DOCSLIB.ORG

'-L . March 1999

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
'-L . March 1999 Christians in Al-Andalus (8th-10th centuries) Ann Christys '-L . Submitted in accordance with the requirements for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy, University of Leeds, School of History. March 1999 The candidate confirms that the work submitted is her own and that appropriate credit has been given where reference has been made to the work of others. Christians in Al-Andalus, (8th-10th centuries) Ann Christys PhD, March, 1999. Abstract: The historiography of early Islamic Spain has become polarised between the Arabic narrative histories and the Latin sources. Although the Arabic sources have little directly to say about the situation of the conquered Christians, a willingness to engage with both Latin and Arabic texts opens up a wide range of material on such controversial topics as acculturation and conversion to Islam. This thesis examines a number of texts written by or attributed to Christians living in Al-Andalus before the fall of the caliphate, early in the eleventh century. It begins with two eighth-century Latin chronicles and their wholly Christian response to the conquest and the period of civil wars which followed it. The reliability of Eulogius' testimony to the Cordoban martyr movement of the 850s is considered in the light of Alvarus' Vita Eulogii and other evidence. Tenth-century Cordoba is briefly described as a backdrop to the later sources. The passions of two Cordoban martyrs of this period show that hagiography allowed for different accounts of dissident Christians. The status of bishop Recemund as the author of the Calendar of Cordoba and the epitome of 'convivencia' is re-evaluated. The translation into Arabic of Orosius' Seven Books of History Against the Pagans is set in the context of other Christian texts in Arabic. The final chapter considers the episodes in Ibn al-QuTiya's History of the Conquest of Al-Andalus dealing with the Christian population, and especially with the Visigothic family from whom he may have been descended. Whilst an attempt is made to draw this material together, the result is a series of Christian perspectives on the Islamic conquest, rather than a new narrative of cultural survival or assimilation. 1 Contents Preface 1 Abbreviations 11 Transliteration, placenames and dates 11 List of maps and illustrations 111 1. Introduction I 2. News from the East in the eighth-century chronicles 11 3. The martyrs of Eulogius 47 4. Cordoba in the tenth century 76 5. Two more martyrs of Cordoba 83 6. Recemund and the Calendar of Cordoba 118 7. The Arabic translation of Orosius 148 8. The descendants of Sara the Goth 177 9. Conclusion 204 Bibliography 208 11 Preface Writing this thesis has, of course, taken far longer than I could have imagined. In the last two years, when it has been 'nearly finished' it has been greatly improved and I have been reanimated by presenting sections of the work to different audiences. There are too many people to mention everyone individually, but I would like to thank in particular the medievalists of the School of History, University of Leeds, as well as Mayke de Jong, Rosamund McKitterick, Walter Pohl and their students of the Utrecht-Vienna-Leeds-Cambridge symposia, Jinty Nelson, Barbara Rosenwein and her colleague Zuhair Ghazzal, who rescued the last copy of the 'Urüsfüs from the publisher's basement in Beirut, the Historians of Medieval Iberia, particularly Roger Wright, and the organisers and participants in the 'Places of Power' conference of the European Science Foundation in Belaggio, September 1998. I have been greatly assisted by the staff of the Brotherton library, the Biblioteca Nacional, Madrid the former Escuela Espanola de Arqueologia in Rome and its director Javier Arce, and by several patient language teachers, especially Shelley Abu-Shanab and Monica Palmis. John Wreglesworth read the whole manuscript with exemplary care, corrected innumerable