Nsda Nationals Topic 2021
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
N S D A N A T I O N A L T O U R N A M E N T T O P I C R E S O L V E D : A P U B L I C H E A L T H E M E R G E N C Y J U S T I F I E S L I M I T I N G C I V I L L I B E R T I E S . 0 TRIUMPH DEBATE LINCOLN DOUGLAS BRIEF – NSDA NATIONALS TOPIC 2021 1 TRIUMPH DEBATE LINCOLN DOUGLAS BRIEF – NSDA NATIONALS TOPIC 2021 In Collaboration With DFW Speech & Debate Staff 1 TRIUMPH DEBATE LINCOLN DOUGLAS BRIEF – NSDA NATIONALS TOPIC 2021 2 TRIUMPH DEBATE LINCOLN DOUGLAS BRIEF – NSDA NATIONALS TOPIC 2021 3 TRIUMPH DEBATE LINCOLN DOUGLAS BRIEF – NSDA NATIONALS TOPIC 2021 Table of Contents TOPIC ANALYSIS BY: MATT SLENCSAK ......................................................................................................................................... 8 Resolved: A public health emergency justifies limiting civil liberties. ................................................................................................................. 8 Introduction & Background .................................................................................................................................................................................. 8 Researching The Resolution ............................................................................................................................................................................... 10 Implementation .................................................................................................................................................................................................. 11 History of Public Health Emergencies ................................................................................................................................................................ 11 Ground (And any potential skew…) ................................................................................................................................................................... 12 Framing ............................................................................................................................................................................................................... 12 Conclusion .......................................................................................................................................................................................................... 13 FRAMING ................................................................................................................................................................................. 14 It is the obligation of people as global citizens to do as much as possible to protect the most vulnerable and the State to create the circumstances where that is possible ................................................................................................................................................................ 15 The social contract necessitates trading freedom for survival- the key is to allow for emergency powers when necessary, for collective safety .................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 16 Methods to resolve PHEs require a balancing of pragmatic and ethical concerns. Failure to do so only undermines the effectiveness of different tactics .................................................................................................................................................................................................. 17 The balancing of ethical principles during a PHE means assessing who is burdened by state action and determining if it is truly justified. A PHE does not immediately justify state action .................................................................................................................................................. 18 Global public health is deeply interconnected - we are only as safe as the most vulnerable person, globally ................................................ 19 AFFIRMATIVE EVIDENCE ........................................................................................................................................................... 21 Implementation / Solvency ............................................................................................................................................................... 22 Analysis across 58 countries finds that public trust increased compliance with restrictions during the COVID-19 pandemic ........................ 22 Taiwanese Policies and infrastructure from the 2003 SARS outbreak allowed for a targeted response to the Covid PHE, proving that governments do not have to default to larger interventions ............................................................................................................................ 24 Isolation and distancing can prevent from overwhelming hospitals and spreading to the most vulnerable ................................................... 25 Outbreaks inevitably stress the medical system- even with all other possible measures in place, distancing is required to prevent deaths 26 Digital health technologies helped with resource allocation, contact tracing, and quarantining for COVID ................................................... 27 A switch to digital technology allowed better real time prediction and reporting of pandemics .................................................................... 29 Malaria, HIV/AIDS, and foot and mouth disease all serve as successful historical examples of modeling to aid in pandemic response ........ 30 Disease Modeling in China allowed the country to provide crucial warning and analysis of effective mitigation policies .............................. 32 South Asia Exemplifies the Success of Using mandatory tracking to contain COVID-19................................................................................... 34 Vaccine mandates in Europe increase the proportion of the population getting vaccinated which supersedes any concerns of individual liberty ................................................................................................................................................................................................................. 35 Environmental ................................................................................................................................................................................... 37 Pollution within Delhi has reached levels that are literally off the charts. These concentrations increase heart disease, respiratory infections, and other forms of harm .................................................................................................................................................................. 37 PHE can help reframe environmental issues into their health consequences, allowing for them to be better confronted. The restrictions of civil liberties allow for first steps to be put in place as well .............................................................................................................................. 38 Air pollution is a global public health emergency .............................................................................................................................................. 39 Smog standards are critical for public health .................................................................................................................................................... 40 WASH (water, sanitation, and hygiene) is critical to fight public health crises like COVID-19 .......................................................................... 41 Water pollution negatively impacts public health ............................................................................................................................................. 42 Government policies that reduce pollution protect public health – laundry list .............................................................................................. 44 After declaring a public health emergency New Delhi has increased environmental focus in the energy, transportation, and agricultural industries ............................................................................................................................................................................................................ 45 The prevalence of air pollution in China has resulted in several positive policy changes in response to the public health crisis ................... 46 Outbreaks.......................................................................................................................................................................................... 47 Outbreaks justify limitations, as the only way for a nation to prevent them is to work ahead of the problem............................................... 47 COVID-19 Patients are seeing long term neurological, cardiovascular, and pulmonary system complications ............................................... 48 4 TRIUMPH DEBATE LINCOLN DOUGLAS BRIEF – NSDA NATIONALS TOPIC 2021 Long term economic consequences of pandemics can persist for 20 years ..................................................................................................... 50 Estimates suggest that lockdowns prevented 3.1 million deaths in the EU and 531 million in the US ...........................................................