A NONPARTISAN PUBLICATION APRIL 13, 2001 ESSION VOLUME 18, NUMBER 15 Weekly SMINNESOTA HOUSE OF REPRESENTATIVES • PUBLIC INFORMATION OFFICE
In this issue:
BIODIESEL DEBATE
OBSOLETE LAWS, TOBACCO ENDOWMENT, AND MORE HF2420-HF2453 ESSION S Weekly Session Weekly is a nonpartisan publication of the Minnesota House of Representatives Public Information Office. During the 2001-2002 Legislative Session, each issue reports daily House action between Thursdays of each week, lists bill introductions and upcoming committee meeting schedules, and provides other information. The publication is a service of the Minnesota House. No fee. CONTENTS To subscribe, contact: Minnesota House of Representatives HIGHLIGHTS Public Information Office 175 State Office Building Agriculture • 5 Game & Fish • 12 Local Government • 17 St. Paul, MN 55155-1298 Children • 5 Government • 13 Metro Affairs • 17 (651) 296-2146 or 1-800-657-3550 Crime • 6 Higher Education • 13 Recreation • 17 TTY (651) 296-9896 Development • 8 Housing • 14 Safety • 18 Education • 9 Human Services • 14 Taxes • 18 Director Employment • 10 Immigration • 15 Transportation • 19 LeClair G. Lambert Energy • 10 Industry • 15 Environment • 11 Law • 16 Editor/Assistant Director Michelle Kibiger
Assistant Editor Mike Cook FEATURES Art & Production Coordinator At Issue: Education — A plan to increase student attendance and reduce Paul Battaglia truancy is being considered by the House K-12 Education Committee. • 21 Writers David Maeda, Theresa Stahl, At Issue: Government — Legislators have proposed a number of bills that Jonas M. Walker, Mary Kay Watson would repeal obsolete laws and rules, ranging from the regulation of track- less trolleys to itinerant carnivals. • 22 Chief Photographer Tom Olmscheid At Issue: Health — Several bills proposing long-term goals for mental Photographers health care in the state are being heard in a House committee • 24 Andrew Von Bank, Sara Kirk At Issue: Higher Education — Lawmakers are mulling a plan that would Office Manager Nicole Wood dedicate tobacco endowment funds to the University of Minnesota’s Aca- demic Health Center. • 25 Staff Assistants Christy Novak, Michelle Sorvari
Session Weekly (ISSN 1049-8176) is published weekly during the legislative session by the Min- DEPARTMENTS/RESOURCES nesota House of Representatives Public Information Office, 100 Constitution Ave., St. Paul, MN 55155-1298. Periodicals postage paid It’s A Fact: Minnesota nice 4 Committee Schedule (April 16-20) 28 at St. Paul, MN, and at additional mailing offices. Governor’s Desk (CH13-23) 26 Reflections: Natural disasters 31 POSTMASTER: Send address changes to Bill Introductions (HF2420-HF2453) 27 Minnesota Index: Teens and tobacco 32 Session Weekly, Public Information Office, Minnesota House of Representatives, 175 State Office Building, 100 Constitution Ave., St. Paul, MN 55155-1298.
Printed on recycled paper which is 50% recycled, On the cover: The Capitol quadriga sits amid gray rainy skies the first full week of April. 30% post-consumer content. —Photo by Andrew Von bank
2 April 13, 2001 IRST READING F
the production facilities are farmer-owned. The committee adopted a second amend- Fueling the debate ment requiring the Department of Agriculture Proponents of biodiesel fuel plan call it good for the to study the “feasibility and desirability” of providing tax credits benefiting biodiesel environment, while opponents say it is bad public policy producers. Westrom told the committee that HF362 is BY JONAS M. WALKER “all about three E’s: environment, economics, ollowing one of the most visible public lobbying campaigns of the and energy.” The middle factor determines stakeholders’ perceptions of the other two. legislative session and the indefatigable efforts of its sponsor, a bill to The debate surrounding the environmen- Frequire the inclusion of biological material in diesel fuels has earned tal benefits of biodiesel takes place in the con- the approval of four House committees. text of new federal rules requiring diesel fuel HF362, sponsored by Rep. Torrey Westrom (R-Elbow Lake), would to reduce its sulfur component by 95 percent by 2000. The National Biodiesel Board wrote, require the sale of so-called “biodiesel” fuels in Minnesota, a mandate pro- “Sulfur emissions are essentially eliminated ponents say would spur the development of “home-grown,” ecologically- with pure biodiesel.” friendly fuels and bolster the state’s sagging rural economy. Opponents, Opponents, however, argue that fuel com- panies will make the necessary improvements including the trucking and airline industries, in fuel at the refinery level. say biodiesels are insufficiently tested and de- John Hausladen of the Minnesota Truck- cry the measure as “good farm politics but bad ing Association said any additive intended to public policy.” reduce sulfur emissions would be “a redun- Biodiesel fuel is just like regular diesel fuel, dant product.” but it includes a biodegradable, combustible A National Biodiesel Board study concluded liquid fuel derived from organic oils for use that biodiesel fuels yield significantly less soot in internal combustion engines. According to and carbon monoxide, both of which are regu- the National Biodiesel Board, a nonprofit in- lated pollutants. Additionally, biodiesels con- dustry association, soybeans provide tribute 93 percent fewer hydrocarbons, which 90 percent of the biological component of contribute to smog. biodiesel fuels. Other sources include recycled However, the same study also found that oils from restaurants and even animal fats, al- biodiesel fuels can produce more nitrogen though those are less commonly used. oxides (NOx), a compound that Runge says is The House Transportation Policy Commit- a “major contributor” to nitrous ground-level tee amended and approved the bill April 10 ozone emission. after one of the longest debates the measure A report issued by University of Minnesota has yet seen. It will now go to the House Trans- Professor C. Ford Runge concluded that “the portation Finance Committee. Twin Cities area has the potential to exceed In its original form, HF362 would require EPA standards for ozone” and that “any in- that all diesel fuel sold in Minnesota after crease in NOx emissions is a potential source July 1, 2002 contain at least 2 percent biodiesel; of environmental costs of compliance.” that would increase to 5 percent by 2006. Proponents counter that “biodiesel’s lack of In response to concern that Minnesota sulfur allows the use of nitrogen oxide con- would isolate itself by becoming the first state PHOTO BY ANDREW VON BANK trol technologies that cannot be used with Bill Frank of Lawrence Transportation testifies be- to adopt such a move, the committee amended fore the House Transportation Policy Committee conventional diesel. Biodiesel nitrogen oxide the bill to stagger the implementation until April 10 in opposition to HF362, a bill that would emissions can be effectively managed and ef- significant production facilities exist in the specify minimum biodiesel fuel content. ficiently eliminated as a concern of the fuel’s state. In the new language, the 2 percent re- use.” quirement would take effect no sooner than material in the same period of time after Min- Westrom’s second “E,” economics, proved 180 days after the commissioner of agricul- nesota producers could generate a quantity among the most contentious. Hoping for a fi- ture announces that Minnesota producers can equal to 2.5 percent the amount of diesel fuel nancial windfall, farmers seek to create a new generate at least one-half the amount needed. sold the previous year. By that second date, market for a bountiful product. Truckers and The amended bill also stipulates all diesel though, the commissioner may only count other industries see themselves as being forced would have to be at least 5 percent biological biological material toward that minimum if to pay for a lopsided mandate benefiting some
