Book Reviews
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
BOOK REVIEWS REFERENCE Higgins develops her theme in a pattern that moves in an elegant sweep to develop surprising conclusions Fluxus Experience by Hannah Higgins (Berkeley & from well-known (and less known) facts. She reveals Lus Angeles, University of CaliforniaPress, 2002.259 the hidden depths of the subject by using apparently pages, 57 illustrations, $29.95 paper) simple Fluxus ideas to deveIop an unexpected range of topics that others have overlooked. 2002 was an interesting year for Fluxus. Most The preface and introduction make an important obviously, it was the fortieth anniversary of the point: Fluxus is experience before it is art, and it is the Wiesbaden festival that introduced the name Fluxus to philosophical and experiential nature of Fluxus that the world. Most important, it marks the appearance of has enabled it to remain a lively presence while the fimmonograph-length philosophical treatment of standard art movements come and go. Notably, the Fluxus idea by a single author. Higgins points to two issues. The first is philosophical, For many years, writing on Fluxus was the province a link to John Dewey, pragmatist philosopher and of enthusiastssharing their ideas, curators undertaking educator. The second is the fact that Fluxus itself has exhibitions, or journalists and art critics. While these always been an educational and philosophical venture. writings were often interesting, they were often filled Higgins's first chapter offers a re-reading of Flws with historical errors, and they sometimes revealed through the topic of vision and a close reading of more about the authors than they revealed about several works. In later chapters, close reading becomes Flwus. FIuxus also benefited from two special groups a central strategy of this book, and Higgins examines of documents. One is the astonishing series of archival specific works and types of work to develop central documents compiled by Jon Hendricks for the GiIbert topics of investigation. She also uses philosophy and and Lila Silvern Fluxus Foundation. The other is politics-in a wide sense- to good effect. Starting with the nearly fifty years of pamphlets, catalogues, books, several films and optical experiments, and ending with documents, event scores, and text-based artifacts a comment on globalization and the strategy of the compiled by the artists themselves. There are notable event as the locus of a democratic practice. high points-including the occasional monographic The second chapter, "Charting Fluxus: Picturing exhibition catalogues and special joumaI issues that History," explores the way that Fluxus artists provided a responsible and rich variety of critical and diagrammed themselves, and constructed their vision historical views by such authors as Stephen Foster, of the world. This leads neatly into the third chapter, Peter Frank, Estera Milman, or Marilyn Ravicz. Until a history of how Fluxus was received, and how it the 1990s, however, one kind of writing was rare: influenced and was ignored by other art streams of the serious, sympathetic, and well-informed discussions of 1960s and 19670e, including Pop Art, Conceptual Art, Fluxus from a philosophical and historical view. and Happenings. The theme of how Flm was In the 1990s, a new generation of Fluxus scholars received, understood, or-more often-misunderstood is began to fill this gap. Hannah Higgins is a charter continued in chapter four, "Great Expectations: A member of this group. Over the past decade, this group Reception Typology. " has included such scholars as Simon Anderson, Philip If these chapters had been the whole of this book, it Auslander, Ina Blom, David Doris, Kathy O'Dell, would have been sufficient for a major contribution, Craig Saper, Owen Smith, Kristine Stiles, and others - but the real core of this book appears at the end: notably Higgins herself - as well as newer voices, "Teaching and Learning as Art Forms: Toward a including Bertrand Clavez, Kevin Concannon, Anna Fluxus-Inspired Pedagogy." This chapter focuses on Dezeuze, Stephen Perkins, and Julia Robinson. Flms as a pedagogical encounter with the world. Until now, these authors have written doctoral After discussing the origins of Fluxus in John Cage's dissertations, book chapters and - in Smith's case - an composition classes at the New School for Social authoritative history of Fluxus. With Fluxlrs research, she notes some of the Fluxus artists and their Experience, the field moves forward to the deeper friends who have been deeply involved in teaching. consideration of central themes and topics. This includes such well-known names as Joseph Beuys, Geoffrey Hendricks, Allan Kaprow, and Robert 32 ~tqyooq e u! snxn~djo~uno33e pd e sraao su@%gq ye mqjaioux njy a~93ealas O~Mqsgnjo dnoa e o$ palms dp9apad uoge%gsarlu~pgdosojyd sr $1 'iCro$sy Fre ue uqaiom nj s! yooq sy~ j am03 -sIpap IF uy, mapad 01 $q%no sr 90% snl) se poo8 st! yooq .yoq lassai e ul SMEIJ 01 smA loj sag!sianc ~ojyoqwa$ pm az~uaraja~ v q3ns ]no* ale3 IOU ppoa aug .sloqne pa~onbaq orm mu e aq ~1%snl~. 