Arxiv:2108.13854V1 [Cs.CL] 31 Aug 2021 (Source Domain) and Test Data (Target Domain)

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Arxiv:2108.13854V1 [Cs.CL] 31 Aug 2021 (Source Domain) and Test Data (Target Domain) Contrastive Domain Adaptation for Question Answering using Limited Text Corpora Zhenrui Yue Bernhard Kratzwald Stefan Feuerriegel Technical University of Munich ETH AI Center ETH Zurich [email protected] [email protected] [email protected] Abstract Question generation has recently shown im- pressive results in customizing question an- swering (QA) systems to new domains. These approaches circumvent the need for manu- ally annotated training data from the new do- main and, instead, generate synthetic question- answer pairs that are used for training. How- ever, existing methods for question generation rely on large amounts of synthetically gen- erated datasets and costly computational re- sources, which render these techniques widely inaccessible when the text corpora is of lim- ited size. This is problematic as many niche domains rely on small text corpora, which nat- urally restricts the amount of synthetic data that can be generated. In this paper, we pro- pose a novel framework for domain adaptation called contrastive domain adaptation for QA Figure 1: Overview of a common framework for QA (CAQA). Specifically, CAQA combines tech- domain adaptation. A question generation model is niques from question generation and domain- used to generate synthetic target data, which can be invariant learning to answer out-of-domain used for training the QA model with source data. The questions in settings with limited text corpora. resulting QA model can answer target questions upon Here, we train a QA system on both source deployment. data and generated data from the target domain with a contrastive adaptation loss that is incor- porated in the training objective. By combin- tive QA, both question and context are represented ing techniques from question generation and by running text, while the answer is defined by a domain-invariant learning, our model achieved start position and an end position in the context. considerable improvements compared to state- An existing challenge for extractive QA systems of-the-art baselines. is the distributional change between training data arXiv:2108.13854v1 [cs.CL] 31 Aug 2021 (source domain) and test data (target domain). If 1 Introduction there is such a distribution change, the performance Question answering (QA) systems generate an- on test data is likely to be impaired. In practice, swers to questions over text. Formally, such sys- this issue occurs due to the fact that users, for in- tems are nowadays trained end-to-end to predict stance, formulate text in highly diverse language answers conditional on an input question and a con- or use QA for previously unseen domains (Hazen text paragraph (e.g., Seo et al., 2016; Chen et al., et al., 2019; Miller et al., 2020). As a result, out-of- 2017a; Devlin et al., 2019). Therein, every QA domain (OOD) samples occur that diverge from the sample is a 3-tuple consisting of a question, a con- training corpora of QA systems (i.e., which can be text, and an answer. In this paper, we consider the traced back to the invariance of the training data) subproblem of extractive QA, where the task is to and, upon deployment, lead to a drastic drop in the extract answer spans from an unstructured context accuracy of QA systems. information for a given question as input. In extrac- One solution to the above-mentioned challenge of a domain shift is to generate synthetic data from while it simultaneously separates answer tokens for the corpora of the target domain using models for answer extraction.1 question generations and then use the synthetic The main contributions of our work are: data during training (e.g., Lee et al., 2020; Shakeri 1. We propose a novel framework for domain et al., 2020). For this purpose, generative mod- adaptation in QA called CAQA. To the best of els have been adopted to produce synthetic data our knowledge, this is the first use of contrastive as surrogates from target domain, so that the QA approaches for learning domain-invariant fea- system can be trained with both data from the tures in QA systems. source domain and synthetic data, which helps to 2. Our CAQA framework is particularly effective achieve better results on the out-of-domain data dis- for limited text corpora. In such settings, we tribution (Puri et al., 2020; Lee et al., 2020; Shak- show that CAQA can transfer knowledge to eri et al., 2020), see Figure1 for an overview of target domain without additional training cost. such approach. Nevertheless, large quantities of 3. We demonstrate that CAQA can effectively an- synthetic data require intensive computational re- swer out-of-domain questions. CAQA outper- sources. Moreover, many niche domains rely upon forms the current state-of-the-art baselines for limited text corpora. Their limited size puts bar- domain adaptation by a significant margin. riers to the amount of synthetic data