DOCSLIB.ORG

Exploitation and Abuse of International Migrants, Particularly Those in an Irregular Situation: a Human Rights Approach

Total Page：16

File Type：pdf, Size：1020Kb

Download full-text PDF Read full-text
Exploitation and Abuse of International Migrants, Particularly Those in an Irregular Situation: a Human Rights Approach GLOBAL MIGRATION GROUP Exploitation and abuse of international migrants, particularly those in an irregular situation A human rights approach Exploitation and abuse of international migrants, particularly those in an irregular situation: a human rights approach THEMATIC PAPER Global Migration Group 2013 Global Migration Group (GMG) The Global Migration Group (GMG) is an inter-agency group bringing together heads of agencies to promote the wider application of all relevant international and regional instruments and norms relating to migration, and to encourage the adoption of more coherent, comprehensive and better coordinated approaches to the issue of international migration. The GMG is particularly concerned with improving the overall effectiveness of its members and other stakeholders in capitalizing upon the opportunities and responding to the challenges presented by international migration. The GMG consists of 16 organizations that are actively involved in international migration and related issues: • International Labour Organization (ILO) • International Organization for Migration (IOM) • Office of the High Commissioner for Human Rights (OHCHR) • UN Regional Commissions • United Nations Children’s Fund (UNICEF) • United Nations Conference on Trade and Development (UNCTAD) • United Nations Department of Economic and Social Affairs (UN-DESA) • United Nations Development Programme (UNDP) • United Nations Educational, Scientific and Cultural Organization (UNESCO) • United Nations Entity for Gender Equality and the Empowerment of Women (UN Women) • United Nations High Commissioner for Refugees (UNHCR) • United Nations Institute for Training & Research (UNITAR) • United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime (UNODC) • United Nations Population Fund (UNFPA) • World Bank • World Health Organization (WHO) © United Nations Office on Drugs and Crime, December 2013. All rights reserved, worldwide. The designations employed and the presentation of material in this publication do not imply the expression of any opinion whatsoever on the part of the Secretariat of the United Nations concerning the legal status of any country, territory, city or area, or of its authorities, or concerning the delimitation of its frontiers or boundaries. This publication has not been formally edited. Acknowledgements The present publication was drafted by Marika McAdam (consultant) who was also responsible for conducting the majority of country surveys. It was coordinated by Martin Fowke and Tatiana Balisova of the Human Trafficking and Migrant Smuggling Section at UNODC. The thematic paper benefitted from the expertise and the contributions of the member agencies of the Global Migration Group, in particular the support and inputs of the following persons: • Beate Andrees, Ryszard Cholewinski (ILO) • Kristina Touzenis, Jonathan Martens (IOM) • Pia Oberoi, Youla Haddadin (OHCHR) • Paul Tacon (ESCWA) • Jason Schachter (UNECE) • Irene de Lorenzo-Cáceres Cantero, Rhea Saab, Susu Thatun (UNICEF) • Liping Zhang (UNCTAD) • Bela Hovy, Sabine Hennings (UN-DESA) • Sarah Rosengaertner, Andree Tzall (UNDP) • Golda El-Khoury (UNESCO) • Jean D’Cunha (UN Women) • Sumbul Rizvi, Sibylle Kapferer (UNHCR) • Yvonne Lodico, Colleen Thouez (UNITAR) • Rahel Gershuni , Silke Albert (UNODC) • Sonia Plaza (World Bank) • Daniel Lopez-Acuna, Helena Nygren Krug (WHO) Thanks also go to Anja Klug, Sue Lemesurier and Anne Gallagher for their valuable comments. The thematic paper was made possible by funding support from the Government of Switzerland through the UNODC Global Programme against Smuggling of Migrants . A human rights response to exploitation of migrants Thematic Paper Exploitation and abuse of international migrants, particularly those in an irregular situation: a human rights approach THEMATIC PAPER Table of Contents Introduction and purpose ...................................................................................... 3 1. Understanding exploitation ................................................................................ 5 1.1. Lack of definition of exploitation ....................................................................................................... 5 1.2. Types of exploitation .............................................................................................................................. 8 1.2.1. Exploitation amounting to criminal offences: Forced labour and trafficking ............ 9 1.2.2. Labour exploitation .............................................................................................................................. 14 1.2.3. Non‐labour exploitation, including sexual exploitation ...................................................... 16 1.2.4. Exploitation during the irregular migration process, including by smugglers ........ 20 1.3. Conceptual challenges in understanding exploitation ........................................................... 23 1.3.1. ‘Degree’ or ‘severity’ of exploitation ............................................................................................. 23 1.3.2. Consent to exploitation ....................................................................................................................... 25 1.4. Vulnerability to exploitation ............................................................................................................. 28 1.4.1. Migrants in irregular situations ..................................................................................................... 