DOCSLIB.ORG

Jurnal Bina Praja 11 (1) (2019): 53-62

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Jurnal Bina Praja 11 (1) (2019): 53-62 Jurnal Bina Praja 11 (1) (2019): 53-62 p-ISSN: 2085-4323 | e-ISSN: 2503-3360 JURNAL BINA PRAJA Journal of Home A airs Governance JURNAL BINA PRAJA VOLUME 11 | ISSUE 1 | MAY 2019 e-ISSN: 2503-3360 | p-ISSN: 2085-4323 Accreditation Number Accredita on Number: 21/E/KPT/2018 21/E/KPT/2018 Valid thru: November 2020 Published by: Research and Development Agency Ministry of Home Affairs http://jurnal.kemendagri.go.id/index.php/jbp/index Republic of Indonesia Nagari Customary Justice System in West Sumatra Welhendri Azwar*, Muliono, Yuli Permatasari, Huriyatul Akmal, Syamsul Ibrar, Melisa State Islamic University of Imam Bonjol Padang Jl. Prof. Mahmud Yunus No. 1 Lubuk Lintah Padang, Sumatera Barat Received: 3 March 2019; Accepted: 9 April 2019; Published online: 31 May 2019 DOI: 10.21787/jbp.11.2019.53-62 Abstract The state recognizes and respects indigenous and tribal people and their traditional rights insofar as they are alive and in accordance with the development of society and the principles of the Unitary State of the Republic of Indonesia, Justiceas contained system in in Article an effort 18 toB paragraphprotect the 2 existence of the 1945 of the Constitution. rights of indigenous However, peoplethe fulfillment to build ofthe cultural strength identity of civil and society the inrights West of Sumatra. indigenous This people research have uses not research been maximized. and development This study methods. aims to Data find retrievalthe conceptual is done model by survey, of the observation, Customary interview, and Focus Group Discussion (FGD) methods. This study found that; 1) Minangkabau people have their own local wisdom in resolving customary disputes, even for a broader range of life issues, long before Indonesia was found, 2) Nagari Customary Justice system is a translation of Limbago Adat which is the life philosophy of Minangkabau people, 3) Nagari Customary Judicial institutional structure is a representation of the existence of the tribe in the Nagari, so that its cultural legitimacy becomes strong. And, 4) the Nagari Customary Justice system is an effort to build the sovereignty of civil society, namely an autonomous, independent, egalitarian, and democratic society. It is hoped that the results of this study will be a guideline in establishing the Nagari Customary Justice institution in West Sumatra. Keywords: Customary Justice, Sovereignty, Civil Society, Nagari. I. Introduction The existence of state authority in processing In Indonesia, there are 19 customary law land does not mean the loss of people’s rights. State power over land is merely public (Harsono, 1999, areas, such as Gampong in Aceh, Desa in Java, Nagari in West Sumatra, as the elements and richness of p. 230) therefore, the state does not own any land. Indonesian national culture (Akmal, 2008, pp. 1–2). This means that law is seen as a resource used Van Vollenhoven noted that indigenous people to legitimize its action. The law has contributed have their own laws that are important enough to be considered and quite potential to be developed, to the emergence of conflict and influenced any namely customary law (Sulaiman, 2017, pp. 98– state develops laws regarding the use of natural land conflict resolution. On the one hand, the 110; Wignjosoebroto, 2002, p. 139). resources. On the other hand, the community also has laws relating to this issue. This is what triggers direction, in article 6 paragraph (1) of Law No. 39 of 1999The states state “thatis obliged in the to framework protect and of upholdingfulfill that law and local community law (Afrizal, 2003, p. 32). conflict, because of the clash between state agrarian human rights, differences and needs in indigenous When the law between the two groups is and tribal people must be considered and protected by the law of society, and the government”, then in theory, society is always in the process of change different, it will trigger a conflict. In view of conflict paragraph (2) states; “That the cultural identity of which is characterized by continuous opposition the customary law community, including the rights between its elements. Whereas, the order in society to communal land is protected, in line with the time”. is due to the pressure of power from the ruling class. Uneven distribution of power and authority is a * Corresponding Author © 2019 Welhendri