PoS(ICRC2015)002 http://pos.sissa.it/ ∗ [email protected] Speaker. With the recent discovery of high-energy neutrinostrino of observatory, extra-terrestrial origin neutrino-astronomy by is the entering IceCubeserved neu- a to date new exceed era. 1 PeV in The energy,point a highest back regime to of energy the particular neutrinos interest still because elusive ob- the acceleratorsrays. neutrinos of should the This highest review energy will Galactic and coverresults extragalactic currently from cosmic operating searches neutrino for telescopes a in fluxsteady of water and transient extra-terrestrial and neutrino neutrinos ice, point and the sources. currentMediterranean latest In efforts Sea addition, in and future the plans detectors for search such IceCube for as detector KM3NeT upgrades in will the be discussed. ∗ Copyright owned by the author(s) under the terms of the Creative Commons Attribution-NonCommercial-ShareAlike Licence. c
The 34th International Cosmic Ray Conference, 30 July- 6 August, 2015 The Hague, The Netherlands C. Kopper Department of Physics, CCIS 4-181, UniversityCanada of Alberta, Edmonton, Alberta T6GE-mail: 2E1, Recent Results in Neutrino Astronomy PoS(ICRC2015)002 ) ]. γ 7 2 ]. It 5 → . Vari- 1 0 − C. Kopper π sr 1 − s 2 − GeVcm 8 − 10 · 3 ≈ Φ 2 E ] and a full overview of highlight results in decays in the atmosphere above a detector 3 K of 1 : 2 : 0 is expected. Due to oscillations, this and 2 τ ν ]. π 6 : µ ν : e . While neutral pions decay into two gammas ( 0 ν π p → γ p ], neutrino-astronomy is entering a new era. Even long before this discov- 2 and , ] can be found later in these proceedings. 1 + 4 π n → γ p All backgrounds to astrophysical neutrino detection are due to interactions of cosmic ray air Given the abundant number of observed high-energy hadronic cosmic rays, a flux of neutrinos A rough estimate of the neutrino flux expected (assuming a proton-only cosmic ray injec- With the recent discovery of high-energy neutrinos of extra-terrestrial origin by the IceCube This article will give a brief overview of neutrino flux expectations, of current and future detec- The flavor composition of the atmospheric neutrino flux is heavily biased towards muon neutrinos and create a flux ofcharged-pion high-energy decay, gamma a rays, flavor charged ratio pions of eventually decay to neutrinos. From showers. ‘Atmospheric muons’, produced by from interactions of these cosmic raysinteractions with can ambient either matter and happen radiation ata fields a high-energy is proton source expected. interacting or These with duringcesses a propagation target like through photon space. will yield As charged an and neutral example, pions in pro- 2. Neutrino Flux Expectation sets an upper bound for the all-flavor flux of neutrinos at can penetrate to reach thesame detector, interactions also even produce through neutrinos substantialmospheric that amounts neutrinos’ enter are of the seen shielding detector at a material. from lower above rate The and due below. to the These lower ‘at- neutrino interaction cross-section [ tion, a purely extra-galactic origininto and neutrons considering and only a charged single pions) interaction is of provided protons by converted the so-called ‘Waxman-Bahcall bound’ [ neutrino astronomy [ corresponds to a flavor ratiolarger at than Earth the of oscillation approximately length 1environments scale. : such 1 as The : in expected 1 the ratio presence assuming can of a strong change source magnetic in distance fields. case much of different source neutrino observatory[ ery, neutrinos have been targetedthus as escape ideal from cosmic dense messengers: astrophysicalThey environments they are that only not are interact affected opaque weakly by to andpaths, Galactic electro-magnetic can and pointing radiation. intergalactic back magnetic to fields theirEarth and sources. provides will insight thus Measuring into travel high-energy in aexplosions straight astrophysical large to neutrinos number acceleration arriving of processes at astrophysicalhadronic in phenomena, processes, active ranging galactic they from can nuclei. supernova cosmic also rays. Because help Finding they to a are solve classsmoking only the of guns created 100-year for Galactic the in and/or old acceleration extra-galactic mystery sites neutrino of of sources cosmic the would rays. make acceleration them of tors, the detection principle andrecent various results detection and channels. briefly touch It on future willof detectors. then the A highlight high-energy discussion astrophysical a of neutrino the few observation multi-messenger important [ connection Recent Results in Neutrino Astronomy 1. Introduction ous detailed model predictions aregamma-ray available bursts for and active a galactic wide nuclei range [ of potential source classes, such as PoS(ICRC2015)002 charged- C. Kopper µ ν ]. At higher energies 8 higher than the rate expected from CC interactions, a high-energy muon 6 τ ν 10 ]. For equal neutrino fluxes of all flavors ≈ 10 , 50% CL in ice, better in water) than for those ◦ 1 3 . ]. 