mistakes and raised enough questions for another thesis. My debt to my supervisor Ian Wood goes back to the first few weeks of my time as an undergraduate in the School of History, where I was a refugee from the unwarranted certainty of medicine. Ian's approach to the great unknown of the early Middle Ages, based on imaginative reading of the way early medieval authors had recorded their world rather than on explanation of what actually happened, was a revelation. I am grateful to Ian for humouring my obsession with the history of Spain for almost a decade, and for providing me with so many opportunities to develop as a historian. He is not to blame if the end result is still so difficult to understand. Finally, although he should perhaps have come first, I would like to thank Roger Collins for writing Early Medieval Spain: Unity in Diversity 400-1000, which I read during my first visit to Spain in 1983 and the rest, I hope, is history. 111 Abbreviations AASS: Acta Sanctorunt quotquot tot orbe coluntur, ed. Bollandus J. et al., (Antwerp and Brussels, 1634-). BL: London, British Library manuscript. BN n. a. lat.: Paris, Bibliotheque Nationale, nouvelles acquisitions latines, manuscript. CCSL : Corpus Christianorumn, Series Latina, (Turnhout, 1952-). CSCO: Corpus Scriptorun Christianorum Orientalium, (Paris and Louvain, 1903 -). SS: Scriptores Syrii, ed. Brooks E., Guidi I., and Chabot J-B, (6 vols., Paris, 1903-7). CSM: Corpus Scriptorum Muzarabicorum, ed. Gil Fernandez J, (2 vols., Madrid, 1973). DHEE: Diccionario de Historia Ecclesiästica de Espana, ed. Aldea Vaquero Q., Marin Martinez T., Vives Gatell J., (4 vols, Madrid, 1972-5). El: Encyclopaedia of Islam, new ed. Gibb H. A. R. et al, (Leiden and London, 1960-). ES: Espana Sagrada, ed. Florez E. et al. (Madrid, 1747-). MBN: Madrid, Biblioteca Nacional, manuscript. MGH: Monumenta Gerntaniae Historica. AA: Auctores Antiquissimi, (15 vols., Berlin, 1877-1919). PL: Patrologia Cursus Cotnpletus, Series Latina, ed. Migne J-P, (221 vols., Paris, 1841-64). Settintane: Settimanedi studio del centro italiano di studi medievo, (Spoleto, 1954-). Transliteration, placenames and dates Apart from Muhammad, Arabic names are transliterated according to the system adopted in the Cambridge History of Islam, except that the limitations of the word-processing programme mean that h appears as H, s as S, t as T and th as Th. Placenames are given in their Spanish version except for Cordoba, Seville and others well-known in English. All dates are given with the equivalent Common Era [AD] dating. iv List of maps and illustrations Christian and Muslim Spain c. 890 9 Eulogius' itinerary in Navarre 48 Cordoba in the tenth century 80 Northwest Spain in the tenth century 87 Columbia University MS X, 893, f. lr. 164 I 1. Introduction 'Although formerly Spain abounded plentifully in every liberal art and in each one those thirsting for the fountain of knowledge were devoting themselves everywhere to the study of letters, this study along with the arts vanished entirely when she was inundated by the forces of the barbarians. And so assailed by necessity both writers were wanting and the deeds of the Spanish perished in silence. " This quotation, from the twelfth-century Chronicle of Silos, is a piece of anti-Muslim polemic, but it cannot be denied that there is a great gap in the narrative evidence for the Christians under Islamic rule. Kennedy's recent history of Muslin Spain and Portugal devoted just three pages to the Christian population of al-Andalus in the period between the conquest of 711 and the collapse Umayyad in Yet hundred of the caliphate the early years of the eleventh century .2 one years ago, Simonet made the 'Mozarabs', as he called them, the subject of a large volume, of which a substantial part deals with the first three centuries after the conquest. ' Simonet wrote with the prolixity of the nineteenth century but he had plenty of material; although manuscripts are still reappearing, especially in