Ethnic Germans in the Soviet Union: the People of Chortitza
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
ETHNIC GERMANS IN THE SOVIET UNION: THE PEOPLE OF CHORTITZA, 1939-1949 A Thesis by ERIKA LEE WEIDEMANN Submitted to the Office of Graduate and Professional Studies of Texas A&M University in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF ARTS Chair of Committee, Walter Kamphoefner Committee Members, Adam Seipp Olga Cooke Head of Department, David Vaught May 2016 Major Subject: History Copyright 2016 Erika L Weidemann ABSTRACT During the Second World War, Nazi and Soviet governments had distinctly different ideologies as well as different reasons for targeting the Soviet Union's German population for relocation. While the Soviets saw ethnic Germans as a national security threat, the Nazis desired to use them to pursue plans for racial social engineering. Using Einwandererzentralstelle and International Red Cross Tracing Service records, the case study of the inhabitants of the ethnic German settlement of Chortitza explore key moments in the population's navigation of the Second World War from Soviet deportation to German occupation to resettlement and life in post-war Germany. These moments reveal that ethnic Germans had continuously shaped their ethnic identity during their time in Russia and the Soviet Union. In the 1920s and 1930s, ethnic Germans began to adapt their German culture to the surrounding Ukrainian and Russian ways of life in an effort to lessen chances of deportation by the NKVD. This malleable ethnic identity became especially fluid during World War II as ethnic Germans struggled to survive the war. Evidence of changes in their ethnic identity include being noticeably different from Germans living in the Reich. Therefore, to an extent, their ethnicity was invented and dependent upon circumstances (varying borders, loyalties, and survival). Their collective identity became instrumental in successfully navigating war as a village unit. As their identity became manipulative, ethnic Germans used their German ethnicity as well as their Soviet roots to survive the war. Therefore, this master's thesis argues that the Chortitza Germans had agency to highlight their ethnicity as Germans or to ii emphasize their citizenship as Soviet-Germans depending upon whose control (Nazi or Soviet) they fell under. Using the Chortitza Germans as a case study enables us to look beyond Soviet and Nazi ideology to show how ethnic Germans struggled to fulfill Nazi or Soviet expectations in order to escape dire consequences. iii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS I would like to thank my committee chair, Dr. Kamphoefner, and my committee members, Dr. Seipp and Dr. Cooke, for their guidance and support throughout the course of this research. To my colleagues and the department faculty and staff in the Texas A&M University History Department, please know that you are appreciated. I also want to extend my gratitude to the individuals who inspired me to do this research and were willing to share their stories. Ileana Douglas - professor, mentor, and friend - your guidance has carried me through. Those closest to me, I thank God for you each day. Finally, I would like to thank my mother and father for their belief in the importance of education. Omi, this is for you. iv TABLE OF CONTENTS Page ABSTRACT ...................................................................................................................... ii ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS ..............................................................................................iv TABLE OF CONTENTS ................................................................................................... v CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION ........................................................................................ 1 Historiography ............................................................................................. 3 Ethnicity ....................................................................................................... 8 Case for the Case Study ............................................................................... 9 Thesis ......................................................................................................... 11 CHAPTER II BEGINNINGS OF HOPE, YEARS OF DISAPPOINTMENT ................ 13 Push and Pull Factors ................................................................................. 13 Growth of Chortitza ................................................................................... 14 Disappearing Freedoms ............................................................................. 17 CHAPTER III REESTABLISHING GERMANNESS: THE GERMAN OCCUPATION OF CHORTITZA ............................................................ 27 Historiography ........................................................................................... 27 Before the German Invasion ...................................................................... 31 After the Soviet Retreat ............................................................................. 38 Religion ...................................................................................................... 39 Language .................................................................................................... 41 Complicity ................................................................................................. 43 Conclusion ................................................................................................. 47 CHAPTER IV RETURNED TO THE REICH ................................................................ 49 Historiography ........................................................................................... 50 The German Experience ............................................................................ 54 The Soviet Experience ............................................................................... 58 Resettlement Plans ..................................................................................... 61 Transported to the Reich ............................................................................ 64 Proving Germanness (Again)..................................................................... 73 Conclusion...................................................................................................81 v CHAPTER V SOVIET ADVANCE AND REPATRIATION: A TIME OF CHANGING IDENTITY .......................................................................... 84 Historiography ........................................................................................... 85 Soviet Advancement .................................................................................. 89 Legal Definition of Ethnic Germans .......................................................... 96 Soviet Repatriation Goals .......................................................................... 99 The Process of Repatriation ..................................................................... 101 Escape from Repatriation......................................................................... 105 Use of the Past ......................................................................................... 106 Physical Movement.................................................................................. 109 CHAPTER VI CONCLUSIONS ................................................................................... 113 Post-war Life............................................................................................ 113 Immigration Plans .................................................................................... 115 Aussiedler................................................................................................. 121 Conclusion ............................................................................................... 123 REFERENCES ............................................................................................................... 125 vi CHAPTER I INTRODUCTION "Volksdeutsche," "Germans from Russia," "Soviet-Germans," "Ethnic Germans" - the many names mirror their varying identities.1 Emigrating from the German states to the Ukraine and Russia in the late eighteenth century, these immigrants were invited by Catherine the Great; they settled the spaces that later became part of the Soviet Union. In 1789, Mennonites from Danzig, West Prussia founded the settlement of Chortitza along the west bank of the Dnieper River. Chortitza and its surrounding villages became the largest Mennonite settlement within Russia and Ukraine. Despite its size, geographic location, and history, few historians have researched the ethnic population that lived there from 1789 to 1943. Historians and the public alike who are familiar with the term "Germans from Russia" often think of either the Volga Germans or of immigration to the American Midwest in the early 1900s. This thesis, however, explores the lives of individuals who lived in Chortitza in the 1930s and early 1940s before being resettled by the German government. The story of ethnic Germans in Russia begins with the Russian government's xenophobia.2 Even ethnic Germans living in the Soviet Union 130 years after original settlement were not exempt from being targeted as an ethnic group. Ethnic Germans were deemed a possible fifth column, individuals who maintained traitorous ties to Germany. These attitudes toward ethnic Germans resulted in the Soviet government's 1 This thesis will primarily use the term ethnic Germans to describe this group of people. 2 Yet, it is also true that Russia and later the