Page 1 STATE of MICHIGAN DETROIT BOARD of POLICE COMMISSIONERS COMMUNITY MEETING

6/13/2013 Page 1 STATE OF MICHIGAN DETROIT BOARD OF POLICE COMMISSIONERS COMMUNITY MEETING

______/

PAGE 1 TO 47

Taken at 2301 Woodmere, Patton Community Center, Detroit, Michigan 48209, Commencing at 6:41 p.m., Thursday, June 13th, 2013, Before Elizabeth Koller, CSR-7042. 6/13/2013 Page 2 1 APPEARANCES: 2 MS. CELIA BANKS WASHINGTON (P54338) 3 Attorney to the Board 4 Detroit Board of Police Commissioners 5 1300 Beaubien 6 Detroit, Michigan 48226 7 (313) 596-1835 8 Appearing on behalf of the Board of Police 9 Commissioners. 10 11 COMMISSIONERS: 12 JEROME WARFIELD (Chairman) 13 JESSICA TAYLOR (Vice-Chairperson) 14 DONNELL WHITE (Regular Member) 15 16 ALSO PRESENT: 17 GEORGE ANTHONY (Secretary) 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 6/13/2013 Page 3 1 Detroit, Michigan 2 June 13, 2013 3 About 6:41 p.m. 4 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Good afternoon, ladies 5 and gentlemen. Welcome to the Board of Police 6 Commissioners meeting. Certainly we are happy and 7 pleased to be here tonight in Southwest District here 8 at the Patton Community Center, and it's so good to see 9 all of you here. My name is Jerome Warfield, Chairman 10 of the Board of Police Commissioners. 11 At this time I want to introduce some of the 12 members here at the table. Serving with me tonight is 13 our Vice-Chairperson Commissioner Jessica Taylor, as 14 well as Commissioner Donnell White sitting to my right 15 and your left. Representing the Chief's Office tonight 16 is Commander McKissic. Sir, good to have you. 17 COMMANDER MCKISSIC: Good to be here. 18 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Also sitting at the table 19 in front of you is Board Secretary Attorney George 20 Anthony. I'm going ask if Mr. Anthony can introduce 21 the rest of our staff that's here tonight. 22 SECRETARY ANTHONY: Thank you, Mr. Chair. 23 For the record, George Anthony, Secretary to the Board. 24 We have present our Chief Investigator Ms. Pamela Davis 25 Drake seated in the front. We have our Personnel 6/13/2013 Page 4 1 Director Ms. Loletha Coleman Porter, also seated in the 2 front. We have Mr. Robert Brown our Office Manager,

3 Officer Dan Donakowski recording our proceedings, and 4 Ms. Beth Koller from Hanson Court Reporting Service. 5 Sir, we also have one of our newest 6 Investigators in the audience, Ms. Tiffany Stewart is 7 also seated in the audience. She is one of our newest 8 investigators. That completes the introductions, sir. 9 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Thank you, sir. We 10 appreciate that. At this time I'm going to ask is 11 Supervisor Carla Williamson here, and if so could you 12 come to the podium, and again we want to thank you. 13 She's a Supervisor here at Patton Community Center. We 14 want to thank you for having us, and if you have any 15 words you can give them at this time. 16 SUPERVISOR WILLIAMSON: Well, thank you very 17 much for choosing to come Patton. This is a community 18 recreation center. It's just a privilege to see 19 everyone here today. If this is your first time to 20 Patton I hope it's not your last. If it's not your 21 first I hope to see you some more. 22 Tomorrow will be our open house for all our 23 summer programs we're having, our swim lessons, Zumba 24 classes, our day camp. We will have a nine week day 25 camp at Patton which is sponsored by Ford Motor 6/13/2013 Page 5 1 Company. We have a few scholarships that are available 2 for our day camp, so if anybody has any questions about 3 that they can ask at the front desk. 4 Thank you very much for having me. I do want 5 to thank a couple people that are not here. I'm not 6 going to call them by name because there's a lot of 7 them. But at Patton Community Center we have a true 8 community spirit and so the decorations you see set up 9 for today, chairs, tables, and the like, were done by 10 one of our two groups Live Action which is our teen 11 council ages 13 to 18, and Action Packed which is a our 12 peewee council and their ages twelve and under, so they 13 were responsible for everything today. 14 Officer Mike gave us the setup and they saw 15 the layout and did it. They did the refreshments and 16 they got it done. So that's what we're doing here. 17 We're building lives of young people so that they can 18 know to come sit in a seat like you are today. So 19 thank you again for having us and we hope to have you 20 here again in the future. 21 (Applause.) 22 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Thank you, 23 Ms. Williamson. At this time we're going to ask if 24 Chaplain Renee Taylor can come -- I'm sorry, Avis Renee 25 Taylor can come and lead us in or invocation. If you 6/13/2013 Page 6 1 can come to the mic, we appreciate it. Again, it's 2 Chaplain Avis Renee Taylor. Thank you, ma'am, good to 3 see you. 4 CHAPLAIN TAYLOR: Thank you, sir. In the 5 presence of the Detroit Police Commission Southwest 6 Detroit, citizens, personnel, let us stand so that we 7 can say a prayer. 8 (Invocation led by Chaplain Taylor.) 9 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Thank you, ma'am, thank 10 you, Chaplain Taylor. 11 At this time, I'm going to ask if 12 Commissioner who's the Vice-Chairperson of our 13 Commission would read the responsibilities and the 14 duties of the Detroit Board of Police Commissioners. 15 VICE-CHAIRPERSON TAYLOR: Created by City 16 Charter July 1st, 1974. Composition: Five members 17 appointed by the Mayor confirmed by City Council. 18 Commissioners serve five year terms and may not serve 19 more than five years consecutively, meets once a week 20 52 weeks out of the year and all meetings are open to 21 the public. 22 The Duties: Establish policy, rules and 23 regulations in consultation with the Chief and approval 24 of the Mayor. Review and approve Department budget, 25 review and approve Department promotions, receive and 6/13/2013 Page 7 1 resolve complaints concerning the operation of the 2 Police Department. Final authority to impose and 3 review discipline of Police Department employees. 4 Appoint Civilian Personnel Director, prepares an annual 5 report of Department activities for the public, Mayor 6 and the City Council. 7 Staff: Executive Secretary who serves as 8 Secretary to the Board and attends all Board meetings, 9 Chief Investigator and additional Investigators, other 10 staff as necessary to provided support to the Board. 11 The Police Commission considers itself a liaison 12 between the citizens of the City of Detroit and the 13 Police Department. 14 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Thank you, ma'am, we 15 certainly appreciate that. At this time we will 16 entertain a motion to approve today's Agenda. 17 COMMISSIONER WHITE: So move. 18 VICE-CHAIRPERSON TAYLOR: Support. 19 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: It's been properly moved 20 and supported without objection. All those in favor? 21 COMMISSIONERS: Aye. 22 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Again, we'll entertain a 23 motion to approve the minutes from Thursday, June 6th, 24 2013. 25 COMMISSIONER WHITE: Mr. Chair, so move with 6/13/2013 Page 8 1 one correction, the date be adjusted to reflect 2 June 6th, 2013. 3 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: So move. 4 VICE CHAIRPERSON TAYLOR: Supported. 5 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: It's been properly moved 6 and support with the necessary correction without 7 objection. All those in favor? 8 COMMISSIONERS: Aye. 9 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: All those opposed? 10 Motion carries. As is already been mentioned by 11 Chaplain Taylor, certainly our hearts and prayers go 12 out to Chief Chester Logan and his family of the 13 transition of his wonderful wife. Certainly he's been 14 in our prayers and thoughts since we've learned of her 15 transition. I left the house on the way here and 16 certainly we would wish he could be here, but certainly 17 we let them know we care for him and we love them. 18 For those of you, and we'll give the 19 arrangements out a little bit later, but for those of 20 you who wish to show your condolences there's a fund 21 set up in lieu of flowers. They're asking that you 22 will send a monetary donation to Good Fellows, again, 23 that's Good Fellows, and that's PO Box 44444, PO Box 24 44444, Detroit, Michigan, 48244 and that would be in 25 Mrs. Ella M. Logan's name, again, in lieu of flowers 6/13/2013 Page 9 1 the family is asking that you would send a monetary 2 donation to Good Fellows, PO Box 4444, Detroit, 3 Michigan 48244. 4 Again, we want just to thank Chief Logan for 5 just serving under such great a weight and we 6 understood when he took over and came out of retirement 7 what he was challenged and faced with but he had 8 decided to serve anyway. Certainly, again, our 9 thoughts and our prayers are with him tonight. 10 That's all the information from the Chair. 11 At this time we'll turn it over to Commander McKissic. 12 COMMANDER MCKISSIC: Good evening, Board, 13 Officers, citizens. I do not have a formal report from 14 the Chief's Office at this time. However, I would like 15 to give some information regarding Ella M. Logan the 16 wife of Chief Logan and mother of Sergeant Kimberly 17 Blackwell. The two visitations will be held Saturday, 18 June 15th, 2013, 6:00 p.m. to 9:00 p.m., the second 19 will be held Sunday, June 16th, from 10:00 to 9:00 p.m. 20 at the Swanson Funeral Home located at 806 East Grand 21 Boulevard, Detroit, Michigan 48207. 22 The family hour will be held from Monday, 23 June 17, 2013, 10:00, service will be conducted on 24 Monday, June 17, 2013 at 11:00 a.m., located at Sacred 25 Heart Church at 1000 Elliot, south of Mack, east of I75 6/13/2013 Page 10 1 Freeway, Detroit, Michigan 48207. 2 Additionally if you'd like to send cards, 3 announcement or telegram they can be forwarded to 4 Detroit Police Department, Office of the Chief of 5 Police, 1300 Beaubien, Suite 300, Detroit, Michigan 6 48226, also emails can be forwarded to the Office of 7 Public Information at [email protected]. 8 At this time I request you join me in a 9 moment of silence on behalf of Ms. Logan. 10 (Silence.) 11 COMMANDER MCKISSIC: Thank you. 12 Additionally, I'd like you guys to know a fireworks 13 curfew is in effect on June 24th, the rain date of 14 June 25th; 17 and under must be accompanied by parents 15 and/or guardians. The curfew takes effect from 16 6:00 p.m. to 6:00 a.m. 17 If it's all right with you, Chair, I'd like 18 to introduce Inspector Yost with the presentation for 19 the 4th Precinct? 20 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Yes. 21 COMMANDER MCKISSIC: Inspector Vicky Yost of 22 the 4th Precinct. 23 INSPECTOR YOST: Through the Chair, Inspector 24 Yost, Commanding Officer of the Southwestern District. 25 Good evening. 