Plagiarism Domenech, a Staff Writer and “I Know That Charges of Plagia- Writing,” Mencarini Said
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
U.S. Postage Paid at Williamsburg, Va. REVIEWS: Fashion faux pas to avoid for spring, page 13 SPORTS: Variety: Women’s club synchronized Campus band advances in swimming places 10th in mtvU competition, page 11 nationals, page 15 MARCH 31, 2006 VOL.95, NO.46 THE STUDENT NEWSPAPER OF THE COLLEGE OF WILLIAM AND MARY SINCE 1911 http://flathat.wm.edu Former student accused of plagiarism Domenech, a staff writer and “I know that charges of plagia- writing,” Mencarini said. “I canʼt permission to do a college-specific columnist for The Flat Hat from fall rism are serious. While I am not a think of any circumstances where version of his classic piece on par- 1999 to fall 2000, was accused of journalist, I have, myself, written anybody would have done that or tying,” Domenech wrote on Red- plagiarizing at least 10 pieces dur- more than one thing that has been that would have happened.” State. “He granted permission, the ing his tenure, and several others plagiarized in the past,” Domenech Dan Miller, reviews editor for piece was cleared with my editors that were published after he left the wrote in his RedState rebuttal. The Flat Hat from 1999 to 2000, also at the paper and it ran as inspired by College without graduating in May In the posting, Domenech denied refuted Domenechʼs claim. OʼRourkeʼs original.” of 2002. the allegations of plagiarism and “I have never personally improp- Mencarini said that he could In his rebuttal to the allegations of said that editors at The Flat Hat were erly inserted any material into a re- not recall Domenech clearing an plagiarism posted March 24 on the responsible for the fact that several view at The Flat Hat,” Miller said. OʼRourke-inspired column with him conservative weblog Redstate.com, of his reviews articles and opinions “I echo Steveʼs sentiment in that that or any other editor. which he co-founded, Domenech columns had passages that were I canʼt imagine anyone else at the “I donʼt remember any instance JONATHAN SEIDEN ✦ THE FLAT HAT said that he was referred to the Col- similar or identical to pieces by other paper at the time who would have specifically where he said anything. I Dean of Admission Henry Broad- legeʼs Honor Council regarding the authors. done so.” donʼt even know who P.J. OʼRourke dus said most revisions were small. FILE PHOTO ✦ THE FLAT HAT accuracy of an article about liberal Domenech said that he once Similarities were first found is,” Mencarini said. Former staff writer for The Flat Hat Ben Domenech in 1999. protests during a visit of newly-se- caught an editor of The Flat Hat in- between a Nov. 19, 1999 column The March 25 online edition of lected Chancellor Henry Kissinger. serting a line into his article that was written by Domenech and writer The New York Times reported that SAT score BY CHASE JOHNSON & ANDY ZAHN However, Domenech also states taken from another article and not P.J. OʼRourkeʼs novel, “Modern OʼRourke said that he had never giv- FLAT HAT VARIETY EDITOR & NEWS EDITOR that he was exonerated of the charge. appropriately cited. Steve Mencari- Manners.” Domenech said in his en Domenech permission to adapt There is no evidence to suggest that ni, editor of The Flat Hat from 1999 RedState rebuttal that he received his piece. blunder Ben Domenech, hired last week Domenech was coerced to leave the to 2000, said that he was surprised to OʼRourkeʼs permission to adapt a Domenech does not credit by Washingtonpost.com to author a College by the Honor Council. Dean hear the allegations. chapter of the novel into a College- OʼRourke with any portion of his conservative weblog entitled “Red of Students Patricia Volp said that “Iʼm fairly confident with the themed column. Nov. 19, 1999 column, “Party affects 47 America,” resigned last Friday after- the Honor Council cannot discuss staff that we had at the time; they “[The truth is that I had met P.J. See PLAGIARISM ✦ page 4 noon amid allegations of plagiarism. past cases. would not enter anything into his at a Republican event and asked his applicants Timeline of Domenech’s Flat Hat involvement and alleged plagiarism March 26: The Flat Hat re- August 27: Domenechʼs October 27: The last instance of May: Domenech March 23: A webloger March 24: Domenech ports that 10 of Domenechʼs first article for The Flat Hat Domenechʼs suspected Flat Hat plagairism, leaves the College ofmakes the first allegation resigns from Washing- 35 articles appear to have Admissions office is published. “Not on the campaign trail,” is published. his own accord. of plagiarism. tonpost.com. been copied. says it changed 1999 2000 2002 2006 no decisions August: Domenech October 22: Domenechʼs first Flat Hat December 8: “Faults with The March 21 (12:00 a.m.): March 24 (11:15 p.m.): Domenech admits in a post enters the College as