Page 1 of 72 I DEX to the Agenda of the Meetings of Goa SEIAA Sr. O

IDEX to the Agenda of the Meetings of Goa SEIAA

Sr. o. Particulars Date Page os.

1. 1st Meeting of Goa SEIAA 24 th February, 2011 2 – 19

2. 2nd Meeting of Goa SEIAA 24 th October, 2011 20 – 33

3. 3rd Meeting of Goa SEIAA 5th April, 2012 34

4. 4th Meeting of Goa SEIAA 10 th August, 2012 35

5. 5th Meeting of Goa SEIAA 18 th December, 2012 36

6. 6th Meeting of Goa SEIAA 7th February, 2013 37 – 39

7. 7th Meeting of Goa SEIAA 15 th March, 2013 40 71

8. 8th Meeting of Goa SEIAA 1st April, 2013 72

Page 1 of 72

Agenda Item for the First GoaSEIAA meeting held on 24 th February 2011

A. Consideration of following proposal seeking Prior EC as mandated under the EIA otification, 2006

1. CRICKET STADIUM AT THIVIM BY GOA CRICKET ASSOCIATION

Sr. Project Proponent Proposed Sitespecific Project details / specification / Comments from GoaSEAC Response to o. Activity location salient features members comments by Project details (extracted from the project details Proponent (PP) submitted) 1 Goa Cricket Association – GCA Cricket 32 acres of Total plot area – 1,30,328 sq. mt. (32 1.It is informed that the Stadium land in Acoi acres) matter pertaining the Mr. Vijaykumar Sawant, village near Total built-up area – 45,087.59 sq. “issuance of approval for Rizvi Sadan, 2 nd Floor, Near Thivim, mt. (35%) diversion of forest land” Municipal Market, Bardez Proposed ground coverage – 32,183 to the Directorate of Panaji, Goa – 403 001. taluka sq. mt. (22%) Sports and Youth Affairs Total parking area – 24,911 sq. mts. granted under the Forest [email protected] Total green area – 1,00,352.56 sq. (Conservation) act, 1980 mt.(77%) has been stayed by the Phone – 2421088 Ministry of Environment Fax - 2420455 Estimated cost – 160 crores & Forests (MoEF) pursuant to Writ Petition Seating capacity – 46, 575 seats No. 321/2010 and PIL W. P. No. 14/2010 filed in the Total parking (open and enclosed) – Hon’ble High Court of The PP is yet to comply 668 cars, 198 two-wheelers Goa at Bombay by M/s with comments against Goa Foundation. sr. nos. 1, 2 4 & 6. Water requirement – 1221 KLD – during 2.The possibility of The PP has submitted widening the State the compliance to Games Highway – the only comments against sr. 493 KLD – approach road to the nos. 3 & 5. during proposed project site be

Page 2 of 72

normal taken on priority so as not days to disturb daily vehicular movement. Further, an Total waste-water generated – 1050 alternate exit-road / KLD to be treated using 1260 KLD secondary road need to be Sewage Treatment Plant (STP) on constructed along the SAFF (Submerged Aerated Fixed north-east periphery of the Film) technology which will generate plot boundary to minimize 840 KLD of treated water to be used traffic congestion. for flushing and landscape. 3.Geotechnical soil analysis Rainwater Harvesting (RWH) may please be carried out initiatives – (1) 32 rainwater to ascertain the soil harvesting pits are proposed for characteristics as well as artificial rainwater recharge. groundwater status and its (2) Desilting tanks and Recharge recharge potential. It is not wells are proposed – LOCATION advisable to opt for NOT DEFINED recharging of groundwater through recharge-pits, Power requirement – 3223 KVA to instead make a provision be sourced through Goa Electricity for optimum Department (GED). During utilization/storage of emergency, proposed to be backed rainwater to be used in up with 3 DG sets of 1250 KVA fair-weather season. each. 4.Location-specific details of the proposed bore well Solid waste generated – 6835 kg./day as well as 32 numbers of (during games) rainwater harvesting pits, - 963 kg/day superimposed on the (during contour map of the normal days) proposed plot area, be furnished.

Page 3 of 72

5.PP should make a provision for exclusive fire-escape routes / staircase to avoid stampede during such eventualities. The PP should submit ‘Stability’ as well as ‘Fire Safety’ Certificates as per the conceptual plan proposed.

6.It is advisable to construct composting pits within the project site to treat the biodegradable waste – bio-composting technique and utilize the manure to maintain the green-field area.

2. HOSPITAL-cum-HOTEL AT TALEIGAO BY M/s ALCON CONSTRUCTIONS (GOA) PVT. LTD.,

Sr. Project Proponent Proposed Sitespecific Project details / specification / Comments from GoaSEAC Response to comments o. Activity location salient features members by Project Proponent details (extracted from the project details (PP) submitted) 2 M/s Alcon Constructions 250-bedded Taleigao Total plot area – 11,988.67 sq. mt. 1.The proposed land was used (Goa) Pvt. Ltd., Hospital- village, (effective – 10,245.53 sq. mt.) to be a landfill site earlier cum-Hotel Tiswadi Total built-up area – 27,958.90 sq. mt. and as such almost 5 to 6 Mr. Nanda Sadassiva Naique (42 rooms) taluka, (upto 5 th floor) mts of top soil is organic- Counto, S. Nos. Proposed open space – 1,542.38 sq. rich fertile and should be Director, G + 5 upper 112/1, mt. (15.05%) utilized for landscaping

Page 4 of 72

Sukerkar Mansion, floors and 1 112/1(part) – Proposed ground coverage – 3,618 sq. development. 1st Floor, M. G. Road, basement 11,988.67 mt. (35.32%) Panaji, Goa – 403 001 sq. mt. Proposed FAR – 21,837.64 sq. mt. 2.The PP must ensure that the effluents / waste water in the e-mail – [email protected] Next to About 30,393 m 3 of earth would be adjoining St.Inez nala Sewage removed / excavated. should not infiltrate within Ph. - 2224451 / 2224452 Treatment the project site and Fax – 2225616 Plant at Raft foundation is proposed with safe contaminate the Taleigao bearing capacity of 10 T/sq.mt. groundwater quality as E. Goa-SEAC recommends Registered address – Coli concentration and FE the proposal subject to M/s Alcon Constructions Heating Ventilation Air Conditioning content is reported to be compliance to Goa-SEAC (Goa) Pvt. Ltd., (HVAC) system is proposed. higher in the bore-well observations / comments. Velho Bldg., 1 st Floor, Panaji. water. Accordingly, PP Internal road with 10 mt. width and should treat the nala on parking space proposed for 420 nos. priority as well as construct (details not mentioned) approach road to the proposed site. Intermediate STP with Moving Bed Bio-Reactor (MBBR) technology is 3.The proposed site, being proposed – part treated sewage to very low-lying area, bears a transfer to authorized STP to St.inez – sandy aquifer regime and as total treated sewage is 235 cmd, 209 such, built individual sump cmd to be reuded for gardening, rather than soak pits to treat flushing, AC-cooling. 26 cmd to waste-water effectively. disposed into sewers.

Well-engineered storm-water drainage system is proposed.

Water requirement – 9 cmd (Construction) 452 cmd (operation)

Page 5 of 72

Contd. / - Total waste-water generated – 1.6 (Construction) 247 cmd (Operation)

60 trees are proposed to be planted.

Power requirement – 25 KW (Construction) - 780 KW (Operation) Back-up power through diesel generator of 750 KVA.

Solid waste generated – 1 – 3 MT/d (Construction) Operation phase - 63 kg/d – Biomedical and 570 kg.d – domestic waste.

Organic Waste Convertor (OWC) is proposed for biodegradable waste.

EMP enclosed as annexure – VII.

3. RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX AT ALTO-BATIM BY ROCKFIRST REAL ESTATE LTD.,

Page 6 of 72

3 M/s Rockfirst Real Estate Residential Alto-Betim Total plot area – 29,120.13 sq. mt. 1.The proposed project “A” Ltd., Mumbai. Apartments village, Total Ground coverage area – 8,751 appears to be an extension Bardez sq. mts. of the ongoing work, being Mr. Rajesh Jaggi, “Ashoka taluka, Green cover area – 20,368 sq. mts. developed, within two Managing Director, Beleza” S. Nos. 57/1 Built-up area – 22,279.67 sq. mts. adjacent plots namely – ‘B’ 1, Peninsula Spenta, (G + 3 of Reis Total construction built-up area – and ‘C’ and is seeking prior Mathurdas Mills, Senapati storied Magos 32,452.52 sq. mts. Environmental Clearance Bapat Marg, Lower Parel, complex) village (EC) from the Goa-SEIAA, Mumbai – 400013 Ready-Mix-Concrete (RMC) to be as the built-up area, taken used. together, exceeds 20,000 sq. Ph. – 022/66229400 – mts. as per the EIA 022/66229300/01 Total occupancy – 652 nos. (max.) Notification, 2006. Fax – 022/66229302 About 80,134 m 3 of earth would be 2.Almost 30% of the total [email protected] removed / excavated. plot area has been (M) - 9820505005 developed and as a result, Goa-SEAC defers the Geotechnical soil investigation appreciable proportion of proposal as the PP is seeking Corres. Add .: (enclosure – 1) as carried out naturally grown vegetation post-facto EC. Mr. Sanjeev - 9890003168 through 17 boreholes with has been lost along the hill- Peninsula Land Ltd., permanent benchmark of +50mt. No slopes. Peninsula Center, H. No. 850, groundwater table was encountered. Opp. SBI, Porvorim – 403 3.It is advisable to re-design 621 Reinforced concrete (i.e. Spread the rainwater-storage tanks foundation) is proposed with proposed in the already Mr. Sanjay Ghatwal maximum water: cement ratio of developed area (i.e. B & C (M) - 9764005561 0.50 at an average depth of 1.5 mt.. portion) so as to account for This foundation has a safe bearing suitable water storage, as capacity of 40 T/sq.mt. (with total one of the rainwater settlement of 9 mm). California harvesting measures. Bearing Ratio (CBR) of 6 is proposed for construction design. 4.The PP, during the Retaining walls with weep holes presentation has ensured with gravel filters are proposed. that as a matter of

Page 7 of 72

Corporate Social Estimated cost – 125 crores. Responsibility (CSR), it would set-up sufficient Noise pollution to be controlled by numbers of composting restricting the usage of equipments units in Reis-Magos village generating more than 90 db (A) to treat and dispose-off sound. biodegradable waste.

Water requirement – During construction : 42 m 3/d 12m 3/d for workers from local authority 20 to 30 m 3/d for construction through tankers.

During operation : 60m 3/d for domestic use (150 m 3/d) 30m 3/d for flushing 60m 3/d for gardening

50 trees are proposed to be planted in lieu of 46 trees for which permission is sought.

Power requirement – 75 kVA (Construction) - from Goa Electricity Dept. 3828 KW (from GED) during Operation.

Page 8 of 72

Back-up power through four diesel generator 2 nos. of 750 kVA and 2 nos. of 500 kVA.

Solid waste generated – 291 kg/d – (Dry garbage – 89 kg. & Wet garbage – 203 kg. / d) Vessel composting is proposed to manage wet garbage (i.e. biodegradable). STP using Moving Bed Bio Reactor (MBBR) technology is proposed to be provided. (Technical details of the proposed STP may please be furnished). Dry sludge to be used as manure for plants.

RWH is proposed.

EMP for HW management is enclosed as Enclosure – 3.

Disaster Management Plan enclosed as Enclosure - 4

4. RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX AT SOCCORRO BY M/s NITIN DEVELOPERS PVT LTD.,

Page 9 of 72

4 Nitin Developres Pvt. Ltd., Residential Soccorro Total plot area – 22,896.38 sq. mts. 1.The PP is seeking prior EC Mr. Nitin Saraf, complex village, FAR (permissible) – 18,317.10 sq. from the Goa-SEIAA for La Casa Grande, Lane No.2, Bardez mts. the extension of the St. Mary’s Colony, Miramar taluka, (proposed) – 17,072.69 sq. ongoing construction / S. Nos. 402/2, mts. development as the built- 404/5 and Coverage (permissible) – 9,124.15 up area, with the proposed 402/2-C sq. mts. extension, exceeds 20,000 Architect - (proposed) – 7,048.11 sq. sq. mts. as per the EIA C/o Soares & Associates, mts. Notification, 2006. G-1, Vikas Bldg., 18 th June Total parking provide for 275 cars Rd., Next to Pharmacy Total occupancy (optimum) – 746 2.Almost 40% of the total College, 18 th June Road, persons plot area has been Panaji, Goa – 403 001 developed and as a result, Water requirement – About 125 m 3 appreciable proportion of Ph. – 2228040 / 2430010 / per day (sump of 1,00,000 liters naturally grown vegetation The Goa-SEAC defers the 2463365 capacity is proposed) to be tapped has been lost along the proposal as the PP seeks Mobile - 9326142082 from P.W.D. moderate to steep sloping post-fact EC. hill-slopes thereby Total waste-water generated – disturbing the natural 98,000 liters per day STP is to be drainage, green cover. provided with generation of sewage sludge of 1.5 m 3 per day - Part of 3.The proposed extension this is proposed to be re-circulated would further degrade the and part to be disposed-off to STP ecological set-up of the through transport trucks. area as the proposed construction-activity would Total solid waste generated – 500 invariably require cutting kgs. per day (max.) of trees (loss of green cover) hill-slope cutting RWH is proposed for both, as (slope instability and storage (02 tanks) as well as disturbance to natural groundwater recharge (02 pits) . drainage). And to be integrated with storm-

Page 10 of 72

water drainage. Wells existing on 4.There exists a nala along site to be used for plantations and the northern boundary of would be recharged. the plot boundary which may get affected / flooded / Power requirement – Not provided. silted / diverted during However, CFL to be utilized. Solar monsoon owing to large- energy for garden lights and water scale storm-water heating system proposed. movement / soil erosion.

5. RESIDENTIAL-cum-COOMERCIAL COMPLEX AT KHORLIM BY BUILDMORE INFRASTRUCTURE INDIA PVT LTD.,

Sr. Project Proponent Proposed Sitespecific Project details / specification / Comments from GoaSEAC Response to comments by o. Activity location salient features members Project Proponent (PP) details (extracted from the project details submitted) 5 Buildmore Infrastructure Residential Khorlim Total plot area – 9,416 sq. mt. 1.The PP should opt for India Pvt. Ltd., building- village, Total built-up area – 27,267.49 sq. additional provision Mr. Jerry Braganza, cum- Bardez taluka, mt. towards storage of Souza Towers, 2 nd Floor, commercial S. Nos. 5/1 Proposed open space – 1521 sq. mt. optimum quantity of Near Municipal Garden, complex and 5/2 of P. ( more than 15%) rainwater to be utilized Panaji, Goa – 403 001 T. Sheet no. Proposed coverage – 3185 sq. mt. during fair-weather season, (Basement + 144 (less than 40%) considering the post- Ph. – 2426662 ground floor FAR consumed – 18,826 sq. mt. project usage of water. Fax – 2431973 + 7 upper Expected total occupancy – 1509 floors – 152 (combined) 2.The bore well drilled to e-mail – flats) carry out geotechnical soil info@[email protected] Geotechnical soil investigation as investigation be recharged carried out through 03 boreholes suitably and be utilized in Goa-SEAC recommends the Address as given on the letter (max. depth – 12 mt.). Groundwater case of need-based proposal subject to head - is encountered at about 2.5 mt. urgency. compliance to Goa-SEAC A/6, Skylark Apartments, below ground level. observations / comments. Menezes Braganza Road,

Page 11 of 72

Panaji, Goa – 403 001 About 16,000 m 3 of earth would be removed / excavated.

Spread foundation is proposed at an average depth of 1.5 mt. – 2.5 mt. with a net allowable bearing capacity of 17 to 35T/sq.mt. (with max. settlement between 30 mm – 70 mm.). Alternatively, Raft foundation is proposed at 1.5 mt. depth with net allowable bearing capacity of 12T/sq. mt.

Heating Ventilation Air Conditioning (HVAC) system is proposed.

