Knitting Ourselves Into Being: the Case of Labour and Hip Domesticity on the Social Network Ravelry.Com

Total Page:16

File Type:pdf, Size:1020Kb

Knitting Ourselves Into Being: the Case of Labour and Hip Domesticity on the Social Network Ravelry.Com View metadata, citation and similar papers at core.ac.uk brought to you by CORE provided by ResearchArchive at Victoria University of Wellington Knitting Ourselves Into Being: the case of labour and hip domesticity on the social network Ravelry.com By Maria Hellstrom A thesis submitted to the Victoria University of Wellington in fulfilment of the requirements for the degree of Master of Arts in Media Studies Victoria University of Wellington 2013 1 Table of Contents Abstract ................................................................................................................................................... 3 Chapter 1 – Introducing Ravelry ............................................................................................................. 4 Welcome to the social network, where your knitting matters ........................................................... 4 We need to talk about labour ............................................................................................................. 6 What is Ravelry? A brief description ................................................................................................... 9 History, membership and context .................................................................................................... 10 Social capital and Ravelry .................................................................................................................. 12 Ravelry’s multiplicity of purpose: labour space, social space, marketplace ..................................... 13 “My Notebook” ................................................................................................................................. 15 Labour space ................................................................................................................................. 17 Commodity space.......................................................................................................................... 17 Social space ................................................................................................................................... 18 A little background: methods for studying online environments ..................................................... 19 Understanding writing, knitting and interfacing through textual analysis ....................................... 22 Thesis structure and chapter outlines .............................................................................................. 24 Chapter 2 - Finding the work in social network: an overview of social media labour .......................... 28 Chapter overview .............................................................................................................................. 28 The new media worker ..................................................................................................................... 29 Contextualizing immaterial labour: a brief history ........................................................................... 33 A brief discussion of affect ................................................................................................................ 37 Facebook: the all-you-can-network social media buffet .................................................................. 39 The specialist social network and kinetic self-representation .......................................................... 42 Locating Ravelry ................................................................................................................................ 44 The prolific profile? ........................................................................................................................... 45 Chapter 3 – Hip domesticity and the cloak of affect ............................................................................ 50 Introduction ...................................................................................................................................... 50 A modern history of domesticity ...................................................................................................... 51 Affective labour explained ................................................................................................................ 54 Domesticity vs. commodity? ............................................................................................................. 56 Hip home ec: from cyberfeminist resistance to hip domesticity ...................................................... 58 2 Gender: the elephant in Ravelry’s living room ................................................................................. 61 I am what I am, not what I knit. Replicating one’s offline social reality through online taste performance ..................................................................................................................................... 63 Hang on, travelling woman: grounding taste performance and affect in a finished object ............. 65 A critique of affect and immateriality ............................................................................................... 67 Conclusion ......................................................................................................................................... 69 Chapter 4 - Crafty commodities: buying, selling and knitting oneself into being ................................. 73 Introduction ...................................................................................................................................... 73 Recapping Ravelry’s spaces of interaction ........................................................................................ 76 What’s in your stash? Ravelry’s user-driven yarn marketplace and discourses of exclusivity ......... 79 The micro-economies of Ravelry: enmeshing handicrafts and capital ............................................. 84 The cloak of affect: Yarnies and enforced entrepreneurship ........................................................... 90 Incorporating materiality: Ravelry’s contribution to theory ............................................................ 92 Conclusion ......................................................................................................................................... 