Middle East Fertility Society Journal Vol. 9, No. 3, 2004 © Copyright Middle East Fertility Society

OPINION

Assisted hatching: routine or selective application in IVF

Bassam A. Elhelw, MRCOG, MFFP Moustafa M. El Sadek, MD Khaled M. El Nomrosy, MRCOG

Middle East Fertility Center, Dokki, Egypt, and Department of Obstetrics and Gynecology, Cairo University, Cairo, Egypt

ABSTRACT

The implantation rate of apparently normal embryos in IVF/ICSI programs has been reported to be 10% to 15% for day 2 or day 3 transfers and 23% to 25% for blastocyst transfers. The hatching process of blastocysts is still not completely understood. In vitro culture of mammalian embryos alters the architecture of their zona pellucida; in vitro derived embryos have thicker zonas, especially the inner layer of zona pellucida. A high proportion of morphologically normal blastocysts have hatching difficulties, and 54% fail to hatch after 8 days of in vitro culture. Assisted hatching was developed as a remedy for this type of implantation failure. Several techniques for assisted hatching have been introduced over the years including; drilling a hole in the zona pellucida, three dimensional partial zona dissection, thinning the zona pellucida, or total removal of the zona. These techniques can be performed chemically, mechanically, by using a LASER beam or a piezoelectric method. Although routine performance of assisted hatching on all embryos in IVF/ICSI patients is neither scientific nor appropriate, there is convincing evidence in the literature that assisted hatching increases the implantation capability of some of the embryos. The proposed indications for assisted hatching are advanced maternal age (≥37 years), elevated basal FSH of women, 2 or more previously failed IVF attempts, embryos with thick zona pellucida (>15 μm), abnormal or poor embryo morphology and retarded developmental rate of the embryo. Key words: Assisted hatching, Zona pellucida, implantation, LASER, Zona drilling, Tyrode's solution

The ability of an embryo to develop and The hatching process of blastocysts is still not implant primarily relates to the quality of completely understood. The zona pellucida (ZP), originating gametes and intrinsic characteristics of which is a glycoprotein coat surrounding the embryo, the embryo, such as its chromosomal constitution begins to form in early antral follicles by the and the quality of its cytoplasm. However, some contributions of both oocyte and granulosa cells. proportion of euploid embryos with full After fertilization, zona pellucida is essential for developmental potential fail to implant because of maintaining the integrity of the pre-compacted hatching difficulties. It has been reported that embryo and prevents dispersion of blastomeres implantation rate per in IVF/ICSI during early cleavage before the junctional programs is 10% to 15% for day 2 or day 3 transfers complexes between blastomeres occur prior to and 23% to 25% for blastocyst transfers (1). compaction. Before hatching, the blastocyst undergoes a series of contractions and expansions

Correspondence and reprint requests: Dr. Bassam Elhelw, that cause a decrease in the thickness of the zona until Director, Middle East Fertility Center, 11 Shooting club St., it becomes almost invisible. In mice, the zona Dokki, Egypt. Email: [email protected] pellucida is digested by the synthesis of the enzyme