Session Weekly 3 farmers at the expense of all other economic sectors. The biodiesel debate is often compared to the ethanol controversy of the mid-1980s. Ethanol is a corn byproduct that reduces pol- lutants when added to gasoline. Building on its green record and wishing to nurture a fledg- Minnesota nice ling market, Minnesota began financially sub- A look at tourism in the 1940’s sidizing ethanol production in the state in Though times have changed, one thing is 1948 was between 12 and 13 days. The fisher- 1987, an incentive that the United States also for sure in Minnesota: vacationers still come man tended to spend more time in Minnesota began providing. to the state mainly for its fishing as they did than the non-fisherman, the report stated. Ten years later, Minnesota became the first 50 years ago. Ninety percent traveled by automobile, while state to require that all gasoline sold within But the scenery, atmosphere, and the state’s others traveled by train, bus, or private airplane. its borders contain ethanol. It remains the only people have also lured both in-state and out- About 60 percent of vacationers occupied state to have done so. of-state enthusiasts. “housekeeping cabins” during their stay, while The Runge report concludes that Minnesota Steps to Better Vacations in Minnesota: A sur- most of the rest lodged in resorts, and a small soybean farmers stand to earn $7.5 million per vey of Minnesota’s vacation industry, which was percentage in “overnight cabins” or hotels. Just year were the state to adopt the biodiesel man- compiled in 1948, was the first comprehensive 2 percent camped in a tent. date, while the added yearly costs to diesel fuel examination of tourism in Minnesota. “Better than three out of every four va- users add up to $16 million at 2 percent and The Department of Business Research and cationists in Minnesota purchased a fish- $48 million at 5 percent. Development surveyed vacationers during the ing license during the 1948 season,” the Hausladen estimated that biodiesels would months of June through September with the report states. The survey concluded that cost truckers about 4 cents per gallon, a figure intent of learning the number of vacationers fishing is the most popular form of recre- that, magnified over hundreds of gallons con- in Minnesota during ation and is “en- the summer season, sumed, and in the context of already slim op- joyed extensively by where they come erating budget, could amount to one-third to both Minnesota from, how much they residents and our one-half of a trucker’s funds. spend on their vaca- non-resident This constitutes a financial “risk that no in- tion, and what they dustry should be forced to take,” said Bill thought about their visitors.” Frank, speaking on behalf of the Lawrence Minnesota vacation. The survey rated Transportation Company. He characterized The department es- fishing as 46 percent the proposed requirement as “a statewide re- timated nearly 860,000 of “what vacationists search project paid for by (diesel) users.” out-of-state residents liked most about Frank and others raised technical concerns and nearly 800,000 Minnesota.” Thirty- about the reliability of biodiesel fuels. Minnesotans spent A 1940’s era postcard promoting vacations in the three percent chose “scenery”; 26 percent Westrom told the committee biodiesel fuels their vacations at one Gull Lake area of Minnesota. Photo courtesy of the Minnesota Historical Society reported “climate and have proven safe and reliable after being “tested or more Minnesota re- weather”; 15 percent in many, many engines for many, many miles.” sorts during the summer of 1948. Illinois and Iowa vacationers comprised almost one-half of for “fellowship and friendliness”; and Proponents characterize biodiesel fuels as 6 percent said for “peace and quiet.” functional at all temperatures and character- Minnesota out-of-state visitors, while Missouri, Nebraska, and Kansas combined sent another Vacationers rated their dislikes as ize the infrastructure upgrades necessary to 20 percent for poor fishing (the publication physically combine diesel and biological ma- 25 percent. Summer vacations were generally family notes there are probably as many definitions terial as negligible. Opponents disagree, argu- affairs, with both resident and non-resident of poor fishing as there are fishermen); ing that biological additives contribute to vacation parties averaging 3.5 people. But the 11 percent for mosquitoes; 7 percent for “hav- diesel’s propensity to gel at low temperatures true cash-generating activities came from ing to go home”; and another 7 percent for and warning that equipment improvements non-residents of the state, who spent an aver- poor cabins and lack of facilities. could prove devastatingly costly to diesel age of $274.15 per trip compared residents Interestingly, the report makes reference to retailers. who spent $159.29. something the state is known for today as “Min- Finally, Westrom argued that adopting Forty-two cents of every vacation dollar nesota nice.” It noted that residents and non- biodiesel could serve American strategic in- were spent on resorts; 13 cents on food; 10 residents listed primarily the same “likes” about terests by reducing reliance on Middle East- cents on transportation; 10 cents on retail their vacations, with one exception. “The latter ern oil. Even this, though, attracted criticism stores; and 8 cents on sports and recreation. group (non-residents) placed much more em- from the bill’s opponents, a number of whom The survey wanted to know who could afford phasis on fishing, on fellowship, and friendli- ness than did Minnesotans. The friendly attitude said that most diesel fuel refined in the United vacations and what their incomes were. Re- … apparently is a very desirable characteristic States is drawn from South American, South- sponses for the survey were kept anonymous. to the visitor. east Asian, and Alaskan wells. The highest percentages of those surveyed earned the following annual incomes: “It might be advisable, therefore, that we 34 percent earned between $2,000 to $3,500; make a conscious effort to cultivate our hos- If you have Internet access, visit the 23 percent earned between $3,500 to $5,000; and pitable atmosphere so that ‘Minnesota Smiles’ Legislature’s web page at: 19 percent $5,000 to $7,500. The highest income might become the national ideal.” http://www.leg.state.mn.us bracket category was listed as “over $25,000.” (T. STAHL) The average length of vacation stay during
