Page 1 of 72 I DEX to the Agenda of the Meetings of Goa SEIAA Sr. O
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
IDEX to the Agenda of the Meetings of Goa SEIAA Sr. o. Particulars Date Page os. 1. 1st Meeting of Goa SEIAA 24 th February, 2011 2 – 19 2. 2nd Meeting of Goa SEIAA 24 th October, 2011 20 – 33 3. 3rd Meeting of Goa SEIAA 5th April, 2012 34 4. 4th Meeting of Goa SEIAA 10 th August, 2012 35 5. 5th Meeting of Goa SEIAA 18 th December, 2012 36 6. 6th Meeting of Goa SEIAA 7th February, 2013 37 – 39 7. 7th Meeting of Goa SEIAA 15 th March, 2013 40 - 71 8. 8th Meeting of Goa SEIAA 1st April, 2013 72 Page 1 of 72 Agenda Item for the First Goa-SEIAA meeting held on 24 th February 2011 A. Consideration of following proposal seeking Prior EC as mandated under the EIA otification, 2006 1. CRICKET STADIUM AT THIVIM BY GOA CRICKET ASSOCIATION Sr. Project Proponent Proposed Site-specific Project details / specification / Comments from Goa-SEAC Response to o. Activity location salient features members comments by Project details (extracted from the project details Proponent (PP) submitted) 1 Goa Cricket Association – GCA Cricket 32 acres of Total plot area – 1,30,328 sq. mt. (32 1.It is informed that the Stadium land in Acoi acres) matter pertaining the Mr. Vijaykumar Sawant, village near Total built-up area – 45,087.59 sq. “issuance of approval for Rizvi Sadan, 2 nd Floor, Near Thivim, mt. (35%) diversion of forest land” Municipal Market, Bardez Proposed ground coverage – 32,183 to the Directorate of Panaji, Goa – 403 001. taluka sq. mt. (22%) Sports and Youth Affairs Total parking area – 24,911 sq. mts. granted under the Forest [email protected] Total green area – 1,00,352.56 sq. (Conservation) act, 1980 mt.(77%) has been stayed by the Phone – 2421088 Ministry of Environment Fax - 2420455 Estimated cost – 160 crores & Forests (MoEF) pursuant to Writ Petition Seating capacity – 46, 575 seats No. 321/2010 and PIL W. P. No. 14/2010 filed in the Total parking (open and enclosed) – Hon’ble High Court of The PP is yet to comply 668 cars, 198 two-wheelers Goa at Bombay by M/s with comments against Goa Foundation. sr. nos. 1, 2 4 & 6. Water requirement – 1221 KLD – during 2.The possibility of The PP has submitted widening the State the compliance to Games Highway – the only comments against sr. 493 KLD – approach road to the nos. 3 & 5. during proposed project site be Page 2 of 72 normal taken on priority so as not days to disturb daily vehicular movement. Further, an Total waste-water generated – 1050 alternate exit-road / KLD to be treated using 1260 KLD secondary road need to be Sewage Treatment Plant (STP) on constructed along the SAFF (Submerged Aerated Fixed north-east periphery of the Film) technology which will generate plot boundary to minimize 840 KLD of treated water to be used traffic congestion. for flushing and landscape. 3.Geotechnical soil analysis Rainwater Harvesting (RWH) may please be carried out initiatives – (1) 32 rainwater to ascertain the soil harvesting pits are proposed for characteristics as well as artificial rainwater recharge. groundwater status and its (2) Desilting tanks and Recharge recharge potential. It is not wells are proposed – LOCATION advisable to opt for NOT DEFINED recharging of groundwater through recharge-pits, Power requirement – 3223 KVA to instead make a provision be sourced through Goa Electricity for optimum Department (GED). During utilization/storage of emergency, proposed to be backed rainwater to be used in up with 3 DG sets of 1250 KVA fair-weather season. each. 4.Location-specific details of the proposed bore well Solid waste generated – 6835 kg./day as well as 32 numbers of (during games) rainwater harvesting pits, - 963 kg/day superimposed on the (during contour map of the normal days) proposed plot area, be furnished. Page 3 of 72 5.PP should make a provision for exclusive fire-escape routes / staircase to avoid stampede during such eventualities. The PP should submit ‘Stability’ as well as ‘Fire Safety’ Certificates as per the conceptual plan proposed. 6.It is advisable to construct composting pits within the project site to treat the biodegradable waste – bio-composting technique and utilize the manure to maintain the green-field area. 2. HOSPITAL-cum-HOTEL AT TALEIGAO BY M/s ALCON CONSTRUCTIONS (GOA) PVT. LTD., Sr. Project Proponent Proposed Site-specific Project details / specification / Comments from Goa-SEAC Response to comments o. Activity location salient features members by Project Proponent details (extracted from the project details (PP) submitted) 2 M/s Alcon Constructions 250-bedded Taleigao Total plot area – 11,988.67 sq. mt. 1.The proposed land was used (Goa) Pvt. Ltd., Hospital- village, (effective – 10,245.53 sq. mt.) to be a landfill site earlier cum-Hotel Tiswadi Total built-up area – 27,958.90 sq. mt. and as such almost 5 to 6 Mr. Nanda Sadassiva Naique (42 rooms) taluka, (upto 5 th floor) mts of top soil is organic- Counto, S. Nos. Proposed open space – 1,542.38 sq. rich fertile and should be Director, G + 5 upper 112/1, mt. (15.05%) utilized for landscaping Page 4 of 72 Sukerkar Mansion, floors and 1 112/1(part) – Proposed ground coverage – 3,618 sq. development. 