Chapter- III the Alienated Self in Agha Shahid Ali and Mahmoud Darwish's
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Chapter- III The Alienated self in Agha Shahid Ali and Mahmoud Darwish’s Poetry Alienation, despair and unrest are the most dominant themes in the modern English poetry. It basically emanates from a particular socio political environment where writers and poets feel marginalized and the dissent continues to be choked by the ruthless ruling class. The term Alienation involves some sort of separation; some relationship or connection that once existed, that is natural, desirable, or good, has been lost. The subject of separation can be either of a person from something or of something from something else. It is used to characterize the economic, social and political structure when that is felt to be oppressive or unrelated to one's longing desire or interests. But alienation also refers to the state of mind in which an individual experiences himself as an alien and estranged at home or away. The term ―alienation‖ refers basically to the displacement of something from one location to another. Many literary critics believe that there are many perennial ailments in the modern society responsible to it, while as others considered it as the objective fact of man‘s life in society. Alienation in terms of emotional isolation or disassociation has been a very common theme in the popular genre of English literature i.e. English poetry. The reason behind it, many opine, is the better future, unresolved conflicts, ongoing wars, spiritual bankruptcy and hollow sophistication which has taken deep roots in our everyday mechanical life. The Encyclopedia Britannica defines alienation as "the state of feeling estranged or separated from ones milieu, work, and products of work or self". The word Alienation is actually derived from the Latin words alius, alienus meaning ―other,‖ is fundamentally different from loneliness or solitude. The sensation arises from being physically close to –but spiritually distant from ----other people. In general sense it means ‗turning away or keeping away from former friends or associates.‘ Oxford Advanced Learner‘s Dictionary of Current English gives two meanings of the verb ‗alienate‘- i) to lose or destroy the friendship, support, sympathy, etc. and ii) to cause somebody to feel different from others and not part of a group.(1988:17) 58 Different interpreters of alienation have given different definitions. According to Arnold Kaufman, ―To claim that a person is alienated is to claim that his relation to something else has certain features which result in avoidable discontent or loss of satisfaction‖ (1970). Feur Lewis says ―........ the word alienation is used to convey the emotional tone which accompanies any behavior in which the person is compelled to act self destructively‖. Keniston views that ―Most usages of alienation share the assumption that some relationship or connection that once existed that is ‗natural‘, desirable or good, has been lost‖(1965). According to Hegel there are two types of alienation. The first type of alienation arises due to man‘s individuality or incompatibility in his personality and social substance. The second type of alienation is of the same level as the alienation expounded by Rousseau etc., in the principle of ‗Social contract‘ in which the theme of surrender or transfer of any right is vested. According to Hegel, the situation arises when a change occurs in man‘s concept of ‗self‘. The second type of alienation is permanent and from this we can control the first type. Karl Marx however puts forth a very comprehensive and complex idea of alienation that comprises various extrinsic dimensions of human existence in socio-economic context. His concept of alienation is often classified in the following manners: 1. Political Alienation 2. Economic Alienation Marx says about political alienation: ―The state does not care about Individual‘s existence, in a society without communion between people and that individual in his relation to such a state does not experience a feeling of solidarity, he is only able to relate himself to it as an isolated monad, an individual. He finds the concepts related to state faulty for political alienation. However the theory of alienation explained by the German philosophers and thinkers like Hegel, and Karl Marx explained alienation explicitly. In the post-colonial epoch, the forced or voluntarily migration and post-industrial experience phenomena has made the term ‗Alienation‘ the main feature of the twentieth century world literature. In the conflict zones where usually people live on the edge are torn between the internal conflict and external conflict or the self versus society feel more 59 alienated than others. Those who faced ethnic cleansing, mass migrations, forcefully dispossession in the host countries because of their cultural as well as political identity. They couldn‘t assimilate in the popular culture which escalates this extreme alienation with every passing day. The sense of exile is purely a psychological and spiritual while the geographical dislocation is just a physical condition. The external exile can be easily suppressed in a global village that facilitates the feeling of being at home anywhere in the cosmopolitan urban quarters of the world. This sense of alienation is more evident in the writings of diaspora writers, who are caught up between the cultural spaces of the host land and their identity. The dislocation and to locate their culture in an alien culture pushes these writers on the margins of two countries. The Indian diaspora which is a largest diaspora in the world also suffers the same fate while anticipating the host country and homeland. However the diaspora writers play a very important part in the galaxy of Indian writing in English which over the period of time has emerged as a unique variety of English literature. They face criticism by the nativists over leaving their country and serving in a foreign land. They blame them of hypocrisy who for better opportunity and good fortunes left their homeland. For these writers better future became important than the sense of being alienated or exile. In some case the internal political circumstances and the geographical reality, repressive regimes in their homeland force many Diaspora voices to express this sense of exile and alienation in the form of verse and prose. Their imaginations as well as their works are caught up in national identity and stagnant political limbos that are deep rooted in the trajectories of colonial history. This diaspora experience can be easily understood by this excerpt from Salman Rushdie: It may be said that writers in any position, exiles or emigrants or expatriates, are haunted by some sense of loss, some urge to reclaim, to look back, even at the risk of being mutated into pillars of salt. But if we do look back, we must also do so in the knowledge---which gives rise to profound uncertainties---that our physical alienation from India almost inevitably means that we will not be capable 60 of reclaiming precisely the thing that we will not be capable of reclaiming precisely the thing that was lost; that we will, in short, create fictions, not actual cities, or villages, but invisible ones, imaginary homelands, Indian of the mind. (1991,Imaginary homelands) Either the diaspora writers or native writers they project the collective consciousness of third world embroiled in the name of identity, counter discourse to the totalitarian Orientalism and hegemonic use of English. Being a late product of the world literature modern Indian English Poetry is still oscillating in between tradition and modernity. And for the diaspora poets there seems to be no escape from the pre-exilic state as they continue to struggle even in the aftermaths of exile and the rootlessness. This rootlessness and nostalgia according to William Saffron becomes the main reason for academic growth industry. Indian English diaspora poetry is one such example where poets instead of achievements and good fortune are still unable to forget their roots or Indian culture. They live with it and celebrate its ethos in the foreign lands before a different audience. Their poetry mark the theme of exile and their divided loyalty between the host country and homeland but it proves if not only mentally, physically they feel alienated and isolated. The post independence period was undoubtedly the most important turning point in the Indian English poetry. It differs from the earlier era because it reflected a moving away from the traditionalist in terms of theme and modes of expression. This was due to the unprecedented changes in the socio-economic and political milieu of the country, and, secondly, because of the rise of modernism in Indian literature in English. Indian poetry in English has been sensitive to these changes given the social and political climate in India. All these factors brought a considerable change in the style and pattern of Indian poetry in English that too on modernist lines. The contemporary Indian English poets write with a sense of analysis, interpretation and evaluation of the contemporary social, political and economic realities that reflect their response to the flux of experiences. It‘s no more slavishly imitates the British or American poets as they have developed now their own style of narration. 61 The 20th Century authors of English poetry in India include Dilip Chitre, Kamala Das, Eunice De Souza, Nissim Ezekiel, KersyKatrak, ArunKolatkar, P. Lal, Jayanta Mahapatra, Dom Moraes, Gieve Patel, and A. K. Ramanujan, and among several others. They represent a spectrum of cosmopolitan positions, in which numerous explicitly Indian elements interact with western ones and traditional sub continental conventions and codes modify and are modified by modern ones. (Haq, Kaiser, 1990) Today the galaxy of Indian English poetry is much larger and more varied than it was ever before. The new poets have found appropriate techniques for their perception of reality, range, variety and themes.