Diversity and Evolution of Rosids . . . roses, currants, peonies . . . Eudicots • continue survey through the eudicots or tricolpates • vast majority of eudicots are Rosids (polypetalous) and Asterids core (sympetalous) eudicots
rosid asterid Eudicots • unlike Asterids, Rosids (in orange) now represent a diverse set of families *Saxifragales • before examining the large Rosid group, look at a small but important order of flowering plants - Saxifragales
Paeonia
Sedum *Saxifragales • small group of 16 families and about 2500 species sister to Rosids • ancient lineage from 120 mya and underwent rapid radiation
Paeonia
Sedum *Saxifragales
• part of this ancient radiation may involve this small family of holo-parasites - Cynomoriaceae *Saxifragales • they generally can be identified by their two or more separate or semi-fused carpels, but otherwise quite variable
Paeonia
Sedum Paeoniaceae 1 genus / 33 species • like many of these families, Paeonia exhibits an Arcto-Tertiary distribution Paeoniaceae 1 genus / 33 species • small shrubs with primitive features of perianth and stamens • hypogynous with 5-8 separate carpels developing into follicles Cercidiphyllaceae 1 genus / 2 species • small trees (kadsura-tree) restricted to eastern China and Japan . . . • . . . but fossils in North America and Europe from Tertiary Cercidiphyllaceae 1 genus / 2 species • unisexual, wind-pollinated but do produce follicles Hamamelidaceae 27 genera and 80 species - witch hazels • family of trees and shrubs in subtropical and temperate areas but only 1 species in Wisconsin - witch hazel found in rich deciduous woods
Hamamelis virginiana - witch hazel Hamamelis mollis Hamamelidaceae CA 4-5 CO 4-5 A 4-5 G (2)
• 4-5 merous and insect pollinated in the fall (images from Sept)
• petals are ribbon-like
Hamamelis virginiana - witch hazel Hamamelidaceae CA 4-5 CO 4-5 A 4-5 G (2)
• ovary is generally inferior or half-inferior with the tops somewhat separated
• fruit woody, dehiscent at top
Hamamelis virginiana - witch hazel Previous year’s fruit Altingiaceae 1 genus and 27 species - sweet gums • small family of trees - sweet gum is familiar in North America; Arcto- Tertiary distribution
• clusters of small follicles
Liquidambar styraciflua *Saxifragaceae 30 genera and 700 species • family of herbs, Northern Hemisphere in distribution • basal leaves common - scapose
• prefer wet woods, swampy conditions, or Sullivantia - cool wort drippy cliffs as in the driftless region of SW WI
Micranthes - saxifrage *Saxifragaceae CA 5 CO 5 A 5or10 G (2)
• 5 merous flowers • Superior pistil is made of 2 carpels, separated, at least from the middle up; perigynous hypanthium often present
2 styles
Micranthes pensylvanica - swamp saxifrage *Saxifragaceae
Note cup-like hypanthium
Mitella - Bishop’s-cap
Heuchera richardsonii prairie alumroot *Saxifragaceae Tiarella cordifolia Foamflower Endangered boreal sp.