198 El Helw et al. Assisted hatching: routine or selective application in IVF MEFSJ trypsin in localized sites of trophectoderm, whereas a blastomere number, fragmentation rates and similar enzyme may be produced over the whole of maternal age) (12). its surface by human blastocysts (2-5). Expansion of Several techniques for assisted hatching have the blastocyst seems not to be the predominant been introduced over the years including; drilling a factor in shedding of the zona pellucida (3,4). hole in the zona pellucida (12,13,17-23), Three Pulsation of the blastocyst during the hatching Dimensional Partial Zona Dissection (24), thinning process was suggested to be nonphysiologic (6), the zona pellucida (25,26), or total removal of the and the collapse of blastocyst cavity may reflect zona (27,28). hatching difficulties of the embryo (6,7). In These techniques can be performed chemically successful hatching, the movement of the embryo (using acid Tyrode's solution), (12,18,21-23,27), plays a crucial role during shedding of the zona mechanically (using special tapered micropipettes) pellucida (8). Treatment of blastocysts with (13,17,20), or by using a LASER beam (19,29). A cytochalasin B, an inhibitor of actin filament piezoelectric technique has also been described (30). polymerization, reversibly blocked the process of The human zona pellucida is composed of inner hatching. and outer layers (31), and superficial chemical In vitro culture of mammalian embryos alters zona thinning failed to enhance embryonic the architecture of their zona pellucida; in vitro implantation (25). A full breaching or sufficient derived embryos have thicker zonas, especially the thinning of the inner layer of the ZP is necessary inner layer of zona pellucida (9). A high proportion for efficient assisted hatching. However, natural of morphologically normal blastocysts have zona thinning and expansion do not occur in hatching difficulties, and 54% fail to hatch after 8 blastocysts with drilling treatment, because inner days of in vitro culture (7). Several investigators pressure exerted on the ZP is released from the believe that the failure of hatching is due mainly to drilling site (32). Moreover, there is a possibility abnormal changes in the quality of the ZP, such as that an extrusion of the blastomere or whole thickening or hardening with poor elasticity embryo from a large slit may be induced by (10,11). contractions of the reproductive tract. In contrast, These conditions are observed in embryos from smaller holes of the ZP trap embryos during the patients ≥ 37 years old and in those with elevated hatching process and prevent their implantation serum FSH concentrations (12,13) and are induced (32,33). by a long-term exposure of embryos to suboptimal Taken together, these findings indicated that in vitro culture conditions (14,15). Recently, assisted hatching can exert both facilitating and embryos obtained from in-vitro maturated oocytes deleterious effects on subsequent embryonic show thickened or hardened ZP due to prolonged development depending on several factors, such as exposure to in vitro culture conditions. zona thickness, the area of thinning treatment, the Assisted hatching was developed as a remedy size of the hole created, mechanical damage to the for this type of implantation failure. In 1989, embryo by manipulation, chemical damage by acid Cohen and associates reported an increased solution, and the technical skill of the operator. For implantation rate following mechanical opening example, an inappropriately small hole may cause partial zona dissection (PZD) of the zona pellucida the embryo to become trapped during hatching, in embryos resulting from IVF (16). These creation of trophoectodermal vesicles, or strangling investigators postulated that the opening of the of the intracellular matrix, which was suggested as zona might enhance the subsequent hatching the possible reason for the higher rate monozygotic process. Cohen et al. subsequently published a twinning after assisted hatching (34). randomized, prospective trial of selected assisted There is still no clear-cut consensus over which hatching 72 hours post-retrieval (zona drilling with technique of assisted hatching will be more efficient acidified Tyrode’s medium), which suggested an to increase the implantation rates. Drawbacks to improvement in implantation rates when the mechanical zona opening are its technical procedure was selectively applied to embryos with complexity, the inability to produce reproducible a poor prognosis (based on zona thickness, uniform openings, and the possibility of embryo

