Carmel Pine Cone, October 16, 2009
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
CHS teacher sues ‘John Doe’ over fake Facebook account By KELLY NIX On Sept. 10, science teacher Michael Guardino filed suit [Guardino] might reasonably use or employ.” in Monterey County Superior Court against unidentified The perpetrators used Guardino’s full name, date of birth A CARMEL High School teacher has filed a lawsuit plaintiffs for creating the accounts in April. and profession to create a Yahoo email address and a alleging someone created a false Facebook account in his “In order to create a false account,” according to the suit, name, and then used the Internet site to ridicule his students. “the defendants created an email address ... which was clear- See FACEBOOK page 14A ly designed to appear as being an email address that BULK RATE U.S. POSTAGE PAID CARMEL, CA Permit No. 149 Volume 95 No. 42 On the Internet: www.carmelpinecone.com October 16-22, 2009 Y OUR S OURCE F OR L OCAL N EWS, ARTS AND O PINION S INCE 1915 Final debate before Region dodges incorporation vote ‘storm of the century’ By CHRIS COUNTS ■ Bulldozers forestall lagoon flood MORE THAN 100 people filled the Hidden Valley Theater Wednesday evening to listen to what could be By CHRIS COUNTS the final debate on the proposed incorporation of Carmel Valley before the Nov. 3 vote on Measure G. THE STORM that pummeled Monterey County early this Larry Bacon, Karin Strasser Kauffman and Glenn week left behind impressive amounts of rain and hundreds of Robinson represented proponents, while Scott Dick, homes without power for nearly two days. But very little damage David Cummings and Bob Sinotte spoke out against was reported — even in fire-scarred Big Sur, where rainfall incorporation. Bacon, Kauffman, Robinson and Dick amounts were staggering. are all running for town council. The debate was spon- “Amazingly, we survived the storm of the century in pretty sored by the Carmel Valley Chamber of Commerce, and good shape,” said Kate Novoa, whose Big Sur Kate blog (big- its managing director, Elizabeth Vitarisi Suro, moderat- surkate.wordpress.com) provides extensive Big Sur weather, fire ed the discussion. and road information. For about 90 minutes, the two sides fielded questions Big Sur Volunteer Fire Brigade Chief Martha Karstens con- from the audience and offered dueling views of the pros firmed Novoa’s assessment of the storm. and cons of making Carmel Valley a town. Since the “I was surprised,” reported Karstens, who recorded nearly 9 public debate over incorporation has been raging for inches of rain at her Big Sur home. “I thought something was years, the discussion understandably offered little new going to happen.” information. Karstens praised Caltrans workers for their hard work along Revenue hits? See STORM page 14A The economy, and its impact on the Town of Carmel Valley’s revenue from sources such as sales and proper- ty taxes, were front and center Wednesday. MAKES DO “We’re in a depression,” Sinotte said. “I don’t know CPD a single retail business that’s running in the black.” Cummings agreed. “A town is a business,” he WITHOUT PG&E observed. “You don’t want to open a business when the market is going in the wrong direction.” By MARY BROWNFIELD Town supporters, though, brushed aside worries about the economy. HEN GUSTY winds and torrential downpours sent a tree “Recessions do end, and when they do, we’re going W into a transformer behind the Carmel Youth Center during Tuesday to be back in prosperity,” Bacon countered. morning’s storm, a large swath of town lost power — including Robinson said he’s not worried about the timing of the critical police and public works buildings. For a day-and-a- the election. PHOTO/(TOP) COURTESY CALTRANS, (BOTTOM) CHRIS COUNTS half, they depended on a 43-year-old generator, and while they “You want to do it during a bottom market,” A tale of two bridges: (Top) A Caltrans engineer makes never went completely dark, the period was not without its chal- Robinson countered. “We’re going to start this town at repairs to Bixby Bridge just days before this week’s pow- lenges. the right time.” erful storm arrived. (Above) A pedestrian bridge in “We did have a problem during the storm,” CPD Cmdr. Mike Carmel Valley Village no longer spans the swollen See DEBATE page 17A Carmel River after being swept away. See POWER page 31A More hearings for downsized hotel project ‘Nonprofit’ doesn’t By MARY BROWNFIELD plan is undergoing environmental review and could be con- sidered by the planning commission before the end of the mean ‘no money’ THE PROPOSAL to tear down the dated Carmel Sands year. Lodge at San Carlos and Fifth and replace it with a boutique “There have been three major changes to the hotel plans,” By KELLY NIX hotel, small restaurant, day spa and underground parking said David How, owner and developer