that can be generated and, as well shall see later, render the 2 Related Work aforementioned approach for limited text corpora The performance of extractive question answer- largely ineffective. ing systems (e.g., Chen et al., 2017b; Kratzwald In computer vision, some works draw upon an- et al., 2019; Zhang et al., 2020) is known to deterio- other approach for domain adaptation, namely dis- rate when the training data (source domain) differs crepancy reduction of representations (Long et al., from the data used during testing (target domain) 2013; Tzeng et al., 2014; Long et al., 2015, 2017; (Talmor and Berant, 2019). Approaches to adapt Kang et al., 2019). Here, an adaptation loss or ad- QA systems to a certain domain can be divided in versarial training approaches are often designed to (1) supervised approaches, where one has access learn domain-invariant features, so that the model to labeled data from the target domain (i.e., trans- can transfer learnt knowledge from the source do- fer learning; Kratzwald and Feuerriegel, 2019), or main to the target domain. However, the afore- (2) unsupervised approaches, where no labeled in- mentioned approach for domain adaptation was formation is accessible. The latter is our focus. designed for computer vision tasks, and, to the best Unsupervised approaches are primarily based on of our knowledge, has not yet been tailored for QA. question generation techniques where one gener- In this paper, we develop a framework for an- ates synthetic training data for the target domain. swering out-of-domain questions in QA settings Question generation (QG): Question genera- with limited text corpora. We refer to our proposed tion (Rus et al., 2010) is the task of generating framework as contrastive domain adaptation for synthetic QA pairs from raw text data. Several ap- question answering (CAQA). CAQA combines proaches have been developed to generate synthetic question generation and contrastive domain adap- questions in QA. Du et al.(2017) propose an end- tation to learn domain-invariant features, so that it to-end seq2seq encoder-decoder for the generation. can capture both domains and thus transfer knowl- Recently, question generation and answer genera- edge to the target distribution. This is in contrast to tion are observed as dual tasks and combined in existing question generation where synthetic data various ways. Tang et al.(2017) train both simul- is solely used for joint training with the source data taneously; Golub et al.(2017) split the process in but without explicitly accounting for domain shifts, two consecutive stages; and Tang et al.(2018) use thus explaining why CAQA improves the perfor- policy gradient to improve between-task learning. mance in answering out-of-domain questions. For Question generation is a common technique for this, we propose a novel contrastive adaptation loss domain adaptation in QA. Here, the generated ques- that is tailored to QA. The contrastive adaptation tions are used to fine-tune QA systems to the new loss uses maximum mean discrepancy (MMD) to target domain (Dhingra et al., 2018). Oftentimes, measure the discrepancy in the representation be- 1The code from our CAQA framework is publicly available tween source and target features, which is reduced via https://github.com/Yueeeeeeee/CAQA only a subset of generated questions is selected to input is given by: increase the quality of the generated data. Com- mon approaches are based on curriculum learning • Training data from source domain: We are given labeled data from the source domain Xs. Each (Sachan and Xing, 2018); roundtrip consistency, (i) where samples are selected when the predicted an- sample xs 2 Xs from the source domain Ds (i) swers match the generated answer (Alberti et al., comprises of a 3-tuple with a question xs;q, a (i) (i) 2019); iterative refinement (Li et al., 2020); and context xs;c, and an answer xs;a. conditional priors (Lee et al., 2020). Target contexts Unsupervised domain adaptation: A large • : We have access to target domain body of work on unsupervised domain adaptation data. Yet, of note, the data is unlabeled. That has been done in the area of computer vision, where is, we have only access to the contexts. We fur- ther assume that the amount of target contexts is the representation discrepancy between a labeled 0 limited. Let Xt denote the unlabeled target data, source dataset and an unlabeled target dataset is (i) 0 reduced (e.g., Tzeng et al., 2014; Saito et al., 2018; where each sample xt 2 Xt from the target (i) Long et al., 2015). Recent approaches are often domain Dt consists of only a context xt;c. based on adversarial learning, where one minimizes Objective: Upon deployment, we aim at maxi- the distance between feature distributions in both mizing the performance of the QA system when both the source and target domain, while simulta- answering questions from the target domain D , neously minimizing the error in the labeled source t that is, minimizing the cross-entropy loss of the domain (e.g., Long et al., 2017; Tzeng et al., 2017).
