June 2015 Welcome to your Digital Edition of Aerospace & Defense Technology Maximizing Thermal Cooling Efficiencies in High-Performance Processors Stand-Off Scanning and Pointing with Risley Prisms Getting It Right with Composites June 2015 Solutions for RF Power Amplifier Test com ensetech. .aerodef www Supplement to NASA Tech Briefs
How to Navigate the Magazine:
At the bottom of each page, you will see a navigation bar with the following buttons:
➭ Arrows: Click on the right or left facing arrow to turn the page forward or backward.
Intro Introduction: Click on this icon to quickly turn to this page.
Cov Cover: Click on this icon to quickly turn to the front cover.
ToC Table of Contents: Click on this icon to quickly turn to the table of contents.
+ Zoom In: Click on this magnifying glass icon to zoom in on the page.
– Zoom Out: Click on this magnifying glass icon to zoom out on the page.
A Find: Click on this icon to search the document.
You can also use the standard Acrobat Reader tools to navigate through each magazine. ➮ Intro Cov ToC + – A ➭ FROM MODEL
TO APP
How do you create the best design and share your simulation expertise? through powerful computational tools. with simulation apps that can be easily shared. comsol.com/5.1
PRODUCT SUITE
› COMSOL Multiphysics® › COMSOL Server™
ELECTRICAL MECHANICAL FLUID CHEMICAL INTERFACING › AC/DC Module › Heat Transfer Module › CFD Module › Chemical Reaction › LiveLink™ for MATLAB® › RF Module › Structural Mechanics › Mixer Module Engineering Module › LiveLink™ for Excel® › Wave Optics Module Module › Microfl uidics Module › Batteries & Fuel Cells › CAD Import Module › Ray Optics Module › Nonlinear Structural › Subsurface Flow Module Module › Design Module › MEMS Module Materials Module › Pipe Flow Module › Electrodeposition Module › ECAD Import Module › Plasma Module › Geomechanics Module › Molecular Flow Module › Corrosion Module › LiveLink™ for SOLIDWORKS® › Semiconductor Module › Fatigue Module › Electrochemistry Module › LiveLink™ for Inventor® › Multibody Dynamics › LiveLink™ for AutoCAD® Module MULTIPURPOSE › LiveLink™ for Revit® › Acoustics Module › Optimization Module › LiveLink™ for PTC® Creo® Parametric™ › Material Library › LiveLink™ for PTC® Pro/ENGINEER® › Particle Tracing Module › LiveLink™ for Solid Edge® › File Import for CATIA® V5
© Copyright 2015 COMSOL. COMSOL, COMSOL Multiphysics, Capture the Concept, COMSOL Desktop, COMSOL Server, and LiveLink are either registered trademarks or trademarks of COMSOL AB. All other trademarks are the property of their respective owners, and COMSOL AB and its subsidiaries and products are not affi liated with, endorsed by, sponsored by, or supported by those trademark owners. For a list of such trademark owners, see www.comsol.com/trademarks.
Free Info at http://info.hotims.com/55590-902 ➮ Intro Cov ToC + – A ➭ June 2015
Innovative Motion for Aerospace Testing
Maximizing Thermal Cooling Efficiencies in High-Performance Processors Stand-Off Scanning and Pointing with RislRisley Prisms Getting It Right with Composites Solutions for RF Power Amplifier Test
Dedicated to the Science of Motion www.aerodefensetech.com www.aerotech.com
Supplement to NASA Tech Briefs ➮ Intro Cov ToC + – A ➭ Aerotech’s aerospace and defense manufacturing and test systems span the realm of laser processing, additive manufacturing, large component test and inspection, electro-optic test, rotary and linear sensor test, vacuum, pointing and tracking, inertial test motion simulators, and advanced controls. Contact us to find out how we can improve your process.
Aerotech expertise includes: • EO/IR Sensor Testing • Satellite Sensor Vacuum Chamber Testing • Satellite Tracking Gimbals • Antenna & Missile Seeker Testing • Automated NDT Motion Systems • Outdoor Prototype Sensor Testing • LIDAR Scanners, Laser Processing Systems • Laser Communications, Directed Energy and Ranging Gimbals • Ground Support Equipment Motion Controls • Additive Manufacturing and Conductive Inks Direct-Writing Systems • Optical Inspection Systems • Motion Simulation for Inertial Device Testing • Aircraft Ground Mapping Gimbals • Resolver & Optical Encoder Calibration Systems • Servo, Stepper, Voice Coil, Piezo Controls
Contact our Research, Aerospace, and Defense Group to discuss your application today. Ph: 412-963-7470 Email: [email protected] www.aerotech.com
Dedicated to the Science of Motion
AH0415B-RAD
Free Info at http://info.hotims.com/55590-871 ➮ Intro Cov ToC + – A ➭ June 2015
Maximizing Thermal Cooling Efficiencies in High-Performance Processors Stand-Off Scanning and Pointing with Risley Prisms Getting It Right with Composites Solutions for RF Power Amplifier Test
www.aerodefensetech.com
Supplement to NASA Tech Briefs ➮ Intro Cov ToC + – A ➭ Innovative Solutions RTD’s Embedded COCOTSTS SSystemsystems and Enclosures
COM 2 & 4 AtAt RTD, we have developed a fullfull suite ofof compatible
Surface-Mounted DDR3 COM 1 & 3 bboardsoards and systems that serve dedefense,fense, aerospace, SDRAM with ECC marmaritime,itime, ground,ground, industrialindustrial andand research-basedresearch-based 14 Advanced DigitalDigital I/OI/O Solid State aapplications.pplications. WeWe provideprovide high-quality,high-quality, cutting-edge,cutting-edge, Flash Disk Utilityty Port 2.02.0 cconcept-to-deployment,oncept-to-deployment, rugged,rugged, embeddedembedded solutions.solutions.
