DOCSLIB.ORG

1 Ubi Ius, Ibi Remedium: Do the Union Courts Have

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
1 Ubi Ius, Ibi Remedium: Do the Union Courts Have UBI IUS, IBI REMEDIUM: DO THE UNION COURTS HAVE THE “LATIN FOR JUDGING” Kieron Beal QC, Blackstone Chambers Bar European Group Conference, Iceland, May 2015 A. Introduction and the obligatory historical anecdote 1. In the Saga of Gudmund the Worthy, a kinsman of Gudmund called Skaering has his hand chopped off by some Norwegian merchants.1 Gudmund is called upon to arbitrate and set an award of compensation for the loss. He pronounces that the sum of “thirty hundreds” should be paid. The Norwegians decline to pay this sum, saying it is too much. After some rather unseemly haggling with the arbitrator, Gudmund amends his award. He determines that he will select one of the Norwegian kinsmen of comparable status and cut off his hand. The Norwegians might then pay such compensation to their own kinsman as they see fit. Forced to recognise the true value of the loss of a hand for one of their own, the Norwegians wisely pay the judgment debt. 2. The common law, in keeping with medieval Icelandic law, has long recognised the need for an effective remedy. That is reflected in the common law brocard2 and the Latin title to this paper: “wherever there is a right, there is a remedy.” In Ashby v. White (1703) 92 ER 126, Lord Holt C.J., in his dissenting opinion, would have granted a voter barred from voting a right to claim compensation. He noted that “if the plaintiff has a right, he must of necessity have a means to vindicate and maintain it, and a remedy if he is injured in the exercise or enjoyment of it; and indeed it is a vain thing to imagine a right without a remedy; for want of right and want of remedy are reciprocal.”3 The common law maxim has even been applied by the Court of Appeal in the context of a claim based on EU law. In Ryanair Limited v. Esso Italiana Srl [2013] EWCA Civ 1450, Rix LJ observed that Article 101 TFEU did embody a right, but held it was one which found its remedy in a claim for breach of statutory duty and not in the implication of a term into a commercial agreement for the purchase of aviation fuel. 3. EU law itself requires Member States to provide an effective remedy for the protection of EU rights. The right to effective judicial protection of EU law rights has long been recognised as a principle of EU law.4 Indeed, in his opinion in Case C-18/94 Barbara Hopkins v. National Power plc [1996] ECR I-2281, at [50], Advocate General Fennelly expressly referred to the maxim ubi ius ibi remedium in support of the general EU law principle of effective protection. Article 19 TEU now states that “Member States shall provide remedies sufficient to ensure effective legal protection in the fields covered by Union law.” Article 47 of the Charter of Fundamental Rights (‘CFR’) provides that everyone whose rights and freedoms guaranteed by EU law are violated has the right to 1 Bloodtaking and peacemaking: Feud, law and society in Saga Iceland, William Ian Miller (1990), Chicago University Press, p. 1-2. 2 See Harding v. Wealands [2006] UKHL 32, [2007] 2 AC 1, per Lord Rodger who at [76] rejected the inverted principle of ubi remedium ibi ius as “unsafe” when it was being applied to the distinction between procedural and substantive legal provisions for the purposes of implementing private international law. 3 The right to compensation for the disgruntled voter was recognised by the House of Lords in the subsequent appeal: (1703) 1 Bro. P.C. 62, 1 E.R. 417. 4 Case 20/88 Roquette Frères v. Commission [1989] ECR 1553, ECJ at [15]. 1 an effective remedy before a tribunal in compliance with the conditions laid down in that article. 4. The Court of Justice of the European Union (‘ECJ’) has adopted a similar approach in the application of Article 47 CFR as the Strasbourg Court has adopted in relation to Article 6 of the Convention. In Case C-279/09 DEB Deutsche Energiehandels- und Beratungsgesellschaft mbH v. Germany [2010] ECR I-13849, the ECJ at [28] reiterated the well-established principle of “effectiveness”, by which the detailed procedural rules governing actions for safeguarding an individual’s rights under EU law must not make it in practice impossible or excessively difficult to exercise rights conferred by EU law. At [29], the Court held that: “29. The question referred thus concerns the right of a legal person to effective access to justice and, accordingly, in the context of EU law, it concerns the principle of effective judicial protection. That principle is a general principle of EU law stemming from the constitutional traditions common to the Member States, which has been enshrined in Articles 6 and 13 of the . ECHR.” 5. In principle, these rights should be equally protected in litigation before the ECJ and the General Court of the European (‘GCEU’). In Opinion 1/2009 [2011] ECR I-1137, the ECJ was invited to rule on a draft proposal for the creation of a unified Patent Court. Having identified (at [65]) that the “essential characteristics” of the EU legal order were founded on the twin principles of primacy and direct effect, the ECJ noted at [66] that the “guardians of that legal order” were the Court of Justice and the courts and tribunals of the Member States. At [70], the Court held that: “The judicial system of the European Union is moreover a complete system of legal remedies and procedures designed to ensure review of the legality of acts of the institutions.” [Emphasis added] More recently, in Opinion 2/13 [2014] ECLI:EU:C:2014:2454, the Court at [174] emphasised that the Treaties have established a judicial system intended to ensure consistency and uniformity in the interpretation of EU law. These Opinions confirm the recognition by the Court of the need for the EU legal system to be based on the rule of law. In an EU context, that means that neither the EU Institutions nor the Member States may avoid a review of the conformity of EU measures with the Treaties.5 6. In other words, a combination of judicial review through direct actions under Articles 263 TFEU and 265 TFEU; and the ability of national courts to request a preliminary ruling under Article 267 TFEU, are intended to constitute a coherent and complete system of remedies. They are designed to ensure the effective review of the legality of all measures emanating from the EU institutions. The concern I shall address in this paper is whether the EU legal system in practice gives proper effect to the right to an effective remedy within its own processes and procedures. Does it recognise the principle of ubi ius, ibi remedium? Do the European Courts, in the words of Peter Cook’s miner, have the “Latin for the judging”? B. The strained hypothetical case 7. As is now customary, in order to answer this question it is convenient to concoct a strained hypothetical case. Chococoins Manufacturing Co (‘CMC’) is a Chinese company 5 See Case 294/83 Les Verts v. Parliament [1986] ECR 1339, ECJ at [23]. 2 that manufactures chocolate coins. Better Together 2016 Limited (‘BTL’) is a company established in England that imports chocolate coins from CMC in China. It imports chocolate coins in each of the currency denominations of the EU. Predicting a surge in demand ahead of the forthcoming referendum on UK membership of the EU, BTL places a large order for a consignment of both chocolate Euros and chocolate pounds from CMC. It proposes to import further consignments in the months up to 2016. 8. At around the same time, the EU Commission receives a complaint from the Association of Chocolate Coin Manufacturers (‘AssocChoc’). It is concerned that chocolate coins from China are being supplied to EU importers at a price which is substantially below the prevailing price for chocolate coins in the EU. A complaint is made that the products are subject to “dumping” which is injurious to EU industry. AssocChoc invites the Commission to impose anti-dumping duties. Following an investigation, the Commission finds that there has been injurious dumping and imposes anti-dumping duties on the import of chocolate coins in a definitive anti-dumping Regulation (‘the ADD Regulation’). An ad valorem duty of 100% is added to the customs duties which are also payable on importation. 9. Furthermore, consumer complaints about the quality of the imported chocolate coins, coupled with fears that they might be mistaken for real currency, prompt the Council and the European Parliament as co-legislators to impose marketing restrictions through the Chocolate Coins Directive (‘the Directive’). The Directive must be implemented by all Member States by May 2016. The Directive imposes strict labelling and packaging requirements on the supply of chocolate Euros, pounds and other currencies in the EU. These include requirements for the packaging to show the following warnings: “Warning: these coins are not real currency” and “Warning: this product is not pure chocolate.” A requirement for a minimum level of cocoa in the chocolate is also imposed. The measure is not preceded by an impact assessment. 10. The combined effect of these measures is to make the ongoing importation of chocolate Euros and pounds from CMC uneconomic. The measures also incense an anti-EU campaigning organisation in the UK, who launch a campaign to save the supply of chocolate pound coins. It will be assumed for the purposes of this paper that there is at least an arguable case that both the ADD Regulation and the Chocolate Coins Directive contravene relevant principles of EU law.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Medieval Devotion to Mary Among the Carmelites Eamon R