North Africa, most of the evidence had already been discovered. Today, however, the question of what happened to the indigenous population of the Iberian peninsula after 711 is beset with methodological problems which have narrowed the field of 850s, Islam. research to two subjects - the Cordoban martyrs of the and conversion to Simonet, who was first and foremost 'a Catholic, above being an Arabist, a professor, or ' Historia Silense ed. Perez de Urbel J. and Gonzalez Ruiz-Zorilla A., (Madrid, 1959), 1, p. 8, trans. Russell J. C., 'Chroniclers of Medieval Spain', Hispanic Review, (1938), III, p. 226 from Espana Sagrada, XVII, p. 270. 2 Kennedy H., Muslim Spain and Portugal, (1996), pp. 48 and 67-68. ' Simonet F., Iistoria de los Mozärabes de Espana, (Madrid, 1897, repr. 1984). The use of the term 'Mozarab' [musta'rib/Arabicized] for Christians under Islamic rule is an anachronism in early Islamic Spain; it first appeared in eleventh-century texts and its use in discussions of early Islamic Spain prejudges one of the questions at issue: see e. g. Burman T. E., Religious Polemic and the Intellectual History of the Mozarabs, c. 1050-1200, (Leiden, 1994), and ibid., 'The Tathlith al-wadäniya' and the Twelfth-Century Andalusian Christian Approach to Islam' in Tolan J. (ed. ), Medieval Christian Perceptions of Islam: A Book of Essays, (New York and London, 1996), pp. 109-130, at p. 110, citing Hitchcock R., 'Quienes fueron los verdaderos mozärabes' Nueva revista de flologia hispänica, (1981), XXXI, 574-585. In this study I will refer to native population as 'the Christians of al-Andalus', making the distinction between those who remained Christian and the converts to Islam only where their religious affiliations are known. The use of 'Islamic' for the conquest, political institutions, etc. does not imply that all those involved were Muslims. 2 anything elsei4 narrated, with considerable hyperbole, the story of embattled Christians under alien rule who kept the flame of Catholicism burning.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • 900 History, Geography, and Auxiliary Disciplines
    900 900 History, geography, and auxiliary disciplines Class here social situations and conditions; general political history; military, diplomatic, political, economic, social, welfare aspects of specific wars Class interdisciplinary works on ancient world, on specific continents, countries, localities in 930–990. Class history and geographic treatment of a specific subject with the subject, plus notation 09 from Table 1, e.g., history and geographic treatment of natural sciences 509, of economic situations and conditions 330.9, of purely political situations and conditions 320.9, history of military science 355.009 See also 303.49 for future history (projected events other than travel) See Manual at 900 SUMMARY 900.1–.9 Standard subdivisions of history and geography 901–909 Standard subdivisions of history, collected accounts of events, world history 910 Geography and travel 920 Biography, genealogy, insignia 930 History of ancient world to ca. 499 940 History of Europe 950 History of Asia 960 History of Africa 970 History of North America 980 History of South America 990 History of Australasia, Pacific Ocean islands, Atlantic Ocean islands, Arctic islands, Antarctica, extraterrestrial worlds .1–.9 Standard subdivisions of history and geography 901 Philosophy and theory of history 902 Miscellany of history .2 Illustrations, models, miniatures Do not use for maps, plans, diagrams; class in 911 903 Dictionaries, encyclopedias, concordances of history 901 904 Dewey Decimal Classification 904 904 Collected accounts of events Including events of natural origin; events induced by human activity Class here adventure Class collections limited to a specific period, collections limited to a specific area or region but not limited by continent, country, locality in 909; class travel in 910; class collections limited to a specific continent, country, locality in 930–990.