Water requirement – During Construction phase - 9 cmd (2 for domestic use and 7 for construction purpose) - During operational phase - 147 cmd (79.6 through PWD supply, 67.4 through recycled water)

Total waste-water generated – 122 cmd. From which 117 cmd is expected to be generated as treated water. STP of treating capacity of 130 cmd based on Moving Bed Bio-

Page 12 of 72

Reactor (MBBR) technology is proposed – Treated water (about 67.4 cmd) to be utilized for landscaping and flushing and remaining (49.8 cmd) to be discharged into municipal sewer. STP would generate about 5 kg./day of sludge.

Storm water drain and RWH –

Power requirement (to be sourced from Goa Electricity Dept.) – Construction phase – 200 KVA Operation phase – 5 KVA

Back-up power through DG sets of 250 KVA capacity

Solid waste generated – 1 – 3 MT./day (Construction) 491 kg/day (on Operation) Organic Waste Convertor (OWC) is proposed for biodegradable waste.

EMP enclosed as Annexure – V

6. PREMIUM HOUSING AND COMMERCIAL DEVELOPMENT BY GERA DEVELOPMNETS PVT. LTD., PUNE

Page 13 of 72

6 Gera Developments Pvt. Ltd., Premium Survey no. 33 Total / Net plot area – 1,21,383.27 1.The PP proposes to 200, Gear Plaza, Boat Club housing (G of village sq. mts. ( no area under road develop the project site in Rd., Pune – 411001 + 1) and Khandola, widening) three phases (Phase – I, II commercial Ponda taluka, Proposed open space – 41,949.52 and III). However, Ph. 020-26125580 / 81 development North Goa. sq. mts. currently seeking prior Fax. 020 – 26113653 Proposed coverage – 22,497.16 sq. Environmental Clearance Five parts – Total Plot mts. (18.53%) (EC) for constructional E-mail – [email protected] 1.Garden area – FAR consumed – 0.69% activity for Phase-I and II Website - www.gera.in Preserve 1,21,383.27 (permissible is 0.80%) as combined. Phase-III is 2.Water sq. mts. Permissible FSI – 97,106.62 sq. mts. proposed to be developed Ms. Sunaina Gera Preserve (80%) later in light of the Vice-President – Product 3.Village Expected total occupancy – About amendment to be made in Development & Design Preserve 750 (Annexure – IV) the permissible FAR, to 4.Town Parking provide for 1013 vehicles. be considered by the TCP. Center 5.Sky Out of 414 trees existing on site and 2.The PP although, has Goa-SEAC recommends the Preserve project proposes to maintain the submitted the ‘Sanad’, proposal subject to maximum number. however, it needs to compliance to Goa-SEAC submit the sale deed / observations / comments. Geotechnical investigation was power of attorney carried out by College of indicating the ownership Engineering, Pune and the inference status of the said plot area. wad made through 16 boreholes (max. depth – 10 mt.). No 3.Geotechnical report Groundwater is encountered upto (Annexure – III) enclosed the depth of 10 mts. Below GL. with the proposal does not mention about (a) bore Isolated type of foundation is hole location and (b) soil proposed at an average depth of 2.5 profile. As such, it needs mt. below GL with a net allowable to be re-submitted, bearing capacity of 27 T/sq.mt. preferably superimposed (with max. settlement upto 25 mm). on suitable contour map of the proposed plot area.

Page 14 of 72

Water requirement – During Construction phase – 50 cmd ( 5 4.Contour map of the area cmd for domestic use and 45 cmd provided is not to a for construction purpose) suitable scale in light of - During operational phase - 212 the effective gradient and cmd ( 90 cmd through PWD contour interval vis-à-vis supply, 122 cmd through land development. recycled water)

There is a single seasonal nala passing through the proposed site. 5.Total waste-water generation during the Total waste-water generated – about operation phase needs to 4 cmd during construction phase. be indicated along with the modus operandi to STP of treating capacity of 130 cmd treat / dispose-off the based with SAFF technology is same. proposed – Treated water (about 122 cmd) to be utilized for landscaping 6.The PP should opt for and flushing. Dual plumbing system additional provision is proposed for PWD water supply towards storage of and use of treated waste-water. optimum quantity of rainwater to be utilized The project proponent proposes during fair-weather RWH for effective recharge of GW season, considering the through construction of – post-project usage of 1. Pond with recharge bore of water. Accordingly, PP 45,000 liters capacity should indicate the site- 2. Tank of 70,000 liters specific locations of capacity (Zone C) and storage tanks, recharge 66,000 liters for Zone F. pond, existing water body, as applicable, without Power requirement (to be sourced affecting the natural

Page 15 of 72

from Goa Electricity Dept.) – drainage / storm water Construction phase – 50 KW flow. Operation phase – 2037 KVA

Energy efficient electrical and Heating Ventilation Air Conditioning (HVAC) system is proposed towards energy conservation.

Back-up power through two DG sets of 40 KVA and 82.5 KVA capacities.

Solid waste generated – 1 – 3 MT./day (construction) 1468 kg/day (on Operation) – to be vermicompost ed. About 10 kg/day sludge generated from STP is to be composted on- site.

EMP enclosed as Annexure VI.

7. RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX BY M/s K. RAHEJA UNIVERSAL PVT. LTD., MUMBAI

Page 16 of 72

7 M/s K. Raheja Universal Pvt. Ltd., Residential Survey Nos. Net plot area – 88,868 sq. mts. 1.NE portion of the Raheja Centre–Point 294, project – 64/1 and Effective plot area – 87,250 sq. proposed plot area has C.S.T. Road, Near Mumbai Raheja 67/1of mts. been classified as No University, Chrysalis Carmona Built-up area – 35, 629 sq. mts. Development Area (NDZ) Off Bandra-Kurla Complex, (including village, Total construction area – 57,006 and as such, top soil Santacruz (E) – Mumbai – 400 098 provision Salcete sq. mts. excavated from the for taluka, South Proposed open space – 47,478 sq. remaining plot, during Ph. 022-66414137/38 commercial Goa. mts. (about 54%) construction, be utilized Fax – 022-66414242 shops ) for proposed landscape Total Plot Expected total occupancy – About development (i.e. Goa-SEAC recommends Mr. Yogesh Yadav, area – 88,868 262 + 511 persons from landscaping) within the the proposal subject to Asst. Manager sq. mts. commercial shops ( refer sr. no. NDZ area. compliance to Goa-SEAC (M) – 9850467028 4.2. on pg. 13 and sr. no. 8.4 on observations / comments. [email protected] Built-up area pg. 22 ) 2.The PP should submit the – 87,250 sq. geotechnical soil analysis mts. Parking provided for 25 ECS on report so as to understand (excluding surface (i.e. open parking) and 35 the soil profile & its road ECS in garage (i.e. covered characteristics, foundation widening of parking). details, hydro-geological 1,618 sq. status. mts. ) The proposed plot has a maximum elevation difference of 6 mts. 3.It is advisable that the (refer 1.1 in Form1A ) with no water / power natural watercourse passing requirement, generation of through the site. Groundwater is optimum solid waste / encountered at a depth of 3 – 5 sewage / waste water as mts. well as methodology to be adopted to treat/dispose- Excavation will be carried out for off be indicated separately foundation of buildings and one as (a) during construction, basement. including excavation debris, if any and (b) on Water requirement – 268 m 3 (216 operationalization of the

Page 17 of 72

– fresh water & 52 recycled project. water) per day to be sourced through municipal supply. 4.The PP should submit the (provisional OC has been issued details of the Sewage by PWD, Margao ) Treatment Plant (STP) proposed to be installed Total waste-water generated – along with the about 58 m 3 per day which is methodology to be proposed to be transferred to STP adopted to teat wet of 65 KLD capacity (output is garbage on-site expected to be 52 KLD – 28 KLD for flushing and 24 KLD for green area) to be installed on -site. Dual plumbing system is proposed for 5.Total waste-water PWD water supply and use of generation during the treated waste-water. Sludge to be operation phase needs to used as manure for green area be indicated along with development. the modus operandi to treat / dispose-off the Solid waste generated – 213 kg. / same. day (Construction) (on Operation) – 105 kg./ day + 6.The PP should opt for 108 kg./day (variable) from additional provision visitors and club entry – towards storage of comprising of organic / inorganic optimum quantity of waste. rainwater to be utilized during fair-weather Power requirement is about 1247 season, considering the KW to be sourced from Goa post-project usage of Electricity Dept. Back-up power water. through DG set (05 nos.) of total capacity 1867.5 KVA is proposed. Air-cooling of the DG sets are

Page 18 of 72

proposed instead of traditional water cooling.

Solar water heating system is proposed to be provided for hot- water supply. Feasibility for installation of solar photovoltaic cells for street lighting is proposed to be assessed.

Central air-conditioning system using water-cooled centrifugal chillers is proposed to be installed.

Storm Water Management Plan (SWMP) is proposed to be developed.

Environment Management Plan (EMP) enclosed – refer pg. 31 to 35 .

B. Any other matter with the permission of the Chair.

&*&*&*&*&*&

Page 19 of 72

Agenda Items for the SECOD GoaSEIAA meeting scheduled on 24 th October 2011 at the GSPCB, Patto.

1. Reconsideration of following two proposals which were not considered favourable to issue Prior Environmental Clearance (EC) during the First GoaSEIAA meeting held on 24 th February 2011.

A. RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX AT ALTO-BATIM BY M/s ROCKFIRST REAL ESTATE LTD.,

Project Proponent Proposed Activity Sitespecific Project details / specification / Comments from GoaSEAC Current Status location salient features members based on the details (extracted from the project details revised presentation made by submitted) the PP M/s Rockfirst Real Estate Residential Alto-Betim Total plot area – 29,120.13 sq. mt. 5.The proposed project “A” is The said proposal has not Ltd., Mumbai. Apartments village, Total Ground coverage area – 8,751 an extension of the ongoing been considered to issue Bardez sq. mts. work, being developed, Prior Environmental Mr. Rajesh Jaggi, “Ashoka Beleza” taluka, Green cover area – 20,368 sq. mts. within two adjacent plots Clearance (EC) on 19 th Managing Director, (G + 3 storied S. Nos. 57/1 Built-up area – 22,279.67 sq. mts. namely – ‘B’ and ‘C’ and is May 2011. 1, Peninsula Spenta, complex) of Reis Total construction built-up area – seeking prior Mathurdas Mills, Senapati Magos 32,452.52 sq. mts. Environmental Clearance The firm has communicated Bapat Marg, Lower Parel, village (EC) from the Goa-SEIAA, for re-consideration its Mumbai – 400013 Ready-Mix-Concrete (RMC) to be as the built-up area, taken proposal and was taken up used. together, exceeds 20,000 for discussion during the Ph. – 022/66229400 – sq. mts. as per the EIA Fifth Goa-SEAC meeting 022/66229300/01 Total occupancy – 652 nos. (max.) Notification, 2006. held on 19 th August 2011. Fax – 022/66229302 About 80,134 m 3 of earth would be 6.Almost 30% of the total However, based on the [email protected] removed / excavated. plot area has been observations as well as (M) - 9820505005 developed and as a result, ground-truth verification, the Geotechnical soil investigation appreciable proportion of Goa-SEAC is not in favour Corres. Add .: (enclosure – 1) as carried out naturally grown vegetation of recommending the said Mr. Sanjeev - 9890003168 through 17 boreholes with has been lost along the hill- project for issuance of prior Peninsula Land Ltd., permanent benchmark of +50mt. No slopes. EC. Peninsula Center, H. No. groundwater table was encountered. 850, Opp. SBI, Porvorim – 7.The proposed extension Remarks – The Authority

Page 20 of 72

403 621 Reinforced concrete (i.e. Spread would further degrade the may like to take a suitable Mr. Sanjay Ghatwal foundation) is proposed with ecological set up of the area independent decision in the (M) - 9764005561 maximum water: cement ratio of as it would invariably matter based on 0.50 at an average depth of 1.5 mt.. require to clear green-cover observations of the Goa This foundation has a safe bearing / hill-slope cutting which is SEAC capacity of 40 T/sq.mt. (with total likely to disturb the natural settlement of 9 mm). California drainage as well as forest Bearing Ratio (CBR) of 6 is cover. proposed for construction design. Retaining walls with weep holes with gravel filters are proposed.

Estimated cost – 125 crores.

Noise pollution to be controlled by restricting the usage of equipments generating more than 90 db (A) sound.

Water requirement – During construction : 42 m 3/d 12m 3/d for workers from local authority 20 to 30 m 3/d for construction through tankers.

During operation : 60m 3/d for domestic use (150 m 3/d) 30m 3/d for flushing 60m 3/d for

Page 21 of 72 gardening

50 trees are proposed to be planted in lieu of 46 trees for which permission is sought.

Power requirement – 75 kVA (Construction) - from Goa Electricity Dept. 3828 KW (from GED) during Operation. Back-up power through four diesel generator 2 nos. of 750 kVA and 2 nos. of 500 kVA.

RWH is proposed.

EMP for HW management is enclosed as Enclosure – 3.

Page 22 of 72

Disaster Management Plan enclosed as Enclosure - 4

B. RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX AT SOCCORRO BY M/s NITIN DEVELOPERS PVT LTD.,

Project Proponent Proposed Sitespecific Project details / specification / Comments from GoaSEAC Current Status Activity location salient features members details (extracted from the project details submitted) Nitin Developres Pvt. Ltd., Residential Soccorro Total plot area – 22,896.38 sq. mts. 5.The PP is seeking prior EC The said proposal has not Mr. Nitin Saraf, complex village, FAR (permissible) – 18,317.10 sq. from the Goa-SEIAA for been considered to issue La Casa Grande, Lane No.2, Bardez mts. the extension of the Prior Environmental St. Mary’s Colony, Miramar taluka, (proposed) – 17,072.69 sq. ongoing construction / Clearance (EC) on 19 th S. Nos. 402/2, mts. development as the built- May 2011. 404/5 and Coverage (permissible) – 9,124.15 up area, with the proposed 402/2-C sq. mts. extension, exceeds 20,000 The firm has communicated Architect - (proposed) – 7,048.11 sq. sq. mts. as per the EIA for re-consideration its C/o Soares & Associates, mts. Notification, 2006. proposal and was taken up G-1, Vikas Bldg., 18 th June Total parking provide for 275 cars for presentation during the Rd., Next to Pharmacy Total occupancy (optimum) – 746 6.Almost 40% of the total Third Goa-SEAC meeting College, 18 th June Road, persons plot area has been held on 25th July 2011. Panaji, Goa – 403 001 developed and as a result, During the Forth Goa-SEAC Water requirement – About 125 m 3 appreciable proportion of meeting held on 2 nd August Ph. – 2228040 / 2430010 / per day (sump of 1,00,000 liters naturally grown vegetation 2011, the Committee, owing 2463365 capacity is proposed) to be tapped has been lost along the to the ambiguity in the Mobile - 9326142082 from P.W.D. moderate to steep sloping project clarity, decided not to hill-slopes thereby recommend the proposed Total waste-water generated – disturbing the natural activity for favour of 98,000 liters per day STP is to be drainage, green cover. according prior EC. provided with generation of sewage sludge of 1.5 m 3 per day - Part of 7.The proposed extension this is proposed to be re-circulated would further degrade the and part to be disposed-off to STP ecological set-up of the Remarks – The Authority

Page 23 of 72

through transport trucks. area as the proposed may like to take a suitable construction-activity would independent decision in the Total solid waste generated – 500 invariably require cutting matter based on kgs. per day (max.) of trees (loss of green observations of the Goa cover) hill-slope cutting SEAC. RWH is proposed for both, as (slope instability and storage (02 tanks) as well as disturbance to natural groundwater recharge (02 pits) . drainage). And to be integrated with storm- water drainage. Wells existing on 8.The proposed activity is site to be used for plantations and likely to affect the adjacent would be recharged. nala which may get silted / diverted / flooded, Power requirement – Not provided. especially during monsoon However, CFL to be utilized. Solar causing severe soil erosion. energy for garden lights and water heating system proposed. 9.The revised plan envisages construction of additional villas, which was believed to be not a part of original proposal, submitted earlier.

