DOCSLIB.ORG

Economic Benefits of Nutrient Reductions in Utah's Waters

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Economic Benefits of Nutrient Reductions in Utah's Waters Economic Benefits of Nutrient Reductions in Utah’s Waters State of Utah Prepared by in association with April 2013 FINAL REPORT Economic Benefits of Nutrient Reductions in Utah’s Waters April 2013 Prepared for: State of Utah Utah Division of Water Quality 195 North 1950 West DEQ Third Floor PO Box 144870 Salt Lake City, UT 84114-4870 Prepared by: Paul Jakus, Utah State University Mary Jo Kealy, CH2M HILL John Loomis, Colorado State University Nanette Nelson, University of Wyoming Survey and Analysis Center Jeff Ostermiller, Utah Division of Water Quality Cody Stanger, CH2M HILL Nicholas von Stackelberg, Utah Division of Water Quality Executive Summary (Under Separate Cover) Contents Section Page Abbreviations and Acronyms .............................................................................................................................. vii 1.0 Introduction ............................................................................................................................................... 1‐1 1.1 The Contribution of Water‐Based Recreation to the Utah Economy ............................................. 1‐1 1.2 The Environmental Problem—Excess Nutrients in Surface Waters ................................................ 1‐1 1.3 Costs of Nutrient Criteria Implementation ...................................................................................... 1‐2 1.4 The Benefit Study ............................................................................................................................ 1‐2 2.0 Types of Benefits Arising from Improved Water Quality ............................................................................. 2‐1 2.1 Use Values ....................................................................................................................................... 2‐1 2.2 Passive Use Values ........................................................................................................................... 2‐1 2.3 Total Economic Value ...................................................................................................................... 2‐1 2.4 Definition of Economic Value .......................................................................................................... 2‐2 2.5 Techniques to Estimate WTP for Water Quality .............................................................................. 2‐2 2.5.1 Stated Preference Methods Including Contingent Valuation Method ............................... 2‐2 2.5.2 Hypothetical Bias in CVM ................................................................................................... 2‐3 2.6 Review of the Economic Benefits of Water Quality Literature ....................................................... 2‐4 2.6.1 Local WTP for Improving Water Quality of Specific Water Resources ............................... 2‐4 2.6.2 Statewide WTP for Improving Water Quality of Specific Water Resources ....................... 2‐5 2.6.3 Statewide WTP for Improving Water Quality of State Water Resources ........................... 2‐6 2.6.4 Nationwide WTP to Avoid a Regional Reduction in Water Quality .................................... 2‐6 2.6.5 Nationwide WTP for Nationwide Improvement in Water Quality ..................................... 2‐6 3.0 Designing the Questionnaires ..................................................................................................................... 3‐1 3.1 The Total Economic Value Questionnaire ....................................................................................... 3‐1 3.1.1 Structure of the TEV Questionnaire ................................................................................... 3‐1 3.1.2 The Science Used to Develop the Valuation Scenario ........................................................ 3‐3 3.1.3 Specifying How the Respondent Will Pay and the Willingness to Pay Question ................ 3‐5 3.1.4 Focus Groups and Pretests ................................................................................................. 3‐5 3.2 The Recreation Questionnaire ......................................................................................................... 3‐6 3.2.1 Structure of the Recreation Questionnaire ........................................................................ 3‐6 3.2.2 The Science Behind the Water Quality Attributes in the Recreation Survey ..................... 3‐7 3.2.3 Focus Group and Pretesting ............................................................................................... 3‐8 4.0 Administering the Surveys .......................................................................................................................... 4‐1 4.1 Sampling, Field Period, and Participation Rates for the TEV Survey ............................................... 4‐1 4.2 Sampling, Field Period, and Participation Rates for the Recreation Survey .................................... 4‐2 4.3 Weighting ......................................................................................................................................... 4‐3 4.4 Summary .......................................................................................................................................... 4‐4 5.0 Analysis of Total Economic Value ................................................................................................................ 5‐1 5.1 Demographic Comparison of Users versus Non‐Users of Utah’s Surface Water Resources ........... 5‐1 5.2 Statistical Model of WTP ................................................................................................................. 