29 1.4.2. Refugees and asylum seekers ........................................................................................................... 33 1.4.3. Age (youth, adolescents and children) ......................................................................................... 33 1.4.4. Gender ......................................................................................................................................................... 35 1.5. Consequences of exploitation of migrants in irregular situations .................................... 38 1.5.1. Financial consequences ...................................................................................................................... 38 1.5.2. Social consequences .............................................................................................................................. 40 1.5.3. Human consequences ........................................................................................................................... 41 2. Human rights response to exploitation and abuse of migrants, particularly those in irregular situations ............................................................................................ 43 2.1. A Human Rights based‐approach to migration ......................................................................... 43 2.1.1. International normative framework against exploitation ................................................ 45 2.1.2. Baseline of human rights for migrants in irregular situations ........................................ 47 2.2. Prevention: reducing vulnerability to exploitation ................................................................. 50 2.2.1. Promote development .......................................................................................................................... 50 2.2.2. Prevent irregular migration and promote safe, regular migration .............................. 52 2.2.3. Reduce harm in irregular migration ............................................................................................ 54 2.2.4. Regularization ........................................................................................................................................ 57 2.3. Prevention: reducing opportunities for exploitation ............................................................. 58 2.3.1. Reduce demand for exploitative goods and services ............................................................. 58 2.3.2. Address exploitative norms and traditional and cultural practices .............................. 61 2.3.3. Promote decent work ........................................................................................................................... 63 2.3.4. Monitor and regulate ........................................................................................................................... 65 2.4. Assistance and Protection of exploited migrants..................................................................... 68 2.4.1. Identify exploited migrants ............................................................................................................... 68 2.4.2. Protect exploited migrants from further harm ....................................................................... 70 2.4.3. Assist exploited migrants ................................................................................................................... 72 2.4.4. Non‐criminalization of exploited migrants ............................................................................... 74 1 A human rights response to exploitation of migrants Thematic Paper 2.5. Prosecution and other actions against exploiters ................................................................... 75 2.5.1. Exploited migrants: Right to a remedy ........................................................................................ 75 2.5.2. Exploiters: Right to a fair trial .......................................................................................................
Load more

Recommended publications
  • The Politics of Roman Memory in the Age of Justinian DISSERTATION Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the D
    The Politics of Roman Memory in the Age of Justinian DISSERTATION Presented in Partial Fulfillment of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy in the Graduate School of The Ohio State University By Marion Woodrow Kruse, III Graduate Program in Greek and Latin The Ohio State University 2015 Dissertation Committee: Anthony Kaldellis, Advisor; Benjamin Acosta-Hughes; Nathan Rosenstein Copyright by Marion Woodrow Kruse, III 2015 ABSTRACT This dissertation explores the use of Roman historical memory from the late fifth century through the middle of the sixth century AD. The collapse of Roman government in the western Roman empire in the late fifth century inspired a crisis of identity and political messaging in the eastern Roman empire of the same period. I argue that the Romans of the eastern empire, in particular those who lived in Constantinople and worked in or around the imperial administration, responded to the challenge posed by the loss of Rome by rewriting the history of the Roman empire. The new historical narratives that arose during this period were initially concerned with Roman identity and fixated on urban space (in particular the cities of Rome and Constantinople) and Roman mythistory. By the sixth century, however, the debate over Roman history had begun to infuse all levels of Roman political discourse and became a major component of the emperor Justinian’s imperial messaging and propaganda, especially in his Novels. The imperial history proposed by the Novels was aggressivley challenged by other writers of the period, creating a clear historical and political conflict over the role and import of Roman history as a model or justification for Roman politics in the sixth century.
