DOCSLIB.ORG

The Struggle for Perfection Continued from Page 84

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
The Struggle for Perfection Continued from Page 84 The Struggle for Perfection Continued from page 84 of La Traviata under the baton of Tullio Serafin flits by the microphone. Everything is solemn and (at one time given as a bonus with Capitol GCR everyone seems very much in earnest. Dealing with 7221 or SGCR 7221) seems tame. Apart from a those recitatives, whose contour Toscanini shaped so rather pointless argument at (rather than with) a skillfully, Karajan asks for contrast above all, es- luckless clarinetist, the disc is largely made up of pecially between the staccato notes and the plain uneventful Verdi accompaniments, over which Sera - ones: "Es muss ein grösserer Unterschied zwischen fin's falsetto solfège rapidly palls. The same opera, dem Staccato and dem anderen sein, die einen sind however, can be heard as prepared by another, and zu verwaschen and die anderen viel zu kurz. a master's, hand-that of Arturo Toscanini (avail- ( "There should be more of a distinction between the able through a contribution of $25 or more to Mu- staccato notes and the others; the former are too sicians Foundation, Inc., c/o Clyde Burrows, 131 colorless and the latter much too short...." ) Riverside Dr., New York, N.Y. 10024). Toscanini He asks too for a singing timbre, of dreamlike goes carefully through the familiar passages - quality. This kind of Teutonic abstraction usually "Seanpre libera" must be in tempo with lots of life, infuriates English and American players, who prefer and this it possesses in abundance, especially when to be told whether to play loud, soft, or mezzo - the Maestro himself sings. Soloists are present, but piano, but there is no doubt whatever about the the orchestra is not yet perfect, and he continues to splendid results of Karajan's frantically detailed sing when they reach "De miei bollenti spiriti," analysis of every note in a phrase. Of the great D adding afterwards that the orchestra must be "like major theme, every shade of meaning in its stepwise the best pianist." In the process of rehearsing the progression is discussed and tried out, first this way, duet for Germont and Violetta, Toscanini sings or then that: "aus dem D herauswachsen lassen, and hums both parts, and still finds fault with the or- dann wieder zurück die Verbindung von D nach E chestra. He probably knew the term Notenfresser, muss weicher sein; aber den Schwerpunkt schon auf for he tells the musicians (in Italian) that they das E legen." ( "Let the [tone] grow out of the D, gobble notes with the appetite of street musicians. and then back again: the connection between D and Invective was a necessary ingredient in Toscanini's E must be softer, but place the center of gravity rehearsal technique, just as quips and anecdotes were already on the E. ") When the return of the Adagio in Beecham's; and in their different ways the two is reached, great pains are taken with the balance conductors usually achieved the same polished result. of the divided violas and cellos, and the orchestra is constantly under fire for failing to observe the exact point at which a crescendo or decrescendo IN HIS WHITE -HOT preparation of Beethoven's begins. The entire rehearsal is an object lesson in Choral Symphony, Toscanini spends what seems to extreme and conscientious thoroughness, and the re- be an inordinate amount of time on the recitative ward is evident in a complete performance of the last passages for cellos and double basses. Everything part of the finale ( from the Presto, meas. 208) . must sound magnificent, monumental, spontaneous; A Gallic view of the Choral Symphony comes and by dint of drilling his men, he eventually molds with the Monteux recording on the Westminster label that entire section of the finale into an unforgettable (XWN 2234 or WST 234), and though rumor has musical experience. In the main, Toscanini's attitude it that the conductor didn't know the rehearsal was is passionate rather than analytical. Quite the reverse being taped and felt somewhat unhappy about its is that of Herbert von Karajan, who can be heard release, the fact remains that his remarks are clearly rehearsing the same symphony in "Herbert von audible and make for enjoyable as well as instructive Kajaran bei der Probe belauscht" (a special disc at listening. He is particularly concerned with crisp- one time available as Deutsche Grammophon ness of rhythm in the Scherzo, taking the strings 004300). Unlike the Toscanini record, which in- over their