Table of Cases

TABLE OF CASES

Adams Express Co. v. Ohio State Caflisch v. Clymer Power Corpo- Auditor ...... 842, 844, 846 ration ...... Ader v. Blan ...... 86 Cahan v. Empire Trust Co ...... Adkins v. Children's Hospital..442, 449 854, 855, Adriatic, The ...... 166 Cammack v. Slattery & Bro., Inc. Agnello v. United States ..... 617, 618 Campbell v. Holt ... 478, 48b, 482, Alabama Great Southern R. R. v. Carlisle v. Frears ...... Carroll ...... 403 Carter, In re ...... Alexander v. Fleming ...... 885 Case of Monopolies ...... Allyn v. Mather ...... 585 Central Transportation Co. v. Alpha Portland Cement Co. v. Pullman Palace Car Co ...... Massachusetts ...... 852 Chaplin v. Smith ...... I American Eagle Fire Ins. Co. v. Chelentis v. Luckenbach Steam- New Jersey Ins. Co ...... 106 ship Co...... Ames v. Union Pacific R. R .... 820 Chespeake & Potomac Tel. Co, v. Anglo Patagonian, The ... 406, 407 W hitman ...... Anway v. Grand Rapids Ry..... 473 Cheung Sum Shee et al. v. Nagle. Aquitania, The ...... 414, 425 Chicago, Milwaukee & St. Patti Archer's Case ...... 583 Ry. v. Minnesota ...... Ashbury Railway Carriage & Iron Chicago Ry. v. Schendel ...... 1 Co. v. Riche ...... 22 Chrysler Sales Corp. v. Smith.,, Asylum of St. Vincent de Paul v. Chrysler Sales Corp. v. Spencer.. McGuire ...... 92 Cia. Minera Ygnacio Rodriguez Attorney General v. Cook ...... 1015 Ramos, S. A. v. Bartlesville Attualila, The ...... 166 Zinc Co...... City of Rockford v. Rockford Bailly v. Betti ...... 498 Electric Co ...... Baker v. Druesedow ...... 846 Cleveland, etc., Ry. v. Backus..844, Ballard v. Ballard ...... 788 Clifton Shirting Co. v. Bronne Baltic Mining Co. v. Massachu- Shirt Co ...... setts ...... 849 Coats v. Town of Stanton ...... Banner Milling Co. v. State of Cohen v. Samuels ...... New York ...... 234 Collector v. Day ...... 960, 965, Barbeau v. Dahlmann ...... 467 Colonial Coal & Coke Co. v. Hol- Bashou v. Adolf ...... 381 son ...... Bass, Ratcliff & Gretton v. State Columbia Real Estate & Trust Co. Tax Commission ...... 843 v. Royal Exchange Assurance. Beesley v. Badger ...... 639 Commonwealth v. Hunt ...... Benicombe and Parker ...... 736 825, 827, 828, Berman v. Standard Wood Heel Commonwealth v. Weiss ...... Co ...... 494, 495 Connally v. General Const. Co. ... Bishoff v. Yorkville Bank ...... 855 Cook v. Cook ...... Bissell v. Michigan Southern & Coombe, In re ...... Northern Indiana R. R...... 19 Cope v. Vallette Dry Dock Co... Black v. Black ...... 789 Coronado Coal Co. v. United Mine Blankford, In re ...... 635 Workers of America ...... Blow Co. v. Cohen ...... 642 Cowen v. Cowen ...... Bluefield Waterworks & Improve- Craig v. Anyon ...... ment Co. v. Public Service Craig v. Warner ...... Comm ...... 813 Critten v. Chemical National Bank Bourgogne, La ...... 424, 426 Cudahy Packing Co. v. Minnesota Bracy v. Miller ...... 891 Cullinan v. Walker ...... Brady v. Welsh ...... 