 174 THIRUVALLUR DISTRICT THIRUVALLUR DISTRICT 1. Introduction district in the South, Vellore district in the West, Bay of Bengal in the East and i) Geographical location of the district Andhra Pradesh State in the North. The district spreads over an area of about 3422 Thiruvallur district, a newly formed Sq.km. district bifurcated from the erstwhile Chengalpattu district (on 1st January ii) Administrative profile (taluks / 1997), is located in the North Eastern part of villages) Tamil Nadu between 12°15' and 13°15' North and 79°15' and 80°20' East. The The following image shows the district is surrounded by Kancheepuram administrative profile of the district. Tiruvallur District Map iii) Meteorological information (rainfall / ii) Agriculture and horticulture (crops climate details) cultivated) The climate of the district is moderate The main occupation of the district is agriculture and allied activities. Nearly 47% neither too hot nor too cold but humidity is of the total work force is engaged in the considerable. Both the monsoons occur and agricultural sector. Around 86% of the total in summer heat is considerably mitigated in population is in rural areas engaged in the coastal areas by sea breeze.
    [Show full text]
  • Kartikeya - Wikipedia, the Free Encyclopedia
    קרטיקייה का셍तिकेय http://www.wisdomlib.org/definition/k%C4%81rtikeya/index.html का셍तिकेय كارتِيكيا کارتيکيا تک ہ का셍तिकेय کا ر یی http://uh.learnpunjabi.org/default.aspx Kartikeya - Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia https://en.wikipedia.org/wiki/Kartikeya Kartikeya From Wikipedia, the free encyclopedia Kartikeya (/ˌkɑrtɪˈkeɪjə/), also known as Skanda , Kumaran ,Subramanya , Murugan and Subramaniyan is Kartikeya the Hindu god of war. He is the commander-in-chief of the Murugan army of the devas (gods) and the son of Shiva and Parvati. Subramaniyan God of war and victory, Murugan is often referred to as "Tamil Kadavul" (meaning "God of Tamils") and is worshiped primarily in areas with Commander of the Gods Tamil influences, especially South India, Sri Lanka, Mauritius, Indonesia, Malaysia, Singapore and Reunion Island. His six most important shrines in India are the Arupadaiveedu temples, located in Tamil Nadu. In Sri Lanka, Hindus as well as Buddhists revere the sacred historical Nallur Kandaswamy temple in Jaffna and Katirk āmam Temple situated deep south. [1] Hindus in Malaysia also pray to Lord Murugan at the Batu Caves and various temples where Thaipusam is celebrated with grandeur. In Karnataka and Andhra Pradesh, Kartikeya is known as Subrahmanya with a temple at Kukke Subramanya known for Sarpa shanti rites dedicated to Him and another famous temple at Ghati Subramanya also in Karnataka. In Bengal and Odisha, he is popularly known as Kartikeya (meaning 'son of Krittika'). [2] Kartikeya with his wives by Raja Ravi Varma Tamil காத
    [Show full text]
  • Muthai-Tharu”) திச்சிற்றம்பலம் Thiruchitrambalam
    ஸ்ரீ அணகிாிநாதர் சுவாமிகள் அளிச்ெசய்த śrí arunagirināthar swāmigal’s திப்கழ் பதிகங்கள் - பாடல் 6 (“த்ைதத்த”) thiruppugal pathigam - song 6 (“muthai-tharu”) திச்சிற்றம்பலம் thiruchitrambalam śrí arunagirināthar swāmigal’s thiruppugal pathigam - song 6 Dedicated with love to The Fragrant Divine Lotus Feet of my beloved SatGuru - Bhagavan Sri Skanda & (“muthai-tharu”) All His Beloved Children of Light (The Glory of God - in the form of Bhagavan Sri Skanda) English (Thiruppugal) meanings courtesy of Sri Gopala Sundaram Tamil unicode lyrics courtesy of www.kaumaram.org Transliteration & Preparation by Sri Skanda's Warrior of Light Page 1 of 8 Published for the World Wide Web (WWW) by Sri Skanda's Warrior of Light - with love - for: Skandagurunatha.org – Bhagavan Sri Skanda’s Divine Online Abode (Home to the Warriors of Light – Ushers of the new age of God) Copyright © Skandagurunatha.org, 2014. For personal (spiritual) use only. Commercial use is strictly prohibited. Source: http://www.skandagurunatha.org/works/thiruppugal/ ஸ்ரீ அணகிாிநாதர் சுவாமிகள் அளிச்ெசய்த śrí arunagirināthar swāmigal’s திப்கழ் பதிகங்கள் - பாடல் 6 (“த்ைதத்த”) thiruppugal pathigam - song 6 (“muthai-tharu”) திச்சிற்றம்பலம் thiruchitrambalam TABLE OF CONTENTS Page # Thiruppugal - Introducton 3 Guide to pronunciation 4 Thiruppugal Pathigam 5 (Tamil) Thirupugal Pathigam 6 (English) References 8 Page 2 of 8 Published for the World Wide Web (WWW) by Sri Skanda's Warrior of Light - with love - for: Skandagurunatha.org – Bhagavan Sri Skanda’s Divine Online Abode (Home to the Warriors of Light – Ushers of the new age of God) Copyright © Skandagurunatha.org, 2014.
