On Mixed Joint Discrete Universality for a Class of Zeta
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Mathematical Modelling and Analysis http://mma.vgtu.lt Volume 25, Issue 4, 569{583, 2020 ISSN: 1392-6292 https://doi.org/10.3846/mma.2020.11751 eISSN: 1648-3510 On Mixed Joint Discrete Universality for a Class of Zeta-Functions: a Further Generalization Roma Kaˇcinskait_ea and Kohji Matsumotob aVytautas Magnus University Vileikos g. 8, LT-44404 Kaunas, Lithuania bNagoya University Furocho, Chikusa-ku, 464-8602 Nagoya, Japan E-mail(corresp.): [email protected] E-mail: [email protected] Received December 16, 2019; revised July 28, 2020; accepted July 30, 2020 Abstract. We present the most general at this moment results on the discrete mixed joint value-distribution (Theorems5 and6) and the universality property (Theo- rems3 and4) for the class of Matsumoto zeta-functions and periodic Hurwitz zeta- functions under certain linear independence condition on the relevant parameters, such as common differences of arithmetic progressions, prime numbers etc. Keywords: discrete shift, Matsumoto zeta-function, periodic Hurwitz zeta-function, simul- taneous approximation, Steuding class, value distribution, weak convergence, universality. AMS Subject Classification: 11M06; 11M41; 11M35; 41A30; 30E10. 1 Introduction In analytic number theory, one of the most interesting and popular subjects is the so called universality property of various zeta- and L-functions in Voronin's sense (see [27]). In particular the mixed joint universality is a rather hot topic today. Recall that the first results in this direction were obtained by J. Sander and J. Steuding (see [25]) and independently by H. Mishou (see [24]). They proved that the pair of analytic functions is simultaneously approximable by the shifts of the Riemann zeta-function ζ(s) and the Hurwitz zeta-function ζ(s; α) with certain real α (as it is well-known the function ζ(s) has the Euler type product expansion over primes, while the function ζ(s; α) in general does not; from this facts the term \mixed joint" arises). Copyright c 2020 The Author(s). Published by VGTU Press This is an Open Access article distributed under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution License (http://creativecommons.org/licenses/by/4.0/), which permits unrestricted use, distribu- tion, and reproduction in any medium, provided the original author and source are credited. 570 R. Kaˇcinskait_eand K. Matsumoto In the series of previous works by the authors (see [9, 10, 11, 12]), the tu- ple consisting from the wide class of the Matsumoto zeta-functions '(s) and the periodic Hurwitz zeta-functions ζ(s; α; B) is considered in the frame of the studies on the value distribution of such pair, as well as the universality property and the functional independence. Let s = σ + it be a complex variable and by P; N; Q; R and C denote the set of all prime numbers, positive integers, rational numbers, real numbers and complex numbers, respectively. Suppose that α, 0 < α ≤ 1, is a fixed real number. Recall the definitions of both the functions under our interest { the Matsumoto zeta-functions '(s) and the periodic Hurwitz zeta-functions ζ(s; α; B). For m 2 N, let g(m) 2 N, f(j; m) 2 N, 1 ≤ j ≤ g(m). Denote by pm (j) α the mth prime number, and let am 2 C. Assume that g(m) ≤ C1pm and (j) β jam j ≤ pm with positive constant C1 and non-negative constants α and β. Define the zeta-function 'e(s) by the polynomial Euler product g(m) 1 −1 Y Y (j) −sf(j;m) 'e(s) = 1 − am pm : m=1 j=1 The function 'e(s) converges absolutely in the region σ > α + β + 1, and, in this region, it can be written as the Dirichlet series 1 X ck '(s) = e e ks+α+β k=1 α+β+" with coefficients eck such that eck = O k if all prime factors of k are large for every positive " (for the comment, see [11]). For brevity, denote the shifted version of the function 'e(s) as 1 1 X ck X ck '(s) := '(s + α + β) = e = e ks+α+β ks k=1 k=1 −α−β with ck := eckk . This series is convergent in the half-plane σ > 1. Suppose that the function '(s) satisfies the following conditions: 1 (i) '(s) can be continued meromorphically to σ ≥ σ0, where 2 ≤ σ0 < 1, and all poles