Chrysosplenium - golden saxifrage Grossulariaceae 1 genus and 150 species - temperate regions • characterized by lobed leaves, raceme inflorescences, and fleshy fruits (currants and gooseberries)
Ribes americanum - American black currant Grossulariaceae CA 5 CO 5 A 5 G (2)
• flowers 5 merous with sepals large and petals smaller
• gynoecium inferior of 2 fused carpels
well developed hypanthium Grossulariaceae • Currants identified by long racemes of many flowers
Ribes americanum Ribes triste - American black currant swamp currant Grossulariaceae • Gooseberries identified by paired flowers; stems often spiny
Ribes cynosbati - prickly Ribes missouriense gooseberry, dogberry Missouri gooseberry *Crassulaceae 34 genera and 1370 species - temperate or warm temperate regions of the world • succulent herbs or small shrubs - jade plants
• CAM (crassulacean acid metabolism) type of photosynthesis
• Wisconsin species are introduced, although yellow sedum is spreading Sedum acre - Gold-moss in sandy soils stonecrop,Yellow sedum *Crassulaceae CA 5 CO 5 A 10 G 5
• 5 merous with stamens 2X number of sepals (3,4, or 6 merous species occur)
• carpels separate and produce follicles when mature
• nectary scales usually evident at base of each carpel Sedum acre - Gold-moss stonecrop,Yellow sedum *Crassulaceae • major radiation of genera in Mediterranean climates (e.g., Canary Islands)
Aeonium Rhodiola *Crassulaceae
Echeveria Kalanchoe Rosids Rosids are one of two large groups of dicots; the other group are the Asterids
Rosids:
separate petals
Asterids:
fused petals *Rosales • two major groups within Rosids - we will start with Fabids N2 fixing • include all N fixing plants clade 2 • the order Rosales: not well defined morphologically (roses, elms, marijuana, nettles, figs)
1. N2 fixing via actinomycetes (Frankia) 2. loss of corolla in order; petals in Rosaceae = stamens! 3. serrated leaves (glandular +/-) *Rosaceae 100 genera and almost 3000 species distributed worldwide but most common in the north temperate regions - commercial fruits • Comprise herbs, shrubs, or trees and with alternate simple or pinnately or palmately compound leaves
Stipules well developed in compound leaves *Rosaceae CA 5 CO 5 A ∞ G [variable!] • 5 merous, with numerous stamens • gynoecium is variable and used to define subfamilies *Rosaceae CA 5 CO 5 A ∞ G [variable!] • hypanthium present in all species
Bracts on calyx (epicalyx) often present *Rosaceae The gynoecium is variable – four basic types
1. Spiraea group
2. Rose group
3. Cherry group
4. Apple group
Gynoecium variability encompasses size of receptacle, position of ovary, size of hypanthium, and the resulting fruit types: *Rosaceae
follicles drupelets
achenes aggregate of achenes
drupes pomes *Rosaceae – spiraea group Physocarpus opulifolius - ninebark CA 5 CO 5 A ∞ G 2-8 apocarpic, superior pistils short hypanthium - perigynous follicle fruits *Rosaceae – spiraea group
Spiraea alba - meadow-sweet Spiraea tomentosa - hardhack *Rosaceae – rose group CA 5 CO 5 A ∞ G ∞
Herbs with compound leaves
Plants with stolons (running stems above ground) or running rhizomes
Flowers apocarpic with many carpels
Hypanthium well-developed or receptacle elongated - perigynous
One-seeded achenes *Rosaceae – rose group CA 5 CO 5 A ∞ G ∞
Achenes often modified into aggregate of achenes (from one flower) as in the strawberry or fleshy drupelets as in raspberry, dewberry
Rubus idaeus - American raspberry Fragaria sp. - strawberry *Rosaceae – rose group
Fragaria virginiana - wild strawberry Geum triflorum - prairie smoke *Rosaceae – rose group
Fragaria virginiana - wild strawberry Agrimonia gryposepala - common agrimony, harvest lice
2 achenes, but hypanthium disperses as a unit with “velcro”-like barbs from top of hypanthium *Rosaceae – rose group
Potentilla argentea silverweed
Potentilla simplex Common cinquefoil *Rosaceae – rose group
Potentilla breweri complex Western cinquefoils *Rosaceae – rose group
Rubus parviflorus thimbleberry *Rosaceae – rose group
Rubus parviflorus Rubus hispidus thimbleberry swamp dewberry
Rubus allegheniensis blackberry *Rosaceae – rose group Rosa rugosa Beach rose