240 Curtis Tire Co. v. Goodrich Tran- Brass v. North Dakota ...... 451, 454 sit Co ...... Bridge v. Wellington ...... 736 Cushney v. Henry ...... Brown v. Shyne ...... 1023 Brown v. United States ...... 355 Danzer & Co., Inc. v. Gulf & S. Brown-Brand Realty Co. v. Saks I. Ry ...... & Co ...... 1019 D'Aprile v. The Turner-Looker Brush, The ...... 877 Co ...... Buenos Aires, The ...... 424, 425 Dartmouth College Case ...... Bullard v. Grace ...... 369 Davidson v. Dallas ...... 789, 790, Burk-Waggoner Oil Association Davis, Fed. Agent v. Pringle .... v. Hopkins, Collector ...... 384 Davis v. Shepard ...... Burn v. Fontaine ...... 468 Davis v. State ...... Butler v. Robins Dry Dock & Dean v. Dean ...... Repair Co ...... 408, 409 Dean v. Halliburton ...... TABLE OF CASES

De Haber v. Queen of Portugal.. 157 Hack's Estate, In re ...... 670 De Hahn v. Hartley ...... 992 Haines' Will, In re ...... 517 Delpit v. C6te ...... 468 Hamilton, The Despatie v. Tremblay ...... 461, 467 409, 410, 411, 415, 416, 421, 422 Diamond Alkali Export Corp. v. Hampton v. Holman ...... r35 Bourgeois ...... 566 Hanger v. Abbott ...... 355 Dobrin v. Mallory Steamship Co. 418 Hardin v. Liverpool & L,ndon & Dohm's Estate, In re ...... 891 Globe Ins. Co., Ltd...... 2,4 Dombroski v. Active Automobile Hardy & Ruperti, Inc. v. Neuss, Exchange ...... 757 Hesslein & Co...... 107 Dominelli v. Markowsld ..... 494, 495 Harnett v. Bond ...... 514 Douglas, Petition of Bower, In re 731 Harris v. Balk Douglass v. Phenix Ins. Co ..... 695, 695, 693, 702, 703, 704 696, 697, 699, 700, 701, 702 Harrisburg, The ...... 395 Dudman v. Dudman ...... 379 Harvey's Estate, In re ...... tT Durant, Matter of ...... 596 Havana Cent. Ry. Y. Knicher- bocker Trust Co ...... 854 H, bert v. Clutitre ...... 4j Easton v. Eaton ...... 1025 Hermes v. Westche,ter Racing Edwards v. Douglas ...... 765 Assoc...... 50 Eisner v. Macomber ...... 209, 213 Hess v. Haas ...... 233 Elwyn v. De Garmendia ...... 117 Hewitt v. Equitable Life Assur- Emerson v. Boyles ...... 1013 ance Society of United States 759 Ernst v. Rivers ...... 597 Hohman v. Rochester Swiss Latin- Evans v. Gore ...... 957, 958 dry Co ...... 234 Evans v. Martlett ...... 554 Hollander v. Central Metal & Everett 0. Fisk & Co. v. Fisk Supply Co ...... 218 Teachers' Agency ...... 499 762 Holliday v. Fields ...... 510 Ezell v. Mobley ...... Holsaple v. Superintendents of the Poor of Menominee ...... 765 Fargo v. Hart ...... 840 Huneyman's Estate, In re ...... 69J Farmers' Loan & Trust Co., 'Mat- Hopt v. People ...... 61, 6S4, (35 ter of ...... 595 Humble Oil & Refining Co. v. Fayerweather v. Ritch ...... 146 Wood ...... 761 Finlay v. Finlay ...... 235 Hylton v. United States ...... 1034 Fire Association of Philadelphia v. Nime ...... 745 Ilott v. Wilkes ...... 537, 538, 539 Flint v. Stone-Tracy Co. Independent Wireless Tel. Co. v. 850, 961, 962, 963, 964 Radio Corp. of America ...... 