DOCSLIB.ORG

Plato__039 S Cosmology and

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Plato__039 S Cosmology and P1: JZZ 0521845602agg.xml CY531/Carone 0521 84560 2 August 26, 2005 18:27 Plato’s Cosmology and Its Ethical Dimensions Although a great deal has been written on Plato’s ethics, his cos- mology has not received so much attention in recent times, and its importance for his ethical thought has remained underexplored. By offering integrated accounts of Timaeus, Philebus, Politicus, and Laws X, the book reveals a strongly symbiotic relation between the cosmic and the human sphere. It is argued that in his late period Plato presents a picture of an organic universe, endowed with struc- ture and intrinsic value, which both urges our respect and calls for our responsible intervention. Humans are thus seen as citizens of a universe that can provide a context for their flourishing even in the absence of good political institutions. The book sheds new light on many intricate metaphysical issues in late Plato, and brings out the close connections between his cosmology and the development of his ethics. Gabriela Roxana Carone teaches at the University of Colorado at Boulder and is a Fellow of the Harvard University Center for Hellenic Studies. i P1: JZZ 0521845602agg.xml CY531/Carone 0521 84560 2 August 26, 2005 18:27 ii P1: JZZ 0521845602agg.xml CY531/Carone 0521 84560 2 August 26, 2005 18:27 Plato’s Cosmology and Its Ethical Dimensions GABRIELA ROXANA CARONE University of Colorado at Boulder and Harvard University Center for Hellenic Studies iii P1: JZZ 0521845602agg.xml CY531/Carone 0521 84560 2 August 26, 2005 18:27 cambridge university press Cambridge, New York, Melbourne, Madrid, Cape Town, Singapore, S˜aoPaulo Cambridge University Press 40 West 20th Street, New York, ny 10011-4211, usa www.cambridge.org Information on this title: www.cambridge.org/9780521845601 C Cambridge University Press 2005 This publication is in copyright. Subject to statutory exception and to the provisions of relevant collective licensing agreements, no reproduction of any part may take place without the written permission of Cambridge University Press. First published 2005 Printed in the United States of America A catalog record for this publication is available from the British Library. Library of Congress Cataloging in Publication Data Carone, Gabriela Roxana. Plato’s cosmology and its ethical dimensions / Gabriela Roxana Carone. p. cm. Includes bibliographical references and index. isbn 0-521-84560-2 1. Plato. 2. Cosmology, Ancient. 3. Ethics, Ancient. I. Title. b398.c67c37 2005 113 .092–dc22 2005046970 isbn-13 978-0-521-84560-1 hardback isbn-10 0-521-84560-2 hardback Cambridge University Press has no responsibility for the persistence or accuracy of urls for external or third-party Internet Web sites referred to in this publication and does not guarantee that any content on such Web sites is, or will remain, accurate or appropriate. iv P1: JZZ 0521845602agg.xml CY531/Carone 0521 84560 2 August 26, 2005 18:27 A Rosa Mazzini, en mi recuerdo v P1: JZZ 0521845602agg.xml CY531/Carone 0521 84560 2 August 26, 2005 18:27 vi P1: JZZ 0521845602agg.xml CY531/Carone 0521 84560 2 August 26, 2005 18:27 Contents Preface page ix 1 Introduction 1 I. Why Cosmology and Ethics? 1 II. Plato’s Cosmology in the Context of the Dynamics of Plato’s Thought 7 III. Plato’s Cosmology and the Interpretation of Plato’s Dialogues 13 IV. The Plan of this Book 18 V. The Order of the Dialogues 22 2 Demiurgy in the Timaeus 24 I. Introduction 24 II. The Philosophical Meaning of the Demiurge 29 III. The Ontological Status of the Demiurge 42 IV. Conclusion 51 3 Cosmic God and Human Reason in the Timaeus 53 I. The Cosmic God as a Model for Human Reason 54 II. Divine and Human Demiurgy 62 III. The Ethical Function of Astronomy 68 IV. Conclusion 78 4 Creating Mixtures in the Philebus 79 I. The Dialectical Prelude and the Context for the Cosmological Discussion 81 II. Cosmology and the Fourfold Classification 85 III. Conclusion 102 vii P1: JZZ 0521845602agg.xml CY531/Carone 0521 84560 2 August 26, 2005 18:27 viii Contents 5 Happiness in the Universe of the Philebus 103 I. Pleasure, God, and Human Life 104 II. Happiness for All Humans: The Socratic Revival and the Philebus’ Educational Suggestions 116 III. Conclusion 122 6 Reversing the Myth of the Politicus 124 I. Understanding the Politicus Myth: Why does It Matter? 