4 April 13, 2001 IGHLIGHTS A PRIL 5 - 11, 2001 H
Fair value from becoming maple syrup producers. AGRICULTURE Calling it a “sticky bill” but one with a “won- The committee took no action on the bill, but it will be considered for possible inclu- Milk board approved derful flavor,” Rep. Roxann Daggett (R-Frazee) presented a bill to the House Taxes Commit- sion in the omnibus tax bill. A plan to create a milk price control board tee Property Tax Division April 9 that would has received its first recommendation to pass add maple syrup to the state’s definition of ag- from a House committee. ricultural products. HF1238, sponsored by Rep. Mary Ellen Daggett said HF2397 literally adds just two CHILDREN Otremba (DFL-Long Prairie), would create a words, “maple syrup” to the statutes. By being five-member board appointed by the gover- Homework helpers included in the definition, maple syrup pro- nor to levy fees on milk producers and dis- ducers would benefit from the tax rates ap- The House Family and Early Childhood tributors. The bill is intended to assist dairy plied to agricultural property. Education Finance Committee has been farmers by bolstering milk prices, which have In current law property that is classified as spending a great deal of time making sure chil- been declining for many years. agricultural must be used for the “raising or dren have constructive activities after school. The House Civil Law Committee unani- cultivation of agricultural products.” Those They have considered several bills that would mously approved the bill April 6 and referred products include livestock, dairy animals, fund after-school enrichment programs. it to the House Governmental Operations and dairy products, poultry and poultry products, On April 9, they heard a proposal for a pi- Veterans Affairs Policy Committee. The House fur-bearing animals, certain horticultural and lot program that would pair St. Cloud State Agriculture Policy Committee approved the nursery stock, fruit, vegetables, forage, grains, University students with at-risk children in a bill Feb. 26, but declined to recommend its bees, and apiary products. nearby neighborhood. passage out of concern that other committees Agricultural land by definition must be 10 “This is the most stressed neighborhood in could perceive the bill as too extreme. acres or more of contiguous acreage. the state outside the Twin Cities,” said Rep. Joe The committee’s approval came after hours Under current law for agricultural property, Opatz (DFL-St. Cloud), sponsor of HF206. “It of testimony and significant amendment to similar to residential homestead property, the happens to be the neighborhood I grew up in, prevent the bill from being challenged on con- market value on the house and garage and the and it’s a very different place than when I grew stitutional grounds. Both opponents and sup- immediately surrounding one acre of land has up in the ‘60s and ‘70s.” porters were concerned that the bill’s original a class rate of 1 percent on the first $76,000 of The bill would appropriate $100,000 for a form could have violated the U.S. market value. The rate is 1.65 percent on prop- grant to the St. Cloud Southside Boys and Girls Constitution’s commerce clause, which gives erty greater than the $76,000 threshold. Club for an after-school computer skills pro- Congress exclusive purview to regulate inter- The value of the remaining land including gram for youth from low-income families. state trade. improvements up to $115,000 has a class rate HF206 will be considered for inclusion in the “I have done everything I can to make this of .35 percent of market value. The value of committee’s omnibus bill. constitutional,” Otremba said. property between $115,000 and $600,000 has The funds would pay for an education and Specifically, the committee removed a pro- a rate of 0.8 percent and the rate increases to career development coordinator for two years. vision that would have required Minnesota 1.2 percent on property greater than $600,000. The program, to take place after school, would milk distributors to purchase milk from Min- Jerry Jacobson, a maple syrup producer in serve about 100-150 children and provide in- nesota producers “whenever possible.” An- Otter Tail and Becker counties, said he con- ternship opportunities for college students other amendment cut a section that would tacted the Department of Agriculture to de- who would teach the children computer and have allowed the board to bring civil action termine whether his land could be classified homework skills. against any party that failed to comply with as agricultural. He was told that because it “The partnership with St. Cloud State Uni- “an order or rule of the board.” wasn’t included in the definition, the land did versity is integral to the success of the project,” Wy Spano, a lobbyist for the Dairies Fed- not qualify. said Mark Sakry, executive director of the Boys eration of Minnesota, opposed the bill “in sor- “We are as dependent on trees as farmers and Girls Clubs of Central Minnesota. row.” He described the measure as the “fourth are on their fields,” Jacobson said. The new club opened in January after a suc- permutation of legislation” intended to assist John Hagen from the Department of Rev- cessful fundraising effort that netted struggling dairy farmers. He warned its adop- enue said the department is concerned there $4.7 million. Contributors included the city tion could have the unintended consequence is no quantifying mechanism in the bill that of St. Cloud and many individuals, founda- of decreasing milk sales in Minnesota, espe- establishes how much syrup has to be pro- tions, and corporations. cially since the amended bill could not pre- duced to qualify. “About five years ago I noticed a build-up vent producers from seeking less expensive Rep. Tom Rukavina (DFL-Virginia) said he of children in the neighborhood who had no milk produced in Wisconsin or Iowa. shared the concern because under the bill pro- place to go after school,” said Larry Haws, St. ducers of any dollar amount could qualify. Cloud city park director. “Now volunteers are Jacobson said the costs of the equipment saying this is the best group of children they’ve and process that ensure a safe and healthy ever worked with.” product would discourage hobby farmers