1018 Florence H., The ...... 166 Inland Steel Co. v. Jelenovic ... 836 Fort Smith Light & Traction Co. International Trust Co. v. Myer-q. 3,7 v. Bourland ...... 177 Fox Film Corp. v. Trumbull... 109 Jackson v. Strong ...... 24B France Milling Co. v. ,Washburn- James & Co. v. Second Russian Crosby Co ...... 116 Insurance Co ...... 162 Francis v. McNeal ...... 362 James McGee, The ...... 414, 415, 422 Franklin Bank v. International Jardot v. City of Rahvay ...... 112 Hospital Equipment Co ...... 380 Jeffries v. Commonwealth ...... 1SS Freeman v. Parsley ...... 584 Johnson v. Patterson ...... 539 Frey v. Woodworth ...... 9A7 Johnson Harvester Co. v. Mein- Frick v. Commonwealth of Pa... 357 hardt ...... 832 Fung Sing, Ex Parte (NG) ..... 6-7 Jones v. Harrison ...... 76-3 Jones v. Oceanic Steam Nay. Co. 09 Galveston, Harrisburg & San An- tonio Ry. v. Gonzales ...... 135 Kapler v. Camp Taghconic ..... 770 Gambling v. Northern Insurance Kariher's Petition, No. I ....474, 476 Co. of New York ...... 637 Keene v. M'Donough ...... PA Georgia Railway & Power Co. v. Kennebec Box Co. v. 0. S. Rich- Georgia Railroad Commission .. 822 ards Corp ...... (41 German Alliance Insurance Co. v. Keogh v. Peck ...... 218 Lewis ...... 441 Kepner v. United States ...... 631 Gilmore v. Severn ...... 789, 790, 793 Kessler v. Valerio ...... 370 Gitlow v. New York ...... 108 Keystone Coal Co. v. Davis ..... 833 Goodman v. Niblack ...... 146 Kirkpatrick's Estate, In re ...... 769 Gozner v. United States ...... 1013 Klinkenstein v. Third Avenue Ry. 1024 Grapico Bottling Co. v. Ennis ... 763 Knickerbocker Ice Co. v. Stewart 4Z3 Green v. Hussey ...... 594 Knight v. Ellis ...... 539 Gross . Yeskel ...... 374 Kring v. Missouri ...... 634 Gul Djemal, The ...... 167 G. IV. K. Ltd. v. Dunlop Rubber Laughlin v. Elliott ...... 7S3 Co ...... 1020 Lawrence's Estate, In re ...... 59G Xxiv YALE LAW JOURNAL

Ledwith v. Hurst New Britain Real Estate & Title 571, 582, 584, 585, 594, 599 Co. v. Collington ...... 377 Legout v. Price ...... 736 New Jersey v. Sargent ...... 807 Leightner v. Leightner ...... 578 Newton v. Illinois Oil Co ...... 513 Le Witt v. Park Ecclesiastical New York & Richmond Gas Co. Society ...... 740 v. Prendergast ...... 822 Liberty Mutual Ins. Co. v. John- Niagara Falls International Bridge son Shipyards Corp ...... 375 Co. v. Grand Trunk Ry. of Lickbarrow v. Mason ...... 554 Canada ...... 229 Lincoln Division, Northwestern Northern Assurance Co. v. Grand Bell Tel. Co. v. Spillman ..... 822 View Building Association .... 971 Lincoln Gas & Electric Light Co. v. City of Lincoln ...... 820 Livingston v. Jefferson ...... 142, 144 Oceanic Steam Nay. Co. v. Cor- Lodge v. Grubb ...... 241 coran ...... 998 Loebel v. jerolemon ...... 503 Ohio Utilities Co. v. Public Utili- London & South Western Ry. v. ties Commission of Ohio ..... 822 Gomm ...... 