Recommended publications
  • Hall of Fame Andy Partridge
    Hall of Fame Andy Partridge Andrew John Partridge (born 11 November 1953) is an English singer, songwriter, guitarist, and record producer from Swindon. He is best known for co-founding the rock band XTC, in which he served as the group's primary songwriter and vocalist. While the band was formed as an early punk rock group, Partridge's music drew heavily from British Invasion songwriters, and his style gradually shifted to more traditional pop, often with pastoral themes. The band's only British top 10 hit, "Senses Working Overtime" (1982), was written by Partridge. In addition to his work with XTC, Partridge has released one solo album on Virgin Records in 1980 called Take Away / The Lure of Salvage. He has also collaborated (as performer, writer or record producer) with recording artists, including Martin Newell, with whom he recorded and produced an album in 1993 entitled The Greatest Living Englishman released in Japan as a duo album. Partridge was producer for the English band Blur during the recording of Modern Life Is Rubbish (1993). He was replaced by Stephen Street at the insistence of their record label, Food. According to Partridge he was unpaid for the sessions and received his expenses only. Partridge also wrote four songs for Disney's version of James and the Giant Peach (1996) but was replaced by Randy Newman when he could not get Disney to offer him "an acceptable deal". In the 2000s, Partridge began releasing demos of his songs under his own name in The Official Fuzzy Warbles Collector's Album and the Fuzzy Warbles album series on his APE House record label.
    [Show full text]
  • Robyn Hitchcock's New Self-Titled
    “Renewed, refreshed and irascibly rambunctious." - NPR ! "Hitchcock sounds more energised and vibrant than he has in decades" - Uncut #5 Billboard Heatseekers (US) #7 Americana Album Charts (UK) #18 Top Current Rock Albums (US) #73 Top Current Albums (US) ROBYN HITCHCOCK’S NEW SELF-TITLED LP IS OUT NOW! - THE MOST CRITICALLY ACCLAIMED ALBUM OF ROBYN’S ILLUSTRIOUS CAREER. ! ! PRESS NPR Music premiere of "I Want To Tell You About What I Want" Salon feature and "Raymond and The Wires" video premiere Billboard feature and EPK premiere US: Paste, American Songwriter, Nashville Scene, The Stranger, Consequence of Sound, Brooklyn Vegan, AP & more SXSW: NPR Music, Paste, American Songwriter & more International: Daily Mail, The Quietus, Q Magazine, Big Take Over Mag, Sunday Times, Record Collector, Americana UK, Uncut, MOJO, Wire Magazine! (pt 1, pt 2), The Independent, DPA & more ! RADIO #45 on Americana Chart #30 on College NACC Top 200 #27 on FMQB AAA Top 200 Non-comm Featured plays on key international radio stations around the world In Studios Confirmed: KCSN, Sirius XM The Loft, KEXP In Studios Completed: The Current, KDHX, WDET, WYEP, WVTF KUTX interview with Jody Denberg and David Fricke @ SXSW Marc Riley and Gideon Coe played "I Want To Tell You About What I Want” on 6 Music Artist of the week on Bayern2 radio (DE) “Autumn Sunglasses” is KCRW’s Top Tune WATCH THE OFFICIAL VIDEO FOR “RAYMOND AND THE WIRES” ! WATCH THE EXCLUSIVE PERFORMANCES FOR SAWYER SESSIONS FIND TOUR DATES HERE FIND TOUR DATES HERE FIND TOUR DATES HERE .
    [Show full text]
  • Stevie Ray Vaughan
    An the Bullcrafe news US~ that's tH paldpennlt to pitch no. 2419 C' PITCtI KCMO February '1986 Kansas City's ffee music and entertainment newspaper Issue 62 A Texas tidal wave Blues, rock, rarb, ballads, you name it from the latest- Hammond discovery the Chantones, Blackbird and Nightcrawlers. by Roger Naber His senior year of high school, he dropped out He's been the most talked-about guitarist in and left his hometown of Dallas in the early 70s. blues and rock circles for the last three years. He followed his brother Jimmie to AUstin, which He dominated reader's and critic's polls in has been his home base ever since. various magazines. For the last two years he has From 1975-77 Stevie played with Austin's been the recipient of "Best Blues Instrumentalist" most popular r&b club band, the Cobras. He at the W.C. Handy Awards in Memphis. And then formed his own r&b revue, Triple Threat, there is no indication that the crest Stevie Ray which featured vocaUst Lu Ann Barton. In ear­ ~ Vaughan is riding is ready to level off. ly '81 Lu Ann quit the band in the middle of I first met the guitar genius four-and-a-half a tour, and that forced Vaughan to take over years ago. After spending several weeks trying lead vocals. He regrouped the band and named to locate him, I hired Vaughan and his band it Double Trouble pr an Otis Rush song. The Double Trouble to perform at HarUng's. The group consisted of Tommy Shannon on elec­ man who urged me to book him was his older tric bass and Chris Layton on drums.