    [Show full text]
  • 180 Goi Erdi Aroko Pertsona-Izenak. Germaniar Jatorriko Pertsona-Izenak
    180 Goi Erdi Aroko pertsona-izenak. Germaniar jatorriko pertsona-izenak 1 Testuingurua 2 Euskaraz nola idatzi germaniar jatorriko izenak? 3 Irizpide xeheak 4 Germaniar jatorriko pertsona-izenen sailkako zerrendak 5 Germaniar jatorriko pertsona-izenak zerrenda bakarrean (euskara-erdarak) 6 Germaniar jatorriko pertsona-izenak zerrenda bakarrean (erdarak-euskara) ------------------------------------------------------------------ 1 Testuingurua Mendebaldeko Erromatar Inperioa desagertu ondoren ere, Erdi Aroaren hasieran, latinak jarraitu zuen prestigiozko hizkuntza izaten Europako erdialdean eta mendebaldean. Garai hartako pertsona-izen nagusiak latinez idatzitako kroniketan (Historiae Francorum, Annales regni Francorum, Annales Fuldenses, Annales Bertiniani...) agertu ziren lehen aldiz idatziz, eta latinaren bidez hedatu ziren Europan erresumetako hizkuntzetara. 1 Inguruko hizkuntzetara eta Europako hizkuntza nagusietara begiratuta, argi eta garbi ageri da garai hartako pertsona-izen nagusiak (errege- erreginak, santu-santak, buruzagiak...) askotan ez direla berdin idazten hizkuntza guztietan. Hau da, hizkuntza bakoitzak bere sistema grafikora egokitu ditu izenok, eta bere grafia eman die. Adibidez, latinezko kroniketan Lotharius dena (jatorria: hlud "ospetsua" eta hari "armada" elementu germanikoak) Lothaire da frantsesez, Lotario gaztelaniaz eta italieraz, Lothair ingelesez, Lothar alemanez, Lotari katalanez, eta abar; latinezko Rudolphus dena (jatorria: hrod "fama" eta wulf "otsoa" elementu germanikoak) Rodolphe da frantsesez, Rodolfo
    [Show full text]
  • La Ciudad Fundada Por M. Marius, Termes Y Colenda (App., Iber. 99-100). La Guerra De 104-93 A.C. En Territorios Arévacos, Vacceos Y Vettones
    LA CIUDAD FUNDADA POR M. MARIUS, TERMES Y COLENDA (APP., IBER. 99-100). LA GUERRA DE 104-93 A.C. EN TERRITORIOS ARÉVACOS, VACCEOS Y VETTONES The city founded by M. Marius, Termes and Colenda (App., Iber. 99-100). The 104-93 B.C. War in Arevaci, Vaccaei and Vetton territories Santiago MARTÍNEZ CABALLERO Museo de Segovia [email protected] Fecha de recepción: 25-III-2011; aceptación definitiva: 15-VI-2011 RESUMEN: Se analiza la actividad militar romana en la Hispania Cite- rior entre 104 y 93 a.C., entendida como una nueva guerra de carácter ane- xionista, detonada por una revuelta fronteriza conectada a la problemática social de grupos celtibéricos del alto Duero. Se reconoce el área de desa- rrollo del conflicto en los territorios arévacos, vacceos y vettones del alto y medio Duero. Desde App., Iber. 99-100, se analizan las conquistas de Ter- mes y Colenda, y se proponen hipótesis para la localización de Colenda y de la ciudad fundada por M. Mario en 100 a.C. en áreas celtibéricas o vet- tonas. Palabras clave: Romano, conquista, conflicto social, T. Didius, C. Vale- rius Flaccus, celtíberos, arévacos, vettones, vacceos, Termes, Colenda, Sepúlveda, Ulaca, Avila. © Ediciones Universidad de Salamanca Stud. hist., H.ª antig., 29, 2011, pp. 119-151 120 SANTIAGO MARTÍNEZ CABALLERO LA CIUDAD FUNDADA POR M. MARIUS, TERMES Y COLENDA (APP., IBER. 99-100). LA GUERRA DE 104-93 A.C. EN TERRITORIOS ARÉVACOS, VACCEOS Y VETTONES ABSTRACT: Roman military activity in Hispania Citerior between 104 and 93 B.C. is analysed and deemed to be a new expansionist war, trigge- red by border unrest underpinned by the social problems of the Celtibe- rian groups of the Upper Duero.
