Minutes of the 583Rd Meeting Ofthe State Level Expert Appraisal
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Minutes of the 583rd meeting ofthe State Level Expert Appraisal Committee held on 16/01/2020 at Committee Room, Gujarat Pollution Control Board, Sector 10A, Gandhinagar. The 583rd meeting of the State Level Expert Appraisal Committee (SEAC) was held on 16th January, 2020 at Committee Room, Gujarat Pollution Control Board, Sector 10A, Gandhinagar. Following members attended the meeting: 1. Dr. Dinesh Misra, Chairman, SEAC 2. Shri S. C. Srivastav, Vice Chairman, SEAC 3. Shri V. N. Patel, Member, SEAC 4. Shri. R. J. Shah, Member, SEAC 5. Shri A. K. Muley, Member, SEAC The regular agenda of Appraisal, Reconsideration & ToR cases were taken up. The Committee considered the applications made by project proponents, additional details submitted as required by the SEAC/SEIAA and details furnished in the Form-1, PFR, EIA-EMP reports. Proposal No. Name and Address of the Unit Remarks M/s. Umiya Dyes & Intermediates 4 SIA/GJ/IND2/45797/2019 Appraisal Plot No D2/CH/90 , GIDC Dahej, Dist - Bharuch. Category of the unit : 5(f) Project status: New Project proponent (PP) has submitted online application vide no. SIA/GJ/IND2/45797/2019 on dated 05/12/2019 for obtaining Environmental Clearance. The SEAC had recommended TOR to SEIAA and SEIAA issued TOR to PP vide their letter dated 03/10/2019. Project proponent has submitted EIA Report prepared by M/s. Aqua Air Environmental Engineering Pvt. Ltd .based on the TOR issued by SEIAA. This is a new unit proposes for manufacturing of synthetic organic chemical as tabulated below: TOTAL PRODUCT SR.NO NAME OF PRODUCTS CAS NO. CAPACITY END – USE (MT/MONTH) Group-A 1. META PHENYLENE DIAMINE-4- 88-63-1 250 DYES INTER. SULPHONIC ACID 583rd meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, dated 16/01/2020 Page 1 of 84 2. Acetyl M.P.D.S.A 88-64-2 DYES INTER. 3. CARBAMOYL PYRIDONE 34562-97-5 DYES INTER. 4. SULPHOMETHYL PYRIDONE 40306-70-5 DYES INTER. 5. META URIDO ANILINE 59690-88-9 DYES INTER. 6. 8 – HYDROXY QUINOLINE 148-24-3 PHARMA INTER. 7. 5-NITRO AMINO PHENOL & 4-NITRO 121-88-0 DYES INTER. AMINO PHENOL 8. 4-CHLORO AMINO PHENOL DYES/ PHARMA 95-85-2 INTER. 9. 2-CHLORO AMINO RHENOL 3964-52-1 DYES/ PHARMA INTER 10. 5-CHLORO AMINO PHENOL DYES/ PHARMA 28443-50-7 INTER. 11. 5-CHLORO 8-HYDROXY QUINOLINE 130-16-5 PHARMA INTER. 12. 4-CHLORO NITRO PHENOL 89-64-5 DYE/PHARMA INTER. 13. 2-CHLORO NITRO PHENOL 619-08-9 DYE / PHARMA INTER. 14. 2,6-DICHLORO PARA NITRO 90-30-9 DYES INTER. ANILINE 15. 2-CHLORO-5-CHLOROMETHYL SRECIALITY 70258-18-3 PYRIDIN PRODUCT Group-B 16. 2,4-DINITRO CHLORO BENZENE 97-00-7 DYES INTER. 17. 2,4- DINITRO ANILINE 97-02-9 DYES INTER. 18. 2,6-DIBROMO PARA NITRO ANILINE 827-94-1 DYES INTER. 19. 2,5-DICHLORO NITRO BENZENE 89-61-2 DYES INTER. 20. 3,4-DICHLORO NITRO BENZENE 99-54-7 DYES INTER. 21. 2,5-DICHLORO ANILINE 95-82-9 1000 DYES INTER. 22. 2,3-DICHLORO ANILINE 608-27-5 DYES INTER. 23. 3,4-DICHLORO ANILINE 95-76-1 DYES INTER. 24. 3,5-DICHLORO ANILINE 626-43-7 DYES INTER. 25. 6-BROMO-2,4-DINITRO ANILINE 1817-73-8 DYES INTER. 26. 6-CHLORO-2,4-DINITRO ANILINE 3531-19-9 DYES INTER. TOTAL 1250 The project falls under Category B of project activity 5(f) as per the schedule of EIA Notification 2006. PP was called for presentation in the SEAC meeting dated 08/01/2020.. Salient features of the project including Water, Air and Hazardous waste management: Sr. no. Particulars Details A A Total cost of Proposed Project 4.0 Crores (Rs. in Crores): ii EMP details (Capital cost & Recurring cost) Brief details of EMP COMPONENT CAPITAL COST OF EMP RECURRING COST OF EMP (per 583rd meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, dated 16/01/2020 Page 2 of 84 (2019-20) Month) Cost Rs. 184.125 Lakhs Rs. 76.12983 Lakhs Bifurcation of EMP Cost Sr. Unit Installed Capital Operating Maintenance Total No Capacity Cost Cost Cost Recurring (KLD) (Rs. in (Lacs/Month) (Lacs/Month) Cost Lakhs ) (Lacs/Month) 1 Effluent 137 KLD 150.0 33.5 0.75 34.25 Treatment Plant 2. APCM -- 16.0 -- 0.1 0.1 3. Hazardous -- 3.25 41.359 -- 41.359 Waste (Expense) 4. AWH -- 10.0 -- 0.125 0.125 Monitoring Cost 5. Greenbelt -- 4.875 -- 0.0625 0.0625 Total 184.125 74.859 1.0375 75.8965 Iii CER details (As per MoEF&CC OM dated 01/05/2018) As per OM no. 22-65/2017 on dated 01/05/2018 regarding “Corporate Environment Responsibility” (CER), greenfield projects have to contribute 2% of the Additional Capital Investment, the company will contribute