    [Show full text]
  • Short-Term Migrant Workers: the Case of Ukraine Short-Term Migrant Workers: the Case of Ukraine
    TECHNICAL REPORT Short-Term Migrant Workers: The Case of Ukraine Short-Term Migrant Workers: The Case of Ukraine In 2012, the State Statistics Service of Ukraine, in collaboration with the Interna- tional Labour Organisation, conducted a Survey on Labour Migration (SLM) in order to estimate the size of labour migration out of Ukraine and analyse the demograph- ic and socio-economic characteristics of migrant workers. This work was done within the framework of the EU-funded project “Effective Governance of Labour Migration and its Skill Dimensions”, implemented by the ILO. The present technical report focuses on analysing short-term labour migration out of Ukraine and finds that this group of migrants constitutes 82.7 per cent of all rm Migrant Workers: The Case of Ukraine migrant workers and 2.9 per cent of all 15–70-year-olds in the country. Data on short-term labour migration are often very scarce, which results in difficulties in developing policy responses to cover this growing group of migrant workers. The ILO Migration Modules tries to address this gap. For more information visit the ILO topic portal on Labour Migration http://www.ilo.org/migration Labour Migration Branch Route des Morillons 4 Phone: +41 (0)22 799 6667 CH-1211 Geneva 22 Fax: +41 (0)22 799 8836 Switzerland Email: [email protected] Short-Te Conditions of Work Department of Statistics ILO and Equality Labour I SBN 978-92-2-130229-2 Department Migration Branch 9 78922 1 302292 Short-Term Migrant Workers: The Case of Ukraine Short-Term Migrant Workers: The Case of Ukraine International Labour Organization • Geneva Copyright © International Labour Organization 2017 Publications of the International Labour Office enjoy copyright under Protocol 2 of the Universal Co- pyright Convention.
    [Show full text]
  • Immigration's Future: Closing the Door on the American Dream?
    Barry Law Review Volume 24 Article 2 Issue 1 Barry Law Review: Fall 2018 1-1-2019 Immigration's Future: Closing The oD or On The American Dream? Ritcy Canelon Follow this and additional works at: https://lawpublications.barry.edu/barrylrev Part of the Immigration Law Commons, International Law Commons, Jurisprudence Commons, Legislation Commons, and the Other Law Commons Recommended Citation Ritcy Canelon (2019) "Immigration's Future: Closing The oorD On The American Dream?," Barry Law Review: Vol. 24 : Iss. 1 , Article 2. Available at: https://lawpublications.barry.edu/barrylrev/vol24/iss1/2 This Article is brought to you for free and open access by Digital Commons @ Barry Law. It has been accepted for inclusion in Barry Law Review by an authorized editor of Digital Commons @ Barry Law. : Immigration's Future IMMIGRATION’S FUTURE: CLOSING THE DOOR ON THE AMERICAN DREAM? Ritcy Canelon* I. INTRODUCTION History repeats itself, sometimes with new characters, new scenarios, or new twists. Throughout its history, the world has continuously seen people flee in masses from tyranny, wars, and other devastations. In the United States, the first settlers were fleeing from the religious oppression from their native homes.1 We study his- tory to feign we’ve learned from our past while ignoring all the signs of its reoccur- rence. If we never learn from history, we are Bound to repeat it, and the progress for our future may be halted by not fixing the problems from our past. The history of human immigration is not one that should be ignored. As the
    [Show full text]
  • The Integration Outcomes of U.S. Refugees
    THE INTEGRATION OUTCOMES OF U.S. REFUGEES Successes and Challenges By Randy Capps and Kathleen Newland with Susan Fratzke, Susanna Groves, Gregory Auclair, Michael Fix, and Margie McHugh MPI NATIONAL CENTER ON IMMIGRANT INTEGRATION POLICY THE INTEGRATION OUTCOMES OF U.S. REFUGEES Successes and Challenges Randy Capps and Kathleen Newland with Susan Fratzke, Susanna Groves, Gregory Auclair, Michael Fix, and Margie McHugh June 2015 Acknowledgments This report was originally prepared to inform the Migration Policy Institute (MPI) roundtable “Mismatch: Meeting the Challenges of Refugee Resettlement,” held in Washington, DC in April 2014. The private meeting convened resettlement providers, federal and state-level government officials, and civil-society stakeholders for a candid conversation on the strengths and weaknesses of the U.S. refugee resettlement program, and future directions for policy development and program expansion. The roundtable and this report were supported by a grant from the J. M. Kaplan Fund. Additional support was provided by the John D. and Catherine T. MacArthur Foundation. © 2015 Migration Policy Institute. All Rights Reserved. Cover Design and Layout: Liz Heimann, MPI No part of this publication may be reproduced or transmitted in any form by any means, electronic or mechanical, including photocopy, or any information storage and retrieval system, without permission from the Migration Policy Institute. A full-text PDF of this document is available for free download from www.migrationpolicy.org. Information for reproducing excerpts from this report can be found at www.migrationpolicy.org/about/copyright-policy. Inquiries can also be directed to: Permissions Department, Migration Policy Institute, 1400 16th Street, NW, Suite 300, Washington, DC 20036, or by contacting [email protected].
