Socio-Cultural and Socio-Economic Profile and Political Views of an Ethnic Community: a Case Study of Two Selected Villages in Moulvi Bazar District
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
SOCIO-CULTURAL AND SOCIO-ECONOMIC PROFILE AND POLITICAL VIEWS OF AN ETHNIC COMMUNITY: A CASE STUDY OF TWO SELECTED VILLAGES IN MOULVI BAZAR DISTRICT Additional Secretary Md. Zahurul Alam, ndc “Hindu-Muslim relations in Manipur are a lodestar for the rest of India. The Muslims in the land came from outside, found wives among the local womenfolk and settled down. The Maharajas did not treat them as aliens”. - A. R. Constantine: Manipur: Maid of the Mountains As it is obvious from the quotation above, it can hardly be overemphasized that development and security depend on a better understanding of the dreams and desires of the mainstream population as well as those of the ethnic groups. Article- 28 (1) of our constitution declares, “The State shall not discriminate against any citizen on grounds only of religion, race, caste, sex or place of birth”.1 Most recent publication of draft Poverty Reduction Strategy Paper (PRSP) of the Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh, entitled, Unlocking the Potential, while highlighting issues like Participation, Social Inclusion and Empowerment, has correctly pointed out these aspects under the heading Supporting Strategies. The section of PRSP that deals with Tribal People (TP) issues, expresses the view that in the social development inclusion framework the tribal people of the country are not effectively included in the development actors – whether as contributors or as beneficiaries. The sense of social, political or economic deprivation felt by the tribal people has been highlighted in the draft PRSP.2 The words Manipuri and Meitei are synonymous with each other, except for drawing a conceptual line of demarcation between the Manipuri Muslims and Manipuri Hindus/Sanamahis, in the discipline of Meiteiology. And there are differences for sure and so is for our present study too. The prevailing sense of mistrust, exclusion, discrimination, insecurity and deprivation etc. which are mentioned in the draft PRSP, can be addressed if a congenial atmosphere prevails. If studies are carried out sociologically, the wholeness of the real life situation of a community gets unfolded. The aim of this article is to explore socio-economic, socio cultural, socio- political along with brief historical aspects of the community. While dealing with their political views, attempts have been made to assess whether that poses any direct or indirect threat to our national security. 1. The Constitution of The People’s Republic of Bangladesh, The British Council Bangladesh, Dhaka, p.24 2. General Economic Division, Planning Commission, Unlocking the Potential: National Strategy for Accel- erated Poverty Reduction, Government of the People’s Republic of Bangladesh, Dhaka, 2004, Pp.136-137 Socio-cultural and Socio-economic Profile and Political Views of an Ethnic Community: A Case Study of Two Selected Villages in Moulvi Bazar District BRIEF HISTORICAL BACKGROUND OF MEITEIS Manipuris of Bangladesh The Manipuris inhabit the Northeastern districts of Sylhet, Moulvibazar, Sunamgonj and Habigonj in Bangladesh. Historians believe the Manipuris are the original inhabitants of the Northeastern Indian State of Manipur. According to Tanubabu,3 “Manipuris are living in Bangladesh since 18th century in four districts of Sylhet Division, located in North-eastern part of Bangladesh.” Political incidents, such as war with Burma and annexation by the British colonists, etc. led the Manipuris to migrate to different places in India and Bangladesh. They came to this country mainly between 1819 and 1826 AD. Meiteis belong to Mongoloid race. Their language belongs to the Tibetan-Burmese branch of the Sino-Tibetan language family. It has similarity and historical connection with Kuki-Chin language family. A section of Manipuris of Bangladesh are Muslim, known as Pangan. Their language is similar to those of the Meiteis but physical features are not.4 Sheram5 maintains that during the reign of Maharaj Garibniwaz (1709-1748), some missionaries went to mainland Manipur from Sylhet. There is a view among researchers or meteiologists that these missionaries named the land ‘Manipur’. Meiteiologists’ View A sovereign state of the past and a northeastern state of present India, Manipur, was the homeland of the Manipuris of Bangladesh, one of the many ethnic communities of the country. ‘Manipur’ literally means the city or the land of gems. During the course of historical developments Manipur was known by different names, such as Mekhala or Mekhali, Kangleipak, Poireipak and Metrabak.6 The present name ‘Manipur’ was first officially introduced in the eighteenth century when Garibnewaz was reigning. 