125 II. Some Gaps in the Traditional Interpretation 129 III. The States of the Cosmos Successively Presented in the Text 132 IV. Autonomy and Divine Guidance 141 V. Conclusion 144 7 Cosmic and Human Drama in the Politicus 146 I. The Cosmological Significance of the Myth 147 II. The Ethical and Political Meaning of the Myth 153 III. Conclusion 160 8 Laws X: First Causes and the Origin of Evil 162 I. The Priority of Soul over Body 164 II. What is the Evil Soul? Some Questions 170 III. The Scope of “Soul” at Laws 896e–897b 172 IV. The Status of an Evil Soul at a Cosmic Level 174 V. Humans, Evil, and Teleology 178 9 Conclusion 189 Notes 197 Bibliographical References 265 Index Locorum 281 General Index 305 P1: JZZ 0521845602agg.xml CY531/Carone 0521 84560 2 August 26, 2005 18:27 Preface This book is the result of many years of thought and research, and has taken on several different shapes before reaching its final version. It started as a project based on (and soon took off beyond) my Ph.D. thesis, written between 1992 and 1995.Myresearch on Plato’s cosmology goes back somewhat further, and I am happy that, as this book is coming to fruition, my La nocion´ de dios en el Timeo de Platon´ , originally published in Buenos Aires in 1991,isdue to appear in its second edition for a Spanish-speaking readership. Proper acknowledgements were made in both those productions to scholars and institutions, in Argentina and in England, which contributed to my research then. But I would like here to thank David Sedley and Richard Sorabji for their keen criticism early on. Iamalso grateful to Christopher Shields and Raphael Woolf, who com- mented on different chapters of the book, and to the anonymous refer- ees for Cambridge University Press for their helpful suggestions. It is my pleasure to thank, in addition, the National Endowment for the Human- ities for generous financial support, and the Center for Human Values at Princeton University, which has allowed me to finalise the manuscript in optimal research conditions and in an excellent collegial environment. Previous versions of sections of this book have appeared as follows: Chapter 2, Section II.2 is based on Carone (2004c); Chapter 3, Section III is based on Carone (1997); parts of Chapter 5, Section I are based on Carone (2000); Chapter 6 is based on Carone (2004a); parts of Chapter 7 are based on Carone (1993); and parts of Chapter 8 are based on Carone (1994). I am grateful to the editors of those outlets for permission to reprint this material. Princeton, February 2004 ix P1: JZZ 0521845602agg.xml CY531/Carone 0521 84560 2 August 26, 2005 18:27 x P1: JZZ 0521845602agg.xml CY531/Carone 0521 84560 2 August 26, 2005 18:27 Plato’s Cosmology and Its Ethical Dimensions xi P1: JZZ 0521845602agg.xml CY531/Carone 0521 84560 2 August 26, 2005 18:27 xii P1: JZX 0521845602c01.xml CY531/Carone 0521 84560 2 August 24, 2005 16:37 1 Introduction i. why cosmology and ethics? This book is a study of Plato’s late cosmology and its relation to Plato’s ethics. The combination might strike one as odd. Indeed, it might seem far from obvious, first, that Plato has any coherent cosmological story to tell; second, that even if he does, it would deserve any special attention beyond historical curiosity, still less as a necessary background for un- derstanding his ethical thinking. In the modern literature, it has in fact been quite common to investigate Plato’s ethics, but much less common to delve into his cosmology. At any rate, these two undertakings have usually been carried out in isolation from each other. Thus, for example, Terence Irwin’s extensive treatment in Plato’s Ethics contains no section on the Timaeus, and virtually no allusion to Plato’s cosmology and theol- ogy. Even more striking in this regard is Christopher Bobonich’s recent book on Plato’s later ethics and politics, Plato’s Utopia Recast, which, de- spite occupying more than 600 pages of exegetical treatment, does not for the most part consider it necessary, for its purposes, to take a stand on cosmological issues.1 Certainly, some fresh air has been brought to these topics in a few recent contributions, though an extensive treatment of Plato’s late cos- mology in relation to his ethics is lacking to this day. Julia Annas, for example, devotes a chapter of her Platonic Ethics, Old and New to the issue of assimilation with god, but does not do much in terms of inte- grating this aspect of Plato with other aspects of his ethical thinking, and is at any rate quite comfortable with the thought that Plato’s ethics can be understood independently of his metaphysical commitments.2 And, 1 P1: JZX 0521845602c01.xml CY531/Carone 0521 84560 2 August 24, 2005 16:37 2 Introduction more generally, even when the issue of assimilation with god has been addressed,3 it has been somewhat detached from an examination of what Plato means by “god” in those cases, and of how such an issue may relate to his wider views about nature.