2. Consideration of the following new proposals

A. EXPANSION OF GROUP HOUSING PROJECT AT VADDEM, VASCO

Page 24 of 72

Building, 12, 13, 14, 15, 16, F.A.R. proposed – 29,510.60 sq. mt. recommend the said proposal for F. L. Gomes Road, Vasco-da- 17, 18, 19, 20 of Existing – 17,734.96 sq. mt. issuance of Prior Environmental Gama Chalta No. 2 of P. Proposed – 11,775.64 sq. mt. Clearance (EC) during the Fifth Goa – 403 802 T. Sheet No. 68 in Goa-SEAC meeting held on 19 th [email protected] Vaddem village of Built-up area – Existing – 26,110 sq. mt. (240 August 2011. Vasco-da-Gama in apartments) Ph. No. 0832-2511110 / 2512987 Mormugao Taluka Proposed – 18,688.41 sq. mt. However, the PP has been requested of South Goa Permissible ground coverage – 6796.25 sq. mt. (40%) to obtain ‘Structural Stability Contact Person: district. Proposed ground coverage – 4303 sq. mt. (25.32%) Certificate’ from Competent Mr. Nilesh Salkar Existing – 3,803.11 sq. mt. Authority. [email protected] Proposed – 500.85 sq. mt. Goa-SEIAA has been Environmental Consultant Total green area proposed – 5343.16 sq. mt. (21.15%) communicated accordingly on 19 th Mr. Sunil Dixit, September 2011. Associate Director, Water requirement – 256 KLD to be sourced from J. M. EnviroNet (P) Ltd., PWD. 1st & 2 nd Floor, S. C. O., 16, Construction of bore-well proposed. Sector-10 A, Gurgaon (Haryana) (Kindly check entries against 1.23 and 2.2 on pg. 8 Ph.: 0124-3206559 and 9 respectively) Mob.: 09971699906 [email protected] Total waste-water generated – 202 KLD to be Remarks – May be considered to disposed through municipal sewerage to be treated issue Prior EC subject to through 14 MLD STP located at Kate-Baina. submission of Stability Certificate by the PP Power requirement – 1520 KW to be sourced from Electricity Dept.,

Two D.G. seta of total 165 KVA capacity (i.e. 82.5 KVA each) with low sulphur diesel is proposed to be installed as a back-up facility.

Solid waste generated (residential-cum-floating) – 884 kg. per day to be dispose-off through vendors for

Page 25 of 72

recycling.

B. RESIDENTIAL BUILDING IN SANCOALE VILLAGE OF MORMUGAO TALUKA, SOUTH GOA DISTRICT

Sr. Project Proponent (PP) / Proposed Sitespecific Project details / specification / salient features Comments of the GoaSEAC o. Applicant Activity location details members / Current Status Environmental Consultant 2 M/s Sattva Builders Pvt. Ltd., Residential Survey no. 199/2 Total plot area – 19,125 sq. mt. Based on the compliance to site- B’lore building of Sancoale Effective Plot area – 18,573 sq. mt. (595 sq. mt. for inspection observations vis-à-vis village in road widening) presentation before the Committee, #3, 4 th Floor, Salarpuria Windsor, ‘Sattva Water’s Mormugao taluka, Total Built-up area – 24,700 sq. mt. (pre-revised) Goa-SEAC has considered to Ulsoor Road, Edge’ South Goa district - 22,786.42 sq. mt. (revised) and recommend the said proposal for Bengaluru – 560 042 Revised plan to includes - (18,913.30 + 1,633.95 + 92 – club house issuance of Prior Environmental include - area) + 347.17 (utilities) + 1,800 (podium) Clearance (EC) during the Fifth Mr. P. K. Mishra, 1. Villas – 10 (G Goa-SEAC meeting held on 19 th Vice President, + first floor) Total green area proposed – 5,696 sq. mt. (30.74%) August 2011. Ph.: 080-42690100 2. 04 Apartment Total area covered by building – 4,909 sq. mt. Fax.: 080-42699011 blocks for Goa-SEIAA has been [email protected] residential use Total soil to be excavated – 3,700 m 3 approx. (1200 communicated accordingly on 19 th (Stilt + 5 floors) m3 to be used for landscape development) September 2011. Environmental Consultant – 3. 01 Apartment Manpower required during construction phase – 150 M/s B. S. Envi-Tech. Pvt. Ltd., Studio block max. However, as per e-mail H’bad. (Stilt + four communication received from PP floors) Parking facility – 106 cars dated 20 th September 2011,the PP intends to revise the plan of the In the pre Total nos. of trees to be cut – 21 (relevant NOC proposed developmental activity. revised plan – 09 obtained) The revised plan has been dully villas and 06 scrutinized by Secretary, Goa- apartment blocks Rainwater harvesting – (a) 12 recharge wells for SEAC were proposed. effective groundwater recharge (b) Roof-top harvesting is proposed to be stored (about 207 m 3 ) to Remarks – Based on above be treated through Water Treatment Plant. Treated submission, the said proposal can water shall be pumped to 09 overhead tanks of 12.6 be considered to issue prior EC

Page 26 of 72

m3 capacity as well as firefighting purpose. on the revised area calculations which are in fact less than the Water requirement – 25 KLD – during construction original proposed calculations phase to be sourced through tankers. w.r.t. builtup area. During operational phase 96 KLD - to be sourced from Municipal supply and recycled treated sewage.

Sewage Treatment Plant - 90 KLD STP is proposed to be installed to generate 78 KLD of treated water to be utilized for flushing, gardening as well as floor / vehicle washing. It will also generate 4.5 kgs. /day of sludge to be used as manure for landscape area.

Power requirement – Two D.G. sets (a) during construction – one of 50 KVA and (b) during operation – Normal supply of 1241 KVA and Max. demand of 931 KVA is to be sourced from Goa Electricity Dept. (GED). Further, one of 160 KVA and two of 220 KVA to be installed as a back-up facility.

Solid waste generated (residential-cum-floating) – 285 kgs./day (173 kgs. of organic & 114 kgs. of inorganic garbage). Organic Waste Converter is proposed to be installed to convert wet waste into manure. While, inorganic waste is to be disposed through Municipal Authorities.

Environment Management Plan (EMP) provides recurring cost of 6.60 lakhs per year.

Page 27 of 72

C. RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX AT TALEIGAO, TISWADI TALUKA, NORTH GOA DISTRICT

Sr. Project Proponent (PP) / Proposed Sitespecific Project details / specification / salient features Comments of the GoaSEAC o. Applicant Activity location details members / Current Status Environmental Consultant 3 M/s Model Real Estate Residential Survey no. 213/2 Total plot area – 27,389 sq. mt. Based on the compliance to site- Developers, Complex of Taleigao village Total Built-up area – 33,752.08 sq. mt. inspection observations vis-à-vis 4th Floor, Joffrey Residency, in Tiswadi taluka Total nos. of flats - 270 presentation before the Committee, Behind College of Pharmacy, ‘Model’s Status’ in North Goa Plinth area / Terrace area – 4,104.89 sq. mt. Goa-SEAC has considered to Panaji, Goa – 403 001 (G + 8 – height District Total green area + open space proposed – 4,514.00 sq. recommend the said proposal for of 24 mt. & G + mt. issuance of Prior Environmental Ph.: 2227688 / 2226251 1 – height of 7.5 Manpower required during construction phase – 125 Clearance (EC) during the Fifth Fax.: 2224484 mt.) max. Goa-SEAC meeting held on 19 th e-mail: [email protected] Cost of the project – 42.39 crores August 2011. Parking facility – 325 four wheelers & 50 two Mr. Peter Vaz, wheelers Goa-SEAC observed that the PP Director, intends to seek Ex-post-facto EC as [email protected] Rainwater harvesting involving (a) groundwater against the prior EC as mandated recharge as well as (b) roof-top harvesting to store the in the EIA Notification, 2006. M/s Sadekar EnviroTech., water has been proposed. Porvorim Mr. Pradip Joshi / Mr. Sadekar Water requirement – 50 m 3 /day during construction Goa-SEIAA has been 130.1 m 3/day during operation phase communicated accordingly on 19 th September 2011. Sewage Treatment Plant – Out of 117.35 m 3/day waste-water generated, about 93.52 of treated water from the STP is proposed to be utilized for gardening Remarks – The Authority may and green-area development. like to take a suitable independent decision in the Power requirement – 100 KVA during construction matter based on observations of phase the GoaSEAC 1500 KVA during operation phase to be sourced from Goa Electricity Dept. (GED). 01 no. of D. G. set of

Page 28 of 72

100 KVA capacity is proposed as stand-by energy source.

Solid waste generated – 500 kg. /day during construction phase and 108 kgs. /day during operation phase (i.e. 64.8 kg – biodegradable waste & 43.2 non- biodegradable waste). Hazardous waste (20 kgs. /month during construction and 10 kgs./month during operation phase) is expected to be generated.

Environment Management Plan (EMP) addressing following issues related to - (a) fire fighting facility (b) Traffic management (c) noise reduction (d) energy conservation (e) post-project monitoring and management have been proposed.

D. SETTING UP OF POT-STILL DISTILLATION PLANT AT LATAMBARCEM, BICHOLIM TALUKA, NORTH GOA

Sr. Project Proponent (PP) / Proposed Sitespecific Project details / specification / salient features Comments of the GoaSEAC o. Applicant Activity location details members / Current Status Environmental Consultant 4 M/a Phoenix Alcobevz Pvt. Ltd., Pot-still a. The site is not The Project Proponent (PP) proposes – Based on the project details, site- 100, Punola, Ucassaim, Bardez, distillation plant located in 1. 2,800 LPD pot-still distillation plant for inspection observations vis-à-vis Mapusa, Goa. Industrial production of presentation made before the Category ‘5(g)’ - Estate. Malt, Grape, Cashew & other consumable spirits. Committee during the Fourth Goa- Mr. Siddharth Bahkta, Distilleries (total plot area - 2. Winery of capacity of 15,000 cases annually SEAC meeting held on 2 nd August Managing Director, 11,400 sq. mts.) 3. Bottling capacity 30,000 cases (9 liters per 2011, following observations / Tel no. 2261599 case) per month for IMFL, Country Liquor clarification:- Fax no. 2261659 (built-up area – and Wine e-mail: 2,500 sq. mts.) To ascertain the nearest distance [email protected] In addition, PP proposes to – from the inter-state boundary and b. Survey Nos. 1. Construct one bore well. submit documentary proof in Pre-construction investigations 299/1 (Part) 2. Construct 300 mts. length road from main support of the same . As General

Page 29 of 72

(i.e. soil testing, hydrogeological and road to the proposed plot. Conditions annexed to the status) is intended to be carried out 301/0(Part) of 3. Creation of artificial pond (300 sq. mt.) Schedule to the EIA Notification, by - Latambarcem 4. Green-belt development would cover total area of 2006, which states – “Any M/s Daftary Descon Engineering village of about project or activity specified in Pvt. Ltd., Bardez taluka, 2,700 sq. mts. (about 24% of total plot area) Category ‘B’ will be treated as Velho Bldg., 2 nd Floor, North Goa Category ‘A’, if located in whole Near Municipal Garden, Panaji. district. Raw material required – Barley, Grapes, Cashew or in part within 10 km from the apples, Chemicals, Yeast, Enzymes, etc., (refer boundary of: (i) Protected Areas c. PP is outright Table II(2)) notified under the Wild Life owner of the (Protection) Act, 1972, (ii) plot. Total manpower requirement – 60 (refer Table (((4)) (Critically Polluted areas as identified by the Central Total water requirement – 81 K liters per day (refer Pollution Control Board) from Table II(3)) . Distillery wastewater is a main time to time, (iii) Eco-sensitive byproduct which is generally 10 to 15 times more areas as notified under section 3 than etahanol produced. Other waste will be of the Environment (Protection) biodegradable – skin seeds stem from sugarcane, Act, 1986, such as , grapes, cashew apples as well as husk of barley. The Mahabaleshwar Panchgani, unit intends to promote Zero-discharge concept”. Matheran, Pachmarhi, Dahanu, Doon Valley, and (iv) inter Process description for liquor / winery is detailed in State boundaries and Chapter – II. It includes – Pre-treatment, international boundaries: Fermentation, Distillation & Maturation To specify, in detail, the steps to be Power requirement – 300 KVA and to be sourced initiated to address Solid Waste from Goa Electricity Dept., (GED). However, stand- Management (SWM) with by D.G. sets (03 nos.) of 100 KVA each as power special reference to the back-up. generation of sludge and its treatment methodology to be Solid waste – domestic waste to be disposed-off adopted, especially in monsoon through soak-pits and septic tank. Other types of season. industrial waste – paper, broken glass, metal caps, etc., is expected to be sold as scrap to M/s Goa To provide sufficient buffer zone

Page 30 of 72

Bottle Supply, Margao. from the either banks of the Tillari canal, which passes through the plot area, to prevent any possibility of leaching into the canal water course. Accordingly submit the conceptual layout plan of the proposed developmental activity.

Goa-SEIAA has been communicated accordingly on 19 th September 2011.

Remarks – As the PP has OT YET complied with the aforementioned observations / comments, the said proposal may be kept in abeyance / reserve pending the compliance, as sought for, by the GoaSEAC.

E. GROUP HOUSING & COMMERCIAL COMPLEX AT VANELIM VILLAGE, SALCETE TALUKA, SOUTH GOA

Page 31 of 72

Zone C1 as per Total coverage area of the proposed building – observations to be forwarded to the Mr. Avinash Borkar, local TCP 34.42% Goa-SEIAA for further compliance. Managing Director, guidelines. Total quantity of soil to be excavated – 8,721 m 3 Out Ph.: 0832-2743684 of which about 7,85 0m 3 to be used for backfilling and a. From the latest communication [email protected] remaining top soil to be used for green area received from the Ministry of development. Environment & Forests (MoEF), Mr. Rohit Borkar, Ground coverage – 34.42% Govt. of India, New Delhi vis-à- [email protected] / Total population – 1399 9. Out of this about 1380 is vis project application submitted [email protected] residential and 19 nos. as floating population. to the Goa-SEAC/Goa-SEIAA, it Plinth area / Terrace area –sq. mt. is yet to be ascertained whether Prepared by – Total green area– 7,170.97 sq.mt. (28.26%) the project is still being Environmental Consultant considered by the MoEF or has Mr. Sunil Dixit, Sedimentological analysis of soil has been conducted. de-listed the same to be Associate Director, considered by the State J. M. EnviroNet (P) Ltd., Manpower required during construction phase –max. Authority. 1st & 2 nd Floor, S. C. O., 16, Coast of the project –crores Sector-10 A, Gurgaon (Haryana) Parking facility – 348 ECS (226 ECS for covered b. It is kindly requested to ascertain Ph.: 0124-3206559 parking & 122 ECS as surface parking. the implementation of High Mob.: 09971699906 Court Directives / decisions, as [email protected] Rainwater harvesting involving only collection and applicable in favour of storage of roof-top water is proposed. Approximately Mundkars, if any, in respect of 212.10 m 3 /day of rainwater is expected to be stored Writ Petition No. 297/2009. in underground tanks with proper filter media and network pipes.. Goa-SEIAA has been communicated accordingly on 19 th Water requirement - during construction 45 lpcd of September 2011. water requirement and during operation phase, 188 KLD of water requirement is to be entirely sourced Remarks: Considering the from Public Water Department (PWD). During uncertainty of the Regulatory operational phase, about 150.4 KLD of waste water Authority (whether MoEF or generated is expected to be treated in 170 KLD GoaSEIAA), the GoaSEIAA capacity STP. About 145 KLD of treated water (at may ascertain the status from the 95% of STP efficiency) will be utilized for MoEF directly. As such, may like

Page 32 of 72

landscaping (28 KLD), car washing (20 KLD) and to keep the said proposal in Municipal authorities for watering public garden 997 abeyance / reserve until KLD). In monsoon season, this water will be compliance from the MoEF or discharged to the low-lying areas. otherwise.

Power requirement – During construction phase, 71 KVA to be sourced from the Goa Electricity Dept.

During operational phase, 1355 KVA has been approved by Goa Electricity Dept., However, Total Maximum Demand is 1208 KVA. It is also proposed to install 7 nos. of 25 KVA and 1 no. of 50 KVA D.G. sets as back-up power supply. This would generate about 200 liters of waste oil per annum to be disposed-off through authorized recycler. Solid waste generated – About 625 kgs./day to be treated after due segregation at source, separately for biodegradable and non-biodegradable wastes.