213, 217 Oklahoma v. Wells Fargo & Co. 852 Lussier v. Archambault ...... 468 Oliver American Trading Co. v. Luther v. Sagor ...... 162, 163 The Government of the U. S. of Lyon v. Mitchell ...... 580 Mexico, et al ...... 153 Lyons v. Schanbacher ...... 233 Opinion of the Justices of Massa- chusetts, In re ...... 110 Macaura v. Northern Assurance Opinion of the Justices of New Co ...... 376 Hampshire, In re ...... 110 Mackenzie v. Hare ...... 950 Oregon School Law Case...... 192 Maipo, The ...... 166 Osborn v. The Bank of the United Marchese v. Marchese ...... 378 States ...... 165 Marlborough Hill, The ...... 566 Marr v. United States ...... 212 Mart v. Mart ...... 1014 Palmer v. Horn ...... 587 Martin v. Condon ...... 113 Palmetto Fire Ins. Co. v. Beha... 990 Martin v. Helms ...... 644 Palmetto Fire Ins. Co. v. Conn.. 990 Mason v. Intercolonial Railway.. 165 Panama, The ...... 986, 989 Mason v. Lickbarrow ...... 564 Panama Railroad Co. v. Johnson 431 Matter of Lawrence ...... 596, 597 Paramore v. Mack Sennett ..... 888 Maynard v. Maynard ...... 738 .Parfit v. Hember ...... 585 Mayor of Wilmington v. Turk... 239 'Parish Mfg. Co. v. Martin-Parry McCarter v. La Rock ...... 242 Corp ...... 881 McCorkle v. State ...... 883 Passaic Valley Sewerage Com'rs McCulloch v. Maryland ...... 958, 966 v. Hollbrook, C. & R. Corp. ... 632 McDowell v. Hopfield ...... 228 Patton-Tully Transportation Co. MoMaster v. Gould ...... 371 v. Turner ...... 427, 428 McNeir v. Anderson ...... 1003 Pedder v. Hunt ...... 583,' 584 Matter of McQueen v. Middleton Peekskill v. Peekskill Light & Mfg. Co ...... 700, 701, 702 Railroad Co ...... 822 Mendelsohn v. Holton ...... 625 Pelzer v. United Dredging Co... 162 Messer v. The Fadettes ...... 499 Penza, The ...... 159 Metcalf v. Mitchell..960, 962, 964, 965 *People ex rel. Chicago Bar Assoc. Meyer v. Nebraska ...... 192, 199 v. Hoering ...... 106 Middlesex, The ...... 416, 421 People ex rel. Fyfe v. Barnett... 887 Midland Steel Sales Co. v. Water- People v. Fisher ...... 826 loo Gas Engine Co ...... 1012 People v. Olcott ...... 687 Miles v. Graham ...... 109 People v. Pomerantz ...... 512 Mills-Morris Co. v. Champion People's Market Co. v. Corbctt & Spark Plug Co ...... 631 Sons ...... 882 Mirizio v. Mirizio...... 758 People v. Steinmetz ...... 232 Mishiloff v. American Central Ins. People v. Zimmerman ...... 230 Co ...... 204 Perovich, Ex Parte ...... 1010 Missouri v. Public Service Com- Peru v. United States ...... 232 o mission ...... 813, 814, 820 Pesaro, The ...... 166, lo7 .Monopolies, Case of ...... 932 Pettiti v. T. J. Pardy C Co.Cnst, 118 Mortimer, In re ...... 586 Pickles v. F. Leyland & Co .... 1007 Muir, Re ...... 166 ,Pierce v. Woodward ...... 297 Munich Reinsurance Co. v. First Pilger v. United States Stcel Reihisturance Co...... 345 Corp ...... 760 Munn v. Illinois 443, 445, 446, 453, 806 ,Pittsburgh, etc., Ry. v. Backus... 840 Mystic Valley Water Works Co. Pollock v. Farmers' Loan & Trust (Re)...... 21 Co ...... 957, 1003, 1004, 1005 National Bank v. ratthews ..... 26 Postley v. Kafka ...... 515 "Xega v. Chicago Rys...... 230 Poulos v. United States ...... 617' TABLE OF CASES