    [Show full text]
  • Modern Monetary Theory: a Marxist Critique
    Class, Race and Corporate Power Volume 7 Issue 1 Article 1 2019 Modern Monetary Theory: A Marxist Critique Michael Roberts [email protected] Follow this and additional works at: https://digitalcommons.fiu.edu/classracecorporatepower Part of the Economics Commons Recommended Citation Roberts, Michael (2019) "Modern Monetary Theory: A Marxist Critique," Class, Race and Corporate Power: Vol. 7 : Iss. 1 , Article 1. DOI: 10.25148/CRCP.7.1.008316 Available at: https://digitalcommons.fiu.edu/classracecorporatepower/vol7/iss1/1 This work is brought to you for free and open access by the College of Arts, Sciences & Education at FIU Digital Commons. It has been accepted for inclusion in Class, Race and Corporate Power by an authorized administrator of FIU Digital Commons. For more information, please contact [email protected]. Modern Monetary Theory: A Marxist Critique Abstract Compiled from a series of blog posts which can be found at "The Next Recession." Modern monetary theory (MMT) has become flavor of the time among many leftist economic views in recent years. MMT has some traction in the left as it appears to offer theoretical support for policies of fiscal spending funded yb central bank money and running up budget deficits and public debt without earf of crises – and thus backing policies of government spending on infrastructure projects, job creation and industry in direct contrast to neoliberal mainstream policies of austerity and minimal government intervention. Here I will offer my view on the worth of MMT and its policy implications for the labor movement. First, I’ll try and give broad outline to bring out the similarities and difference with Marx’s monetary theory.
    [Show full text]
  • The Nepali Caste System and Culturally Competent Mental
    THE NEPALI CASTE SYSTEM AND CULTURALLY COMPETENT MENTAL HEALTH TREATMENT: EXPLORING STRATIFICATION, STRESS, AND INTEGRATION. A Dissertation Presented to The Graduate Faculty at The University of Akron In Partial Fulfillment Of the Requirements for the Degree Doctor of Philosophy Scott Swiatek May 2021 THE NEPALI CASTE SYSTEM AND CULTURALLY COMPETENT MENTAL HEALTH TREATMENT: EXPLORING STRATIFICATION, STRESS, AND INTEGRATION. Scott Swiatek Dissertation Approved: Accepted: ___________________________ _____________________________ Advisor Department Chair Dr. Juan Xi Dr. Rebecca Erickson ___________________________ ______________________________ Committee Member Dean of the College Dr. Clare Stacey Dr. Mitchell S. Mckinney ___________________________ _____________________________ Committee Member Dean of the Graduate School Dr. Manacy Pai Dr. Marnie Saunders ___________________________ _____________________________ Committee Member Date Dr. Kathy Feltey ___________________________ Committee Member Dr. Marnie Watson ii ABSTRACT During the late 1990s, the Northern Bhutanese enacted policies marginalizing Bhutanese of Nepali Descent. Thousands of Bhutanese refugees were forcibly displaced to Nepal and established refugee camps where they lived for decades. While in the camps, refugees encountered traumatic life events, including torture, imprisonment, and sexual violence. Starting in 2008 and continuing for years. Bhutanese/Nepali refugees were resettled in the Akron area and encounter a new set of acculturation stressors related to finding employment, learning English, and reestablishing a new set of social networks. Older adults may cling to the Nepali caste system to cope with the unique stressors during the integration process. For over 100 years, people of Nepali descent subscribed to Muluki Ain, which codified discrimination against lower castes and mandated every individual be assigned a caste. Further, members of the ethnic and religious minority were often placed in the lower castes.