Environment Management Plan (EMP) has been prepared. 3. Followup / further course of action on the proposal submitted by GoaSEAC :

1. Approval and sanction for sitting fees / remuneration for project scrutiny / T.A. (Rs. 2,000/- per member per project) to Goa-SEAC/ Goa-SEIAA Members per meet / site-inspection (Rs. 1,000/- per member per site inspected), as the case may be. 2. Modus-operandi to create awareness about the effective implementation of EIA Notifications, especially for building construction projects of built-up area exceeding 20,000 sq. mts., among the local developmental authorities (i.e. Village Panchayats, PDAs’, Municipalities (including CCP), etc.,) 4. Any other matter with the prior permission of the Chairman, GoaSEIAA.

&*&*&*&*&*&

Page 33 of 72

Agenda Items for the 3 rd GoaSEIAA meeting held on 5 th April 2012 (Thursday) from 10.00 a.m. onwards

A. Consideration of the proposed development of residential complex by M/s Four Seasons Shelter at Bainguinim village in Tiswadi taluka ( The site was visited by Members, GoaSEAC on 25 th ovember 2011 and subsequently, by Chairman, Goa SEIAA on 17 th January 2012 ).

B. Consideration of the proposed development of a residential complex by M/s Prithvi Consultants Pvt. Ltd., Panaji at Bainguinim. ( The site was visited by Members, GoaSEAC on 25 th ovember 2011 and subsequently, by Chairman, GoaSEIAA on 17 th January 2012 ).

C. Consideration of the proposed development by M/s anu Estates Pvt. Ltd., Margao of residential-cum-commercial project at Aquem, Margao. ( The site was visited by Members, GoaSEAC on 25 th ovember 2011 and subsequently, by Chairman, Goa SEIAA on 17 th January 2012 ).

D. Consideration of the proposed development by M/s Commonwealth Developers Pvt. Ltd., Margao of the residential-cum-commercial project at Gogol, Margao. ( The site was visited by Members, GoaSEAC on 25 th ovember 2011 and subsequently, by Chairman, GoaSEIAA on 17 th January 2012 ).

E. Consideration of the proposed on-site expansion by M/s Berger Paints India Ltd., Kundaim in production capacity of paint products / ranges (i.e. Waterbased Emulsion and Distemper paint ). The said proposal has already been appraised by the EAC (i.e. Expert Appraisal Committee) of the Ministry of Environment & Forests (MoEF), New Delhi in 2010 in the absence of constitution of Goa-SEAC/Goa-SEIAA at that time. Subsequently, the MoEF had suggested Terms of Reference (ToRs') to conduct the EIA study and accordingly, M/s Kadam Environmental Consultants - NABET / QCI accredited Consultant has carried out the study incorporating these ToRs' and has submitted the same to the O/o the Goa-SEIAA for seeking prior EC as mandated under the EIA Notification, 2006. ( Accordingly, the proposal was presented at the Sixth GoaSEAC meeting held on 7 th December 2011 and has recommended the project, pending onsite inspection.).

F. Any other matter as per the approval of the Chairman, Goa-SEIAA.

&*&*&*&*&*&

Page 34 of 72

Agenda Items to be discussed during the 4 th GoaSEIAA meeting held on 10 th August 2012 at GSPCB

A. COSIDERATIO / DECISIO O OLD PROJECT PROPOSALS

A. Request for rectification in the prior EC granted by Goa-SEIAA vide its letter no. 3-181-2010/STE-DIR/05 dated 30 th April 2012 for proposed residential-cum- commercial project in Bainguinim village as requested by M/s Prithvi Consultants Pvt. Ltd., Panaji vide letters dated 4 th June and 28 th June 2012. The rectification is proposed in (i) Total plot area, (ii) Total built-up area and (iii) Parking facility provided

B. Discussions on compliance to SCN / site-specific observations / revised EMP submitted by following Project Proponents (PPs’) in response to Goa-SEIAA’s communication– 1. M/s itin Developers – proposed construction project at Socorro, Bardez. 2. M/s Rockfirst Developers Pvt. Ltd ., - proposed construction at Alto-Batim 3. M/s Berger Paints (India) Pvt. Ltd., - proposed expansion at Kundaim

B. COSIDERATIO OF EW PROJECT PROPOSALS

A. Proposal by M/s Bandekar Brothers Pvt. Ltd., VascodaGama for construction of Ore-loading Jetty at Kotambi in Bicholim taluka of North Goa district.

B. Proposal by M/s Ganesh Benzoplasts Pvt. Ltd., Mumbai for construction of two storage tanks for Butane and Propane within MPT port limit area at Sada in Marmagoa of South Goa district.

C. Two proposals by M/s Raj Housing Development Pvt. Ltd., Ponda for construction of residential-cum-commercial project namely –

1. ‘Ral Enclave’ in P.T. sheet No. 8 of Chalta No. 01 within Mapusa Municipal limits, Mapusa. ( Builtup area – 30,244.17 sq.mts .)

2. ‘Raj Ryle Residency’ in P. T. shhet No. 14 of Chalta Nos. 40, 41, 42, 43, 45, 46, 47 & 48 and P. T. sheet No. 32 of Chalta Nos. 4 & 36 within Mapusa Municipal limits. ( Builtup area – 22,626.44 sq. mts .)

D. Any other matter as per the approval of the Chairman, Goa-SEIAA.

&*&*&*&*&*&

Page 35 of 72

Agenda Items to be discussed during the 5 th GoaSEIAA meeting held on 18 th December 2012 at GSPCB

A. COSIDERATIO / DECISIO O OLD PROJECT PROPOSALS (03)

A. Final considerations / decision on the project proposals of - 1. M/s itin Developers, Panaji – proposed construction project at Socorro. 2. M/s Rockfirst Rel Estate Ltd., Panaji - proposed construction at Alto-Batim 3. M/s Model Real Estate Developers, Panaji – proposed construction at Taleigao

B. COSIDERATIO OF DEFERRED (during last Authority meet) PROJECT PROPOSALS (03)

A. Proposal by M/s Ganesh Benzoplasts Pvt. Ltd., Mumbai for construction of two storage tanks for Butane and Propane within MPT port limit area at Sada in Marmagoa of South Goa district. ( The firm has submitted the response to observations made during the SEAC / SEIAA inspection ).

B. Two proposals by M/s Raj Housing Development Pvt. Ltd., Ponda for construction of residential-cum-commercial project namely –

3. ‘Ral Enclave’ in P.T. sheet No. 8 of Chalta No. 01 within Mapusa Municipal limits, Mapusa. ( Builtup area – 30,244.17 sq.mts .)

4. ‘Raj Ryle Residency’ in P. T. sheet No. 14 of Chalta Nos. 40, 41, 42, 43, 45, 46, 47 & 48 and P. T. sheet No. 32 of Chalta Nos. 4 & 36 within Mapusa Municipal limits. (Builtup area – 22,626.44 sq. mts .)

C. COSIDERATIO OF EW PROJECT PROPOSALS (based on GoaSEAC recommendations during its 9 th meet held on 11 th October 2012 )

A. Construction / Residential projects

a. Proposal by M/s Palacio Property Developers Pvt. Ltd., Panaji for proposed expansion of a rresidential project comprising of 17 residential buildings with amenities – playground, swimming pool in survey nos. 181/(P), 181/2, 181/3, 181/5(P), 182/7, 183/9, 180/1(P), 180/2(P), and 184/3 of St. Andre – (Near Lobo Garage), Goa Velha village in Tiswadi taluka of North Goa district. (SITE ISPECTED BY GoaSEAC)

A. ew / Renewal of Minor Minerals (road metal / laterite stones) quarrying lease

i. Renewal of one ‘Stone Quarry’ lease belonging to M/s Shailaja Vasudev Tamba bearing no. 04/BA/07 located in Survey No. 11/1, 2 & 6 at St. Pedro, Village Panelim, Tiswadi taluka, North Goa district. (SITE ISPECTED BY GoaSEAC)

ii. Renewal of two ‘Stone Quarries’ lease with common boundary belonging to M/s Vasudev Tamba bearing no. 5/BA/MU/91 and 3/Basalt/05 located in Survey No. 11/1, 2 & 6 at St. Pedro, Village Panelim, Tiswadi taluka, North Goa district. (SITE ISPECTED BY GoaSEAC)

iii. New lease of one “Laterite Quarry’ ( proposed extraction – 240 cubic mt. per month ) belonging to Mr. Shirish Kamat covering lease area of 8,000 sq.mts. in Survey no. 29/4 of Soliem village in Cacora of Quepem taluka in South Goa district. (SITE ISPECTED BY GoaSEAC). B. Any other matter as per the approval of the Chairman, GoaSEIAA.

&*&*&*&*&*&*

Page 36 of 72

Tentative Agenda Items to be discussed during the 6th GoaSEIAA meeting held on 7th February 2013 at GSPCB from 03.30 p.m. onwards

1. Proposal by Goa Industrial Development Corporation (GoaIDC) seeking Renewal / Extension of the prior Environmental Clearance (EC) for establishment of Common Hazardous Wastes Treatment, Storage and Disposal Facility (CHWTSDF) in a land admeasuring 1,10,390 sq.mts. in Survey No. 193/1 of Dharbandora village in Sanguem taluka of South Goa district.

Background of the proposal –

a. The Ministry of Environment and Forests (MoEF), Govt. of India, New Delhi has accorded prior EC for the proposed establishment of the CHWTSDF vides letter No. 10-32/07-IA-III dated 19 th February 2008 as mandated in the Environment Impact Assessment (EIA) Notification, 2006.

b. As per clause (9) of the said Notification, the validity of the said prior EC expires on 18 th February 2013 ( i.e. for a period of five years from the date of its issuance ). Further, the said clause specifies that the period of the validity may be extended by the regulatory authority concerned by a maximum period of five years provided an application is made to the regulatory authority by the applicant within the validity period.

The above proposal was taken up for discussions following the project presentation by GoaIDC / President, Industrial Waste Association of Goa (IWAG) during the twelfth GoaSEAC meeting convened on 30 th January 2013 with a request to submit Operational Procedural Manual (i.e. flow chart), proposed to be adopted by the Project Proponent (PP) / IWAG or any Authorized Service Operator while dealing with transportation, storage and treatment methodology for “Landfillable” hazardous waste category at the desired site .

2. COSIDERATIO / DECISIO O OLD PROJECT PROPOSALS (01)

A. Final considerations / decision on the project proposals of M/s Model Real Estate Developers, Panaji – proposed construction at Taleigao.

3. COSIDERATIO OF DEFERRED (during last Authority meet) PROJECT PROPOSALS (03)

a. M/s Ganesh Benzoplasts Pvt. Ltd., Mumbai for construction of two storage tanks for Butane and Propane within MPT port limit area at Sada in Marmagoa of South Goa district.

b. M/s Raj Housing Development Pvt. Ltd., Ponda for construction of residential-cum-commercial projects namely –

1. ‘Ral Enclave’ in P.T. sheet No. 8 of Chalta No. 01 within Mapusa Municipal limits, Mapusa. ( Builtup area – 30,244.17 sq.mts .)

Page 37 of 72

2. ‘Raj Ryle Residency’ in P. T. sheet No. 14 of Chalta Nos. 40, 41, 42, 43, 45, 46, 47 & 48 and P. T. sheet No. 32 of Chalta Nos. 4 & 36 within Mapusa Municipal limits. ( Builtup area – 22,626.44 sq. mts .).

c. M/s Palacio Property Developers Pvt. Ltd., Panaji for proposed expansion of a residential project comprising of 17 residential buildings with amenities – playground, swimming pool in survey nos. 181/(P), 181/2, 181/3, 181/5(P), 182/7, 183/9, 180/1(P), 180/2(P), and 184/3 of St. Andre – (Near Lobo Garage), Goa Velha village in Tiswadi taluka of North Goa district.

4. COSIDERATIO OF EW PROJECT PROPOSALS (06) (based on Goa SEAC recommendations / observations during its 10 th , 11 th and 12 th meetings )

1. Construction / Residential projects

a. PROPOSED CONSTRUCTION OF RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX IN SANCOALE VILLAGE BY M/s TRINITAS DEVELOPERS INDIA PVT. LTD., PUNE.

b. PROPOSED CONSTRUCTION OF RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX IN BAMBOLIM (S. NO. 93/2) BY Mr. PASCOAL TRINDADE.

c. PROPOSED CONSTRUCTION OF RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX IN BAMBOLIM (S. NO. 93/4) BY Mr. PASCOAL TRINDADE.

d. PROPOSED GROUP HOUSING AND COMMERCIAL PROJECT SURVEY NO. 20/3 A OF BAINGUINIM VILLAGE BY Mr. RAJENDRA PRASAD SINGLA.

e. PROPOSED CONSTRUCTION OF ECO-RESORT IN SURVEY NO. 16 & 7 OF MOITEM VILLAGE IN BARDEZ TALUKA OF NORTH GOA DISTRICT BY M/s MAHINDRA AND MAHINDRA, CHENNAI.

f. PROPOSED EXPANSION OF RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT IN SURVEY NO. 103/1, 103/2 & 104/1 OF BAMBOLIM BY M/s PRIVE REALTY PVT. LTD., MUMBAI

5. ew / Renewal of Minor Minerals (road metal / laterite stones) quarrying leases

i. Renewal of one Laterite stone quarry – Lease no.13/Lat. Boulder/2007 – 35,575 sq.mts. located in Survey No. 123/1 of Lotulim village in Salcete taluka of South Goa district by Mrs. Maria Yvonne Baptista, Rai.

ii. Renewal of following three Basalt stone quarries namely – (a) Lease no. 10/basalt/93 – 10,000 sq.mts. , (b) Lease no. 03/Basalt/94 – 29,225 sq.mts. , (c) Lease no. 2/Basalt/98 – 22,000 sq.mts. and One ew Lease covering total area of 50,000 sq.mts. located in Survey No. 29/1, of village Conquerim in Sattari taluka of North Goa district by M/s Sapna Ceramics Pvt. Ltd., Margao.

Page 38 of 72

iii. Renewal of one Basalt stone quarry – Lease no. 01/Basalt/97 located in Survey No, 63/1 of village Santona in Sanguem taluka of South Goa district by Mr. Vinayak Vasudev Chodankar , Sanvordem.

iv. Renewal of following three Laterite stone quarry (including murrum / laterite rubble) – (03 leases), (a) 02/Laterite/88 – 2.6424 ha. , (b) 03/Laterite/03 – 2.35 ha. and (c) 06/Laterite/07 – 2.9886 ha. located in Survey Nos. 58/0 (2.8650 ha.), 52/1&2 (4.26 ha.) and 56/0 (3.2275 ha.) in Loutolim village in Salcete taluka of South Goa district by M/s Bomba Laterite Stones, Margao.

6. Any other matter as per the approval of the Chairman, GoaSEIAA. Accordingly, the following matter was discussed / appraised as per the communication received from the Goa Coastal Zone Management Authority (GCZMA) – 1. Revised proposal for reconstruction of the existing resort / hotel in survey nos. 340/1, 354/2, 355, 356 (Part), 356/8 and 353/5 of Anjuna village in Bardez taluka of North Goa district by M/s Diana Buildwell Ltd., Vagator.

**********

Page 39 of 72

Agenda Items for the 7 th GoaSEIAA meeting held on 15 th March 2013

1. Finalization / issuance of directions / order in the matter of a project proposal “Group housing and residential complex” by M/s Akar Creations Pvt. Ltd., Margao in survey no. 40/1 of Vanelim village in Salcete taluka of South Goa district subsequent to ‘Order’ issued by the NGT dated 22 nd February 2013 followed by Personal Hearing before the Chairman, Goa-SEIAA on 5 th March 2013.