6/13/2013 Page 11 1 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Good evening. 2 INSPECTOR YOST: I'd like to thank you all 3 for coming out to the 4th Precinct. We've got a good 4 presentation. It's a slide show that Lieutenant Pierce 5 put together and she'll be walking you through it. 6 Before we get there I'd like to announce that 7 we have a precinct-wide community relations meeting the 8 second Tuesday of every month with the exception of 9 July and August at the Precinct and we invite all of 10 our citizens to attend. It's at 6:00 p.m. 11 I also want to thank Lieutenant Pierce and 12 our Community Relations staff for the food in the back. 13 It is a local business. They did a really good job 14 with it. So without further ado, Lieutenant Lori 15 Pierce, CO of Number 4. 16 LT. PIERCE: Good afternoon everybody. For 17 those of you that come to these type of meetings, 18 typically do a Power Point Presentation. We tried to 19 do a little something different to show you sights of 20 the 4th Precinct and show you the rich culture at the 21 4th Precinct. 22 Everyone know the Ambassador Bridge located 23 in the 4th Precinct. It is a very busy border 24 crossing. It is the busiest border crossing, 25 international border crossing in American in terms of 6/13/2013 Page 12 1 trade volume. 2 That is the location of the 4th Precinct 3 known as Southwest Public Safety Center. We're located 4 at Fort and Clark. We also have the Fire Department 5 attached to our building on the other side. 6 This is our staff at the Precinct and we have 7 many Officers of various ethnicity that speak numerous 8 languages to better serve people that come in. Here's 9 our statistics in terms of how we've reduced crime and 10 that's the current year. We're also down in almost all 11 categories last year, as well. 12 Last year our Officers serviced over 106,000 13 police runs when they're combined as the Southwestern 14 District. We're both 2nd and 4th Precincts. This is 15 one of the biggest landmarks in the City, the old train 16 station which is also located in the 4th Precinct. 17 That's Roosevelt Park is right in front of 18 the train station. This is River Side Park. There's a 19 lot of activity -- there used to be a lot of activity. 20 I believe it's closed at the moment. The J. Wescott if 21 anyone's familiar with that. As the freighters make 22 their travels and -- they do get mail delivered to them 23 through the Wescott. I don't know if there's any old 24 people like me here who remember Boblo? Some more 25 freighters. 6/13/2013 Page 13 1 Does that look familiar to anybody, the 2 drawbridge, which is due to go under construction soon? 3 That was Fort Street. That one's due to go under 4 construction soon. Our Precinct is 14.4 square miles. 5 We have a population of 70,529. We have 34 churches. 6 The 4th Precinct with a couple pictures of them, very 7 old historic beautiful churches, just goes to show you 8 the culture and diversity of Number 4. 9 Anyone who drives to Number 4 will notice a 10 lot of wall murals and graffiti. Some consider it to 11 be artwork, others, not so much. I think everyone's 12 probably seen that at one point or another. 13 We have a lot of businesses, over 1,000 14 business successfully operating in the 4th Precinct. 15 These are some ones that stand out. The best coffee. 16 We all know Telway's, right? We also have what we call 17 critical infrastructures in the 4th Precinct which 18 means that basically in layman terms give very special 19 attention to these locations because they could be 20 locations for terrorist activity or terrorist targets. 21 The water sewage department, the water 22 treatment center is one them. The bridge is another. 23 This is an aerial view of the water treatment center. 24 Another one is the Marathon Oil Refinery. You're all 25 familiar with that at Fort and Schaefer. I think 6/13/2013 Page 14 1 that's a very familiar sight to many of us. 2 We have 17 schools and 12 parks. You are 3 here. A lot of you might know the Kennedy Center. You 4 vote there. And good old 48217. Also Historic Fort 5 Wayne is located in the 4th Precinct. One of our 6 closed fire houses. 7 That's pretty much it. I'll give a little 8 bit of additional information just so you know we're 9 trying hard to reduce crime in the community. Just 10 year-to-date as of the June 2nd we've made 367 felony 11 arrests, 135 misdemeanor arrests, detained 12 69 juveniles, issued close to 3,000 tickets, 13 investigated almost 12,000, over 12,000 vehicles, and 14 initiated 3,284 traffic stops. We're trying our best 15 to keep those crime numbers to come down. And that's 16 it. 17 (Applause.) 18 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Thank you. Any questions 19 for the Lieutenant? 20 VICE CHAIRPERSON TAYLOR: I have none. 21 COMMISSIONER WHITE: Thank you, Lieutenant, 22 if there are areas of concern with the Southwest what 23 would you attribute those to as relates to crime 24 patterns? 25 LT. PIERCE: What areas of concern we have? 6/13/2013 Page 15 1 We do try to pay particular attention to the 48217 area 2 on the other side of the bridge near Marathon. Because 3 of the structure of our geography it's very hard to get 4 down there. Basically there's only two ways to get 5 down there by Fort Street or I75. And soon -- it's 6 called the Besttoon Bridge, in Detroit, is about to be 7 closed for over a year I believe which posses a 8 particular problem because if there's crime going on 9 down there and we have to always have someone down 10 there, but if you need additional reinforcements down 11 there we're going to be hindered in a way. So we do 12 have a plan in place. But basically we do kind of pay 13 extra attention to that area just due to the geography 14 of the area. 15 COMMISSIONER WHITE: For the record, 16 Lieutenant, your boundaries? 17 LT. PIERCE: Our boundaries, we go all the 18 way to Warren. We travel down the Lincoln Park Border 19 like Outer Drive to Fort Street. We have a very 20 crooked border because we border like Jefferson to 14, 21 and Michigan. It's a very crooked border. 22 COMMISSIONER WHITE: Thank you, Mr. Chair. 23 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Thank you. Lieutenant, 24 you might be able to answer this question. Inspector 25 Yost mentioned earlier about the business that supplied 6/13/2013 Page 16 1 the food tonight. She didn't mention the name. Would 2 you happen to know the name so we can all know it? 3 LT. PIERCE: Yes, I do know it's Gonellas for 4 the subs. What about the pastry? Mexican Town Bakery 5 for the pastries. 6 COMMISSIONER WHITE: I'm sorry, Mexican 7 Town -- 8 LT. PIERCE: Bakery. 9 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: What was the other 10 restaurant? 11 LT. PIERCE: Gonellas. 12 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Great. Thank you. We 13 appreciate it. Excellent presentation. Thank you. 14 Sir, is there anything else? 15 (Applause.) 16 COMMANDER MCKISSIC: There's nothing else on 17 our agenda at this time. 18 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Thank you, sir, 19 appreciate that. At this time we're going to ask if 20 Commissioner White would lead us as we honor and 21 recognize Mr. Jesse Gonzales for his outstanding work 22 here in the Southwest District. 23 Mr. Gonzales, could you come forward at this 24 time, you may come right on down here, sir. Give him a 25 hand, would you please. 6/13/2013 Page 17 1 (Applause.) 2 COMMISSIONER WHITE: That's right. I started 3 my morning off with Mr. Gonzales. He didn't know I was 4 there, but 7:30, he was also the recipient of a 5 community award for the Southwest Business Association. 6 So I said, two for today. He said, no, that was three, 7 I had a Spirit of Detroit Award, too. We're going to 8 pile onto your running total today, Mr. Gonzales. 9 Before us, Commissioners, is a Resolution 10 honoring Mr. Jesse Gonzales. Whereas, Mr. Jesse 11 Gonzales is a proud and lifelong resident of Southwest 12 Detroit for more than 54 years and remains an active 13 member of the Southwest Community Relations Council. 14 Mr. Gonzales graduated from Western High 15 School which is located within the 4th Precinct 16 boundaries. Mr. Gonzales worked for Ford Motor Company 17 for 37 years and currently serves as the liaison for 18 the Wayne County Commission. 19 And whereas, Mr. Gonzales previously served 20 as a member of the Weed and Seed for the Southwest 21 District Sector 5 for over two years. As a member of 22 the C.E.R.T., Citizens Emergency Response Team, three 23 years an active member of Alpact which is facilitated 24 by the National Conference of Community and Justice as 25 well as the Michigan Round Table which promotes 6/13/2013 Page 18 1 diversity and inclusion. 2 And whereas, Mr. Gonzales is a police liaison 3 for implementing safety programs with the surrounding 4 communities such as Melvindale and Lincoln Park. 5 Mr. Gonzales was very active in organizing a group of 6 young people to clean up at the park as well as other 7 community arts projects. 8 And whereas, Mr. Gonzales has always been 9 interested in police community relations and has always 10 contributed in efforts to improve neighbor safety and 11 quality of life. His participation and community 12 organization goes back to the early years when he 13 received his first paycheck from Ford and immediately 14 started to donate a portion of his check back to the 15 community in which he had lived in and loved since 16 1958. 17 And whereas, Mr. Gonzales has participated in 18 numerous community forums, town hall summits and many 19 events that include Motor City Makeover, Angels Night 20 and Crime Walks. Mr. Gonzales continues to volunteer 21 his time and service when called upon for any event. 22 He is a living example of steadfastness and what it 23 takes to build a city. He is very happy and outgoing. 24 Two of his seven children have graduated with Criminal 25 Justice Degrees and one of his daughters is a member of 6/13/2013 Page 19 1 the Detroit Police Department. 2 Now therefore be it resolved, that the 3 Detroit Board of Commissioners speaking on behalf of 4 the citizens of the City of Detroit and the Detroit 5 Police Department acknowledge the dedication and 6 persistence of Mr. Jesse Gonzales, his highly displayed 7 commitment to community service, his ability to build 8 sustainable community partnerships merit our highest 9 regards. 10 We thank and congratulate, Mr. Jesse 11 Gonzales, signed the Detroit Board of Police 12 Commissioners and adopted this day by the Board of 13 Police Commissioners, June 13th, 2013. It's our honor 14 to bestow upon you your third award of the day, 15 Mr. Gonzales. Congratulations. 16 (Applause and picture were taken.) 17 COMMANDER McKissic: On behalf of the Detroit 18 Police Department, we present this Certificate of 19 Recognition to Mr. Jesse Gonzales resident of the City 20 of Detroit in appreciation for your contribution, your 21 involvement in the community and service to the City of 22 Detroit demonstrates the spirit of commitment that is 23 worthy of recognition. Signed by Chief Chester L. 24 Logan. 