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Right to Peace, Which Occurred on 19 December 2016 by a Majority of Its Member States
    In July 2016, the Human Rights Council (HRC) of the United Nations in Geneva recommended to the General Assembly (UNGA) to adopt a Declaration on the Right to Peace, which occurred on 19 December 2016 by a majority of its Member States. The Declaration on the Right to Peace invites all stakeholders to C. Guillermet D. Fernández M. Bosé guide themselves in their activities by recognizing the great importance of practicing tolerance, dialogue, cooperation and solidarity among all peoples and nations of the world as a means to promote peace. To reach this end, the Declaration states that present generations should ensure that both they and future generations learn to live together in peace with the highest aspiration of sparing future generations the scourge of war. Mr. Federico Mayor This book proposes the right to enjoy peace, human rights and development as a means to reinforce the linkage between the three main pillars of the United Nations. Since the right to life is massively violated in a context of war and armed conflict, the international community elaborated this fundamental right in the 2016 Declaration on the Right to Peace in connection to these latter notions in order to improve the conditions of life of humankind. Ambassador Christian Guillermet Fernandez - Dr. David The Right to Peace: Fernandez Puyana Past, Present and Future The Right to Peace: Past, Present and Future, demonstrates the advances in the debate of this topic, the challenges to delving deeper into some of its aspects, but also the great hopes of strengthening the path towards achieving Peace.
    [Show full text]
  • Plato Journal
    DEZ 2013 ISSN 2079-7567 I3 eISSN 2183-4105 Established 1989 http://platosociety.org/ Papers William H.F. Altman “The Missing Speech of the Absent Fourth: Reader Response and Plato’s Timaeus-Critias” David Levy, “Socrates vs. Callicles: Examination and Ridicule in Plato’s Gorgias.” Nathalie Nercam, “En tout et pour tout (Théétète 204a-210b)” Matthew Robinson, “Competition, Imagery, and Pleasure in Plato’s Republic, 1-91” Scott J. Senn, “Ignorance or Irony in Plato’s Socrates?: A Look Beyond Avowals and Disavowals of Knowledge” INTERNATIONAL PLATO SOCIETY PLATO INTERNATIONAL PL ATO Société Platonicienne JOURNALInternationale Associazione Internazionale dei Platonisti Sociedad Internacional de Platonistas Internationale Platon-Gesellschaft Imprensa da Universidade de Coimbra Coimbra Universiy Press 2 | Enicaper ficaed susta nondin is es nonim et dolore CREDITS EditOriAL BOARD INterNAtiONAL PLATO Francisco Gonzalez SOcietY EXecutiVE University of Ottawa COmmittee (2013-16) Irmgard Männlein-Robert President: Francisco Bravo Universität Tübingen Universidad Central de Venezuela Angela Ulacco President: Gabriele Cornelli Albert-Ludwigs-Universität Freiburg Universidade de Brasília Vice President: Tom Robinson ScieNtific BOArd University of Toronto Luc Brisson Ex-President: Mauro Tulli CNRS – UPR76 Centre Jean-Pépin, Paris Università degli Studi di Pisa Tomás Calvo Next President: Luc Brisson Universidad Complutense, Madrid CNRS – UPR76 Centre Jean-Pépin, Paris John Dillon Next President: Olivier Renaut Trinity College, Dublin Université Paris
    [Show full text]
  • A Book of Jewish Thoughts Selected and Arranged by the Chief Rabbi (Dr
    GIFT OF Digitized by the Internet Archive in 2007 with funding from IVIicrosoft Corporation http://www.archive.org/details/bookofjewishthouOOhertrich A BOOK OF JEWISH THOUGHTS \f A BOOK OF JEWISH THOUGHTS SELECTED AND ARRANGED BY THE CHIEF EABBI (DR. J. H. HERTZ) n Second Impression HUMPHREY MILFORD OXFORD UNIVERSITY PRESS LONDON EDINBURGH GLASGOW COPENHAGEN NEW YORK TORONTO MELBOURNE CAPE TOWN BOMBAY CALCUTTA MADRAS SHANGHAI PEKING 5681—1921 TO THE SACRED MEMORY OF THE SONS OF ISRAEL WHO FELL IN THE GREAT WAR 1914-1918 44S736 PREFATORY NOTE THIS Book of Jewish Thoughts brings the message of Judaism together with memories of Jewish martyrdom and spiritual achievement throughout the ages. Its first part, ^I am an Hebrew \ covers the more important aspects of the life and consciousness of the Jew. The second, ^ The People of the Book \ deals with IsraeFs religious contribution to mankind, and touches upon some epochal events in IsraeFs story. In the third, ' The