Session Weekly 5 assumptions in the fiscal notes because of in- designed” for the making of a fraudulent iden- CRIME consistencies in some of the averages used. tification cards. For example, different agencies did not Current law provides for imprisonment of Examining felony DWI costs agree on the increase in trials a felony penalty not more than one year and up to a $3,000 The House Judiciary Finance Committee would create. In addition, officials said given fine. The committee amended the bill’s origi- spent the majority of its April 10 and 11 hear- the serious nature of a felony and the rights nal felony penalty of not more than five years ings discussing the fiscal note for a bill that lost, defendants will be more likely to contest and/or a fine of up to $10,000. First time of- would institute a felony-level drunken driv- the gross misdemeanor drunken driving cases, fenders will face only the current penalty. Any ing penalty. as well as the felony penalties. future offenses would be a felony, carrying up The bill (HF351), sponsored by Rep. Rich “As you have enhanced penalties,” said Maj. to a four-year prison term and $10,000 fine. Stanek (R-Maple Grove), would make a Mike Asleson of the State Patrol, “when you “I don’t want to advocate kids making ID’s person’s fourth drunken driving conviction have the possibility of prison time versus jail for their buddies,” commented Rep. Michael within 10 years a felony. The committee will time, there’s simply going to be some addi- Paymar (DFL-St. Paul). “But I don’t think a consider the measure for inclusion in its om- tional work.” kid making a mistake should be charged with nibus bill. Both the State Patrol and the Bureau of a felony.” Stanek said he planned to spend a substan- Criminal Apprehension stated in the fiscal The bill does not affect the penalty for us- tial amount of time scrutinizing the fiscal note note they anticipate more court time for of- ing a fraudulent identification card, up to so the committee could include a fair amount ficers and scientists with the felony penalty. 90 days in jail and up to a $1,000 fine. of funding for the plan, while still meeting Local costs also reflected high overtime for In another provision, the bill makes illegal other obligations under its spending target. officers to appear in court. the possession of “any device, gear, or instru- Fiscal staff from the House and various state Stanek and other committee members ques- ment designed to assist in shoplifting or de- agencies testified to the difficult nature of pin- tioned the assumptions department officials feating electronic surveillance systems.” Such ning down drunken driving costs. They said used and in some cases asked them to return systems are commonly used in retail stores there are so many variables and different as- with different numbers. selling items such as compact discs or cloth- sumptions, it’s hard to settle on one standard. Several officials agreed if some assumptions ing. Offenders could be punished by up to According to the fiscal note, the bill would were changed, the costs would likely decrease. three years in prison and a fine of $5,000. increase budgets for state criminal justice The committee will continue discussing the agencies by $5 million in the first year and be- potential fiscal impact and determine a rec- tween $10 million and $11 million in subse- ommendation to include in the bill with the quent years. Impact on local government committee’s omnibus spending package. agencies would be about $632,000 in the first Alcohol monitoring “I do think this is good legislation,” said Rep. year, $1.4 million in the second year and nearly Legislators are moving forward with a plan Sheldon Johnson (DFL-St. Paul). “I don’t $2 million in the third year. to study the effectiveness of remote alcohol think this legislation is going to have a deter- However, Stanek questioned many of the monitoring in reducing recidivism among re- rent effect on the chronic alcoholic. It’s just peat drunken driving offenders. the nature of the disease, and these people Rep. Mary Jo McGuire (DFL-Falcon need to be taken off the streets. This bill effec- Heights) sponsors SF773, which the House tively does that, and I appreciate it.” Crime Prevention Committee approved April 5. The bill now moves to the House floor. University of Minnesota Law School Pro- fessor Steve Simon, a member of the state- Forging identification cards mandated DWI Working Group, told the Legislators have approved a plan to stiffen committee that most drunken driving offend- penalties regarding the for-profit manufacture ers repeatedly drink and drive. “Because of fraudulent driver’s licenses and identifica- chemical dependency is involved, the simple tion cards. threat of punishment is ineffective.” Sponsored by Rep. Peggy Leppik (R-Golden Simon endorsed the proposed study, draw- Valley), HF2122 would create felony-level pen- ing attention to the bill’s demand that a group alties for multiple offenses against laws pro- not assigned home breathalyzers be included hibiting making false identification cards. as a control group. “The state would like ac- The House Crime Prevention Committee curate data” he said. approved the bill April 10. It goes now to the The bill calls for the commissioner of cor- House Judiciary Finance Committee. rections to report the results of the study “to Leppik said the manufacture of false iden- the chairs and members of the Senate and tification cards “is a huge problem for alcohol House committees and divisions having juris- and tobacco retailers. These producers are get- diction over impaired driving policy and fund- ting more and more sophisticated, and it’s ing” by Feb. 15, 2002. becoming increasingly difficult to trust Courts can order offenders to use remote identifications.” alcohol monitoring systems at home. The sys- Kevin Kajer from the State Public Defender’s Of- Reflecting the technological sophistication tems use a computer, phone, and camera to fice testifies before the House Judiciary Finance of contemporary forgers, the bill specifically measure blood-alcohol concentration, and Committee April 10 on HF351, a bill relating to criminalizes the use of digital cameras, com- then communicate that information to a felony DWI penalties. puter software, and paper “adapted and
6 April 13, 2001 Concealed weapon permit measure passes House