individual entries time and time again cludes a running commentary by Marcia Davenport until perfection is achieved. The workout he gives in English, DGG's offering is in German from start to the first and third movements proves how sensi- to finish (and in a rapid, guttural, sotto -voce kind of tive the late maestro was to subtleties of balance and German which might tax the powers of compre- to the preservation of rhythmic strength. hension of even a native German), but admirers of Franz Liszt, talking of the art of conducting, Karajan's Beethoven cycle will probably find it once said, "We are pilots, not drillmasters." Yet well worth searching out. Certainly, much of the even Liszt would have admitted that the French nervous intensity of the conductor's personality word for rehearsal -répéter-expresses the basic emerges from his rehearsal procedure. need in the struggle for perfection which these con- Karajan talks a great deal, and the musicians ductors so well recognize. Sometimes, at least, the listen attentively, only rarely interrupting when some result is a great performance, whose myriad features necessary question has to be asked. There are no fuse into an indestructible musical alloy, unique jokes. Once, and once only, a spectral laugh or two and splendid. 90 HIGH FIDELITY MAGAZINE www.americanradiohistory.com.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • ARSC Journal
    A Discography of the Choral Symphony by J. F. Weber In previous issues of this Journal (XV:2-3; XVI:l-2), an effort was made to compile parts of a composer discography in depth rather than breadth. This one started in a similar vein with the realization that SO CDs of the Beethoven Ninth Symphony had been released (the total is now over 701). This should have been no surprise, for writers have stated that the playing time of the CD was designed to accommodate this work. After eighteen months' effort, a reasonably complete discography of the work has emerged. The wonder is that it took so long to collect a body of information (especially the full names of the vocalists) that had already been published in various places at various times. The Japanese discographers had made a good start, and some of their data would have been difficult to find otherwise, but quite a few corrections and additions have been made and some recording dates have been obtained that seem to have remained 1.Dlpublished so far. The first point to notice is that six versions of the Ninth didn't appear on the expected single CD. Bl:lhm (118) and Solti (96) exceeded the 75 minutes generally assumed (until recently) to be the maximum CD playing time, but Walter (37), Kegel (126), Mehta (127), and Thomas (130) were not so burdened and have been reissued on single CDs since the first CD release. On the other hand, the rather short Leibowitz (76), Toscanini (11), and Busch (25) versions have recently been issued with fillers.
    [Show full text]
  • An Interview with Robert Shaw: Reflections at Eighty
    An Interview with Robert Shaw: Reflections at Eighty by Jeffrey Baxter RobertShaw .Robert Shaw's distinguished career began in New York City In 1979, Shaw was appointed by President Jimmy Carter to in 1938, where he prepared choruses for such renowned con­ the National Council on the Arts and he was a 1991 recipient of ductors as Fred Waring, Arturo Toscanini, and Bruno Walter. the Kennedy Center Honors, the nation's highest award given to In 1949 he formed the Robert Shaw Chorale, which for two artists. Musical America, the international directory of the per­ decades reigned as America's premier touring choir. Under the forming arts, named him Musician of the Year for 1992, and auspices ofthe U.S. State Department, the Chorale performed during the same year he was awarded the National Medal ofthe in thirty countries throughout Europe, the Soviet Union, the Arts in a White House ceremony. He was the 1993 recipient of Middle East, and Latin America. During this period Shaw also the Conductors' Guild TheodoreThomas Award, in recognition served as Music Director ofthe San Diego Symphony and then ofhis outstanding achievement in conducting and his contribu­ as Associate Conductor of the Cleveland Orchestra, working tions to the education and training ofyoung conductors. closely with George Szell for eleven years. He served as Music A regular guest conductor ofmajor orchestras in this country Director of the Atlanta Symphony Orchestra from 1967 to and abroad, Shaw also is in demand as a teacher and lecturer at 1988, during which time the orchestra garnered widespread leading U.S.