5‐3 5.3 Statistical Results ............................................................................................................................. 5‐6 5.4 Economic Benefit Estimates ............................................................................................................ 5‐8 5.5 Generalizing the Sample WTP to the Utah Population ................................................................... 5‐9 5.6 Present Value of Benefits ................................................................................................................ 5‐9 ES062712232531SLC\UTAHDWQ_STATEWIDEBENEFITS_RPT_V2_KM _MJK EO.DOCX iii CONTENTS (CONTINUED) 5.7 Interpretation of Results in Relation to the Study Objectives ....................................................... 5‐10 5.8 Conclusions .................................................................................................................................... 5‐11 6.0 Analysis of Water‐Based Recreation Demand ............................................................................................. 6‐1 6.1 Lake and River Recreation in Utah .................................................................................................. 6‐1 6.2 A Brief Introduction to the Travel Cost Model ................................................................................ 6‐7 6.3 Review of the Relevant Literature ................................................................................................... 6‐9 6.4 Recreational Site Characteristics ................................................................................................... 6‐13 6.5 Implementing the Travel Cost Model: Econometric Issues ........................................................... 6‐16 6.5.1 The Conditional Logit “Site Choice” Model ...................................................................... 6‐16 6.5.2 A Nested Logit Model ....................................................................................................... 6‐17 6.5.3 A Poisson “Total Trips” Model .......................................................................................... 6‐18 6.5.4 Summary of the Econometric Model ............................................................................... 6‐19 6.6 Empirical Results ............................................................................................................................ 6‐19 6.6.1 Preliminary Issues ............................................................................................................. 6‐19 6.6.2 Balancing the Tradeoffs: An Initial Model Specification ................................................... 6‐20 6.6.3 Model Results: Day Trips .................................................................................................. 6‐23 6.6.4 Overnight Trips ................................................................................................................. 6‐27 6.6.5 Model Selection ................................................................................................................ 6‐30 6.7 Benefits Estimation ........................................................................................................................ 6‐32 6.8 Summary ........................................................................................................................................ 6‐36 7.0 Nuisance Algae Threshold for Recreation and Aesthetics ............................................................................ 7‐1 7.1 Background ...................................................................................................................................... 7‐1 7.2 Methods ........................................................................................................................................... 7‐2 7.3 Results .............................................................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • 6.19.2016 Display.Indd
    www.slenterprise.com June 19, 2017 Volume 46, Number 46 $1.50 OF NOTE Panelist: We have enough workforce programs At the Salt Lake Chamber event, pan- can’t afford the risk of diluting ourselves Brice Wallace elists discussed programs at universities, further. Everybody knows this is an impor- The Enterprise high schools, the Governor’s Offi ce of Eco- tant topic and there are enough great orga- nomic Development, the Utah Department nizations and programs in existence today A gathering last week to discuss edu- of Workforce Services and industries and that I feel like we don’t need to go create cational approaches to solve workforce is- businesses. Perhaps there are too many, ac- more.” sues featured many oft-told ideas: Getting cording to Vance Checketts, vice president Checketts said he prefers to see better kids excited about various career options of Utah operations for Dell EMC, who said coordination and a stronger focus for suc- earlier. Having youngsters and their parents some programs are good but others are not cessful programs. He said he is hopeful that understand that manufacturing and other very effective and should face elimination. Talent Ready Utah can serve as a clearing- trades are clean and safe, countering current “The fi rst thing we need to do is not house or forum for all the initiatives across misperceptions. Pushing for more diversity start any new ones,” Checketts said. “That the state. Quarter (mile) pounder in the workforce. sounds kind of like maybe I’m a downer “We don’t need new programs, and But one panelist stood out by calling here, but, oh my goodness, there are so yet a lot of the existing programs proba- Fiat Chrysler is getting back into for fewer — not more — programs to ad- many great initiatives and so many great the muscle car business — and in dress workforce needs.