25 (Applause and pictures were taken.) 6/13/2013 Page 20 1 INSPECTOR YOST: This is seriously piling on. 2 The spirit of Detroit Award is presented, herein, with 3 an expression of gratitude and esteem of the Citizens 4 of Detroit to Mr. Jesse Gonzales in recognition of 5 exceptional achievement outstanding leadership and 6 dedication to improving the quality of life. Signed by 7 all the members of the Detroit City Council. 8 Congratulations. 9 (Applause.) 10 MR. GONZALES: Well, I just got to say thank 11 you so much. I do love my neighborhood. And I do it 12 from my heart. It's not because I have to because it's 13 something I love doing. I also with the help of the 14 Commissioner Varges she has opened more doors for me. 15 And the 4th Precinct is also a good place to 16 visit. I never had no trouble going in there and 17 talking and getting my feedback from people from 18 outside the streets. And we work together this way. 19 And that's what I just love about our Southwest Detroit 20 Police Department. 21 And like I said this week has been a blessing 22 to me. My granddaughter graduated from school, my 23 other daughter she graduated and got her Bachelor in 24 Criminal Justice, my son's birthday, new baby in the 25 family. So I'm honored with all these awards. It's 6/13/2013 Page 21 1 overwhelming to me. Thank you, Southwest Detroit. 2 (Applause and photos.) 3 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: You're welcome and you 4 are deserving. Thank you. 5 At this time I'm going to ask if Lieutenant 6 Bliss could come to podium that we may hear some 7 Directives. Sir, can you hold on one quick second, 8 stay there, though. 9 Is there a motion regarding the Resolution 10 honoring Mr. Jesse Gonzales? 11 COMMISSIONER WHITE: Motion to adopt. 12 VICE CHAIRPERSON TAYLOR: Support. 13 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: It's been properly moved 14 and supported that the Resolution honoring Mr. Jesse 15 Gonzales be adopted and be a part of our permanent 16 archives. Anymore discussion? Without objection, all 17 those in favor? 18 COMMISSIONERS: Aye. 19 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Thank you. Yes, sir, 20 thank you. 21 LIEUTENANT BLISS: Good evening, 22 Commissioners and Commander McKissic. Lieutenant Bliss 23 from Planning and Accreditation. I'm here today to 24 present for your review and approval Directive 204.1 25 Crash Investigation. This basically entails how an 6/13/2013 Page 22 1 Officer is supposed to investigate and document crash 2 investigations. The changes that we've made are 3 basically we did, well, there have been substantial 4 changes. The investigation procedure for the Officers, 5 the implementation of the MAS System for certain forms, 6 and a new process for reviewing the UD10 which is a 7 traffic crash investigation is now online and it's no 8 longer being done on paper form, they've been 9 implemented in this policy. 10 The policy is at the front of the recreation 11 center for people to, if they want to review it and 12 it's also posted online on the City website and at the 13 Districts. 14 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: All of them or one at a 15 time? 16 LIEUTENANT BLISS: Okay. The other two are 17 for basically for approval. 18 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Okay. Say it again. 19 LIEUTENANT BLISS: The other two are for 20 approval. This is the first for the crash 21 investigation. 22 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Thank you. 23 LIEUTENANT BLISS: The other two for approval 24 are Manual Directive 401.2 Transfers, and Directive 25 203.7 Organized Crime Vice and Narcotics. I believe 6/13/2013 Page 23 1 Commander Romeo made the presentation prior. If 2 there's any questions regarding these three Directives? 3 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Let me say this in 4 regards to the transfers, I know this is the first time 5 that I have seen them, I can't speak for my colleagues, 6 I would like to look over it and may be another week I 7 feel comfortable -- 8 SECRETARY ANTHONY: We can wait. 9 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: We're going to table this 10 one. 11 LIEUTENANT BLISS: Just to give you a brief 12 overview of the changes. 13 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Yes, sir. 14 LIEUTENANT BLISS: All the information 15 contained in the transfers are based on the current CBA 16 which is the Collective Bargaining Agreements with the 17 City. They've been in place for years. There has been 18 no major change to the transfer process. The only 19 thing that we did add other than minor grammar and 20 punctuation is the MAS process and that is that when a 21 new Command gets personnel they're required within a 22 certain time period to update there MAS profile that 23 they've been transferred to that new Command. 24 It was not in there prior and we were holding 25 Commands responsible for doing that, but it was never 6/13/2013 Page 24 1 documented. So we did put that new policy in and then 2 we just put small things that we checked with Personnel 3 on. But the transfer process has not changed, just the 4 documentation through MAS at the Commands for that. 5 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Okay. 6 LIEUTENANT BLISS: Thank you, sir. 7 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Thank you. At this time 8 we want to ask Sergeant Stephens could come to the 9 podium as we honor Quarter Awards members of the 10 Department. Sergeant Stephens, it's always good to see 11 you, ma'am. 12 SERGEANT STEPHENS: Okay. Good evening, 13 everyone. At this time we would like to thank everyone 14 for coming out tonight. And I will ask if there's any 15 of tonight's awardees if you have not checked in, please 16 see Officer Cook, he's behind the screen, so they can 17 make sure we acknowledge you. 18 Our first award recipient for the First 19 Quarter in 2013 is Officer Borkowski from Central 20 District, if you can come forward, please. 21 Police Officer Borkowski was appointed to the 22 Detroit Police Department on January 17th, 1995. He is 23 currently assigned to Central District. He is working 24 with an investigative unit as a liaison officer 25 preparing search warrants, arrest warrants, and 6/13/2013 Page 25 1 investigating crime. 2 During his investigation Officer Borkowski 3 will meet on a regular basis with the prosecutor's 4 office to assist in mediation issues that arise from 5 the investigation. His skills in crime analysis has 6 been a great asset in identifying several crime 7 patterns, and strategies to help combat those issues. 8 He is a Central District Crime Analysis Officer who is 9 a respected Officer of the Downtown Detroit Partnership 10 Safety and Security Committee and is well respected. 11 His input has been valuable in making the 12 Downtown area and Central District a safer place. He 13 has been instrumental in several investigations which 14 have resulted in the closing of numerous larcenies, and 15 motor vehicles cases that occur within the central 16 business district. 17 Officer Borkowski did not use any sick time 18 during this quarter. He is reliable, neat, and always 19 well groomed and has an excellent understanding of the 20 Detroit Police Department rules and regulations. His 21 demonstration of that knowledge and skills which is 22 typically associated with a veteran officer. Officer 23 Borkowski diligence and dedication to duty maintains 24 within the highest standards of the Detroit Police 25 Department where he remains a role model and asset. 6/13/2013 Page 26 1 It was strongly recommended and proved that 2 Officer Borkowski be selected as Central District's 3 Officer of the First Quarter. Congratulations. 4 (Applause and photos.) 5 SERGEANT STEPHENS: Next from Eastern 6 District Police Officer Chancellor Searcy and his 7 partner Police Officer Charles Lynem. This is a first. 8 We've never had partners recognized in the Quarter, so 9 job well done. Officer Chancellor Searcy was appointed 10 to the Detroit Police Department on November 21st, 11 2008. Officer Charles Lynem was appointed to the 12 Department October 6th, 2008. 13 They have consistently performed their duties 14 in a professional and courteous manner. During the 15 period of January through March 2013 they had 16 demonstrate enthusiasm as they patrolled the streets of 17 Detroit. During this quarter they made 38 felony 18 arrests, they recovered 29 illegal firearms, and they 19 have demonstrated to the public by answering and 20 responding to 100 police runs. 21 They maintained excellent attendance during 22 this Quarter and are always neat and orderly in their 23 professional appearance which reflect a positive image 24 on the Department. 25 They have been selected to be Officers of the 6/13/2013 Page 27 1 Quarter for the First Quarter. They have the high 2 degree of professionalism and outstanding service which 3 they exhibit daily while they are working. Together, 4 they're partners. We thank you. Congratulations. 5 (Applause and photos.) 6 SERGEANT STEPHENS: Thank you. Next we have 7 from Northeastern District Police Officer Jana Greeno. 8 Police Officer Jana Greeno was appointed to the Detroit 9 Police Department on October the 6th, 2008. She was 10 assigned to Northeastern District on August 12th, 2009. 11 Since being assigned to Northeastern District she has 12 gained a reputation for being a highly motivated 13 productive Officer. 14 Doing the First Quarter, Officer Greeno has 15 demonstrated consistent quality of work. She effected 16 twelve felony arrests, 18 misdemeanor arrests and 17 issued 178 misdemeanor and traffic ordinances. 18 Officer Greeno has demonstrated her 19 dedication to the public by responding to over 250 20 police runs. Also to be noted Officer Greeno was on 21 vacation for two weeks during that First Quarter. She 22 has always been a dependable Officer showing up early 23 to review the crime reports and touch base with the 24 Officers from the prior shift to familiarize herself 25 with any ongoing incidents and problems. 6/13/2013 Page 28 1 Officer Greeno appearance is always neat and 2 her best quality is her motivation. In a time of low 3 morale and low production Office Greeno continues to 4 post high number arrests and issuance of citations. 5 Her enthusiasm has earned her a position to 6 work out of service on a threshold detail to address 7 specific crime patterns in a given geographic location. 8 Officer Greeno continued to volunteer for priority 9 police runs which aids in providing citizens service. 10 Her attendance and enthusiasm and reliability 11 have made her highly respected by her peers and 12 Supervisors. Officer Greeno exhibits a high degree of 13 professionalism and devotion to her duties. Therefore, 14 Police Officer Jana Greeno will be recognize as Officer 15 of the First Quarter. Congratulations. 