    Marian Studies Volume 52 The Marian Dimension of Christian Article 11 Spirituality, Historical Perspectives, I. The Early Period 2001 The aM rian Spirituality of the Medieval Religious Orders: Medieval Devotion to Mary Among the Carmelites Eamon R. Carroll Follow this and additional works at: https://ecommons.udayton.edu/marian_studies Part of the Religion Commons Recommended Citation Carroll, Eamon R. (2001) "The aM rian Spirituality of the Medieval Religious Orders: Medieval Devotion to Mary Among the Carmelites," Marian Studies: Vol. 52, Article 11. Available at: https://ecommons.udayton.edu/marian_studies/vol52/iss1/11 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Marian Library Publications at eCommons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Marian Studies by an authorized editor of eCommons. For more information, please contact [email protected], [email protected]. Carroll: Medieval Devotions…Carmelites The Marian Spirituality of the Medieval Religious Orders: Medieval Devotion ... Carmelites MEDIEVAL DEVOTION TO MARY AMONG THE CARMELITES Eamon R. Carroll, 0. Carm. * The word Carmel virtually defines the religious family that calls itself the Carmelite Order. It is a geographical designation (as in also Carthusian and Cistercian), not a person's name like Francis, Dominic and the Servite Seven Holy Founders. In the Church's calendar, Carmel is one of three Marian sites celebrated liturgically, along with Lourdes and St. Mary Major. It may be asked: Who founded the Carmelites on Mount Carmel? There is no easy answer, though some names have been suggested, begin, ning with the letter B-Brocard, Berthold, ...What is known is that during the Crusades in the late eleven,hundreds some Euro, peans settled as hermits on Mount Carmel, in the land where the Savior had lived.
    [Show full text]
  • Homily at the Requiem Mass for Fr. Brocard Sewell, O.Carm. (April 2000)
    Homily at the Requiem Mass for Fr. Brocard Sewell, O.Carm. (April 2000) Portrait of Brocard Sewell by Jane Percival When someone dies, and especially when that person is as well known as Fr. Brocard Sewell, there is a time for writing obituaries (and we have seen a series of these published on Fr. Brocard during the past week), and, possibly some time in the future, there will be a moment for a scholarly evaluation of Fr. Brocard’s contribution to literature. Now, at the celebration of this funeral Mass, it is time to rejoice at Fr. Brocard’s long life among us, to feel humbled by his love for the God to whom he dedicated his life, and grateful for the many ways in which his kindness and generosity blessed those who were privileged to know him. Rejoice is a right and proper word here, amidst our sadness at losing Brocard’s company, because for those of us who share his faith, his passing is a final movement towards the God he served so well. That is not to say that Brocard ever found his long journey of faith simple or easy. He started life as an Anglican and was nourished in the strong Church of England atmosphere that he found at Cheltenham and Weymouth Colleges. However, after leaving school, it was not long before he sought his spiritual home in the Roman Catholic tradition. In this, he followed in the footsteps of some of his literary heroes, notably G. K. Chesterton. However, Brocard was never a person to settle down and meekly accept opinions from others, so throughout his life he frequently found himself at odds with his fellow Catholics and with the Church authorities.
    [Show full text]
  • |||GET||| Jurisprudence (Legal Philosophy) in a Nutshell 1St Edition
    JURISPRUDENCE (LEGAL PHILOSOPHY) IN A NUTSHELL 1ST EDITION DOWNLOAD FREE Surya P Sinha | 9780314013798 | | | | | Jurisprudence Legal Philosophy: In a Nutshell On rare occasions, you may receive notice that an item listed on your order receipt has become out of stock. I also attempt to explain how conceptual analysis is related to other areas in philosophy, such as metaphysics and epistemology. He is widely considered one of the most important English-language political philosophers of the 20th century. AbeBooks Bookseller Since: May 31, But as a matter of pure logic, one cannot conclude that we ought to do something merely because something is the case. Of political justice, Aristotle argues that it is partly derived from nature and partly a matter of convention. Jurisprudence in Ancient Rome had its origins with the periti —experts in the jus mos maiorum traditional lawa body of oral laws and customs. Jurisprudenceor legal theoryis the theoretical study of law. It might be true, for example, that all judges wear robes, but this is not a feature of law that is sufficiently crucial to law that it must figure into an explication of the concept of law. In the second half of the twentieth century, sociological jurisprudence as a distinct movement declined Jurisprudence (Legal Philosophy) in a Nutshell 1st edition jurisprudence came more strongly under the influence of analytical legal philosophy; but with increasing criticism of dominant orientations of legal philosophy in English-speaking countries in the present century, it has attracted renewed Jurisprudence (Legal Philosophy) in a Nutshell 1st edition. It is true, of course, that 1 the content of all legal norms ultimately depend, in large measure, on social processes that can be empirically observed and 2 the norms of a system must be understandable in order to be sufficiently efficacious to constitute a legal system.
