The Whole As a Result of Its Parts: Assembly in Aaron Copland's Score for the Red Pony
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
THE WHOLE AS A RESULT OF ITS PARTS: ASSEMBLY IN AARON COPLAND’S SCORE FOR THE RED PONY William Lawrence McGinney, B.M. Thesis Prepared for the Degree of MASTER OF MUSIC UNIVERSITY OF NORTH TEXAS May 2003 APPROVED: John Michael Cooper, Major Professor Bernardo Illari, Committee Member Mark McKnight, Committee Member Margaret Notley, M.M. Committee Chair Lester Brothers, Chair, Division of Music History, Theory, and Ethnomusicology Hildegard Froehlich, Acting Director, Graduate Studies College of Music James C. Scott, Dean, College of Music C. Neal Tate, Dean, Robert B. Toulouse School of Graduate Studies McGinney, William Lawrence, The Whole as a Result of Its Parts: Assembly in Aaron Copland’s Score for The Red Pony, Master of Music (Musicology), May 2003, 178 pp., 60 musical examples, 24 figures, 3 facsimiles, references, 28 titles. Aaron Copland’s music for The Red Pony (1948-49), based on John Steinbeck’s story collection, is probably the best known of his film scores. The effectiveness of The Red Pony score stems from Copland’s belief that film music should be subordinate to the film it accompanies. Copland composed The Red Pony score using his self-described method of “assembly,” augmenting this process with devices to synchronize the music with the picture. Examination of archival sources shows how the score reflects the acknowledged influence of Igor Stravinsky, the needs of the film medium, and the plot of The Red Pony specifically. Despite Copland’s modern style characteristics, the music functions much like a conventional Hollywood film score. Copyright 2003 By William Lawrence McGinney ii ACKNOWLEGEMENTS The author wishes to acknowledge the following individuals for their assistance in the production of this study: Mr. James Kendrick and the Aaron Copland Fund for Music for their generous permission allowing me to examine the Copland materials and to reproduce the included score examples; Elizabeth H. Auman of the Library of Congress, Music Division, for all of her enthusiastic assistance and cooperation; Dr. Michael Cooper, my major professor, for his guidance during the course of this undertaking; Drs. Bernardo Illari and Mark McKnight, members of my thesis committee, for their helpful comments and insights; and Dr. Margaret Notley, chair of the departmental thesis committee, for all of her encouragement. I would also like to extend my deepest thanks to my parents for their support, and to my wife, Stacey, for her understanding, patience, and love. iii TABLE OF CONTENTS Page LIST OF MUSICAL EXAMPLES . v LIST OF FIGURES. viiI LIST OF FACSIMILES . x INTRODUCTION . 1 Chapter I. GENESIS AND STORY OF THE RED PONY . 13 II. SOURCES FOR THE SCORE OF THE RED PONY . 23 III. A CLOSE EXAMINATION OF THE CUES PRESENT IN THE FIRST HALF OF THE RED PONY . .32 IV. A CLOSE EXAMINATION OF THE CUES PRESENT IN THE SECOND HALF OF THE RED PONY. .92 V. THE RELATIONSHIP BETWEEN THE MUSIC AND THE NARRATIVE IN THE RED PONY . .132 VI. REASSEMBLY OF THE RED PONY FOR THE CONCERT STAGE . 