16 (Applause and photos.) 17 SERGEANT STEPHENS: Next we will have from 18 the 2nd Precinct Police Officer Christopher Champagne, 19 please come forward. Police Officer Christopher 20 Champagne was appointed to the Detroit Police 21 Department on December the 29th, 2004. Office 22 Champagne showed that he's extremely hard working, 23 reliable, cooperative, and self-motivated. 24 He stays updated on the changes in the 25 Department policies and State laws. He also strives to 6/13/2013 Page 29 1 keep himself aware of the relative crime patterns 2 within the 2nd Precinct. He has also proficient 3 knowledge of general and specific duties and maintains 4 a stellar appearance. He has demonstrated tremendous 5 courage when arresting some of the fiercest and 6 dangerous criminals in the community and his leadership 7 qualities are far beyond his years. 8 During the First Quarter Officer Champagne 9 has demonstrated his strong commitment to the citizens 10 of Detroit and the Department by producing the 11 following statistics: He effected 16 misdemeanor 12 arrests, issued 36 uniform citations, answered 249 13 police runs for service, and recovered $54,500 worth of 14 property. 15 Is it without hesitation that Officer 16 Christopher Champaign be considered the Officer of the 17 Quarter for the First Quarter 2013. Congratulations. 18 (Applause and photos.) 19 SERGEANT STEPHENS: From the 4th Precinct we 20 have Police Officer Aref Algarrafi. Officer Algarrafi 21 was appointed to the Detroit Police Department on 22 February 26th, 2001. He has been instrumental in the 23 reduction of violent crimes with more than 36 felony 24 arrests. He's assigned to Special Operations and 25 conducts a comprehensive review of all violent cases 6/13/2013 Page 30 1 within the 4th Precinct. 2 Officer Algarrafi utilizes intelligence that 3 has been gathered to identify potential suspects. He 4 openly shares information with his colleagues to assist 5 in the apprehension of wanted criminals. During this 6 First Quarter of March 27th, 2013, Officer Algarrafi 7 and his partner received and developed information 8 regarding suspects believed to be connected to as many 9 as five robberies and shootings that occurred in the 10 north end of the 4th Precinct. 11 The suspects were allegedly driving a black 12 Ford Escape with a hanging rear bumper. He and his 13 partner began canvassing the area for this vehicle and 14 suspects were located. They conducted a traffic stop. 15 The occupants fled from the vehicle and a foot pursuit 16 ensued. All the suspects were apprehended and charged 17 with multiple counts of armed robbery. 18 In addition to making the 36 felony arrests, 19 Officer Algarrafi issued 30 uniform citations, 20 investigated 257 individuals and 63 vehicles. He 21 deserves to be recognized for being an outstanding 22 Officer at the 4th Precinct. Officer Algarrafi, 23 congratulations. 24 (Applause and photos.) 25 SERGEANT STEPHENS: Next we're going to have 6/13/2013 Page 31 1 Police Officer Christopher Salisbury and his partner 2 Cak. Police Officer Christopher Salisbury is assigned 3 to the Canine Unit. He is a canine's assistant trainer 4 and is responsible for conducting weekly training and 5 maintaining the Department's canines to ensure they're 6 ready to patrol the streets when needed. 7 He reports to duty in a professional manner 8 and needs little guidance from his immediate 9 supervisor. During the first quarter he and his canine 10 partner conducted five narcotic searches, two explosive 11 searches, one building search, two article searches and 12 tracked ten suspects. They investigates 42 males, 13 22 females, and 89 vehicles, and issued 93 civil 14 infractions. 15 It is because of his and Cak their dedication 16 is exemplary that they are being recognized as Officer 17 of the Quarter. Congratulations. 18 (Applause and Photos.) 19 SERGEANT STEPHENS: From the Criminal 20 Investigation Bureau we have Police Officer Robert 21 Bolden, please come forward. 22 Police Officer Robert Bolden is assigned to 23 the Detroit Fugitive Apprehension Team, D-FAT. He was 24 appointed to the Detroit Police Department on 25 October 31st, 1997. Officer Bolden was selected and 6/13/2013 Page 32 1 accepted the responsibilities to be the team leader for 2 the D-FAT Enforcement Team. 3 Daily he exemplifies professionalism and 4 keeps a positive attitude while apprehending the most 5 dangerous criminals sought by law enforcement. 6 Officer Bolden investigates his crimes in a 7 detailed manner which resulted in a very high number of 8 suspects being apprehended closing a high number of 9 cases. He has demonstrated that he self-motivated and 10 does not require a great deal of supervision. On 11 numerous occasions he has been acknowledged for his 12 commitment to service. 13 Officer Bolden was selected to receive this 14 award not only because of his accomplishments during 15 the First Quarter but for his years of determination 16 and professional service to the citizens of Detroit. 17 He has become a valuable asset to the Detroit Police 18 Department, the Detroit Fugitive Apprehension Team, and 19 the City of Detroit, and is worthy of this recognition 20 as Police Officer of the Quarter. Congratulations. 21 (Applause and photos.) 22 SERGEANT STEPHENS: Next we will have from 23 the Criminal Investigations Bureau Police Officer 24 Benita Brewer. Police Officer Benita Brewer is 25 assigned to Domestic Violence Bureau. She was 6/13/2013 Page 33 1 appointed to the Detroit Police Department on May 24th, 2 1993. Police Officer Brewer is currently assigned to 3 the Unit as the Court and Property Officer in Domestic 4 Violence. However, she has the background and 5 experience which allows her to take on additional tasks 6 often unasked which makes the flow and operation of the 7 Unit effective and efficient. 8 She has an excellent working relationship 9 with the various departmental personnel and the judges, 10 clerks, and prosecutors within the court system. This 11 partnership has assisted in timely processing of court 12 proceedings. 13 Officer Brewer is very meticulous in her job 14 functions and always engaged in duties going for the 15 extra mile when necessary to assist colleagues and 16 victims and citizens. Her knowledge on the procedures 17 and policies is well known as she's a major asset to 18 her immediate supervisors, peers, and citizens. 19 Officer Brewer has set a high standard in the 20 area of job performance and easily meets the 21 qualification of an outstanding employee. Not only 22 does members of the Domestic Violent benefits from 23 Officer Brewer's abilities but other units and entities 24 within law enforcement agencies across the county 25 boundaries, as well. 6/13/2013 Page 34 1 Because she has been an exemplary Officer and 2 goes above and beyond her duties and responsibilities 3 she is being recognized tonight for being one of the 4 Detroit's finest. Congratulations. 5 (Applause and photos.) 6 OFFICER BREWER: Thank you. 7 SERGEANT STEPHENS: I'd like to thank you, 8 and that concludes the Quarter Awards Presentation. 9 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Let us give a round of 10 applause. It is always an honor and a privilege to be 11 able to celebrate what our men and women who wear the 12 uniform who always go above and beyond the call of 13 duty. So we thank them. 14 Certainly it is a small token but, you know, 15 we hope that you understand we recognize what you do 16 day in and day out and how you literally put your life 17 on the line. And not only do we thank you, we also 18 thank your families and your loved ones who support 19 you. So to the families and the loved ones, we say, 20 thank you to you, as well. 21 Attorney Washington, disciplinary appeal is 22 that on for today? Okay. We'll move that one until 23 later. Our next Board of Police Commissioners meeting 24 will be held on Thursday, June the 20th, 2013, at 25 3:00 p.m., Police Headquarters 1300 Beaubien, Room 6/13/2013 Page 35 1 328A. 2 At this time the agenda calls for Oral 3 Communication from the audience. If you wish to 4 addressed the Board of Police Commissioners we ask you 5 to come to the podium in the center, please give us 6 your first and last name and because of the echo, can 7 you spell it for our recorder and we ask that you abide 8 by our two minute time limit so that we may hear from 9 as many individuals as possible. You may come at this 10 time. 11 MS. DAVIS: Hello everybody. My name is 12 Donna Davis. I used to be a resident of Detroit. But 13 my family is still a resident in Detroit. I had a 14 incident that happened back in August the 6th, 2012 15 that I would like to bring to everybody's attention 16 here. 17 I have a daughter that's missing. She became 18 missing August 6th, 2012. This is a female that I know 19 as a mother knows their child, would not go missing, 20 would answer your phone calls. Is a very well 21 participant of a family, didn't have any kind of major 22 problems, we all got problems, but didn't have any 23 major problems. 24 I spoke to my daughter on August 6th, 2012 25 and that was the last call that I have talked to her 6/13/2013 Page 36 1 since. I've been back and forth here since August 13th 2 of 2012. I no longer live here. I live in Florida. 3 So it's difficult for me to keep contact and to have on 4 the phone participation with the Police Officer is null 5 and void. 6 So I just want to bring awareness that Tamale 7 Wells is missing and I don't know who else to reach out 8 to. If it was your child or anybody's child we go as 9 high as we go to go to bring our children or our family 10 or our loved ones back home safe. 11 I understand this is a real high epidemic 12 here. And as I ride through the streets of the City of 13 Detroit anything can happen, you know. And I just want 14 to bring awareness so that I can get some type help in 15 this matter. So if there's anyone I can talk to 16 afterwards I appreciate it. 17 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Thank you, Ms. Davis, 18 could you stand there for one second, ma'am, please. 19 We want to try and get you some help right now. 20 COMMANDER MCKISSIC: Tell me where she's 21 missing from? 22 MS. DAVIS: 19703 Appleton was the last known 23 that I know that she was supposed to left there. That 24 was her home. She stayed with her boyfriend for 25 fifteen years. So it was kind of like shaky. When the 6/13/2013 Page 37 1 little girl call you early in the morning August the 2 7th and tell you her mother didn't come home, you're in 3 Florida, she's in Detroit, kind of raised some type of 4 suspicious(sic). For five days I spoke to this little 5 girl, my granddaughter, over the phone to reassure her 6 that everything will be okay, but it wasn't, and it 7 still hasn't been. 8 Now, the boyfriend never got on the phone to 9 call me to tell me something happened, he made a police 10 report, any concerns. This is a boyfriend that she had 11 been with for 15 years. I want to know why didn't you 12 get on phone? 