(2000) Flow and Temperature
Total Page:16
File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb
Flow and Temperature Recommendations for Endangered Fishes in the Green River Downstream of Flaming Gorge Dam Humpback chub Gila cypha Colorado pikeminnow Ptychocheilus lucius Razorback sucker Xyrauchen texanus Upper Colorado River Endangered Fish Recovery Program Final Report Project FG-53 September 2000 Cover illustrations © Joseph R. Tomelleri FLOW AND TEMPERATURE RECOMMENDATIONS FOR ENDANGERED FISHES IN THE GREEN RIVER DOWNSTREAM OF FLAMING GORGE DAM prepared by Robert T. Muth,1 Larry W. Crist,2 Kirk E. LaGory,3 John W. Hayse,3 Kevin R. Bestgen,4 Thomas P. Ryan,2 Joseph K. Lyons,5 Richard A. Valdez6 1 Upper Colorado River Endangered Fish Recovery Program, U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, 134 Union Boulevard, Lakewood, Colorado 80228 2 U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, Upper Colorado Regional Office, 125 South State Street, Salt Lake City, Utah 84138 3 Environmental Assessment Division, Argonne National Laboratory, 9700 South Cass Avenue, Argonne, Illinois 60439 4 Larval Fish Laboratory, Department of Fishery and Wildlife Biology, Colorado State University, Fort Collins, Colorado 80523 5 Technical Services Center, Water Supply, Use, and Conservation Group, U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, P.O. 25007, Denver, Colorado 80225 6 SWCA, Inc. Environmental Consultants, 172 West 1275 South, Logan, Utah 84321 Final Report Upper Colorado River Endangered Fish Recovery Program Project FG-53 September 2000 Final Report September 2000 PRINCIPAL AUTHORS OF CHAPTERS OR MAJOR SECTIONS Chapter or Section Principal Authors Chapter 1: Introduction John W. Hayse, Kirk E. LaGory Chapter 2: Flaming Gorge Flow John W. Hayse, Robert T. Muth, Recommendations Investigation Kirk E. LaGory, Larry W. Crist Chapter 3: Hydrology and Joseph K. Lyons, Kirk E. LaGory, Geomorphology of the Green River Thomas P. Ryan Chapter 4: Fishes of the Green River 4.1 Overview Robert T. Muth 4.2 Colorado Pikeminnow Kevin R. Bestgen 4.3 Razorback Sucker Robert T. Muth 4.4 Humpback Chub Larry W. Crist, Richard A. Valdez Chapter 5: Flow and Temperature Robert T. Muth, Larry W. Crist, Recommendations Kirk E. LaGory, Kevin R. Bestgen, Thomas P. Ryan, John W. Hayse Appendix A: Supporting Information Thomas P. Ryan, Kirk E. LaGory on the Hydrology of the Green River System iii Final Report September 2000 iv Final Report September 2000 ACKNOWLEDGMENTS This project was funded by the Upper Colorado River Endangered Fish Recovery Program (Recovery Program). The Recovery Program is a joint effort of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service; U.S. Bureau of Reclamation; Western Area Power Administration; the states of Colorado, Utah, and Wyoming; upper basin water users; environmental organizations; and the Colorado River Energy Distributors Association. Authors of this synthesis report thank members of the Flaming Gorge Research Group and workshop participants (Appendix C) for their assistance and thoughtful input. L. Lentsch helped develop the foundation of this report. Technical reviews by D. Beyers, R. Marston, N. Poff, D. Propst, J. Stanford, R. Strand, B. Trush, and H. Tyus improved the report. We also thank the Recovery Program Biology Committee and other interested agencies or individuals for their reviews and comments. K. Fenton assisted in the production of maps and other selected figures. M. Moniger edited the final report. Administrative staffs of the U.S. Fish and Wildlife Service, Utah Field Office; U.S. Bureau of Reclamation, Upper Colorado Regional Office; Argonne National Laboratory; and Recovery Program Director’s Office assisted in compiling various drafts of this report. Disclaimer.—Opinions and recommendations expressed in this report are those of the authors and do not necessarily reflect the views of their respective agencies or the Upper Colorado River Endangered Fish Recovery Program. The mention of trade names, commercial products, or firms and businesses does not constitute endorsements or recommendations for use. v Final Report September 2000 vi Final Report September 2000 CONTENTS PRINCIPAL AUTHORS OF CHAPTERS OR MAJOR SECTIONS .................... iii ACKNOWLEDGMENTS .......................................................v LIST OF TABLES ............................................................ xi LIST OF FIGURES .......................................................... xv NOTATION ................................................................ xix EXECUTIVE SUMMARY ................................................... xxiii 1 INTRODUCTION ....................................................... 1-1 1.1 Purpose and Scope .................................................. 1-2 1.2 Changes in River Ecosystems of the Colorado River Basin .................. 