Vol. 9, No. 3, 2004 El Helw et al. Assisted hatching: routine or selective application in IVF 199 damage (35). Also the use of the acidic Tyrode's with the recommendations of The Practice solution cannot produce standardized uniform Committee of the American Society for holes. It was suggested that acidic Tyrode's Reproductive Medicine after reviewing the solution is detrimental to human oocytes and different published reports on the role of assisted embryos, especially to blastomeres adjacent to the hatching in IVF suggesting that assisted hatching opened area (32). However, by using the infrared may be clinically useful and that individual ART 1.48-µm diode laser it is feasible to open the zona programs should evaluate their own patient even in largely expanded blastocysts without populations in order to determine which subgroups visible blastocyst damage. The safety of the 1.48- may benefit from the procedure. The routine or µm diode laser beam has been evaluated in mouse universal performance of assisted hatching in the and human oocytes and zygotes (29). Laser- treatment of all IVF patients appears, at this point, assisted microdissection of the ZP can be done to be unwarranted. with high precision and repeatability with no negative impact on in vitro embryo development. The technique is easy to perform and very effective REFERENCES with regard to the overall time requirement and can be performed in a sterile environment without any 1. Huisman GJ, Fauser BC, Eijkemans MJ, Pieters MH. additional micromanipulations. Implantation rates after in vitro fertilization and transfer of a maximum of two embryos that have undergone three The routine or universal performance of assisted to five days in culture. Fertil Steril 2000;73:117–22. hatching on all embryos in IVF/ICSI patients is 2. Gordon JW, Dapunt U. A new mouse model for embryos neither scientific nor appropriate. Randomized trials with a hatching deficiency and its use to elucidate the of assisted hatching on all embryos without any mechanism of blastocyst hatching. Reprod Anim Res 1993;59:1296–301. selection, revealed that there is no difference in the 3. Montag M, Koll B, Holmes P, van der Ven H. implantation and pregnancy rates between the Significance of the number of embryonic cells and the treatment and control groups (17,36). In a recently state of the zona pellucida for hatching of mouse published meta-analysis of randomized controlled blastocysts in vitro versus in vivo. Biol Reprod studies on assisted hatching for all patients treated 2000;62:1738–44. 4. Gonzales DS, Bavister BD. Zona pellucida escape by with IVF/ICSI (13 studies out of 165 fitted the hamster blastocysts in vitro is delayed and selection criteria); the results of the meta-analysis morphologically different compared with zona escape in could not be accepted because of the heterogeneity of vivo. Biol Reprod 1995;52:470–80. the studies which may be due to the different 5. Sawada H, Yamazaki K, Hoshi M. Trypsin-like hatching protease from mouse embryos: evidence for the presence techniques used or due to different patient in culture medium and its enzymatic properties. J Exp populations studied (37). Zool 1990;25:83–7. On the other hand, there is convincing evidence in 6. Checiu I, Checiu M. There are no in vivo pulsations of the literature that assisted hatching may increase the mouse blastocysts. Morphol Embryol 1996;42:147–54. implantation capability of some of the embryos. The 7. Fong CY, Bongso A, Sathananthan H, Ho J, Ng SC. Ultrastructural observations of enzymatically treated proposed indications for assisted hatching are human blastocysts: zona-free blastocyst transfer and advanced maternal age (≥37 years), elevated basal rescue of blastocysts with hatching difficulties. Hum FSH of women and 2 or more previously failed IVF Reprod 2001;16:540–6. attempts, embryos with thick zona pellucida (>15 8. Cheon YP, Gye MC, Kim CH, Kang BM, Chang YS, Kim SR, et al. Role of actin filaments in the hatching μm), abnormal or poor embryo morphology, process of mouse blastocyst. Zygote 1999;7:123-9. cytoplasmic fragmentation and retarded 9. Silva CP, Silva V, Kommineni K, Keefe D. Effect of in developmental rate (12,13,38-42). Sallam et al. vitro culture of mammalian embryos on the architecture concluded after conducting a series of sensitivity of the zona pellucida. Biol Bull 1997;193:235–6. 10. Cohen J. Assisted hatching of human embryos. J In Vitro analyses, that assisted hatching improves the Fert Embryo Transf 1991;8:179 –90. , implantation rate and the ongoing 11. Edwards RG, Fishel SB, Cohen J, Fehilly CB, Purdy JM, pregnancy rate significantly for patients with poor Salter JM, et al. Factors influencing the success of in prognosis treated with IVF/ICSI, particularly those vitro fertilization for alleviating human . J In with two or more previous failures (37). This concurs Vitro Fert Embryo Transfer 1984;1:3–23. 12. Cohen J, Alikani M, Trowbridge J, Rosenwacks Z.