94 Overall conclusions ............................................................................................................................... 96 3 Abstract Knitting Ourselves Into Being: the case of labour and hip domesticity on the social network Ravelry.com Thinking of social media participation in terms of doing work may seem a strange proposition. Yet, social network and handicrafts website Ravelry.com requires a great deal of labour from its members. From painstakingly hand-knitting fuzzy objects to photographing, recording and sharing these objects online, Ravelers must supply evidence of their hard work in order to fully participate in this online community. On Ravelry, “writing oneself into being” (Sundén 2002), or performing one’s self through a textual medium, encompasses much more than simply writing. One must knit oneself into being too. Social capital is then accumulated through extensive cataloguing of handmade items. These ‘finished objects’ of knitting and crochet are imbued with affective meaning as tokens of nurturing and gift-giving, consistent with a historicity in which handicrafts like knitting have been associated with gendered care-work. Yet, much of Ravelry’s activity centres on commodity exchange. Displaying commodity ownership is as important as displaying evidence of labour for the accrual of social capital. Recording and displaying domesticity as both acts of labour and acts of consumption fit within a wider trend of hip domesticity, where demonstrating one’s domesticity has become a facet of popular culture. This project examines Ravelry.com’s emphasis on the placement of a physical object between the self and the social network. The thesis argues that this incorporation of material objects into the structure of a social network challenges notions of disembodiment and immateriality. Ravelry.com demonstrates the need for a discussion of social media participant labour which goes beyond the immaterial and affective. 4 Chapter 1 – Introducing Ravelry Welcome to the social network, where your knitting matters Traditional domestic arts such as knitting and crochet are perhaps not the associations which first spring to mind when talking about social networks and new media technologies. Yet, communities surrounding these traditional handicrafts flourish online. The fibrecrafts-oriented website Ravelry.com (“a site for knitters and crocheters”) is prominent within these communities, and within this site, and others like it, a particular social network dynamic has emerged. At a cursory glance, the Ravelry world may seem straight-forward: it is a one-stop shop for the resources required for knitting or crocheting, and additionally fulfils the expectations of social network functions so prevalent within contemporary online mediascapes. Yet, an interesting moment occurs when attempting to access Ravelry’s social network. It appears that simply identifying oneself as a knitter or crocheter (as one evidently is when signing up to such a niche site) is not in itself sufficient for gaining the social capital necessary for full entry into Ravelry as community. It is not adequate to state that one is a knitter or crocheter – one must prove it through acts of labour
Recommended publications
  • K2TOG NL Sept2018
    THE OFFICIAL NEWSLETTER OF THE K2TOG KNITTING GUILD ASSOCIATION CONTENTS 1 September 2018 2 Program News 3 The Word on Fall Fashion 4 Knitting Outside the Box 5 Accurately Measure Gauge 6 A Guild Knit-Along - Up the Learning Curve 7 Chunky Fall Headband September 2018 9 Pantone Top 10 Color Palette September 2018 Get Ready For Fall Knitting! !1 Program News • Design approval for Level 3 projects that may deviate 2018 Master Hand Knitting from the directions. I Have A Question! The program includes many exercises other than just At some point in working the MHK program, you may knitting. These show your ability to read the directions and also find you have a question. What do you do? Where can you find find materials that meet the requirements. We are testing your the answer? ability to not only knit well but also your ability to: September There are several methods to get the answer you need. • Find resources that can be recommended to other You’ll need to decide if it’s the topic you don’t understand or knitters the wording of the instructions that is causing your confusion. • Find and evaluate resources for techniques that are K2TOG Other questions may concern materials for projects. If it’s the unfamiliar to you topic you are not understanding, you need to step back and • Succinctly and clearly write directions for techniques that research the topic. We’ve discussed the many ways to research another knitter can understand and follow for this program in this newsletter, on Ravelry, and in the On • Gather information on topics related to knitting.
    [Show full text]
  • 'Nothing but the Truth': Genre, Gender and Knowledge in the US
    ‘Nothing but the Truth’: Genre, Gender and Knowledge in the US Television Crime Drama 2005-2010 Hannah Ellison Submitted for the degree of Doctor of Philosophy (PhD) University of East Anglia School of Film, Television and Media Studies Submitted January 2014 ©This copy of the thesis has been supplied on condition that anyone who consults it is understood to recognise that its copyright rests with the author and that no quotation from the thesis, nor any information derived therefrom, may be published without the author's prior, written consent. 2 | Page Hannah Ellison Abstract Over the five year period 2005-2010 the crime drama became one of the most produced genres on American prime-time television and also one of the most routinely ignored academically. This particular cyclical genre influx was notable for the resurgence and reformulating of the amateur sleuth; this time remerging as the gifted police consultant, a figure capable of insights that the police could not manage. I term these new shows ‘consultant procedurals’. Consequently, the genre moved away from dealing with the ills of society and instead focused on the mystery of crime. Refocusing the genre gave rise to new issues. Questions are raised about how knowledge is gained and who has the right to it. With the individual consultant spearheading criminal investigation, without official standing, the genre is re-inflected with issues around legitimacy and power. The genre also reengages with age-old questions about the role gender plays in the performance of investigation. With the aim of answering these questions one of the jobs of this thesis is to find a way of analysing genre that accounts for both its larger cyclical, shifting nature and its simultaneously rigid construction of particular conventions.