2. Consideration of following EW projects subsequent to site inspection conducted by the Authority (02 nos.).

1. Proposed construction of residential complex in Bambolim in survey no. 93/2 by M/s Pascoal Trindade .

2. Proposed construction of residential complex in Bambolim in survey no. 93/4 by M/s Pascoal Trindade .

(The project proponent has submitted the compliance to sitespecific observations)

3. Consideration of following EW construction project proposals.

a. Proposed construction of residential complex in survey no. 117/1-A of Sancoale village by M/s Trinitas Developers (India) Pvt. Lltd., Pune.

b. Proposed Group housing and Commercial project in survey no. 20/3 of Baiguinim village by M/s Rajendra Prasad Singla, Margao .

c. Proposed construction of Eco-resort in survey no. 16 and 7 of Moitem village in Bardez taluka by M/s Mahindra and Mahindra, Chennai .

d. Proposed expansion of residential development in survey no. 103/1, 103/2 and 104/1 of Bambolim village by M/s Prive Realty Pvt. Ltd., Mumbai .

e. Proposed expansion of residential complex in chalta no. 13 & 15 of P. T. sheet no. 299 of Margao city by M/s SRE Estate Developers, Margao.

7. ew / Renewal of Minor Minerals (road metal / laterite stones) quarrying leases.

i. Renewal of two ‘Basalt stone quarries by Mr.Manual Da Coasta . 1. Lease no. 05/Basalt/89 – plot area - 5 Ha. and 2. Lease no. 04/Basalt/89 – Plot area - 4.9 Ha. Both located in Survey no. 77/1(Part) and 72/1(Part) respectively of Santonal village in Sanguem taluka of South Goa district.

ii. Renewal of one ‘Basalt stone quarry’ ( Lease no., 09/Basalt/90 – 5,200 sq.mts. ) located in Survey No. 272(P) of village Casarvarnem in Pernem taluka of North Goa district by M/s Halarnkar Industries, Mapusa.

iii. Renewal of one ‘Basalt stone quarry’( Lease no.05/Basalt/06 – 4,800 sq.mts. ) located in Survey No. 86/0 of Kotambi village in Quepem taluka of South Goa district by Mrs. Anila Rege, Margao.

Page 40 of 72

iv. Renewal of one ‘Basalt stone quarry’ ( Lease no., 06/Basalt/03 – 12,075 sq.mts. ) located in Survey No. 47/1 and 47/2, of village Alorna in Pernem taluka of North Goa district by M/s Halarnkar Industries, Mapusa.

v. ew ‘Basalt stone quarry’ ( plot area – 5,000 sq.mts ) located in Survey No, 62/1 of village Cordem in Quepem taluka of South Goa district by Mr. Chandrashekhar G. Dessai, Canacona.

vi. ew ‘Laterite stone / rubble quarry’ ( plot area – 4 Ha. ) located in Survey No. 15/2 of Costi village in Sanguem taluka of South Goa district by Dr. Damodar T. Gaonkar, Sanguem.

vii. Renewal of one ‘Basalt stone quarry’ ( lease no. 05/Basalt/03 – 3.30 Ha .) located in Survey No. 70/1 of Santona village in Sanguem taluka of South Goa district by Smt. Maria Alda Pinto, Sanguem .

viii. ew ‘Laterite stone quarry’ ( plot area – 7,180 sq.mts. ) located in Survey No. 42/0 of Muguli village in Sanguem taluka of South Goa district by Shri. Rumaldo Fernandes, Sanguem.

ix. ew ‘Laterite rubble stone quarry’ ( plot area –15,000 sq.mts. ) located in Survey No. 38 of Codar village in Ponda taluka of North Goa district by Shri. Shriram V. Gaonkar, Margao.

x. Renewal of following two ‘Basalt stone quarries’ by Mr. R.B.S. Khandeparkar –

1. Lease no. 03/Basalt/93 ( Plot area – 2.32 Ha .) located in Survey no. 6/2(P) of Piliem village in Dharbandora taluka of South Goa district.

2. Lease no. 04/Basalt/93 ( Plot area – 3.42 Ha .) located in Survey no. 11/1(P) of Piliem village in Dharbandora taluka of South Goa district. ( This lease does not have a valid explosive magazine )

xi. ew ‘Laterite rubble quarry’ ( plot area –20,000 sq.mts. ) located in Survey No. 150 (Part-B) of Verna village in Salcete taluka of South Goa district by Mr. Jaiwas aik, Sancoale.

8. Appraisal of project proposals forwarded by GCZMA as per ew Hotel Policy

A. Construction of ‘Beach Resort’ in Survey No. 156/2 and 156/3-A of Calangute village, Bardez taluka by Mr. Edfar Afonso, Calangute .

B. Construction of ‘Hotel Villas’ in Survey No. 53/1 of Chicalim village in Mormugao taluka of South Goa district by Mr. Mario J. A. Alvares – P.O.A holder Mr. Gustavo De Souza.

C. Construction of Beach Resort in Survey No. 138/1-D (Part) and 138/1-E-1 of Varca village in Salcete taluka, South Goa district by M/s Total Composites Pvt. Ltd., C/o Goa Glass Fibre Ltd., Colvale.

D. Construction of beach resort in Survey No. 207/1, 207/2 and 208/3 of Calangute village in Bardez taluka, North Goa district by Mr. Domnic Alleluia De Souza , R/o Chalstan Beach Resort, Baga.

E. Construction of beach hotel in Survey No. 209/9, 10 of Anjuna village in Bardez taluka, North Goa district by M/s Good Value Hotel and Resorts Pvt. Ltd., Anjuna .

Page 41 of 72

F. Construction of Beach Resort / Hotel in Survey No. 98/1 of Betalbatim village in Salcete taluka by M/s Best Location Properties Pvt. Ltd .

G. Construction of Arun resort (68 rooms) in Survey No. 63/3 of Chicalim village, Mormugao taluka in South Goa district by Mr. Arun aik .

H. Construction of Beach Resort / Hotel in Survey No. 221/1-B of Mandrem village of Pernem taluka by M/s Asvem Beach Resort and Villas Pvt. Ltd .

9. Any other matter as per the approval of the Chairman, GoaSEIAA.

######

Page 42 of 72

Salient features of the EW Project Proposals for appraisal during the SEVETH GoaSEIAA meeting

1. ew project proposals seeking prior EC as mandated under the EIA otification, 2006

A. PROPOSED CONSTRUCTION OF RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX IN SANCOALE VILLAGE BY M/s TRINITAS DEVELOPERS INDIA PVT. LTD., PUNE

Sr. Project Proponent (PP) / Proposed Activity Sitespecific Project details / specification / salient features Remarks o. Applicant location details

1 M/s Trinitas Developers Proposed Survey no. 117/1-A Total plot area – 8,000 sq. mt. Pvt. Ltd., Residential project of Sancoale village Deduction for road widening – 213 sq.mts. GoaSEAC has Level-VIII, Muttha (NEW) of Mormugao taluka Effective plot area – 7,787 sq. mts. appraised the project Chambers, - II, Senapati in South Goa district. Open space proposed – 1,170 sq. mts. in its tenth meeting Bapat Marg, Pune – 411 Total no. of flats – Proposed built-up area – 29,358 sq.mts. held on 11 th December 016 160 2012 and subsequently Total proposed covered area – 3,071.14 sq. mts. (max. 40%) conducted the site Ph. 020 - 40050000 Category 8 (a) – B Permissible FAR – 200 % inspection on 22 nd Fax. – 020 - 40050011 Construction Floor area permissible – 16,000 sq.mts. January 2013. e-mail – projects Mr. Samir Muttha, Expected total occupancy – 720 persons Parking proposed – 188 ECS Accordingly and based Director on clarification sought Geo-technical soil investigation has been proposed. carried out to understand the to observations made foundation characteristics through M/s Safe Cores and Tests, Mumbai in June 2006 during the meeting as Environmental – by analyzing four (04) bore holes ranging in depth from 24 – 28 mts. well as siteinspection Consultants M/s Groundwater has been uniformly encountered at a depth of 1.5 mts. Chemical SEAC has Aditya Environmental analysis of water indicate that it is aggressive to ‘concrete’ and corrosive to recommended the Services, Mumbai ‘reinforcement steel’. project for issuance of Prior EC . Water requirement – a. During Construction phase – 20 m 3/day. (i.e. 18 m 3/d for construction and 2 m3/d for domestic usage): to be sourced from private tankers / PWD.

b. During operational phase – 109.65 m 3/d (i.e. 66.6 m 3/d-PWD and 43.05 m3/d-recycled water)

Wastewater generated – 84.24 m 3/d to be treated in 92.66 cmd Sewage Treatment

Page 43 of 72

Plant (STP) with Moving Bed Bio-Reactor (MBBR) technology. It is proposed that recycled water will be used for flushing, car washing / gardening.

Solid waste generated - a. 1-2 MT/day (construction phase) – to be used for land-filling within the plot.

b. 306 kgs./day (operational phase) biodegradable waste to be treated through in-house mechanical composting using Organic Waste Convertor (OWC).

Power requirement. – a. Construction phase – 20 HP Diesel generator. b. Operation phase – 2,673.72 KVA, to be sourced from Goa State Electricity Board.

Back-up power through 02 DG sets of 160 KVA capacity each. (@ 65% load factor)

Energy consumption assumed – 6.73 W per sq.ft. of built-up area.

EMP has been prepared.

Page 44 of 72

B. PROPOSED CONSTRUCTION OF RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX IN BAMBOLIM (S. NO. 93/2) BY MR. PASCOAL TRINDADE

Sr. Project Proponent (PP) / Proposed Activity Sitespecific Project details / specification / salient features Remarks o. Applicant location details

2 Mr. Pascoal Trindade, Proposed Residential Survey no. 93/2 of Total plot area – 35,600 sq. mt. Palbrica Mansion, project (NEW) Bambolim village Area under No Development Zone – 600 sq.mts. GoaSEAC has appraised Near White House, in Tiswadi taluka of Area under road widening – 120 sq.mts. the project in its tenth Donapaula, Goa 111 units (G + 4) North Goa district. Effective plot area – 34,880 sq. mts. meeting held on 11 th including 72 flats Open space proposed – 5,245 sq. mts. December 2012 and and Proposed covered area – 9,219.32 sq.mts. subsequently conducted the paramount.buildwell@redif 39 villas. Proposed built-up area – 26,313.69 sq.mts. siteinspection on 22 nd fmail.com Proposed area for green-belt – 10,000 sq.mts. January 2013. Category 8 (a) – B Tel no. 0832-2453369 / 70 Construction projects Expected total occupancy – 850 persons Parking proposed – 217 ECS Subsequently, GoaSEIAA Fax no. 0832-2451504 during its sixth meeting Geo-technical soil investigation has been proposed. held on 7 th February 2013 Environmental Water requirement – has decided to conduct site Consultants a. During Construction phase – 55 m3/day to be sourced from private inspection. Subsequently, tankers. proponent has submitted M/s Sadekar Enviro the compliance to site Engineers Pvt. Ltd., b. During operational phase – 125 m 3/d (i.e. 75 m 3/d-PWD and 50 m 3/d- specific observations Panaji recycled water from STP) conducted on 25 th February 2013. c. One time water demand for firefighting – 200 m 3.

PP has proposed to construct underground water storage tanks (50 m 3 capacity for every building.

Wastewater generated – 100 m 3/d to be treated in 120 CMD Sewage Treatment Plant (STP) with Moving Bed Bio-Reactor (MBBR) technology. 80 kgs./month of sludge generated is to be used as manure. It is proposed that recycled water will be used for flushing, car washing / gardening.

Solid waste generated - a. 50 kgs./day of domestic waste to be disposed-off through local

Page 45 of 72

authorities and 200 kgs./day of debris generated during construction phase to be used for land-filling within the plot. Hazardous waste generated (i.e. used oil from D.G. sets (20 kgs./m during construction and 10 kgs./m during operation) will be suitably disposed-off.

b. 425 kgs./day (operational phase) biodegradable waste (255 kgs./d) to be treated through in-house mechanical composting. While, non- biodegradable waste (170 kgs./d) to be disposed through authorized recycler.

Power requirement. – a. Construction phase – 100 KVA to be sourced from GSEB / Diesel generator. b. Operation phase – 800 KVA, to be sourced from Goa State Electricity Board.

Back-up power through 01 DG sets of 65 KVA capacity.

EMP has been prepared.

Page 46 of 72

C. PROPOSED CONSTRUCTION OF RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX IN BAMBOLIM (S. NO. 93/4) BY MR. PASCOAL TRINDADE

Sr. Project Proponent (PP) / Applicant Proposed Activity Sitespecific Project details / specification / salient features Remarks o. location details 3 Mr. Pascoal Trindade, Proposed Residential Survey no. 93/4 Total plot area – 35,075 sq. mt. GoaSEAC has appraised Palbrica Mansion, project (NEW) of Bambolim Open space (including garden / playground) proposed – 26,961.46 the project in its tenth Near White House, village (Curca sq. mts. meeting held on 11 th Donapaula, Goa (Stilt + 4) village Total proposed built-up area – 25,918.85 sq.mts. December 2012 and Panchayat) in Proposed area for green-belt – 9,000 sq.mts. subsequently conducted the e-mail – 103 flats (3-BHK – Tiswadi taluka of siteinspection on 22 nd [email protected] 31, 2-BHK – 72) North Goa Expected total occupancy – 783 persons Parking proposed – 197 January 2013. [email protected] district. ECS. Category 8 (a) – B Tel no. 0832-2453369 / 70 Construction projects Geo-technical soil investigation has been proposed. Subsequently, GoaSEIAA Fax no. 0832-2451504 during its sixth meeting Water requirement – held on 7 th February 2013 Environmental Consultant – a. During Construction phase – 50 m3/day to be sourced from has decided to conduct site private tankers. inspection. Subsequently, M/s Sadekar Enviro Engineers Pvt. proponent has submitted Ltd., Panaji b. During operational phase – 120 m 3/d (i.e. 75 m 3/d-PWD the compliance to site and 45 m 3/d-recycled water from STP). specific observations conducted on 25 th February c. One time water demand for firefighting – 100m 3. 2013.

d. One time water demand for swimming pool – 100m 3.

PP has proposed to construct underground water storage tanks of 50 m3 capacity.

Wastewater generated – 95m 3/d to be treated in 100CMD Sewage Treatment Plant (STP) with Moving Bed Bio-Reactor (MBBR) technology. 80 kgs./month of sludge generated is to be used as manure. It is proposed that recycled water (about 85 CMD) will be used for toilet flushing ( 45 CMD ) through dual plumbing system and irrigation in garden – 40 CMD (i.e. green-area maintenance)

Page 47 of 72

Solid waste generated - a. 50 kgs./day of domestic waste to be disposed-off through local authorities and kgs./day of debris generated during construction phase to be used for land-filling within the plot. Hazardous waste generated (i.e. used oil from D.G. sets (20 kgs./m during construction and 10 kgs./m during operation) will be suitably disposed-off.

b. 400 kgs./day (operational phase) biodegradable waste (240 kgs./d) to be treated through in-house mechanical composting. While, non-biodegradable waste (160 kgs./d) to be disposed through authorized recycler.

Power requirement. – a. Construction phase – 100 KVA to be sourced from GSEB / Diesel generator.

b. Operation phase – 800 KVA, to be sourced from Goa State Electricity Board. Back-up power through 01 DG set of 65 KVA capacity.

EMP has been prepared.