The House passed a contentious bill would merely increase the number of guns April 9 regarding the state guidelines for in Minnesota communities and would not issuing and receiving concealed weapons necessarily make citizens safer. permits. The vote was 85-46. Discussion also surrounded the effective- HF1360, sponsored by Rep. Lynda ness of background checks, particularly Boudreau (R-Faribault), would require when thousands of records, called “sus- sheriffs in Minnesota to issue a permit to pense files,” are currently unable to be anyone who meets various criteria con- matched by the state Bureau of Criminal tained in the bill. Currently, police chiefs Apprehension and therefore do not show and sheriffs have the discretion to grant or up on background checks. deny permits. “Almost 50,000 of these are felonies,” said Requirements to obtain a permit include Rep. Jean Wagenius (DFL-Mpls). “So if being at least 21 years old, completing fire- some sheriff does a background check, even arms safety training from a certified instruc- if there’s a conviction ... there are 50,000 tor, passing a criminal background check, and felonies that aren’t even tappable by the applicants must not be mentally ill, chemi- sheriff.” cally dependent, or known criminal gang Nevertheless, proponents said without members. the bill, there’s no guarantee of annual The bill would also create a statewide reg- background checks and there’s nothing istry of permit holders, who would be re- providing that the state have a central quired to undergo a background check registry of permit holders. PHOTO BY TOM OLMSCHEID annually. It would further enhance penal- Rep. Wes Skoglund holds a cutout of a semi- “A vote against this bill is a vote against ties for carrying a gun without a permit and automatic weapon as he speaks against the a bill that creates centralized data system for felonies committed by permit holders bill that would allow Minnesotans to more so that our police officers know who’s car- using a pistol. easily obtain a permit to carry a concealed rying and who doesn’t,” said Rep. John The fee for a new permit would be $45 weapon. The House voted 85-46 April 9 to Tuma (R-Northfield), “so they can do the approve the measure. under the bill. A permit would be good for background checks and so they can find the three years and renewals would cost $15. trolled substance, or otherwise being influ- bad guys that are carrying permits. So we The bill was amended several times on enced by a hazardous substance. know who they are, so they can track them.” the floor to answer concerns expressed by To violate that provision could The Senate version of the bill, sponsored members of the House Ways and Means ultimately result in permanent revocation by Sen. Pat Pariseau (R-Farmington) was Committee April 2. Amendments ad- of a permit. defeated in that body’s Crime Prevention dressed specific requirements for who is Another amendment, offered by Rep. Jim committee April 6. Though it’s not impos- allowed to provide certified training and Abeler (R-Anoka), would require anyone sible for the bill to become law, the action would allow sheriffs to contract with po- carrying a concealed weapon at a school with does severely hamper that reality. lice departments to process permit a permit to notify the school’s principal, but “We are spending hours and hours of our requests. would not require the principal’s permission time debating a bill that will not become Permit holders would not be allowed to to do so. It was approved. law,” said Rep. Matt Entenza (DFL-St. Paul). carry their weapon under the influence. An Boudreau and other supporters of the “And what we are succeeding in doing is amendment, offered by Rep. Rich Stanek measure said the bill is about protecting making the public just that much more (R-Maple Grove) and adopted by the people’s rights to defend themselves and cynical. With the defeat in the Senate Crime House, defines “under the influence” as their families. Boudreau called it a “basic Prevention committee, it is absolutely clear having a blood-alcohol concentration of civil right.” that the bill will not advance.” 0.04 or higher, having consumed a con- Opponents emphasized their belief that it (M. KIBIGER)
Frequently called numbers (Area code 651) Information, House TTY, House ...... 296-9896 Secretary of the Senate 175 State Office Building ...... 296-2146 Toll free ...... 1-800-657-3550 231 Capitol ...... 296-2343 Chief Clerk of the House Information, Senate Voice mail/order bills ...... 296-2343 211 Capitol ...... 296-2314 231 Capitol ...... 296-0504 Index, Senate Index, House TTY, Senate...... 296-0250 110 Capitol ...... 296-5560 211 Capitol ...... 296-6646 Toll free ...... 1-888-234-1112
Session Weekly 7 central facility that can alert parole officers if honest about their lives. She could relate to a violator has violated a court order. them, she said. DEVELOPMENT Simon said home breathalyzer units gener- Williams testified April 5 before the House Entrepreneur program funding ally cost about $10 to $12 per day, an expense Judiciary Finance Committee in favor of a bill An entrepreneur program designed to as- often borne by offenders themselves. If they that would keep the Camp Ripley camp open sist low-income, inner-city neighborhoods are unable to pay, the court can provide money for at least two more years. Gov. Jesse Ventura through training, lending, and support might for the devices. did not recommend funding for the program receive funding, under a bill sponsored by Rep. in his 2002-03 budget. Michael Paymar (DFL-St. Paul). “The people on this program are my fam- HF182 would allocate $96,500 to the Neigh- ily,” Williams said. “They were there for me Preventing gang violence borhood Development Center, Inc. in St. Paul when my regular family were not.” specifically for “entrepreneur training pro- A bill that would appropriate $750,000 dur- The bill (HF2151), sponsored by Rep. Debra grams, development and operation of a ing the 2002-03 biennium for a gang interven- Hilstrom (DFL-Brooklyn Center), would ap- Somali marketplace and business assistance to tion pilot project in Minneapolis and St. Paul propriate $1.25 million during the biennium Somali entrepreneurs, American Indian will be considered for inclusion in the omni- for the program. It would also establish a goal classes, staffing for the emerging businesses bus bill for the House Judiciary Finance for the camp of serving 500 youths per year. and emerging neighborhoods program, and Committee. The committee will consider the bill for alumni training programs.” The bill (HF2227), sponsored by Rep. possible inclusion in its omnibus bill. The bill was heard April 9 in the House Jobs Gregory Gray (DFL-Mpls), was heard by the Lori Roberson, a mother whose 11-year-old and Economic Development Finance Com- committee April 5. son with Attention Deficit Disorder attended mittee, and will be considered for inclusion Several representatives from the Boys and the camp two years ago, testified the program in the committee’s omnibus bill. Girls Clubs of the Twin Cities testified that made a remarkable difference in her son and Since 1993, the center has taught their programs of gang intervention, includ- has contributed to better grades in school. entreprenuership in four ethnic communities ing tattoo removal, are working. “At 11, he was headed in a direction where — Hmong, Latino, Somali, and American In- “They go where the kids are,” said Wendell his teachers didn’t want to deal with him,” dian — and 12 low-income neighborhoods. Butler, board member of the clubs. “They go Roberson said. “I didn’t want to deal with The center’s training program alumni have in the housing projects. They go into (Ameri- him.” started more than 280 businesses and created can) Indian land. They go into military Roberson’s son has improved attention, is 