    [Show full text]
  • Simple Crocheted Blanket Materials • Hook – Size G • Yarn – Acrylic Baby
    Simple Crocheted Blanket Materials Hook – Size G Yarn – Acrylic Baby Yarn (NO MOHAIR) 140 Stitches for 36”‐38”; 3‐ply – 120 stitches (approx.); 4 –ply – 100 stitches (approx.) Instructions ROW 1 – Chain enough stitches to make string 36‐38” ROW 2 – Double crochet in each chain, starting in 3rd stitch; Chain 3 turn ROW 3 to END – Starting in 2nd DC; continue back and forth until blanket is square. FINISH Tie off end; Weave end of thread into blanket. NO FRINGE PLEASE Option– Single crochet around 4 sides (making 3 S.C. in corner stitch) as a border. Marge’s “Very Easy” Crochet Baby Blanket Materials Baby or Sport Yarn (approximately 6 skeins – 3 ply) G Hook Instructions Row 1 – Chain 140 stitches (36”‐38”) or 100 stitches with 4‐ply Row 2 – DC (Double Crochet) in 4th stitch from end, DC across; at end Ch. 3 Row 3 – DC in 1st DC, continue across row, Ch. 3 at end; Repeat Row 3 until blanket is square Last Row = Tie off end. Weave 2‐3” of yarn into blanket to hide end. Option – Can do a crochet edge around just as a finish. Bev's Stretchy Knit Baby Cap copyright 2001, 2010 Beverly A Qualheim This cap can be made for a boy or girl preemie, and fits from 2- 3 lbs- (4-5 lb) (7-8 lb) babies . It is super fast to knit up and will stretch to fit. 1 oz. of sport or baby yarn - not fingering Size 9 knitting needles (size 5 Canadian and English -5.5 mm) Loosely cast on 36 (44) (50) sts.
    [Show full text]
  • Knitting Needles Plus Bonus Knitting Needle Conversion Chart
    FREE GUIDE TO Knitting Needles Plus Bonus Knitting Needle Conversion Chart ® ©Interweave | Not to be reprinted | All rights reserved | interweaveknits.com Free Guide to Knitting Needles PLUS BONUS KNITTING NEEDLE CONVERSION CHART When a project and knitter find their perfect needle match, stitches slip by effortlessly. Like knitters, needles come in all shapes and sizes, and somewhere on that wall of needles at your local yarn store, there’s FREE GUIDE TO KNITTING a set perfect for you. But is it wood? Metal? Plastic? NEEDLES PLUS BONUS KNITTING Straight or circular? Fixed or interchangeable? Short NEEDLE CONVERSION CHART An Interweave Knits eBook edited by of buying every pair and trying them all out, how do the Interweave Knits Staff you find your needles, the ones that create a seamless EDITORIAL STAFF transition between your hands and your project? EDITOR, INTERWEAVE KNITS Eunny Jang We tested dozens of needles to help you find your EDITOR, KNITTING DAILY Kathleen Cubley knitting soulmate. CREATIVE SERVICES DESIGNER Charlene Tiedemann PHOTOGRAPHY Amanda Williams PRODUCTION Dean Howes Cheers, Eunny Jang Editor, Interweave Knits ©Interweave | Not to be reprinted | All rights reserved | interweaveknits.com i b e without exception, a pleasure to hold and c f to behold. a Pros: Good-looking, warm to the touch, d g quiet, light (especially bamboo) Cons: Can be delicate; smaller sizes vulner- able to breaking or warping under stress Good for: Lace knitters and beginning knitters, who will appreciate the way Wood Needles stitches stay put;
