African-A1merican Women Workers and the Women's Trade Union League
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
"YOUR SISTEXS OF DARKER HUE": AFRICAN-A1MERICAN WOMEN WORKERS AND THE WOMEN'S TRADE UNION LEAGUE Jennifer Lynn Carson Department of History Subrnitted in partial fidfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts Faculty of Graduate Studies The University of Western Ontario London, Ontario March, 1998 @ Jennifer Lynn Carson 1998 National Library Bibliothèque nationale I*U ofcanada du Canada Acquisitions and Acquisitions et Bibliographie Services senices bibliographiques 395 wellingtori Street 395. nie Wellington ûüawaON KIAONQ ôtrawa ON KIA ON4 Canada CaMda The author has granted a non- L'auteur a accordé une licence non exclusive licence allowing the exclusive permettant à la National Library of Canada to Bibliothèque nationale du Canada de reproduce, loan, distriiute or sell reproduire, prêter, disbn'buer ou copies of this thesis in microform, vendre des copies de cette thèse sous paper or electronic formats. la forme de microfiche/fïlxn, de reproduction sur papier ou sur format électronique. The author retains ownership of the L'auteur conserve la propriété du copyright in this thesis. Neither the droit d'auteur qui protège cette thèse. thesis nor subsîantial extracts fkom it Ni la thèse ni des extraits substantiels may be printed or otheMrise de celle-ci ne doivent être imprimés reproduced without the author's ou autrement reproduits sans son permission. autorisation. This thesis explores the relationship between the Women's Trade Union League (WTUL) and African-American women workers. It examines both the official poiky of the National WTUL regarding the unionization of black women workers, as weli as some of its organuational campaigns involving Affican- American workers. This anaiysis will outline the reasons why the League's rhetorical commitment to racial equality did not lead to a concerted attack on the racist practices found within the American labor movement The second haif of this work provides a comparative analysis of the racial practices of the National WTUL, and the New York WTUL, the most active local branch of the National League. Focusing on the New York League's campaign to organue New York City's laundry workers, the majority of whom were African- American women, this thesis will explain why the NY League was able to Iive up to the National League's espoused principies of racial equaiity. ACKNOWLEDGEMENTS 1 would iike to express my sincere gratitude for the time, guidance and encouragement provided by my thesis advisor Margaret Kellow. Her insighthil comments and unfiagging support have made this work possible. 1 would also iike to express my deep appreciation to Jack Blocker, whose insightful comments on Afncan-American workers has greatly enhanced this project. TABLE OF CONTENTS Certificate of Examination Abstract Acknowledgements Table of Contents List of Acronyms 1. Introduction 2. "When you can find your way clear to join hands with your sisten of darker hue": The National Women's Trade Union League and African- American Women Workers 3 . "They performed a very real fùnction": The New York Women's Trade Union League and Afiican-Amencan Wornen Workers 4. "It was like the salvation": The Organization of New York City's Laundry Workers and the New York Women's Trade Union League Conclusion Bibliography Vita LIST OF ACRONYMS ACWA Amdgamated Clothing Workers of Amenca AFL American Federation of Labor BWOHE' Black Woman Oral History Project CIO Congress of Industrial Organizations FDR Frankllli Delano Roosevelt rLGW international Ladies' Garment Workers Union ElLw international Laundry Workers' Union LOR Leonora O'Reilly MA Mary Anderson MD Mary Dreier MDR Margaret Dreier Robins NAACP National Association for the Advancement of Colored People NAWSA National Amencan Woman Suffrage Association NRA National Recovery Act NUL National Urban League NwP National Woman's Party NWTUL National Women's Trade Union League NYWTUL New York Women's Trade Union League NYDL New York Department of Labor NYUL New York Urban League RS Rose Schneiderman TC'ITUW Twentieth Century Trade Union Woman USDL United States Department of Labor UTWA United Textile Workers of America WCTC Woman's Christian Temperance Union WTUL Women's Trade Union League YMCA Young Men's Christian Association YWCA Young Women's Christian Association Chapter One Introduction In 1903, at an Arnerican Federation of Labor Convention, Mary k~eyO'Sdlivan announced the formation of a League dedicated to the "organization of women wage earners into Trade Unions. "' Convhced that collective labor bargainhg would provide the solution to women's exploitation in the industrial labor force, a smalI group of upper-class "ailies" and social reformers set out to improve the working conditions of their industrial sisters through the formation of the National Women's Trade Union League of America (NWTUL).2 The League was to be modeled after the British Women's Trade Union League, which had been in existence since 1874.' The National League established its 'In its 1905-1906 program, League leaders