Agenda Reports Pack (Public) 17/11/2010, 18.00
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Public Document Pack Sustainable Communities Overview and Scrutiny Committee Date: Wednesday, 17 November 2010 Time: 6.00 pm Venue: Committee Room 1 - Wallasey Town Hall Contact Officer: Brian Ellis Tel: 0151 691 8491 e-mail: [email protected] Website: http://www.wirral.gov.uk AGENDA 1. DECLARATIONS OF INTEREST/PARTY WHIP Members are asked to consider whether they have personal or prejudicial interests in connection with any item(s) on this agenda and, if so, to declare them and state what they are. Members are reminded that they should also declare, pursuant to paragraph 18 of the Overview and Scrutiny Procedure Rules, whether they are subject to a party whip in connection with any item(s) to be considered and, if so, to declare it and state the nature of the whipping arrangement. 2. MINUTES (Pages 1 - 8) To receive the minutes of the meeting held on 14 September, 2010. 3. HIGHWAYS AND TRAFFIC REPRESENTATION PANEL - MINUTES The minutes of the meeting of the Highways and Traffic Representation Panel on 8 November, 2010 will be circulated separately. 4. ARROWE PARK HOSPITAL TRAVEL PLAN (Pages 9 - 142) 5. OBJECTIONS TO TRAFFIC SIGNAL JUNCTION IMPROVEMENT - UPTON ROAD/NOCTORUM AVENUE, UPTON (Pages 143 - 148) 6. ROAD SAFETY - REDUCING DEATH AND SERIOUS INJURY ON THE ROADS (Pages 149 - 154) 7. GREEN SPECIFICATION AND RENEWABLE ENERGY GENERATION BY THE COUNCIL (Pages 155 - 172) 8. PROTECTING THE VULNERABLE FROM DOORSTEP CRIME (Pages 173 - 184) 9. FOOD SAFETY AND NUTRITION (Pages 185 - 190) 10. DOG FOULING (Pages 191 - 196) 11. SECOND QUARTER PERFORMANCE REPORT 2010/11 (Pages 197 - 218) 12. UPDATED WORK PROGRAMME 2010/11 (Pages 219 - 224) 13. FORWARD PLAN The Forward Plan for the period November 2010 to February 2011 has now been published on the Council’s intranet/website. Members are invited to review the Plan prior to the meeting in order for the Committee to consider, having regard to the Committee’s work programme, whether scrutiny should take place of any items contained within the Plan and, if so, how it could be done within relevant timescales and resources. 14. DECISIONS TAKEN UNDER DELEGATED POWERS (Pages 225 - 226) 15. SITE VISITS - UPDATE Members’ views are requested on suitable dates for the above. 16. ANY OTHER URGENT BUSINESS APPROVED BY THE CHAIR To consider any other business that the Chair accepts as being urgent. Public Document Pack Agenda Item 2 !"# $ !(&) %& ! (*+ !"' * %& # ,,& )(& ! ' -* ./ &0+0 1 0 ' $ 002 ! $3 &*% !4$ $!2 &0 ' 3$ 5440 ( 001 0 0 $ $0 ''2602 . % $ )0 ( ! &' $ ' 2 (4M42 .8 %$)0 (!&' $ '3 004 9 ( R +' & ) ) 4$426 R;< Page 1 $ # $ ( +' 40 '' $ ; $ 2 ($+ '' $ ,' 60"' $$$'0 '4 ' $$ $$ 02 / ($+'';$ +'$"( & $ ' 4$ $2 %$ $ ;' $ 4 44'"0%4$%4 0 $$'0 02 8 64$$ $$' $' + ( ) 4 45440 0 $'2 # &R;'' '$ 4, = 9 "0 %4 $ %4 0 % $ 4 $$ 0 +' ' 0 00 +$2 (4M $ 42 & R +'&) ) 4$42 .