CORE Metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk
Provided by CERN Document Server
Determining the Redshift of Reionization From the Sp ectra of High{Redshift
Sources
1;2 1
Zoltan Haiman and Abraham Lo eb
ABSTRACT
The redshift at which the universe was reionized is currently unknown. We
examine the optimal strategy for extracting this redshift, z , from the sp ectra of
reion
early sources. For a source lo cated at a redshift z beyond but close to reionization,
s
32
(1 + z ) < (1 + z ) < (1 + z ), the Gunn{Peterson trough splits into disjoint
reion s reion
27
Lyman , , and p ossibly higher Lyman series troughs, with some transmitted ux
in b etween these troughs. We show that although the transmitted ux is suppressed
considerably by the dense Ly forest after reionization, it is still detectable for
suciently bright sources and can b e used to infer the reionization redshift. The Next
Generation Space Telescop e will reach the sp ectroscopic sensitivity required for the
detection of such sources.
Subject headings: cosmology: theory { quasars: absorption lines { galaxies: formation
{intergalactic medium { radiative transfer
Submitted to The Astrophysical Journal, July 1998
1. Intro duction
The standard Big Bang mo del predicts that the primeval plasma recombined and b ecame
predominantly neutral as the universe co oled b elow a temp erature of several thousand degrees at
3
a redshift z 10 (Peebles 1968). Indeed, the recent detection of Cosmic Microwave Background
(CMB) anisotropies rules out a fully ionized intergalactic medium (IGM) beyond z 300 (Scott,
Silk & White 1995). However, the lack of a Gunn{Peterson trough (GP, Gunn & Peterson 1965)
in the sp ectra of high{redshift quasars (Schneider, Schmidt & Gunn 1991) and galaxies (Franx et
<
al. 1997) implies that the IGM is highly ionized at low redshifts, z 5. Taken together, these
< <
two observations indicate that the IGM was reionized in the redshift interval 5 z 300.
reion
The epoch of reionization marks the end of the \dark ages" during which the cosmic radiation
background was dominated by the ever-fading CMB at all wavelengths. During this ep o ch, ionized
1
Astronomy Department, Harvard University, 60 Garden Street, Cambridge, MA 02138, USA
2
NASA/Fermilab Astrophysics Center, Fermi National Accelerator Lab oratory,P.O. Box 500, Batavia, IL 60510, USA
{2 {
hydrogen (HI I) started to o ccupy again most of the volume of the universe. Most likely, the phase
transition from HI to HI I was triggered by the emission from the rst stars and quasars in the
universe (see Lo eb 1998, and references therein).
The characteristic distance b etween the sources that ionized the universe was much smaller
than the Hubble scale, and the overlap of the HI I regions surrounding these sources was completed
on a timescale much shorter than the Hubble time. The resulting reionization redshift, z ,
reion
is therefore sharply de ned and serves as an imp ortant milestone in the thermal history of the
universe. Measurement of this parameter would also constrain the small-scale p ower of primordial
density uctuations that pro duced the rst ob jects. Theoretical mo dels and three{dimensional
< <
simulations predict that reionization o ccurs at 7 z 20, just b eyond the horizon of current
reion
observations (Haiman & Lo eb 1997, 1998; Gnedin & Ostriker 1997). Forthcoming instruments,
suchasthe Space Infrared Telescope Facility (SIRTF), and the Next Generation Space Telescope
(NGST) are exp ected to reach the sensitivity required for the detection of sources beyond the
reionization redshift. It is therefore timely to ask: how could one infer z from the observed
reion
sp ectra of these sources?
The sp ectrum of a source at a redshift z > z should show a GP trough due to
s reion
absorption by the neutral IGM at wavelengths shorter than the lo cal Ly resonance at the
source, < (1 + z ). By itself, the detection of sucha trough would not uniquely establish
s
obs
the fact that the source is lo cated beyond z , since the lack of any observed ux could be
reion
equally caused by (i) ionized regions with some residual neutral fraction, (ii) individual damp ed
Ly absorb ers, or (iii) line blanketing from lower column densityLy forest absorb ers (see, e.g.
the sp ectrum of a z =5:34 galaxy taken by Dey et al. 1998). An alternative approach prop osed
by Miralda-Escude (1998) is to study the detailed shap e of the damping wing of the GP trough.
Although a measurement of this shap e could ideally determine the optical depth of the absorbing
HI slab between the source redshift and reionization, it is also likely to be compromised by
contaminating e ects such as: (i) redshift distortions due to p eculiar velo cities; (ii) uncertainties
in the absorption pro le due to the unknown intrinsic shap e of the Ly emission line from the
source; (iii) ionization of the IGM in the vicinity of the source due to the source emission; and (iv)
the existence of a damp ed Ly absorb er outside or inside the source.
In this pap er we consider a di erent approach for measuring z . Our metho d relies on the
reion
existence of some transmitted ux b etween the Ly and Ly absorption troughs in the sp ectra of
sources which are lo cated just b eyond the reionization redshift. For such sources, the GP troughs
due to di erent Lyman series resonances do not necessarily overlap, and the transmitted ux
between these troughs is only a ected by the p ost-reionization Ly forest. In x2, we simulate the
absorption by the dense Ly forest (or \Ly jungle") and demonstrate that the transmitted ux
features are detectable. In x3, we estimate the numb er of sources which are suciently brightto
allow detection of these features with NGST. Finally, x4 summarizes the main conclusions of this
work.
{3 {
2. Sp ectra of High Redshift Sources
The phase transition from HI to HI I o ccurs almost simultaneously throughout the IGM
volume, when the expanding HI I regions around the separate ionizing sources overlap (Arons &
Wingert 1972). This pro cess is nearly instantaneous (Haiman & Lo eb 1998; HL98) and de nes
a corresp onding redshift, z . However, at z each individual HI I region could still have
overlap overlap
a non{negligible Ly optical depth due to its residual HI fraction. The GP trough from the
uniform IGM disapp ears only at a somewhat later redshift, z , when the average Ly optical
reion
depth of the smo oth IGM drops b elow unity. (We distinguish b etween this GP absorption and the
absorption pro duced due to IGM clumpiness by the p ost-reionization Ly forest). In this pap er,
we assume that the delaybetween z and z is small and set z = z , based on the
reion reion
overlap overlap
following reasoning.
4
The Ly optical depth across a stationary HI I sphere is as large as 10 (Osterbro ck 1974),
but cosmological HI I regions are much thinner b ecause of the cosmological redshifting of the
Ly photons away from resonance. If z 7 and the HI I regions are driven by quasars or
overlap
4 8
star{clusters in Cold Dark Matter halos of virial temp erature of 10 K(M 1:5 10 M ),
halo
then the typical prop er radius of an HI I region is R 0:05 Mp c (HL98). When two such
HI I