11 , 50% CL in ice, better in water) [ mesons decay overwhelmingly to muons rather than electrons. Because of the ◦ K 15 ]. ∼ 13 CC events make up only 20% of interactions. Tau neutrinos can have other signatures, , and µ π 12 at lower energies are on-going [ ν ]. This ‘prompt’ atmospheric neutrino flux has not yet been observed and is only poorly τ 9 ν [ In order to detect a flux on the order of the Waxman-Bahcall bound within a few years, detec- Because muons at the relevant energies can travel over distances of several kilometers, one K / (1:1:1), such as “double-bang” events withbe two detectable showers close at to the each PeVfrom other. level, Such have not signatures, yet expected to been observed. Searches for double-pulse signatures tors on the scale of a cubicof kilometer natural are transparent necessary. Building medium, such such detectorsdetectors: requires as Neutrinos large water are amounts detected or by ice.created observing when the The neutrinos Cherenkov principle interact. light of These produced particles detection byindividually generally charged is and travel particles similar the distances too for particle small all shower to (or be ‘cacade’) resolved is observed only in aggregate. In way to look for neutrinoswhelming is to number search of for down-going track atmospheric events muons entering ( the detector. To suppress the over- of about 100TeV a similarpected flux to of become muons important. and Because of neutrinosinteraction the from before shorter the lifetime decay decay of is these of expected, particles, leading charmedπ no to mesons suppression an is from expected ex- cross-over with the neutrino flux from 3. Detection Principle current (CC) interactions, however, as well as ais minority produced of that leaves a visible trackAlthough (unless the produced deposited on energy the resolution detector boundary iscontaining heading similar visible outward). for muon all tracks events, is the much angular better resolution ( for events neutrinos) only up-going events in the detectoragainst are selected. the This atmospheric effectively muon uses the background. Earthin to Atmospheric this shield case. neutrinos They are need an to be irreduciblespectrum included background and in angular analyses on distribution. a statistical Thesample basis other and is main described to by way use their to the energy select outeratmospheric a layers muons reasonably of will pure the be neutrino detector rejected as event pass while an the neutrinos anti-coincidence veto. veto. interacting inside Incoming This tracks thechannel from significantly detector described will reduces above be but the it able effective allows to The detection to veto volume detect will compared all even suppress three to some flavors thetriggered of and by “track” the allows muons down-going for traveling atmospheric all-sky in neutrino observation. coincidence flux withshower because [ the the neutrino veto generated is in the same cosmic ray air constrained at the moment. that do not ( Recent Results in Neutrino Astronomy because increasing lifetime of the parent mesonsatmosphere with increases. increasing energy, This their leads interaction probability toimately in a one the suppression power at steeper high than energies the producing original a primary spectrum cosmic approx- ray spectrum [ PoS(ICRC2015)002 C. Kopper ]. 19 . ANTARES and the 3 01km . ] and the ANTARES neutrino tele- 15 4 ]. The discovery of two PeV energy cascades in a two-year 21 ]. ]. It was deployed between 2005 and 2010 and consists of 86 strings with 17 ]. ], the NEMO project close to Sicily [ 18 16 14 ] and in the cascade channel [ Before the discovery of the astrophysical neutrino flux mentioned earlier, hints of it had been Another neutrino detector, NT200, is deployed in Lake Baikal using the frozen lake surface Currently, the largest neutrino telescope is the IceCube neutrino telescope, located at the geo- Several large-scale neutrino telescopes are currently in operation around the world. All of In the Mediterranean sea, several efforts were started at different sites: the NESTOR project off 20 seen in various analyses of data ofnel the [ partially completed IceCube detector, both in the track chan- 5. Neutrino Searches 5.1 Diffuse Neutrino Flux Searches search for GZK neutrinos (from cosmic raysground) interacting provided on the photons first of concrete the evidence cosmicwere for microwave back- too an astrophysical low flux. for Theprovided a detected further event GZK evidence energies for flux an but unaccountedfor component higher in events than the with expected measured the flux. from neutrino A atmospheric vertex dedicated