158 APPENDIX: A BRIEF OVERVIEW OF THE STEPS IN SCORING A MOTION PICTURE . .172 REFERENCE LIST. .176 iv LIST OF MUSICAL EXAMPLES All musical examples reproduced with permission by the Aaron Copland Fund for Music, Inc., copyright holder. Example Page 3-1. Recurring Themes in The Red Pony. 35 3-2. M100 “Prelude and Main Title” mm. 1-5 . 37 3-3. M100 “Prelude and Main Title” mm. 6-18 . 38 3-4. M100 “Prelude and Main Title” mm. 26-37 . 39 3-5. M100 “Prelude and Main Title” mm. 51-59 . 40 3-6. Melodic Fragments in “Morning on the Ranch” . 41 3-7. M101 “Morning on the Ranch” mm. 1-5 . .43 3-8. M102 “Walk to the Bunkhouse, Pt I” mm. 1-12 . 46 3-9. M102A “Walk to the Bunkhouse, Pt II” mm. 17-32 . .46 3-10. M102 “Walk to the Bunkhouse, Pt I” mm 21-23 . .47 3-11. M201 “March Dream, Pt I” mm. 1-6 . 49 3-12. M201A “March Dream, Pt II” mm. 1-12 . .50 3-13. M201A “March Dream, Pt II” mm. 41-46 . .51 3-14. M201A “March Dream, Pt II” mm. 69-76 . .52 3-15. M202 “Intro to Circus Dream” mm 6-17 . .55 3-16. M300 “Circus Music, Pt I” mm. 25-33 . .55 3-17. M300 “Circus Music, Pt I” mm. 40-48, with overlap to M301A “Circus Music, Pt V” . .56 v Example 3-18. M300A “Circus Music, Pt II” mm. 1-18 . 58 3-19. M300B “Circus Music, Pt III” mm. 1-42 . 60 3-20. M302 “The Boring Dinner” mm. 1-12 . 62 3-21. M302 “The Boring Dinner” mm. 23-32 . 63 3-22. M400 “The Gift” mm. 1-40 . .65 3-23. M400 “The Gift” mm. 55-62 . .67 3-24. M400 “The Gift” mm. 67-77 . .67 3-25. M400 “The Gift” mm. 82-85 . 68 3-26. M401 “Tom’s Friends” mm. 1-17 . .70 3-27. M401 “Tom’s Friends” mm. 47-51. 71 3-28. M401 “Tom’s Friends” mm. 57-68 . .71 3-29. M401 “Tom’s Friends” mm. 83-94 . .73 3-30. M500 “Grandfather’s Story” mm. 1-13 . .76 3-31. M500 “Grandfather’s Story” mm. 30-43 . .76 3-32. M603 “Morning Training” mm. 1-9 . 79 3-33. M603 “Morning Training” mm. 19-24 . 79 3-34. M603 “Morning Training” mm. 27-41 . 80 3-35. M603 “Morning Training” mm. 42-48 . 81 3-36. M603 “Morning Training” mm. 49-57 . 82 3-37. M700 “Prelude to Tom’s Indecision” mm. 1-11 . .84 3-38. M701 “Tom’s Indecision” mm. 1-24 . .85 3-39. M701 “Tom’s Indecision” mm. 28-38 . .86 vi Example 3-40. M701 “Tom’s Indecision” mm. 46-50 . .87 3-41. M701 “Tom’s Indecision” mm. 54-77 . .87 4-1. M702 “The Sick Pony” mm. 1-9 . .95 4-2. M702 “The Sick Pony” mm. 11-27 . .96 4-3. M800 “The Sick Pony” mm. 1-10 . .97 4-4. M801 “At the Fireside” mm. 1-18 . .100 4-5. M802 “Strangles, Pt I” mm. 1-24 . 101 4-6. M802 “Strangles, Pt I” mm. 36-43 . 103 4-7. M900 “Strangles, Pt II” mm. 1-19 . .104 4-8. M901 “The Operation, Pt I” mm. 1-9 . 107 4-9. M901 “The Operation, Pt I” mm. 14-22 . 107 4-10. M901 “The Operation, Pt I” mm. 23-43 . 108 4-11. M901A “The Operation, Pt II” mm. 1-5 . 109 4-12. Cell Types in “Buzzard Fight . .111 4-13. M1001 “Buzzard Fight, Pt I” mm. 40-51 . 114 4-14. M1001A “Buzzard Fight, Pt II” mm. 46-48 . 115 4-15. M1001B “Buzzard Fight, Pt III” mm. 1-6 . .118 4-16. M1100 “Tom Readjusted, Pt II” mm. 1-10 . ..