    [Show full text]
  • Kartikeya : the Destroyers Son Pdf, Epub, Ebook
    KARTIKEYA : THE DESTROYERS SON PDF, EPUB, EBOOK Anuja Chandramouli | 240 pages | 20 Oct 2017 | Rupa & Co | 9788129149114 | English | New Delhi, India KARTIKEYA : The Destroyers Son PDF Book In this part of the Interview, she tells us how the journey of the book first happened, how it feels now that she is finally plugging the holes in Shiva's sons' phase, and much more, Folks Then Shiva announces a contest, saying that the first child who goes round the whole world and comes back first would be the one to get the fruit. She serves the Devas first and then proceeds to feign disappointment that the Amrita got over before she could feed the Asuras. Shiva is depicted in many moods, of which the Mahakala form is the most feared. Lord Karttikeya is a well known figure in Hindu mythology. This was done mainly to bridge the gap between the various Hindu sects in existence at the time. His vehicle is the peacock, which represents the destroyer of harmful habits and the conqueror of sensual desires. But not all Kavadi types involve extreme physical endurance. Sign up to join this community. The Vel Kavadi is the most spectacular object of worship. So guys, go and grab your Copy Now from here. PIN IT. After Rudra decapitated this boy. He may be depicted sitting, reclining, standing, dancing, playing with his family, or engaging in a range of contemporary situations. The end was beautiful. His hair is matted and he is adorned with snake and skull ornaments. It also means kind, pure, generous and gracious.
    [Show full text]
  • Kanthar Sashti Kavasam
    ஸ்ரீ ேதவராய சுவாமிகள் அளிச்ெசய்த śrí thëvarāya swāmigal’s கந்தர் சஷ் கவசம் (திச்ெசந்ர்த் ேதவேசனாபதி) kanthar sashti kavas am (thiruchendur) திச்சிற்றம்பலம் thiruchitrambalam śrí thëvarāya swāmigal’s Dedicated with love to kanthar sashti kavasam The Fragrant Divine Lotus Feet of my beloved SatGuru - Bhagavan Sri Skanda & All His Beloved Children of Light (thiruchendur) (Lord Skanda’s protective armor for devotees) English meanings by Sri P.R. Ramachander Tamil unicode by ProjectMadurai.org English Transliteration, Preparation, and Proof-reading by Sri Skanda's Warrior of Light Page 1 of 26 Published for the World Wide Web (WWW) by Sri Skanda's Warrior of Light - with love - for: Skandagurunatha.org – Bhagavan Sri Skanda’s Divine Online Abode, 2014. For personal (spiritual) use only. Commercial use is strictly prohibited. Source: http://www.skandagurunatha.org/works/ ஸ்ரீ ேதவராய சுவாமிகள் அளிச்ெசய்த śrí thëvarāya swāmigal’s கந்தர் சஷ் கவசம் (திச்ெசந்ர்த் ேதவேசனாபதி) kanthar sashti kavas am (thiruchendur) திச்சிற்றம்பலம் thiruchitrambalam TABLE OF CONTENTS Page # Introduction 3 Guide to pronunciation 4 kanthar sashti kavasam 5 (Tamil) kanthar sashti kavasam 8 (English with meaning) References 14 Page 2 of 26 Published for the World Wide Web (WWW) by Sri Skanda's Warrior of Light - with love - for: Skandagurunatha.org – Bhagavan Sri Skanda’s Divine Online Abode, 2014. For personal (spiritual) use only. Commercial use is strictly prohibited. Source: http://www.skandagurunatha.org/works/ ஸ்ரீ ேதவராய சுவாமிகள் அளிச்ெசய்த śrí thëvarāya swāmigal’s கந்தர் சஷ் கவசம் (திச்ெசந்ர்த் ேதவேசனாபதி) kanthar sashti kavas am (thiruchendur) திச்சிற்றம்பலம் thiruchitrambalam śrí thëvarāya swāmigal’s Lord Murugan killed Tharagan and Singan at first.
