Proposed New Passenger Station at Glyne Gap Bexhill – Final Report
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Proposed New Passenger Station at Glyne Gap, Bexhill Final Report August 2013 Rother District Council Proposed New Passenger Station at Glyne Gap, Bexhill 311776 ITD ITN 4 B P:\Manchester\Northwest\Projects (Even)\311776 - Glyne Gap\9.0 Reports\4 Final report\RevB for issue\Glyne Gap Stage 4 Final Report 1 Augustrev B.1.docx 2013 Final Report Proposed New Passenger Station at Glyne Gap, Bexhill Final Report August 2013 Rother District CouncilCouncil, Town Hall, Bexhill-on-Sea, TN39 3JX Town Hall, Bexhill-on-Sea, TN39 3JX Mott MacDonald, 111 Piccadilly, Manchester M1 2HY, United Kingdom T +44 (0)161 638 0885 W www.mottmac.com Proposed New Passenger Station at Glyne Gap, Bexhill Final Report Issue and revision record Revision Date Originator Checker Approver Description Standard A 31 May 2013 Laura Magson John Taylor, Robert Fickling Initial Draft Tony Millward B 1 August 2013 John Taylor Robert Fickling Frank Shorter Final Report C 19 August 2013 John Taylor Robert Fickling Frank Shorter Final Report (with minor revisions) This document is issued for the party which commissioned it and We accept no responsibility for the consequences of this for specific purposes connected with the above-captioned project document being relied upon by any other party, or being used only. It should not be relied upon by any other party or used for for any other purpose, or containing any error or omission any other purpose. which is due to an error or omission in data supplied to us by other parties. This document contains confidential information and proprietary intellectual property. It should not be shown to other parties without consent from us and from the party which commissioned it.. 311776 /ITD/ITN/4/B 1 August 2013 P:\Manchester\Northwest\Projects (Even)\311776 - Glyne Gap\9.0 Reports\4 Final report\RevB for issue\Glyne Gap Stage 4 Final Report rev B.1.docx Proposed New Passenger Station at Glyne Gap, Bexhill Final Report Contents Chapter Title Page Executive Summary i 1 Introduction 1 1.1 Introduction ________________________________________________________________________ 1 1.2 The GRIP process __________________________________________________________________ 2 1.3 Previous studies into Glyne Gap station __________________________________________________ 3 2. Infrastructure Assessment 6 3. Demand Forecasts 10 4. Operational Assessment 12 5. Business Case 13 5.1 Appraisal Methodology ______________________________________________________________ 13 5.2 Scheme Benefits __________________________________________________________________ 15 5.2.1 User benefits _____________________________________________________________________ 15 5.2.2 Non-user benefits __________________________________________________________________ 16 5.2.3 Demand from Ravenside Retail Park ___________________________________________________ 16 5.2.4 Demand from Bexhill College _________________________________________________________ 17 5.2.5 Abstracted Trips from Bexhill _________________________________________________________ 18 5.2.6 New-to-rail trips at Glyne Gap ________________________________________________________ 19 5.2.7 Through-traveller Impacts ____________________________________________________________ 20 5.3 Scheme costs _____________________________________________________________________ 21 5.3.1 Capital costs ______________________________________________________________________ 21 5.3.2 Operating costs ___________________________________________________________________ 21 5.4 Benefit to Cost Ratio (BCR) __________________________________________________________ 21 5.5 Appraisal results ___________________________________________________________________ 22 5.6 Sensitivity test – impacts of high growth _________________________________________________ 23 5.7 Summary and Recommendations _____________________________________________________ 24 6. Funding Sources 26 7. Conclusions and Next Steps 28 Appendices 30 Appendix A. Location Map _____________________________________________________________________ 31 Appendix B. Photographs ______________________________________________________________________ 34 Appendix C. Capital Cost Breakdown _____________________________________________________________ 40 Appendix D. Operating Cost Breakdown __________________________________________________________ 48 Appendix E. Land Ownership ___________________________________________________________________ 51 Appendix F. Details of Timetabling Assessment ____________________________________________________ 56 311776 /ITD/ITN/4/B 1 August 2013 P:\Manchester\Northwest\Projects (Even)\311776 - Glyne Gap\9.0 Reports\4 Final report\RevB for issue\Glyne Gap Stage 4 Final Report rev B.1.docx