13 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Ms. Davis, one of the 14 things I'm sure Commander McKissic will do, I don't 15 want to put too many details out there, there's 16 probably an investigation. 17 MS. DAVIS: There is. 18 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: And we don't want to 19 spoil that, so I'm going to ask if the Commander will 20 follow up with someone for you right now. 21 COMMANDER MCKISSIC: Inspector Yost is going 22 to assign someone to gather your information and do 23 some followup. 24 MS. DAVIS: Okay. 25 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Ms. Davis, I think I 6/13/2013 Page 38 1 spoke with you on the phone. 2 MS. DAVIS: What's your name? 3 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Warfield. 4 MS. DAVIS: Yes, I did, yes, you was the 5 pastor? 6 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Yes, ma'am. 7 MS. DAVIS: I never got a call back and I was 8 hurt about that. 9 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Yes, ma'am, yes, ma'am, 10 and we're still checking. We're still looking into 11 that. Absolutely. One of the things is not an excuse 12 for, one of things we try and do is when we do call 13 back is make sure we have something that's different 14 than what we've already had discussed. 15 So that's still the notion. And as the 16 Commander said, Inspector Yost will talk to you and 17 give you an update as best we can. She'll get your 18 information, your personal information while you're 19 here and pass along to me and we'll follow up again. 20 MS. DAVIS: Okay. 21 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Thank you, ma'am. 22 MS. DAVIS: I appreciate that. 23 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: You're welcome. Are 24 there others who wish to address the Board? You may 25 come at this time. 6/13/2013 Page 39 1 MS. ZUNIGA: Hello to all. My name is Azalia 2 Zuniga, A-Z-A-L-I-A, Z-U-N-I-G-A. My house was broken 3 into December and my cameras caught the person that 4 broke into my house or the two people that came in. We 5 had Detectives come out to our house. They knew who 6 they were because them names were given, not to us but 7 between them. We never heard from the Detectives or 8 from anybody. 9 They attempted to break in again, same person 10 in May. We tried to contact -- we got no response from 11 anybody so we went to Channel 2. The following day I 12 did get a call saying in December I had given an 13 invalid phone number which I had an email where I sent 14 videos about these two people that broke into my house. 15 I haven't heard anything back. I mean, who do I go to 16 next? 17 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Thank you, ma'am. 18 COMMANDER MCKISSIC: You live in the 4th 19 Precinct? 20 MS. ZUMIGA: Yes, I do. 21 COMMANDER MCKISSIC: Lieutenant Pierce will 22 gather your information and she'll provide a followup. 23 MS. ZUMIGA: Okay. Thank you. 24 MS. EDWARD: Good evening. 25 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Good evening. 6/13/2013 Page 40 1 MS. EDWARD: I'm the cousin of the young lady 2 whose daughter is missing. I'm a life-long Detroit 3 resident. 4 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Your name, ma'am, for the 5 record. 6 MS. EDWARD: Francine Edward. I chose to 7 leave the City. Now I have chosen to move back into 8 the City. I have faith in the City. I have faith in 9 Detroit Police Department. And to prove to me that you 10 guys are still the best please help us find her and 11 bring her home. This is our family. This is my 12 cousin. I love her. And I know that this is a great 13 team of people. But it's hurting her mom and she's 14 disconnected, and we're also disconnected. 15 So again, I'm pleading on behalf of my family 16 that somebody helps us and not just -- if you don't 17 have any information just a phone call would be nice. 18 A return phone call would be nice to say, Mrs. Davis, I 19 haven't forgotten about you, we're still working on 20 your case, just be patient with us. Thank you. 21 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Thank you, ma'am. 22 MS. SEMMA: Good evening. Julia Semma, on 23 behalf of the Detroit Authorized Towers Association. 24 I'm here in regards to the tow rates, the increase that 25 we had. We went through a series of meetings with City 6/13/2013 Page 41 1 officials, City Council, Tow Rate Commissioners and 2 everybody. And I'm under the understanding the City of 3 Detroit Police Department now is changing our rates as 4 far as what they want to pay us and I'd like to find 5 out if you guys know anything about that. And I'm 6 under the understanding that once the tow rate is set 7 the standard that's the rate we're supposed to be 8 getting paid, so. And this is going in regard to us 9 getting paid for Gene's Towing, City Towing that does 10 anything with the Detroit Police Department and 11 anything going to forfeiture, they want to pay us less 12 than what we're supposed to be allotted for. 13 So I just want to know if you guys know 14 anything about it and if you can guide us or help with 15 that, as well? 16 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Thank you, ma'am, for 17 coming. Certainly it is the Tow Rate Commission who 18 sets those rates. So unfortunately it's them who deals 19 with that. I know the Department, and someone can 20 correct me if I'm wrong, the Department's perspective 21 it's not our job or responsibility to set those rates 22 if those rate are set differently than what the Tow 23 Rate Commission and the City Council because the City 24 Council had actually approved -- approval, sorry, those 25 tow rates that are in place and the Mayor and the 6/13/2013 Page 42 1 Emergency Manager signed off on them those are the 2 rates that are in effect. 3 If they're different rates that come about we 4 don't know anything about them, and so, you know, my 5 colleagues -- so if there's something different please 6 let us know. 7 MS. SEMMA: There's something extremely 8 different right now and we've been told by Management 9 Services Roland Clark and other people that work in his 10 department that our rates are significantly getting 11 paid less to perform our services. 12 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Well, I'm going to ask 13 then if Sergeant Clark or Lieutenant Adams can come to 14 our next meeting and give us an update because we have 15 not had that presentation to us. 16 Again, our understanding as relates to 17 adjusting the tow rate, that comes from the Tow Rate 18 Commission. Not us. 19 MS. SEMMA: Thank you. 20 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Thank you, ma'am. 21 Anybody else? 22 SERGEANT STEPHENS: I just want to invite you 23 tomorrow we're going to be having a United States Flag 24 Presentation at Central District at 10:00 a.m. We're 25 having several flags that are being donated to be 6/13/2013 Page 43 1 presented to our Precincts and Districts. So if you're 2 available please join us tomorrow 10:00 a.m., Central 3 District, 7310 Woodward Avenue. 4 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Thank you, ma'am. 5 MS. SMITH: Good evening. 6 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Good evening. 7 MS. SMITH: Bernice Smith, Political 8 Activist. It is a sad fact period for all of us that 9 have concerns about our Police Department especially 10 our Chief. I met his wife one time and I feel as 11 though that was a loving couple when I met her, and he 12 was so devoted to her. 13 Due to the fact I was concerned about her 14 health because I would ask him each meeting how is she 15 doing and would say pray for her. But, you know, God 16 knows best. And most of us we don't even know how to 17 pray to God but we should take time some time and just 18 give him some of our time. 19 With me being an employee with Swanson I got 20 inside on what the arrangements were. I understand, 21 Chief, that you gave the address out so I don't have to 22 give the address. But I do advise you not to come 23 before 6:00 because Saturday is a busy day at the 24 funeral home. 25 I work mainly Friday and Saturday. So I 6/13/2013 Page 44 1 suggest that you do come after 6:00, maybe about 6:30 2 something like that because this way they'll be able to 3 have her body shown and you won't have to be standing 4 around waiting for her to come into the chapel. 5 Also I think it's a good idea because I 6 believe that the Chief would want us to give a 7 contribution rather than flowers because normally you 8 don't have too many flowers at a Catholic church. So 9 in the meantime I do stress to each and everyone of you 10 not only the Police Department but the people in the 11 neighborhoods and citizens, in other words, that we 12 will just abide by his wishes. 13 I didn't get a chance to go by the home. So 14 I feel as though a lot of people would not want to go 15 and disturb him. He needs his silence. So, again, I 16 thank you much for making that announcement and let's 17 keep up the good work. 18 The Police Department, I congratulate each 19 and everyone of the Officers that were given awards. 20 And they deserve it. They really do because they go 21 out each and everyday and my thoughts are with them and 22 I do speak to them and tell them to be careful when 23 they're out there. 24 In the meantime I'm still wanting to get you 25 to your pay increase again, and I want you to get them 6/13/2013 Page 45 1 hours back to normal hours for you. Because I know you 2 will be better than what you doing now. I know your 3 morale is down. And we will see what's going to happen 4 with the new Chief coming in because I'm waiting with 5 all energy. 6 I did get a chance to see the EM the other 7 night, so I got one more time we going to meet with the 8 Chief again and see what he's going to do for the 9 citizens here in the Detroit area. I thank you so much 10 for your time. 11 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Thank you, ma'am. Any 12 others? Seeing that there are no others wishing to 13 address the Board we will close that section of our 14 meeting. 15 Again, our next meeting will be held 16 Thursday, June 20th, 2013, 3:00 p.m., Police 17 Headquarters 1300 Beaubien. 18 At this I'm going to entertain a motion to 19 adjourn. 20 COMMISSIONER WHITE: So move. 21 VICE CHAIRPERSON TAYLOR: Support. 22 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: It's been properly moved 23 and supported. No objection. All those in favor? 24 COMMISSIONERS: Aye. 25 CHAIRMAN WARFIELD: Meeting is concluded. 6/13/2013 Page 46 1 Thank you, ladies and gentlemen. 2 (The hearing concluded at 7:51 p.m.) 3 4 5 6 7 8 9 10 11 12 13 14 15 16 17 18 19 20 21 22 23 24 25 6/13/2013 Page 47 1 CERTIFICATE OF REPORTER 2 3 4 STATE OF MICHIGAN ) 5 ) SS 6 COUNTY OF WAYNE ) 7 8 I, Elizabeth Koller, hereby certify 9 that I reported stenographically the foregoing 10 proceedings and testimony under oath at the time and 11 place hereinbefore set forth; that thereafter the same 12 was reduced to computer transcription under my 13 supervision; and that this is a full, true, complete 14 and correct transcription of said proceedings. 15 16 17 ______18 Elizabeth Koller, CSR 7042, 19 Notary Public, 20 Wayne County, Michigan 21 My Commission expires: June 1, 2018 22 23 24 25 6/13/2013 Page 1