> ?.9.@8@ ,%< 5 % !+ 60+ &' 6 + A' ' (&' '$ *='& 4' 2 &!+< $0 $ 4400;0 0+2 $ 44 0 4 $$ '' + 0 ; $ 0+0 R0020 $ <$'4' ' $ 0 0 '$ 0+2 Page 2 ! '$0 4 4<4 0 4 0 0''2 !' ' ' '2 & %< ; $ & ' R ' ' $ &1 A4 $+ $ 9 40 $ '$ 2 )( 0 +&%<'$ 9 ' $ 0 '' $440 +0' 0 9' $ '2 + +$ $ 0$$$0 2&%<' 2 &+ $(&' ' 0 $ 0 0 $ $ $ 0 2 0 1 4$'$'''44 2 +&%<$'2 0 $ 4'2 (4M 2 & %< ' + $ '2 .. ?> @>@ &"* 060+&' ' 0 ; $ '' 4 $ '' 4 0 $ 1 ' $ $ 0 &R 02 < 4'4$40 0+' $4 '2 0 0 0+ 0 0 ''0+ ' ' + $ 2 Page 3 & " $$ '0 & 4 &' $ ''0'4' $$ 4$''0+20 $ $ 0 2 +&*$'2 0 '' $ 0 '' 4 $42+$$ '$ 'R $'0+0 02 (4M &*+$ 2 $ $'$ $0+$ 0 $''4 0 4'2 .3 ?> @>@ %$ 4 ''$,08(40 $'0A'' 42 ,0 8 (40 0 0 < ) 5' ' + < 0 ;4 ;4 $ 0 $' <2#''' $ ' 4 + ' 0 4 $ 42 (40 $ $+'$$O'< P2 (40$ '$'$ 0 0 ' 0 4' 4 $ 4' 4 $ ; 2 $4$< $0 $ (40 ' '$ 2 04 '0'$+00 04$$2 (40 $ 0 ' 0 '' ! < $ 2 (40%4$!0 !@, $O $4 204 0 + 1 '42P (4M Page 4 6$( 2 (; $ $ ; ,0 8 (40 $ '$2 .D ? > 3@ @D % $ 4 $ 4 '< $,040 $ $ 0+'4$$' 4 $2 &6 ('&'$ '4 ' ' E 4 4 ; 4 0 E ' '4 'E $4 4'$ 0 6'A2 &6 ;$' 9 4$'0+' 9 ; $$0+ 9 $0 9 $ (4M&6+$ 2 3 %$)0 (!&' $$ &*% !''$ 4'$ & & *&' '2 (4M 2 3 &R 40 0 ; '' & * % !$4&(? "2 (4 M ' $ 4 & 5 2 3 % $ 4 ' $ 4 1 ' + ) Q(*R? R 00 R @ 6# 3> $*R)!!'2 Page 5 0; ' '' 1''**(! ! <!$ 2 # ;$'' + $ %< 4 0002!'$ 4 ''A'15'2 #0$'& $&(#0 0 4'' 0 ;$$'4R'2 #04* O 6 $ ' $ 4 *90 Q (R 1+) 2 A 4 1 Q (R 1 ' + $ 12P #04 &) $$0' ' O,4040'&(#$' & $0 4$'' 004$$42P 0 . 0 D (4D M 6 $ ' $ 4 *90 Q (R 1+) 2 A 4 1 Q (R 1 ' + $ 12 3/ * $ 0002 3 %$ 4 440$ '' $ @ + 1004 5440 4'$; $! Page 6 2! < 4$ $0 $$;<4 ;2 # $30 0' 30@24 $' @ 1 0/ 0' 04' 1 ++0 4 002 #$4 • !0 ' ' $0'$ • *R( $&?( 4 '$4* 44 '$2 • 4$.DG>8D $@& 4$.28G>8 4; 4D.G$ 0 'DDG; 0 4'+$80+'2( 4D> $ $$#3D $/ G$42 • *R$,?' +$ ' $ @ 0 '<'' 2 • ? $H4$ $' +42 • * $0 ' & '4*0 $'0' 42 $'$$'0$ ++4'14$ 042! ' 140 (' 9 0 '$ 4 $ 4 $ ' 0 ' 2 A R ' 0 4 0< 40 ''0'40% 2 4 9 ,4 ' ! ' 2 0 14 $!/ '' 0+ % 0 0+ $2% $ 0; ' 0'2 &8/1/ 00$ 5 2 Page 7 % $ 0$$'9$$'$'$!D. / $$ $ 4 0 0 $ & '2 +' $ 0 ' 9 $ $ 0 !' 2 % $' 0+ 4 ' !R $ 0 +4'2 (4M 2 38 % $ 4 $' 0 ! 4 $ %' $ 0 '$ $2 (4M 2 Page 8 Agenda Item 4 WIRRAL COUNCIL SUSTAINABLE COMMUNITIES OVERVIEW AND SCRUTINY COMMITTEE – 17 NOVEMBER 2010 REPORT OF THE DIRECTOR OF TECHNICAL SERVICES WIRRAL UNIVERSITY TEACHING HOSPITALS (WUTH) NHS FOUNDATION TRUST - TRAVEL PLAN REVIEW 2010 1.0 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY 1.1 This report presents the Wirral University Teaching Hospital (WUTH) NHS Foundation Trust’s Travel Plan Review 2010. This is the fourth annual review since the original Travel Plan was implemented as part of the Planning Approval for car parking provision at Arrowe Park Hospital in March 2006. The Travel Plan review details progress to date and an action plan for the coming year including a number of proposed amendments to the plan. 1.2 The report recommends that Members note the contents of the report and attachments and endorse the Travel Plan Review 2010 and the Traffic Management and Parking Policy Report. It is also recommended that in future the reporting of the Travel Plan Review is undertaken on a bi- annual basis to committee whilst reporting an update to the action plan on an annual basis to officers. 