Testimony of the Nations \ will be found some striking tributes to Jews and Judaism from non-Jewish sources. The fourth pai-t, ^ The Voice of Prayer ', surveys the Sacred Occasions of the Jewish Year, and takes note of their echoes in the Liturgy. The fifth and concluding part, ^The Voice of Wisdom \ is, in the main, a collection of the deep sayings of the Jewish sages on the ultimate problems of Life and the Hereafter. The nucleus from which this Jewish anthology gradually developed was produced three years ago for the use of Jewish sailors and soldiers. To many of them, I have been assured, it came as a re-discovery of the imperishable wealth of Israel's heritage ; while viii PREFATORY NOTE to the non-Jew into whose hands it fell it was a striking revelation of Jewish ideals and teachings.
    [Show full text]
  • Excessive Use of Force by the Police Against Black Americans in the United States
    Inter-American Commission on Human Rights Written Submission in Support of the Thematic Hearing on Excessive Use of Force by the Police against Black Americans in the United States Original Submission: October 23, 2015 Updated: February 12, 2016 156th Ordinary Period of Sessions Written Submission Prepared by Robert F. Kennedy Human Rights Global Justice Clinic, New York University School of Law International Human Rights Law Clinic, University of Virginia School of Law Justin Hansford, St. Louis University School of Law Page 1 of 112 TABLE OF CONTENTS Executive Summary & Recommendations ................................................................................................................................... 4 I. Pervasive and Disproportionate Police Violence against Black Americans ..................................................................... 21 A. Growing statistical evidence reveals the disproportionate impact of police violence on Black Americans ................. 22 B. Police violence against Black Americans compounds multiple forms of discrimination ............................................ 23 C. The treatment of Black Americans has been repeatedly condemned by international bodies ...................................... 25 D. Police killings are a uniquely urgent problem ............................................................................................................. 25 II. Legal Framework Regulating the Use of Force by Police ................................................................................................
    [Show full text]
  • Beachermar12.Pdf
    THE TM 911 Franklin Street Weekly Newspaper Michigan City, IN 46360 Volume 25, Number 9 Thursday, March 12, 2009 The Young People’s Theatre Company brings to Michigan City by Charles McKelvy A Michigan City couple walk into Elston Middle School Performing Arts Center on March 21 at 7:30 p.m., sit down, and laugh themselves silly for a really, really good cause. Why? Because Chicago’s legendary comedy theatre The Sec- ond City will aim their blistering comedy at Michigan City that evening in a single performance to raise need- ed funds for The Young People’s Theatre Company. Why? Because The Young People’s Theatre Company has been mounting Broadway quality productions since they fi rst dazzled local audiences with a sparkling rendition of Joseph and the Amazing Technicolor Dreamcoat in 2004. Formed by Steve Gonzalez and Andrew Tallack- son to give La Porte County youth from 13 to 21 an op- portunity to excel in theatrical productions. Members of The Second City Green Company The newly minted theatre company sold out their per- formances of Joseph and went on to thrill their growing audi- ence with The Wiz and Scrooge the Mu- sical in 2005, Beau- ty and the Beast in 2006, Wizard of Oz in 2007, The Fan- tasticks in 2007 and 2008, and their celebrated reprise of Joseph and the Amazing Technicol- or Dreamcoat last summer. Continued on Page 2 THE Page 2 March 12, 2009 THE 911 Franklin Street • Michigan City, IN 46360 219/879-0088 • FAX 219/879-8070 In Case Of Emergency, Dial e-mail: News/Articles - [email protected] email: Classifieds - [email protected] http://www.thebeacher.com/ PRINTED WITH Published and Printed by TM Trademark of American Soybean Association THE BEACHER BUSINESS PRINTERS Delivered weekly, free of charge to Birch Tree Farms, Duneland Beach, Grand Beach, Hidden 911 Shores, Long Beach, Michiana Shores, Michiana MI and Shoreland Hills.