A 16:17 35:2 33:1 40:23 abide 35:7 44:12 ages 5:11,12 appreciate 4:10 attached 12:5 abilities 33:23 Agreements 23:16 6:1 7:15 16:13 attempted 39:9 ability 19:7 aids 28:9 16:19 36:16 attend 11:10 able 15:24 34:11 Algarrafi 29:20 38:22 attendance 26:21 44:2 29:20 30:2,6 appreciation 28:10 Absolutely 38:11 30:19,22 19:20 attends 7:8 accepted 32:1 allegedly 30:11 apprehended attention 13:19 accompanied allotted 41:12 30:16 32:8 15:1,13 35:15 10:14 allows 33:5 apprehending attitude 32:4 accomplishments Alpact 17:23 32:4 Attorney 2:3 32:14 Ambassador 11:22 apprehension 3:19 34:21 Accreditation American 11:25 30:5 31:23 attribute 14:23 21:23 analysis 25:5,8 32:18 audience 4:6,7 achievement 20:5 and/or 10:15 approval 6:23 35:3 acknowledge 19:5 Angels 18:19 21:24 22:17,20 August 11:9 24:17 announce 11:6 22:23 41:24 27:10 35:14,18 acknowledged announcement approve 6:24,25 35:24 36:1 32:11 10:3 44:16 7:16,23 37:1 Action 5:10,11 annual 7:4 approved 41:24 authority 7:2 active 17:12,23 answer 15:24 archives 21:16 Authorized 40:23 18:5 35:20 area 15:1,13,14 available 5:1 Activist 43:8 answered 29:12 25:12 30:13 43:2 activities 7:5 answering 26:19 33:20 45:9 Avenue 43:3 activity 12:19 Anthony 2:17 areas 14:22,25 Avis 5:24 6:2 12:19 13:20 3:20,20,22,23 Aref 29:20 award 17:5,7 Adams 42:13 23:8 armed 30:17 19:14 20:2 add 23:19 anybody 5:2 13:1 arrangements 24:18 32:14 addition 30:18 39:8,11 42:21 8:19 43:20 awardees 24:15 additional 7:9 anybody's 36:8 arrest 24:25 awards 20:25 14:8 15:10 Anymore 21:16 arresting 29:5 24:9 34:8 33:5 anyone's 12:21 arrests 14:11,11 44:19 Additionally anyway 9:8 26:18 27:16,16 aware 29:1 10:2,12 appeal 34:21 28:4 29:12,24 awareness 36:6 address 28:6 appearance 26:23 30:18 36:14 38:24 43:21,22 28:1 29:4 article 31:11 Aye 7:21 8:8 45:13 APPEARANCES 2:1 arts 18:7 21:18 45:24 addressed 35:4 Appearing 2:8 artwork 13:11 Azalia 39:1 adjourn 45:19 applause 5:21 asking 8:21 9:1 A-Z-A-L-I-A 39:2 adjusted 8:1 14:17 16:15 asset 25:6,25 a.m 9:24 10:16 adjusting 42:17 17:1 19:16,25 32:17 33:17 42:24 43:2 ado 11:14 20:9 21:2 26:4 assign 37:22 B adopt 21:11 27:5 28:16 assigned 24:23 adopted 19:12 29:18 30:24 27:10,11 29:24 baby 20:24 21:15 31:18 32:21 31:2,22 32:25 Bachelor 20:23 advise 43:22 34:5,10 33:2 back 11:12 18:12 aerial 13:23 Appleton 36:22 assist 25:4 30:4 18:14 35:14 afternoon 3:4 Appoint 7:4 33:15 36:1,10 38:7 11:16 appointed 6:17 assistant 31:3 38:13 39:15 agencies 33:24 24:21 26:9,11 assisted 33:11 40:7 45:1 agenda 7:16 27:8 28:20 associated 25:22 background 33:4 29:21 31:24 Association 17:5 Bakery 16:4,8 6/13/2013 Page 2

BANKS 2:2 border 11:23,24 canines 31:5 39:25 40:4,21 Bargaining 23:16 11:25 15:18,20 canine's 31:3 41:16 42:12,20 base 27:23 15:20,21 canvassing 30:13 43:4,6 45:11 based 23:15 Borkowski 24:19 cards 10:2 45:22,25 basically 13:18 24:21 25:2,17 care 8:17 CHAIRPERSON 8:4 15:4,12 21:25 25:23 26:2 careful 44:22 14:20 21:12 22:3,17 Boulevard 9:21 Carla 4:11 45:21 basis 25:3 boundaries 15:16 carries 8:10 chairs 5:9 Beaubien 2:5 15:17 17:16 case 40:20 challenged 9:7 10:5 34:25 33:25 cases 25:15 Champagne 28:18 45:17 Box 8:23,23 9:2 29:25 32:9 28:20,22 29:8 beautiful 13:7 boyfriend 36:24 categories 12:11 Champaign 29:16 began 30:13 37:8,10 Catholic 44:8 chance 44:13 behalf 2:8 10:9 break 39:9 caught 39:3 45:6 19:3,17 40:15 Brewer 32:24,24 CBA 23:15 Chancellor 26:6 40:23 33:2,13,19 celebrate 34:11 26:9 believe 12:20 34:6 CELIA 2:2 change 23:18 15:7 22:25 Brewer's 33:23 center 1:19 3:8 changed 24:3 44:6 bridge 11:22 4:13,18 5:7 changes 22:2,4 believed 30:8 13:22 15:2,6 12:3 13:22,23 23:12 28:24 benefits 33:22 brief 23:11 14:3 22:11 changing 41:3 Benita 32:24,24 bring 35:15 36:6 35:5 Channel 39:11 Bernice 43:7 36:9,14 40:11 central 24:19,23 chapel 44:4 best 13:15 14:14 broke 39:4,14 25:8,12,15 Chaplain 5:24 28:2 38:17 broken 39:2 26:2 42:24 6:2,4,8,10 40:10 43:16 Brown 4:2 43:2 8:11 bestow 19:14 budget 6:24 certain 22:5 charged 30:16 Besttoon 15:6 build 18:23 19:7 23:22 Charles 26:7,11 Beth 4:4 building 5:17 certainly 3:6 Charter 6:16 better 12:8 45:2 12:5 31:11 7:15 8:11,13 check 18:14 beyond 29:7 34:2 bumper 30:12 8:16,16 9:8 checked 24:2,15 34:12 Bureau 31:20 34:14 41:17 checking 38:10 biggest 12:15 32:23,25 Certificate Chester 8:12 birthday 20:24 busiest 11:24 19:18 47:1 19:23 bit 8:19 14:8 business 11:13 certify 47:8 Chief 3:24 6:23 black 30:11 13:14 15:25 Chair 3:22 7:25 7:9 8:12 9:4 Blackwell 9:17 17:5 25:16 9:10 10:17,23 9:16 10:4 blessing 20:21 businesses 13:13 15:22 19:23 43:10,21 Bliss 21:6,21,22 busy 11:23 43:23 Chairman 2:12 44:6 45:4,8 22:16,19,23 3:4,9,18 4:9 Chief's 3:15 23:11,14 24:6 C 5:22 6:9 7:14 9:14 Board 1:2 2:3,4 Cak 31:2,15 7:19,22 8:3,5 child 35:19 36:8 2:8 3:5,10,19 call 5:6 13:16 8:9 10:20 11:1 36:8 3:23 6:14 7:8 34:12 35:25 14:18 15:23 children 18:24 7:8,10 9:12 37:1,9 38:7,12 16:9,12,18 36:9 19:3,11,12 39:12 40:17,18 21:3,13,19 choosing 4:17 34:23 35:4 called 15:6 22:14,18,22 chose 40:6 38:24 45:13 18:21 23:3,9,13 24:5 chosen 40:7 Boblo 12:24 calls 35:2,20 24:7 34:9 Christopher body 44:3 cameras 39:3 36:17 37:13,18 28:18,19 29:16 Bolden 31:21,22 camp 4:24,25 5:2 37:25 38:3,6,9 31:1,2 31:25 32:6,13 canine 31:3,9 38:21,23 39:17 church 9:25 44:8 6/13/2013 Page 3 churches 13:5,7 24:14 41:17 Composition 6:16 28:23 citations 28:4 45:4 comprehensive correct 41:20 29:12 30:19 Command 23:21,23 29:25 47:14 citizens 6:6 Commander 3:16 computer 47:12 correction 8:1,6 7:12 9:13 3:17 9:11,12 concern 14:22,25 council 5:11,12 11:10 17:22 10:11,21 16:16 concerned 43:13 6:17 7:6 17:13 19:4 20:3 28:9 19:17 21:22 concerning 7:1 20:7 41:1,23 29:9 32:16 23:1 36:20 concerns 37:10 41:24 33:16,18 44:11 37:14,19,21 43:9 counts 30:17 45:9 38:16 39:18,21 concluded 45:25 county 17:18 city 6:15,17 7:6 Commanding 10:24 46:2 33:24 47:6,20 7:12 12:15 Commands 23:25 concludes 34:8 couple 5:5 13:6 18:19,23 19:4 24:4 condolences 8:20 43:11 19:19,21 20:7 Commencing 1:21 conducted 9:23 courage 29:5 22:12 23:17 Commission 6:5 30:14 31:10 court 4:4 33:3 32:19 36:12 6:13 7:11 conducting 31:4 33:10,11 40:7,8,8,25 17:18 41:17,23 conducts 29:25 courteous 26:14 41:1,2,9,23,23 42:18 47:21 Conference 17:24 cousin 40:1,12 civil 31:13 Commissioner confirmed 6:17 crash 21:25 22:1 Civilian 7:4 3:13,14 6:12 congratulate 22:7,20 Clark 12:4 42:9 7:17,25 14:21 19:10 44:18 Created 6:15 42:13 15:15,22 16:6 congratulations crime 12:9 14:9 classes 4:24 16:20 17:2 19:15 20:8 14:15,23 15:8 clean 18:6 20:14 21:11 26:3 27:4 18:20 22:25 clerks 33:10 45:20 28:15 29:17 25:1,5,6,8 close 14:12 Commissioners 30:23 31:17 27:23 28:7 45:13 1:2 2:4,9,11 32:20 34:4 29:1 closed 12:20 3:6,10 6:14,18 connected 30:8 crimes 29:23 14:6 15:7 7:21 8:8 17:9 consecutively 32:6 closing 25:14 19:3,12,13 6:19 Criminal 18:24 32:8 21:18,22 34:23 consider 13:10 20:24 31:19 coffee 13:15 35:4 41:1 considered 29:16 32:23 Coleman 4:1 45:24 considers 7:11 criminals 29:6 colleagues 23:5 commitment 19:7 consistent 27:15 30:5 32:5 30:4 33:15 19:22 29:9 consistently critical 13:17 42:5 32:12 26:13 crooked 15:20,21 Collective 23:16 Committee 25:10 construction crossing 11:24 combat 25:7 Communication 13:2,4 11:24,25 combined 12:13 35:3 consultation CSR 47:18 come 4:12,17 communities 18:4 6:23 CSR-7042 1:23 5:18,24,25 6:1 community 1:3,19 contact 36:3 culture 11:20 11:17 12:8 3:8 4:13,17 39:10 13:8 14:15 16:23,24 5:7,8 11:7,12 contained 23:15 curfew 10:13,15 21:6 24:8,20 14:9 17:5,13 continued 28:8 current 12:10 28:19 31:21 17:24 18:7,9 continues 18:20 23:15 35:5,9 37:2 18:11,15,18 28:3 currently 17:17 38:25 39:5 19:7,8,21 29:6 contributed 24:23 33:2 42:3,13 43:22 Company 5:1 18:10 C.E.R.T 17:22 44:1,4 17:16 contribution comes 42:17 complaints 7:1 19:20 44:7 D comfortable 23:7 complete 47:13 Cook 24:16 daily 27:3 32:3 coming 11:3 completes 4:8 cooperative Dan 4:3 6/13/2013 Page 4 dangerous 29:6 departmental discipline 7:3 E 32:5 33:9 disconnected earlier 15:25 date 8:1 10:13 Department's 40:14,14 early 18:12 daughter 20:23 31:5 41:20 discussed 38:14 27:22 37:1 35:17,24 40:2 dependable 27:22 discussion 21:16 earned 28:5 daughters 18:25 deserve 44:20 displayed 19:6 easily 33:20 Davis 3:24 35:11 deserves 30:21 district 3:7 east 9:20,25 35:12 36:17,22 deserving 21:4 10:24 12:14 Eastern 26:5 37:13,17,24,25 desk 5:3 16:22 17:21 echo 35:6 38:2,4,7,20,22 detail 28:6 24:20,23 25:8 Edward 39:24 40:18 detailed 32:7 25:12,16 26:6 40:1,6,6 day 4:24,24 5:2 details 37:15 27:7,10,11 effect 10:13,15 19:12,14 34:16 detained 14:11 42:24 43:3 42:2 34:16 39:11 Detectives 39:5 Districts 22:13 effected 27:15 43:23 39:7 43:1 29:11 days 37:4 determination District's 26:2 effective 33:7 deal 32:10 32:15 disturb 44:15 efficient 33:7 deals 41:18 Detroit 1:2,20 diversity 13:8 efforts 18:10 December 28:21 2:4,6 3:1 6:5 18:1 Elizabeth 1:23 39:3,12 6:6,14 7:12 document 22:1 47:8,18 decided 9:8 8:24 9:2,21 documentation Ella 8:25 9:15 decorations 5:8 10:1,4,5 15:6 24:4 Elliot 9:25 dedication 19:5 17:7,12 19:1,3 documented 24:1 EM 45:6 20:6 25:23 19:4,4,11,17 doing 5:16 20:13 email 39:13 27:19 31:15 19:20,22 20:2 23:25 27:14 emails 10:6 degree 27:2 20:4,7,19 21:1 43:15 45:2 Emergency 17:22 28:12 24:22 25:9,20 Domestic 32:25 42:1 Degrees 18:25 25:24 26:10,17 33:3,22 employee 33:21 delivered 12:22 27:8 28:20 Donakawski 4:3 43:19 demonstrate 29:10,21 31:23 donate 18:14 employees 7:3 26:16 31:24 32:16,17 donated 42:25 energy 45:5 demonstrated 32:18,19 33:1 donation 8:22 enforcement 32:2 26:19 27:15,18 35:12,13 36:13 9:2 32:5 33:24 29:4,9 32:9 37:3 40:2,9,23 Donna 35:12 engaged 33:14 demonstrates 41:3,10 45:9 Donnell 2:14 ensued 30:16 19:22 Detroit's 34:4 3:14 ensure 31:5 demonstration developed 30:7 doors 20:14 entails 21:25 25:21 devoted 43:12 Downtown 25:9,12 entertain 7:16 department 6:24 devotion 28:13 Drake 3:25 7:22 45:18 6:25 7:2,3,5 different 11:19 drawbridge 13:2 enthusiasm 26:16 7:13 10:4 12:4 38:13 42:3,5,8 Drive 15:19 28:5,10 13:21 19:1,5 differently drives 13:9 entities 33:23 19:18 20:20 41:22 driving 30:11 epidemic 36:11 24:10,22 25:20 difficult 36:3 due 13:2,3 15:13 Escape 30:12 25:25 26:10,12 diligence 25:23 43:13 especially 43:9 26:24 27:9 Directive 21:24 duties 6:14,22 Establish 6:22 28:21,25 29:10 22:24,24 26:13 28:13 esteem 20:3 29:21 31:24 Directives 21:7 29:3 33:14 ethnicity 12:7 32:18 33:1 23:2 34:2 evening 9:12 40:9 41:3,10 Director 4:1 7:4 duty 25:23 31:7 10:25 11:1 41:19 42:10 disciplinary 34:13 21:21 24:12 43:9 44:10,18 34:21 D-FAT 31:23 32:2 6/13/2013 Page 5