Page 48 of 72

D. PROPOSED GROUP HOUSING AND COMMERCIAL PROJECT SURVEY NO. 20/3 A OF BAINGUINIM VILLAGE BY MR. RAJENDRA PRASAD SINGLA

Sr. Project Proponent (PP) / Proposed Sitespecific Project details / specification / salient features Remarks o. Applicant Activity location details

4 M/s Rajendra Prasad Singla, Proposed Group Survey no. Total plot area – 32,893 sq. mt. GoaSEAC has House No. 235/1, Housing and 20/3-A of Effective plot area – 27,966 sq. mts. appraised the Karle Properties, Commercial Bainguinim Permissible F.A.R. – 26,314.40 sq.mts. project in its Pulwada, Margao-Benaulim project village of Proposed F.A.R. – 26,306.34 sq.mts. eleventh Road, including Tiswadi taluka Proposed built-up area – 44,604.70 sq.mts. meeting held on Margao, Goa. in North Goa 11 th January 400 flats and 52 district. Ground coverage – 9,233.22 sq.mts. 2013 and Environmental Consultant commercial Greenbelt development – 4,822 sq.mts. (17.24% of effective plot area) subsequently Mr. Sunil Dixit, shops of 609 conducted the M/s J. M. Enviroet (P) sq.mts. each. Expected total occupancy – 2,796 persons (residential – 1,735 and floating – 1,061) siteinspection Ltd., (NEW) Parking proposed – 478 ECS on 22 nd January 1st and 2 nd Floor, S. C. O. 16, 2013 and has Sector – 10A, Category 8 (a) Geo-technical soil investigation has been proposed and has been submitted. accordingly Gurgaon – 122 001 – B recommended e-mail : Construction Water requirement – the project for [email protected] projects a. During Construction phase – 25KLD to be sourced from private tankers. issuance of [email protected] Prior EC. b. During operational phase – 318 KLD (i.e. 195 KLD from PWD and 123 KLD from STP- Correspondence address – recycled) C/o Avinash Borkar, Akar Creations Pvt. Ltd., 2 nd Wastewater generated – 248 KLD to be treated in Sewage Treatment Plant (300 KLD STP) with Floor, Lake Plaza, Fatorda, Moving Bed Bio-Reactor (MBBR) technology upto tertiary level which will generate 223 KLD Margao, Goa. – 403 602 of treated water. Out of this 113 KLD to be used in green area development (15 KLD), toilet flushing (100 KLD) and car washings (8 KLD) and the rest will be drained into the municipal [email protected] , sewerage line. As such. Dual plumbing system is proposed. [email protected] Solid waste generated - Ph. 2743680 / 2743684 a. 1,450 kgs./day (operational phase) – proposed to be segregated at source into wet and Fax. 2743686 dry garbage.

Page 49 of 72

Power requirement. – a. Construction phase – 20 kw. In addition, back-up power through one (01) DG set of 60KVA capacity.

b. Operation phase – 2,060 kw to be sourced from Goa State Electricity Board. In addition, back-up power through 23 DG sets of 30KVA capacity each, totaling to 690 KVA.

Page 50 of 72

E. PROPOSED CONSTRUCTION OF ECO-RESORT IN SURVEY NO. 16 & 7 OF MOITEM VILLAGE IN BARDEZ TALUKA OF NORTH GOA DISTRICT BY M/S MAHINDRA AND MAHINDRA, CHENNAI

Sr. Project Proponent (PP) / Applicant Proposed Activity Sitespecific Project details / specification / salient features Remarks o. location details

5 M/s Mahindra & Mahindra Ltd., Proposed Survey nos. 16 & Total plot area – 45,853 sq. mt. GoaSEAC has Mahindra Towers, construction of Eco- 7 of Moitem Area for road-widening – 1,629.64. sq.mts. appraised the 17/18, Pattulos Road, resort village in Bardez Effective plot area – 44,223.36 sq. mts. project in its Chennai – 600 002 (1 restaurant – 572 taluka of North Permissible F.A.R. (50%) – 23,741.32 sq.mts. eleventh meeting seats and 16 Goa district. Proposed built-up area – 29,059.10 sq.mts. held on 11 th January Mr. S. V. Balram, building clusters Open space required – 6,877.80 sq.mts. 2013 and r/o H. No. 79, Nagwado, (i.e. G + 2 ) with Open space proposed – 9,546.80 sq.mts. subsequently Betalbatim, Salcete, Goa – 403 713 200 rooms) (NEW) conducted the site Parking proposed – 100 ECS inspection on 24 th Ph. 0832-2880756 / 9822101871 Category 8(a) – B January 2013 and e-mail – [email protected] Construction Geo-technical soil investigation has been prepared through 04 bore hole has accordingly has projects drillings upto the depth of 6 mts. Accordingly, isolated footing / recommended the foundations (as per IS 1904-1986) at a depth of 1.2 mts. from ground level project for issuance is proposed with allowable bearing pressure of 20t/m 2. of Prior EC .

Environmental Consultant As the plot / land is a sloppy area, embankment wall of 525 mts. is M/s Aditya Environmental Services proposed. Pvt. Ltd., Ms. Poonam More - 9422739540 Water requirement – a. During Construction phase – 20 cmd (2 cmd for domestic purpose and 18 cmd for construction activity) to be sourced from private tankers as well as proposed open well.

b. During operational phase – 105 cmd (i.e. 27 cmd for domestic use to be sourced from PWD + open well and 78 cmd (i.e. for flushing, gardening and cooling) to be sourced from STP- recycled). As such. Dual plumbing system is proposed.

Wastewater generated – 83 cmd to be treated in Sewage Treatment Plant with Moving Bed Bio-Reactor (MBBR) technology upto tertiary level

Page 51 of 72

which will generate 78 cmd of treated water. Out of this, 47 cmd for landscaping, 13 cmd for cooling purposes and 13 cmd for flushing

Solid waste generated - a. Debris of about 1 – 2 MT/day (construction phase) – to be used for land-filling within the plot.

b. 175 kgs./day (operational phase) – proposed to be segregated at source into wet and dry garbage. Wet waste to be composted on- site.

Power requirement. – a. Construction phase – 125 KVA.

b. Operation phase – 2.5 HP. In addition, back-up power through 02 DG sets of 750 KVA capacity each, totaling to 1,500 KVA.

EMP has been prepared.

Page 52 of 72

F. PROPOSED EXPANSION OF RESIDENTIAL DEVELOPMENT IN SURVEY NO. 103/1, 103/2 & 104/1 OF BAMBOLIM BY M/S PRIVE REALTY PVT. LTD., MUMBAI

Sr. Project Proponent (PP) / Proposed Activity Sitespecific Project details / specification / salient features Remarks o. Applicant location details

6 M/s Prive Reality Pvt. Ltd., Proposed Survey no. 103/1, Total plot area –76,675 sq. mt. GoaSEAC has appraised 302, Aircondition Market, construction of 103/2 and 104/1 of Area under Orchard-zone non-development – 29,675 sq.mts. the project in its Twelfth Tardeo, Mumbai residential complex Bambolim village in Area under settlement zone (i.e. effective plot area) – 47,000 sq.mts. meeting held 30 th January (NEW) including Tiswadi taluka of Open space required – 7,050 sq.mts. 2013. Subsequently, SEAC Fax. 0832-4437787 North Goa district.. Open space provided – 7,090 sq.mts. has conducted site 16 building blocks Permissible covered area – 18,800 sq.mts. inspection on 14 th February (2BKH flats – 128 Approved covered area – 2,307 sq.mts. 2013 and has sought Mr. Rajan Bhavnani, nos.) Total covered area – 15,687.61 sq.mts. clarification to sitespecific 9820057615 23 Villas of Type- Proposed FAR – 22,143.83 sq.mts. (as per RP-2021) observation. The PP has 1, Approved FAR – 6,040.95 sq.mts. complied with the same and e-mail: 02 Villas of Type- Total F.A.R. – 28,184 sq.mts. has accordingly has [email protected] 2, Proposed Built-Up-Area – 33,837.2 sq.mts. recommended the project 06 Shops and Approved Built-Up-Area – 9,766.98 sq.mts. for issuance of Prior EC. [email protected] 01 Clubhouse Proposed gross built-up area – 43,604.18 sq.mts. [email protected] Expected total occupancy – 689 users @ 4.5 persons per flat Category 8 (a) – B Parking proposed – 196 ECS Construction projects Geo-technical soil investigation has been proposed and has been submitted.

Water requirement – a. During Construction phase – 20 CMD to be sourced from proposed open well.

b. During operational phase – 142 CMD (i.e. 66 CMD from PWD and 76 CMD from STP-recycled)

Wastewater generated – 81 CMD of wastewater to be treated in Sewage Treatment Plant of 85 CMD capacity having Moving Bed Bio-Reactor

Page 53 of 72

(MBBR) technology which will generate 76 CMD of treated water. Out of this, 31 CMD for flushing, 35 CMD for gardening, 5 CMD for car washings and 5 CMD for irrigation purposes. As such, dual plumbing system is proposed.

10 kgs. of sludge per day will be generated which is proposed be dewatered, dried and mixed with compost for gardening.

Solid waste generated - a. 1-2 MT per day of construction debris to be used for land-filling within the plot.

b. 295 kgs./day (operational phase) – proposed to be segregated at source into wet and dry garbage.

Power requirement. – a. Construction phase – 2 HP

b. Operation phase – 3,050 KW to be sourced from Goa State Electricity Board. In addition, back-up power through 02 DG sets of 160 KVA capacity each, totaling to 320 KVA.

Energy consumption assumed – 6.73 W per sq.ft. of Built-Up Area (BUA)

EMP has been prepared.

Page 54 of 72

G. PROPOSED EXPANSION OF RESIDENTIAL COMPL IN CHALTA NO. 13 & 15 ANDP.T. SH NO. 299 OF NAVELIM IN MARGAO CITY BY M/S SRE ESTATES DEVELOPERS, MARGAO

Sr. Project Proponent (PP) / Proposed Activity Sitespecific Project details / specification / salient features Remarks o. Applicant location details

7 M/s SRE Estates Developers, Proposed expansion Chalta no. 13 & 15 Total plot area – 8,566 sq. mt. Supreme, Behind New of residential of Petitate Sheet No. Approved Built-up area – 6,958.15 sq.mts. 1. It is understood that the existing structure is Telephone Exchange, complex (G + 8 299 of Margao city Proposed built-up area – 22,386.21 sq.mts. proposed to be demolished and proposed Opposite Bombi House, floors) “Supreme in Salcete taluka of Gross built-up area – 29,344.36 sq.mts. development is an expansion. Total builtup Comba, Margao – 403 601 Colmorod Central” South Goa district. Permissible F.A.R. – 16,932 sq.mts. area of these existing structures is 407.26 (Post Box. No. 778) that includes – (i.e. Navelim) FAR consumed – 16,904 sq.mts. sq.mts . Open space required – 1,284.90 sq.mts. Ph. 0832-2736418 / 19 01 –Studios (i.e. Margao Open space provided – 1,580 sq.mts. 2. The proposed development falls under Fax. 0832-2735976 06 – 1 BHK Municipal Limits) Margao Municipal Council (MMC). Since the e-mail – [email protected] 124 – 2 BHK Expected total occupancy – 702 persons area falls under C1 (commercial) zone, the 25 – 3 BHK Ph. 0832-2714448 maximum height permissible is 24 mts. as per Mr. Yogesh Naik – Partner, (total 156 flats ) Parking proposed – 185 ECS TCP laws. Ph. 0832-2736418 Fax. 0832-2735976 Category 8 (a) – B Geo-technical soil investigation (through three bore- 3. South Goa Planning and Development Authority e-mail – Construction holes (SGPDA) has issued development permission in [email protected] projects drilled upto 10mts.) has been prepared and submitted February 2012. M - 9822100532 with Received on 23 rd the proposal ( conducted by M/s Surbhi Enterprises – 4. During construction phase, water requirement Environmental consultant – January 2013 a Geotek Consortium, Mahim, Mumbai .). Accordingly, will be met through proposed open well. As M/s Aditya Environmental Groundwater table is encountered at a depth ranging such, may like to specify site-specific details Consultancy, Mumbai from 1.7 mts. to 2 mts. As such, Raft foundation has superimposed on a contour map. It is been proposed with allowable bearing pressure recommended that water requirement during Ms. Poonam Moye of 15 t/m 2 that may result with maximum settlement construction phase should not be sourced from less than 65 mm. open well. PP need to make alternate arrangement for the same. However, on Water requirement – operationalization, the PP should mandatorily a. During Construction phase – 20CMD ( 2CMD adapt rainwater harvesting (RWH) for effective for recharging of open well. – PP has domestic use and 18CMD for construction communicated that proposed construction of purpose ) underground tanks of 200 cu.m. capacity and

Page 55 of 72

to be sourced from private tankers and proposed septic tanks will be designed by a RCC open well. consultant by providing proper upward thrust considering occurrence of groundwater at b. During operational phase – 139CMD (i.e. relatively shallow depth . 63CMD from PWD and 76CMD from STP-recycled) 5. PP may like to clarify w.r.t. digging of any bore- well(s) and accordingly, may specify modus Wastewater generated – 81CMD of wastewater to be operandi for its effective recharge either through treated roof-top or watershed approach as RWH in Sewage Treatment Plant of 85CMD capacity having initiatives. – Complied. Moving Bed Bio-Reactor (MBBR) technology which will 6. Total capital cost of EMP is Rs. 75 lakhs and generate 76CMD of treated water. Out of this, 32CMD expected operation and maintenance cost is for flushing, 08CMD for gardening, 05CMD for car Rs. 9 lakhs. It is proposed to – washings. 31 CMD of the balanced STP treated water is proposed to be provided to existing bungalows a. Capital cost for environmental / buildings for the purpose of gardening . T infrastructure to be borne by Developer he PP has proposed dual plumbing system. b. Infrastructure to be operated and 10kgs. of sludge per day will be generated which is maintained by Developer till formation of proposed be dewatered, dried and mixed with compost Society and Conveyance. for gardening. c. Corpus fund to be created for Solid waste generated - maintenance of Environmental 1. During construction phase about 1-2 MT /day of Infrastructure @ Rs. 50,000/ per flat. debris is estimated to be generated. GoaSEAC has considered the proposal for 2. During operational phase, about 298 kgs./day is recommendation. estimated to be generated which will be segregated at source into wet and dry garbage. Biodegradable waste ( 50% of the total waste ) is proposed to be treated on Organic Waste Convertor (OWC). Space of 200 sq.mts. has been proposed as per the plan for segregation of the non biodegradable waste and segregated waste is proposed to be disposedoff through scrap

Page 56 of 72

dealer for recycling.

Power requirement. – a. Construction phase – 2.5 HP

b. Operation phase – 2,124 KVA to be sourced from Goa State Electricity Board. In addition, back-up power through 01 DG sets of 625 KVA capacity.

Page 57 of 72

10. As per the “Goa Mineral Concession (Amendment) Rules, 2012” notified by the Directorate of Mines and Geology (DMG) and published in Official Gazette Series 1 No. 24 dated 17 th September 2012, following proposals seeking prior EC for New / Renewal of Quarrying Lease has been received for suitable appraisal / consideration.

Sr. Project Proponent (PP) / Proposed Activity Sitespecific location Project details / specification Status update subsequent to site inspection of the o. Applicant details / salient features proposed site followed by discussions / deliberations Environmental Consultant during the 13 th SEAC meeting convened on 7 th March 2013 and as well as compliance by the proponent, till date The proposal was appraised during the Twelfth Goa-SEAC 1 M/s Halarnkar Industries, Basalt stone quarry Survey no. 272 (P) of Total project area – 5,200 meeting held on 30 th January 2013. Accordingly, the Tivim Industrial Estate, Casarvarnem village in sq.mts. Committee has deferred the decision pending compliance / Karaswada Industrial Estate, REEW Pernem taluka of Total quantity – 60 m 3 per day submission to - Bardez, Goa. North Goa district. Lease no. 09/Basalt/90 1. Ascertaining on-site demarcation and construction of Mr. Meghashyam Halarnkar (Lease validity has expired in lease boundary with poles / bio-fencing / barbed wire for 9421242947 2012 ) the proposed leased area in question. th Site inspected on 14 EMP prepared by Air consent is valid upto 26 th February 2013 2. Construction of approach road / proper access from Mr. Pradip Sarmokadam, February 2013 village road to enable transportation from site to desired Director, destination. M/s Lila Digital and Environmental Solutions Pvt Category 1(a) – B 3. Proposed plan of action / modus operandi for extraction Ltd., of stones within the available boundary limits of the 1st Floor, Rani Pramila Arcade, 9th January 2013 proposed lease extent so as to comply with the 18 th June Road, Panaji. provisions of the Mines and Safety Rules / Guidelines, 2426250 / 2222496 / 6653250 as applicable.