Rs. 8.0 Lakhs as funds for CER activities Component As per Norms Allocation CER Rs. 8.0 Lakhs (2 %) Rs. 8.0 Lakhs (2 %) Activities to be carried out under CER: CER Activities Fund (Rs.) RO Plants and Primary School Modification at Vegani Village 3,00,000/- Solar Street Light, Solar Roof Top and RO Water plant at Bhadbhut Village 5,00,000/- Total 8,00,000/- B Total Plot area ( sq. meter) 5000 Sq. m. Green belt area 1500.0 Sq. m. ( sq. meter) C Employment generation 15 D Water i Source of Water Supply GIDC Water Supply (GIDC Bore well, Surface water, Tanker supply etc...) Status of permission from the concern authority. GIDC/DEE/(WS)/BRH/166 ii Water consumption (KLD) Category Quantity Remarks KLD 583rd meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, dated 16/01/2020 Page 3 of 84 (A) Domestic 2.0 (B) Gardening 3.0 (C) Industrial Process 75.0 Washing 4.0 Boiler 20.0 Cooling 15.0 Scrubber 1.0 Industrial Total 115.0 Total (A + B + C) 120.0 1) Total water requirement for the project: 120 KLD 2) Quantity to be recycled: 80 KLD 3) Total fresh water requirement: 40 KLD iii Waste water generation (KLD) - Category Waste water Remarks KLD (A) Domestic 1.6 (B) Industrial Process 131 Low COD & TDS:39 KLD High COD & TDS: 92 KLD Washing 4.0 Boiler 1.0 Cooling 1.0 Scrubber 1.4 Reuse and sell under rule-9 permission Total Industrial 138.4 waste water Total [A + B] 140.0 iv Treatment facility within premises with capacity 583rd meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, dated 16/01/2020 Page 4 of 84 [In-house ETP (Primary, Secondary, Tertiary), MEE, Stripper, Spray Dryer, STP etc. ETP (Primary, Secondary): 45 KLD MEE + Ammonia &Solvent Stripper : 92 KLD Treatment scheme including segregation at source. Low COD & TDS effluent from Process, Boiler, Cooling and Washing will be treated in ETP (Primary, Secondary). High COD & TDS effluent from process will be treated in-house MEE. Note: (In case of CETP discharge) : Management of waste water keeping in view direction under section 18 (1) (b) of the Water (Prevention and Control of Pollution) act, 1974 issued by CPCB regarding compliance of CETP. Not Applicable Brief note on adequacy of ZLD (In case of Zero Liquid Discharge): Low COD & TDS effluent will be discharge into CETP, Dahej after treated in Primary and Secondary treatment. High COD & TDS effluent will be treated in Solvent Stripper + MEE, and then after reuse within premises. v Mode of Disposal & Final meeting point Domestic: Disposal through soak pit/ septic tank Industrial: Low COD & TDS: Effluent will be treated in Primary and Secondary treatment, after that sent to CETP, Dahej. High COD & TDS: Effluent will be treated in Ammonia &Solvent Stripper + MEE, after that reuse within premises. vi In case of Common facility (CF) like CETP, Common Spray dryer, Common MEE etc. Name of CF CETP: GIDC/BRH/DEE (DRG)/150 Membership of Common facility (CF) (For waste water treatment) Ref No.: BEIL/ANK/2019, dated 22/05/2019 vii Simplified water balance diagram with reuse / recycle of waste water 583rd meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, dated 16/01/2020 Page 5 of 84 viii Reuse/Recycle details (KLD) Total reuse: 80 KLD Source of waste Application Characteristics of Remarks water for reuse area with waste water to be regarding with quantity in quantity in reused (COD, BOD, feasibility KLD (From KLD (Where it TDS etc.) to reuse i.e. where it is is used) coming) MEE Condensate: Boiler: 20.0 COD: 150 mg/l 80.0 KLD KLD BOD: 50 mg/l Process: 60.0 TDS: 500 mg/l KLD E Air i Flue gas emission details No. of Boilers/TFH/Furnaces/DG sets etc. with capacities viz. TPH, Kcal/hr, MT/hr, KVA etc. -Proposed Sr. Source Stack Type of Quantity Type of Air 583rd meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, dated 16/01/2020 Page 6 of 84 no. of Height Fuel of Fuel emissions Pollution emission (meter) MT/Day i.e. Air Control With Pollutants Measures Capacity (APCM) SPM < 150 3 mg/Nm MCS with Briquettes of Boiler (2 Bag Filter + 1 30 2.5 SO2 < 100 TPH) Biocoal/Coal water ppm scrubber NOx < 50 ppm SPM < 150 mg/Nm3 Adequate Boiler (1 2 30 Natural gas 1300.0 SO2 < 100 stack TPH) ppm Height NOx < 50 ppm SPM < 150 Thermic 3 mg/Nm MCS with Fluid Briquettes of Bag Filter + 3 Heater (5 30 5.0 SO2 < 100 Biocoal/Coal water lakhs ppm scrubber kcal/hr) NOx < 50 ppm SPM < 150 mg/Nm3 D. G Set Adequate 4 (250 11 HSD 1.4 SO2 < 100 stack KVA) ppm Height NOx < 50 ppm 583rd meeting of SEAC-Gujarat, dated 16/01/2020 Page 7 of 84 ii Process gas emission details i.e.