Identification and Comparison of Varroa Species Infesting Honey Bees Lilia I
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Identification and comparison of Varroa species infesting honey bees Lilia I. de Guzman, Thomas E. Rinderer To cite this version: Lilia I. de Guzman, Thomas E. Rinderer. Identification and comparison of Varroa species infesting honey bees. Apidologie, Springer Verlag, 1999, 30 (2-3), pp.85-95. hal-00891570 HAL Id: hal-00891570 https://hal.archives-ouvertes.fr/hal-00891570 Submitted on 1 Jan 1999 HAL is a multi-disciplinary open access L’archive ouverte pluridisciplinaire HAL, est archive for the deposit and dissemination of sci- destinée au dépôt et à la diffusion de documents entific research documents, whether they are pub- scientifiques de niveau recherche, publiés ou non, lished or not. The documents may come from émanant des établissements d’enseignement et de teaching and research institutions in France or recherche français ou étrangers, des laboratoires abroad, or from public or private research centers. publics ou privés. Invited review article Identification and comparison of Varroa species infesting honey bees Lilia I. de Guzman Thomas E. Rinderer ARS, USDA, Honey Bee Breeding, Genetics and Physiology Laboratory, 1157 Ben Hur Road, Baton Rouge, LA 70820, USA (Received 26 July 1998; accepted 21 February 1999) Abstract - Varroa jacobsoni Oudemans, V. underwoodi Delfinado-Baker and Aggarwal and V. rindereri de Guzman and Delfinado-Baker are obligatory parasites of honey bees. The key mor- phological characters, host range and geographic distribution of these three species are reviewed. The occurrence of different genotypes of V. jacobsoni, their geographic distribution and virulence on honey bee hosts are discussed. © Inra/DIB/AGIB/Elsevier, Paris Varroa jacobsoni / Varroa underwoodi / Varroa rindereri / morphology / genotype / host range / distribution 1. INTRODUCTION covery of still more species of Varroa. This review compares the key morphological characters, host and distribution of There are three known species of Var- range the three known Varroa In addi- roa (Acari: Varroidae) parasitizing honey species. bees (Apis spp.), namely: Varroa jacobsoni tion, the genetic diversity of V. jacobsoni Oudemans 1904, V. underwoodi Delfinado- and its possible correlation to the virulence Baker and Aggarwal 1987 and V. rindereri of mites on infested hosts are also discussed. de Guzman and Delfinado-Baker 1996. The recent identification of V. rindereri from the cavity dwelling honey bee, Apis kosche- 2. VARROA JACOBSONI vnikovi Buttel-Reepen, in Borneo and the identification of different varieties of The general morphology and chaetotaxy V. jacobsoni indicate the need for further of V. jacobsoni, V. rindereri and V. under- investigations which may lead to the dis- woodi are very similar. However, V. jacob- * Correspondence and reprints E-mail: [email protected] soni and V. rindereri are transversely oval as R and J genotypes were established by using opposed to the ellipsoidal shape of V. under- two RAPD primers [15]. In the R genotype, woodi. V. jacobsoni can be distinguished primer OPE-07 produced a 766-bp band from V. rindereri by several characters which was absent in the J genotype (figure 1) including small size, short and sharp-looped [ 15]. Similarly, using primer OPP-03, the peritreme, fewer endopodal setae and pres- R genotype produced a band at 442 bp not ence of a seta on the palpal trochanter (table I). found in the J genotype. The J genotype pro- A more detailed description of characters duced two distinct bands at 675 and 412 bp of the adult female, nymphal stages and that were absent in the R genotype. adult male of V. jacobsoni are described by Oudemans [45] and Delfinado-Baker [26], The PCR amplification and subsequent respectively. restriction enzyme digestion of a portion of the mtDNA CO I region [4] was also used to Delfinado-Baker and Houck [28] found distinguish between the R and J genotypes some morphological differences between [16]. When the PCR products were digested populations of V. jacobsoni, especially with Sst I, the fragment amplified from mites regarding body size. In general, V. jacob- with the R genotype did not undergo diges- soni that infests A. cerana F. is smaller than tion (producing a single band of 519 bp). those infesting A. mellifera L. These differ- Sst I digestion of the fragment from the ences may be due to the existence of at least J genotype produced fragments of 236 and three genotypes of V. jacobsoni: Russian (R), Japanese (J) and Papua New Guinea (PNG) genotypes [4, 14-17]. We use the term ’genotype’ to indicate mites having common DNA variations within the native range of V. jacobsoni. This definition fol- lows that of King [34]. The R genotype is also referred to as the GER genotype by Anderson and Fuchs [4]. In a previous anal- ysis using random amplification of poly- morphic DNA (RAPD), Kraus and Hunt [37] found bands that were shared by Ger- man and US V. jacobsoni but absent in Malaysian mites. Using the same technique, 338 bp in length, similar to the pattern observed in PNG (figure 2). Digestion with Xho I did not show any differences between R and J genotypes (fragments of 269 and 300 bp). However, the PNG type lacked the restriction site, producing a single band of 519 bp [4]. 