Rosa multiflora Multiflora rose Rosa palustris Invasive weed Swamp rose *Rosaceae – cherry group CA 5 CO 5 A ∞ G 1 Shrubs and trees with simple leaves, often with glands along petiole (cherries, plums, peaches, almonds)
Prunus serotina - black cherry *Rosaceae – cherry group CA 5 CO 5 A ∞ G 1 Gynoecium superior with one carpel = monocarpic - perigynous Fruit a drupe = fleshy, with one bony seed *Rosaceae – cherry group
Prunus serotina wild black cherry
Prunus virginiana choke cherry *Rosaceae – cherry group
Prunus pumila - sand cherry *Rosaceae – cherry group
Prunus americana Wild plum *Rosaceae – apple group — CA 5 CO 5 A ∞ G (3-5)
Shrubs or trees with showy 5 merous flowers
Gynoecium inferior of 3 to 5 fused carpels
Malus pumila - apple *Rosaceae – apple group — CA 5 CO 5 A ∞ G (3-5)
Hypanthium thickens in fruit to form pome fruit Calyx (& CO + A) inserted at top of ovary = epigynous flower
ovary
Malus pumila - apple *Rosaceae – apple group Aronia melanocarpa black chokeberry
Pyrus communis Pear (introduced) *Rosaceae – apple group Amelanchier laevis Serviceberry, Juneberry *Rosaceae – apple group
Crataegus crus-galli - cockspur hawthorn
Crataegus mollis - downy hawthorn Xiang et al. . doi:10.1093/molbev/msw242 *RosaceaeMBE
Malus baccata * Malus domestica * Docynia delavayi Eriolobus trilobatus * Pyrus bretschneideri DNA tree Pyrus betulifolia * Sorbus alnifolia * Sorbus aria Sorbus torminalis Sorbus commixta * Sorbus aucuparia * Cydonia oblonga Pseudocydonia sinensis Maleae • spiraea group is polyphyletic Chaenomeles japonica * Photinia villosa * * Sorbus keissleri Stranvaesia amphidoxa * Eriobotrya japonica * Rhaphiolepis indica Amygdaloideae Amelanchier alnifolira * Malacomeles denticulata * Crataegus cuneata - not first diverging group * * Mespilus germanica Vauquelinia californica * Kageneckia oblonga Gillenia stipulata * Gillenia trifoliata Gillenieae * Neviusia alabamensis * Neviusia cliftonii * Kerria japonica * Coleogyne ramosissima Kerrieae Rhodotypos scandens * Prinsepia uniflora * Prinsepia utilis * Oemleria cerasiformis Exochordeae Exochorda racemosa Sorbaria sorbifolia * * Sorbaria tomentosa • rose core group is * Chamaebatiaria millefolium Sorbarieae * Adenostoma fasiculatum Prunus mume * * Prunus sibirica * Prunus salicina Prunus dulcis * * Prunus persica Prunus yedoensis Amygdaleae * Maddenia hypoleuca monophyletic, but others are * * Maddenia wilsonii Prunus buergeriana * Prunus spinulosa * Pygeum topengii Lyonothamnus floribundus Lyonothamneae Sibiraea laevigata * * Sibiraea tomentosa * Petrophytum caespitosum scattered around * Spiraea japonica * * Spiraea thunbergii Spiraeeae Aruncus dioicus * Holodiscus discolor Stephanandra chinensis * Stephanandra tanakae * Neillia affinis * * Neillia sinensis Neillieae Physocarpus opulifolius Acaena glabra * Acaena microphylla Acaena magellanica Polylepis australis * * Polylepis besseri * Margyricarpus pinnatus * Cliffortia repens Agrimonieae Sanguisorba officinalis • cherry group and apple group * * Sarcopoterium spinosum * Hagenia abyssinica * Leucosidea sericea * Agrimonia pilosa Spenceria ramalana Horkelia californica * * Horkeliella purpurascens Potentilla aurea form a monophyletic clade * * Potentilla recta
Duchesnea indica Rosoideae * * Potentilla erecta * Potentilla freyniana Potentilla nitida Sibbaldianthe bifurca * * Sibbaldia adpressa * * Sibbaldia parviflora Alchemilla alpina Potentilleae * * Alchemilla fissa Fragaria ananassa * * Fragaria vesca Comarum palustre * Drymocallis arguta * Drymocallis glandulosa * Chamaerhodos altaica * * Chamaerhodos erecta Dasiphora glabra * Potaninia mongolica * * Rosa canina * Rosa multiflora * Rosa davurica Roseae Rosa stellata Geum aleppicum * * Geum macrophyllum Geum triforum * Acomastylis elata Colurieae * Coluria henryi * * Taihangia rupestris Waldsteinia geoides Xiang et al. 2017 Fallugia paradoxa * Rubus coreanus * * Rubus idaeus * Rubus corchorifolius Rubeae Rubus odoratus Filipendula palmata * * Filipendula rubra Ulmarieae Filipendula ulmaria Cercocarpus betuloides * Cercocarpus montanus * Chamaebatia australis Dryad- Purshia mexicana Dryadeae * * Purshia stansburyana Dryas octopetala Outgroup oideae