200 El Helw et al. Assisted hatching: routine or selective application in IVF MEFSJ Implantation enhancement by selective assisted hatching 27. Mansour RT, Rhodes CA, Aboulghar MA, Serour GI, using zona drilling of human embryos with poor Kamal A: Transfer of zona-free embryos improves outcome prognosis. Hum Reprod 1992;7:685–91. in poor prognosis patients: A prospective randomized 13. Stein A, Rufas O, Amit S, Avrech O, Pinkas H, Ovadia J, et controlled study. Hum Reprod 2000;15:1061-1064 al. Assisted hatching by partial zona dissection of human 28. Fong CY, Bongso A, Ng SC, Anandakumar C, Trounson pre-embryos in patients with recurrent implantation failure A, Ratnam SS. Ongoing normal pregnancy after transfer of after in vitro fertilization. Fertil Steril 1995;63:838–41. zona-free blastocysts: implications for embryo transfer in 14. Cohen J, Elsner C, Kort H, Malter H, Massey J, Mayer the human. Hum Reprod 1997;12:557-60. MP, et al. Impairment of the hatching process following 29. Germond M, Rink K, Nocera M, Delacre´taz G, Senn A, IVF in the human and improvement of implantation by Fakan S. Microdissection of mouse and human zona assisting hatching using micromanipulation. Hum Reprod pellucida using a 1.48-µm diode laser beam: efficacy and 1990;5:7–13. safety of the procedure. Fertil Steril 1995;64:604–11. 15. Zhang X, Rutledge J, Armstrong DT. Studies on zona 30. Nakayama T, Fujiwara H, Yamada S, Tastumi K, Honda hardening in rat oocytes that are matured in vitro in a T, Fujii S: Clinical application of a new assisted hatching serum-free medium. Mol Reprod Dev 1991;28:292– 6. method using a piezo-micromanipulator for 16. Cohen J, Inge KL, Suzman M, Wiker SR, Wright G. morphologically low-quality embryos in poor-prognosis Videocinematography of fresh and cryopreserved embryos: infertile patients. Fertil Steril 1999;71:1014-1018 a retrospective analysis of embryonic morphology and 31. Gordon JW, Grunfeld L, Garrisi G, Talansky BE, Richards implantation. Fertil Steril 1989;51:820–7. C, Laufer N. Fertilization of human oocytes by sperm from 17. Hellebaut S, De Sutter P, Dozortsev D, Onghena A, Qian infertile male after zona pellucida drilling. Fertil Steril C, Dhont M: Does assisted hatching improve implantation 1988;50:68 –73. rates after in vitro fertilization or intracytoplasmic sperm 32. Malter HE, Cohen J. Blastocyst formation and hatching in injection in all patients? A prospective randomized study. J vitro following zona drilling of mouse and human Assist Reprod Genet 1996;13:19–22 embryos. Gamete Res 1989; 24:67– 80. 18. Tucker MJ, Morton PC, Wright G, Ingargiola PE, Sweitzer 33. Garrisi G, Talansky BE, Grunfeld L, Sapira V, Gordon CL, Elsner CW, Mitchell-Leef DE, Massey JB: JW. Clinical evaluation of three approaches to Enhancement of outcome from intracytoplasmic sperm micromanipulation-assisted fertilization. Fertil Steril injection: Does coculture or assisted hatching improve 1990;54:671–7. implantation rates? Hum Reprod 1996;11:2434–2437 34. Schieve LA, Meikle SF, Peterson HB, Jeng G, Burnett 19. Antinori S, Selman HA, Caffa B, Panci C, Dani GL, NM, Wilcox LS. Does assisted hatching pose a risk for Versaci C: Zona opening of human embryos using a non- monozygotic twinning in pregnancies conceived through in contact UV laser for assisted hatching in patients with poor vitro fertilization? Fertil Steril 2000;74: 288–94. prognosis of pregnancy. Hum Reprod 1996;11:2488–2492 35. Vajta G, Holm P, Greve T, Callesen H. Survival and 20. Chao KH, Chen SU, Chen HF, Wu MY, Yang YS, Ho development of bovine blastocysts produced in vitro after HN: Assisted hatching increases the implantation and assisted hatching, vitrification and in-straw direct pregnancy rate of in vitro fertilization (IVF)-embryo rehydration. J Reprod Fertil 1997;111:65–70. transfer (ET), but not that of IVF-tubal ET in patients with 36. The practice committee of the American Society for repeated IVF failures. Fertil Steril 1997;67:904–908 Reproductive Medicine. The role of assisted hatching in in 21. Hurst BS, Tucker KE, Awoniyi CA, Schlaff WD: Assisted vitro fertilization: a review of the literature. Fertil Steril hatching does not enhance IVF success in good-prognosis 2004;82, Suppl. 1, 164-5. patients. J Assist Reprod Genet 1998;15(2):62–64 37. Sallam HN., Sadek S, Agameya A. Assisted Hatching-A 22. Magli MC, Gianaroli L, Ferraretti AP, Fortini D, Aicardi Meta-Analysis of Randomized Controlled Trials. J Assist G, Montanaro N: Rescue of implantation potential in Reprod Genet 2003;20:332-42. embryos with poor prognosis by assisted zona hatching. 38. Demirel LC, Evirgen O, and Al-Hasani S. The role of Hum Reprod 1998;13:1331–1335 assisted hatching in human IVF. Middle East Fert Soc J 23. Lanzendorf SE, Nehchiri F, Mayer JF, Oehninger S, 2002;7:6-12. Muasher SJ: Prospective, randomized, double-blind study 39. Parikh FR, Kamat SA, Nadkarni S, Arawandekar D, Parikh for the evaluation of assisted hatching in patients with RM. Assisted hatching in an in vitro fertilization advanced maternal age. Hum Reprod 1998;13:409-413 programme. J Reprod Fertil Suppl 1996;50:121–5. 24. Cieslak J, Ivakhnenko V, Wolf G, Sheleg S, Verlinsky Y. 40. Montag M, van der Ven H. Laser-assisted hatching in Three-dimensional partial zona dissection for assisted reproduction. Croat Med J 1999;40:398–403. preimplantation genetic diagnosis and assisted hatching. 41. Zakova J, Ventruba P, Adler J, Travnik P, Nemcova S. Fertil Steril 1999; 71: 308-313. Assisted hatching-a useful micromanipulation technique in 25. Tucker MJ, Luecke NM, Wiker SR, Wright G: Chemical women after repeated failure of embryo transfer. Ceska removal of the outside of the zona pellucida of day 3 Gynekol 1996;61:6-9. human embryos has no impact on implantation rate. J 42. Antinori S, Panci C, Selman HA, Caffa B, Dani G, Versaci Assist Reprod Genet 1993;10:187–191 C. Zona thinning with the use of laser: a new approach to 26. Antinori S, Panci C, Selman HA, Caffa B, Dani G, Versaci assisted hatching in humans. Hum Reprod 1996;11:590-4. C: Zona thinning with the use of laser: A new approach to assisted hatching in humans. Hum Reprod 1996;11:590– 594 Received on July 21, 2004; revised and accepted on October 12, 2004

Vol. 9, No. 3, 2004 El Helw et al. Assisted hatching: routine or selective application in IVF 201