SVSVGA Whether you need a stack ooff modules, or a ffullyully eenclosednclosed system, RTD has a solution for you. CallCall us to DisplayPortDisplayP withwith AudioAu lleverageeverage our iinnovativennovative productproduct lineline to ddesignesign your own eembeddedmbedded ssystemystem that is reliable, flexible, expandable, 2 USB 2.0 Power aandnd field-serviceable.field-serviceable. Let us show you what we do best. GigE Stackable PCI Express StartStart here: www.rtd.com/systemswww.rtd.com/systems Type 2 Connectors
GigE SATA
LearnLearn more about this QQuad-Coreuad-Core Intel Core i7 - ISO 00 9 1 0 SingleSingle Board CPU at www.rtd.com/iwww.rtd.com/i77 9 0 S 1
A
C ERTIFIED
CopyrightCopyright © 2015 RTD Embedded Technologies,Technologies, Inc. All rightsrights reserved. All trademarks or registeredregistered trademarks are the propertpropertyy of their respective companies.companies.
AS9100AS9100 and ISOISO 9001 CCertifiertifi eded www.rtd.comwww.rtd.com GSA Contract HolderHolder s [email protected]@rtd.com
Free Info at http://info.hotims.com/55590-872 ➮ Intro Cov ToC + – A ➭ TUBING INNOVATIONS TUBING SOLUTIONS TUBING EXCELLENCE
See us at the Paris Air Show, Hall 2B, Stand G170 (WEAF)
1965 1970 1980 1999 2006 2014 Fine Tubes and Superior Tube NASA Space Shuttle (XURðJKWHUXVHV Fine Tubes Fine Tubes Superior Tube supplies the life support system Fine Tubes titanium supplies Airbus supplies specialist collaborate to Ti3Al2.5V hydraulic relies on high tubing for hydraulic A380 with tubing for Solar supply tubes for the line tubing used in pressure stainless systems & EJ200 Ti3Al2.5V tubing Orbiter satellite to AM350 Concorde )(DJOHðJKWHU steel tubing by for 5,000 psi investigate the Sun program Superior Tube hydraulic systems
With over 150 years combined expertise in supplying high performance tubing, Fine Tubes and Superior Tube have a proven track record of turning design concepts of today Contact Us into industry standards tomorrow. Our teams of metallurgists and engineers work closely with the world’s leading manufacturers in the aerospace and defense industry developing tubing solutions for ‘mission critical’ applications. :HVXSSRUWRXUFXVWRPHUVLQLPSURYLQJVSHFLðFDWLRQV and to help them solve their future technical challenges. tel: +44 (0) 1752 876406 WHO Involve us at an early stage to discuss your requirements HPDLODHURVSDFH#ÀQHWXEHVFRP HPDLOLQIR#VXSHULRUWXEHFRP for innovative tubing solutions in Stainless Steel, Nickel, Titanium and Zirconium alloys. twitter.com/FineTubes twitter.com/SuperiorTube
Tubing excellence built on innovation and quality YEARS
Free Info at http://info.hotims.com/55590-873 ➮ Intro Cov ToC + – A ➭ Aerospace & Defense Technology Contents FEATURES ______DEPARTMENTS ______6 Rugged Computing 35 Technology Update 6 Maximizing Thermal Cooling Efficiencies 43 Application Briefs in High Performance Processors 46 New Products 12 Lasers & Optics 49 Advertisers Index 12 Stand-Off Scanning and Pointing with Risley Prisms 50 What’s Online 18 Simulation/Manufacturing ______18 Getting It Right with Composites ON THE COVER 24 Aircraft In an attempt to reduce the noise footprint of aircraft during landing, NASA has expand- 24 Regional and Bizjets Refined and Redefined ed its use of Exa Corp’s PowerFLOW soft- 28 RF & Microwave Technology ware. This image shows the radiated sound field from a business jet with flaps and main 28 Solutions for RF Power Amplifier Test landing gear deployed. To learn more, check 34 Air-Ground Communications System Aims out the What’s Online section on page 50. to Make Flying Safer (Photo courtesy of Exa Corp) 37 Tech Briefs 37 Fabricating Transparent and Stretchable Supercapacitors Based on Wrinkled Graphene Electrodes 38 Modular Exhaust Design and Manufacturing Techniques for Build-to-Order Muffler Systems 40 Silicon Microsphere Fabrication 41 Designing and Fabricating a Multiple-Decade Battery
Coherent beam propagation Get the right result when FRED Stray light analysis software is part of the equation. Illumination and non-imaging optical design FRED® – Photon Engineering’s leading optical engineering Imaging system analysis software – works seamlessly with your optical design and CAD Multi-wavelength software to achieve your final results quickly and accurately. characterization Find out why major universities, national labs, and government and Thermal imagery aerospace organizations around the world depend on FRED to play an integral role in their scientific and engineering projects. There’s never been a better time to add FRED® software to the equation.