    [Show full text]
  • A Study of Dentist Workforce Supply Estimates, Trends, and Capacity to Provide Service
    Utah’s Dentist Workforce: A study of dentist workforce supply estimates, trends, and capacity to provide service Utah Medical Education Council December 2002 Utah’s Dentist Workforce: A study of dentist workforce supply estimates, trends, and capacity to provide service Prepared by Matt Horstmann, Health Policy Analyst Utah Medical Education Council December 2002 Acknowledgements Utah’s Dentist Workforce: A study of dentist workforce supply estimates, trends, and capacity to provide service was funded by the Utah Medical Education Council. The data in this report was made available through the professional efforts of various state, federal, and private organizations. Special appreciation is given to the following individuals for their expertise and assistance. Steven Steed, DDS Susan Aldous, RDH State Dental Director Dental Access Consultant Utah Department of Health Utah Department of Health Lynn Powell, DDS Wayne Cottam, DMD, MS Assistant Dean, School of Medicine Dental Director University of Utah School of Medicine Community Health Centers Inc. Kathleen Hardy, MPA Don Hawley, DDS, MPA Research Analyst Program Coordinator Utah Office of Primary Care Utah Department of Health, and Rural Health Division of Health Care Financing Further Acknowledgement and appreciation is given to the staff and consulting members of the Utah Medical Education Council: Gar Elison, M.L.S. David Squire, M.P.A Executive Director Chief Financial Officer Brenda Silverman, Ph.D. Julie Olsen Staff Consultant Administrative Assistant Dan Bergantz Jennifer Ha Research Analyst Research Analyst Clint Elison Mike Bronson Research Analyst Research Analyst Boyd Chappell Research Analyst This report can be reproduced and distributed without permission. Board Members of the Medical Education Council Chair W.
    [Show full text]
  • Early Childhood Services Study
    EARLY CHILDHOOD SERVICES STUDY 2017 General Session SB 100 December 31, 2017 WORKFORCE SERVICES CHILD CARE CONTENTS Executive Summary ............................................................................................................ 5 Introduction ........................................................................................................................ 8 A Framework for Early Childhood in Utah ........................................................................ 12 Early Childhood State Systems......................................................................................... 21 Key Programmatic Components of Family Support and Safety ....................................... 27 Key Programmatic Components of Health and Development ......................................... 38 Key Programmatic Components of Early Learning .......................................................... 48 Key Programmatic Components of Economic Stability .................................................... 58 Conclusion ........................................................................................................................ 73 Appendices Appendix A. Utah County-level Single Age Population Estimates .............................. 74 Appendix B. Early Childhood State Systems ............................................................... 76 Appendix C. A Methodology for State Early Childhood Systems Gap Analysis .......... 78 Endnotes .........................................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Utah Region 41 Plan 700 MHZ Frequency Plan
    Utah Region 41 Plan 700 MHZ Frequency Plan Page 1 Contributions The Region 41 Planning Committee acknowledges the following agencies for their contributions of time, material and dollars towards completion of this plan: The National Public Safety Telecommunications Council (NPSTC) State of Utah Division of Information Technology Services State of Utah Department of Public Safety Logan City, Utah Utah Communications Agency Network City of St. George, Utah To all departments, agencies, cities and counties who attended meetings and provided input into the process. Page 2 TABLE OF CONTENTS REGIONAL CHAIRPERSON ...................................................................................4 RPC MEMBERSHIP..................................................................................................4 DESCRIPTION OF THE REGION............................................................................5 NOTIFICATION PROCESS......................................................................................9 REGIONAL PLAN ADMINISTRATION...............................................................11 UTILIZATION OF INTEROPERABILITY CHANNELS......................................13 ADDITIONAL SPECTRUM SET ASIDE FOR INTEROPERABILITY WITHIN THE REGION.....................................19 ALLOCATION OF GENERAL USE SPECTRUM ................................................19 AN EXPLANATION OF HOW NEEDS WERE ASSIGNED PRIORITIES IN AREAS WHERE NOT ALL ELIGIBLES COULD RECEIVE LICENSES ................................................................22
    [Show full text]
  • Building Blocks for a Good Life Assessing Our Community’S Needs in the Areas of Education, Income and Health TABLE of CONTENTS