4. It was observed that proposed lease area cut-across the natural seasonal stream at its upstream boundary thereby bifurcating the lease area and disturbing the natural flow of water to its downstream, especially during monsoon. Accordingly, the proponent has proposed to diver the water channel along the lease boundary. A such, proponent may like to clarify probable environmental concerns arising due to such a diversion of natural flow across the stream against the gradient, if any

Page 58 of 72

Sr. Project Proponent (PP) / Proposed Activity Sitespecific location Project details / specification / Status update subsequent to site o. Applicant details salient features inspection of the proposed site followed Environmental Consultant by discussions / deliberations during the 13 th SEAC meeting convened on 7 th March 2013 and as well as compliance by the proponent, till date

1 Mr. Manuel Da Costa, Basalt stone quarry – RENEW Survey No. 71/1 (Part) Total lease area – 5 ha. SO – 12A Block, Lease No. 05/Basalt/89 (5 ha.) and 77/1 (Part) of Baboy Commerce Center, (valid upto July 2014) Santona village of Production capacity – 48,000 m3 per Margao, Goa. Sanguem taluka of annum (i.e. 4,000 m 3 per month) Ph. 2736397 / 2732434 Water Consent – valid upto South Goa district. Fax. 2731893 December 2014 Total geological resource – 9,27,850 3 www.mdcgroup.in m Air Consent valid upto – December th 3 Mr. Suresh Kandolkar, 2014 Site inspected on 8 Total mineable resource – 2,64,350 m 9822980608 February 2013 [email protected] Category 1(a) – B The proposal was appraised during the Twelfth Goa-SEAC meeting held on 30 th st 21 December 2012 January 2013.

2 Mr. Manuel Da Costa, Basalt stone quarry – RENEW Survey No. 71/1 (Part) Total lease area – 4.9 ha. 3 GoaSEAC has considered the proposal SO – 12A Block, Lease No. 04/Basalt/89 (4.9 ha.) of Santona village of Production capacity – 48,000 m per for recommendation. Baboy Commerce Center, (valid upto July 2014) Sanguem taluka of annum (i.e. 4,000 m 3 per month) Margao, Goa. South Goa district. Total geological resource – 13,567,800 Ph. 2736397 / 2732434 Water Consent – valid upto m3 Fax. 2731893 December 2014 Total mineable resource – 3,24,050 m 3 www.mdcgroup.in th Air Consent valid upto – December Site inspected on 8 Mr. Suresh Kandolkar, 2014 February 2013 9822980608 [email protected] Category 1(a) – B

21 st December 2012

Page 59 of 72

Sr. Project Proponent (PP) / Applicant Proposed Activity Sitespecific Project details / Status update subsequent to o. Environmental Consultant location details specification / salient site inspection of the features proposed site followed by discussions / deliberations during the 13 th SEAC meeting convened on 7 th March 2013 and as well as compliance by the proponent, till date

1 Mrs. Anila Rege, Basal stone quarry – 05/Basalt/06 ( Lease expired in Survey no. 86/0 of Total plot area – 4,800 Flat No. 6-3-B, Aquem, Alto, September 2011 ) Kotambi village in sq.mts. Margao, Goa. and seeking renewal from 29 th September 2011 for Quepem taluka of Total capacity – 1,800 PP and Consultant have been Ph. 0832 – 2663160 a period of five years (05 yrs.) South Goa district. m3 per year (18 m 3 per directed by the SEAC to submit the Mobile – 08805366042 day) proposed quarrying plan as well as EMP has been prepared by Category1(a) – B Total mineral reserve is EMP prior to consider the proposal M/s Sinha Mining Consultancy, Application received on 21 st January 2013 estimated to be about further. Mr. P. V. Hegde, 95,000 m 3. Reg. no. RQP/Goa/162/2003/A (IBM) REEWAL GoaSEAC has deferred the e-mail – [email protected] REEWAL proposal until GoaSEAC has inspected the site on 26 th submission of details. Mr. Sinha – 9822067769 / 9405923043 February 2013.

2 M/s Halarnkar Industries, Basalt stone quarry – Lease no. 06/Basalt/03 Survey no. 47/1 and Total project area – The PP has been directed by the Tivim Industrial Estate, (valid upto 7 th September 2013) 47/2 of Alorna 12,075 sq.mts. SEAC to submit the projectspecific Karaswada Industrial Estate, village in Pernem Total quantity – 60 compliance for further Bardez, Goa. Air consent is valid upto 26 th February 2013 taluka of North Goa m3 per day consideration. Ph. 0832-2257304 district. Category 1(a) – B GoaSEAC has reserved the decision Mr. Meghashyam Halarnkar - 9421242947 for REEWAL of the proposal EMP prepared by 29 th January 2013 pending clarification. Mr. Pradip Sarmokadam, Director, M/s Lila Digital and Environmental REEWAL Solutions Pvt Ltd.,

Page 60 of 72

1st Floor, Rani Pramila Arcade, GoaSEAC has inspected the site on 28 th 18 th June Road, Panaji. February 2013. 2426250 / 2222496 / 6653250

3 M/r Chandrashekhar Govind Dessai, Basalt stone quarry Survey no. 62/1 in Total project area – 5,000 Committee has decided to keep its House No. 166/J, Ghaneshem, Cordem village of sq.mts. decision reserved, pending Gaodongrem, Canacona. EW LEASE Quepem taluka of Total quantity – 18 m 3 per submission of projectspecific South Goa district. day - 4,200 m 3 per annum. compliance with specific reference to M - 9923397535 Category 1(a) – B Expected life of a quarry – proposed onsite quarrying plan as Toposheet – 48 I/3 05 years well as Environment Management Environment Management Plan (EMP) 24 th January 2013 Plan (EMP). prepared by - Mr. P. V. Hegde GoaSEAC has inspected the site on GoaSEAC has deferred the 9822067769 26 th February 2013. decision.

M/s Sinha Mining Consultant, e-mail – [email protected] 9822067769 / 9405923043

4 M/s Dr. Damodar T. Gaunker , Laterite stone quarry Survey no. 15/2 of Total project area – 4 The PP has clarified the House No. 5, Costi village of ha. projectspecific observations. Costi, Kalay, Sanguem. EW LEASE Sanguem taluka of Quantity to be South Goa district. extracted per year – M – 9011000207 / 9011000254 Category 1(a) – B 1,500 m 3. Ph. 0832-2601234 GoaSEAC has considered the 1st February 2013 proposal for recommendation. e-mail – [email protected] GoaSEAC has inspected the site on 27 th February 2013.

Page 61 of 72

5 Smt,. Maria Alda Pinto , Basalt stone quarry Survey no. 70/1 of Santona Existing lease area – The PP has clarified the And Shri. Dementro V. Fernandes, village in Sanguem taluka 3.360 Ha. projectspecific H. No. 516, Periudak, Santona, REEWAL of South Goa district. Rated capacity – observations. Sanguem, Goa. 4,500 m 3 per Quarry lease no. 05/Basalt/03 (Lease valid upto 30 th Total geological resource – month - 54,000 m 3 M – 9049775024 April 2013) 9,23,900 m 3 per annum e-mail – [email protected] GoaSEAC has considered Rapid EIA / EMP has been prepared Air consent is valid upto 11 th March 2013 only for Total Mineable resource – Existing capacity – the proposal for 3 by Joshi-Upadhye Associates extraction capacity of 180 m 3 per month. 4,13,600 m 180 m 3 per month – recommendation. 2,160 m 3 per annum. Explosive license is valid upto 31 st March 2005. Site was inspected by th GoaSEAC on 8 Feb. Expected life of a Category 1(a) – B 2013. quarry – 8 years

5th February 2013

6 Shri. Rumaldo Fernandes, Laterite stones Survey no. 42/0 of Existing lease are a- 7,180 sq.mts. GoaSEAC has kept its decision H. No. 11, Behind Sasnguem Muguli village in Rated capacity of extraction – 800 stones / reserved pending clarification to Church, EW Sanguem taluka of day sitespecific observations and re Sanguem, Goa – 403 704 South Goa district. - 6,250 m 3 per annum / 700 m 3 per inspection, if any. Category 1(a) – B month M – 9823264577 Proposed land is 8th February 2013 owned by the Total excavation during the life-span of a Consultant – M/s Kurade and proponent. quarry - 25,000 m 3 (i.e. 6.15 crores GoaSEAC has deferred the Associates, Cuncolim. GoaSEAC has inspected the site on stones) decision pending compliance and 27 th February 2013. reinspection. Expected life of a quarry – 15-20 years

Page 62 of 72

7 Shri. Shriram V. Gaonkar, Laterite / Rubbles stone quarry Survey no. 38 of Proposed lease area – The PP has complied with the H. No. L-12, Gogal, Codar village in 15,000 sq.mts. sitespecific observations. Near Housing Board, EW Ponda taluka of Margao – 403 601 North Goa district. Proposed capacity – Category 1(a) – B 19,200 m 3 per annum / (M) - 9422057061 Proposed land is 24,000 m 3 (i.e. 1,600 GoaSEAC has considered the 8th February 2013 owned by the m3 per month) proposal for recommendation. proponent. GoaSEAC has inspected the site on 21 st February 2013. Total excavation during the life-span of a quarry – 5,80,000 m 3 @ 80 m 3 per day.

Expected life-span of quarry – 20-25 years

]8 M/s R.B.S. Candiaparcar , Basalt stone quarry Survey no. Total lease area – 3.42 Ha. (2.495 Ha. Has The PP has been Purushottam Niwas, 11/1(P) of been unutilized) directed to comply with Khandepar, Ponda, REEWAL Piliem village in the proposed quarrying Goa – 403 401 Dharbandora Rated capacity – 5,000 m 3 per annum plan in light of the Mines (Lease no. 04/Basalt/93) – valid upto 11 th taluka of South Rejection (i.e. overburden) handling – 600 m 3 Safety Regulations w.r.t. Mr. Paresh Khandeparkar February 2013 Goa district. per annum benches and terraces. Ph. 0832-2314918 / 2318324 Fax. – 0832-2318567 Category 1(a) – B Total available geological reserves – 3,11,562 m3. . e-mail: [email protected] The lease does not have a separate explosive GoaSEAC has magazine. Current depth of the pit achieved – 20 mts. considered the proposal Consultant – M/s Kurade and BGL. for recommendation Associates, Cuncolim. 8th February 2013 subject to compliance. GoaSEAC has inspected the site on 21 st Optimum depth proposed – 30 mts. BGL. February 2013. Expected life –span – 62 years

Page 63 of 72

9 M/s R.B.S. Candiaparcar , Basalt stone quarry Survey no. Total lease area – 2.32 ( Ha. has been The PP has been Purushottam Niwas, 6/2(P) of Piliem unutilized). directed to comply with Khandepar, Ponda, REEWAL village in the proposed quarrying Goa – 403 401 Dharbandora Rated capacity – 6,000 m 3 per annum plan in light of the Mines (Lease no. 03/Basalt/93) – valid upto 11 th taluka of South Rejection (i.e. overburden) handling – 700 m 3 Safety Regulations w.r.t. Mr. Paresh Khandeparkar February 2013 Goa district. per annum benches and terraces. P. O. Box no. 187, Anant Smriti, Behind Main Post office, Category 1(a) – B Total available geological reserves – 2,82,760 Ponda, Goa. m3. The lease has a separate explosive magazine. Ph. 0832-2314918 / 2318324 Current depth of the pit achieved – 20 mts. Fax. – 0832-2318567 8th February 2013 BGL. GoaSEAC has e-mail: [email protected] considered the proposal GoaSEAC has inspected the site on 21 st Optimum depth proposed – 30 mts. BGL. for recommendation Consultant – M/s Kurade and February 2013. subject to compliance. Associates, Cuncolim. Expected life –span – 47 years

10 Shri. Jaiwas aik, Laterite / Rubbles stone quarry Survey no. 150 (Part-B) of Verna Proposed lease area – 20,000 The PP has complied H. No. 353, Shindolim, village in Salcete taluka of South sq.mts. with the sitespecific Sancoale, EW LEASE Goa district. Proposed capacity – 5,000 m 3 per observations. Cortalim. annum (about 500 m 3 per month – Category 1(a) – B Property rights are with the 25m 3 / 60 m 3 per day) M – 7350787380 proponent by way of partition suit - 7350933668 bearing no. 25/11/III. Total expected Laterite extraction – GoaSEAC has 11 th February 2013 75,000 m 3. (within life-span of 15 considered the proposal Consultant – M/s Kurade and years) for recommendation. Associates, Cuncolim. GoaSEAC has inspected the site on 21 st February 2013.

Page 64 of 72

11. Project proposals forwarded by the GCZMA for scrutiny and appraisal as per State Govt’s ‘Hotel Policy’ in CRZ areas.

Applicability of EIA Notification, 2006 for the projects Such Beach Resorts projects falling within the CRZ zone need to obtain NOC from the MoEF (i.e. NCZMA) on related to Construction of ‘Beach Resort’ in Survey o. recommendation of the State Coastal Zone Management Authority concerned (i.e. GCZMA) as per CRZ Notification, 156/2 and 156/3A of Calangute village, Bardez taluka by 2011. However and as per the ‘Schedule’ annexed to the EIA Notification, 2006 (as amended up to 4 th April 2011), said A Mr. Edfar Afonso, Calangute. construction activity involving built-up area less than 20,000 sq.mts. does not come under the purview of the said EIA Notification, 2006. File o. GCZMA//1213/21 GoaSEAC has appraised that said proposal does not come under the purview of the EIA otification. EW Total BUA is 1,626.65 sq.mts . EMP by M/s Sadekar Enviro Engineers Pvt. Ltd., Panaji.

B Applicability of EIA Notification, 2006 for the projects related to Such Hotel Villas projects falling within the CRZ zone need to obtain NOC from the MoEF (i.e. NCZMA) on Construction of ‘Hotel Villas’ in Survey o. 53/1 of Chicalim recommendation of the State Coastal Zone Management Authority concerned (i.e. GCZMA) as per CRZ village in Mormugao taluka of South Goa district by Mr. Mario Notification, 2011. J. A. Alvares – P.O.A holder Mr. Gustavo De Souza. GoaSEAC has appraised that said proposal does not come under the purview of the EIA otification. File o. GCZMA/S/1213/11 Total BUA is 735.55 sq.mts . EMP by M/s Sadekar Enviro Engineers Pvt. Ltd., Panaji EW

Applicability of EIA Notification, 2006 for the projects Such Beach Resorts projects falling within the CRZ zone need to obtain NOC from the MoEF (i.e. NCZMA) on related to Construction of Beach Resort in Survey o. recommendation of the State Coastal Zone Management Authority concerned (i.e. GCZMA) as per CRZ Notification, 138/1D (Part) and 138/1E1 of Varca village in Salcete 2011. C taluka, South Goa district by M/s Total Composites Pvt. However and as per the ‘Schedule’ annexed to the EIA Notification, 2006 (as amended up to 4 th April 2011), such Ltd., C/o Goa Glass Fibre Ltd., Colvale . construction activity involving built-up area less than 20,000 sq.mts. does not come under the purview of the said EIA Notification, 2006. File o. GCZMA/S/0809/66 GoaSEAC has appraised that said proposal does not come under the purview of the EIA otification.

EW Total BUA is 1,641.26 sq.mts . EMP by M/s Aditya Environmental Services, Mumbai

Page 65 of 72

Applicability of EIA Notification, 2006 for the Such Beach Resorts projects falling within the CRZ zone need to obtain NOC from the MoEF (i.e. NCZMA) on recommendation projects related to Construction of beach resort in of the State Coastal Zone Management Authority concerned (i.e. GCZMA) as per CRZ Notification, 2011. However and as per the Survey o. 207/1, 207/2 and 208/3 of Calangute ‘Schedule’ annexed to the EIA Notification, 2006 (as amended up to 4 th April 2011), said construction activity involving built-up D village in Bardez taluka, orth Goa district by area less than 20,000 sq.mts. does not come under the purview of the said EIA Notification, 2006. Domnic Alleluia De Souza, R/o Chalstan Beach GoaSEAC has scrutinized the said proposal and has requested to ascertain – (a) Whether a proposal is for EW Resort, Baga. construction or “EXPASIO’ project and (b) the total Builtup are (BUA) proposed to be consumed for suitable appraisal under the EIA otification, 2006. File o. GCZMA//1213/24 EW The proponent has clarified that said proposal is a EW IDEPEDET HOTEL covering total BUA of 4,635.77 sq.mts. As such and as per ‘Schedule’ annexed to the EIA otification, the aforesaid activity does not come under the purview of the said otification .