39:24,25 40:22 feedback 20:17 forms 22:5 given 28:7 39:6 43:5,6 feel 23:7 43:10 Fort 12:4 13:3 39:12 44:19 event 18:21 44:14 13:25 14:4 go 8:11 13:2,3 events 18:19 Fellows 8:22,23 15:5,19 15:17 34:12 everybody 11:16 9:2 forth 36:1 47:11 35:19 36:8,9,9 35:11 41:2 felony 14:10 forums 18:18 39:15 44:13,14 everybody's 26:17 27:16 forward 16:23 44:20 35:15 29:23 30:18 24:20 28:19 God 43:15,17 everyday 44:21 female 35:18 31:21 goes 13:7 18:12 everyone's 13:11 females 31:13 forwarded 10:3,6 34:2 example 18:22 fiercest 29:5 Francine 40:6 going 3:20 4:10 excellent 16:13 fifteen 36:25 Freeway 10:1 5:6,23 6:11 25:19 26:21 Final 7:2 freighters 12:21 15:8,11 16:19 33:8 find 40:10 41:4 12:25 17:7 20:16 exception 11:8 finest 34:4 Friday 43:25 21:5 23:9 exceptional 20:5 fire 12:4 14:6 front 3:19,25 30:25 33:14 excuse 38:11 firearms 26:18 4:2 5:3 12:17 37:19,21 41:8 Executive 7:7 fireworks 10:12 22:10 41:11 42:12,23 exemplary 31:16 first 4:19,21 Fugitive 31:23 45:3,7,8,18 34:1 18:13 22:20 32:18 Gonellas 16:3,11 exemplifies 32:3 23:4 24:18,18 full 47:13 Gonzales 16:21 exhibit 27:3 26:3,7 27:1,14 functions 33:14 16:23 17:3,8 exhibits 28:12 27:21 28:15 fund 8:20 17:10,11,14,16 experience 33:5 29:8,17 30:6 funeral 9:20 17:19 18:2,5,8 expires 47:21 31:9 32:15 43:24 18:17,20 19:6 explosive 31:10 35:6 further 11:14 19:11,15,19 expression 20:3 five 6:16,18,19 future 5:20 20:4,10 21:10 extra 15:13 30:9 31:10 21:15 33:15 37:4 G good 3:4,8,16,17 extremely 28:22 Flag 42:23 gained 27:12 6:2 8:22,23 42:7 flags 42:25 gather 37:22 9:2,12 10:25 fled 30:15 39:22 11:1,3,13,16 F Florida 36:2 gathered 30:3 14:4 20:15 faced 9:7 37:3 general 29:3 21:21 24:10,12 facilitated flow 33:6 Gene's 41:9 39:24,25 40:22 17:23 flowers 8:21,25 gentlemen 3:5 43:5,6 44:5,17 fact 43:8,13 44:7,8 46:1 graduated 17:14 faith 40:8,8 follow 37:20 geographic 28:7 18:24 20:22,23 familiar 12:21 38:19 geography 15:3 graffiti 13:10 13:1,25 14:1 following 29:11 15:13 grammar 23:19 familiarize 39:11 George 2:17 3:19 Grand 9:20 27:24 followup 37:23 3:23 granddaughter families 34:18 39:22 getting 20:17 20:22 37:5 34:19 food 11:12 16:1 41:8,9 42:10 gratitude 20:3 family 8:12 9:1 foot 30:15 girl 37:1,5 great 9:5 16:12 9:22 20:25 Ford 4:25 17:16 give 4:15 8:18 25:6 32:10 35:13,21 36:9 18:13 30:12 9:15 13:18 40:12 40:11,15 foregoing 47:9 14:7 16:24 Greeno 27:7,8,14 far 29:7 41:4 forfeiture 41:11 23:11 34:9 27:18,20 28:1 favor 7:20 8:7 forgotten 40:19 35:5 38:17 28:3,8,12,14 21:17 45:23 form 22:8 42:14 43:18,22 groomed 25:19 February 29:22 formal 9:13 44:6 group 18:5 6/13/2013 Page 6 groups 5:10 44:13 initiated 14:14 J guardians 10:15 honor 16:20 input 25:11 J 12:20 guidance 31:8 19:13 24:9 inside 43:20 Jana 27:7,8 guide 41:14 34:10 Inspector 10:18 28:14 guys 10:12 40:10 honored 20:25 10:21,23,23 January 24:22 41:5,13 honoring 17:10 11:2 15:24 26:15 21:10,14 20:1 37:21 Jefferson 15:20 H hope 4:20,21 38:16 Jerome 2:12 3:9 hall 18:18 5:19 34:15 instrumental Jesse 16:21 hand 16:25 hour 9:22 25:13 29:22 17:10,10 19:6 hanging 30:12 hours 45:1,1 intelligence 19:10,19 20:4 Hanson 4:4 house 4:22 8:15 30:2 21:10,14 happen 16:2 39:2,4,5,14 interested 18:9 Jessica 2:13 36:13 45:3 houses 14:6 international 3:13 happened 35:14 hurt 38:8 11:25 job 11:13 26:9 37:9 hurting 40:13 introduce 3:11 33:13,20 41:21 happy 3:6 18:23 3:20 10:18 join 10:8 43:2 I hard 14:9 15:3 introductions judges 33:9 28:22 idea 44:5 4:8 Julia 40:22 Headquarters identify 30:3 invalid 39:13 July 6:16 11:9 34:25 45:17 identifying 25:6 investigate 22:1 June 1:22 3:2 health 43:14 illegal 26:18 investigated 7:23 8:2 9:18 hear 21:6 35:8 image 26:23 14:13 30:20 9:19,23,24 heard 39:7,15 immediate 31:8 investigates 10:13,14 14:10 hearing 46:2 33:18 31:12 32:6 19:13 34:24 heart 9:25 20:12 immediately investigating 45:16 47:21 hearts 8:11 18:13 25:1 Justice 17:24 held 9:17,19,22 implementation investigation 18:25 20:24 34:24 45:15 22:5 21:25 22:4,7 juveniles 14:12 Hello 35:11 39:1 implemented 22:9 22:21 25:2,5 help 20:13 25:7 implementing 31:20 37:16 K 36:14,19 40:10 18:3 investigations keep 14:15 29:1 41:14 impose 7:2 22:2 25:13 36:3 44:17 helps 40:16 improve 18:10 32:23 keeps 32:4 hereinbefore improving 20:6 investigative Kennedy 14:3 47:11 incident 35:14 24:24 Kimberly 9:16 hesitation 29:15 incidents 27:25 Investigator kind 15:12 35:21 high 17:14 27:1 include 18:19 3:24 7:9 36:25 37:3 28:4,12 32:7,8 inclusion 18:1 investigators knew 39:5 33:19 36:9,11 increase 40:24 4:6,8 7:9 know 5:18 8:17 highest 19:8 44:25 invite 11:9 10:12 11:22 25:24 individuals 42:22 12:23 13:16 highly 19:6 30:20 35:9 invocation 5:25 14:3,8 16:2,2 27:12 28:11 information 9:10 6:8 16:3 17:3 23:4 hindered 15:11 9:15 10:7 14:8 involvement 34:14 35:18 historic 13:7 23:14 30:4,7 19:21 36:7,13,23 14:4 37:22 38:18,18 issuance 28:4 37:11 40:12 hold 21:7 39:22 40:17 issued 14:12 41:5,13,13,19 holding 23:24 infractions 27:17 29:12 42:4,4,6 43:15 home 9:20 36:10 31:14 30:19 31:13 43:16 45:1,2 36:24 37:2 infrastructures issues 25:4,7 knowledge 25:21 40:11 43:24 13:17 I75 9:25 15:5 6/13/2013 Page 7

29:3 33:16 31:8 37:1,4 Management 42:8 mic 6:1 known 12:3 33:17 live 5:10 36:2,2 Manager 4:2 42:1 Michigan 1:1,20 36:22 39:18 manner 26:14 2:6 3:1 8:24 knows 35:19 lived 18:15 31:7 32:7 9:3,21 10:1,5 43:16 lives 5:17 Manual 22:24 15:21 17:25 Koller 1:23 4:4 living 18:22 Marathon 13:24 47:4,20 47:8,18 local 11:13 15:2 Mike 5:14 located 9:20,24 March 26:15 30:6 mile 33:15 L 11:22 12:3,16 MAS 22:5 23:20 miles 13:4 L 19:23 14:5 17:15 23:22 24:4 minor 23:19 ladies 3:4 46:1 30:14 matter 36:15 minute 35:8 lady 40:1 location 12:2 Mayor 6:17,24 minutes 7:23 landmarks 12:15 28:7 7:5 41:25 misdemeanor languages 12:8 locations 13:19 ma'am 6:2,9 7:14 14:11 27:16,17 larcenies 25:14 13:20 24:11 36:18 29:11 law 32:5 33:24 Logan 8:12 9:4 38:6,9,9,21 missing 35:17,18 laws 28:25 9:15,16 10:9 39:17 40:4,21 35:19 36:7,21 layman 13:18 19:24 41:16 42:20 40:2 layout 5:15 Logan's 8:25 43:4 45:11 model 25:25 lead 5:25 16:20 Loletha 4:1 McKissic 3:16,17 mom 40:13 leader 32:1 longer 22:8 36:2 9:11,12 10:11 moment 10:9 leadership 20:5 look 13:1 23:6 10:21 16:16 12:20 29:6 looking 38:10 19:17 21:22 Monday 9:22,24 learned 8:14 Lori 11:14 36:20 37:14,21 monetary 8:22 leave 40:7 lot 5:6 12:19,19 39:18,21 9:1 led 6:8 13:10,13 14:3 mean 39:15 month 11:8 left 3:15 8:15 44:14 means 13:18 morale 28:3 45:3 36:23 love 8:17 20:11 mediation 25:4 morning 17:3 lessons 4:23 20:13,19 40:12 meet 25:3 45:7 37:1 let's 44:16 loved 18:15 meeting 1:3 3:6 mother 9:16 liaison 7:11 34:18,19 36:10 11:7 34:23 35:19 37:2 17:17 18:2 loving 43:11 42:14 43:14 motion 7:16,23 24:24 low 28:2,3 45:14,15,25 8:10 21:9,11 lieu 8:21,25 LT 11:16 14:25 meetings 6:20 45:18 Lieutenant 11:4 15:17 16:3,8 7:8 11:17 motivated 27:12 11:11,14 14:19 16:11 40:25 motivation 28:2 14:21 15:16,23 Lynem 26:7,11 meets 6:19 33:20 motor 4:25 17:16 21:5,21,22 Melvindale 18:4 18:19 25:15 22:16,19,23 M member 2:14 move 7:17,25 8:3 23:11,14 24:6 M 8:25 9:15 17:13,20,21,23 34:22 40:7 39:21 42:13 Mack 9:25 18:25 45:20 life 18:11 20:6 mail 12:22 members 3:12 moved 7:19 8:5 34:16 maintained 26:21 6:16 20:7 24:9 21:13 45:22 lifelong 17:11 maintaining 31:5 33:22 multiple 30:17 life-long 40:2 maintains 25:23 men 34:11 murals 13:10 limit 35:8 29:3 mention 16:1 Lincoln 15:18 major 23:18 mentioned 8:10 N 18:4 33:17 35:21,23 15:25 name 3:9 5:6 line 34:17 Makeover 18:19 merit 19:8 8:25 16:1,2 literally 34:16 making 25:11 met 43:10,11 35:6,11 38:2 little 8:19 30:18 44:16 meticulous 33:13 39:1 40:4 11:19 14:7 males 31:12 Mexican 16:4,6 names 39:6 6/13/2013 Page 8 narcotic 31:10 occur 25:15 orderly 26:22 patrolled 26:16 Narcotics 22:25 occurred 30:9 ordinances 27:17 patterns 14:24 National 17:24 October 26:12 organization 25:7 28:7 29:1 near 15:2 27:9 31:25 18:12 Patton 1:19 3:8 neat 25:18 26:22 office 3:15 4:2 Organized 22:25 4:13,17,20,25 28:1 9:14 10:4,6 organizing 18:5 5:7 necessary 7:10 25:4 28:3,21 Outer 15:19 pay 15:1,12 41:4 8:6 33:15 officer 4:3 5:14 outgoing 18:23 41:11 44:25 need 15:10 10:24 22:1 outside 20:18 paycheck 18:13 needed 31:6 24:16,19,21,24 outstanding peers 28:11 needs 31:8 44:15 25:2,8,9,17,22 16:21 20:5 33:18 neighbor 18:10 25:22 26:2,3,6 27:2 30:21 peewee 5:12 neighborhood 26:7,9,11 27:7 33:21 people 5:5,17 20:11 27:8,13,14,18 overview 23:12 12:8,24 18:6 neighborhoods 27:20,22 28:1 overwhelming 20:17 22:11 44:11 28:8,12,14,14 21:1 39:4,14 40:13 never 20:16 28:18,19 29:8 42:9 44:10,14 23:25 26:8 29:15,16,20,20 P perform 42:11 37:8 38:7 39:7 30:2,6,19,22 Packed 5:11 performance new 20:24 22:6 30:22 31:1,2 PAGE 1:16 33:20 23:21,23 24:1 31:16,20,22,25 paid 41:8,9 performed 26:13 45:4 32:6,13,20,23 42:11 period 23:22 newest 4:5,7 32:24 33:2,3 Pamela 3:24 26:15 43:8 nice 40:17,18 33:13,19,23 paper 22:8 permanent 21:15 night 18:19 45:7 34:1,6 36:4 parents 10:14 persistence 19:6 nine 4:24 Officers 9:13 park 12:17,18 person 39:3,9 normal 45:1 12:7,12 22:4 15:18 18:4,6 personal 38:18 normally 44:7 26:25 27:24 parks 14:2 personnel 3:25 north 30:10 44:19 part 21:15 6:6 7:4 23:21 Northeastern officials 41:1 participant 24:2 33:9 27:7,10,11 Oil 13:24 35:21 perspective Notary 47:19 okay 22:16,18 participated 41:20 noted 27:20 24:5,12 34:22 18:17 phone 35:20 36:4 notice 13:9 37:6,24 38:20 participation 37:5,8,12 38:1 notion 38:15 39:23 18:11 36:4 39:13 40:17,18 November 26:10 old 12:15,23 particular 15:1 photos 21:2 26:4 null 36:4 13:7 14:4 15:8 27:5 28:16 number 11:15 once 6:19 41:6 partner 26:7 29:18 30:24 13:8,9 28:4 ones 13:15 34:18 30:7,13 31:1 31:18 32:21 32:7,8 39:13 34:19 36:10 31:10 34:5 numbers 14:15 one's 13:3 partners 26:8 picture 19:16 numerous 12:7 ongoing 27:25 27:4 pictures 13:6 18:18 25:14 online 22:7,12 partnership 25:9 19:25 32:11 open 4:22 6:20 33:11 Pierce 11:4,11 opened 20:14 partnerships 11:15,16 14:25 O openly 30:4 19:8 15:17 16:3,8 oath 47:10 operating 13:14 pass 38:19 16:11 39:21 objection 7:20 operation 7:1 pastor 38:5 pile 17:8 8:7 21:16 33:6 pastries 16:5 piling 20:1 45:23 Operations 29:24 pastry 16:4 place 15:12 occasions 32:11 opposed 8:9 patient 40:20 20:15 23:17 occupants 30:15 Oral 35:2 patrol 31:6 25:12 41:25 6/13/2013 Page 9