    [Show full text]
  • VOGUEKNITTINGLIVE.COM SC HEDULE Thursday, October 23 Registration: 3 P.M
    VOGU Eknitting CHICAGO THE ULTIMATE KNITTING EVENT OCTOBER 24 –26 ,2014 • PALMER HOUSE HILTON HOTEL PRINTABLE BROCHURE NEW& INSPIRATIONAL KNITWORTHY HAND KNITTING PRODUCTS CLASSES & LECTURES! VOGUEKNITTINGLIVE.COM SC HEDULE Thursday, October 23 Registration: 3 p.m. –7 p.m. OF EVENTS Classroom Hours: 6 p.m. –9 p.m. Friday, October 24 VOGUEknitting Registration: 8 a.m. –7:30 p.m. 3-hour Classroom Hours: 9 a.m.–12 p.m., 2 p.m.–5 p.m., 6 p.m. –9 p.m. 2-hour Classroom Hours: 9 a.m.–11 a.m., 2 p.m.–4 p.m. Marketplace: 5:00 p.m. –8:30 p.m. Please refer to VogueknittingLIVE.com for complete details. Saturday, October 25 HOTEL INFORMATION Registration: 8 a.m. –6:30 p.m. Vogue Knitting LIVE will be held in 3-hour Classroom Hours: 9 a.m.–12 p.m., 2 p.m.–5 p.m., 6 p.m. –9 p.m. downtown Chicago at the luxurious 2-hour Classroom Hours: Palmer House Hilton Hotel, located 9 a.m.–11 a.m., 2 p.m.–4 p.m. near Millennium Park in the heart of Marketplace: 10 a.m. –6:30 p.m. the theater, financial, and shopping districts of downtown Chicago. The Palmer House Hilton Hotel is within walking distance of the Windy City’s Sunday, October 26 most famous museums, shopping,a government, and corporate buildings. Registration: 8 a.m. –3 p.m. 3-hour Classroom Hours: The Palmer House Hilton Hotel 9 a.m.–12 p.m., 2 p.m.–5 p.m.
    [Show full text]
  • FIVE by FIVE a Ribbed Infinity Cowl // by Felicia Lo KNITTING PATTERN
    FIVE BY FIVE a ribbed infinity cowl // by Felicia Lo KNITTING PATTERN Blend and indulge in the colours and textures of beautiful hand-dyed yarns. This super easy- to-knit cowl takes three yarns knit together to make a lush, cozy and bouncy infinity loop that can be worn wrapped once as a cowl or unwrapped as a scarf. Find your perfect blend! SKILL LEVEL NEEDLES & NOTIONS Beginner US 10 ¾ / 7 mm needles Adjust needle size if necessary to obtain the correct gauge. FINISHED MEASUREMENTS Spare knitting needle, yarn needle, crochet hook and waste yarn for 52" / 122 cm circumference, 7" / 18 cm wide provisional cast-on YARN GAUGE 1 skein SweetGeorgia Yarns Silk Mist in Wisteria (325 yd / 297 m 14 sts and 18 rows = 4" / 10 cm in Five by Five Rib, after blocking. per 0.88 oz / 25 g skein; 60% Fine Kid Mohair, 40% Cultivated Silk). Please note that changes in gauge will affect yardage used and 2 skeins SweetGeorgia Yarns CashLuxe Fine, 1 each in Magician final measurements. and Mulberry (400 yd / 365 m per 4 oz / 115 g skein; 70% Superwash Merino, 20% Cashmere, 10% Nylon). All three yarns are held together throughout. Version 1.1 // © SweetGeorgia Yarns 2020 unapologetic colour + craft since 2005 | sweetgeorgiayarns.com 2 Version 1.1 // © SweetGeorgia Yarns 2020 FIVE BY FIVE // by Felicia Lo ABBREVIATIONS SPECIAL TECHNIQUES approx approximately Note: to work Kitchener St over ribbing, CO cast on flip your work to the other side each time k knit you reach the purl stitches. This way, you mult multiple are always working Kitchener St over what p purl appears to be stockinette.