inside search backgrounds the and detector thus using the outer layer of optical modules as 5160 optical modules in total.1450m The and instrumented 2450m. volume isantarctic Unlike a glacier. the cubic water-based The kilometer detectors at detectorthreshold described a contains for previously depth a neutrino it between denser physics is sub-array studies deployedcomplemented called by using in DeepCore an the the lowering air-shower atmospheric array the on neutrino energy the flux surface as of the a glacier source. called IceTop It [ also is during the winter as awith 192 deployment optical platform. modules in total This wasstrings version completed with of in 12 1998. the modules An detector upgrade, eachthan NT200+, consisting was adding ANTARES, of three deployed but 8 more in a strings 2005. futuredeployed in gigaton The early upgrade currently 2015 operating is [ detector planned is and smaller a first cluster of this upgrade was scope off the coast of France.and While future the deep-sea first neutrino two detector projects technology, madea the significant large-scale ANTARES contributions collaboration detector to has current in been operating stable12 conditions vertical “strings” for with several 25 years.mented storeys volume of The of consisting ANTARES the of detector detector, three completed consistsfuture optical in of Mediterranean 2008, modules cubic-kilometer is each. detector approximately The KM3NeT 0 are totalin highlighted instru- these in prcoeedings a [ separate contribution graphical South Pole [ these use the samenatural detection water principle or ice for with Cherenkovpressure-resistant a light: glass three-dimensional housings, array they of so-called instrument photomultiplier ‘opticalarrival time tubes a modules’. and (PMTs) large amplitude contained These volume of in optical photons. of of modules Dedicated water record algorithms or use the ice a (scattering,energy model absorption in of and the the detector. noise) optical to properties reconstruct the event direction, topologythe and coast of Greece [ Recent Results in Neutrino Astronomy 4. Neutrino Detectors PoS(ICRC2015)002 ]. 24 (5.1) C. Kopper . 1 − sr 1 − s 2 − level against the atmospheric- σ IceCube IceCube Preliminary GeVcm 3 25 . > 0 ± 58 . 0 − ) 5 100TeV . Assuming a 1:1:1 flavor ratio and a 1:1 neutrino to / 1 E ( 8 shows limits set on the flavor composition by this global − 3 10 × 7 . 0 ]. Fig. ± 2 25 . 2 ]. A follow-up extending this analysis to three years of data increased the 1 ) = ), 6 total years of IceCube data have now been analyzed and results will be 2 E . Continuing this analysis with a fourth year of data increases this significance ( σ φ 7 2 . ] in these proceedings). A total of 54 events are detected in the whole 4-year sam- E ]. 22 22 Deposited energies of the observed events in four years of the high-energy starting event search ] (see Fig. 23 [ Searches using the track channel using incoming muons entering the detector from below have σ 7 . fit. Some source flavor compositionneutrinos is models expected such at as the neutron source, decay, are where already excluded a by pure this flux analysis. of electron now also confirmed this result inyears an of almost IceCube independent data channel. which Starting3 found from a an component analysis beyond of atmospheric two background expectations of anti-neutrino ratio, the best fit per-neutrino flux for a sample of four years of data is The choice of 100TeV as thethe pivot normalization. point minimizes It the should correlationBahcall between also bound, the be although spectral the noted index spectral and that index the and normalization detected are flux still is uncertain. on the order of the Waxman- published soon. Results fromAll a these 3-year searches sub-sample confirm canuncertainties be the on found the flux spectral later detected shapes in and inIceCube these on the flavor analyses proceedings composition. starting has [ A event dedicated been “global channel. performedto fit” in answer to There multiple order these are to questions still use [ as large much available information as possible ple. Their energy spectrum is shown in Fig. Figure 1: in IceCube. [ a veto (as explained above) finally provided evidence on the significance to 5 further (see [ Recent Results in Neutrino Astronomy only null-hypothesis [ PoS(ICRC2015)002 C. Kopper 6 10 5 10 Astrophysical ). Although not significant, the apparent Experimental data Experimental Sum of predictions 5 Prompt atmospheric 4 Conventional atmospheric 6 10 ] 23 Muon Energy Proxy (arb. units) 3 10 ], but neither has found significant clustering at any position on the sky. An near the galactic center has been studied in detail by ANTARES. Their field of 27 , 5 1 0 4 3 2 -2 -1 26