E Applicability of EIA Notification, 2006 for the Such Beach Resorts projects falling within the CRZ zone need to obtain NOC from the MoEF (i.e. NCZMA) on recommendation projects related to Construction of beach hotel in of the State Coastal Zone Management Authority concerned (i.e. GCZMA) as per CRZ Notification, 2011. However and as per the Survey o. 209/9, 10 of Anjuna village in Bardez ‘Schedule’ annexed to the EIA Notification, 2006 (as amended up to 4 th April 2011), said construction activity involving built-up taluka, orth Goa district by M/s Good Value area less than 20,000 sq.mts. does not come under the purview of the said EIA Notification, 2006. Hotel and Resorts Pvt. Ltd., Anjuna. GoaSEAC has appraised that said proposal does not come under the purview of the EIA otification. File o. GCZMA//1213/23 EW Total BUA is 1,010.10 sq.mts . EMP by M/s Aditya Environmental Services, Mumbai.

Applicability of EIA Notification, As per the ‘Schedule’ annexed to the EIA Notification, 2006 (as amended up to 4 th April 2011), such activity does not come under the purview of the 2006 for the projects related to said EIA Notification, 2006. However, it is required to obtain NOC from the GCZMA as per the CRZ Notification, 2011. proposed construction of Beach Resort / Hotel in Survey o. 98/1 GoaSEAC has scrutinized the said proposal and has requested to ascertain total Builtup are (BUA) proposed to be consumed for the said of Betalbatim village in Salcete “EXPASIO” project including the BUA already consumed by the existing structure so as to suitably appraisal under the EIA F taluka by M/s Best Location otification, 2006. Properties Pvt. Ltd., The proponent has clarified that although the aforesaid proposal is an “EXPASIO” of the existing hotel, total BUA consumed by the File o. GCZMA / S / 1213 / 41 development is 6,114.08 sq.mts. only. This includes BUA of the old hotel – 2,957.48 sq.mts. + proposed BUA for expansion – 3,156.60 sq.mts. totaling to 6,114.08 sq.mts. As such and as per ‘Schedule’ annexed to the EIUA otification, the aforesaid activity does not come under the EXPASIO purview of the said otification.

Page 66 of 72

Applicability of EIA Notification, 2006 for the projects related to The proposed site is classified as CRZ-III area (open land under settlement zone) located beyond 200 mts. proposed construction of Arun resort (68 rooms) in Survey o. 63/3 from HTL covering total plot area of 9,159 sq.mts. The proposed resort construction involves built-up area of G of Chicalim village, Mormugao taluka in South Goa district. 2,922.64 sq.mts.

File o. GCZMA / S / 342 GoaSEAC has appraised that said proposal does not come under the purview of the EIA otification .

Mr. Arun Naik, PAH for Mr. Arun Shah, H. No. 10, Gaint, Bogmolo. Total BUA is 2,922.64 sq.mts . EMP by M/s Sadekar Enviro Engineers Pvt. Ltd., Panaji.

Applicability of EIA Notification, 2006 for the projects related to As per the ‘Schedule’ annexed to the EIA Notification, 2006 (as amended up to 4 th April 2011), such activity proposed construction of Beach Resort / Hotel in Survey o. does not come under the purview of the said EIA Notification, 2006. However, it is required to obtain NOC from 221/1B of Mandrem village of Pernem taluka by M/s Asvem the GCZMA as per the CRZ Notification, 2011. Beach Resort and Villas Pvt. Ltd.,

H File o. GCZMA / / 1213 / 44 C/o constituted Attorney – Anil Mishra, House No. 129/1, Naroji GoaSEAC has appraised that said proposal does not come under the purview of the EIA otification. Waddo, Morjim Beach Road, Morjim, Pernem, Goa. However, requested the GCZMA to ascertain the CRZ applicability for proposed construction of ‘EW ROAD’ in lieu of ‘EXISTIG PUBLIC ROAD’ within 200 mts. from the HTL. Regd. Address – Mr. Anil Mishra, r/o RZ-232, F-52 block, Raj Nagar- II, Palam Colony, New Delhi Total BUA is 2,444.30 sq.mts . EMP carried out by M/s Aditya Environmental Services, Mumbai. Mobile - 09765853152 Based on the GCZMA clarification to SEAC’s observation, the SEIAA has appraised that said activity does not EW come under the purview of the EIA Notification, 2006.

Page 67 of 72

Background note on issues reg: Show Cause Notice bearing No. 1/80/12-PCB/SEAC/P-1/45, dated 10/09/2012, issued by Goa – SEIAA to M/s Akar Creations Pvt. Ltd.

Vide Show Cause Notice dated 10 th September 2012, the Goa State Environment Impact Assessment Authority (Goa – SEIAA) directed M/s Akar Creations Pvt. Ltd., to clarify and explain as to why the Environmental Clearance bearing no. 3-181-2010/STE-DIR/20 dated 15/06/2012 should not be revoked for concealment of the factual position/ misrepresentation by M/s Akar Creations Pvt. Ltd to the Goa- SEIAA with regard to the group housing and commercial project “Akar Exclsior” in survey no. 40/0 of Vanelim village in Salcete taluka, South Goa.

Vide letter/reply dated 26/09/2012, M/s Akar Creations Pvt. Ltd. has submitted a reply to the Show Cause Notice dated 10/09/2012.

Subsequently the Authority vide letter dated 21/02/2013 has directed M/s Akar Creations Pvt. Ltd. to depute their Authorised representatives before the Chairman of the Goa- SEIAA 05/03/2013 in order to submit their say on the Show Cause Notice dated 10/09/2012. Mrs. Judith Almeida, Secretary of the Colva Civic and Consumer Forum was also requested to remain present for the said hearing. Accordingly the Authorised representatives of M/s Akar Creations Pvt. Ltd. and CCEF were heard by the Chairman on the Show Cause notice dated 10/09/2012. A detailed additional reply dated 05/03/2012 submitted by M/s Akar Creations Pvt. Ltd was also taken on record. The submissions of both the parties were heard and considered in detail.

Relevant files in this regard are enclosed.

The brief facts in the matter as follows:-

1. Vide letter dated 20/07/2011, M/s Akar Creations Pvt. Ltd. submitted an application to the Goa – SEIAA for grant of Environmental Clearance (as per new EIA notification dated 14/09/2006 as amended on 01/12/2009 for group housing and commercial project “Akar Exclsior” in survey no. 40/0 of Vanelim village in Salcete taluka, South Goa.

2. The Project was presented before the Goa-SEAC at its Meeting held on 19/08/2011. Subsequently, the Goa-SEAC carried out a site inspection of the said project. The Goa –SEIAA at its meeting held on 24/10/2011 observed that the project proponent had violated the provisions of the EIA Notification by not obtaining prior Environmental Clearance before undertaking Construction /expansion activity and as such the Goa –SEIAA proposed to initiate proceeding under section 5 of the Environment Protection Act 1986 against M/s Akar Creations Pvt. Ltd.

3. Accordingly a Show Cause Notice dated 30/04/2012 was issued to M/s Akar Creations Pvt. Ltd. directing them to Show Cause as to why action under Section 5 of the Environment (Protection) Act, 1986 should not be initiated against them for carrying out construction activity at their project without obtaining prior Environmental Clearance.

4. In this regard, Goa SEIAA was in receipt of a reply dated 04/05/2012 from the project proponent submitting that:- a. They were under the bonafied impression that Environmental Clearance is not required for any project which does not exceed the built up area of 20,000 sq. mts . While

Page 68 of 72

calculating the area of 20,000 sq. mts. the have calculated the same as equal to FSI/FAR as computed as per the regulations of planning and Development Authorities of the Government of Goa. In this measurement, area of cantilever projection for balconies, stilt parking areas, staircase area, etc. are excluded. In these terms, the project proponent claimed that FSI/FAR did not exceed 20,000 sq. mts.

b. That the project proponent has obtained approvals from the local Village Panchayats, Senior Town Planner, TCP. That matter pertaining to obtaining of prior EC under EIA Notification, 2006 came to light only when Writ Petition No. 297/2009 was filed against them before the Hon. High Court of Bombay at Goa. However, the project proponent had already constructed 18,045 sq. mts.

c. Subsequently, the project proponent proceeded to apply for Environmental Clearance to the MoEF vide application dated 01/09/2009.

d. That their project was initially put up for consideration before the Expert Appraisal Committee (EAC) of the MoEF in the year October 2009 at the 75 th meeting of the EAC and that the EAC recommended the project for EC and awarded Silver grading for the project.

e. That subsequently MoEF has communicated to M/s Akar Creations Pvt. Ltd. informing them that the said project was delisted and that they would require to submit a fresh proposal to the Goa –SEIAA for the grant of Environmental Clearance.

f. That in this regard M/s Akar Creations Pvt. Ltd. has submitted an application dated 20/07/2011 to the Goa –SEIAA for grant of Environmental Clearance for the project.

g. That the project proponent has given an undertaking to the Hon. High Court of Bombay at Goa which is referred to at para 12 of order dated 20/03/2012 passed in WP NO. 297/2009 that they undertake to deposit 6 lakhs with the concerned Authority that was earlier MoEF but which is presently Goa-SEIAA and that Hon. High Court has accepted the undertaking to pay the said amount to the Goa –SEIAA.

5. Vide note dated 17/05/2012, the Goa –SEIAA, directed M/s Akar Creations Pvt. Ltd to provide certain clarifications regarding site specific details of the said project. M/s Akar Creations Pvt. Ltd submitted their reply dated 21/05/2012 in this regard.

6. After considering the reply and clarifications submitted by M/s Akar Creations Pvt. Ltd. the Goa- SEIAA vide order dated 14/06/2012, discharge the Show Cause Notice dated 04/05/2012 and directed the project proponent to pay a penalty in the form of a fine of Rs. 6 lakhs as per the submissions by the proponent to the Hon. High Court in Writ Petition No. 297/2009.

7. Vide letter dated 15/06/2012, M/s Akar Creations Pvt. Ltd. paid the amount of 6 lakhs to the Goa –SEIAA and as such the Goa –SEIAA has issued EC dated 15/06/2012 for the said project.

8. The Goa –SEIAA has subsequently received complaints dated 23/06/2012 and 13/08/2012 from the Colva Civic and Consumer Forum alleging that the Goa –SEIAA has wrongly issued the EC dated 15/06/2012 to M/s Akar Creations Pvt. Ltd. on the grounds that;

Page 69 of 72

i) The construction is on agricultural land without obtaining conversion sand.

ii) That the Construction has been carried out by filling up a natural pond, well and a storm

water drain.

iii) That an illegal 3 meter retaining wall has also been constructed.

iv) That the undertaking made by the Project proponent to the Hon. High Court in W.P. no.

297/2009, regarding payment of Rs. 600,000/- was an undertaking for payment towards

conversion fees and not for purpose of obtaining EC.

9. In this regard, the Goa –SEIAA has issued the present Show Cause Notice dated 10/09/2012, directing M/s Akar Creations Pvt. Ltd., to clarify and explain as to why the Environmental Clearance bearing no. 3-181-2010/STE-DIR/20 dated 15/06/2012 should not be revoked for concealment of the factual position/ misrepresentation by M/s Akar Creations Pvt. Ltd to the Goa- SEIAA, as stated by the CCCF.

10. In this regard, M/s Akar Creations Pvt. Ltd. has replied to the aforesaid Show Cause Notice vide reply dated 26/09/2012, wherein they refuted the allegation that they have misled the Goa SEIAA, and have now specifically stated that the undertaking given by them to the Hon. High Court of Bombay at Goa which is referred to at para 12 of order dated 20/03/2012 passed in WP No. 297/2009, was an undertaking to pay the amount of Rs. 6 lakhs to the Deputy Collector and Sub Divisional officer towards conversion fees. They have further denied filling up the natural pond, well and storm water drain as alleged and have also denied blocking of traditional acess and filling up of agricultural land. They have further submitted that the matter is sub judice before the Hon. High Court of Bombay at Goa in W.P. no. 297/2009.

11. Subsequently the Authority vide letter dated 21/02/2013 has directed M/s Akar Creations Pvt. Ltd. to depute their Authorised representatives before the Chairman of the Goa- SEIAA 05/03/2013 in order to submit their say on the Show Cause Notice dated 10/09/2012. Mrs. Judith Almeida, Secretary of the Colva Civic and Consumer Forum was also requested to remain present for the said hearing.

12. These facts have been intimated to the National Green Tribunal at New Delhi in Appeal no. 52/2012, wherein the Environmental Clearance dated 15/06/2012, granted by the Goa SEIAA to the Project proponent has been challenged by the Colva Civic and Consumer Forum. The National Green Tribunal vide its order dated 22/02/2013, was pleased to direct the GOA SEIAA, to complete the hearing in the matter of Show cause notice dated 10/09/2012, issued to the project proponent within a period of 3 weeks. The NGT was further pleased to keep the EC in abeyance and to maintain status quo position.

13. During the course of personal hearing conducted on 05/03/2013 the Project proponent has submitted a reply dated 5/03/2013 and has reiterated their reply dated 26/09/2012 and have refuted the allegation of misleading the Goa –SEIAA. They have submitted that;

i) The Project proponent has not suppressed any facts or misrepresented before the Authority while seeking Environmental Clearance for the said Project.

Page 70 of 72

ii) The existence or non existence of a pond or a well is not at all valid while considering grant of Environmental Clearance which was verified by the office of Town and Country Planning Department.

14. The representatives of the Colva Civic and Consumer Forum, have reiterated the submissions as contained in the Appeal no. 52/2012, filed by them before the NGT, namely; i) The Project proponent has proceeded to obtain Environmental Clearance on a misconception that the Hon. High Court has directed for grant of clearance subject to payment of Rs 6 lakhs as penalty for not obtaining prior EC, whereas no such directions has been issued by the Hon. High Court wherein the amount was with regard to payment of fees for conversion of land. ii) The proponent has affected the ground water stream as well as low lying areas resulting into adverse environmental impacts.

12. Any other matter with the permission of the Chair. **********

Page 71 of 72

Agenda Items for the 8th GoaSEIAA meeting held on 1st April 2013

4. Issues pertaining to strengthening of the EIA-Goa State Authority w.r.t (a) Recruitment of staff for day-to-day functioning of the office, (b) purchase of stationery items / infrastructure requirement (i.e. table, cupboard, telephone-fax, photocopier, etc.,) independently for office, (c) purchase / hiring of office premises, (d) Charging of scrutiny fees from Project Proponents seeking prior EC, etc.,

5. Followup action subsequent to compliance to ‘otice for payment of Penalty” issued to –

a. M/s Rockfirst Real Estate Developers , Panaji. b. M/s itin Developers Ltd., Panaji

6. Final decision regarding following ew / Renewal of Minor Minerals ( road metal / laterite stones ) quarrying leases subsequent to submission / compliances to SEAC’s site/project specific observations. (These proposals were deferred / reserved pending submission of details)

i. Renewal proposals by M/s Halarnkar Industries, Mapusa of two ‘Basalt stone quarries’ namely –

1. Lease no., 09/Basalt/90 – 5,200 sq.mts. ) located in Survey No. 272(P) of village Casarvarnem in Pernem taluka of North Goa district .

2. Lease no., 06/Basalt/03 – 12,075 sq.mts. ) located in Survey No. 47/1 and 47/2, of village Alorna in Pernem taluka of North Goa district

ii. Renewal of one ‘Basalt stone quarry’( Lease no.05/Basalt/06 – 4,800 sq.mts. ) located in Survey No. 86/0 of Kotambi village in Quepem taluka of South Goa district by Mrs. Anila Rege, Margao.

iii. ew ‘Basalt stone quarry’ ( plot area – 5,000 sq.mts ) located in Survey No, 62/1 of village Cordem in Quepem taluka of South Goa district by Mr. Chandrashekhar G. Dessai, Canacona.

iv. ew ‘Laterite stone quarry’ ( plot area – 7,180 sq.mts. ) located in Survey No. 42/0 of Muguli village in Sanguem taluka of South Goa district by Shri. Rumaldo Fernandes, Sanguem.

7. Any other matter as per the approval of the Chairman, GoaSEIAA.

**********

Page 72 of 72