    [Show full text]
  • Plato's Symposium
    PLATO’S SYMPOSIUM Continuum Reader’s Guides Continuum’s Reader’s Guides are clear, concise and accessible introduc- tions to classic works of philosophy. Each book explores the major themes, historical and philosophical context and key passages of a major philosophical text, guiding the reader towards a thorough under- standing of often demanding material. Ideal for undergraduate students, the guides provide an essential resource for anyone who needs to get to grips with a philosophical text. Reader’s Guides available from Continuum Aristotle’s Nicomachean Ethics – Christopher Warne Aristotle’s Politics – Judith A. Swanson and C. David Corbin Berkeley’s Principles of Human Knowledge – Alasdair Richmond Berkeley’s Three Dialogues – Aaron Garrett Deleuze and Guattari’s Capitalism and Schizophrenia – Ian Buchanan Deleuze’s Difference and Repetition – Joe Hughes Derrida’s Writing and Difference – Sarah Wood Descartes’ Meditations – Richard Francks Hegel’s Philosophy of Right – David Rose Heidegger’s Being and Time – William Blattner Heidegger’s Later Writings – Lee Braver Hobbes’s Leviathan – Laurie M. Johnson Bagby Hume’s Dialogues Concerning Natural Religion – Andrew Pyle Hume’s Enquiry Concerning Human Understanding – Alan Bailey and Dan O’Brien Kant’s Critique of Aesthetic Judgement – Fiona Hughes Kant’s Critique of Pure Reason – James Luchte Kant’s Groundwork for the Metaphysics of Morals – Paul Guyer Kuhn’s The Structure of Scientific Revolutions – John Preston Locke’s Essay Concerning Human Understanding – William Uzgalis Locke’s Second Treatise of Government – Paul Kelly Mill’s On Liberty – Geoffrey Scarre Mill’s Utilitarianism – Henry West Nietzsche’s On the Genealogy of Morals – Daniel Conway Plato’s Republic – Luke Purshouse Rousseau’s The Social Contract – Christopher Wraight Sartre’s Being and Nothingness – Sebastian Gardner Spinoza’s Ethics – Thomas J.
    [Show full text]
  • 2021 Louisiana Recreational Fishing Regulations
    2021 LOUISIANA RECREATIONAL FISHING REGULATIONS www.wlf.louisiana.gov 1 Get a GEICO quote for your boat and, in just 15 minutes, you’ll know how much you could be saving. If you like what you hear, you can buy your policy right on the spot. Then let us do the rest while you enjoy your free time with peace of mind. geico.com/boat | 1-800-865-4846 Some discounts, coverages, payment plans, and features are not available in all states, in all GEICO companies, or in all situations. Boat and PWC coverages are underwritten by GEICO Marine Insurance Company. In the state of CA, program provided through Boat Association Insurance Services, license #0H87086. GEICO is a registered service mark of Government Employees Insurance Company, Washington, DC 20076; a Berkshire Hathaway Inc. subsidiary. © 2020 GEICO CONTENTS 6. LICENSING 9. DEFINITIONS DON’T 11. GENERAL FISHING INFORMATION General Regulations.............................................11 Saltwater/Freshwater Line...................................12 LITTER 13. FRESHWATER FISHING SPORTSMEN ARE REMINDED TO: General Information.............................................13 • Clean out truck beds and refrain from throwing Freshwater State Creel & Size Limits....................16 cigarette butts or other trash out of the car or watercraft. 18. SALTWATER FISHING • Carry a trash bag in your car or boat. General Information.............................................18 • Securely cover trash containers to prevent Saltwater State Creel & Size Limits.......................21 animals from spreading litter. 26. OTHER RECREATIONAL ACTIVITIES Call the state’s “Litterbug Hotline” to report any Recreational Shrimping........................................26 potential littering violations including dumpsites Recreational Oystering.........................................27 and littering in public. Those convicted of littering Recreational Crabbing..........................................28 Recreational Crawfishing......................................29 face hefty fines and litter abatement work.