    [Show full text]
  • Arturo Toscanini and Don Gillis in Rehearsal, Don Gillis Collection, University of North Texas
    Arturo Toscanini and Don Gillis in rehearsal, Don Gillis Collection, University of North Texas. Reproduced with permission. MARK MCKNIGHT, SUSANNAH CLEVELAND Rediscovering “Toscanini: The Man Behind the Legend” The following article is based on the authors’ presentation at the ARSC Conference in Austin, TX, April 2005. The focus is on the Don Gillis Collection, which the University of North Texas (UNT) Music Library acquired after Gillis’s death in 1978. Gillis, a longtime associate of Arturo Toscanini, served as the conductor’s assistant and the producer for the NBC Symphony broadcast concerts from 1944 until they ended ten years later. The photographs that illustrate this article are from the collection and are reproduced with permission. __________________________________________________________________________________ he story of Arturo Toscanini’s rise to fame as one of history’s most celebrated con- ductors is well known. Having spent the first several years of his professional life in T the opera pit, Toscanini then gained a reputation for his symphonic conducting, serving as principal conductor of the New York Philharmonic from 1929 to 1936. When he left that post and retired to his native Italy, his American fans believed they would never again see the maestro conduct here. At the age of 70, however, when most individuals are happily settled into retirement, Toscanini returned to the podium, this time in a completely new and, in some ways controversial, forum, as head of the recently organized NBC Symphony. He would remain with the orchestra until his final departure in 1954. Toscanini died three years later in New York, just two months before his ninetieth birthday.
    [Show full text]
  • Bruno Walter (Ca
    [To view this image, refer to the print version of this title.] Erik Ryding and Rebecca Pechefsky Yale University Press New Haven and London Frontispiece: Bruno Walter (ca. ). Courtesy of Österreichisches Theatermuseum. Copyright © by Yale University. All rights reserved. This book may not be reproduced, in whole or in part, including illustrations, in any form (beyond that copying permitted by Sections and of the U.S. Copyright Law and except by reviewers for the public press), without written permission from the publishers. Designed by Sonia L. Shannon Set in Bulmer type by The Composing Room of Michigan, Grand Rapids, Mich. Printed in the United States of America by R. R. Donnelley,Harrisonburg, Va. Library of Congress Cataloging-in-Publication Data Ryding, Erik S., – Bruno Walter : a world elsewhere / by Erik Ryding and Rebecca Pechefsky. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references, filmography,and indexes. ISBN --- (cloth : alk. paper) . Walter, Bruno, ‒. Conductors (Music)— Biography. I. Pechefsky,Rebecca. II. Title. ML.W R .Ј—dc [B] - A catalogue record for this book is available from the British Library. The paper in this book meets the guidelines for permanence and durability of the Committee on Production Guidelines for Book Longevity of the Council on Library Resources. For Emily, Mary, and William In memoriam Rachel Kemper and Howard Pechefsky Contents Illustrations follow pages and Preface xi Acknowledgments xv Bruno Schlesinger Berlin, Cologne, Hamburg,– Kapellmeister Walter Breslau, Pressburg, Riga, Berlin,‒
    [Show full text]
  • Of the Reader If Possible.” Check out His Blog – It's Great! “
    of the reader if possible.” Check out his Blog Britten, Tippett, Walton as they were writing – it’s great! their masterieces and being able to discuss “A lot of modern critics employ double them with the composers. I’ve met many of standards. If it’s a new piece they go for it, in the most famous musicians: Messiaen, Nono, the old days they’d have gone at it!” Stockhausen, Strauss.” Ever lighthearted John then told me a Meeting Richard Strauss face to face is criticism joke about Sarasate. “Sarasate last described as “one of the most climactic mom - Tuesday left all criticism behind him, as he did ents in my life”. “It was during the Beecham/ the orchestra.” Strauss Festival in Drury Lane. I was working Sir Thomas Beecham was also reported to for Beecham then and went to see him arriv - be quite a wit and a bit of a joker: wasn’t it ing at the same time as Strauss. The door was Dame Kiri te Kanawa Beecham, who, when asked if he had ever locked and Strauss turned and looked me conducted any Stockhausen, said, “No, but I straight in the eye and shouted loudly, “diese once trod in some.”? verdammen Tür”. I was too shocked to say efugees are grateful people and Georg Solti “Beecham only ever told me one joke in all anything. Fortunately someone came and Rnever forgot how many people helped him the years I worked for him, he needed to have opened it.” to get work with letters of recommend ation, an audience or an orchestra in front of him to “Stockhausen was an hour late for a TV including Arturo Toscanini with whom he had become entertaining.