Powell, In re ...... 791, 792, 793 Suuthern Pacific L'o. %.Jeiv .n Prendergast v. Drew ...... 511 3 .J3 424#. 423 President & Directors of Manhat- Southern Pacific Co. v. lie Valle tan Co. v. Morgan ...... 87S da Co ta ...... 411 Public Utilities Commission v. Spring v. Nagle ...... 1i; Narragansett Electric Light Co. 822 Springer v. United State.V....I4 Pullman Co. v. Kansas ...... 851 Stadtmuller v. Miller ...... :4, Pullman Co. -. Richardson .. .848, 849 Stailman v. Cundill ...... 41, Pullman's Palace Car Co. v. Penn- Stamford Trust Co. v. L, diwo 4 sylvania ...... 83. 841 Purefoy v. Rogers ...... 7S7, 788 Stanton v. Baltic Mining Co .... 957 Stark v. Bauer Couperage C4, .. 117 Ralph v. Carrick ...... 5,1,8 State Bank cd Peczk v. Pic';anr ... 713 Renne v. Volk ...... 7(4 State v. Brodes ...... S;3 Reading Co. v. Koons ...... 1017 State v. Devot ...... 79 Red Cross Line v. Atlantic Fruit State v. Grcen ...... 44. 545 Co ...... 314 State v. Lee ...... 7#, t,77, o,79 Rembert v. Vetoe ...... 579, 595, 59"4 State v. Schleiftr ...... 105 Rhea v. Smith ...... t,8 State v. Wtzadruff ...... 671 to(7 Rhird v. Wilkinson ...... 993 State Railroad Tax CaQs .... 03, 043 Rhode Island Hospital Trust Co. Steel Cities Chemical C,. v. Vir- v. Bridgham ...... 5 iS ginia-Carolina Chemical Co. ... 634 Rice v. Angell ...... 49 Sterne v. Ide & Cc ...... 113 Richardson v. Shaw ...... 72) Stewart %-Pacific Steam Naviga- Ritter v. American Life Ins. Co. 239 tion Co ...... 42), 431 River Queen. The Dispatch II, Sudbury v. Ambi Verv:altunp- The Eva Leigh ...... 876 K nimmanditge:ell-chaft aui Ak- Roberts v. Petrova ...... & U tien ...... 94 Robidoux v. Chicago & N. W. Ry. 370 Supreme L4 dge ,-of the Wori!, Robins v. Quinliven ...... 5V4 L,al Order of M.we v. In- Robinson v. Roe ...... 732 dependent. Beniy, lent ad Pr.- Rockefeller v. United States .. 212, 213 tective Order of Mbioe ...... 752 Rodger, v. Oliver ...... 754 Sutt.,n's Hospital Care ...... 21 Rogday, The ...... 159 Suzuki v. Small ...... 1021 Ross v. Ross ...... 58, 5&9, 593 Sydney v. MacraIlva Pib. 1,,rp, 122 Rudolph v. United States ...... 237 Rundell v. La Compagnie Gn.rale Transatlantique ...... 414 Tasin v. Bastre,, ...... # 97 Russell v. McCaughey ...... 241 Thompc,,nTayltfr v. FluhartyTowinhg ...... A--.,,ciat -.n'v. 753 Russian Government v. Lehigh Vallvy Railroad Co ...... 156 McGregor ...... 427 Russian Reinsurance Co. v. Stod- The Delaware & Pllard v. Vintn 554 ard ...... 98 Thrrne, 'Matter of ...... 374 Russian Socialist Federated Soviet Todd v. Stewart ...... 51fo Republic v. Cibrario ...... 158. 1(0 Torrey v. Wolfe; ...... 