Deputy First Tom Clarke CBE Minister Swinney responds to addresses Catholic bishops’ general headteachers. election advice. Pages 4-5 SUPPORTING 50 YEARS OF SCIAF, 1965-2015 Page 10
No 5619 VISIT YOUR NATIONAL CATHOLIC NEWSPAPER ONLINE AT WWW.SCONEWS.CO.UK Friday May 8 2015 | £1 MSPs set to reject flawed assisted suicide proposal I Bill puts pressure on vulnerable people to kill themselves, says expert By Ian Dunn crossing a legal and ethical “Rubicon” stridently condemned the legislation. Rev that are raised by assisted suicide,’ that Sally Foster-Fulton, convener of its THE Scottish Parliament appears the bill contains no requirement ‘for church and society council, said they BISHOPS BACK poised to reject the Assisted Suicide mandatory psychiatric assessment’ to any ‘remain concerned with both the general (Scotland) Bill after the Holyrood request for assisted suicide by a person... principles and the specific content of the committee reviewing the controversial with a history of mental disorder, and that assisted suicide bill.’ “Critical flaws in the legislation said that it contained ‘legislation to permit assisted suicide proposed legislation include an absence SCIAF PUSH(BIKE) ‘significant flaws.’ seems discordant with a wider policy of of any mental health check and a mini- Holyrood’s health and sport committee suicide prevention by “normalising” mum age of 16,” she said. “Both make reported that—as it is a matter of suicide and seeming to endorse it.’ the bill in its present form untenable.” conscience—it had chosen to make no Mr Macdonald said the report ‘confirms formal recommendation to parliament on what [Care has] said all along.’ MSPs the bill which means the Scottish “The bill is poorly thought out, ill- Green MSP Patrick Harvie agreed to Parliament will vote on the bill in its current conceived, badly-drafted and effectively take the bill forward following the death form. That will happen before the end of not fit for purpose,” he said. “We are of independent MSP Margo MacDonald, May and MSPs are expected to reject it. delighted that the committee agrees who had campaigned for assisted with us that the bill contains significant suicide to be legalised in Scotland. Right direction flaws which are likely to prevent it from Responding to the committee’s Peter Kearney, director of the Scottish being enacted. It is gratifying to note a concerns, Mr Harvie said he was open Catholic Media Office who backs the majority of the committee is against the to suggestions as to how the legislation Church’s opposition to the bill, told the bill although they have not made a formal could be strengthened. SCO he believed the chances of the bill recommendation to the Parliament to “This committee report makes no progressing are ‘very, very slim and reject the bill.” formal recommendation to MSPs, and rightfully so.’ He also highlighted that the leaders of it’s right that members decide on this issue Gordon Macdonald of the campaign Scottish Labour, the Scottish Liberal each having considered it carefully,” he group Care Not Killing said it would be Democrats and the Scottish National said. “It is however disappointing that ‘absolutely astonishing’ if a majority of Party have all said they are opposed to the committee has placed so little MSPs voted for the proposals to legalise the legislation of assisted suicide. emphasis on the responses I and others assisted suicide to pass stage 1 in the “I am delighted the First Minister and have given to the criticisms of the bill, Scottish Parliament after the committee other party leaders including Jim Murphy many of which are grounded in an was so critical of it. Among the ‘significant (Labour) and Willie Rennie (Liberal ideological opposition to personal choice.” flaws’ highlighted by the health and Democrats) have expressed their Labour MSP Michael McMahon, a sport committee were that ‘there are opposition to the legalisation of assisted Catholic and an opponent of the bill, ways of responding to suffering which suicide,” he said. “They clearly understand told the SCO: “I hope that any of my Archbishop Philip Tartaglia of Glasgow and Bishop Joseph Toal of Motherwell, president do not raise the kind of concerns about it would bring pressure on vulnerable colleagues who remain open to persuasion of SCIAF, gave SCIAF’s director Alistair Dutton and Gemma Lamarra their blessing as people to end their lives and put the appreciate the criticisms of the bill Mr Dutton set off on a 700 mile cycle pilgrimage around Scotland to thank schools, elderly and disabled at risk of abuse as contained in the report and that this parishes and supporters for helping to change the lives of millions of people over the well as very ill young children.” leads to this dangerous proposal receiving last 50 years. The moment was captured after the archbishop and the bishop marked the firm rejection it deserves.” SCIAF’s golden jubilee last Thursday by celebrating Mass at St Andrew’s Cathedral. Ecumenical opposition Report, see page 3 PIC: PAUL McSHERRY The Church of Scotland has also I [email protected]
SCO, 19 Waterloo Street, Glasgow G2 6BT I tel 0141 221 4956 I fax 0141 221 4546 I e-mail [email protected]
$ # #"" #!!&