    [Show full text]
  • The Daily Gamecock, TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 10, 2009
    University of South Carolina Scholar Commons February 2009 2-10-2009 The aiD ly Gamecock, TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 10, 2009 University of South Carolina, Office oftude S nt Media Follow this and additional works at: https://scholarcommons.sc.edu/gamecock_2009_feb Recommended Citation University of South Carolina, Office of Student Media, "The aiD ly Gamecock, TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 10, 2009" (2009). February. 14. https://scholarcommons.sc.edu/gamecock_2009_feb/14 This Newspaper is brought to you by the 2009 at Scholar Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in February by an authorized administrator of Scholar Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. dailygamecock.com UNIVERSITY OF SOUTH CAROLINA TUESDAY, FEBRUARY 10, 2009 VOL. 102, NO. 92 ● SINCE 1908 Weather Have questions for your Student Government TODAY Debate nets poor turnout candidates? Send them to The Daily Gamecock HIGH 75° at gamecockeditor@ Two of 12 candidates last week in academics sc.edu to be submitted committee to get teachers for the SG debates discuss platforms, to work more with students Wednesday and TONIGHT on their book lists.” Thursday. Questions LOW 52° argue qualifi cations If elected to student directed to senatorial senate, Kevin Burke , a fi rst- candidates in the Josh Dawsey year undecided student, said College of Arts and STAFF WRITER he would look to implement Sciences, as well TOMORROW a business learning as candidates for HIGH 76° Of the 12 candidates community executive offi ce, running for the business similar to should be submitted school district (district 5) that of the by Tuesday at 5 p.m. of student senate, only two pre-med, Attend the next two Inside showed up to debate the pre-law and debates and if you miss merits of their platform in engineering them, check out our coverage the day after.
    [Show full text]
  • La Sfida Di Threadgill L'ultimo Ribelle Jazz
    Alla corte del Kantor A proposito di Henry www.musicamorfosi.it gregsandow.com/threadg.htm 39 DOMENICA Qui potete trovare il progetto La vita e le gesta 11 APRILE «Pensavo fosse Bach di Henry Threadgill 2010 Robyn Hitchcock Xiu Xiu Le 10 canzoni più tristi del mondo TOP TRISTEZZA secondo blogcritics.org Lo psichedelico e i Venus 3 Sintetismi accessibili Your Song 02 Forever Autumn Justin Hayward Robyn Hitchcock Xiu Xiu Propellor time Dear God, I hate myself Elton John 03 Colour my World Chicago Sartorial Kill rock stars E piangete come fontane **** *** 04 Silent all These Years Tori Amos 05 Yesterday The Beatles 06 Everybody's Talkin' Harry Nilsson Nuovo capitolo del progetto del mae- La band californiana culto di rock elet- stro di psichedelia inglese assieme ai Ve- tronico torna con un nuovo esperimento 07 Listen to your Heart DHT nus 3 ovvero Peter Buck dei Rem e due a riscaldare i cuori di orde di nerd idolazio- altri collaboratori della band di Athens. Ma nisti.Ma anchegli amantidegli Einsturzen- 08 Separate Lives Phil Collins & Marylin Martin anche John Paul Jones, Nick Lowe e John- de Neubauten gioiranno. Sintetismi e ru- ny Marr (Smiths) alla chitarra. Malinconi- morismi si rincorrono nel nuovo «caro 09 Life in a Northern Town Dream Academy co, enigmatico, talvolta rock di impatto, dio, mi odio», ma stavolta, con una chiave sempre di classe. SI.BO. in più di accessibilità. SI.BO. 10 My Heart Will Go On Celine Dion La sfida di Threadgill ´Emotion...Æ SILVIA BOSCHERO la carriera solista. Oggi dobbiamo accontentarci, perché è tutta un al- tra storia.