702 Ryan v. Cincinnati Model Homes Transp,.rte; Maritim,,o; o, E!,tailo 1'7 Co ...... 510 Traveler .' Ins. C,. v. Brass G.t'ib 11fg. Co ...... 624 Sagamore, The ..... 412. 414, 421. 425 Truelsch v. Northve,tern Mutual St. Louis & E. St. L. Elec. Ry. Life Ins. Co ...... 220 v. Hagerman ...... 846 Trustees of And.!ver Thcgk,_-cal St. Louis Railroad Co. v. Terre Seminary v. Visitrs.of Awl,,ver Haute Railroad Co ...... 25 Theoldo cal Iniitutfn ...... 03 St. Louis Southwestern Ry. v. Arkansas ...... 843 United States v. Balim..re ' Ohi, Salt Lake City v. Hollister ...... 963 R. R...... 935 Sarders v. Mfaclean ...... 557 United States v. Bl, ,*m ...... 332 Seagull. The ...... 395 United States v. Chemcal Fo unda- Scatterwocd v. Edge ...... 786 tion ...... 352 Schlesinger v. State ...... 1011 United Statei; v. Dbs...... 32 Schopflocher v. Zimmerman ... 239 United States v. Dickle ...... 115 Shalter; v. Ladd ...... 579 United States %-.Henning ...... F97 Shaw v. Weigh ...... 578 United States v. Holt State Pan: .40 Sherry v. Perkins ...... 832 United States v. Hudnut ...... 1017 Sibley v. Perry ...... 587, 588, 5S9 United States v. Xati-.al Ex- Skene v. Carayanis ...... 892 change Bank of Baltim-ore ... 103) Smith v. Jones ...... 112 United States %. thee Clievr, let Smyth v. Ames ...... 811 C u e ...... '1- Soko'off v. National City Bank.. 101 United States v. Percheman .... 355 South Carolina v. United States United State; v. Phle1 . 212. 213 962, 94. 965 United States v. Prioeau ...... xxvi YALE LAW JOURNAL

United States Fidelity & Guaranty Western Union Telegraph Co. v. Co. v. Worthington & Co .... 486 Kansas ...... 851, 852 United States Glue Co. v. Oak Western Union Telegraph Co. v. Creek ...... 848 Massachusetts ...... 847 'Jnderwood Typewriter Co. v. Western Union Telegraph Co. v. Chamberlain ...... 840, 847 Taggart ...... 839, 841 Union Refrigerator Transit Co. Weston v. Brown ...... 767 v. Kentucky ...... 846 Weston v. Jordan ...... 730 Union Tank Line Co. v. Wright White v. Collins ...... 583 840, 842, 843, 846 White v. White ...... 299 Whiting v. Hudson Trust Co ... 855 Vanatta's Estate, In re . 862, 867 Wilcox v. Consolidated Gas Co. 819 Vietor v. National City Bank. .567, 568 Wilkins v. Rowan ...... 578 Wilson v. New ...... 448 'Walker v. New Mexico & S. P. Wolff Packing Co. v. Court of R. R ...... 300 Industrial Relations ...... 448 Wallace v. Hines ...... 840 Wong Shee v. Nagle ...... 626 Warren v. Salt Creek Drainage Woodall v. Clifton ...... 217, 218 District ...... 114 Wulfsohn v. Russian-Socialist Watkins Co. v. Denbeigh ...... 383 Federated Soviet Republic Waugh v. Mississippi University 197 157, 158, 160 Weiss v. Steam ...... 212 Wenmoth's Estate, In re 791, 792, 793 Wenzler v. Robin Line Steamship Yrisarric v. Clement ...... 160 Co ...... 430, 431 Wesp v. Muckle ...... 874 Zenith Bathing Pavilion, Inc. v. Western" Fuel Co. v. Garcia . .397, 428 Fair Oaks S. S. Corp ...... 229