of the Sands property. garage has been off the radar since late last year, but a revised Most significantly, the room count is dropping from 58 to 42, IS $2.5 million per year too high a salary for the which is the number of units on the head of a chain of nonprofit hospitals? property now. James Mongan, head of Partners HealthCare in “That’s the big change,” he said Massachusetts, made that much in 2008. Wednesday. While no local nonprofit or charity pays anywhere Also, ingress and egress for the near that much, the chief executives of two local hospi- underground parking garage will be on tals are the highest-paid executives with Monterey San Carlos Street in the same location as County nonprofits, according to a Pine Cone survey of the existing driveway. In the earlier IRS documents. Steve Packer, CEO of CHOMP, was plans, the entrance was on San Carlos paid $624,691 plus benefits of $32,000 last year. And, and the exit was on Mission Street, while more recent figures were not available, Salinas which prompted complaints from prop- Valley Memorial hospital’s CEO, Sam Downing, was erty owner Catherine Compagno. paid $546,306 and received $128,048 in pension contri- “The net effect of that redesign is butions in 2000, according to IRS files. that the one significant oak tree that we Other local examples: were proposing to cut down is now being saved,” he added. “So there are no ■ Monterey Bay Aquarium significant trees that are being removed, RENDERING/ERIC MILLER + ASSOCIATES although we were approved by forest According to 2007 IRS tax forms, the Monterey Bay Revised plans to replace the old Carmel Sands Lodge with a boutique hotel are back on the table nearly a year after the last public hearing. See SANDS page 18A See NONPROFIT page 13A Get your complete Carmel Pine Cone every Thursday evening in convenient pdf format via email. Free subscriptions available at www.carmelpinecone.com. 2A The Carmel Pine Cone October 16, 2009 ARCHITECT, ARCHAEOLOGIST FILL VACANCIES ON CITY BOARDS By MARY BROWNFIELD Service after assignments in Guam, Hawaii, the Northern Ungaretti. “I would like to see it grow and continue to be a Marianas and India. great resource for young and grownups alike.” CHANGE IS afoot in city commissions, with longtime She said she wishes to use her background knowledge in Mosher said she would like to continue serving “because members leaving and newcomers joining the ranks. The service to the community. “Moreover, I would be grateful for I feel strongly that in this time of transition and budget Carmel City Council last week approved several appoint- the opportunity to work closely with members of this com- restrictions, we have made real progress working together ments to three boards and will next month offer its thanks munity who share a love of history and understand the sig- with CPLF and the city.” (The Carmel Public Library and farewell to three people who are stepping down. Mayor nificance of preservation,” she wrote. Foundation is a nonprofit that raises money to fund the Sue McCloud and Mayor Pro-Tem Karen Sharp reviewed Architect Victoria Beach was appointed to replace former library’s materials, programs and services.) applications and interviewed the candidates before making Carmel Planning Commission chairman Bill Strid, who But McCloud and Sharp could find no new appointees for their recommendations to the city council Oct. 6. resigned last spring when he moved out of town. Her term the forest and beach commission, so applications are still “We had a wonderful group of people who came forward,” will end in October 2010. being accepted. They have two positions to fill, with the Sharp said, adding that she was impressed by their qualifica- Beach, who received her masters of architecture from departures of longtime member and chairman Kathleen Coss tions and desire to serve. Harvard in 1993, runs her own firm, which she started in and Dr. Les Kadis, who joined in April 2008 to serve the For the historic resources board, the duo recommended 1996. She served on the Riverside Planning Commission in remainder of commissioner Bob Tierney’s term and did not reappointing Erik Dyar and appointing Laura Quimby to take 2006, is secretary of the River School PTA and joined the seek reappointment. the seat vacated by Julie Wendt, who served on the board for American Institute of Architects National Ethics Council last several years, including terms as its chair. year. She taught at Harvard from 1990 until 2003. An architect, Dyar joined in 2005. In his original applica- “We heard from some commissioners that they felt a qual- tion, he professed his “deep love and appreciation of Carmel- ified architect was important for at least one seat,” McCloud City turns 93 on Halloween by-the-Sea, its character of place, its community and its his- and Sharp wrote in their memo to the council.