Azwar, Muliono, Yuli Permatasari, Phone : +62 812 6725 247 Huriyatul Akmal, Syamsul Ibrar, Melisa Email : [email protected] This work is licensed under the Creative 53 Commons Attribution-NonCommercial- ShareAlike 4.0 International License. factor that determines the occurrence of systematic recognized by the state, none of the legal products regulates the way of implementing protection that ulayat rights are often threatened. socialThe conflict dispute (Ritzer over & ulayatGoodman, land, 2005, for pp.example, 153– Some studies show that the existence of the occurs164; Ritzer because & Smart, there 2012, is pp.no 283–286).juridical legitimacy collective rights of the Minangkabau indigenous peoples in West Sumatra still exists, as evidenced that occurred in the Caniago tribe with the National by the ulayat of the people, tribes and Nagari with Landtowards Agency customary (BPN) landin Pariaman,ownership. indicating The conflict the presence of the state actually triggered the birth of Azwar et al., 2018; Fauzan, 2004; Tegnan, 2015). Thevarious study conflicts explained and the dynamics existence (Aermadepa, of customary 2016; law indigenous people in the process of matrilineal inheritanceconflict (Fitlayeni, of Minangkabau 2015). Disputes (Aermadepa, occur between 2016; that emerged to maintain that existence. For example,communities the disputein West over Sumatra communal and various land. However, conflicts that occur between indigenous peoples and the it has not yet found a model for resolving customary governmentPrasetya, Firdaus, are due & toHasanah, the presence 2018), of even development disputes disputes through Customary Justice institutions based on the Minangkabau customary value system, Ismono, 2015). Likewise, customary land disputes as described in this study. Unlike other Southeast thatproject occurred investments in Aceh (Mutolib, society Yonariza,after the Mahdi,tsunami, & Asian countries such as the Philippines (Corpuz, 2012), Malaysia (Doolittle, 2012), Bangladesh (Roy, 2012) and Thailand (Trakansuphakon, 2012) whichSettlement led to conflicts of customary between landindigenous disputes groups can which still use customary law in land or land use be(Amalia, carried Mukhlis, out with & Yusrizal,the involvement 2018). of indigenous decisions. In southern Sudan, as many as 50 tribes peoples’ institutions. Empower and use the power still use the customary justice system (Penal Reform of civil society in building community independence International, 2000, pp. 23–24) and in Guatemala, in reducing government interference (Suroto, 2015, the people put the concept of the dimensions pp. 665–666). For the context of West Sumatra, the of nature, humans, and universes integrated as existence of Law No. 6 of 2014 concerning Villages Chapter XIII on Special Provisions for Adat Village, discourse (UN-Habitat, 2015, p. 10). In Africa, about which is derived in the form of Local Law Number 80%a unified of land concept issues are of incustomary the discourse law of incustomary judicial 7 of 2018 about Nagari, is a legitimacy given to the community to manage the community life the High Commissioner, 2016, p. 41). Whereas in system using local wisdom, including in managing Westernlaw (United liberal Nations democracies for Human (Faundez, Rights 2003), Office the of customary justice system is not dominant because it communal land. However, the problem will not is more used as an integrated component in a state stopand resolvingwith the various existence conflicts of Local and disputesLaw Number over justice mechanism. 7 of 2018. Technical guidance is needed on the This study uses a sociological perspective, operationalization of the roles, functions, and authorities of the Customary Justice Institution, Nagari Customary Justice system in an effort to in accordance with the social structure of each protectwhich aims the existenceto find the of conceptualthe rights ofmodel indigenous of the Nagari. The reason is that Nagari is an autonomous peoples, to build the strength of civil society in customary law area and has sovereignty that West Sumatra. Therefore, this research is expected contains value as social capital and shows its to be a reference in re-actualizing, restructuring, existence as an indigenous community, which has and re-functioning of the Customary Justice system in every Nagari in West Sumatra. This research is Permatasari, 2018). Nagari has its own peculiarities andpeople’s sovereignty, sovereignty with (Azwar, a different