    Building Blocks for a Good Life Assessing our Community’s Needs in the Areas of Education, Income and Health TABLE OF CONTENTS INTRODUCTION............................................................................................ 3 BACKGROUND.............................................................................................. 4 ASSESSMENT METHODOLOGY ...................................................................5-8 EDUCATION ............................................................................................9-28 INCOME ................................................................................................29-44 HEALTH .................................................................................................45-62 BASIC NEEDS .......................................................................................63-78 IMMIGRANT AND REFUGEE INTEGRATION .............................................79-86 APPENDIX ............................................................................................87-98 INDEX OF MEASUREMENTS EDUCATION ........................................................................................................................88-89 INCOME ..............................................................................................................................90-91 HEALTH ...............................................................................................................................92-94 BASIC .................................................................................................................................95-96
    [Show full text]
  • Migration and Life of Hispanics in Utah. PUB DATE 1998-00-00 NOTE 24P
    DOCUMENT RESUME ED 425 876 RC 021 601 AUTHOR Gallenstein, Nancy L. TITLE Migration and Life of Hispanics in Utah. PUB DATE 1998-00-00 NOTE 24p. PUB TYPE Historical Materials (060) Information Analyses (070) EDRS PRICE MF01/PC01 Plus Postage. DESCRIPTORS Church Programs; *Cultural Maintenance; Ethnic Discrimination; *Hispanic American Culture; *Hispanic Americans; Immigrants; Mexican Americans; *Migration Patterns; Population Growth; Social Organizations; Social Support Groups; *Sociocultural Patterns; Spanish Speaking; *State History IDENTIFIERS Sense of Community; *Utah ABSTRACT This paper presents a historical and cultural overview of the migration and life of Hispanics in Utah and identifies three themes: search for a better life, need for and acquisition of a sense of belonging, and substance of the Hispanic people. Over the past 4 centuries, Hispanics have migrated to Utah from New Mexico, Mexico, and Central and South America. A brief history of Hispanics in Utah, beginning in the 1500s, reveals that the search for a better life was the primary reason for moving there, whether it was to escape political turmoil or recession, to avoid crime in larger urban areas, or simply to earn income and return to their homeland. Utah Hispanics satisfied their need to belong by maintaining their cultural heritage through various practices and support systems, including the use of Spanish, special foods, festivals, traditional holidays, and interactive art forms such as music and dance. Churches, social organizations, and mutual aid societies have been important factors in maintaining Hispanic culture. Spanish language newspapers, magazines, and radio stations serve the Hispanic population, which has seen most of its growth since World War II and is presently the fastest growing minority group in Utah.
    [Show full text]
  • Teachers' Guide
    BECOMING UTAH: A PEOPLES’ JOURNEY A Guide for Educators with Supplemental Resources Emma Moss | Cassandra Clark | Wendy Rex-Atzet Utah Division of State History | December 2020 > history.utah.gov OVERVIEW: On January 4, 1896, after a forty-eight-year struggle, Utah became the 45th state to enter the Union. Utah’s path to statehood was complicated and often controversial, which makes its journey an important American story. Utah’s leaders applied for statehood seven times—and failed six times—over five decades. To achieve the political status of statehood, Utahns had to confront weighty cultural, political, and social issues and overcome differences among the state’s diverse communities. While statehood marks an important moment, it is Utah’s people who have defined this place. Long before 1896, diverse peoples shaped what the state became by working to build its towns, industries, economies, and communities. Not all Utahns were represented politically before, or after, 1896. However, Utah’s people worked toward equality and legal representation. Utah’s journey to statehood and beyond shows how many groups contributed to building Utah, and also how they raised their voices to secure political, legal, religious, social, and cultural rights. CONNECTIONS TO STATE STANDARDS: 4th Grade Social Studies Standards Standard 2 - Objective 2 - Describe ways that Utah has changed over time. a. Identify key events and trends in Utah history and their significance (e.g. American Indian settlement, European exploration, Mormon settlement, westward expansion, American Indian relocation, statehood, development of industry, World War I and II). b. Compare the experiences faced by today’s immigrants with those faced by immigrants in Utah’s history.