    [Show full text]
  • Palace Songs Hope Mp3, Flac, Wma
    Palace Songs Hope mp3, flac, wma DOWNLOAD LINKS (Clickable) Genre: Rock Album: Hope Country: Europe Released: 2012 Style: Folk Rock, Acoustic, Lo-Fi MP3 version RAR size: 1147 mb FLAC version RAR size: 1544 mb WMA version RAR size: 1458 mb Rating: 4.7 Votes: 105 Other Formats: TTA AUD VOX MP4 MP2 DXD DTS Tracklist Hide Credits 1 Agnes, Queen Of Sorrow 4:18 2 Untitled 2:29 Winter Lady 3 2:51 Written-By – Cohen* Christmastime In The Mountains 4 1:38 Written-By – Black*, Baker* 5 All Gone, All Gone 4:52 6 Werner's Last Blues To Blokbuster 4:41 Credits Design – Dan Osborn, Frankie Blue Drums – Rob Allum Drums, Harmony Vocals [Harmonies] – Rian Murphy Harmony Vocals [Harmonies] – Briana Corrigan Photography By [Front Cover] – Nicole Vitello Photography By [Push With Frankie Blue] – Steve Gullick Piano, Harmony Vocals [Harmonies] – Sean O'Hagan Piano, Organ, Electric Guitar – Liam Hayes Producer – Rian Murphy Recorded By – Charlie Francis , Konrad Strauss, Reza Ebrahimi Voice, Guitar, Bass – Push* Written-By – Palace Songs* (tracks: 1, 2, 5, 6) Notes ℗1994 ©2012 Drag City Made in the EU Reissue in a cardboard sleeve, including 8-pages booklet Barcode and Other Identifiers Barcode: 5 034202 208228 Other versions Category Artist Title (Format) Label Category Country Year DC57CD Palace Songs* Hope (CD, EP) Drag City DC57CD US 1994 WIGLP18 Palace Songs* Hope (12", EP) Domino WIGLP18 UK 1994 DC57 Palace Songs* Hope (12", EP, TP) Drag City DC57 US 1994 REWIGLP82 Palace Songs* Hope (12", EP, RE) Domino REWIGLP82 Europe 2012 WIGCD18 Palace Songs* Hope (CD, EP) Domino WIGCD18 UK Unknown Related Music albums to Hope by Palace Songs 1.
    [Show full text]
  • Best of the Year
    Bestof theYear Pete/s SoothingSongs for a TurbulentYear Dave's Soul Stirring Genre Mash TOP FIVE (with impertinentcommentary when irrepressible) Art Srut: BangBang Rock & Roh -Bg- Tom Verlaine: Songs and Other Things oh thosewicked charms EricBachmann: To the Races T-Bone Burnett: True False ldentity Ane Brun: ATemporaryDive Alejandro Escovedo: the Boxing Mirror !p f/t count Belle& Sebastian:the LifePursuit JonDeeGraham: Full...ofguitardrlvenpaeanstodesperation&emotionalrescue The Streets:the HardestWay to Makean EasyLiving Kaki King: Until We Felt Red queenofaltthingsstringed&more THEREST Paul Simon: Surprise soundscapescounesy Eno the Be-GoodTanyas: Hello Love Jel: Soft Money &ha.dtruths the BlackKeys: MagicPotion Jon Langford: Gold Brick ainol list Bonnie'Prince"Billy: the LettingCo A by Kelly Mogwai: Mr. Beast BottleRockets: Zoysia Cotan Project: Lunatico .Calexico:the GardenRuin the DresdenDolls: YesViroinia Robyn Hitchcock & the Venus 3: Ole! Tarantula the Decemberists: 'Sno Califone:Roots & Crowns the Craie Wife Howe Celb: Angel Like You H.c.'sinimirable gospelplow White NekoCase: Fox confessor Brings the Flood Whale:WWI 50 Foot Wave: Free Music (EP) surfis... Centro-matic:Fort Recovery Calexico:Garden Ruin Squarewave: s/t transcendent the Cush: NewAppreciation for Sunshine CameraObscura: Let's Cet Out ofThis Country Mark Knopfler & Emmylou Harris: All This Roadrunning plas "Live" cDlDVD DeadMeadow: s/t Placebo:Meds Ooubledup anddelicious MatesofState: Bring the Drams:Jubilee Drive it Back Carrie Rodriquez: Seven Angels on a Bicycle
    [Show full text]
  • Issue 139.Pmd
    email: [email protected] website: nightshift.oxfordmusic.net Free every month. NIGHTSHIFT Issue 139 February Oxford’s Music Magazine 2007 photo by Squib RichardRichardRichard Oxford’sWaltersWaltersWalters master of melancholy on his incredible ten-year musical journey - interview inside. Plus - News, reviews and six pages of local gigs NIGHTSHIFT: PO Box 312, Kidlington, OX5 1ZU. Phone: 01865 372255 NEWNEWSS photo: Matt Sage Nightshift: PO Box 312, Kidlington, OX5 1ZU Phone: 01865 372255 email: [email protected] BANDS AND SINGERS wanting to play this most significant releases as well as the best of year’s Oxford Punt on May 9th have until the its current roster. The label began as a monthly 15th March to send CDs in. The