Yunus, socio-cultural Muliono, & the government, investors, and customary law system, which is called adat salingka Nagari custom. useful for managing and resolving conflicts between Sociologically for customary law communities, and obligations of customary law communities and the land is a social asset that functions as a lawcommunities. enforcement At the parties, same time, including it clarifies government the rights communal identity (tribe or clan) and as a means bureaucracies and groups of investors or other legal of binding social unity. Meanwhile, the collective entities. This research describes 1) the concept of rights of indigenous peoples over land, according Minangkabau Nagari Customary
Load more

Recommended publications
  • Print This Article
    20 Rahmawati Baharuddin Islamic Education In West Sumatra: Historical Point Of View By Rahmawati Baharuddin Abstract Paper ini berfokus pada sejarah singkat pertumbuhan dan perkembangan pendidikan Islam di Minangkabau sebelum dan sesudah munculnya gerakan pembaharuan Muhammadiyah. Perkembangan pendidikan Islam itu sendiri dimulai berbarengan dengan kedatangan Islam di Sumatera Barat. Gagasan reformis gerakan Muhammadiyah dalam bidang sosial keagamaan pada abad ke-20 memberikan sumbangsih yang besar terhadap perkembangan modemisme Islam di Sumatera Barat dan telah memberikan wama terhadap sistem pendidikan di Indonesia. A. Introduction Many scholars have argued that the rise and growth of Islamic education in one region began with the preaching oflslam which mainly conducted through the medium of education. Mahmud Yunus, 1 a great Indonesian educator, for instance, thought that Aceh, a region located at the northern tip of Sumatra, was the first part of Indonesia whose its inhabitants were converted to Islam. 2 However, scholars do not agree on the exact moment that Islam was introduced into the Indonesian archipelago. This difference of opinion stems from the fact that the factual data on the earliest period of Islam in the archipelago are so scanty. Nevertheless, we can classify their opinions into two categories. The Ulul Albab, Vol. 5 No. 1, 2004 Islamic Education In West Sumatra 21 first group, most of them Dutch scholars, such as Pijnappel, hold the opinion that Islam was first introduced into Indonesia in the twelfth century by Shii.f'f Arabs from Gujarat and Malabar. His opinion was based on the fact that these regions are mentioned so frequently in the early history of the Indonesian archipelago.3 The same holds true for Snouck Hurgronje, who believed that the twelfth century was the most probable date for the lslamization of the Indonesian archipelago.
    [Show full text]
  • Matrilineal Inheritance and Migration in a Minangkabau Community R. J
    M atrilineal Inheritance and M igration in a M inangkabau Community R. J. Chadwick Minangkabau and Marantau The matrilineal and uxorilocal Minangkabau population of West Sumatra is composed of about five hundred self-contained communities called nagari. These communities are geographically discrete, largely endogamous, and formerly self-governing.1 Each nagari has a specific ecological and economic adaptation according to its situation at home2 and pro­ duces a specific adaptation to city life among its very large emigre population. Migration from one's home nagari to another area is called marantau. Marantau is an ancient trend among the Minangkabau,3 is intrinsic to immemorial social process, and is functionally implicated in the social structure of villages in the homeland. But even in the 1 During my first fieldwork in Minangkabau, Koto Anu, the community I researched, did not constitute an ad­ ministrative unit in its own right. Together with a distant neighbor, the nagari Koto Apo, it was one part of an artificially created administrative unit, the kenegarian of Kaduo Koto (the two settlements). Under Dutch rule, it constituted one of the six communities in a different administrative unit, the lareh of Anam Koto (six settle­ ments). Neither lareh nor kenegarian were perceived as having any sociological relevance for Koto Anu people. (Like Koto Anu, the names Koto Apo, Kaduo Koto, and Anam Koto are pseudonyms.) The Village Law of 1979 (see Tsuyoshi Kato, "Different Fields, Similar Locusts: Adat Communities and The Village Law of 1979 in Indo­ nesia" Indonesia 20:89-114) constituted Koto Anu as a minimal administrative unit (desa) for the first time in liv­ ing memory and thus redressed the situation for Koto Anu people, at least.