1,200 jobs, according to Mara O’Neill, chief installations.” succeeding in his public school classes after operating officer. Though Gray said the bill is a “pilot project,” struggling in private school, and says positive Tsong Sawh Lo, president of Hmong Diver- the intent of the bill is to give successful pro- things about his Camp Ripley experience, she sified Industries, Inc., testified to the commit- grams some financial support so they can testified. grow and spread to other areas, much like the tee in support of the center. Lo started his philosophy behind pilot projects. Enrique Estrada who works with the Boys and Girls Clubs, said he took what he learned WOMENVENTURE TOUTED there and tries to help keep kids out of gangs today. “I grew up in Boys and Girls Clubs,” Estrada testified. “I have older brothers who were in gangs and went to prison. ... Because of the Boys and Girls Clubs, I did not get involved in gangs.” Rep. Mary Murphy (DFL-Hermantown) asked Gray whether permanent state funding is necessary for projects like this one to continue when they receive private funding as well. Butler said about 26 percent of the program funding is from government sources. “Government certainly has an interest in providing for an alternative to gangs, if only for it’s own self interest,” Gray said. “I don’t anticipate that problem is going to go away. Private funding is good, but in times of eco- nomic downturn, like we’re experiencing now, those funds tend to dry up.”
PHOTO BY TOM OLMSCHEID Tene Heidelberg, president of WomenVenture, holds 3-month-old Rosalie McGough-Pose April Saving Camp Ripley program 11 as her mother, Maureen, tells the House Jobs and Economic Development Finance Com- Thirteen-year-old Jasmyn Williams recalled mittee about her business, Noble Birth, that was helped by a grant from WomenVenture. the “rap sessions” at the Camp Ripley week- end camp for at-risk youth as the most mean- ingful to her because the children there were
8 April 13, 2001 company in 1999 after completing the entre- improvements, and risks. Compiled data Teacher mentoring program preneur program. would be available to the public on a “user- A comprehensive plan designed to trans- Located in the Frogtown Neighborhood in friendly” Web site, he said. form teacher compensation and help retain St. Paul, Hmong Diversified Industries, Inc. is HF71 allocates an initial $2.5 million in teachers was introduced to the House K-12 a light manufacturing business that provides 2001, though officials suggest it might take Education Finance Committee April 6. distribution services to organizations and more than one year to be effective. HF71 states Committee Chair Alice Seagren (R- manufacturing companies. Lo’s company cur- the contractor would submit a written report Bloomington), sponsor of HF2353, said the rently has 14 employees directly from the of its findings to the commissioner of the intent of the bill is “to try to recruit teachers neighborhood it serves. Department of Children, Families and Learn- and retain them.” The bill would give school Besides creating jobs, businesses such as Lo’s ing within one year of the contract signing. districts the option to create “accountability return thousands of dollars back to the com- Cox said the cost is comparable with Michi- and educational improvement plans” for dis- munity. Graduates of the center are most likely gan and Pennsylvania, who have approxi- tricts, school sites, teachers, and students. to open stores in vacant storefronts, thereby mately the same number of school districts as If school districts so choose, Seagren’s bill improving the general image in neighbor- Minnesota. provides incentives for those that would re- hoods, O’Neill said. Entrepreneurs have also Rep. Barb Goodwin (DFL-Columbia structure teacher compensation systems “for become role models in their communities by Heights) questioned the need for spending teachers to continuously improve their knowl- helping to educate others, providing needed money on another consultant. She said the edge and skills,” the bill reads. services and goods, and by stabilizing the department already plans to spend In order to be approved for a new pay sys- community’s financial base. $25 million on consultants in the tem, districts must add an extra 10 days of staff A loan from the state would contribute to 2002-03 biennium. development activities. The additional time new work the center wishes to achieve. The “There is a lot of oversight of school ex- would be dedicated to a new teacher induc- center receives the majority of its support from penses already,” Goodwin said, citing finan- tion and mentoring program, which partici- foundations and corporations. The center cial managers, regular audits, and state pants would be compensated for, providing all charges for services depending on the income legislative auditors. She said the evaluation in conditions are met. level of the emerging entrepreneur. O’Neill the bill would add another layer, but wouldn’t Probationary teachers would receive $2,000 said most pay $50; the full fee is $550. take anything away. in compensation, and mentoring teachers But Pawlenty said it is not easy for a citizen would receive $500. One-third of the overall or policy maker to access information on funds would go to districts in Greater Minne- schools. “There is no one place where you can sota, one-third to the metropolitan area, and EDUCATION quickly and coherently” receive impartial data, the remaining one-third would be available for he said. “What we have now is not effective.” either area. Analyzing returns The bill was a collaborative project among Amid every report, survey, and assessment several education groups in the state. WEAR’N THE PLAID of Minnesota’s schools, there is not one that Jan Alswager, a lobbyist for Education Min- objectively and comprehensively evaluates the nesota, said her organization supports financial and academic performance of Seagren’s bill, but isn’t sure if there will be suf- schools, said House Majority Leader Tim ficient dollars to support it. Alswager also Pawlenty (R-Eagan). In other words, one that pointed out if large school districts such as calculates the return on the investment of Minneapolis or St. Paul were to use the pro- education. gram there wouldn’t be enough money. She Pawlenty is sponsoring a bill (HF71) that added the $500 teacher mentor compensation would hire an outside consultant to analyze could be increased. Minnesota’s schools for the benefit of taxpay- Julie Kalnin, assistant professor of education ers, educators, school board members, and at the University of Minnesota, emphasized to state and local officials. the committee the importance of mentoring. “There’s often a disconnect between policy “Mentoring programs are designed to make makers and education leaders,” Pawlenty told sure teachers are more productive in the class- the House K-12 Education Finance Commit- room,” she said. “There must be active engage- tee April 11. The bill will be