Orzech, Charles D
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
H-Buddhism Orzech, Charles D. Page published by A. Charles Muller on Tuesday, November 17, 2020 Teachers of an Accidental Buddhist Studies Scholar: on Good Friends 善知識kalyāṇa-mitra Charles D. Orzech When Chuck Prebish contacted me about this project it occurred to me that his aim was to capture a more fine-grained picture of the assimilation of Buddhism in North America during the second half of the twentieth century. It is also—in effect—a group portrait or an autobiography of a generation of Buddhist teachers, scholars, and practitioners. I hope that when complete these self-portraits might serve as data for a larger analysis. Thinking about this assignment off and on for some time I also am reminded of one of John McRae’s rules of Zen Studies (I teach a course on Chan and Zen and use McRae). Rule number two reads, “Lineage assertions are as wrong as they are strong” (John R. McRae, Seeing Through Zen, xix). McRae then adds that if the lineage claims can be shown to be genuine they are probably insignificant. If we have learned anything in the last fifty years of Zen studies it is that Chan/Son/Zen traditions are under continual construction and reconstruction under the scaffolding of lineage. Almost every scholar of Buddhism or Buddhist practitioner I have met will at some point make a bow to their Buddhist ancestors. Should we be under any illusion that our ancestral invocations are fundamentally different that those of the eleventh century? The living construct the present out of the past. This is not in any way to call this effort into question. Rather, it is a reflection on the contingent and always situated nature of our knowledge. Will some future Buddhist construct lineages out of what were, for me, accidental and happenstance encounters? I am taking this assignment in a personal direction, and not as a narrative CV. I grew up in a family of Catholic Polish and French Canadian mill workers in central Massachusetts. Neither of my parents graduated from high school. My father had been in Japan with the occupation. The family lore is that he was the sergeant in charge of the Yokohama liquor warehouse that supplied officer’s clubs in Tokyo. Perhaps the album of small faded black and white photos from his tour of duty in Japan made some kind of impression on me. Later in life I repeatedly offered to take Citation: A. Charles Muller. Orzech, Charles D.. H-Buddhism. 11-17-2020. https://networks.h-net.org/node/6060/pages/6796127/orzech-charles-d Licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License. 1 H-Buddhism him to Japan, but he would not go. In high school I was a science geek, and though I went to college I had no clearly formulated goal other than having fun. Starting at the University of Massachusetts in 1970 I began to take classes toward an Astronomy and Astrophysics major only to discover my shortcomings, and those of my high school science curriculum. Without sufficient background in chemistry I would have flunked Planetary Atmospheres had I not decided to drop. Two things intervened that pushed me toward Buddhism. I had chosen to live in Project 10, a “Living-Learning” environment based in Pierpont House in U Mass’s Southwest complex. Teresina Rowell Havens—then in her sixties—was teachingTaiji . It was only many years later that I read her"The Background and Early Use of the Buddhakṣetra Concept” (Eastern Buddhist 6: 1933: 199–246, 379–431; and 7: 1936: 131–145). Also, a number of friends I had made in the dorm were deeply into various strains of the occult. One of them, my roommate Rick Taupier, would later go on to a career in geographic information systems and, more recently, a second Ph.D. in history with a focus on Mongolian Buddhism. The writings of Alice Bailey, Aleister Crowley, and Alfred Percy Sinnett (Esoteric Buddhism, London: Trubner, 1883) presented an enticing, but rather strange, introduction to Buddhism and Hinduism. However peculiar such an entrée might seem it is clear that various strains of the occult nurtured in colonial encounters were still helping to seed an interest in Buddhism across Europe and America in the 1960s and 1970s. By the next semester I had signed up for a philosophy course on “Metaphysics” (not at all what I had naively imagined!) and a comparative literature course titled “Mysticism East and West.” This course, taught by Lucien Miller, cemented my interest in religion. I asked him what professional opportunities might be available—he noted that I could become an academic, and if I was serious I should start Chinese immediately. It took another year but in the summer of 1973 I began Mandarin at Middlebury