    [Show full text]
  • Pilgrimage to Temples Dakshina Kannada
    E-Book: for free circulation Pilgrimage to Temples In Dakshina Kannada By Tamarapu Sampath Kumaran About the Author: Mr T Sampath Kumaran is a freelance writer. He regularly contributes articles on Management, Business, Ancient Temples, and Temple Architecture to many leading Dailies and Magazines. His articles are popular in “The Young World section” of THE HINDU. His e- books on nature, environment and different cultures of people around the world are educative and of special interest to the young. His e-books – Guide to 108 Divya Desams, Guide to 275 Siva Sthalams, The Path of Ramanuja, Guide to Kancheepuram and Hinduism in a nutshell have been well received in the religious circle. He was associated in the renovation and production of two Documentary films on Nava Tirupathi Temples, and Tirukkurungudi Temple in Tamilnadu. Acknowledgement: I wish to express my gratitude to the authors from whose works I gathered the details for this book, and Courtesy, Google for some of the photographs. Special thanks to www.scribd.com for hosting my e-books. Introduction to Dakshina Kannada / SouthCanara. Dakshina Kannada, also called South Canara, is a coastal district of the Karnataka state. It is bordered by the districts of Udupi to the north, Chikkamagaluru to the northeast, Hassan District to the east, Kodagu to the southeast, and Kasaragod in Kerala to the south. The Arabian Sea bounds it on the west. Mangalore is the capital and chief city of the district. There is also the good presence of mountainous region in the state, with tea and coffee plantations. Dakshina Kannada and Udupi districts are often called Tulu Nadu, as Tulu is the majority language in the region.
    [Show full text]
  • Valli: a Venerated Folk Deity
    Vol. 2 No. 3 January 2015 ISSN: 2321 – 788X VALLI: A VENERATED FOLK DEITY Dr. B. Kathiresan Associate Professor of English, Thiruvalluvar University, Vellore – 632115 Abstract Existence of myths from time immemorial assures people’s belief and respect towards God. Attitude towards spirituality on the basis of the mystical experiences that myths provide is often viewed incredulously. On the other hand those that carry certain conviction do have its impact on people in positive sense. These differential perspectives build the need to analyse myths that hold metaphysical intentions to be envisioned pragmatically. Extending this logical exploration to the myth of Valli, the goddess and the wife of Lord Murugan discloses the facts and motives in the pretext of their marriage. Valli, as a tribal lady elevated to a position of celestial being is an interesting mystery to probe. Keywords: Subrahmanya, Velayudha, Muruga, Kumaresa, Karttikeya, Shanmukha Lord Subrahmanya, the symbolic representation of the power of Knowledge is the energy of Lord Siva and is indeed believed to be the incarnation of Lord Shiva. The purpose of his incarnation is to illumine the intelligence of human beings and liberate them from ignorance of various kinds which hides the truth from them. Valli and Deivayanai being His two consorts represent the Ichcha Sakti and the Kriya Sakti of the Lord respectively. He bestows on His devotees material and spiritual prosperity and success in all their undertakings even at the slightest devotion shown to Him. Guha, Muruga, Kumaresa, Karttikeya, Shanmukha (He who has six faces), Subrahmanya, Velayudha (He who wears the spear) are synonymous names.