    [Show full text]
  • Hostages and the Dangers of Cultural Contact: Two Cases from Umayyad Cordoba*
    MARIBEL FIERRO Hostages and the Dangers of Cultural Contact: Two Cases from Umayyad Cordoba* Hostages are captives of a peculiar sort. Rather than having been captured during war, they are in the hands of the enemy as free persons who have temporarily lost their freedom, either because they were given and kept as a pledge (for example, for the fulfilment of a treaty) or in order to act as a substitute for someone who has been taken prisoner1. The prisoner, usually an important person, can regain his or her freedom under certain conditions, usually by the payment of a ransom. When those conditions are fulfilled, the hostage is released. In the medieval period, the taking of hostages was linked to conquest, the establishment of treaties, and the submission of rebels. The Spanish word for »hostage« (rehén, pl. rehenes) derives from the Arabic root r.h.n (which produces, in Classical Arabic, rāhin, pl. rahāʾin)2, and this origin attests to the fact that the practice of taking hostages was widespread in medieval Iberia and more generally in the Mediterranean3. The Muslims had not, however, invented it4. We lack specific studies dealing with hostages in Islamic lands and the procedures related to their taking and release, as well as their life as hostages, in spite of the fact that medieval historical and, more generally, literary sources are full of references to this widespread, persistent, and accepted practice which had advantages for both par- * This paper was undertaken as part of the project »Knowledge, heresy and political culture in the Islamic West (second/eighth–ninth/fifteenth centuries) = KOHEPOCU«, F03049 Advanced Research Grant, European Research Council (2009–2014).
    [Show full text]
  • El Urbanismo Vacceo
    El urbanismo vacceo The Vaccean urbanism José David SACRISTÁN DE LAMA Arqueólogo Territorial de la Junta de Castilla y León. Servicio Territorial de Cultura de Valladolid. C/ San Lorenzo 5, 1º. 47001-Valladolid. [email protected] Recibido: 15-12-2010 Aceptado: 13-04-2011 RESUMEN La cuenca media del Duero conoció durante la Segunda Edad del Hierro un sistema de ocupación del espacio caracterizado por núcleos grandes y distantes entre sí, sin apenas aldeas dependientes, y con un ur- banismo bien planificado. Se propone que este modelo se originó por concentración, estimulada y dirigida, de las aldeas del grupo Soto de Medinilla, a lo largo del siglo IV a.C., como resultado de un incremento de la producción, tal vez debido a la generalización de la reja de arado de hierro, lo que permitió el autoabas- tecimiento de las concentraciones urbanas aprovechando las amplias vegas y campiñas, que se ocuparon selectivamente. Esto sugiere que era un modelo de poblamiento de baja densidad poblacional, que no agotó la capacidad de carga del territorio. Se estudia la evolución del poblamiento, que permanecería estable hasta las guerras de Sertorio y Pompeyo al finalizar el primer cuarto del siglo I a.C., cuando desaparecie- ron la mitad de las ciudades. Las que sobrevivieron, constituyeron la base del entramado urbano de época romana. PALABRAS CLAVE: Valle Medio del Duero. Segunda Edad del Hierro. Vacceos. Oppida. Fortificaciones. ABSTRACT During the Second Iron Age, the occupation of space in the Duero central basin was characterized by large, well-planned settlements, distant from each other and with hardly any dependent small villages.
