IPEC Evaluation
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
IPEC Evaluation Regional Programme on Prevention Withdrawal and Rehabilitation of Children Engaged in Hazardous Work in Commercial Agriculture P 34000100050 RAF/00/P51/USA An independent final evaluation by a team of external consultants Zambia, Kenya, Uganda, Tanzania April 2005 NOTE ON THE EVALUATION PROCESS AND REPORT This independent evaluation was managed by ILO-IPEC’s Design, Evaluation and Documentation Section (DED) following a consultative and participatory approach. DED has ensured that all major stakeholders were consulted and informed throughout the evaluation and that its independence was not compromised during the process. The evaluation was carried out a team of external consultants1. The field mission took place in April 2005. The opinions and recommendations included in this report are those of the authors and do not compromise the ILO or any other organization involved in the project. USDOL FUNDED PROJECT Funding for this project evaluation was provided by the United States Department of Labor. This report does not necessarily reflect the views or policies of the United States Department of labor nor does mention of trade names, commercial products, or organizations imply endorsement by the United States Government. 1 INTERNATIONAL CONSULTANT, TEAM LEADER DR. BIRGITTE WOEL NATIONAL CONSULTANT, UGANDA M.A. ECONOMICS Mr. DAN N. OPIO NATIONAL CONSULTANT, TANZANIA MASD STATISTICS IN AGRICULTURE Mr. A.G. MUGYABUSO NATIONAL CONSULTANT, KENYA M.A. SOCIOLOGY Mr. JOHN M. NJOKA NATIONAL CONSULTANT, ZAMBIA B.A. SOCIAL WORK Mr. CARLTON SULWE NATIONAL CONSULTANT, MALAWI FCCA (CHARTERED CERTIFIED ACCOUNTANT Mr. BRIGHT C. KAMANGA TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF ABBREVIATIONS........................................................................................ 3 EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ............................................................................................ 4 1. INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................... 7 2. BACKGROUND........................................................................................................ 8 2.1. CHILD LABOUR POLICY ..............................................................................................8 3. PROGRAMME ORGANISATION........................................................................ 9 3.1. INTRODUCTION.............................................................................................................9 3.2 PROGRAMME MANAGEMENT ......................................................................................9 3.3. PARTNERS AND THEIR ROLE IN PROGRAMME IMPLEMENTATION...................10 4.EVALUATION METHODOLOGY ........................................................................ 12 4.1EVALUATION IMPLEMENTATION STRATEGY .........................................................12 4.2. METHODOLOGY..........................................................................................................12 4.2.1. COMPARABILITY.............................................................................................12 4.2.2 PARADIGMATIC FRAMEWORK FOR THE EVALUATION ............................13 4.2.3. SUB-REGIONAL VS NATIONAL DATA COLLECTION.................................13 4.2.4. DESIGN AND USE OF JOINT DATA COLLECTION TOOLS..........................14 4.2.5. SELECTION OF RESPONDENTS......................................................................14 4.2.6 REVIEW OF LITERATURE................................................................................15 4.2.7 FIELD EXPOSURE...............................................................................................15 4.2.8. ANALYSIS, SYNTHESIS AND VALIDATION OF DATA ..............................15 4.2.9. NATIONAL STAKEHOLDER WORKSHOPS ...................................................15 4.2.10. SUB-REGIONAL WORKSHOP........................................................................16 4.3 WORK EXPERIENCES ..................................................................................................16 5. MAIN FINDINGS..................................................................................................... 17 5.1. INTRODUCTION ...........................................................................................................17 5.2. RELEVANCE OF PROGRAMME DESIGN ...................................................................17 5.3 ADEQUACY OF ASSUMPTIONS AND EXTERNAL FACTORS ..................................18 5.4 SUITABILITY OF PROGRAMME STRATEGY .............................................................20 5.5 SUITABILITY OF MONITORING APPROACH.............................................................21 5.5.1. SUITABILITY OF CLMS ...................................................................................21 5.6. RELEVANCE OF EACH OF THE PROGRAMME COMPONENTS.............................22 5.6.1TRAINING AND AWARENESS CREATION.......................................................22 5.6.2. SUITABILITY OF EDUCATION AS AN ALTERNATIVE TO CHILD LABOUR .......................................................................................................................................22 5.6.3 SUITABILITY OF IGAs TO REPLACE INCOME FROM CHILD LABOUR .....24 5.7 IMPLEMENTATION OF THE PROGRAMME ..............................................................25 5.7.1. ADHERENCE TO WORKPLAN ........................................................................25 5.7.2. IMPACT OF HIGH TURNOVER OF CTAs.........................................................25 5.7.3.EFFECTIVENESS AND EFFICIENCY OF ADMINISTRATIVE AND MANAGEMENT SYSTEMS.........................................................................................26 5.7.4. RELEVANCE OF MANAGEMENT STRUCTURE AT COUNTRY LEVEL ....26 5.7.5. RELEVANCE OF MANAGEMENT STRUCTURES AT SUB-REGIONAL LEVEL...........................................................................................................................27 5.7.6. ROLE OF FACTORS OUTSIDE PROGRAMME MANAGEMENT CONTROL .......................................................................................................................................27 5.7.7. SELECTION OF PARTNERS AND ACTION PROGRAMMES......................27 5.7.8 STAFF AND PARTNER SENSITIVITY TOWARDS GENDER ISSUES............27 Regional Programme on Prevention, Withdrawal and Rehabilitation of Children Engaged in Hazardous Work in Commercial Agriculture 1 5.7.9 UTILISATION OF MID-TERM EVALUATION RECOMMENDATIONS .........28 5.8 SYNERGIES AND COLLABORATION..........................................................................29 5.8.1 APPLICATION AND ADVANTAGES OF COMAGRI/IPEC COLLABORATIONS ....................................................................................................29 5.8.2 APPLICATION OF EXPERIENCE SHARING AMONG IMPLEMENTORS.......29 5.8.3 ANALYSIS OF LOCAL MANAGEMENT STRUCTURES..................................30 5.9 PROGRAMME ACHIEVEMENTS..................................................................................30 5.9.1 INTRODUCTION .................................................................................................30 5.9.2. ACHIEVEMENTS IN TOTAL.............................................................................31 5.9.3. ACHIEVEMENTS AS PER COUNTRY ..............................................................31 5.9.4 ACHIEVEMENTS AGAINST EXPECTED OUTPUTS........................................34 5.9.5 IMPACT AT FAMILY LEVEL.............................................................................38 5.9.6 MULTIPLIER EFFECT.........................................................................................38 5.9.7. SUITABILITY OF MEDIA ..............................................................................39 5.10 EVIDENCE OF SUSTAINABILITY AND MOBILISATION OF RESOURCES ...........39 5.10.1. ESTABLISHMENT OF SUSTAINABILITY....................................................39 5.10.2. SUITABILITY AND APPLICATION OF PHASE-OUT STRATEGY .............40 5.10.3. ROLE OF OTHER ILO/IPEC PROGRAMMES .................................................40 6. LESSONS LEARNED............................................................................................ 40 6.1. GOOD PRACTICES......................................................................................................40 6.2 LESSONS LEARNED.............................................................................................41 7. RECOMMENDATIONS ....................................................................................... 42 ANNEXES .............................................................................................................................44 ANNEX 1...............................................................................................................................44 TERMS OF REFERENCE......................................................................................................44 ANNEX 2...............................................................................................................................52 ITINERARY FOR THE EVALUATION................................................................................52 ANNEX 3...............................................................................................................................58 LISTS OF PEOPLE MET.......................................................................................................58 ANNEX 4...............................................................................................................................64