Punt, now in singles club back in 1997 with Dustball’s ‘Senor its tenth year, will feature nineteen acts across Nachos’, and was responsible for The Young six venues in the city centre over the course of Knives’ debut single and mini-album as well as one night. The Punt is widely recognised as the debut releases by Unbelievable Truth and REM were surprise guests of Robyn premier showcase of new local talent, having, in Nought. The box set features tracks by Hitchcock at the Zodiac last month. Michael the past, provided early gigs for The Young Unbelievable Truth, Nought, Beaker and The Stipe and Mike Mills joined bandmate Pete Knives, Fell City Girl and Goldrush amongst Evenings as well as non-Oxford acts such as Buck - part of Hitchcock’s regular touring others. Venues taking part this year are Borders, Beulah, Elf Power and new signings My band, The Venus 3 - onstage for the encores, QI Club, the Wheatsheaf, the Music Market, Device.
    [Show full text]
  • Mass Manslaughter: but Less Than a Felony,Sometimes an Ear Is Just an Ear: Baylies Band Releases Freudian Ears,RIP Andy Gill &Am
    Spring Growth: New albums and local shows kick the season off right The Z-Boys – Elwood Here’s (I’m assuming) a Motif exclusive: Elwood, the sophomore album from Newport’s The Z-Boys, hits the streets March 6. They’re a band known for their high-energy performances. With tempos and influences all over the place, it’s like a dump truck careening along the edge of a canyon road. Fans will be pleased that the new album manages to keep much of the mayhem intact. You may be familiar with the brand of “everything overload” the Newport band pours into the cauldron, throwing in blues rock, surf, Latin, country and more. Distilling a dynamic live band into an album format can be difficult. Studio constraints have the Z-Boys a bit more restrained, but without a lot of production fluff. “You Lie” is familiar blues rock territory about lying, cheating, etc, and “Don’t Have to Hang Around” is a folk-Mariachi tune mixed with a pleasant country vibe. “Too Slow” is a Steely Dan-like shuffle with a barrage of drum fills, and “Wanna Be Sure” features chunky, arena rock power chords. The downside with the everything-but-the-kitchen-sink method is there’s no real standout track. Elwood has the expected guitar fireworks present in every song, along with rock solid, tasteful bass playing. The drumming is enthusiastic if not overbearing at times, like Keith Moon on Lite Rock 105. I think the best times are when they just fuckin’ go for it full bore without bothering with a melody.
    [Show full text]
  • Sewanee Purple,1985
    Second Class Postage Paid Novembers, 198S PurpleThe Sewanee The University of the South Of last year's ice storm Sewanee Residents Are Given Cold Reminder BYKALASPANGLER and offered to pay for their food then Thev were Ms. Irwin's opinion). Also, street liqhting decreased MANY LOCAL COMMUNITY members who tease told 'no', that the University would pay for it And from $19,816 in 1984 to $19,726 in 1985. The oi their homes and land from the University recently re- then there were community members who did in increase was in Trash collection and roadway clean- ceived an upsetting letter. This letter informed tr.em fact, pay for their food, but are still being charged the (from $34,468 in 1984 to $54,453 in 1985 and I very general 'other community services' from $1,8 Fees. This increase is due to the labor used to clean up thermore, Bruce Harper, head of the AFM was quoted in 1984 to $4,913 in 1985). It was pointed out in t branches, fallen limbs, and other debris, as well as the in the Feb. 11, 1985 issue of the Sewanee Purple as letter that the increase in the trash collection ood provided Gailor the a by to community during the telling the Vice-Chancellor that "Those who can pay roadway clean up included only half of the cost orm last year. This amount totals $38,628. we will ask to pay, those who can't, we will absorb the community related ice storm. And when Ms. Irv asked how much was spent on the food provided by nd the municipal fee.