    [Show full text]
  • Adjusting the Conflicting Interests of Landowner and Aviator in Anglo-American Law Edward C
    Journal of Air Law and Commerce Volume 3 | Issue 3 Article 1 1932 Adjusting the Conflicting Interests of Landowner and Aviator in Anglo-American Law Edward C. Sweeney Follow this and additional works at: https://scholar.smu.edu/jalc Recommended Citation Edward C. Sweeney, Adjusting the Conflicting Interests of Landowner and Aviator in Anglo-American Law, 3 J. Air L. & Com. 329 (1932) https://scholar.smu.edu/jalc/vol3/iss3/1 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by the Law Journals at SMU Scholar. It has been accepted for inclusion in Journal of Air Law and Commerce by an authorized administrator of SMU Scholar. For more information, please visit http://digitalrepository.smu.edu. THE JOURNAL OF AIR LAW Volume III JULY, 1932 Number 3 ADJUSTING THE CONFLICTING INTERESTS OF LANDOWNER AND AVIATOR IN ANGLO-AMERICAN LAW EDWARD C. SWEENEY* I. THE PROBLEM Aviation has developed to a point where it now assumes a considerable economic, social and military importance. But, in establishing itself, it has given rise to important legal problems associated with the conflicting interests of landowner and aviator. The question is no longer: shall the aviator be permitted to fly above the land of another, but is, instead: how shall flying activi- ties be conducted so as to be least harmful, if harmful at all, to the owner of the land. At the outset, it is necessary to state and clarify the problems involved in this conflict of interest. While the settlement of the various questions concerned with trespass, nuisance, liability, etc., can be settled only by the courts, still, it is important that there be a clear understanding of the interests involved and the extent to which they should be protected.
    [Show full text]
  • From Decadent Diabolist to Roman Catholic Demonologist: Some Biographical Curiosities from Montague Summers’ Black Folio
    From Decadent Diabolist to Roman Catholic Demonologist: Some Biographical Curiosities from Montague Summers’ Black Folio Bernard Doherty Introduction The history and practice of black magic, witchcraft, and Satanism have long held a deep fascination in British—and indeed international—popular culture. Beginning with the gothic literature of the eighteenth century, through to the nineteenth century occult revival and Victorian “penny dreadful,” and then into twentieth century pulp fiction, tales of the supernatural involving maleficent magic have been authored some of Britain’s most popular—if not always critically acclaimed—writers including, among others M. R. James, Arthur Machen, William Somerset Maugham, Agatha Christie, Charles Williams, and Dennis Wheatley. These writers, as well as various other short story writers, novelists, and journalists, have all played an important role in shaping, recording, and reflecting popular beliefs about these topics. Indeed, not a few occult practitioners, most notably Aleister Crowley, Dion Fortune, Gerald Gardner, and Doreen Valiente, even turned their hands to writing popular occult fiction. Despite this, the frequent blurring of the often porous boundary between actual occult practices and groups, and the imagined worlds of the purveyors of popular and literary fiction, has been seldom explored outside of highly specialised academic literature dedicated to the history of gothic or weird fiction and the burgeoning study of what has come to be called Western Esotericism.1 Bernard Doherty is a lecturer in the School of Theology at Charles Sturt University. 1 See, for example, Nick Freeman, ‘The Black Magic Bogeyman 1908–1935’, in The Occult Imagination in Britain, 1875–1947, ed. Christine Ferguson and Andrew Radford, pp.