    [Show full text]
  • American Indians Chronic Conditions, Reproductive Health, Injury and Lifestyle Risk
    Utah Health Disparities Summary 2009 American Indians Chronic Conditions, Reproductive Health, Injury and Lifestyle Risk Utah American Indians (including Alaska Utah American Indians die from Natives) share many health issues with complications of diabetes at nearly all Utahns, but also have health problems double the rate of all Utahns (147.4 and strengths unique to their communities. diabetes deaths/100,000 Utah American The Utah Department of Health, Division Indians compared to 73.0 deaths/100,000 of Community and Family Health Services statewide).6 More than 11% of Utah’s has compiled this summary to help tribes, American Indian population has diabetes, community members and health workers: compared to 6% of all Utahns.7 Complications • Raise awareness of health issues among from diabetes can result in loss of vision and American Indians in Utah; leg amputations.8 Cigarette smoking presents • Plan health programs specific to particular problems for people with diabetes American Indians; and increases risks of diabetes complications.8 • Partner with tribes to obtain grant funding to benefit American Indians; Commercial tobacco use is a leading cause and of death in Utah and is high among Utah • Eliminate racial health disparities. American Indians compared to the general 7 This page provides context for some of the Utah population. Exposure to cigarette health indicators listed on page 2. smoke may trigger asthma symptoms and full-blown attacks in adults and children and may contribute to the development of asthma Inadequate health care is a problem for in children.13 The adult Utah American Indian Utah American Indians. Higher percentages asthma rate of 11.5% exceeds the state rate are uninsured and lack adequate prenatal of 7.9%.7 care compared to all Utahns.1,2 This can result in fewer health screenings, delayed health interventions, and difficulty managing chronic conditions like diabetes.
    [Show full text]
  • "We Are Entitled To, and We Must Have, Medical Care": San Juan County's Farm Security Administration Medical Plan, 1938-1946
    Utah State University DigitalCommons@USU All Graduate Theses and Dissertations Graduate Studies 5-2015 "We are Entitled to, and we Must Have, Medical Care": San Juan County's Farm Security Administration Medical Plan, 1938-1946 John Howard Brumbaough Jr. Utah State University Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.usu.edu/etd Part of the History Commons Recommended Citation Brumbaough, John Howard Jr., ""We are Entitled to, and we Must Have, Medical Care": San Juan County's Farm Security Administration Medical Plan, 1938-1946" (2015). All Graduate Theses and Dissertations. 4589. https://digitalcommons.usu.edu/etd/4589 This Thesis is brought to you for free and open access by the Graduate Studies at DigitalCommons@USU. It has been accepted for inclusion in All Graduate Theses and Dissertations by an authorized administrator of DigitalCommons@USU. For more information, please contact [email protected]. "WE ARE ENTITLED TO, AND WE MUST HAVE, MEDICAL CARE”: SAN JUAN COUNTY’S FARM SECURITY ADMINISTRATION MEDICAL PLAN, 1938 – 1946 by John Howard Brumbaugh Jr. A thesis submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree of MASTER OF SCIENCE in History Approved: _____________________ _____________________ Victoria Grieve David Rich Lewis Major Professor Committee Member _____________________ _____________________ Evelyn Funda Mark McLellan Committee Member Vice President for Research and Dean of the School of Graduate Studies UTAH STATE UNIVERSITY Logan, Utah 2015 ii Copyright John H. Brumbaugh Jr. 2015 All Rights Reserved iii ABSTRACT “We are Entitled to, and We must have, Medical Care.”: San Juan County’s Farm Security Administration Medical Plan, 1938 - 1946 by John H.