article later suspected of plagiarism, “Pitt, Flat Hat,” a letter to the editor, is Domenechʼs Washington Post we- on RedState.org to using other writersʼ work without BY BRIAN MAHONEY a freshman. Norton, Pick ʻFight,ʼ” is published. Domenechʼs final Flat Hat submission. blog, Red America, is launched. attribution and apologizes to his former editors. FLAT HAT ASST. NEWS EDITOR GRAPHIC BY JONATHAN SEIDEN ✦ THE FLAT HAT Earlier this month, the College Board announced that over 4,000 Students high school students nationwide INSIDE THE GARDENS HOME RUN received incorrect SAT results due to scanning problems on last claim city Octoberʼs test. In every reported case, the errors resulted in a de- crease of the studentʼs true score. voter bias In total, 47 applicants to the Col- lege were affected by the error, with the largest grade discrepancy Voter registrar at 170 points. “[A] technical processing mat- says students, ter affected a very small percent- age of October 2005 SAT test tak- Nichol wrong ers,” a March 17 announcement on the College Boardʼs website said. “As a result, approximately BY AUSTIN WRIGHT 4,000 students (0.8 percent of the FLAT HAT ASST. NEWS EDITOR SAT Reasoning Test takers who tested during that administration) In a March 21 e-mail to students, did not receive credit for some President Gene Nichol criticized correct answers; therefore, their limitations on student voter registra- scores are higher than originally tion and voiced support for the Stu- reported.” dent Assemblyʼs efforts to increase A later announcement on col- student voting in Williamsburg. legeboard.com said that a rescan “As I have said many times, in of over 495,000 tests March 23 my judgment, the barriers placed, discovered an additional 375 er- in recent years, in the path of resi- rors, increasing the total number dential student voting here are inap- of incorrect results to 4,411. propriate and unconstitutional,” he Before the announcement was wrote. “I am working with members made public, a College Board of the General Assembly, as are vari- JONATHAN SEIDEN ✦ THE FLAT HAT representative notified Dean of ous student leaders, to seek legisla- Freshman Josh Cromwell swings at a pitch, trying for a home run, while freshman Sarah Aviles catches during sorority Phi Muʼs Home Undergraduate Admissions Henry Run Derby in the Sunken Gardens yesterday. The proceeds from the event will go to support the Childrenʼs Miracle Network charity. tive change.” See APPLICANTS ✦ page 3 Williamsburg General Regis- trar Dave Andrews, a member of the Voter Registrars Association of Virginia, said that in a meeting ear- Student Assembly overrides Scofield budget veto lier this year he told Nichol that he would be glad to meet with him to BY KATIE PHOTIADIS However, Lowe was disappointed current rules, abstaining votes serve discuss the issue and come up with THE FLAT HAT by the Williamsburg voter registrarʼs as nays. The current system says more consistent guidelines for stu- response. that in order to truly abstain, a voter dent voter registration. Andrews At their meeting Tuesday, the “Basically, weʼre trying to get would have to physically leave the said he is disappointed that Nichol Student Assembly outlined problems as many students registered as pos- room and be counted as absent. The made such a strong statement to concerning the initiative to increase sible,” he said. “Studentʼs shouldnʼt amendment would allow senators to students without ever attempting to student voter registration, overrode have the type of barriers that are in abstain without leaving the room. contact him. SA President junior Ryan Scofieldʼs place. The registrar has cut down 180 Sophomore Sen. Brett Phillips According to Andrews, Nichol veto of the budget, proposed a bill degrees on its precedent for off-cam- opposed the amendment. is incorrect in his assumptions. to change voting pus students. However, sophomore Sen. Cait Andrews said that, in order to reg- procedures and “Even if you donʼt believe Two weeks Smith countered his objection, say- ister, students must prove that they passed a bill sup- in global warming, like me, ago, students ing that if everyone abstained, it have domicile in Williamsburg and porting Student you should still vote for this were register- would be “irresponsible on the part intend to stay. He said Nicholʼs an- Environmental ing … now of the people voting.” nouncement that all students should Action Coalitionʼs bill ... Itʼs commonsense stu- they would be “I donʼt even know why this is in be allowed to vote in Williamsburg campus improve- dent-life wise.” denied.” debate,” she added. implies that all students should be ment initiative. — JOE LUPPINO-ESPOSITO, The senate “The way weʼve been using ab- CLASS OF 2008 SENATOR given domicile status. Senior Sen- ✦ voted 14-1- stentions is kind of like saying no in “Heʼs made a big leap there,” ate Chair Luther 0 to override a polite way.