    [Show full text]
  • Vogue Knitting LIVE Launches in New York City in January
    NEW YORK, NEW YORK 6,000 Knitters and Industry “Knitterati” to Gather for New Event Vogue Knitting LIVE Launches in New York City in January. Popular Classes Already Sold Out More than 53 million people know how to knit or crochet—and the number is growing. Following the successful premier of Vogue Knitting LIVE in Los Angeles last year, Vogue Knitting magazine announces a new event at the Hilton New York January 14–16, 2012 . Knitting, an ages-old craft, is taking the world by storm. Professionals, Hollywood A-listers, and rock stars have all joined the ranks of knitters, and Ravelry, a popular social media site for stitchers, boasts close to 2 million members. Its benefits are renown: A Harvard study from 2007 concluded that knitting may be as effective as medication in reducing stress. “We know that knitters love getting together at yarn stores to learn new techniques, compare projects, and hear from top designers. We’ve simply taken that to the next level by creating the largest live gathering of knitters in New York,” says Trisha Malcolm, editor of Vogue Knitting and originator of Vogue Knitting LIVE. Vogue Knitting LIVE caters to knitters at all levels—from the knit-curious to experienced designers and crafters. In 2012, knitters can expect: • More than 75 how-to sessions, some of which are already sold out. Topics like “An Overture to Estonian Lace” and “Working with Antique and Vintage Knitting Patterns” bring 200-year old techniques to new generations. Other sessions such as “Happy Hat Knitting” and “Sock Innovation” focus on specific types of projects.
    [Show full text]
  • KNITTING Definition Statement Relationship Between Large Subject
    D04B KNITTING Definition statement This subclass/group covers: weft knitting machines are covered by D04B 7/00 to D04B 13/00, details of, or auxiliary devices incorporated in such machines are covered by D04B 15/00 and articles made by such machines are covered by D04B 1/00 warp knitting machines are covered by D04B 23/00 to D04B 25/00, details of, or auxiliary devices incorporated in such machines are covered by D04B 27/00 and articles made by such machines are covered by D04B 21/00 details of, or auxiliary devices incorporated in knitting machines not limited to a specific kind of knitting machine are covered by D04B 35/00 miscellaneous knitting machines and articles made by such machines are covered by D04B 39/00 hand knitting equipment is covered by D04B 3/00, D04B 5/00 and D04B 33/00 auxiliary apparatuses or devices for use with knitting machines are covered by D04B 37/00 or for hand knitting equipment are covered by D04B 17/00, D04B 19/00 and D04B 31/00 Relationship between large subject matter areas The difference between the subclass D04B and B32B5 is as follows:layered products including knitted products as such should be classified in B32B5 only; layered products formed by a knitting process featuring specified patterns or information on the composition of the knit article should be classified in D04B. Note that such products may comprise additional coated faces. References relevant to classification in this subclass This subclass/group does not cover: Layered products (i.e. laminates) B32B 5/00 including knitted articles 1 Knitted products of unspecified A41A61F structure or composition, e.g.
    [Show full text]
  • Textile Design: a Suggested Program Guide
    DOCUMENT RESUME CI 003 141 ED 102 409 95 Program Guide.Fashion TITLE Textile Design: A Suggested Industry Series No. 3. Fashion Inst. of Tech.,New York, N.T. INSTITUTION Education SPONS AGENCY Bureau of Adult,Vocational, and Technictl (DREW /OE), Washington,D.C. PUB DATE 73 in Fashion Industry NOTE 121p.; For other documents Series, see CB 003139-142 and CB 003 621 Printing AVAILABLE FROM Superintendent of Documents,U.S. Government Office, Washington, D.C.20402 EDRS PRICE NP -$0.76 HC-$5.70 PLUS POSTAGE Behavioral Objectives; DESCRIPTORS Adult, Vocational Education; Career Ladders; *CurriculumGuides; *Design; Design Crafts; EducationalEquipment; Employment Opportunities; InstructionalMaterials; *Job Training; Needle Trades;*Occupational Rome Economics; OccupationalInformation; Program Development; ResourceGuides; Resource Units; Secondary Education;Skill Development;*Textiles Instruction IDENTIFIERS *Fashion Industry ABSTRACT The textile designguide is the third of aseries of resource guidesencompassing the various five interrelated program guide is disensions of the fashionindustry. The job-preparatory conceived to provide youthand adults withintensive preparation for and also with careeradvancement initial entry esploysent jobs within the textile opportunities withinspecific categories of provides an overviewof the textiledesign field, industry. The guide required of workers. It occupational opportunities,and cospetencies contains outlines of areasof instruction whichinclude objectives to suggestions for learning be achieved,teaching
    [Show full text]
  • Would You Like to Receive a 2020 Catalog?