10 10 10 10 10 10 10 Events Distribution of a muon energy proxy variable of the final event sample used in a two-year track- . Note that these point-source samples are dominated by atmospheric backgrounds in order 4 The next step after detection of an astrophysical neutrino flux is to attribute it to sources or view for track-like events includes thislower region energies. and None allows of them these to searches extend have searches found for significant clustering. clustering to More recent point-source clustering in Fig. source classes. The moreclustering traditional in way the sky. to These do searchesand this are atmospheric is dominated neutrinos by to atmospheric for use muonssuch the up-going for searches down-going “track” events. [ events channel and Both search ANTARES for and IceCube have performed 5.2 Point Source Searches overview of current limits on neutrino pointin sources Fig. from both ANTARES and IceCube canto be seen allow as much low-energysitivity signal to as clustering possible (under to the belaws). accepted, assumption In which that principle, in neutrino searches for turn source point maximizesportional spectra sources to the are in the sen- neutrinos steeply-falling square should power root have of theirthan observation sensitivities that time. scale because Up pro- of improvements to in this analysis pointreconstruction technique in techniques (such time as (mostly the the improvements inclusion scaling in of has reconstruction eventhas been quality/angular energy) faster also and error). performed IceCube a clusteringlier. study Even though using this the sample should high-energy beangular starting-event signal-dominated, resolution sample the of described limited shower-type amount ear- events of limits statisticsany the and significant sensitivity poor clustering of after this trial-correction search which (see has Fig. not yielded Figure 2: based study of thephysical diffuse component neutrino are flux. shown as Best-fitseen colored at contributions lines. the of high-energy atmospheric An end excess of backgrounds the above and distribution. atmospheric an [ expectations astro- can clearly be Recent Results in Neutrino Astronomy PoS(ICRC2015)1066PoS(ICRC2015)002 -ray γ ] C. Kopper ]. 25 14 15 8 7 8 7 6 0 5 4 ...... 30 0 0 0 1 0 0 2 0 7 1 + + + + + 6 7 0 7 as measured at Earth. . . . . 35 τ ]. Also point sources . 3 3 0 ν : 2 29 µ , as measured ν ’. Composi- : 28 t L. Mohrmann e ⇥ ]. It should be noted, however, ν n 08 08 7 5 7 6 4 0 : . . 32 ...... 0 0 0 0 2 0 0 1 69 0 µ . + + + + n 1 2 3 0 : ], respectively. The . . . 53 , where we focus on e + . 3 3 0 n 24 3(a) 7 2 2 2 ]. Triggers are (or were) sent to networks of small 34 , cm cm cm 33 1 1 1 sr sr sr 1 1 1 ]. s s s 1 1 1 26 —2 Results on the flavor composition, using hy- PeV — 2 ] and Enberg et al. [ confidence level. s 23 GeV GeV GeV 18 18 18 Constraints on flavor composition of the astrophysical neutrino flux from a global fit of various Figure 2: pothesis B for the energy spectrum.triangle Each corresponds to point a on ratio the at Earth. The besttions fit expected is for three marked different with sourceindicated. ‘ scenarios are 6 10 10 10 One of the most prominent transient sources discussed as candidates for the production of Best-fit results for the flavor composition fit. The quoted astrophysical neutrinos are gamma-ray bursts (GRBs). These objects generate very bright searches using a joint sample of IceCube and ANTARES data have been performed [ 5.3 Limits on Transient Sources signals within a short durationrelevant of background typically from 1 atmospheric to neutrinos 100 toneutrino seconds. GRBs observations is Because significantly within of reduced a this and shortinterest. short even time single No time span, such window the coincidence coincident hasGRBs been to as reported the a so sources GRB far, of which cosmic would places rays be stringent of the limits of reported on significant neutrino models flux of [ robotic telescopes (ROTSE and TAROT), the Palomar Transient Factory (PTF), the SWIFT X-ray Figure 3: other IceCube analyses. Each point on the triangle corresponds to a ratio searches in IceCube andto ANTARES are the beginning usual to track use channel to the improve starting sensitivity event to channel lower in energies addition [ that other transient phenomena such as off-axis orthe failed progenitor GRBs star) (GRBs and where several the other jet modelstive does are to not not escape a ruled wide out range by of this transientin non-observation. phenomena, direction both To and be ANTARES time. and sensi- IceCube Versions of search thesewith for searches event other are clusters run observatories in are real-time so possible that [ follow-up observations Recent Results in Neutrino Astronomy Compositions expected for three different source scenarios (before oscillations) are indicated. [ L ln e t µ cut g f D f f
with 10 years of data. Note that a single isotropic cosmic E 2
Param. Unit Hyp. A Hyp. B s