    [Show full text]
  • UNIVERSITY of CALIFORNIA, SAN DIEGO Democratic Education in The
    UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, SAN DIEGO Democratic Education in the Works of Plato A dissertation submitted in partial satisfaction of the requirements for the degree Doctor of Philosophy in Political Science by Richard A. Barrett Committee in charge: Professor Tracy B. Strong, Chair Professor Page duBois Professor Fonna Forman Professor Marcel Hénaff Professor Gerry Mackie 2014 Copyright Richard A. Barrett, 2014 All rights reserved. The Dissertation of Richard A. Barrett is approved, and it is acceptable in quality and form for publication on microfilm and electronically: ______________________________________________ ______________________________________________ ______________________________________________ Chair UNIVERSITY OF CALIFORNIA, SAN DIEGO 2014 iii DEDICATION To those who have shared conversations about our world with me. iv TABLE OF CONTENTS Signature Page……………………………………………………………………...…iii Dedication……………………………………………………………………………..iv Table of Contents……………………………………………………………………....v Vita…………………………………………………………………………………....vii Abstract of the Dissertation.………………………………………………………....viii Introduction: Plato and the Problem of Democratic Education ..................................... 1 Chapter 1 Reading Plato: Plato and Xenophon as Teachers and Poets ............. 7 1.1 Introduction ...................................................................................................... 7 1.2 Comparison of Apologies ................................................................................ 8 1.3 Plato on the Relationship of Philosophy,
    [Show full text]
  • Title Spons Agency Bureau No Pub Date Contract Note
    DOCUMENT LIZSUME ED 071' C87 82 015 524 TITLE Project Musics Reader 2,Motion in the Heavens. .INSTITUTION Harvard Univ., Cambridge,Mass. Harvard Project _Physics. SPONS AGENCY Office of Education (DREW), Washington, D.C.,Bureau of Research. BUREAU NO BK-5-1038 PUB DATE 68 CONTRACT 08C-5-10-058 NOTE 233p.; Authorized InterimVersion EDRS PRICE MF -$0.65 HC-89.87 _DESCRIPTORS Astronomy; Instructional Materials;.*Motion; *Physics; Science, Fiction;. Science Materials; _Secondary Grades; *Secondary School Science; *Space; *Supplementary Reading Materials IDENTIFIER'S Harvard Project Physics ABSTRACT As a supplement to.Projpct Physics Unit 2, specially, selected articles are presented in this reader for student browsing. _Eight excerpts are given under headings:,the starry messenger, Newton_. And the principia, an appreciation of the earth, space the unconquerable, Is there intelligent life beyond the earth3,11 the life story of a galaxy, expansion of the universe, and Dyson sphere. Seven book passages. are included under. the, headings of the black cloud, roll call, a night at the observatory, Repler's celestial music, universal gravitation, a table of stars within twenty-two light years that could have habitable planets, and three poetic _fragments about astronomy. The remaining articles includea preface to the books of the ,revolutions, Kepler, Kepler on. Mars, laws of ..motion and proposition one,, garden of Epicurus, a search for life on earth at Kilometer resolution, the. boy who redeemed his father's _name, great comet of 1965, gravity experiments, unidentified flying objects, and negative mass. Illustrations for explanationpurposes . are provided. The work of Harvard. Project Physics has been .financially supported by: the Carnegie Corporation of New York, the Ford.