2.1. Host range V. jacobsoni was first discovered infest- ing A. cerana in Java, Indonesia. It has since successfully extended its host range to dif- ferent honey bee species, including intro- duced A. mellifera in Asia (table II). 2.2. Distribution Recently, V. jacobsoni was observed in drone brood of A. nigrocincta Smith in Since its discovery in 1904 by Oude- Sulawesi, Indonesia [32]. Infestation of mans, V. jacobsoni has been found through- V. jacobsoni has also been reported in out the world except Australia, New colonies of A. koschevnikovi in Borneo [29]. Zealand, Hawaii and parts of Africa [40]. However, it is possible that this report may However, recent genetic studies revealed be referring to V. rindereri instead of V. that the R genotype is actually the predom- jacobsoni. V. jacobsoni was also found inant genotype of V. jacobsoni. The PNG infesting mixed populations of the newly or ’NRP’ strain, which is currently found described honey bee species, A. nuluensis only in Asia, is the type of V. jacobsoni that Tingek, Koeniger and Koeniger and A. cer- Oudemans described in 1904 [1, 4]. There- ana in Borneo [13]. With this mixed bee fore, the PNG genotype found in Java, species condition, the actual colony source Indonesia is not the type that has spread of the V. jacobsoni is unclear. worldwide as originally thought. This was supported by further DNA analyses, which The reported global differences in the revealed that the R and J genotypes had a virulence of V. jacobsoni toward A. mellif- wider distribution than the PNG type era may suggest that some genotypes of V. [14-17]. The R genotype was the most pre- jacobsoni have reduced virulence. DNA dominant type being found in much of analyses revealed variable genotypes of Europe, Russia, South and North America, V. jacobsoni infesting A. mellifera and Africa, and Asia. The J genotype has been A. cerana in Asia [4, 14-17] (table III). Lack recorded in South and North America, and of virulence of the PNG genotype of Asia (table III). V. jacobsoni has been documented in PNG and Indonesia [1, 4]. This V. jacobsoni reproduces in A. cerana drone brood, but 2.3. Virulence not in drone and worker brood of A. mellif- era [4]. Whether or not this characteristic is specific to the PNG genotype has yet to be V. is known to be the most jacobsoni seri- investigated. The PNG genotype was also ous parasite of A. mellifera worldwide. It recorded in Borneo and the Philippines causes abnormalities, reduced weight and infesting A. cerana colonies (de Guzman, longevity of workers and drones, reduced unpublished data). mucus gland and seminal vesicle weights, In contrast, tremendous losses of A. mel- reduced number of spermatozoa, death of due to V. infestations were brood and death of adult lifera jacobsoni young premature recorded in the and Korea [10, bees [5, Enormous losses Philippines 18, 23, 30, 47, 49]. 11]. Both countries have the R of managed honey bee colonies in Europe genotype. The R genotype was a recent introduction [38, 48] and the United States have [33] into Java, Indonesia [2, 4] but the level of been reported. Likewise, the establishment virulence in A. mellifera colonies has not of V. jacobsoni in the US resulted in the been monitored. Both R and J genotypes of apparent loss of much of the feral population V. jacobsoni were found in Thailand [15]. of honey bees. However, Tropilaelaps clareae which pre- Different honey bee species and sub- dominates in the colonies could mask the effects of V. in species of A. mellifera vary in response to jacobsoni A. mellifera V. jacobsoni parasitism [9, 20, 22, 43, 44, colonies. T. clareae is reported to be a more 46, 48]. For instance, in Asia, where the injurious parasite to A. mellifera than V. V. is also a indigenous A. cerana and introduced A. mel- jacobsoni [6, 8]. jacobsoni for A. lifera are now sympatric, effects of V. jacob- major problem mellifera beekeeping in Vietnam In A. soni parasitism on these two honey bee [31]. Vietnam, mellifera colonies have the R while colonies species are quite different. While A. cerana genotype, of A. cerana have the J regulates V. jacobsoni infestations success- genotype [15]. This observation the differential fully, A. mellifera seems to be very suscep- may explain tible to V. jacobsoni infestations. This resis- reproduction of V. jacobsoni observed in A. and A. cerana colonies in Viet- tance of A. cerana is due to their ability to mellifera nam The J was confine mite reproduction to drone brood, in [7].