Matthew's Wisdom Christology in Its Jewish and Early Christian Contexts
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
MATTHEW’S WISDOM CHRISTOLOGY IN ITS JEWISH AND EARLY CHRISTIAN CONTEXTS Submitted by Thathathai Singsa shb B.Ed (Thailand), M.A (Theology ACU) A thesis submitted in total fulfilment of the requirements of the degree of Doctor of Philosophy School of Theology, Melbourne Faculty of Theology and Philosophy Australian Catholic University Research Services Locked Bag 4115, Fitzroy, Victoria 3065 Australia 5 May 2011 1 Statement of Sources This thesis contains no material published elsewhere or extracted in whole or in part from a thesis by which I have qualified for or been awarded another degree or diploma. No other person’s work has been used without due acknowledgment in the main text of the thesis. This thesis has not been submitted for the award of any degree or diploma in any other tertiary institution. Full name: Thathathai Singsa Signed: Date: 5 May 2011 2 Acknowledgements I wish to acknowledge with gratitude my principal supervisor Associate Professor David C. Sim for his expertise, insights and patience. I thank him for his constructive criticism and exposing weaknesses in my work. For his thoroughness, I am most grateful. I acknowledge also, co-supervisor Associate Professor James S. McLaren, for his support and concern throughout my study. I acknowledge the assistance given to me by Dr Veronica Lawson rsm, in the early years of my study and Dr Rod Doyle cfc for his teachings in Biblical Greek, and continued support in my studies. I acknowledge the academic skills advisors at Australian Catholic University, Melbourne, Dr Jo Reidy and Elizabeth Powell for their constant academic advice and friendship. I also acknowledge the Library Staff at Australian Catholic University, Melbourne; Catholic Theology College Library; Dalton McCaughey Library and Whitley College Library for their assistance in my research. I acknowledge with gratitude the Religious Communities with whom I have been associated during my years of study, the Sisters of Mercy, particularly the North Melbourne community, the Loreto Sisters at St. Mary’s College, University of Melbourne and the Good Shepherd Sisters in Abbotsford. The hospitality and support of each congregation is greatly appreciated along with the Mary Ward Grant from the Loreto Sisters. In particular, I wish to acknowledge Sr Margaret Ignatius rsm and Sr Mary Lewis rsm for their untiring support, encouragement and friendship throughout my years of study. I acknowledge with a great debt of gratitude, my own Congregation of the Sisters of the Sacred Heart of Jesus of Bangkok (SHB). I thank the Congregation leaders Sr Pannee Phurunghong shb and Sr Chalieng Vetchayan shb for their generosity and constant support and for giving me the opportunity to study Theology. I acknowledge, finally, and in the highest place my late father Taweep Singsa and my mother Yuthani Singsa who were the first to teach me and did so much to give me a good education. I acknowledge all members of my family and friends from Thailand and Australia who have supported me throughout my studies. 3 Table of Contents Statement of Sources 2 Acknowledgements 3 Table of Contents 4 Abstract 7 Abbreviations 9 Introduction 11 1. Survey of Early Studies 12 1.1 M. J. Suggs 12 1.2 C. M. Deutsch 15 1.3 E. A. Johnson 19 1.4 B. Witherington 21 1.5 F. T. Gench 27 1.6 E. M. Wainwright 30 1.7 S. J. Gathercole 32 1.8 Conclusion 34 2. Plan of This Thesis 36 3. Presuppositions 41 4. Methodology 44 5. Terminology 56 Chapter 1: Wisdom in Judaism 61 1. Introduction 61 2. The Meaning of Human Wisdom and Divine Wisdom 62 3. The Origin of Human Wisdom and Divine Wisdom 63 3.1 Human Wisdom in the Ancient Near East 63 3.2 Divine Wisdom in the Ancient Near East 64 3.3 Human Wisdom in Ancient Israel 65 3.4 Human and Divine Wisdom in the Jewish Wisdom Literature 67 4 4. Wisdom in the Jewish Tradition 68 4.1 Wisdom in the Book of Proverbs 69 (a) 1:20-33 70 (b) 3:13-20 72 (c) 4:5-9 73 (d) 8:1-36 74 (e) 9:1-11 83 4.2 Wisdom in the Book of Job 87 (a) Job 28 88 4.3 Wisdom in the Book of Sirach or Ecclesiasticus or Ben Sira 91 (a) 1:1-10 92 (b) 4:11-19 93 (c) 6:18-37 94 (d) 24:1-29 94 (e) 51:13-30 97 4.4 Wisdom in the Book of Wisdom 98 (a) 6:22 99 (b) 7:7-8:1 99 (c) 8:2-21 102 (d) 10:1-21 103 4.5 Wisdom in the Book of Baruch 105 (a) 3:9-4:4 106 4.6 Wisdom in the Book of 1 Enoch 109 (a) 1 En 42 109 4.7 Summary 110 