    [Show full text]
  • A Moralistic Case for A-Moralistic Law
    Valparaiso University Law Review Volume 20 Number 1 Fall 1985 pp.1-41 Fall 1985 A Moralistic Case for A-Moralistic Law Neil MacCormick Follow this and additional works at: https://scholar.valpo.edu/vulr Part of the Law Commons Recommended Citation Neil MacCormick, A Moralistic Case for A-Moralistic Law, 20 Val. U. L. Rev. 1 (1985). Available at: https://scholar.valpo.edu/vulr/vol20/iss1/1 This Lecture is brought to you for free and open access by the Valparaiso University Law School at ValpoScholar. It has been accepted for inclusion in Valparaiso University Law Review by an authorized administrator of ValpoScholar. For more information, please contact a ValpoScholar staff member at [email protected]. MacCormick: A Moralistic Case for A-Moralistic Law ValparaisoUniversity Law Review Volume 20 Fall 1985 Number 1 A MORALISTIC CASE FOR A-MORALISTIC LAW? NEIL MACCORMICK* Two LECTURES ON LAW AND THE ENFORCEMENT OF MORALS The essays presented here were first delivered as the Seegers Lectures at the Valparaiso University School of Law on March 26th and 27th, 1985. Edward A. Seegers has been a generous benefactor of the School, and it is an honor to be invited to present lectures in honor of such a friend of learning; all the more so in that the 1985 lectures in the series followed those of Professors Harold Berman and Tom Shaffer, and are to precede lectures by Professor Eugene V. Rostow, of whom I once had the good fortune to be a junior colleague when he was Eastman Professor at Balliol College, Oxford, and who is himself author of a seminal article' in the field I address here.
    [Show full text]
  • The Beginning, Flourishing and Decline of the Inns of Court: the Consolidation of the English Legal Profession After 1400
    Vanderbilt Law Review Volume 10 Issue 1 Issue 1 - December 1956 Article 3 12-1956 The Beginning, Flourishing and Decline of the Inns of Court: The Consolidation of the English Legal Profession after 1400 Anton Hermann Chroust Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarship.law.vanderbilt.edu/vlr Part of the Legal Profession Commons Recommended Citation Anton Hermann Chroust, The Beginning, Flourishing and Decline of the Inns of Court: The Consolidation of the English Legal Profession after 1400, 10 Vanderbilt Law Review 79 (1956) Available at: https://scholarship.law.vanderbilt.edu/vlr/vol10/iss1/3 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by Scholarship@Vanderbilt Law. It has been accepted for inclusion in Vanderbilt Law Review by an authorized editor of Scholarship@Vanderbilt Law. For more information, please contact [email protected]. THE BEGINNING, FLOURISHING AND DECLINE OF THE INNS OF COURT: THE CONSOLIDATION OF THE ENGLISH LEGAL PROFESSION AFTER 1400 ANTON-HERMANN CHROUST* Wherever the common law is studied and practiced [the Inns of Court] must be regarded as the original fountainhead of the law, toward which the true lawyer must feel as a Jew does toward Jerusalem and a Mus- sulman towards Mecca. The four Inns of Court-Lincoln's Inn, Gray's Inn, the Middle Tem- ple and the Inner Temple-may well be called one single legal univer- sity composed of four relatively independent colleges. In their long and illustrious history these Inns have discharged important func- tions in the domains of legal education and professional discipline. As the depository of splendid professional traditions which date back to the Middle Ages, they were for a long time the guardian as well as the gateway to the higher English Bar.