    [Show full text]
  • 95649 Digibooklet Lucerne Festival Vol
    HISTORIC PERFORMANCES Karl Böhm Hindemith Concerto for Woodwinds, Harp and Orchestra Bruckner Symphony No. 7 Vienna Philharmonic Paul Hindemith (1895–1963) Concerto for Woodwinds, Harp and Orchestra I. Moderately Fast 8:01 II. Grazioso 2:57 III. Rondo. Rather Fast 4:34 Anton Bruckner (1824–1896) Symphony No. 7 in E major, WAB 107 I. Allegro moderato 19:40 II. Adagio. Sehr feierlich und sehr langsam 22:09 III. Scherzo. Sehr schnell – Trio. Etwas langsamer 9:35 IV. Finale. Bewegt, doch nicht schnell 11:12 Werner Tripp flute Gerhard Turetschek oboe Alfred Prinz clarinet Ernst Pamperl bassoon Hubert Jelinek harp Vienna Philharmonic Karl Böhm recorded live at Lucerne Festival (Internationale Musikfestwochen Luzern) Previously unreleased Naturalness and sense of form Karl Böhm in Lucerne “When I conducted Tristan and Isolde in Munich in January 1981, by chance almost all the conductors of note were in town: Carlos Kleiber, Herbert von Karajan and Karl Böhm,” Leonard Bernstein wrote in his preface to Franz Endler’s Böhm monograph. Forty years later, the compilation of these names makes us sit up, since it signals the tectonic shift that has taken place in musical interpretation in the meantime. Whereas the enigmatic podium refusenik Carlos Kleiber has risen by virtue of his charisma to the narrow ranks of the century’s greatest conductors alongside Arturo Toscanini and Wilhelm Furtwängler, the spell of the former “miracle” Karajan seems to have been broken comprehensively, and Karl Böhm appears to be almost forgotten. Yet Böhm, who died in Salzburg on 14 August 1981 at the age of 86, was undoubtedly one of the great conductors of international standing during the three decades between 1950 and 1980.
    [Show full text]
  • The Pin-Up Boy of the Symphony: St. Louis and the Rise of Leonard
    The Pin-Up Boy of the Symphony St. Louis and the Rise of Leonard Bernstein BY KENNETH H. WINN 34 | The Confluence | Fall/Winter 2018/2019 In May 1944 25-year-old publicized story from a New Leonard Bernstein, riding a York high school newspaper, had tidal wave of national publicity, bobbysoxers sighing over him as was invited to serve as a guest the “pin-up boy of the symphony.” conductor of the St. Louis They, however, advised him to get The Pin-Up Boy 3 Symphony Orchestra for its a crew cut. 1944–1945 season. The orchestra For some of Bernstein’s of the Symphony and Bernstein later revealed that elders, it was too much, too they had also struck a deal with fast. Many music critics were St. Louis and the RCA’s Victor Records to make his skeptical, put off by the torrent first classical record, a symphony of praise. “Glamourpuss,” they Rise of Leonard Bernstein of his own composition, entitled called him, the “Wunderkind Jeremiah. Little more than a year of the Western World.”4 They BY KENNETH H. WINN earlier, the New York Philharmonic suspected Bernstein’s performance music director Artur Rodziński Jeremiah was the first of Leonard Bernstein’s was simply a flash-in-the-pan. had hired Bernstein on his 24th symphonies recorded by the St. Louis Symphony The young conductor was riding birthday as an assistant conductor, Orchestra in the spring of 1944. (Image: Washing- a wave of luck rather than a wave a position of honor, but one known ton University Libraries, Gaylord Music Library) of talent.
    [Show full text]
  • ROBERT SHAW, Conductor
    ROBERT SHAW, Conductor Music Director Emeritus and Conductor Laureate of the Atlanta Symphony Orchestra, Robert Shaw began his tenure as Music Director of the ASO 30 years ago in 1967 and served in that capacity until 1988. During that time, he built it into a major American orchestra, gamering widespread acclaim through national and international tours and award-winning recordings. A regular guest conductor of major orchestras in this coun­ try and abroad, Mr. Shaw is also in demand as a teacher and lec­ turer in leading U.S. universities. He founded the Robert Shaw Institute to foster excellence in music making, especially in the choral arts. The Institute’s summer festivals in southwest France have attracted admiring attention from the international press and produced a number of recordings from the Robert Shaw Festival Singers. Beginning this summer, the Institute is sponsored by the University of Utah and is in residence in Park City, Utah. In Atlanta, he per­ forms and records with the Robert Shaw Chamber Singers. Mr. Shaw’s distinguished career began in New York, where he prepared choruses for such renowned conductors as Arturo Toscanini and Bruno Walter. In 1949 he formed the Robert Shaw Chorale, which for two decades reigned as America’s premier touring choral group and was sent by the U.S. State Department to 30 countries in Europe, the Soviet Union, the Middle East, and Latin America. During this period, Mr. Shaw also served as Music Director of the San Diego Symphony and then as Associate Conductor of the Cleve­ land Orchestra, working closely with George Szell for 11 years.