    [Show full text]
  • Max Planck Institute for the History of Science Aristotle And
    MAX-PLANCK-INSTITUT FÜR WISSENSCHAFTSGESCHICHTE Max Planck Institute for the History of Science 2012 PREPRINT 422 TOPOI – Towards a Historical Epistemology of Space Pietro Daniel Omodeo, Irina Tupikova Aristotle and Ptolemy on Geocentrism: Diverging Argumentative Strategies and Epistemologies TOPOI – TOWARDS A HISTORICAL EPISTEMOLOGY OF SPACE The TOPOI project cluster of excellence brings together researchers who investigate the formation and transformation of space and knowledge in ancient civilizations and their later developments. The present preprint series presents the work of members and fellows of the research group Historical Epistemology of Space which is part of the TOPOI cluster. The group is based on a cooperation between the Humboldt University and the Max Planck Institute for the History of Science in Berlin and commenced work in September 2008. Contents 1 Introduction 1 2 Aristotle 5 2.1 Aristotle’s confrontation with the cosmologies of his prede- cessors . 6 2.2 Aristotle’s presentation of his own views . 9 3 Ptolemy 15 3.1 The heavens move like a sphere . 16 3.2 The Earth, taken as a whole, is sensibly spherical . 24 3.3 The Earth is in the middle of the heavens . 24 3.4 The Earth has the ratio of a point to the heavens . 32 3.5 The Earth does not have any motion from place to place . 33 4 Conclusions and perspectives 37 Chapter 1 Introduction This paper aims at a comparison of the different argumentative strategies employed by Aristotle and Ptolemy in their approaches to geocentrism through an analysis of their discussion of the centrality of the Earth in De caelo II, 13-14 and Almagest, I, 3-7.
    [Show full text]
  • PROCEEDINGS Table of Contents Basanizein
    PROCEEDINGS Table of Contents Basanizein. Practical Experience as the Touchstone of Platonic Education ................................................. 1 Francisco Benoni (University of Verona) Concealment, Compulsion, and the Educated Citizen of the Protagoras .................................................... 8 Ryan Drake (Fairfield University) Imag(in)ing Nature and Art in Plato’s Phaedrus......................................................................................... 20 Marina McCoy (Boston University) Aristotle, Philosophêmata, and Aristotle’s Disciplinary History of Philosophy .......................................... 25 Chris Moore (Pennsylvania State University) Aristotle on Pleonexia, Proper Self-Love and the Unity of Justice.............................................................. 32 Marta Jimenez (Emory university) Philodemus and the Peripatetics on the Role of Anger in the Virtuous Life .............................................. 42 David Kaufmann (Transylvania University) Among the Boys and Young Men: Philosophy and Masculinity in Plato’s Lysis ......................................... 50 Yancy Dominick (Seattle University) The Dis-Community of Lovers: Kinship in the Lysis ..................................................................................... 58 Benjamin Frazer-Simser (DePaul University) How to Speak Kata Phusin: Magico-religious Speech in Heraclitus ............................................................ 71 Jessica Elbert Decker (California State University) Heraclitus and the Riddle
    [Show full text]
  • Epistemic Beliefs and Coherence of Justification in Modern Cosmology
    Journal of Siberian Federal University. Humanities & Social Sciences 7 (2013 6) 957-1001 ~ ~ ~ УДК 24-17 The Universe as a Construct: Epistemic Beliefs and Coherence of Justification in Modern Cosmology Alexei V. Nesteruk* University of Portsmouth, Lion Gate Building, PORTSMOUTH, PO1 3HF, UK Received 12.03.2013, received in revised form 06.06.2013, accepted 19.06.2013 In this paper we continue to study the epistemic nature of cosmological claims, in particular the status of the notion of the universe as a whole. It is demonstrated that this notion has a status of a construct with some epistemic links with empirical reality. However, it is argued that the effective methodology of contemporary mathematical cosmology related to the modelling of the very early stages of the evolutionary universes, consists not in the principle of correspondence of its theoretical constructs with empirical reality, but in the coherence of epistemic justification which relates to belief-like commitments of the community of cosmologists. As a case study, the inflationary model of the early universe is analysed and it is demonstrated that the coherence of justification leads to the transcendental problems in the style of Kant. Keywords: beliefs, cosmology, coherence, correspondence principle, epistemology, extrapolation, universe. The real world is not a thing founded in itself, that can in a significant manner be established as an independent existence. Recognition of the world as it comes from God cannot … be achieved by cognitions crystallising into separate judgements that have an independent meaning and assert definite facts. It can be gained only by symbolic construction. Hermann Weyl, Mind and Nature, p.
    [Show full text]