    [Show full text]
  • The Philosophy of Law
    THE PHILOSOPHY OF LAW an Expirlsitiirn OF TBE FUNDAXENTAL PRINCIPLES OF JURISPRUDENCE Ar THE SCIENCE OF RIGHT. BY IMMANUEL KANT. EransIateb from tbe Germaa BY W. HASTIE, B.D. EDINBURGH : T. & T. CLARK, 38 QEORGE STREET. 1887. TRANSLATOR'S PREFACE. KANT'SScience of Riyht ' is a complete exposition of the Yhilosophy of Law, viewed as a rational investigation of 'But next to a new ~isto&of Law, what we most require is a the fundamental Principles of Jurisprudence. It was new Philosophy of faw.'-Sir HENRYSUMNE~ MAINE. published in 1'796,2 as the First Part of his Metaphysic of Mo~nls: the promised sequel and completion of the Foundation for a ilfetaphysic of Movals~published in 1'785. The irnportance and value o£ the great thinker's exposition of the Science of Right, both as regards the fundamental Principles of his own Practical Philosophy and the general interest of the Philosophy of Law, were at once recognised. A second Edition, enlarged by an 1 Rechtslehre. It appeared soon after Michaelmas 1796, but with the year 1797 on the title-page. This has given rise to some confusion regarding the date of the first Edition, which is now usually quoteri as 1796-7. (Schubert, Kant's Werke, Bd. ix. viii., and Biographie, p. 145.) * Die Metaphysik der Sitten. Erster Theil. Metaphysische Anfangs- gründe der Rechtslehre. Köriigsberg, 1797. 4 Grundlegung zur Metaphysik der Sitten. Translated by Willich (1798), Semple (1836), and Abbott (1873). vi KANT'S PHILOSOPHY OF LAtK TRAXSLATOR'S PREFACE. vii Appendix, containing Supplementary Explanations of the and with it he virtually brouglit his activity as a master Principles of Right, appeared in 1'798? The work has of thought to a close? It fittingly crowned the, rich since then been several times reproduced by itself, as practical period of his later philosophical teaching, and well as incorporated in all fhe complete editions of he shed into it the last effort of his energy of thought.
    [Show full text]
  • Bulletin Du Centre D'études Médiévales D'auxerre
    Bulletin du centre d’études médiévales d’Auxerre | BUCEMA 21.2 | 2017 Varia Édition électronique URL : http://journals.openedition.org/cem/14724 DOI : 10.4000/cem.14724 ISSN : 1954-3093 Éditeur Centre d'études médiévales Saint-Germain d'Auxerre Référence électronique Bulletin du centre d’études médiévales d’Auxerre | BUCEMA, 21.2 | 2017 [En ligne], mis en ligne le 31 décembre 2017, consulté le 25 novembre 2020. URL : http://journals.openedition.org/cem/14724 ; DOI : https://doi.org/10.4000/cem.14724 Ce document a été généré automatiquement le 25 novembre 2020. Les contenus du Bulletin du centre d’études médiévales d’Auxerre (BUCEMA) sont mis à disposition selon les termes de la Licence Creative Commons Attribution - Pas d’Utilisation Commerciale - Partage dans les Mêmes Conditions 4.0 International. 1 SOMMAIRE Recherche active L’eucharistie, l’apostat et le crapaud. Sur un exemplum de Césaire de Heisterbach François Wallerich La femme tel un diamant marial : idéal féminin, spiritualité et médecine dans le Livre de la vertu du sacrement de mariage de Philippe de Mézières Marc-André Moreau La Bourgogne au premier Moyen Âge (VIe‑Xe s.) : approches spatiales et institutionnelles – 1re livraison Introduction Jessika Nowak et Jens Schneider Les Chamaves et les autres : une enquête linguistique sur les traces des Chamaves, Hattuaires, Varasques, Scotinges et Burgondes au nord de la Bourgogne Wolfgang Haubrichs Burgund und das « unsichtbare Römische Reich » im Spiegel der sogenannten merowingischen Monetarmünzen. Eine Anmerkung Jürgen Strothmann The Burgundian « visage ». Seals between tradition and innovation Jessika Nowak Dossier cartographique Chantiers Saint-Martin de Blanquefort (Gironde) : apport d’une fouille de faible ampleur à la connaissance d’un cimetière paroissial Juliette Masson, Hélène Réveillas et Mikaël Rouzic Bulletin du centre d’études médiévales d’Auxerre | BUCEMA, 21.2 | 2017 2 Parutions récentes Le temps long de Clairvaux.