    [Show full text]
  • Utah-Bid-2011 Optimized.Pdf
    2011 Table of Contents 02 Executive Summary 03 League Defintion 06 League Leadership 08 League Following 09 League Partnerships 11 Race Event Venues 18 Event Venues 20 League Fundraising & Development 21 Conclusion UT HIGH SCHOOL CYCLING LEAGUE :: 2011 1 Executive Summary WHY UTAH SHOULD BE AWARDED LEAGUE STATUS NICA is a developing governing body with a goal to be across the country by 2020. NICA needs states who believe in their way of running operations and who believe in NICA’s success. NICA needs a state who can not only jump on board but do so in a way that makes a powerful statement to other states that NICA is the way to go. Utah makes that powerful statement by moving to Project League for 2012. We are able to save NICA the expenses of overseeing an Emerging League for extended periods and jumping straight to Project League status demonstrates a strong belief in the NICA system. We have done all the work and we are ready to go. Additionally, we feel we can confidently say we will claim the title of being NICA’s largest first-year League with our current number of committed schools. We have had time for non-committed leaders, volunteers and coaches to come and go. Our current committee leaders are in for the long haul. Another positive factor is that the state’s population disbursement will lead to high participation in this state as many race venues will be approximately a one hour drive for most participants. Utah makes a powerful statement from the involvement of key organizations and individuals.
    [Show full text]
  • Utah State Pdf, Epub, Ebook
    NEVADA: UTAH STATE PDF, EPUB, EBOOK Rand McNally | 1 pages | 01 Jan 2010 | Rand McNally & Co ,U.S. | 9780528994982 | English | Skokie, IL, United States Nevada: Utah State PDF Book The economy of Nevada is tied to tourism especially entertainment and gambling related , mining, and cattle ranching. Flaming Gorge Glen Canyon. Most Utahns are of Northern European descent. Retrieved November 13, USA Today. Harvard University Press. White Hispanic. The state's involvement in major-college sports is not limited to its local schools. Retrieved April 3, The state has a highly diversified economy, with major sectors including transportation, education, information technology and research, government services, and mining and a major tourist destination for outdoor recreation. Small mountain ranges and rugged terrain punctuate the landscape. The Nevada Aerospace Hall of Fame provides educational resources and promotes the aerospace and aviation history of the state. Archived PDF from the original on March 25, Utah State 38, Nevada I was surprised to see Nevada open as a three-touchdown underdog against Utah State, which is a solid team but has taken a step back from a season ago. Archived from the original on September 29, Finally, the response from Washington came on October 31, "the pain is over, the child is born, Nevada this day was admitted into the Union". July 10, Nevada Judiciary. The science behind positive psychology has been become very popular in recent years, and has drawn a lot of attention," Rabbi Zalman Abraham of JLI's headquarters in Brooklyn said. I like Nevada to cover the spread, however. They called the region Nevada snowy because of the snow which covered the mountains in winter like to Sierra Nevada in Spain.
    [Show full text]
  • Traffic Sign Vandalism and Demographics of Local Population: A
    journal of traffic and transportation engineering (english edition) 2016; 3 (3): 192e202 Available online at www.sciencedirect.com ScienceDirect journal homepage: www.elsevier.com/locate/jtte Original Research Paper Traffic sign vandalism and demographics of local population: A case study in Utah * Majid Khalilikhah a, , Kevin Heaslip b, Kathleen Hancock c a Smart Urban Mobility Lab, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Falls Church, VA 22043, USA b Department of Civil & Environmental Engineering, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Arlington, VA 22203, USA c Department of Civil & Environmental Engineering, Virginia Polytechnic Institute and State University, Falls Church, VA 22043, USA article info abstract Article history: Among the different types of traffic sign damage, vandalism is exclusively caused by Received 21 July 2015 humans. Traffic sign vandalism is a serious concern, since it can lead to an increase in Received in revised form unsafe driving behaviors. In addition, it results in increased costs to transportation 20 October 2015 agencies to replace, repair, or maintain the vandalized signs. This paper examines the Accepted 2 November 2015 association between the local population demographics and traffic sign vandalism rates in Available online 22 April 2016 the State of Utah. To accomplish this goal, sign data of over 97,000 traffic signs across Utah were digitally collected by an equipped vehicle. Sign damage data were obtained from the Keywords: inspection of daytime digital images taken of each individual sign. Demographic data of Traffic sign vandalism Utah's counties, including population density, ethnicity, age, income, education, and Mobile-based data collection gender, were obtained from the U.S.
    [Show full text]