    [Show full text]
  • Redalyc.ESPACIOS Y FRONTERAS EN EL DISCURSO TERRITORIAL
    Studia Historica, Historia Medieval ISSN: 0213-2060 [email protected] Universidad de Salamanca España MONSALVO ANTÓN, José M.ª ESPACIOS Y FRONTERAS EN EL DISCURSO TERRITORIAL DEL REINO DE ASTURIAS (DEL CANTÁBRICO AL DUERO EN LAS CRÓNICAS ASTURIANAS) Studia Historica, Historia Medieval, vol. 23, 2005, pp. 43-87 Universidad de Salamanca Salamanca, España Disponible en: http://www.redalyc.org/articulo.oa?id=367539027002 Cómo citar el artículo Número completo Sistema de Información Científica Más información del artículo Red de Revistas Científicas de América Latina, el Caribe, España y Portugal Página de la revista en redalyc.org Proyecto académico sin fines de lucro, desarrollado bajo la iniciativa de acceso abierto ISSN: 0213-2060 ESPACIOS Y FRONTERAS EN EL DISCURSO TERRITORIAL DEL REINO DE ASTURIAS (DEL CANTÁBRICO AL DUERO EN LAS CRÓNICAS ASTURIANAS) Areas and Frontiers in the Territorial Discourse of the Kingdom of Asturias (from the Cantabrian Sea to the Duero River in the Crónicas Asturianas) José M.ª MONSALVO ANTÓN Depto. de Historia Medieval, Moderna y Contemporánea. Facultad de Geografía e Historia. Universidad de Salamanca. C/ Cervantes, 3. E-37002 SALAMANCA. C. e.: [email protected] BIBLID [0213-2060(2005)23;43-87] RESUMEN: El presente trabajo se plantea comprender cómo son descritos en las Crónicas Asturianas los espacios que formaban el Reino de Asturias en los siglos VIII y IX. Se intenta averiguar si había una lógica en el discurso territorial, tanto en lo que se refiere a las regiones septentrionales del Astororum Regnum como el que afecta a las áreas ganadas al enemigo al sur de la cordillera, que constituyeron una “frontera” en la meseta castellana.
    [Show full text]
  • Manifiesto De La Alhambra English
    Fernando Chueca Goitia and others The Alhambra Manifesto (1953) Translated by Jacob Moore Word Count: 2,171 Source: Manifiesto de la Alhambra (Madrid, Dirección General de Arquitectura, 1953). Republished as El Manifiesto de la Alhambra: 50 años después: el monumento y la arquitectura contemporánea, ed. Ángel Isac, (Granada: Patronato de la Alhambra y Generalife, Consejería de Cultura, Junta de Andalucía : Tf Editores, 2006) 356-375. We, the signers of this Manifesto, do not want to be pure iconoclasts, for we are already too weary of such abrupt and arbitrary turns. So people will say: “Why the need for a Manifesto, a term which, almost by definition, implies a text that is dogmatic and revolutionary, one that breaks from the past, a public declaration of a new credo?” Simply put, because reality, whose unequivocal signs leave no room for doubt, is showing us that the ultimate traditionalist posture, which architecture adopted after the war of Liberation, can already no longer be sustained and its tenets are beginning to fall apart. […] Today the moment of historical resurrections has passed. There is no use denying it; just as one cannot deny the existence of the Renaissance in its time or that of the nineteenth century archaeological revivals. The arts have tired of hackneyed academic models and of cold, lifeless copies, and seek new avenues of expression that, though lacking the perfection of those that are known, are more radical and authentic. But one must also not forget that the peculiar conditions implicit in all that is Spanish require that, within the global historical movement, we move forward, we would not say with a certain prudence, but yes, adjusting realities in our own way.
    [Show full text]
  • Myth of a Christian Europe and the Massacre in Norway
    Commentaries SEPTEMBER 11, 1683: MYTH OF A CHRISTIAN EUROPE AND THE MASSACRE IN NORWAY September 11, 1683: Myth of a Christian Europe and the Massacre in Norway ŞENER AKTÜRK* ABSTRACT he cause of Anders Breivik’s This essay critically approaches the massacre in Norway, which he impact of September 11, 2001 attacks Tstated rather verbosely in his in galvanizing the myth of a Christian fifteen hundred pages long manifesto, Europe, a myth that provided the 2083: A European Declaration of In- ideological justification for the dependence, was ignored in the me- recent massacre in Norway. The myth dia: The myth of a “Christian Europe” making around the failed Ottoman based on the identification of the Euro- siege of Vienna in 1683, an event that provided the inspiration for Anders pean continent solely with Christianity. Breivik’s fifteen hundred pages This is a malicious and mythical claim long anti-Muslim manifesto, 2083: A that has been calamitously employed European Declaration of Independence, throughout history in most episodes of comes under scrutiny. The author ethnic cleansing against non-Christians argues that Europe has been, not in Europe, from the expulsion of Jews only a Christian, but also a Jewish and and Muslims from Spain in 1492 to the Muslim continent for many centuries, genocidal campaign against Bosnian using examples from the centuries- Muslims in the 1990s. Hence Breivik old history of Islamic civilization in chose 2083, the 400th anniversary of France, Greece, Hungary, Italy, Poland, the Ottomans’ failed siege of Vienna, and Spain, among other European countries. The author draws attention and the beginning of 240 years of Otto- not only to the total annihilation of man retreat in Europe, as the title of his historical Muslim communities in manifesto, which can be described as places such as Sicily and Spain, but the Mein Kampf or the Turner Diaries also to the nearly total eradication of a European Islamophobe.