1-3 1.2.1 The Green River System ........................................ 1-7 1.3 1992 Biological Opinion on Operation of Flaming Gorge Dam ............... 1-9 2 FLAMING GORGE FLOW RECOMMENDATIONS INVESTIGATION .......... 2-1 2.1 Study Area ........................................................ 2-1 2.2 Study Objectives and Approach ........................................ 2-1 2.3 Research Flows .................................................... 2-4 2.4 Development of Integrated Flow Recommendations ........................ 2-6 2.4.1 Workshops and Technical Reviews ............................... 2-7 2.4.2 Synthesis ................................................... 2-7 3 HYDROLOGY AND GEOMORPHOLOGY OF THE GREEN RIVER ............ 3-1 3.1 Characteristics of the Green River Basin ................................. 3-1 3.2 Operations of Flaming Gorge Dam ..................................... 3-4 3.3 Description of Green River Reaches Downstream of Flaming Gorge Dam ...... 3-6 3.4 Flows in the Green River Downstream of Flaming Gorge Dam ............... 3-9 3.4.1 Seasonal Distribution of Green River Flows ....................... 3-14 3.4.2 Peak Flows in the Green River ................................. 3-14 3.4.3 Base Flows in the Green River ................................. 3-18 3.4.4 Tributary Contributions to Green River Flow ...................... 3-25 3.4.5 Stage-Flow Relationships and the Effect of Hydropower Operations on Daily Fluctuations ......................................... 3-27 3.5 Green River Water Temperatures ..................................... 3-30 3.5.1 Summer Water Temperatures .................................. 3-32 3.5.1.1 Water Temperature in Reach 1 .......................... 3-32 3.5.1.2 Water Temperature in Reach 2 .......................... 3-33 3.5.1.3 Water Temperature in Reach 3 .......................... 3-33 vii Final Report September 2000 3.5.2 Ice Conditions .............................................. 3-34 3.6 Geomorphic Processes in the Green River .............................. 3-36 3.6.1 Channel Planforms ........................................... 3-37 3.6.1.1 Restricted and Fixed Meanders .......................... 3-37 3.6.1.2 Canyon Reaches with Abundant Debris Fans ............... 3-39 3.6.2 Sediment Dynamics, Shoreline Complexity, and Low-Velocity Habitats ........................................ 3-40 3.6.3 Sediment Dynamics and Spawning Substrates ..................... 3-44 3.6.4 Vertical Accretion of Banks and Channel Narrowing ................ 3-45 3.6.5 Floodplain Inundation ........................................ 3-47 3.7 Summary of Relationships between Flow, In-Channel Habitats, and Floodplain Inundation .............................................. 3-50 4 FISHES OF THE GREEN RIVER .......................................... 4-1 4.1 Overview ......................................................... 4-2 4.1.1 Native Fishes ................................................ 4-2 4.1.2 Nonnative Fishes ............................................. 4-6 4.2 Colorado Pikeminnow .............................................. 4-12 4.2.1 Distribution and Status Overview ............................... 4-12 4.2.2 Life History Overview ........................................ 4-12 4.2.3 Research on Colorado Pikeminnow for the 1992 Flaming Gorge Biological Opinion ........................................... 4-13 4.2.4 Research on Colorado Pikeminnow for the 1990–1996 Flaming Gorge Flow Recommendations Investigation ...................... 4-14 4.2.5 Ecology of Colorado Pikeminnow in the Green River System ......... 4-14 4.2.5.1 Distribution and Abundance ............................ 4-14 4.2.5.2 Life History by Season ................................ 4-21 4.2.5.3 Recruitment Dynamics ................................ 4-32 4.2.5.4 Limiting Factors for Colorado Pikeminnow in Historic Green River Habitat .................................. 4-37 4.2.6 Summary of Seasonal Flow-Habitat Relationships for Colorado Pikeminnow in the Green River System .......................... 4-41 4.2.6.1 Spring ............................................. 4-41 4.2.6.2 Summer and Autumn ................................. 4-42 4.2.6.3 Winter ............................................. 4-43 4.3 Razorback Sucker ................................................. 4-49 4.3.1 Distribution and Status Overview ............................... 4-49 4.3.2 Life History Overview ........................................ 4-50 4.3.3 Research on Razorback Sucker for the 1992 Flaming Gorge Biological Opinion ........................................... 4-51 4.3.4 Research on Razorback Sucker for the 1990–1996 Flaming Gorge Flow Recommendations Investigation ............................ 4-51 4.3.5 Ecology of Razorback Sucker in the Green River System ............. 4-52 4.3.5.1 Distribution and Abundance ...........................