considered for ment from learning (to) teaching.” the committee’s omnibus finance measure. Rep. John Dorn (DFL-Mankato) asked what A specific consultant to perform the evalu- has been recognized as to why so many new ation is not named in the bill. However, Will- teachers leave the profession. Kalnin said sup- iam Cox, managing director at Standard and port for new teachers causes them to stay or Poor’s, an internationally recognized financial PHOTO BY SARA KIRK leave, noting that many feel isolated. “Salary analysis company, gave a presentation of S&P’s Tad Myers from the Twin Cities Pipe Band, left, and broader working conditions” also influ- School Evaluation Services. Two other states, plays his bagpipe along with 10 other per- ence the decision, she said. Michigan and Pennsylvania, have contracted formers April 7 prior to a parade leading to In programs where universities work with the State Capitol in remembrance of Tartan with the company for the services. mentoring programs, the “attrition rate is sin- Cox claimed findings of the report would Day. Tartan Day is a Scottish holiday celebrat- ing the Declaration of Arbroath, signed in cerely reduced,” she said. “These mentoring not be a ranking or a rating, but instead a 1320, that provides freedom from English programs do have an effect.” management tool to determine financial and rule for Scotland. The bill will be considered for inclusion in academic strengths, weaknesses, the committee’s omnibus bill.
Session Weekly 9 Charter school oversight Sen. Ann H. Rest (DFL-New Hope) spon- The House Governmental Operations and KIDCLUB sored the bill in the Senate, where it received Veterans Affairs Policy Committee approved a 64-0 vote March 5. a bill April 10 without recommendation that HF456/SF647*/R2 would establish a state board for charter schools. The bill now goes to the House K-12 Edu- cation Finance Committee. EMPLOYMENT HF1265, sponsored by Rep. Mindy Greiling (DFL-Roseville), would expand the list of ac- HIV/AIDS workplace education countability factors for charter schools and Rep. Karen Clark (DFL-Mpls) is requesting establish a board that would perform the a $300,000 one-time grant to help educate and state’s role in sponsoring charter schools. The increase HIV/AIDS awareness in small board would also administer state and federal businesses. start-up aid. Clark, sponsor of HF846, said the last grant The governor, with the Senate’s advice and awarded for HIV/AIDS business education 10 consent, would appoint the seven-member years ago went to major corporations. Her bill board. Members would serve staggered six- would be focused on helping small businesses year terms. “to provide education and awareness and to Greiling said the bill would be considered improve capacities to manage HIV in the for inclusion in the omnibus education fi- workplace,” the bill states. nance bill along with another that would es- Under the bill, a community-based organi- tablish a state board of education. She said if zation would use at least one-half of the allo- the decision was made to establish a board of cation for education and legal and technical education, that board could also oversee char- assistance for employers and their employees. ter schools and thus HF1265 would not be Bob Tracy, director of community affairs needed. and education at the Minnesota AIDS Project, Greiling said she is offering the bill because PHOTO BY TOM OLMSCHEID spoke to the House Jobs and Economic De- she believes greater oversight is needed for Phyllis O’Brien from Kid Key Club testifies for velopment Finance Committee April 9. He charter schools. a bill that would expand the dependent care said a national study found about one-half of “There’s been a lot in the news about char- credit on individual income taxes from 12- people surveyed thought they could contract ter schools having problems, and it’s the con- year-olds to 14-year-olds to cover more chil- HIV from a sneeze, cough, or touch from a tention of this bill that if there was some dren in after school programs like hers. Her person with the virus. testimony came during an April 9 hearing of prevention ahead of time and more focus on the House Taxes Committee Sales and (HIV is the virus that can develop into the responsible sponsoring as well as help along Income Tax Division. disease AIDS.) the way, which this board could provide, then “When people don’t have the facts they still some of those problems could be headed off,” act on what they don’t know,” he said. Greiling said. Ventura signs request Tracy sees lots of discrimination, partly be- cause of a lack of information, he said. HF846 Jessie Montano, an assistant commissioner A resolution urging Congress to fulfill its would provide businesses with resources to of the Department of Children, Families and promise to fund 40 percent of the cost of spe- give help before they get into trouble, he said. Learning, said the administration opposes the cial education was signed by Gov. Jesse “This is to reduce the risk and cost to Min- bill because it would create a new level of Ventura April 6. nesota employers,” Tracy said. bureaucracy. As a result, the resolution will now officially Rep. Bob Gunther (R-Fairmont) asked if Montano said when charter schools first be sent to both the U.S. House of Representa- employment agencies could do HIV/AIDS started in Minnesota, the idea was for the state tives and Senate. education for businesses. Tracy said compa- to “step aside” and let the schools move along Rep. Andrew Westerberg (R-Blaine), spon- nies need more than just a handout, they need and learn from their mistakes. But she said that sor of the bill in the House, said the lack of peer-to-peer interaction, an expense that with the recent problems the department has funding is “hurting our education system” and would be covered by the bill’s allocation. taken a more proactive approach. explained that Minnesota has to subsidize The bill will be considered for inclusion in There is one staff member for every 10 education funds to afford special education the committee’s omnibus bill. schools and extensive training is provided be- expenses. fore the school is open, Montano said. Federal allocations for special education Rep. Tony Kielkucki (R-Lester Prairie) said funding have averaged 13 percent annually for he thought the department should be focused the past few years. ENERGY on providing services and not on regulating The resolution reads: “Over 25 years ago, the activities. federal government required states to provide From waste to watts “When you meld things together you cre- children with disabilities an appropriate edu- Anaerobic digester systems — transform- ate problems,” Kielkucki said. cation, and for 25 years, the government has ing manure into renewable energy — might failed to meet its promise to pay 40 percent of qualify for an incentive program that would the cost.” pay 1.5 cents per kilowatt hour, under a House The House passed the resolution with a bill. 123-1 vote April 2.