5. Pre-Existence in the Jewish Tradition 113 6. Conclusion 116 Chapter 2: Wisdom in Early Christianity 118 1. The Pauline Tradition 118 (a) 1 Cor 24, 30 119 (b) 1 Cor 8:6 122 (c) Gal 4:4-6 and Rom 8:3-4 124 (d) Phil 2:6-11 128 (e) Summary 131 5 2. The Markan Tradition 132 3. The Q Tradition 139 (a) Q 7:18-35 (Lk 7:18-35//Mt 11:2-19) 140 (b) Q 11:49 (Lk 11:49//Mt 23:34a) 148 (c) Q 13:34-35 (Lk 13:34-35//Mt 23:37-39) 152 (d) Q 10:21-22 (Lk 10:21-22//Mt 11:25-27) 155 (e) Q 11:31-32 (Lk 11:31-32//Mt 12:41-42) 158 (f) Summary 160 4. The Johannine Tradition 161 5. Conclusion 181 Chapter 3: Wisdom in the Matthean Tradition 184 1. Mt 11:2-19 185 2. Mt 11:25-30 193 (a) vv. 25-27 194 (b) vv. 28-30 200 3. Mt 23:34-39 212 (a) vv. 34-36 212 (b) vv. 37-39 218 4. Mt 1:23 224 5. The Matthean ‘I Have Come’ Sayings 233 6. The Matthean Jesus and the Law 239 7. Conclusion 254 General Conclusions 257 Bibliography 264 6 Abstract This thesis aims to study the identification of the Matthean Jesus with Wisdom or Sophia, a personified feminine figure. The roots of this identification are traced to the traditions in Judaism as depicted in Proverbs, Job, Sirach, the Wisdom of Solomon, Baruch and 1 Enoch. The early Christians made use of this Wisdom tradition when speculating on the identity and significance of Jesus, and scholars have identified explicit Wisdom Christologies in Paul, Q and John. The thesis has its main focus in the Matthean tradition and demonstrates that Matthew develops a high Christology from his Jewish and Christian sources by portraying Jesus as Wisdom incarnate. This thesis studies Matthew’s Wisdom Christology from the perspective of its Jewish and early Christian contexts. How has Matthew been influenced by these traditions, and how has he developed them? The nature and roles of Wisdom in Judaism differ from text to text. In some she is a distinct pre-existent being, subordinate to and distinct from God, while in others she appears to be an aspect of God and not a distinct entity. In terms of her functions, Wisdom is assigned a variety of roles. She plays a part in the creation of the universe as the assistant of God, mediates between God and humans, plays a salvific role and is identified with the Torah. Wisdom can be described in various ways, including mother, lover and counsellor. In the Judaism of Matthew’s time, Wisdom is only one of many pre-existent beings. Other figures that were thought to pre-exist and await a future revelation include the Messiah and the Son of Man, and these too play an important role in the emergent Christology of the first century. 7 The study of the early Christian texts reveals that the Christians accessed the Jewish Wisdom traditions in different ways. Paul uses the term ‘the Wisdom of God’ for Jesus (1 Cor 1:24; cf. 1:30), but he seems not to use it as a Christological title. The concept of Wisdom as a distinct figure first appears in the Q tradition. In this Sayings Source, Jesus is not identified with Wisdom herself but as her messenger or envoy. The Gospel of John testifies to a further development. John has a clear Wisdom Christology, especially in the Prologue where the pre-existent Jesus is assigned many of Wisdom’s roles. But this author never refers to Jesus as ‘Wisdom’. He prefers the masculine term ‘the Word’. Between the Q and the Johannine traditions comes Matthew, and it is in this Gospel that the early Christian Wisdom Christology is most clearly attested. In distinction to Q, Matthew makes explicit the identification of Jesus with Wisdom herself and, in distinction to John, he has no qualms about using that particular feminine term. For Matthew Jesus is pre-existent Wisdom, subordinate to God and separate from God, who becomes incarnate in the body of a human through a miraculous conception. In portraying Jesus in this way, Matthew adopts many of the attributes and roles of Wisdom in the Jewish tradition, including her role in creation, her close relationship with God, her role as prophet and teacher, her rejection by humans and her identification with the Law. Moreover, in constructing his Wisdom Christology, the evangelist reinterprets and develops some aspects of Wisdom’s traditional roles on the basis of Christian claims about Jesus. Thus in Matthew it is significant that Jesus as Wisdom is a miracle-worker, the definitive interpreter of the Law, dies on the cross to save her people from their sins and will come in the future as the eschatological judge.