College’s intensive summer school. In the meantime I realized that I could not do a religious studies major at UMass because there was no such department. However, Smith College did have an excellent department, and the Five College Consortium would allow me to take courses there. As a result I proposed an independent major at UMass in the Bachelor’s Degree with Individual Concentration program with a focus on East Asian Languages and Religion. My advisors were Lucien Miller at UMass and Denis Hudson, the Hinduism professor at Smith. I started Classical Chinese with Alvin P. Cohen (a student of Peter Alexis Boodberg at Berkeley) aiming to be able to read Chinese Buddhist texts. I had the privilege to Citation: A. Charles Muller. Orzech, Charles D.. H-Buddhism. 11-17-2020. https://networks.h-net.org/node/6060/pages/6796127/orzech-charles-d Licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License. 2 H-Buddhism take a year long Hinduism course with Denis Hudson and Buddhism with Taitesu Unno. I was now becoming more serious about the study of Buddhism. I moved off campus with a new roommate, and on our refrigerator we posted a segment of “The Repulsiveness of Food” from the Visuddhimagga (as translated in Edward Conze’s Buddhist Meditation 1956, 100-103). We soon realized that a young Tibetan Buddhism scholar, Robert Thurman, had joined the faculty at Amherst College, and my roommate and I signed up for his introduction to Literary Tibetan. The class started out with four of us, but soon the two Amherst students dropped leaving my roommate and I struggling with Tibetan in Bob’s office. I was not the most assiduous student, and Tibetan seemed doubly difficult as we were using Foucaux’s Grammaire de la Langue Tibétaine (Paris, 1858)! During the next two years Thurman’s fledgling American Institute of Buddhist Studies began more ambitious programing, and invited Dodrupchen Rinpoche, a Nyingma lama then living in Sikkhim to help establish The Mahasiddha Nyingmapa Center in Western Massachusetts. It was a crash course in the reality of practice--- seemingly endless chanting of the praises of Guru Rinpoche (Padmasambhava)! Still following Lucien Miller’s advice, I applied to graduate schools. I became more interested in the History of Religions program at the University of Chicago and in the program at the University of Wisconsin, and I went for a visit in late 1973, staying with a friend from UMass, Dan Brown, who would go on to write a dissertation on Tibetan meditative texts. I talked to faculty at Chicago including Dean Joseph Kitagawa and Edward Dimock, and I also made a side trip to sit in on Stephen Beyer’s Buddhism class in Madison. Chicago admitted me to the master of divinity program, and gave me a partial scholarship so, in the Fall of 1974, I was in Chicago. Chicago at the time was stocked with luminaries: Mircea Eliade, Robert Grant, David Tracy, Joseph Kitagawa, Jonathan Z. Smith, etc. The Masters program was designed to replicate the sort of training that students used to get with a Bachelor of Divinity degree, and was structured around a series of qualifying exams, mostly focused on the history of Christianity and theory in the study of religion. This training was excellent preparation for working in a small department where one is called on to teach courses such as Introduction to Religion, as well as Non-Western Religions and Buddhism. While pursuing the MA I enrolled in Frank Reynold’s Buddhism course during which I wrote a research paper arguing that Dignāga’s poetic preface to his treatise on perception (Hattori’sDignāga, on perception; being the Citation: A. Charles Muller. Orzech, Charles D.. H-Buddhism. 11-17-2020. https://networks.h-net.org/node/6060/pages/6796127/orzech-charles-d Licensed under a Creative Commons Attribution-Noncommercial-No Derivative Works 3.0 United States License. 3 H-Buddhism Pratyakṣapariccheda of Dignāga's Pramāṇasamuccaya from the Sanskrit fragments and the Tibetan versions, HUP 1968) should be taken as more than a perfunctory bow to religious sensibilities, and seen as a serious piece of religious argumentation. I also continued classical Chinese with David Roy in East Asian Languages and Civilizations, and took a course on Scripture with Jonathan Z. Smith that was to be influential in my approach to Buddhism. The following year I completed the Masters (December 1975) and applied for and was accepted into the Ph.D. Program in the History of Religions. At this point I decided to return to UMass to begin studying Japanese. On my return to Chicago I enrolled T. H. Tsien’s Chinese Bibliography course, Michael Dalby’s course on Six Dynasties Religion, and Joseph Kitagawa’s course on Patterns of Worship.