    [Show full text]
  • The Masters of Calatrava and the Castilian Civil War 1350-1369
    The Masters of Calatrava and the Castilian Civil War 1350-1369 BY JOSEPH F. O'CALLAGHAN Düring the third quarter of the fourteenth Century the bitter civil war between King Pedro the Cruel (1350-1369) and his half-brother, Count Enrique of Trastamara, tore the kingdom of Castile asunder, dividing its leaders and people, allowing no one the privilege of neutrality. Prominent among the participants in the conflict were the masters of the military Order of Calatrava who, together with the masters of Santiago and Alcäntara, ranked among the great men of the realm. As the war progressed, the king and his challenger endeavored to control magisterial elections and, through them, the immense resources that the Order of Calatrava possessed in the modern provinces of Ciudad Real, Jaen, Cordoba, Seville, and so forth. The consequence was schism within the Order, the diversion of its interest and wealth to domestic politics rather than the reconquest, and an increasing brutalization of life, typified by the execution of one master by Pedro and another by Enrique. Above all, the civil war pointed up the crown's growing awareness of the need to subject all the military Orders to effective royal control. ^ Juan Nünez de Prado At the time of Pedro the CruePs accession to the throne in March 1350 at the youthful age of sixteen years, Juan Nünez de Prado was the master of Calatrava. The illegitimate son of a knight named Carpintero and Bianca, senora of Las Huelgas and daughter of King Afonso III of Portugal (1248-1279), he was legitimated in 1313, on his mother's request, 2 by Pope Clement V, and entered the Order of Calatrava.
    [Show full text]
  • Functionalism and Caprice in Stonecutting. the Case of the Nativity Chapel in Burgos Cathedral
    Proceedings of the Third International Congress on Construction History, Cottbus, May 2009 Functionalism and Caprice in Stonecutting. The Case of the Nativity Chapel in Burgos Cathedral Miguel Ángel Alonso Rodríguez, Ana López Mozo, José Carlos Palacios Gonzalo, Enrique Rabasa Díaz Technical University of Madrid, Spain José Calvo-López Polytechnic University of Cartagena, Spain Alberto Sanjurjo Álvarez San Pablo-CEU University, Madrid, Spain ABSTRACT: Starting from the inaugural text of Philibert de L'Orme, stereotomic treatises and manuscripts are subject to the opposing forces of reason and fancy. The Nativity Chapel in Burgos Cathedral provides an outstanding case study on this subject. It was built in 1571-1582 by Martín de Bérriz and Martín de la Haya, using an oval vault resting on trumpet squinches to span a rectangular bay. Bed joints and rib axes are not planar curves, as usual in oval vaults. This warping is not capricious; we shall argue that it is the outcome of a systematic tracing method. As a result of this process, the slope of the bed joints increases slightly in the first courses, but stays fairly constant after the third course; this solution prevents the upper courses from slipping. Thus, in the Nativity Chapel of Burgos Cathedral, the constraints of masonry construction fostered a singular solution verging on capriccio. It is also worthwhile to remark that the warping of the joints is not easily appreciable to the eye and that the tracing process does not seem to start from a previous conception of the resulting form. All this suggests that we should be quite careful when talking about the whimsical character of Late Gothic and Early Renaissance; in some occasions, apparent caprice is the offspring of practical thinking.