FIG. 1. A summary of Rosaceae phylogeny and Rosaceae fruit morphologies. On the left is a summary tree with results from five coalescence analyses of 882, 571, 444, 256, and 113 gene sets, respectively, and a concatenation analysis using the 113-gene supermatrix. Topologies consistent in all six trees are drawn in black lines. Grey lines show uncertain relationships, with some trees support the topology. For further information see figure 3 and supplementary figure S14, Supplementary Material online. Asterisks (*) indicate 100% supports in all six trees. Diamonds indicate more than 90% supports in at least five trees and more than 85% supports in all six trees. Squares indicate more than 80% supports in at least three trees
Downloaded from264 https://academic.oup.com/mbe/article-abstract/34/2/262/2528249 by guest on 15 March 2018 on 15March2018 by guest Downloaded fromhttps://academic.oup.com/mbe/article-abstract/34/2/262/2528249 yohtclacsrlfut fPrne vle nomvatepril“ikn”o h vr notehpnhu n uigwt t n: it. with fusing and hypanthium k: the carpels). into ovary few the o: of a top). “sinking” the with partial near the (nuculanium, still via endocarp Amygdaleae m the into of (with evolved five ancestor l with Pyrinae. that hypothetical of to fruits (h) A carpels ancestral j: (indefinite) hypothetical many (i). with follicetum carpels a from fewer evolving Amygdaloideae, or of fruits ancestral Hypothetical i: h, Amygdaloideae. g: hypanthium); clock of fruit molecular ancestral the hypothetical from a b: redrawn (achenetum); right Rosoideae of the c: fruit on ancestral hypothetical scale a time a: geological Rosoideae. in with types correspond branches and nodes in shown of analysis positions The taxa. extant of types hrce) q: character). of fruit ancestral hypothetical a f: receptacle); of enlargement fleshy with (achenetum, in shown than from phylogeny abbreviated F al. et Xiang 274 IG Rubus 6. . vltoayhsoiso ri ye nRsca.( Rosaceae. in types fruit of histories Evolutionary dueu,wt oefls) :ahpteia neta ri of fruit ancestral hypothetical a d: flesh); more with (drupetum, . Malus doi:10.1093/molbev/msw242 Rosa A B gr 4 figure a wt etal oae noapaogtevria xs hc eh n n rtosesprcre,allkl eie features). derived likely all carpel, per seeds two or one and flesh, thick axis, vertical the along endocarp located centrally (with
ahntm ihfl nlsr ytehpnhu,adicesdfutsz) ( size). fruit increased and hypanthium, the by enclosure full with (achenetum, Malus/Pyrus oeplpeosdrupe pome/polyprenous nuculanium follicetum drupetum drupe coccetum achenetum achene h oiin ffutdaig ontrpeettehsoyo g ftefuttps ( types. fruit the of age or history the represent not do drawings fruit of positions The . Crataegus Vauquelinia b d f Kageneckia
Eriobotrya Gillenia gr 1 figure Sorbaria
ryln ersnsacsrlfuttp fRsca.Ohrln oosrpeetdfeetfruit different represent colors line Other Rosaceae. of type fruit ancestral represents line Grey . Rhodotypos wt eaieyti eh.p: flesh). thin relatively (with c e g Exochorda A
h vltoayhsoyo ifrn ri ye nRsca ntecneto an of context the in Rosaceae in types fruit different of history evolutionary The ) Prinsepia Lyonothamnus Prunus C h
Fragaria Spiraea
n Physocarpus Pseudocydonia ahntm ihu nagmn frcpal) e: receptacle); of enlargement without (achenetum, Filipendula i Rosa Rubus opq ahntm ihprilecoueo risb the by fruits of enclosure partial with (achenetum, Geum l wt ayoue o apl ieyancestral likely a carpel, a for ovules many (with
C Rosa rpsdhsoiso eea ri ye in types fruit several of histories Proposed ) j Prunus
Fragaria * m due ihasnl apl.l m: l, carpel). single a with (drupe, Agrimonia B Rubus rpsdhsoiso he fruit three of histories Proposed ) Chamaebatia Rosaceae k dueu,wt esflesh); less with (drupetum, Dryas
L-CretaceousPal Eocene Oli 110 100 90 80 70 60 50 40 30 Age (Mya) MBE Crataegus Fragaria fruit evolution? What this does tell about us Xiang et et Xiang • • once twice or • achenes follicles pomes al. al. and are ancestral 2017 evolved many times drupes evolved