3. Tanubabu, Hamom, op cit. p.2 4. Source: http://www.weeklyholiday.net/2005/220705/cul.html Accessed on 26-03-2006 (10:04pm) 5. Sheram, A.K., “The Manipuri”, in Islam, Sirajul and Sajahan Miah (Eds), BANGLAPEDIA: National Encyclopedia of Bangladesh, Vol. 6, Asiatic Society of Bangladesh, Dhaka, 2003, p.409 6. Kabui, Gangmumei, History of Manipur: Precolonial Period, Volume-I, National Publishing House, New Delhi: 1991, p.1 222 Parratt and Parratt7 quote from Grimwood’s description of Manipur in his My Three Years in Manipur, as follows.8 In order to know the Ethnic Community under study from different angles it is essential to have some idea about the Mainland Manipuries, the Meiteis, including the genesis and evolution of the term Meitei. Kabui, at the very outset of his book on the history of Manipur, states in the preface “The History of Manipur is the story of the evolution of the culture and society of a remarkable people who built up their cradle of civilization in Manipur valley amidst the mountain ranges that divide India and Burma. The beautiful valley of Imphal9 which is situated on the trade and migration route between South Asia and South East Asia was a valley of cultural assimilation of the varied people who came to this hilly country in search of land, fortune, better living and glory.”10 He goes on to maintain which is given in footnote.11 It follows from above that history, culture, religion, ethnicity, tradition etc. have intermingled with one another in the process of making of the history of Manipuris. 7. Parratt, Jhon and Saroj N. Arambam Parratt, Queen Empress vs.Tikendrajit Prince of Manipur: The Anglo-Ma- nipuri Conflict of 1891, Har-Anand Publications & Vikas Publishing House Pvt Ltd, New Delhi: 1992, p.11 8. “A pretty place, more beautiful than many of the show places of the world; beautiful in its habitable parts, but more beautiful in those tracts covered with forest where the foot of man seldom treads.” 9. Present capital city of the North-East Indian State of Manipur. 10. Kabui, Gangmumei, op.cit. 1991, p. vii. 11. Manipur was a cradle of human civilization and creativity which has come under the influence of many cultures of many different ethnic groups who came at various times and contributed to the growth of the civilization in this hilly state in India’s north eastern frontier. Manipur being a gateway of India to South East Asia, was influenced by her geographic situation and ecology in the shaping of her history and cultural development. (ibid, p.1) 223 Socio-cultural and Socio-economic Profile and Political Views of an Ethnic Community: A Case Study of Two Selected Villages in Moulvi Bazar District SOCIO-ECONOMIC PROFILE OF THE COMMUNITY During a previous study conducted by the researcher almost in the same study-area, it was found that Manipuris of Bangladesh do have poverty, in some cases ‘abject poverty’. Following is a brief discussion based on data collected from the study area, it is found that Meitei households have higher incomes, on average, compared to Muslim households. Percentage of Manipuri Muslims and Meitei in the study area is 66.67% and 33.33% respectively. Manipuri Muslims have larger family size compared to Meiteis—97% of Muslim households have family size of 4 or more, as compared to 85% of Meitei households. Distribution of the Respondents by Family Size and Religion Table-1 Family Muslim Hindu / Sanamahi Total Size (f) (%) (f) (%) (f) (%) 1-3 1 2.5 3 15 4 6.67 4-6 25 62.5 14 70 39 65 6+ 14 35 3 15 17 28.33 Total 40 100 20 100 60 100 Meitei households have higher incomes, on average, compared to Muslim households—60 percent of Meitei families have annual income above Tk 40,000, compared to 40 percent of Muslim families. Distribution of the Respondents by Annual Family Income (Taka) and Religion Table-2 Income Group Muslim Hindu / Sanamahi Total (in Taka) (f) (%) (f) (%) (f) (%) 1-20000 6 15 1 5 7 11.67 20001-40000 18 45 7 35 25 41.67 40001-60000 7 17.5 4 20 11 18.33 60001-80000 2 5 2 10 4 6.67 80000+ 7 17.5 6 30 13 21.67 Total 40 100 20 100 60 100 224 Distribution of the Respondents by Number of Children and Religion Table-3 Number of Muslim Hindu / Sanamahi Total Children (f) (%) (f) (%) (f) (%) Still Single 1 2.5 1 5 2 3.33 0-2 14 35 8 40 22 36.67 3-4 17 42 7 35 24 40 4+8204201220 Total 40 100 20 100 60 100 The above Table-03 shows that Manipuri Muslims tend to have more children—62% of Muslim families have 3 children or more, as compared to 55% of Meitei families; whereas the following Table-4 shows that Meitei households have higher incomes, on average, compared to Muslim households—60 percent of Meitei families have annual income above Tk 40,000, compared to 40 percent of Muslim families. Distribution of the Respondents by Annual Family Income (Taka) and Religion Table-4 Income Group Muslim Hindu / Sanamahi Total (in Taka) (f) (%) (f) (%) (f) (%) 1-20000 6 15 1 5 7 11.67 20001-40000