    [Show full text]
  • Slavery and Exploitation of Syrian Refugees in Lebanon
    Struggling to survive: Slavery and exploitation of Syrian refugees in Lebanon 1 The Freedom Fund plays a critical role to [Slavery] is happening identify and invest in the most effective everywhere... front line efforts to end slavery and human Lebanese municipality official trafficking, bringing together a wide range of partners committed to this cause. Commissioned by the Freedom Fund, this report examines the manifestations I know a 12 year old girl of slavery and human trafficking among who has packed her toys Syrian refugees in Lebanon. It draws on in a bag because she has interviews with Syrian refugees in Lebanon, to work. She doesn’t want representatives from Lebanese and people in the camp to see international NGOs, Syrian organisations, UN bodies and Lebanese government her play with her toys and officials. The study, which was conducted think she is young and during January and February 2016, unfit to work. also reviews other recent research and Lebanese municipality official vulnerability assessments. 2 Contents 2 4 5 Executive summary Recommendations Syrian refugees in Lebanon: the growing risk of slavery and trafficking 7 10 12 Child labour Child marriage Sexual exploitation 14 16 21 Forced labour Factors contributing to Conclusion slavery and trafficking of Syrian refugees Acknowledgement We are grateful and humbled by the time and willingness that women, men and children showed in accepting to share their experience with us. We would also like to thank individuals and organisations working on the Syrian refugees crisis for taking time from their busy schedules to share their knowledge and analysis. Dr Katharine Jones Senior Research Fellow, Centre for Trust, Peace and Social Relations, Coventry University Contact: [email protected] Leena Ksaifi Independent Consultant and Director of The George Ksaifi Organization Contact: [email protected] Cover image © Tabitha Ross 1 Executive Summary Since it began in 2011, the conflict in Syria has crisis that has unfolded over the past five years.
    [Show full text]
  • Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada
    Responses to Information Requests - Immigration and Refugee Board of... https://irb-cisr.gc.ca/en/country-information/rir/Pages/index.aspx?doc=4... Responses to Information Requests - Immigration and Refugee Board of Canada India: Treatment of Dalits by society and authorities; availability of state protection (2016- January 2020) 1. Overview According to sources, the term Dalit means "'broken'" or "'oppressed'" (Dalit Solidarity n.d.a; MRG n.d.; Navsarjan Trust n.d.a). Sources indicate that this group was formerly referred to as "'untouchables'" (Dalit Solidarity n.d.a; MRG n.d.; Navsarjan Trust n.d.a). They are referred to officially as "Scheduled Castes" (India 13 July 2006, 1; MRG n.d.; Navsarjan Trust n.d.a). The Indian National Commission for Scheduled Castes (NCSC) identified that Scheduled Castes are communities that "were suffering from extreme social, educational and economic backwardness arising out of [the] age-old practice of untouchability" (India 13 July 2006, 1). The Commonwealth Human Rights Initiative (CHRI) [1] indicates that the list of groups officially recognized as Scheduled Castes, which can be modified by the Parliament, varies from one state to another, and can even vary among districts within a state (CHRI 2018, 15). According to the 2011 Census of India [the most recent census (World Population Review [2019])], the Scheduled Castes represent 16.6 percent of the total Indian population, or 201,378,086 persons, of which 76.4 percent are in rural areas (India 2011). The census further indicates that the Scheduled Castes constitute 18.5 percent of the total rural population, and 12.6 percent of the total urban population in India (India 2011).
    [Show full text]
  • Digital Marx: Toward a Political Economy of Distributed Media
    tripleC 10(2): 313-333, 2012 ISSN 1726-670X http://www.triple-c.at Digital Marx: Toward a Political Economy of Distributed Media Andreas Wittel Nottingham Trent University, School of Arts and Humanities, Nottingham, United Kingdom, [email protected], http://www.ntu.ac.uk/apps/Profiles/70220-2-2/Dr_Andreas_Wittel.aspx Abstract: This is the claim: In the age of mass media the political economy of media has engaged with Marxist concepts in a rather limited way. In the age of digital media Marxist theory could and should be applied in a much broader sense to this field of research. The article will provide a rationale for this claim with a two step approach. The first step is to produce evidence for the claim that political economy of mass media engaged with Marxist theory in a rather limited way. It is also to explain the logic behind this limited engagement. The second step – which really is the core objective of this article – is an exploration of key concepts of Marx’s political economy - such as labour, value, property and struggle - and a brief outline of their relevance for a critical analysis of digital media. These concepts are particularly relevant for a deeper understanding of phenomena such as non-market production, peer production, and the digital commons, and for interventions in debates on free culture, intellectual property, and free labour. Keywords: Marx, labour, value, property, struggle, political economy of media, digital, distributed media, mass media, internet, network 1. Introduction This is the claim: In the age of mass media the political economy of media has engaged with Marxist concepts in a rather limited way.