    [Show full text]
  • GEORGE SZELL the FORGOTTEN RECORDINGS
    GEORGE SZELL and the CLEVELAND ORCHESTRA THE FORGOTTEN RECORDINGS ARIADNE 5011-2 JS Bach (1685-1750) · Brahms (1833-97) · Mozart (1756-91) Schumann (1810-56) · Smetana (1824-84) R Strauss (1864-1949) · Stravinsky (1882-1971) The Cleveland Orchestra, George Szellconductor GEORGE CD 1 1- 5 JS Bach Orchestral Suite No.3 in D major, BWV 1068a 19:33 SZELL 6 Smetana The Moldau (Vltava) from Má vlasta 11:37 7 R Strauss Till Eulenspiegel’s Merry Pranksa 13:49 and the 8- bm Mozart Symphony No.39 in E flat, K543b 24:42 Total duration: 69:44 CLEVELAND Recorded in the Masonic Auditorium, Cleveland, Ohio on: aDecember 24, 1954 (mono); bOctober 19-21, 1955 (stereo) ORCHESTRA CD 2 1 Brahms Academic Festival Overture, Op.80 10:25 2- bm Brahms Variations on a Theme by Haydn, Op.56a* 17:31 bn- bq Schumann Symphony No.4 in D minor, Op.120 25:37 br- cn Stravinsky The Firebird Suite (1919 Version) 19:36 The Total duration: 73:13 From stereo recordings in the Masonic Auditorium, Cleveland, Ohio, October 19-21, 1955 FORGOTTEN All FIRST RELEASES on CD except * Producing and Audio Restoration: Lani Spahr RECORDINGS Ariadne Front cover: George Szell Design: Andrew Giles Booklet Editor: Michael Quinn Includes Seven First Releases AAD Visit www.somm-recordings.com for further information Ariadne © & 2021 SOMM RECORDINGS · THAMES DITTON · SURREY · ENGLAND · Made in EU The Cleveland Orchestra, George Szellconductor 4 Variation II: Più vivace 0:59 THE FORGOTTEN RECORDINGS 5 Variation III: Con moto 1:44 6 Variation IV: Andante con moto 2:04 7 JS Bach: Orchestral Suite
    [Show full text]
  • The Blake Collection Click on Item Titles Or in Memory of Nancy M
    (Scroll to the end of this document for an Index to all items. Please note that this Archive contains Live Links: The Blake Collection click on item titles or pictures to go to the In Memory of Nancy M. Blake Library’s catalog, and click on citations to see full articles.) BELLINI’S NORMA featuring CECILIA BARTOLI This tragic opera is set in Roman-occupied, first-century Gaul, features a title character, who although a Druid priestess, is in many ways a modern woman. Norma has secretly taken the Roman proconsul Pollione as her lover and had two children with him. Political and personal crises arise when the locals turn against the occupiers and Pollione turns to a new paramour. Norma “is a role with emotions ranging from haughty and demanding, to desperately passionate, to vengeful and defiant. And the singer must convey all of this while confronting some of the most vocally challenging music ever composed. And if that weren't intimidating enough for any singer, Norma and its composer have become almost synonymous with the specific and notoriously torturous style of opera known as bel canto — literally, ‘beautiful singing’” (“Love Among the Druids: Bellini's Norma,” NPR World of Opera, May 16, 2008). And Bartoli, one of the greatest living opera divas, is up to the challenges the role brings. (New York Public Radio’s WQXR’s “OperaVore” declared that “Bartoli is Fierce and Mercurial in Bellini's Norma,” Marion Lignana Rosenberg, June 09, 2013.) If you’re already a fan of this opera, you’ve no doubt heard a recording spotlighting the great soprano Maria Callas (and we have such a recording, too), but as the notes with the Bartoli recording point out, “The role of Norma was written for Giuditta Pasta, who sang what today’s listeners would consider to be mezzo-soprano roles,” making Bartoli more appropriate than Callas as Norma.