asserted that "The object of the Women's Trade Union League shall be to assist in the organization of women wage emers into Trade Unions and thereby to help them secure conditions necessary for healthfUI and efficient work and to obtain a just retum for such work. " OflciaZ Report of the WTUL of Arne- 1905-1906, 1, Reel 1, National Women's Trade Union League Papers of Arnerica (Hereafkr NWTUL Papers), Schlesinger Library, Radcliffe College, Cambridge, Mas. (Microfilm Edition of the Papers of the WïüL and its Principal Leaders). Mary Kenney O'Sullivan was a bindny worker whose help in the organization of Ladies Federal Labor Union No. 2703 of the American Federation of Labor (An)made her the An's first woman organizer. Barbara Mayer Wertheimer, We Were ïhere: The Story of Working Women m Amena (New York: Pantheon Books, 1977)- 267. 2 In addition to OfSullivan, founders included seîtlement worker and socialist WiIliam English Walling, a Boston philanthropist Mary Kehew, senlement workers Jane Addams, Lillian Wald and Mary McDoweU, shirtwaist rnaker and Knights of Labor activist Leonora OReilly, a shoernaker by the name of Mary Donovan, and garment workers Mary Freitas and EUen Lindstrom Wertheimer7 We Were There: The Story of Wovkng Women in Arne- 265-28 1; Philip Foner, Women and the Americm? Labor Movement: From Colonial Times to the Eve of Worki W'ar I,vol. 1, (New York: The Free Ress, 1979), 25 1,295. 3Foner, Women anù the American Ldor Movement, vol. 1,295-296. headquarters in Chicago, and soon afterwards local Leagues opened in New York Chicago and Boston. During the next fifteen years League supporters opened other local Leagues in several cities throughout the Nonhem United States, and in 1929 League activities were extended into the south.' As their primary objective League founders planned to create an egahtarian cross-class alliance of women dedicated to improving the working conditions of femaie wage eamers through trade unionism. Leaders sought to achieve this goal by strengthening existing unions and creating new unions of women wage eamers. They dso hoped to educate the American public and the mainstrearn male labor movement about the depiorable conditions under which women labored, as well as their pressing need to organize into trade unions. From the beginning, the League sought to establish close ties with the Amencan Federation of Labor (An).Its constitutional platform included a provision that wherever possible, unions that they organized would afliliate with the appropriate An local.' Despite hopes of eniisting the support, hancial and othenvise, of organized labor, League leaders were continually mistrated by An President Samuel Gompers' uninterested and generally patronizing attitude toward the organization of women workers. Although the crafl union emphasis of the An excluded rnost women owing to their concentration in low skilled trades, Gompers did Linle to assist the League in carnpaigns to help these women achieve organization. WMe publicly Gompers professed his support of the 1Nancy Schrom Dye, As EQuaLs andm Sisters: Feminim, the hbor Mowment, d the Womenk Traie Union Leagrie of New York (Columbia: University of Missouri Press, l98O), 5. 'philip Foner, Women mui the Arne- Labor Movement, vol. 1,3 17-322; Wfiarn Chafe, fie Amencm Wom:Her Chcnigmg Srocid, Ecoromic unà Political Roles, NZO- 19 70 (London: Mord University Press, 1972), 76-79. 3 League, in reality he gave the League virtuaily no assistance. By 19 13, hstrated by the An's lack of support, and having achieved only moderate organizational success, the League increasingly tunied its attention toward the passage of su5age and protective labor legislation as the best avenue for improving working conditions for women wage earners. Nevertheless, although the League fded to achieve its primary goal of organizing women into the predominantly male American labor movement, the contributions the WTLZ made to the Progressive Movement, to the Labor Movement, and in the Lives of working wornen, should not be underestirnated. Under the able leadership of Margaret Dreier Robins, a Chicago philanthropist who held the position of President of the NWTUL from 1907 to 1922, the League vigorousiy pursued the organization and education of wornen workers, as weU as the enactment of sufhge and protective labor legislation. The League provided organizers, funds and favorable publicity for numerous strikes involving women workers, including corset workers in Illinois, collar starchers in Troy, textile workers in Boston, shirtwaist makers in New York and Philadelphia, and many others. In 191 1, enabled by the financial sponsorship of Margaret Robins, the League published its first copy of Lije mtd Labor. which would serve as its officia1 journal fiom 191 1 to 192 1.6 Three years later the National League opened a training school for women workers providing both academic and practical education.' Many historians argue that the League's most signincant %me Kirby, "Class, Gender and the Peds of PManthropy: The Story of Life dhbw and Labor Reform in the Women's Trade Union League," Journal of Women's History 42 (1992): 36-5 1.