Random Walk Models Classifications: an Empirical Study for Malaysian Stock Indices
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
American Journal of Applied Sciences 5 (4): 411-417, 2008 ISSN 1546-9239 © 2008 Science Publications Random Walk Models Classifications: An Empirical Study for Malaysian Stock Indices Chin Wen Cheong Faculty of Information Technology Multimedia University, 63100 Cyberjaya, Selangor, Malaysia Abstract: This article studied the Random Walk models introduced by Campbell et al.[2] for Malaysian stock market. The analysis is implemented under the possible drastic economics structural change using an iterative structural change test. After the break-date identification, the random walk hypothesis is tested by multiple variance ratios test in two separate periods. We further examined the serial correlations of return’s squared innovations for random walk classifications. Our empirical results evidenced the random walk type 3 dominating most of the Malaysian stock indices. Keywords: structural break, market efficiency, stock market, unit root test, random walk. INTRODUCTION can provide insight understanding of efficiency market hypothesis (EMH). However, the RWH can only be Informationally efficiency is often used to describe treated as equivalent to EMH under the risk neutrality how all relevant information is impounded into the condition. Investors, economists and econometricians security prices of financial markets. Fama’s[1] weak- have shown considerable interests to identify these form efficient market hypothesis (EMH), which is our processes which are important in their investments, focus, stated that the current asset price is determine implication of market efficiency and developing correct only by its historical prices (information set) of that model specifications. particular asset. If stock price failed to reject the As an emerging stock market, Kuala Lumpur stock random walk hypothesis (RWH), this implies that the exchange (KLSE) has received great attentions from future returns are unpredictable by using information on researchers and investors[5-8] as the case studies and past returns. On the other hand, if the stock prices is potential investment alternatives. For structural break characterised by a mean reverting (trend stationary) analysis, Chaudhuri and Wu[9] reject the null hypothesis process, then there is a tendency for the price level to of random walk in KLSE using 12 years monthly stock return to its trend path. This suggests that the presence prices among the other 17 emerging markets. Goh et al. of predictable component based on the historical [10] [2] relates the structural break and Asian financial crisis information. Campbell et al. further this study by for five ASEAN countries included Malaysian stock distinguishing the random walk processes into three index. They discovered a structural break on the date sub-hypotheses. The random walk 1(RW1) is the most of 1st September after the implementation of currency restrictive model which requires independent and USD and RM using the Vogelsang[11] approach. identically distributed (i.i.d) of the price changes. In [12] random walk 2(RW2), the restriction of identically Similarly Lean and Russell applied the LM unit root distributed condition is not imposed. Therefore, the test to examine the random walk hypothesis for eight unconditional heteroscedasticity is allows in the Asian countries including Malaysia using the natural log of weekly stock indices from 1991 to 2005. Chin increments. Finally, by relaxing the independence [8] restriction of RW2, the RW3 model is obtained. RW3 and Zaidi investigate the recovery period (after Asian is actually further examines the possible of serial crisis) of KLSE and found that the composite index correlation in the squared increments which leads to the follows a mean-reverting process. To the author’s best presence of conditional heteroscedasticity. This knowledge, relative less studies has been carried out at conditional volatility is well modeled by ARCH models the sectoral level under the presence of structural break. introduced by Engle[3] and Bollerslev[4] among others. It Thus, it is interesting to investigate the underlying is worth noted that RW3 contains RW1 and RW2 under processes under the nine sectoral markets in Malaysian special conditions. The implication of RWH sometimes stock market. Corresponding Author: Chin Wen Cheong, Faculty of Information Technology, Multimedia University, 63100 Cyberjaya, Selangor, Malaysia. Tel: +603-83125249, Fax: +603-83125264 411 Am. J. Applied Sci., 5 (4): 411-417, 2008 This study evaluates the possible type of random pt. The variance of a qth-differenced variable is q time walk in the Kuala Lumpur Stock Exchange (KLSE) and as large as the first differenced variable. The idea can the nine sectoral indices before and after the periods of be illustrated in the form of: Asia financial crisis. The ten selected stock indices V(pt- pt-q) = qV(pt - pt-1), (1) consist of KLCI and nine major multi-sectors such as industrial(IND), industrial product(INP), consumer where q is any positive integer. The variance ratio can products(COP), construction(CON), mining(MIN), further written as: finance(FIN), properties(PRO), plantation(PLA) and 1 2 qV ( pt − pt −q ) σ (q) trading/services(TRA) respectively. The Technology VR(q) = = . (2) V ( p − p ) 2 and Syariah indices are not included in our empirical t t −1 σ (1) 2 2 analysis due to the unavailability (begin at year 2000) The unbiased estimators σ (1) and σ (q) are denoted as: and overlapping listed companies which initially exist nq 2 in other sectors respectively. We firstly examine the ( pk − pk −1 − µˆ) random walk hypothesis using the multiple variance σˆ 2 (1) = k =1 ; (3) ratios. Each of the indices is group accordingly follows (nq −1) [2] the Campbell et al. random walk processes namely nq 2 the homoscedasticity RW (RW1), heteroscedasticity ( pk − pk −q − qµˆ) RW (RW2) respectively. For RW 3, even though the σˆ 2 (q) = k =q ; (4) returns series commonly follow the random walk m hypothesis with uncorrelated innovations, but their 1 q squared innovations often exhibit the presence of serial where µˆ = ( pnq − p0 ) and m = q(nq +1− q)(1− ) . correlations. This phenomena is also named as the nq nq conditional heteroscedasticity effect which introduced Two alternative test statistics Z(q) and Z*(q) with by Engle[3]. After the classifications of RW, we can the assumption of homomskeastic and heteroskedastic utilize the predictable component based on the increments random walk respectively. If the null historical information that may assist investors to hypothesis of homoskedastic increments of random produce above average profits. walk is not rejected, the associated test statistics has an Daily closing transaction price indices have been asymptotic standard normal distribution as follows: selected from 1996 to 2006 which covers before and VR(q) −1 after the Asian crisis. All the data are collected from Z(q) = , (5) σˆ0 (q) the DATASTREAM with 2578 observations for each 1 series. During this period, the KLSE composite index »2(2q −1)(q −1) 2 where σˆ0 (q) = … . On the other hand, (CI) come under severe pressure and encountered 3q(nq) drastic fall in price level. One of the objectives of this study is to examine whether the nine sectoral indices the associate test statistic for heteroskedastic increments follow the behaviour of the KLCI. The specific day of random walk, Z*(q) is given as follows: the structural break is determined by an iterative VR(q) −1 [13] Z *(q) = * ; (6) Chow’s test introduced by Andrews tests. σˆe (q) Alternatives for unknown break location test are such as 1 [14] [15] » 2 ÿ 2 CUSUM test by Brown et al and Bai and Perron q−1 ≈ ’ * … ∆ k ÷ ˆ Ÿ using UDMax and WDMax statistics among others. whereσˆe (q) = 4ƒ∆1− ÷ φk (7) … « q ◊ Ÿ k =1 ⁄ METHODOLOGY nq ( p − p − µˆ)2 ( p − p − µˆ)2 [16] ƒ j j−1 j−k j−k −1 Multiple Variance Ratios test: Lo and MacKinlay ˆ j=k +1 . (8) φk = focus on individual variance ratio test for a specific » nq ÿ … 2 Ÿ interval in random walk hypothesis. LOMAC conclude ( p j − p j − µˆ) …ƒ −1 Ÿ that in a finite sample the increments in the variance are j=1 ⁄ linear in the observation interval for a random walk. Chow and Denning[17] extend the test to cover all Lets a sample size of nq+1 observations(p0, p1, …., pnq) possible intervals which is consistent with the random at equally spaced intervals, where q is any integer walk hypothesis. The propose multiple variance greater than 1 and nq is the number of observations of ratios(MVR) test generated a procedure for multiple 412 Am. J. Applied Sci., 5 (4): 411-417, 2008 comparison of the varied set of variance ratio estimates Andrews[13] test. Except the trading & service index, with unity. Consider a set of variance ratio estimates, significant break points are found for all the other ˆ M r (qi ) | i = 1,2,...,m} , the random walk null hypothesis indices. The earliest break is experienced by the test a set of sub-hypothesis, H0i : Mr(qi) = 0 and H1i : Property index (12/25/1997) during the crisis, follows Mr(qi) ≠ 0. Since any rejection of H0i will lead to the by Finance (8/18/1998) and simultaneously by other rejection of the random walk null hypothesis, only the indices at 9/2/1998, a day after the Malaysian maximum absolute value in the set of test statistics is government imposed the currency policy. Most of the highlighted. The largest absolute value of the test indices rebounded significantly after the currency statistics are defined using the following probability inequality: controls, for example, the KLCI radically increase by 12%, Construction 13%, Finance, Plantation, Industrial P[max(|Z(q1)|, …, | Z(qm)|)≤SMM(α;m;N)] ≥ (1-α), (9) product, 9% and the lowest is 3% by Property. where the SMM(α;m;N) is the upper α point of Studentized Maximum Modulus(SMM) distribution 10 with parameter m and N(sample size) degrees of 9 freedom.