1st Floor, M. G. Road, basement 11,988.67 mt. (35.32%) Panaji, Goa – 403 001 sq. mt. Proposed FAR – 21,837.64 sq. mt. 2.The PP must ensure that the effluents / waste water in the e-mail – [email protected] Next to About 30,393 m 3 of earth would be adjoining St.Inez nala Sewage removed / excavated. should not infiltrate within Ph. - 2224451 / 2224452 Treatment the project site and Fax – 2225616 Plant at Raft foundation is proposed with safe contaminate the Taleigao bearing capacity of 10 T/sq.mt. groundwater quality as E. Goa-SEAC recommends Registered address – Coli concentration and FE the proposal subject to M/s Alcon Constructions Heating Ventilation Air Conditioning content is reported to be compliance to Goa-SEAC (Goa) Pvt. Ltd., (HVAC) system is proposed. higher in the bore-well observations / comments. Velho Bldg., 1 st Floor, Panaji. water. Accordingly, PP Internal road with 10 mt. width and should treat the nala on parking space proposed for 420 nos. priority as well as construct (details not mentioned) approach road to the proposed site. Intermediate STP with Moving Bed Bio-Reactor (MBBR) technology is 3.The proposed site, being proposed – part treated sewage to very low-lying area, bears a transfer to authorized STP to St.inez – sandy aquifer regime and as total treated sewage is 235 cmd, 209 such, built individual sump cmd to be reuded for gardening, rather than soak pits to treat flushing, AC-cooling. 26 cmd to waste-water effectively. disposed into sewers. Well-engineered storm-water drainage system is proposed. Water requirement – 9 cmd (Construction) 452 cmd (operation) Page 5 of 72 Contd. / - Total waste-water generated – 1.6 (Construction) 247 cmd (Operation) 60 trees are proposed to be planted. Power requirement – 25 KW (Construction) - 780 KW (Operation) Back-up power through diesel generator of 750 KVA. Solid waste generated – 1 – 3 MT/d (Construction) Operation phase - 63 kg/d – Biomedical and 570 kg.d – domestic waste. Organic Waste Convertor (OWC) is proposed for biodegradable waste. EMP enclosed as annexure – VII. 3. RESIDENTIAL COMPLEX AT ALTO-BATIM BY ROCKFIRST REAL ESTATE LTD., Sr. Project Proponent Proposed Site-specific Project details / specification / Comments from Goa-SEAC Response to comments by o. Activity location salient features members Project Proponent (PP details (extracted from the project details submitted) Page 6 of 72 3 M/s Rockfirst Real Estate Residential Alto-Betim Total plot area – 29,120.13 sq. mt. 1.The proposed project “A” Ltd., Mumbai. Apartments village, Total Ground coverage area – 8,751 appears to be an extension Bardez sq. mts. of the ongoing work, being Mr. Rajesh Jaggi, “Ashoka taluka, Green cover area – 20,368 sq. mts. developed, within two Managing Director, Beleza” S. Nos. 57/1 Built-up area – 22,279.67 sq. mts. adjacent plots namely – ‘B’ 1, Peninsula Spenta, (G + 3 of Reis Total construction built-up area – and ‘C’ and is seeking prior Mathurdas Mills, Senapati storied Magos 32,452.52 sq. mts. Environmental Clearance Bapat Marg, Lower Parel, complex) village (EC) from the Goa-SEIAA, Mumbai – 400013 Ready-Mix-Concrete (RMC) to be as the built-up area, taken used. together, exceeds 20,000 sq. Ph. – 022/66229400 – mts. as per the EIA 022/66229300/01 Total occupancy – 652 nos. (max.) Notification, 2006. Fax – 022/66229302 About 80,134 m 3 of earth would be 2.Almost 30% of the total [email protected] removed / excavated. plot area has been (M) - 9820505005 developed and as a result, Goa-SEAC defers the Geotechnical soil investigation appreciable proportion of proposal as the PP is seeking Corres. Add .: (enclosure – 1) as carried out naturally grown vegetation post-facto EC. Mr. Sanjeev - 9890003168 through 17 boreholes with has been lost along the hill- Peninsula Land Ltd., permanent benchmark of +50mt. No slopes. Peninsula Center, H. No. 850, groundwater table was encountered. Opp. SBI, Porvorim – 403 3.It is advisable to re-design 621 Reinforced concrete (i.e. Spread the rainwater-storage tanks foundation) is proposed with proposed in the already Mr. Sanjay Ghatwal maximum water: cement ratio of developed area (i.e. B & C (M) - 9764005561 0.50 at an average depth of 1.5 mt.. portion) so as to account for This foundation has a safe bearing suitable water storage, as capacity of 40 T/sq.mt. (with total one of the rainwater settlement of 9 mm).