    [Show full text]
  • The Self-Coronations of Iberian Kings: a Crooked Line
    THE SELF-Coronations OF IBERIAN KINGS: A CROOKED LINE JAUME AURELL UNIVERSIDAD DE NAVARRA SpaIN Date of receipt: 10th of March, 2012 Final date of acceptance: 4th of March, 2014 ABSTRACT This article focuses on the practice of self-coronation among medieval Iberian Castilian kings and its religious, political, and ideological implications. The article takes Alfonso XI of Castile self-coronation (1332) as a central event, and establishes a conceptual genealogy, significance, and relevance of this self-coronation, taking Visigothic, Asturian, Leonese, and Castilian chronicles as a main source, and applying political theology as a methodology. The gesture of self-coronation has an evident transgressive connotation which deserves particular attention, and could throw some light upon the traditional debate on the supposed “un-sacred” kingship of Castilian kings1. KEY WORDS Coronation, Unction, Castile, Monarchy, Political Theology. CAPITALIA VERBA Coronatio, Unctio, Castella, Monarchia, Theologia politica. IMAGO TEMPORIS. MEDIUM AEVUM, VIII (2014) 151-175. ISSN 1888-3931 151 152 JAUME AURELL 1Historians have always been fascinated by the quest for origins. Alfonso XI of Castile and Peter IV of Aragon’s peculiar and transgressive gestures of self-coronation in the fourteenth century are very familiar to us, narrated in detail as they are in their respective chronicles2. Yet, their ritual transgression makes us wonder why they acted in this way, whether there were any precedents for this particular gesture, and to what extent they were aware of the different rates at which the anointing and coronation ceremonies were introduced into their own kingdoms, in their search for justification of the self-coronation3.
    [Show full text]
  • Al-Andalus' Lessons for Contemporary European
    IMMIGRATION, JUSTICE AND SOCIETY AL-ANDALUS’ LESSONS FOR CONTEMPORARY EUROPEAN MODELS OF INTEGRATION MYRIAM FRANÇOIS • BETHSABÉE SOURIS www.europeanreform.org @europeanreform Established by Margaret Thatcher, New Direction is Europe’s leading free market political foundation & publisher with offices in Brussels, London, Rome & Warsaw. New Direction is registered in Belgium as a not-for-profit organisation and is partly funded by the European Parliament. REGISTERED OFFICE: Rue du Trône, 4, 1000 Brussels, Belgium. EXECUTIVE DIRECTOR: Naweed Khan. www.europeanreform.org @europeanreform The European Parliament and New Direction assume no responsibility for the opinions expressed in this publication. Sole liability rests with the author. AUTHORS TABLE OF CONTENTS 1 INTRODUCTION 6 2 AL-ANDALUS’ MODEL OF INTEGRATION 8 2.1 THE IBERIAN HISTORY FROM THE MUSLIM CONQUEST TO THE RECONQUISTA 10 2.1.1 Visigoth Spain 11 2.1.2 The Muslim advance in Arabia and Northern Africa 11 2.1.3 The conquest of Spain 12 2.1.4 The unstable first years of the Umayyad dynasty 14 2.1.5 The golden ages of the Caliphate of Cordoba 14 2.1.6 The fall of the Caliphate of Cordoba 16 2.1.7 The end of Al-Andalus and the Reconquista 16 2.2 2.2 THE SOCIAL MODEL OF INTEGRATION OF AL-ANDALUS 18 2.2.1 The social and religious landscape 19 2.2.2 Controversy over the meaning of ‘convivencia’ 19 2.2.3 Protection of religious’ communities boundaries 21 2.2.4 Towards an increased integration and acculturation: The Arabization of the non-Muslim communities 22 2.2.5 The cultural impact of the convivencia 25 Myriam François Bethsabée Souris 2.2.6 Limits of coexistence 26 Dr Myiam Francois is a journalist and academic with a Bethsabée Souris is a PhD candidate in Political Science at 3 TODAY’S EUROPEAN MODELS OF MUSLIM INTEGRATION 28 focus on France and the Middle East.
    [Show full text]