of '(s) in this region are included in a compact set which has no intersection with the line σ = σ0; C2 (ii) for σ ≥ σ0, '(σ + it) = O(jtj ) with a certain C2 > 0; (iii) it holds the mean-value estimate Z T 2 j'(σ0 + it)j dt = O(T ): 0 We call the set of all such functions '(s) as the class of Matsumoto zeta- functions and denote by M. On Mixed Joint Discrete Universality for a Class of Zeta-Functions 571 Now, for N0 := N [ f0g, let B = fbm : m 2 N0g be a periodic sequence of complex numbers bm with minimal positive period l 2 N. The periodic Hurwitz zeta-function ζ(s; α; B) with parameter α 2 R, 0 < α ≤ 1, is given by the Dirichlet series 1 X bm ζ(s; α; B) = for σ > 1: (m + α)s m=0 It is known that the function ζ(s; α; B) is analytically continued to the whole complex plane, except for a possible simple pole at the point s = 1 with residue 1 Pl−1 b := l m=0 bm: If b = 0, then ζ(s; α; B) is an entire function. It is possible to prove functional limit theorems for the whole class M, but it is difficult to prove the denseness lemma which is necessary to prove the universality theorem. Therefore in the proof of the universality we use an assumption that the function '(s) belongs to the Steuding class Se defined below. We say that the function '(s) belongs to the class Se if the following condi- tions are satisfied: P1 −s (a) there exists a Dirichlet series expansion '(s) = m=1 a(m)m with a(m) = O(m") for every " > 0; (b) there exists σ' < 1 such that '(s) can be meromorphically continued to the half-plane σ > σ' and is holomorphic except for a pole at s = 1; C3+" (c) for every fixed σ > σ' and " > 0, the order estimate '(σ+it) = O(jtj ) with C3 ≥ 0 holds; (d) there exists the Euler product expansion over primes, i.e., l Y Y −s−1 '(s) = 1 − aj(p)p ; p2P j=1 (e) there exists a constant κ > 0 such that 1 X lim ja(p)j2 = κ, x!1 π(x) p≤x where π(x) denotes the number of primes p up to x. ∗ For '(s) 2 Se, let σ be the infimum of all σ1 such that 1 1 Z T X ja(m)j2 j'(σ + it)j2dt ∼ 2T m2σ −T m=1 1 ∗ ∗ holds for any σ ≥ σ1. Then 2 ≤ σ < 1, and we see that Se ⊂ M if σ0 = σ + " is chosen. Note that the class Se is not a subclass of the Selberg class! To formulate mixed joint discere limit theorems and universality property for the tuple '(s); ζ(s; α; B) and further results, we need some notation. For Math. Model. Anal., 25(4):569{583, 2020. 572 R. Kaˇcinskait_eand K. Matsumoto any compact set K ⊂ C, denote by Hc(K) the set of all C-valued functions defined on K, continuous on K and holomorphic in the interior of K. By c c c H0(K) denote the subset of H (K) such that, on K, all elements of H (K) are non-vanishing. Let D(a; b) = fs 2 C : a < σ < bg for a; b 2 R, a < b, and we denote by measfAg the Lebesgue measure of the measurable set A ⊂ R. For any set S, B(S) denotes the set of all Borel subsets of S, and, for any region D, H(D) denotes the set of all holomorphic functions on D. The first result on the mixed joint universality of the pair '(s); ζ(s; α; B) is the following theorem, which considers the situation when the shifting pa- rameter is moving continuously. Theorem 1 [Theorem 2.2, [9]]. Suppose '(s) 2 Se, and α is a transcendental ∗ number, 0 < α < 1. Let K1 be a compact subset of the strip D σ ; 1 , K2 be a 1 compact subset of the strip D 2 ; 1 , both with connected complements. Suppose c c that f1(s) 2 H0(K1), f2(s) 2 H (K2). Then, for every " > 0, it holds that 1 n lim inf meas τ 2 [0;T ] : sup j'(s + iτ) − f1(s)j < "; T !1 T s2K1 o sup jζ(s + iτ; α; B) − f2(s)j < " > 0: s2K2 More interesting and complicated questions on mixed joint universality are concerning the discrete case, when shifting parameters take discrete values. The first result of such kind is the discrete analogue of Theorem1, which was proved by the authors in [10]. Let h > 0 be the shifting parameter, that is the common difference of the relevant arithmetic progression, and put L(α; h) := f(log p : p 2 P); (log(m + α): m 2 N0); 2π=hg : We call L(α; h) is linearly independent over Q when the relation X X kp log p + lm log(m + α) + a2π=h = 0 (1.1) p2P m2N0 (where kp; lm; a 2 Z and only a finite number of them are nonzero) holds if and only if all kp; lm; a are zero.