    [Show full text]
  • Surau As Education Institutions of Muslim in Minangkabau (Study the Role Sheikh Burhanuddin Ulakan in Building Education System of Surau in Minangkabau 1100-1111 Ah)
    SURAU AS EDUCATION INSTITUTIONS OF MUSLIM IN MINANGKABAU (STUDY THE ROLE SHEIKH BURHANUDDIN ULAKAN IN BUILDING EDUCATION SYSTEM OF SURAU IN MINANGKABAU 1100-1111 AH) JEMMY HARTO Abstract Jemmy Harto Surau is one of the classical Islamic educational institutions Ibn Khaldun University present a kind of pesantren in the history of Islamic education in Indonesia. Sheikh Burhanuddin Ulakan is the Email founder of surau as educational institutions in [email protected] Minangkabau. Surau education system aims to explore the m role of Sheikh Burhanuddin Ulakan in building the education system of surau, analyze the educational system, the objectives, programs, educational process and evaluation of education. The method used the qualitative research approach to field research and library research. The result of research obtained is the concept of education surau more emphasis on the authority of a tuanku / sheikh. Surau using a curriculum of book, a fakih (students) cannot ride without first mastering the kitab’s that have been determined. There is no time limit for study at the surau. The ability of students in mastering the kitab’s into the requirement of passing of the surau. Inculcation of adab within a fakih to be the key in the learning process. Surau is Islamic educational institutions in Minangkabau who gave birth to scholar title tuanku. Surau become pioneer founding pesantren Modern in Minangkabau. Sheikh Burhanuddin Ulakan intellectual heritage still exist and survive until today. Keywords : Syeikh Burhanuddin, Surau, Education, Tuanku 71 Jurnal TAWAZUN Volume 9 No. 1 Januari – Juni 2016 A. Introduction mereka kepada alam berfikir Barat, jang dengan demikian Pesantren as said by Muhammad ditjiptakanlah satu golongan, Natsir is mental a bulwark for the jang akan dapat mendjamin berlandjutnya kolonialisme defense of the centuries.
    [Show full text]
  • Surau” Traditional Education in West Sumatera, Indonesia
    Journal of Islamic Studies and Culture December 2015, Vol. 3, No. 2, pp. 28-38 ISSN: 2333-5904 (Print), 2333-5912 (Online) Copyright © The Author(s). All Rights Reserved. Published by American Research Institute for Policy Development DOI: 10.15640/jisc.v3n2a4 URL: http://dx.doi.org/10.15640/jisc.v3n2a4 Modernization Of Islamic “Surau” Traditional Education In West Sumatera, Indonesia Muhammad Mawangir1 Abstract Since Indonesian reformation era, west sumateran society (Minang) echoed the emergence of slogan ‘back to the surau’ to bring back Islamic educational institution. Surau is the mosques dubbed by west sumateran society that has the function not only as the worshipping place but also as the center of community education. Law Number 22 of 1999 on Regional Autonomy and Regional Regulation No. 9 of 2000 on the nagari, west sumateran system of society are the cornerstone of the initial desire. Although there is no direct connection between the surau and those regulation, but those affect the attention of people who want return the missing old tradition revived. In addition, it is also very closely related to the community creed adaik basandi Syarak, Syarak basandi Kitabullah, customs based on syariah, and syariah based on the book of Allah. This paper tries to offer the process to modernize the Surau as the integration of Islamic traditional society with the modern education system in Indonesia. The surau education models that can be offered in the present era, among others, are at least the surau has to build Islamic center, boarding school or something, a mosque itself, dormitories, classrooms, seminar rooms, a wellness area, a consultation room, a library, means of sports, laboratories, and park.
    [Show full text]
  • Prinsip Kepemimpinan
    The Portrait of Surau as a Forerunner of Madrasah: The Dynamics of Islamic Institutions in Minangkabau Toward Modernization Zainal Efendi Hasibuan Pascasarjana IAIN Padang Sidempuan [email protected] Abstract: Surau as traditional educational institutions in Minangkabau, West Sumatera province, has significantly contributed to the emergence of outstanding figures or muslim scholars in Indonesia, some of them are those who have international reputation, such as Buya Hamka, Muhammad Natsir, Muhammad Hatta, and Haji Agus Salim. As the most influenting scholar among Indonesian muslim scholars, Sheikh Ahmad Khatib al-Minangkabawiy was used to be the teacher of the two founders of two major organizations in Indonesia, namely KH. Ahmad Dahlan the founder of Muhammadiyah and KH. Hashim Asy'ariy the founder of Nahdatul Ulama. On the other hand, the return of Kaum Muda Minangkabau (the youth of Minangkabau) had a strong effect on the development and performance of Surau as an educational institution. The function of Surau has developed, not only as a place for Islamic observance but also a centre of learning and teaching activities. The paper will discuss about the phases of the modernization of surau to be madrasah. This study is a library research that used content analysis. It is found that the changing function of surau from place of worship to be madrasah (Islamic school) was led by the modernist that returned after finishing studying from Mecca, they were called the youth. The changing of surau had an impact on the education system, such as aspects of the curriculum, teaching methods, teachers, students, management, and other educational components.