Proposed New Passenger Station at Glyne Gap, Bexhill Final Report Appendix G. Economic Assessment, assuming central growth _________________________________________ 62 Appendix H. Economic Assessment, assuming high growth ___________________________________________ 67 Tables Table 1.1: Summary of previous studies into Glyne Gap station ________________________________________ 4 Table 2.1: Cost estimates _____________________________________________________________________ 8 Table 3.1: Demand at Glyne Gap, excluding abstraction assessment __________________________________ 10 Table 3.2: Demand at Glyne Gap, including abstraction assessment ___________________________________ 11 Table 5.1: Sources of benefit for demand from Ravenside Retail Park __________________________________ 17 Table 5.2: Sources of benefit for demand from Bexhill College ________________________________________ 18 Table 5.3: Sources of benefit for demand abstracted from Bexhill _____________________________________ 19 Table 5.4: Sources of benefit for new-to-rail demand _______________________________________________ 20 Table 5.5: Source of benefits for through travellers _________________________________________________ 20 Table 5.6: Analysis of Monetised Costs and Benefits for Glyne Gap, Central Growth Scenario _______________ 22 Table 5.7: Analysis of Monetised Costs and Benefits for Glyne Gap, High Growth Scenario _________________ 23 Table F.1: Glossary of station codes and other abbreviations _________________________________________ 58 Figures Figure 1.1: East Coastway route between Brighton and Ashford ________________________________________ 1 Figure 1.2: The GRIP Process __________________________________________________________________ 2 Figure 2.1: Site Location Map ___________________________________________________________________ 7 Figure 2.2: Platform Arrangement – Option 2 _______________________________________________________ 9 Figure 6.1: South East of England ERDF area _____________________________________________________ 27 Figure A.1: Location of proposed station at Glyne Gap ______________________________________________ 32 Figure B.1: Existing cycle storage facilities, looking south ____________________________________________ 34 Figure B.2: Existing under-bridge no.214 south elevation (beach side) __________________________________ 34 Figure B.3: Existing under-bridge no.214 north elevation (retail park side) ________________________________ 35 Figure B.4: Existing retail access road looking towards A259, showing area grass adjacent to the leisure centre __ 35 Figure B.5: Grassed area adjacent to existing leisure centre looking towards under-bridge no. 214 ____________ 36 Figure B.6: Existing car park showing end of existing building and bus stop for Bexhill on A259 _______________ 36 Figure B.7: Existing car park looking west toward Ravenside Retail Park ________________________________ 37 Figure B.8: Existing bus stop for Hastings on A259 north of the site ____________________________________ 37 Figure B.9: Existing car park for Ravenside Retail Park _____________________________________________ 38 Figure E.1: Land owned by Rother District Council in the Glyne Gap area ________________________________ 52 Figure E.2: Land owned by East Sussex County Council in the Glyne Gap area ___________________________ 53 Figure E.3: Land owned by Land Securities in the Glyne Gap area _____________________________________ 54 311776 /ITD/ITN/4/B 1 August 2013 P:\Manchester\Northwest\Projects (Even)\311776 - Glyne Gap\9.0 Reports\4 Final report\RevB for issue\Glyne Gap Stage 4 Final Report rev B.1.docx Proposed New Passenger Station at Glyne Gap, Bexhill Final Report Executive Summary This report provides an overall summary of the ongoing study into a proposed new railway station at Glyne Gap, as well as reporting the business case for the station. The study has been commissioned by Rother District Council (RDC), East Sussex County Council (ESCC) and Land Securities Group PLC (Land Securities) in order to build on earlier studies which suggested, at an outline level, that there might be a case for the provision of a station at this site. This report brings together the results of a number of reports produced for the new station at Glyne Gap, as follows: Stage 1 – Review of Existing Studies; Stage 2 – Infrastructure Assessment Report; Stage 3a – Demand Forecasting Report; and Stage 3b – Operational Assessment Report. Following on from Stage 3, this Final Report also outlines the results of the business case of the scheme. The results of the business case for the central case are summarised below: Analysis of Monetised Costs and Benefits £’000, discounted to 2010 prices, in 2010 market prices PRESENT VALUE OF BENEFITS (PVB) £1,539 PRESENT VALUE OF COSTS (PVC) £5,430 OVERALL IMPACTS NET PRESENT