    [Show full text]
  • ARSC Journal
    TOSCANINI FROM FRANCE BRAHMS: The Four Symphonies; Academic Festival Overture, Op. 80; Tragic Overture, Op. 81. French RCA GM-43664 (4-record set) $31.92. CHERUBINI: Requiem in C Minor (with the Robert Shaw Chorale); Symphony in D; Overtures to Medea, Ali Baba, Anacreon. French RCA VL-42949 $15.96. -- ROSSINI: Overtures: The Barber of Seville, La Cenerentola, Il Signor Bruschino, La Gazza ladra, Semiramide; William Tell. William Tell: "Passo a sei." French RCA GM-43556, $7.98 WAGNER: Gotterdammerung: Prologue, Brunnhilde's Immolation, Siegfried's Death and Funeral Music (with Helen Traube! soprano, Lauritz Melchior, tenor). Lohengrin: Preludes to Act I and Act III. Siegfried: Forest Murmurs. Die Meistersinger: Preludes to Act I and Act III. Die Walkure: Act I, Scene 3 (with Lauritz Melchior and Helen Traube!), Ride of the Valkyries. Tristan and Isolde: Prelude and Liebestod. Parsifal: Prelude and Good Friday Spell. "Siegfried Idyll." "A Faust Overture." French RCA GM-43404 (4-record set), $31.92. TOSCANINI CONDUCTS FRENCH MUSIC OF THE TURN OF THE CENTURY: Saint­ Saens: Symphony No. 3 in C, Op. 78; Danse Macabre. Bizet: Carmen Suite No. 1. Franck: Psyche: No. 4, Psyche and Eros. Dukas: The Sorcerer's Apprentice. Ravel: Daphnis et Chloe: Suite No. 2. Debussy: La Mer, Ibe'ria. French RCA VL-42950 (3-record set), $32.94 All items feature the NBC Symphony conducted by Arturo Toscanini and all are distributed by HARMONIA MUNDI USA, 2351 WESTWOOD BLVD., LOS ANGELES, CALIFORNIA 90064. The phonograph has produced its strange curiosities, but none is more outrageous than the many sonic swindles and perversions that -- in the name of "improvement" --have been directed against the recordings of Arturo Toscanini.
    [Show full text]
  • 95643 Digibooklet Lucerne Festival Vol. VIII
    HISTORIC PERFORMANCES Annie Fischer Schumann Piano Concerto Philharmonia Orchestra | Carlo Maria Giulini Leon Fleisher Beethoven Piano Concerto No. 2 Swiss Festival Orchestra | George Szell Robert Schumann (1810–1856) Piano Concerto in A minor, Op. 54 Annie Fischer piano Philharmonia Orchestra | Carlo Maria Giulini LUCERNE, KUNSTHAUS, 3 SEPTEMBER 1960 Ludwig van Beethoven (1770–1827) Piano Concerto No. 2 in B-flat major, Op. 19 Leon Fleisher piano Swiss Festival Orchestra | George Szell LUCERNE, KUNSTHAUS, 29 AUGUST 1962 recorded live at LUCERNE FESTIVAL (Internationale Musikfestwochen Luzern) Two truths – Annie Fischer and Leon Fleisher in Lucerne How does a man play the piano? With strong hands; in a clear, unfussy, unsentimental and alert fashion; completely in control, free, measured and purposeful. A woman, on the other hand? She touches the piano delicately; loves the soft notes, the ornamen- tal and the decorative; she is a refined young lady, educated in salons and trained, by well-meaning teachers, to remain faithful to the musical text. If these clichés were to represent the truth, Annie Fischer would be a gentleman-pianist, whilst Leon Fleisher could be said to epitomise female musical virtues. If one hears them, one straight after the other (and not with an interval of two years, as was the case in Lucerne), one could indeed conceive such silly, and yet illuminating, ideas and ask oneself how these musical stereotypes have come to appear back-to-front. After all, a contemporary critic writing about Annie Fischer in the 1960s commented that her tone at the piano demonstrated “an astonishingly resolute steeliness for a woman”.
    [Show full text]