    [Show full text]
  • Perguruan Thawalib Padang Panjang in the Perspective of Educational History 1912 - 1926
    Perguruan Tawalib Padang Panjang In The Perspective.........Harmonedi PERGURUAN THAWALIB PADANG PANJANG IN THE PERSPECTIVE OF EDUCATIONAL HISTORY 1912 - 1926 Harmonedi Fakultas Tarbiyah dan Keguruan UIN Imam Bonjol Padang Jl. Prof. Mahmud Yunus No.1 Lubuk Lintah Padang e-mail : [email protected] DOI: 10.36424/jpsb.v6i1.154 Naskah Diterima: 14 Maret 2020 Naskah Direvisi: 08 Mei 2020 Naskah Disetujui: 08 Mei 2020 Abstract Perguruan Thawalib Padang Panjang has contributed greatly to the nation. The history of its establishment cannot be separated from Surau Jembatan Besi. To uncover this problem the authors conducted research under the title " Perguruan Thawalib Padang Panjang in the Perspective of Educational History 1912-1926". This research aims at revealing the history of Perguruan Thawalib Padang Panjang, and its work in education. it is qualitative research through library studies. After conducting research, it was revealed that Surau Jembatan Besi, is used to implement the traditional education system, turned into Thawalib Padang Panjang, It implements a modern education system. The modernization of education is motivated by the demands of the people who need a noble, intelligent, critical, skilled generation. The renewal efforts carried out is to encourage the students with critical thinking, independent in opinion and skilled the organization, implementing classical system education, establishing teacher handbooks, and developing curriculum. The main figure in the modernization of education in Thawalib Padang Panjang is Sheikh Abdul Karim Amrullah, a charismatic cleric who has been in touch with modernization movements in the Middle East. Keywords: Thawalib, Surau, Modernization, Education, Abdul Karim Amrullah Abstrak Perguruan Thawalib Padang Panjang telah berkontribusi besar untuk bangsa.
    [Show full text]
  • Islamic Educational Dynamic in Minangkabau (An 86-Year Journey of Madrasah Diniyah Pasia
    (ISLAMIC EDUCATIONAL DYNAMIC IN MINANGKABAU (AN 86-YEAR JOURNEY OF MADRASAH DINIYAH PASIA) Widia Fithri State Islamic Institute of Imam Bonjol Padang, Indonesia Email: widia_fithri @yahoo.co.id Abstract: Islamic Education in Minangkabau is one of the con- tributors to the Indonesian Muslim intellectuals. In the recent de- cade, such statement is resounded to reproduce Muslim intellec- tuals in the present and in the future. What and how is the history of Islamic education atmosphere in Minangkabau in maintaining its existence? This paper will explore one of the Islamic educa- tional institutions in Minangkabau, Madrasah Diniyyah Pasia. In the world of Islamic education in Minangkabau, the name of Madrasah Diniyyah Pasia is that popular, but this Madrasah has survived though it has undergone several changes in its education system. Since July 1, 1992, the Madrasah has adopted a boarding school system. Some names recorded to have been in contact with the Madrasah are Sheikh Abdul Latif Syakur, Prof. Mahmud Yu- nus, Prof Zakiyah Derajat and Prof Hashim Djalal. Keyword: Existence, Islamic Education, Minangkabau A. Introduction Madrasah Diniyyah Pasia is an old school and still survives until today in Minangkabau. It was established on October 11, 1928, initiated by H. Muhammad Isa who was a protégé of Sheikh Muhammad Cangkiang. Madrasah Diniyyah Pasia is located in Nagari Pasia.1 The Madrasah, whose existence is almost one century, has experienced several reformations in the journey of its educational system. Originally, it was a Madrasah. Later it was 1 Nagari Pasia is located in the east of Ampeng Angek sub-district of high land Agam district.
    [Show full text]