2.0 BACKGROUND 2.1 WUTH originally submitted a Travel Plan in support of its planning application to increase the on-site car parking provision at Arrowe Park Hospital in 2005. This eventually became an integral part of the overall scheme through a Section 106 Agreement. The original Travel Plan was developed following negotiation and coordination with WUTH, the Council’s Sustainable Transport Co-ordinator and Merseyside TravelWise who continue to provide on-going support and advice. The Plan covers both Arrowe Park Hospital and Clatterbridge Hospital and aims to reduce the levels of travel generated by the hospitals and sets out the Trust’s aspirations for reducing the use of single occupancy private cars as the mode of choice when travelling to the hospitals. 2.2 WUTH as one of the largest employers in Wirral can make a major contribution to Wirral’s commitment to develop and implement a sustainable transport strategy, and indeed to the delivery of the objectives set out in the Merseyside Local Transport Plan 2006-2011. The Travel Plan also supports other national and local polices such as encouraging healthy lifestyles and the reduction in obesity through increased exercise. Page 9 2.3 For reference, a site plan of the Arrowe Park Hospital and car parks is attached in Appendix 1 . 3.0 TRAVEL PLAN REVIEW 2010 3.1 The main aims of the review of the Travel Plan are: • To provide an update on the Travel Plan implementation • To demonstrate what has been achieved since the last review • To identify and make changes to the plan • To review future actions and target dates 3.2 WUTH commissioned Mott MacDonald to undertake a review of the Travel Plan and the associated Traffic Management and Parking Policy, this review has been undertaken in consultation with the Councils Sustainable Transport Coordinator. Copies of the Travel Plan Review 2010, Appendix 2, and Traffic Management and Parking Policy Report, Appendix 3, are attached and form the main part of this report. 3.3 In summary the review includes: § The results of a staff and patient/visitor travel survey and confirms that future surveys will be undertaken every two years. § Highlights key achievements and progress on delivery of the previous action plan. § A breakdown of the costs of delivering the travel plan and a proposal that public parking charges are increased in line with the increases in charges in other hospitals and public car parks in Wirral since 2005. It also proposes that in future parking charges are increased periodically in line with inflation or the increase in parking charges in Wirral Council car parks, subject to coin of the realm limitations.