10 April 13, 2001 Besides producing energy, such systems pro- The bill, sponsored by Rep. Tom Osthoff “Despite the ban on lead shot in 1991, we vide several environmental benefits, includ- (DFL-St. Paul), would allow for a bond sale see as much lead poisoning in eagles now as ing odor control, pathogen reduction, weed and appropriation of $8 million as a grant to before the ban,” said Patrick Redig, executive seed destruction, and greenhouse gas the city of St. Paul for the acquisition and de- director of the center, which has been treat- reduction. velopment of approximately 58 acres, includ- ing and studying bald eagles and other rap- Rep. Bob Gunther (R-Fairmont), sponsor ing the Trout Brook/Trillium site and the tors for 27 years. of HF1741, presented the bill to the House Lower Phalen Creek Greenway. HF785, sponsored by Rep. Kathy Tingelstad Jobs and Economic Development Finance “We believe we can open this up and make (R-Andover), would appropriate $270,000 for Committee April 6. It will be considered for it an area the whole state can be proud of,” the 2002-03 biennium for the proposed study. inclusion in the committee’s omnibus bill. Osthoff said. The bill will be considered for inclusion in the HF1741 would provide reimbursement to The site forms a natural buffer of open space committee’s omnibus finance bill. facilities that begin generating electricity af- between neighborhoods and industry, The Raptor Center study would consist of ter July 1, 2001. Qualified facilities would re- bounded by Maryland Avenue, the Burlington trapping 75 bald eagles and taking blood ceive funds through 2015. Hydroelectric and Northern Railroad tracks, Interstate 35E, and samples, which would be analyzed for lead wind energy conversion facilities are currently Cayuga, Agate, and Jackson streets. residue. Twelve of the birds, six with high lead eligible for the incentive payment. The concept plan shows a greenway corri- levels and six without, would be outfitted with The bill would cost $80,000 in the 2002- dor that will include the restoration of wood- satellite tracking units. The birds would be 2003 biennium. The Department of Finance lands, prairies, and a brook; the creation of tracked to determine where they are feeding estimates funds for the program would gradu- wetlands; a series of small pools and water- so the sources of contamination might be pin- ally climb to $361,200 by 2016. The Depart- falls; an interpretive trail; and an interpretive pointed. ment of Commerce, which would manage the center. It will form a connecting link to 130 The goal of the study would be to determine program, assumes that two 150 kilowatt sys- miles of trails, according to Schmidt. the incidence, the potential sources, and the tems will be installed each year during the 15- “It’s a visionary plan,” said Rep. Margaret impact of lead exposure in the bald eagle year period for the subsidy, and each system Anderson Kelliher (DFL-Mpls). population in Minnesota. will be subsidized for 10 years. Osthoff gave much of the credit to St. Paul Information gained from the study would Estimates are based on the Haubenschild Mayor Norm Coleman, who “kept us all be shared with the Department of Natural Dairy Farm in Princeton — the only opera- together on this.” Resources and other government agencies to tional anaerobic manure digestion facility in facilitate management of the eagle population the state. Haubenschild is a 1,000-acre, family and help ensure the species’ long-term owned and operated farm that processes ma- survival. nure from more than 400 cows, and plans to Lead poisoning in eagles “The continued presence of lead in the eco- expand to 900 cows by this summer. A young bald eagle paid a visit to the House system is an ongoing threat to wild bald eagles According to the Minnesota Project, which Environment and Natural Resources Finance in Minnesota,” said Mark Martell, coordina- compiled a report on the performance of the Committee April 11. The eagle was a member tor of conservation programs for the center. Haubenschild Farms, before the digester was of a delegation from the University of “When we know where it’s coming from, built, Haubenschild entered into a contract Minnesota’s Raptor Center, which is seeking hopefully we can do something about it.” with a local electric cooperative. Now, “enough state funding for a study of lead poisoning in electricity is being produced to provide all the the birds. electric needs on-farm, plus enough surplus electricity to power about 45 average homes.” The report cautions future anaerobic di- gester systems that cooperation and financial support from agencies is essential for success. However, it notes payback of five years or less on the investment is possible.