'uoy?lp?lsul w oapp aAgma$u! JO $'try) 01 Map alpoddo ue ayel Aayl asne3aq lo 'smgp wry aql. 'ou~o7s,ueqslaH umf? 30 uogquaummp s,su@%gqjo~a~od aqa9np ha% asnmaq 3geuxalqo~d SF urayl 30 aug xpyxa uolslan pogelado ou ~DXM are asay 30 auxos .salonb a$:m33euy paiias 103 y1o.w.1~pue sdord epmwau 3uguammp pue saJepuamsyujo mqumu e a= a1aqL -s~ealouyu 'oapv pazgerp osp s! aiaqL -aremos pr3iamo:, JO qumu B Aq paysem si 11 -sysApue wawod pue ia~ndmo>auxoqpm 'sag!sranyn ~t?p1m3 arewos dgsme~oq~ssnouas jo yo^ e sr asua!~adxzsmnld 'spo~gaLmalg ~uapuadapm"Ire jq@q'same% ~~ZIJO .san%a~lo31aq pue su@%mst! saldma suqum yooq aq~ujuedmcme a3 aqL .q-srauraa snloqs q3ns 30 suognq~uo3ayl OJ svql.fau?iama ur~~pue 'Jarloo3 uaqox '~auu!~uop%ue? 'fame? MOU AVO S! JE~Ia~g~adsad lCreu~1dpsyp~a~u~ peolq e aqb~samaq asaqL .ppofi rre ayl apIslno uroy r?pual€f'uem~lt3pS PW3% 'aplnaL harl~'?WA amz~pm asnmaq puo3as pm awg sq jo peav 1118 'Aquew 'a$nodo.@a~=loqq~ 'pre~l~rpne~ $7 asnew w~y'suosear ow 103 pqooparlo uaaq seq mf 'Jaml)J:A11!8 -?3N In 'ouyle3 ~JOMsIz3pq ~nxn~d uo uauw uogwassq po~mp OW1 boslaN PL 'sq~~0JWI'S m!TFM 'Pal1aPE)nS uen~'%uyk~, uew psn8 g:namn 'sa%~o~sp? mrj aqul o8e smA &m sanssr asaq passarppe a%lof apnpu! sioJnqwuo3 aq'qa& apTM ppo& ayl z3pq mqa ~.QEN~s?o~dolqw aq pq Sugou 30 hua8.iawa aql pm 11 SZM plio~uaamaq pa~sypd OM sl 11 'sapnls snxnld 30 amps aq OJ sanssl jo a2m q3p e s2uuq qooq s,sul%%mr@uue~ alw Ap@pg 'saugdpslpssome %UIYJOM sppppu~pue 'pl1oa l.le ayl puohaq '~393pin:, 'sra&!sap a~?pqu~'sra)yhi lCre1a3g uoguaue Am 2up3aq Suyeal pogm~%ioprre 'slm$ry31t?'slsw 'wguaps ralndmm moy amm ~uama%ma%pal~oq U!yio~ MOU 1 pue 'ie~slanprn wa$aqL 'play gu@lama-~~gssw 30 uogepmoy arll nrroj pure fiowry aqapyuosyo I~J-pug01 a~q~ssoelw~ e u; ang jvq lapun palago aq oj SSB~s!pama)uf aq alqM 3a3sds JE wouqe MQU mayl jo dm-sweSoad la~ndwmpm lay Zu!dola~ap xq%w 1 'pr.10~aq tq wampadxa y3ns lsarlsea aw JO auo soap^. 'wa~wn[o3 (mox-aa pm WQPOO'SP$ 'EOOZ 'ssald m 'vm 'agppqrme3)~rojlmom q3i3a~ put! unend 'a8a1loa puampadxg a%a~lo~alqs o~spue~dms am 30 iapunoj-03 e sea lamag[Bar 'so96 I aqjo appp -WreM TON J@ WP 'J~PB~x@!PaH AaM a%I, ayl u~-pme 1uama~ag3e amgas1 e ylw lag paaouoq uoge!mssy a8allo3 ayj uaqM paz@o%r ~3ej '1082-11 ZOl AN %Oh MaN 'PZZ '3)s'ABMPO~~ B 'SISWJO suogeiarmaZ piaAas oj laqwa) pguanpq 669L "3UI 0) PQaS .00'6Z$ J'P~ ue uaaq sey 'snxn[dJO lapmoj-03 saqoue 'sal~oaq sf mAow IOJ am uogd~sqnsppxk y 'aro 57~10% uosrw .sanssl uog~y~t~moopue &!sap u! pa2e8ua sr jqfi WI)IM dn dmy 03 3u~ny~anpm IaAw oq~ Ire u~pwalalul asoq 103 1003 Wsmup@sap Lldaap st!^ pue auq3m 3upr.rts1 e pa3uanuy seunppq a%dqsazp81opmia~?-amu snxnu .siaqdoso~gd -1laM sw sajalduro3 (10103 UI IF)ho~3arTp uogarpsnlj! 3gqedyad 30 uogpenl leas aq n! a%xl-le q .axid Aq SMO~Spm OJ app2 e se se '%ngsqpgaqqdp m s! aiaq, 'p~io~aq$noq%noq -1aqcx-m e se pah~asoqMzsyoaq pw njoq3s pale3ypap swoqs pw S.FR~o$ ap@ e aago 01 uogm11qnd lCljreall e m@2~yxa ~apunoj-msnxn~ -ssy~re snxnid parlas Aq sagpp3e p3@o%qadio[m uaaq anq alaq -99% e s! (EOOZ 'cnepq210~ M~M) sdaoqcj 'pauoguaur QS~IEaq qps 8uow -pa57e2ua A~cHaap sanba$w PW S~PBuv apmpaon%ar=qq au uaaq aneq saAlasuraq qspsnxngd aq'aurayl prlua3 s* s* 01 papuam 1I~a.waneq snxnid uo srapw aim .sag@g3e snxn~30 punofia~ojaw o$ qdol sg%u?upq Aq a3p.1~pm.2 e surropad yooq Sm'WW snxn1,l Baom %uq3ea$pue 8u q sla-J* as6 p~ fau~3mL~, WIPg 9qti? 30 IQpnz ~o~l~~~UXpx$3 UO~E~~WA~? w SH '~amkoq"la~d.ey~ sw 30 ax03 aqJ +SUE& Smithsonian InstitutionPress, 2003, $36.95) discusses stunning story of the hunt, as well as a marvelous the premises for establishing the Farm Security presentation. Hebey's own introduction shows us AdminisIration established in the 1930s to portray an about the hunt for such items and the story of the urgent, powem reminder that "one -third of a nationy7 collecting instincts.