    Would you like to receive a 2020 catalog? There will be a $5 shipping fee to cover the cost of postage on all mailed catalogs. Return this card along with a check for $5 made payable to Maryland Sheep & Wool Festival to PO Box 99, Glenwood, MD 21738, or order a catalog online at www.sheepandwool.org. There will be a $25 charge on any check returned for any reason. Please send me a 2020 Festival Catalog Please Print Clearly Name Address City State Zip Phone # or email Check if this is a change of address. I have enclosed a check for $5 per catalog to cover shipping. Number of catalogs ordered _____. I have enclosed a donation of $_____. Total enclosed $ __________. The Forty-Sixth Annual May 4 & 5, 2019 Howard County Fairgrounds Sponsored by The Maryland Sheep Breeders Association Cover art by Bart Walter Artist information on page 40 Cover design by Ashton Design The Maryland Sheep & Wool Festival is presented by the Maryland Sheep Breeders Association, Inc., a not for profit organization. The Festival’s purpose is to educate the public about sheep and wool. The Festival is organized and conducted by volunteers from the sheep breeding and fiber arts communities. Maryland Sheep & Wool Festival PO Box 99, Glenwood, MD 21738 410-531-3647 www.sheepandwool.org Festival Location: Howard County Fairgrounds 2210 Fairgrounds Road, West Friendship, MD 21794 2020 Festival Dates: May 2 & 3 CONTENTS Festival Map ........................................2 Sheep Breeds Display .....................118 2019 Sheep & Wool Festival Sheep Shearing Demonstrations
    [Show full text]
  • Mary Walker Phillips: “Creative Knitting” and the Cranbrook Experience
    Mary Walker Phillips: “Creative Knitting” and the Cranbrook Experience Jennifer L. Lindsay Submitted in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the degree Master of Arts in the History of Decorative Arts Masters Program in the History of Decorative Arts The Smithsonian Associates and Corcoran College of Art + Design 2010 ©2010 Jennifer Laurel Lindsay All Rights Reserved TABLE OF CONTENTS LIST OF ILLUSTRATIONS.............................................................................................iii PREFACE........................................................................................................................... x ACKNOWLDGEMENTS ............................................................................................... xiv INTRODUCTION .............................................................................................................. 1 CHAPTER 1. CRANBROOK: “[A] RESEARCH INSTITUTION OF CREATIVE ART”............................................................................................................ 11 Part 1. Founding the Cranbrook Academy of Art............................................................. 11 Section 1. Origins of the Academy....................................................................... 11 Section 2. A Curriculum for Modern Artists in Modern Times ........................... 16 Section 3. Cranbrook’s Landscape and Architecture: “A Total Work of Art”.... 20 Part 2. History of Weaving and Textiles at Cranbrook..................................................... 23
    [Show full text]
  • Representations of Bisexual Women in Twenty-First Century Popular Culture
    Straddling (In)Visibility: Representations of Bisexual Women in Twenty-First Century Popular Culture Sasha Cocarla A thesis submitted to the Faculty of Graduate and Postdoctoral Studies in partial fulfillment of the requirements for the Doctorate of Philosophy in Women's Studies Institute of Feminist and Gender Studies Faculty of Social Sciences University of Ottawa © Sasha Cocarla, Ottawa, Canada 2016 Abstract Throughout the first decade of the 2000s, LGBTQ+ visibility has steadily increased in North American popular culture, allowing for not only more LGBTQ+ characters/figures to surface, but also establishing more diverse and nuanced representations and storylines. Bisexuality, while being part of the increasingly popular phrase of inclusivity (LGBTQ+), however, is one sexuality that not only continues to be overlooked within popular culture but that also continues to be represented in limited ways. In this doctoral thesis I examine how bisexual women are represented within mainstream popular culture, in particular on American television, focusing on two, popular programs (The L Word and the Shot At Love series). These texts have been chosen for popularity and visibility in mainstream media and culture, as well as for how bisexual women are unprecedentedly made central to many of the storylines (The L Word) and the series as a whole (Shot At Love). This analysis provides not only a detailed historical account of bisexual visibility but also discusses bisexuality thematically, highlighting commonalities across bisexual representations as well as shared themes between and with other identities. By examining key examples of bisexuality in popular culture from the first decade of the twenty- first century, my research investigates how representations of bisexuality are often portrayed in conversation with hegemonic understandings of gender and sexuality, specifically highlighting the mainstream "gay rights" movement's narrative of "normality" and "just like you" politics.
    [Show full text]