    [Show full text]
  • Bala Bhavan Bhajans Contents
    Bala Bhavan Bhajans 9252, Miramar Road, San Diego, CA 92126 www.vcscsd.org Bala Bhavan Bhajans Contents GANESHA BHAJANS .................................................................................................. 5 1. Ganesha Sharanam, Sharanam Ganesha ............................................................ 5 2. Gauree Nandana Gajaanana ............................................................................... 5 3. Paahi Paahi Gajaanana Raga: Abheri .......................................... 5 4. Shuklambaradharam ........................................................................................... 5 5. Ganeshwara Gajamukeshwara ........................................................................... 6 6. Gajavadana ......................................................................................................... 6 7. Gajanana ............................................................................................................. 6 8. Ga-yi-yeh Ganapathi Raga: Mohana ........................................ 6 9. Gananatham Gananatham .................................................................................. 7 10. Jaya Ganesha ...................................................................................................... 7 11. Jaya Jaya Girija Bala .......................................................................................... 7 12. Jaya Ganesha ...................................................................................................... 8 13. Sri Maha Ganapathe ..........................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Thai Poosa Thai Poosam
    Hindu Community and Cultural Center 1232 Arrowhead Ave, Livermore, CA 94551 A Non-Profit Organization since 1977 Tax ID# 94-2427126; Inc #D0821589 Shiva-Vishnu Temple Tel: 925-449-6255; Fax: 925 -455-0404 Om Namah Shivaya Om Namo Narayanaya Web: http://www.livermoretemple.org Thai Poosam Thurs day, January 16th , 2014 5:00 PM – 7.30 PM Thai Poosam is a festival celebrated in the month of Thai as per Solar Calendar. The word Thai Poosam is derived from the month name Thai and Poosam, which refers to a star that is at its highest point during the festival. The festival is celebrated with fervor in the Murugan Temples. As per one of the legends, t here was a demon named Tharakasura who gave a lot of trouble to the saints. Lord Muruga was given a task by his parents Lord Shiva and Goddess Parvati to destroy the demon. Lord Muruga took with him twelve weapons, eleven of which were given by his father Lord Shiva and the 'Vel' given by his moth er Parvati and destroyed Tharakasura on the PoosamNakshatra day in the month of Thai and hence the name Thai Poosam. Please plan on participating in the event with your family & friends and receive divine blessings. Kavadi Puja and Procession will be performed during Thai Poosam event Event Schedule 5:00 PM Kavadi Puja and Procession , MayuraVahanaSeva for Lord Muruga, Goddess Valli, and Goddess Devasena 6:00 PM Kartikeya Abhisheka m– Ashtottarasata(108) kalasapalakodum 7:00 PM Archanaand TheerthaPrasadam Sponsorship Information Suggested Donation Archana $ 7 108 Kalasapalakodum $ 21 Abhishekam, Kavadi Puja and Procession $ 51 Thai Poosam – All events (Including Kavadi Puja) $ 116 Limited number of Kavadi’s are available , please sponsor at your earliest convenience.
    [Show full text]
  • Compiled by Michigan Ayyappa Seva Sangam Page 1
    Compiled by Michigan Ayyappa Seva Sangam Page 1 Compiled by Michigan Ayyappa Seva Sangam Page 2 Contents Ayyappa Temple History .....................................................................................................................6 வரத ைறக !................................................................................................................. 13 Ayyappa Gayathri Manthra ...................................................................... Error! Bookmark not defined. ஐய ப லமதிர .............................................................. Error! Bookmark not defined. சாதா காய .................................................................................................................... 18 தம ஸாதா காய ........................................................ Error! Bookmark not defined. ஐய ப மகா மதிர ......................................................................................................... 19 ஐய ப ஸு ரபாத .......................................................................................................... 20 சார ஸு ரபாத ........................................................................................................... 23 மஹாசாதா அ ேடாதர ......................................................................................... 24 Mantra chanted while wearing the Ayyappa Mudra Mala ................................................................... 29 மாைல அண$ ேபா% ெசா'ல ேவ()ய மதிர ................................................ 30 The mantra to be recited while removing the Mudra
    [Show full text]
  • Wojciech Maciejowski Batu Caves
    View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by Portal Czasopism Naukowych (E-Journals) PEREGRINUS CRACOVIENSIS 2015, 25 ( 4 ), 119 – 134 eISSN 2083-3113 doi : 10.4467/20833105PC.14.008.3738 Wojciech Maciejowski Batu Caves ( Gua-gua Batu ) : Hindu Pilgrimage Centre in Malaysia Abstract : The article presents the complex of Batu Caves which is on the one hand, one of the most recognizable religious centres of Hinduism in the area of Muslim Malaysia, annually visited by thousands of pilgrims within Holy Thaipusam festival, and, on the other hand, the complex of caves popular with tourist and willingly visited. The author presents both the character and specific custom elements of this popular festival and discusses the advantages of caves as formation of inanimate nature available to tourism. Keywords : Malaysia, Batu Caves, religious tourism, Hindu pilgrimage, thaipusam, kavadi 1. Introduction Religion, as an important element of man’s spirituality constitutes one of the most important factors, generating migration processes of their inhabitants in many countries of the world ( Jackowski et al. 1999 : 1 ; Jackowski 2003 : 115 ). Searching and striving for communing with the sacred exerts strong impact on religious motives of journeys undertaken by man ( Jackowski et al. 1999 : 1 ). From the viewpoint of tourism development, journeys of this type may currently have a two-fold character, which results from reciprocal overlapping of clearly religious and cognitive motives ( Jackowski 2003 : 116 ). On the one hand, the purpose of tourists ( in this aspect a pilgrim ) is to reach the holy place from their own spiritual ( internal ) need ; on the other hand, the same holy places are visi- ted by tourists who are eager to get to know the new space, see the similar or completely different customs, spectacular ceremonies or observe the behaviour of other people ( e.g.
    [Show full text]