    [Show full text]
  • WORT–Charts022809
    WORT Charts 3/6/09 2:04 AM This is Google's cache of http://lists.wort-fm.org/textupdates/charts.htm. It is a snapshot of the page as it appeared on Feb 26, 2009 07:32:55 GMT. The current page could have changed in the meantime. Learn more These search terms are highlighted: fula flute mansa Text-only version WORT, Madison Charts for the week beginning February 23, 2009 top 30 1 KINKY Barracuda Nettwerk-KIN KON 2 ANTONY AND THE JOHNSONS The Crying Light Secretly Canadian 3 VETIVER Tight Knit Sub Pop 4 BAKERTON GROUP El Rojo Weathermaker 5 BPA I Think We're Gonna Need A Bigger Boat Southern Fried 6 ANDREW BIRD Noble Beast Fat Possum 7 ROBYN HITCHCOCK AND THE VENUS 3 Goodnight Oslo Yep Roc 8 BRUCE SPRINGSTEEN Working On A Dream Columbia 9 BRAN FLAKES I Have Hands Illegal Art 10 URSULA 1000 Mystics ESL 11 VOX JAGUARS The Vox Jaguars Anodyne 12 PAVEMENT Brighten The Corners Matador 13 LILY ALLEN It's Not Me, It's You Capitol Records 14 CUT OFF YOUR HANDS You And I Frenchkiss 15 LARKIN GRIMM Parplar Young God 16 GOBLIN COCK Come With Me If You Want To Live Robcore 17 ANIMAL COLLECTIVE Merriweather Post Pavilion Domino http://74.125.47.132/search?q=cache:49VclDRtMBkJ:lists.wort-fm.org/t…charts.htm+fula+flute+mansa&hl=en&ct=clnk&cd=39&gl=us&client=safari Page 1 of 5 WORT Charts 3/6/09 2:04 AM 18 RADIO SOULWAX Part Of The Weekend Never Dies Pias 19 MAGNIFICENTS Year Of Explorers Mush 20 MEGAPUSS Surfing Vapor 21 HOWLIES Trippin' With Howlies OverUnder 22 LADYHAWKE Ladyhawke Modular 23 WILLIE NELSON AND ASLEEP AT THE WHEEL Willie And The Wheel
    [Show full text]
  • Robyn Hitchcock
    ISSUE #25 MMUSICMAG.COM ISSUE #25 MMUSICMAG.COM MUSICIAN How did you approach the record? animal. You feed it, water it, keep it clean and TOOLS OF THE TRADE I played guitar and sang to a variety of get it to behave properly. When it’s ready, rhythm tracks, and then Paul grafted the you let it go. But you need the embryo. And bass on afterward. Machinery being what once you’ve got that, the essence, you might Paul Noble—who produced and engineered it is today, you’ve got the sounds of Ocean spend six to nine months developing it. The Robyn Hitchcock’s Love From London— Way, Abbey Road or Olympic Studios—all gestation period is long, but the conception detailed the gear and techniques employed these legendary facilities—available at your is instantaneous. And sometimes you just in the studio. “For electric guitars, there was a fingertips. Jenny Adejayan came in to play have to abort, because there’s not enough standard American Fender Strat, a Telecaster, cello, which gives the record a large part of there to bring a song to birth. an Ibanez Talbo and a Gibson ES-335,” says its sound. Jenny Macro and Lucy Parnell did Nobel. “Acoustic parts were generally done some vocals. Anne Lise Frøkedal sent her How about your sense of melody? with Robyn’s main Fylde guitar (an Orsino), voice from Oslo, singing harmony on “Be I had no sense of melody to begin with. I but occasionally we used his Larrivee J-05 to Still” and “I Love You.” I didn’t even meet used to try to make up songs as a teenager achieve a softer sound.” Lizzie Anstey, but she did harmonies on “Fix and couldn’t do it.
    [Show full text]