    [Show full text]
  • BSR | Migrant Worker Management Toolkit: a Global Framework 2
    Migrant Worker Management Toolkit: A Global Framework Managing Workers and Protecting Rights BSR September 2010 www.bsr.org Contents 3 About This Toolkit 8 Educate: Understand the Country Context 16 The Transition: From Initial Recruitment to Pre-Departure 18 Partner: The Engagement Process 23 Build Capacity: Post-Arrival Orientation 32 Grievance Process www.bsr.org BSR | Migrant Worker Management Toolkit: A Global Framework 2 About This Toolkit This management tool for multinational companies and employers provides guidance on how to better manage migrant worker issues, from managing risks to better protecting migrant workers’ rights. This toolkit is: » A product of the Malaysia multistakeholder initiative and two factory pilot projects that included engagement and training with workers and factory management » Focused on regulation, recruitment, post-arrival orientation, and grievance procedures and represents consensus areas among union, civil society, brand, and employers during multistakeholder initiative » Intended for a broad audience, including employers or suppliers, multinational brands, and other relevant stakeholders (government, NGOs, and unions). Global and Local This global framework for employer engagement on labor migration issues can be applied in national and local contexts around the world. It provides guidance and clear recommendations in areas of utmost importance to workers and relevance for business. The goal is for this toolkit to be taken up by employers globally and applied at a country level. Finally, the common point of reference throughout this document is Malaysia because of its role as the host country for the field component of the initiative and this pilot. It is intended to serve as a ‘blueprint’ for how this framework may be applied at a country level.
    [Show full text]
  • Children of Migrant Workers: Exploring the Issues
    Social Studies and the Young Learner 19 (2), pp. –12 ©2006 National Council for the Social Studies Children of Migrant Workers: Exploring the Issues Lynne Bercaw, Susan Colby, Linda Pacifici, Sandra Oldendorf, Robin Groce, and Eric Groce After a long, hard, and hot day in the field, under the implacable rays of the Father of Life, my muscles ache and my bones hurt and crack as though they were crystals breaking. I’m dirty, thirsty, and hungry. My body is so tired and sore that I fear it might crumble like an old building being torn down. Oritz, in S. B. Atkin, ed., Voices from the Fields. Scholastic The topic of migrant workers is either an “undocumented commonplace among headlines in the worker” or an “illegal alien.”) the emigration of one million Mexican national news, but such workers have We define a “migrant worker” as a workers and their families across the been part of the United States economy person who moves (within a country or border. Today, immigrants (legal and for at least seventy-five years, as can be across borders) in order to find employ- undocumented) from Mexico number seen in decades of enrollment records ment. Often, migrant workers follow sea- about 20 million.4 in K-12 schools.1 Migrant students have sonal jobs, like harvesting crops. Many been, until recent years, a concern for migrant workers in the United States Challenge and Change schools closest to the US-Mexican bor- today are immigrants from Mexico. The opening quote hints at the physical der, but children of migrant workers are The first wave of immigration from hardships that migrant workers com- now part of the social fabric across the Mexico began with the Mexican monly endured.
    [Show full text]
  • Critiques of Growth in Classical Political Economy: Mill's Stationary
    Critiques of growth in classical political economy: Mill’s stationary state and a Marxian response GARETH DALE ABSTRACT In recent political-economic theories of ‘nature,’ Mill and Marx/Engels form important reference points. Ecological economists see Mill’s ‘stationary state’ as seminal, while Marxists have ‘brought capitalism back in’ to debates on growth and climate change, sparking a Marxological renaissance that has overturned our understanding of Marx/Engels’ opus. This essay explores aspects of Mill’s and Marx/Engels’ work and contemporary reception. It identifies a resemblance between their historical dialectics. Marx’s communism is driven by logics of ‘agency’ and ‘structure’ (including the ‘tendency of profit rates to fall’). In Mill’s dialectic a ‘thesis,’ material progress, calls forth its ‘antithesis,’ diminishing returns. The inevitable ‘Aufhebung’ is a stationary state of wealth and population; Mill mentions countervailing tendencies but fails to consider their capacity to postpone utopia’s arrival. Today, Mill’s schema lives on in ecological economics, shorn of determinism but with its market advocacy intact. It appears to contrast with the ‘productive forces expansion’ espoused by Marx/Engels. They stand accused of ‘Promethean arrogance,’ ignoring ‘natural limits’ and ‘gambling on abundance.’ But I find these criticisms to be ill-judged, and propose an alternative reading, arguing that their work contains a critique of the ‘growth paradigm,’ and that their ‘cornucopian’ ends do not sanction ‘promethean’ means. That Karl Marx and John Stuart Mill inhabited the same city for over twenty years without encountering one another has prompted some of their admirers to compensate for the frustration of this event’s unfortunate non-occurrence by means of fantasy.
    [Show full text]