47:11 pray 43:15,17 26:14,23 31:7 quarter 24:9,19 plan 15:12 prayer 6:7 32:16 25:18 26:3,8 Planning 21:23 prayers 8:11,14 professionalism 26:17,22 27:1 pleading 40:15 9:9 27:2 28:13 27:1,14,21 please 16:25 Precinct 10:19 32:3 28:15 29:8,17 24:15,20 28:19 10:22 11:3,9 proficient 29:2 29:17 30:6 31:21 35:5 11:20,21,23 profile 23:22 31:9,17 32:15 36:18 40:10 12:2,6,16 13:4 programs 4:23 32:20 34:8 42:5 43:2 13:6,14,17 18:3 question 15:24 pleased 3:7 14:5 17:15 projects 18:7 questions 5:2 PO 8:23,23 9:2 20:15 28:18 promotes 17:25 14:18 23:2 podium 4:12 21:6 29:2,19 30:1 promotions 6:25 quick 21:7 24:9 35:5 30:10,22 39:19 properly 7:19 point 11:18 Precincts 12:14 8:5 21:13 R 13:12 43:1 45:22 rain 10:13 police 1:2 2:4,8 precinct-wide property 29:14 raised 37:3 3:5,10 6:5,14 11:7 33:3 rate 41:1,6,7,17 7:2,3,11,13 prepares 7:4 prosecutors 41:22,23 42:17 10:4,5 12:13 preparing 24:25 33:10 42:17 18:2,9 19:1,5 presence 6:5 prosecutor's rates 40:24 41:3 19:11,13,18 present 2:16 25:3 41:18,21,25 20:20 24:21,22 3:24 19:18 proud 17:11 42:2,3,10 25:20,24 26:6 21:24 prove 40:9 reach 36:7 26:7,10,20 presentation proved 26:1 read 6:13 27:7,8,9,20 10:18 11:4,18 provide 39:22 ready 31:6 28:9,14,18,19 16:13 23:1 provided 7:10 real 36:11 28:20 29:13,20 34:8 42:15,24 providing 28:9 really 11:13 29:21 31:1,2 presented 20:2 pubinfo@detro... 44:20 31:20,22,24 43:1 10:7 rear 30:12 32:17,20,23,24 pretty 14:7 public 6:21 7:5 reassure 37:5 33:1,2 34:23 previously 17:19 10:7 12:3 receive 6:25 34:25 35:4 prior 23:1,24 26:19 27:19 32:13 36:4 37:9 40:9 27:24 47:19 received 18:13 41:3,10 43:9 priority 28:8 punctuation 30:7 44:10,18 45:16 privilege 4:18 23:20 recipient 17:4 policies 28:25 34:10 pursuit 30:15 24:18 33:17 probably 13:12 put 11:5 24:1,2 recognition policy 6:22 22:9 37:16 34:16 37:15 19:19,23 20:4 22:10 24:1 problem 15:8 p.m 1:21 3:3 32:19 Political 43:7 problems 27:25 9:18,18,19 recognize 16:21 population 13:5 35:22,22,23 10:16 11:10 28:14 34:15 Porter 4:1 procedure 22:4 34:25 45:16 recognized 26:8 portion 18:14 procedures 33:16 46:2 30:21 31:16 position 28:5 proceedings 4:3 P54338 2:2 34:3 positive 26:23 33:12 47:10,14 recommended 26:1 32:4 process 22:6 Q record 3:23 posses 15:7 23:18,20 24:3 qualification 15:15 40:5 possible 35:9 processing 33:11 33:21 recorder 35:7 post 28:4 producing 29:10 qualities 29:7 recording 4:3 posted 22:12 production 28:3 quality 18:11 recovered 26:18 potential 30:3 productive 27:13 20:6 27:15 29:13 Power 11:18 professional 28:2 recreation 4:18 6/13/2013 Page 10

22:10 19:19 35:12,13 S 26:5 27:6 reduce 14:9 40:3 Sacred 9:24 28:17 29:19 reduced 12:9 Resolution 17:9 sad 43:8 30:25 31:19 47:12 21:9,14 safe 36:10 32:22 34:7 reduction 29:23 resolve 7:1 safer 25:12 42:13,22 Refinery 13:24 resolved 19:2 safety 12:3 18:3 series 40:25 reflect 8:1 respected 25:9 18:10 25:10 seriously 20:1 26:23 25:10 28:11 Salisbury 31:1,2 serve 6:18,18 refreshments responding 26:20 Saturday 9:17 9:8 12:8 5:15 27:19 43:23,25 served 17:19 regard 41:8 response 17:22 saw 5:14 serves 7:7 17:17 regarding 9:15 39:10 saying 39:12 service 4:4 9:23 21:9 23:2 30:8 responsibilities Schaefer 13:25 18:21 19:7,21 regards 19:9 6:13 32:1 34:2 scholarships 5:1 27:2 28:6,9 23:4 40:24 responsibility school 17:15 29:13 32:12,16 regular 2:14 41:21 20:22 serviced 12:12 25:3 responsible 5:13 schools 14:2 services 42:9,11 regulations 6:23 23:25 31:4 screen 24:16 serving 3:12 9:5 25:20 rest 3:21 search 24:25 set 5:8 8:21 reinforcements restaurant 16:10 31:11 33:19 41:6,21 15:10 resulted 25:14 searches 31:10 41:22 47:11 relates 14:23 32:7 31:11,11 sets 41:18 42:16 retirement 9:6 Searcy 26:6,9 setup 5:14 relations 11:7 return 40:18 seat 5:18 seven 18:24 11:12 17:13 review 6:24,25 seated 3:25 4:1 sewage 13:21 18:9 7:3 21:24 4:7 shaky 36:25 relationship 22:11 27:23 second 9:18 11:8 shares 30:4 33:8 29:25 21:7 36:18 she'll 11:5 relative 29:1 reviewing 22:6 Secretary 2:17 38:17 39:22 reliability rich 11:20 3:19,22,23 7:7 shift 27:24 28:10 ride 36:12 7:8 23:8 shootings 30:9 reliable 25:18 right 3:14 10:17 section 45:13 show 8:20 11:4 28:23 12:17 13:16 Sector 17:21 11:19,20 13:7 remains 17:12 16:24 17:2 Security 25:10 showed 28:22 25:25 36:19 37:20 see 3:8 4:18,21 showing 27:22 remember 12:24 42:8 5:8 6:3 24:10 shown 44:3 Renee 5:24,24 River 12:18 24:16 45:3,6,8 sick 25:17 6:2 robberies 30:9 Seed 17:20 side 12:5,18 report 7:5 9:13 robbery 30:17 Seeing 45:12 15:2 37:10 Robert 4:2 31:20 seen 13:12 23:5 sight 14:1 reported 47:9 31:22 selected 26:2,25 sights 11:19 REPORTER 47:1 Roland 42:9 31:25 32:13 signed 19:11,23 Reporting 4:4 role 25:25 self-motivated 20:6 42:1 reports 27:23 Romeo 23:1 28:23 32:9 significantly 31:7 Room 34:25 Semma 40:22,22 42:10 Representing Roosevelt 12:17 42:7,19 silence 10:9,10 3:15 round 17:25 34:9 send 8:22 9:1 44:15 reputation 27:12 rules 6:22 25:20 10:2 sir 3:16 4:5,8,9 request 10:8 running 17:8 sent 39:13 6:4 16:14,18 require 32:10 runs 12:13 26:20 Sergeant 9:16 16:24 21:7,19 required 23:21 27:20 28:9 24:8,10,12 23:13 24:6 resident 17:11 29:13 sit 5:18 6/13/2013 Page 11 sitting 3:14,18 stay 21:8 sure 24:17 37:14 6:4,9,9 7:14 skills 25:5,21 stayed 36:24 38:13 9:4 10:11 11:2 slide 11:4 stays 28:24 surrounding 18:3 11:11 14:18,21 small 24:2 34:14 steadfastness suspects 30:3,8 15:22,23 16:12 Smith 43:5,7,7 18:22 30:11,14,16 16:13,18 19:10 somebody 40:16 stellar 29:4 31:12 32:8 20:10 21:1,4 son's 20:24 stenographically suspicious(sic) 21:19,20 22:22 soon 13:2,4 15:5 47:9 37:4 24:6,7,13 27:4 sorry 5:24 16:6 Stephens 24:8,10 sustainable 19:8 27:6 34:6,7,13 41:24 24:12 26:5 Swanson 9:20 34:17,18,20 sought 32:5 27:6 28:17 43:19 36:17 38:21 south 9:25 29:19 30:25 swim 4:23 39:17,23 40:20 Southwest 3:7 31:19 32:22 system 22:5 40:21 41:16 6:5 12:3 14:22 34:7 42:22 33:10 42:19,20 43:4 16:22 17:5,11 Stewart 4:6 44:16 45:9,11 17:13,20 20:19 stop 30:14 T 46:1 21:1 stops 14:14 table 3:12,18 thing 23:19 Southwestern strategies 25:7 17:25 23:9 things 24:2 10:24 12:13 Street 13:3 15:5 tables 5:9 37:14 38:11,12 speak 12:7 23:5 15:19 take 33:5 43:17 think 13:11,25 44:22 streets 20:18 taken 1:18 19:16 37:25 44:5 speaking 19:3 26:16 31:6 19:25 third 19:14 special 13:18 36:12 takes 10:15 thoughts 8:14 29:24 stress 44:9 18:23 9:9 44:21 specific 28:7 strives 28:25 talk 36:15 38:16 three 17:6,22 29:3 strong 29:9 talked 35:25 23:2 spell 35:7 strongly 26:1 talking 20:17 threshold 28:6 spirit 5:8 17:7 structure 15:3 Tamale 36:6 Thursday 1:22 19:22 20:2 subs 16:4 targets 13:20 7:23 34:24 spoil 37:19 substantial 22:3 tasks 33:5 45:16 spoke 35:24 37:4 successfully Taylor 2:13 3:13 tickets 14:12 38:1 13:14 5:24,25 6:2,4 Tiffany 4:6 sponsored 4:25 suggest 44:1 6:8,10,15 7:18 time 3:11 4:10 square 13:4 Suite 10:5 8:4,11 14:20 4:15,19 5:23 SS 47:5 summer 4:23 21:12 45:21 6:11 7:15 9:11 staff 3:21 7:7 summits 18:18 team 17:22 31:23 9:14 10:8 7:10 11:12 Sunday 9:19 32:1,2,18 16:17,19,24 12:6 supervision 40:13 18:21 21:5 stand 6:6 13:15 32:10 47:13 teen 5:10 22:15 23:4,22 36:18 supervisor 4:11 telegram 10:3 24:7,13 25:17 standard 33:19 4:13,16 31:9 tell 36:20 37:2 28:2 35:2,8,10 41:7 supervisors 37:9 44:22 38:25 43:10,17 standards 25:24 28:12 33:18 Telway's 13:16 43:17,18 45:7 standing 44:3 supplied 15:25 ten 31:12 45:10 47:10 started 17:2 support 7:10,18 terms 6:18 11:25 timely 33:11 18:14 8:6 21:12 12:9 13:18 today 4:19 5:9 State 1:1 28:25 34:18 45:21 terrorist 13:20 5:13,18 17:6,8 47:4 supported 7:20 13:20 21:23 34:22 States 42:23 8:4 21:14 testimony 47:10 today's 7:16 station 12:16,18 45:23 thank 3:22 4:9 token 34:14 statistics 12:9 supposed 22:1 4:12,14,16 5:4 told 42:8 29:11 36:23 41:7,12 5:5,19,22 6:2 tomorrow 4:22 6/13/2013 Page 12

42:23 43:2 22:23 27:21 view 13:23 Washington 2:2 tonight 3:7,12 31:10,11 35:8 Violence 32:25 34:21 3:15,21 9:9 39:4,14 33:4 wasn't 37:6 16:1 24:14 type 11:17 36:14 violent 29:23,25 water 13:21,21 34:3 37:3 33:22 13:23 tonight's 24:15 typically 11:18 visit 20:16 way 8:15 15:11 total 17:8 25:22 visitations 9:17 15:18 20:18 touch 27:23 void 36:5 44:2 tow 40:24 41:1,6 U volume 12:1 Wayne 14:5 17:18 41:17,22,25 UD10 22:6 volunteer 18:20 47:6,20 42:17,17 unasked 33:6 28:8 ways 15:4 Towers 40:23 understand 34:15 vote 14:4 wear 34:11 Towing 41:9,9 36:11 43:20 website 22:12 town 16:4,7 understanding W Weed 17:20 18:18 25:19 41:2,6 wait 23:8 week 4:24 6:19 tracked 31:12 42:16 waiting 44:4 20:21 23:6 trade 12:1 understood 9:6 45:4 weekly 31:4 traffic 14:14 unfortunately walking 11:5 weeks 6:20 27:21 22:7 27:17 41:18 Walks 18:20 weight 9:5 30:14 uniform 29:12 wall 13:10 welcome 3:5 21:3 train 12:15,18 30:19 34:12 want 3:11 4:12 38:23 trainer 31:3 unit 24:24 31:3 4:14 5:4 9:4 Wells 36:7 training 31:4 33:3,7 11:11 22:11 went 39:11 40:25 transcription United 42:23 24:8 36:6,13 Wescott 12:20,23 47:12,14 units 33:23 36:19 37:11,15 Western 17:14 transfer 23:18 update 23:22 37:18 41:4,11 we'll 7:22 8:18 24:3 38:17 42:14 41:13 42:22 9:11 34:22 transferred updated 28:24 44:6,14,25 38:19 23:23 use 25:17 wanted 30:5 we're 4:23 5:16 transfers 22:24 utilizes 30:2 wanting 44:24 5:17,23 12:3 23:4,15 Warfield 2:12 12:10,14 14:8 transition 8:13 V 3:4,9,18 4:9 14:14 15:11 8:15 vacation 27:21 5:22 6:9 7:14 16:19 17:7 travel 15:18 valuable 25:11 7:19,22 8:3,5 23:9 30:25 travels 12:22 32:17 8:9 10:20 11:1 38:10,10 40:14 treatment 13:22 Varges 20:14 14:18 15:23 40:19 41:7,12 13:23 various 12:7 16:9,12,18 42:23,24 tremendous 29:4 33:9 21:3,13,19 we've 8:14 11:3 tried 11:18 vehicle 30:13,15 22:14,18,22 12:9 14:10 39:10 vehicles 14:13 23:3,9,13 24:5 22:2 26:8 trouble 20:16 25:15 30:20 24:7 34:9 38:14 42:8 true 5:7 47:13 31:13 36:17 37:13,18 White 2:14 3:14 try 15:1 36:19 veteran 25:22 37:25 38:3,3,6 7:17,25 14:21 38:12 Vice 8:4 14:20 38:9,21,23 15:15,22 16:6 trying 14:9,14 21:12 22:25 39:17,25 40:4 16:20 17:2 Tuesday 11:8 45:21 40:21 41:16 21:11 45:20 turn 9:11 Vice-Chairperson 42:12,20 43:4 wife 8:13 9:16 twelve 5:12 2:13 3:13 6:12 43:6 45:11,22 43:10 27:16 6:15 7:18 45:25 Williamson 4:11 two 5:10 9:17 Vicky 10:21 warrants 24:25 4:16 5:23 15:4 17:6,21 victims 33:16 24:25 wish 8:16,20 18:24 22:16,19 videos 39:14 Warren 15:18 35:3 38:24 6/13/2013 Page 13 wishes 44:12 42:24 43:2 204.1 21:24 5 17:21 wishing 45:12 100 26:20 21st 26:10 52 6:20 women 34:11 1000 9:25 22 31:13 54 17:12 wonderful 8:13 106,000 12:12 2301 1:18 596-1835 2:7 Woodmere 1:18 11:00 9:24 24th 10:13 33:1 Woodward 43:3 12 14:2 249 29:12 6 words 4:15 44:11 12th 27:10 25th 10:14 6th 7:23 8:2 work 16:21 20:18 12,000 14:13,13 250 27:19 26:12 27:9 27:15 28:6 13 3:2 5:11 257 30:20 35:14,18,24 42:9 43:25 13th 1:22 19:13 26th 29:22 6:00 9:18 10:16 44:17 36:1 27th 30:6 10:16 11:10 worked 17:16 1300 2:5 10:5 29 26:18 43:23 44:1 working 24:23 34:25 45:17 29th 28:21 6:30 44:1 27:3 28:22 135 14:11 6:41 1:21 3:3 33:8 40:19 14 15:20 3 63 30:20 worth 29:13 14.4 13:4 3,000 14:12 69 14:12 worthy 19:23 15 37:11 3,284 14:14 32:19 15th 9:18 3:00 34:25 45:16 7 wrong 41:20 16 29:11 30 30:19 7th 37:2 16th 9:19 300 10:5 7:30 17:4 Y 17 9:23,24 10:14 31st 31:25 7:51 46:2 year 6:18,20 14:2 313 2:7 70,529 13:5 12:10,11,12 17th 24:22 328A 35:1 7042 47:18 15:7 178 27:17 34 13:5 7310 43:3 years 6:19 17:12 18 5:11 27:16 36 29:12,23 17:17,21,23 1958 18:16 30:18 8 18:12 23:17 19703 36:22 367 14:10 806 9:20 29:7 32:15 1974 6:16 37 17:17 89 31:13 36:25 37:11 1993 33:2 38 26:17 year-to-date 1995 24:22 9 14:10 1997 31:25 4 9:00 9:18,19 Yost 10:18,21,23 4 11:15 13:8,9 93 31:13 10:24 11:2 2 4th 10:19,22 15:25 20:1 2 39:11 11:3,20,21,23 37:21 38:16 2nd 12:14 14:10 12:2,14,16 young 5:17 18:6 28:18 29:2 13:6,14,17 40:1 20th 34:24 45:16 14:5 17:15 2001 29:22 20:15 29:19 Z 2004 28:21 30:1,10,22 Zumba 4:23 2008 26:11,12 39:18 ZUMIGA 39:20,23 27:9 401.2 22:24 Zuniga 39:1,2 2009 27:10 42 31:12 Z-U-N-I-G-A 39:2 2012 35:14,18,24 4444 9:2 36:2 44444 8:23,24 $ 2013 1:22 3:2 47 1:16 $54,500 29:13 7:24 8:2 9:18 48207 9:21 10:1 9:23,24 19:13 48209 1:20 1 24:19 26:15 48217 14:4 15:1 1 1:16 47:21 29:17 30:6 48226 2:6 10:6 1st 6:16 34:24 45:16 48244 8:24 9:3 1,000 13:13 2018 47:21 10:00 9:19,23 203.7 22:25 5