    [Show full text]
  • Dissenting Opinion of Judge Eboe-Osuji
    ICC-01/09-02/11-863-Anx 26-11-2013 1/79 EC T Dissenting Opinion of Judge Eboe-Osuji 1. I have read with care the joint decision of Judge Ozaki and Judge Fremr 'reconsidering' the Majority decision that Judge Fremr and I had issued in the matter of the Defence request for conditional excusai from continuous presence at trial. The good faith of my colleagues is not in doubt, hi particular, I am very certain that my very good and leamed friend, Judge Fremr, with whom I authored the Majority decision now being 'reconsidered', is motivated by nothing less than the most impeccable of honourable intentions. Nevertheless, for the reasons explained in this opinion, I regret my inability to agree with their decision, both on the procedure and as to the substance. [I regret, too, my inability to express my opinion with comparable brevity. More presses to be said in solitary dissent.] OVERVffiW 2. hi view of its length, I divide this opinion into five parts. Part I discusses why the decision of the Majority of the Trial Chamber is unsuitable for reconsideration. The better approach, in my view, is to seise the Appeals Chamber of the Kenyatta appeal, in order to give them an opportunity to resolve certain questions arising from their decision in the Ruto case, particularly the questions that I discuss in parts II, III, IV and V. 3. Part II lays out the thought that, in the construction of legal texts, the incidence of the auxiliary verb 'shall' has not always been accepted as signifying a mandatory outcome that eliminates further judicial inquiry as to the import of the given provision.
    [Show full text]
  • Legal and Market Uncertainty in Market-Based Instruments: the Case of the Eu Ets
    DARI-VAN ZEBEN FOR PRINTER.DOC 8/31/2012 5:07:29 PM ARTICLES LEGAL AND MARKET UNCERTAINTY IN MARKET-BASED INSTRUMENTS: THE CASE OF THE EU ETS * ** GIUSEPPE DARI-MATTIACCI & JOSEPHINE VAN ZEBEN Parties in litigation may experience legal uncertainty, which can spread into markets. If so, there are relevant and pervasive consequences for unrelated third parties. We argue that certain types of legal remedies cause the transformation from legal uncertainty into “market uncertainty.” This problem is particularly important for “artificial markets,” such as those created by the legislator for the purposes of market-based regulation, e.g., the European Union Emission Trading System (“EU ETS”). Specifically, market uncertainty is a likely consequence of the use of restitutio in integrum (a property-rule remedy) as opposed to the use of damages (a liability-rule remedy). Recent litigation within the EU ETS provides a clear example of both the mechanisms of transmission of legal uncertainty to the market and of its causes. We identify the costs of letting legal uncertainty turn into market uncertainty and examine possible solutions to this problem. * Professor of Law and Economics, Amsterdam Center for Law and Economics, University of Amsterdam. ** Hauser Global Research Fellow, New York University School of Law, 2010-2011; PhD candidate, Amsterdam Center for Law and Economics and Center for Environmental Law, University of Amsterdam. The authors would like to thank the following people for helpful comments on earlier versions of this article: Alessandra Arcuri, Oren Bar-Gill, William B. Buzbee, Stefano Clò, Suzanne Kingston, Rosemary Lyster, Marc Pallemaerts, Eric Posner, and Henri de Waele as well as the participants in the 2010 EMLE Conference, participants of the 2010 EDLE Conference, and participants of the 2010 SELE Annual Conference.
    [Show full text]
  • Right of Privacy and Restraints on Abortion Under the "Undue Burden" Test: a Jurisprudential Comparison of Planned Parenthood V
    The Right of Privacy and Restraints on Abortion under the "Undue Burden" Test: A Jurisprudential Comparison of Planned Parenthood v. Casey with European Practice and Italian Law by Charles Stanley Ross* I. INTRODUCTION The most recent Supreme Court decision on state regulation of abortion continues a particularly American line of precedent and rea- soning-welcome to some, indefensible to others-in upholding a wom- an's right to choose an abortion before fetal viability. At the same time the Court recognized that a state may impose restrictions on the in- terruption of pregnancy, so long as these restraints do not impose an "undue burden" on the exercise of the constitutionally defended right.' The Court's 5-4 decision contains a withering dissent wherein the Chief Justice and three colleagues deny the existence of a constitutional right to an abortion and argue that a state legislature has total dominion over restraints on abortion procedures. Justice Scalia's additional dissent further gores the majority opinion by lamenting the impossibility of applying the "undue burden" test associated with the reasoning, in past decisions and this one, of Justice O'Connor.2 The language of the Court's opinion-from the majority's proc- lamation of the right to abortion as a "fundamental liberty" protected by the Constitution to the ridicule Scalia heaps on the "undue burden" test, 3 as well as Justice Blackmun's lament that he is eighty-three years old and cannot much longer hold back the forces of darkness that were one vote away from gaining their will in this decision 4-reveals a court * Associate Professor, Department of English, Purdue University & J.D.
    [Show full text]