520.733.9557 | 310 S. Williams Blvd., Suite 222 | Tucson, AZ 85711 www.photonengr.com
2 Free Info at http://info.hotims.com/55590-874 Aerospace & Defense Technology, June 2015 ➮ Intro Cov ToC + – A ➭ Critical Moments call for Critical Products
Coilcraft CPS has the battle-proven magnetics you need when the mission is on the line
Our critical-grade RF and Power inductors are built to We also offer comprehensive product testing and withstand the most punishing conditions imaginable, validation services in accordance with MIL-STD-981 including extreme temperatures, thermal shock, and EEE-INST-002, as well as custom screening to G-forces, EMI and vibration. your electrical and physical specifi cations. • Tin-lead (Sn-Pb) terminations for the best possible Learn more about how our battle-tested board adhesion. RoHS terminations also available. components will keep your • Extended temperature ranges (-55°C to +200°C) mission on target. Call or • Vibration testing to 80 G / shock testing to 1000 G visit us online today!
800.981.0363 847.639.6400 www.coilcraft-cps.com
Free Info at http://info.hotims.com/55590-875 ➮ Intro Cov ToC + – A ➭ ONE PARTNER FOR EVERY
From 3D printed prototyping to full-scale production, Stratasys Direct Manufacturing empowers designers and engineers with solutions at every stage of the design and development process. Discover our industry-leading machine capacity and full suite of traditional and advanced manufacturing services to manufacture your products better, faster and more affordably. To learn how Stratasys combined the widest breadth of technology and experience
from the industry’s top service pioneers, visit STRATASYSDIRECT.COM ➮ Intro Cov ToC + – A ➭ N O
A FULL SUITE OF TRADITIONAL & ADDITIVE MANUFACTURING TECHNOLOGIES
STRATASYSDIRECT.COM 1-888-311-1017
PART [email protected] ➮ Intro Cov ToC + – A ➭ Maximizing Thermal Cooling Efficiencies in High-Performance Processors
espite the continuous devel- opment of new, higher per- forming processors, the thirst Dfor increased embedded com- puting capability remains unquenched. In fact, it seems like Moore’s Law may have slowed when it comes to fre- quency but increased in terms of driv- ing processor core and field program- mable gate array (FPGA) LUTS counts. The previous need for fewer frequency increases has become a need for in- creased core counts, faster front side bus speeds, and greater support chip inte- gration, all of which drive continually rising power requirements. Meeting these ever increasing "compute density escalations" while simultaneously maxi- mizing thermal cooling efficiencies re- quires innovative packaging solutions. The need to increase core counts in Figure 1. Intel®Microprocessor Pin Count Over Time (Credit: Lee Pavelich, Progression of CPU Pin Counts, processor chips and LUTs growth in Scrub Physics blog, September 19, 2011) FPGAs continues to grow at an un- precedented pace. Processor manufac- turers like Intel and AMD continue to integrate functionality and processor core count to achieve greater processor volumetric efficiency. FPGA suppliers like Xilinx and Altera that dominate 90% of the FPGA market are offering larger LUTs-size FPGAs that appeal to embedded computing engineers, but come at a higher thermal management cost. This thermal management chal- lenge is usually left to the end of the design process when engineers start to ask, “How will we cool these new chip densities?”
Size Matters Silicon chips continue to evolve. Fig- Figure 2 (left to right). Intel "Arrandale" mobile-class processor, Intel "Haswell" server-class processor with ure 1 articulates how the ball grid array integrated heat sink. (Images courtesy of Intel Corporation)
6 www.aerodefensetech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, June 2015 ➮ Intro Cov ToC + – A ➭ WorkReduce, with Save, an embedded Improve. computing partner you can count on Elma’s Rugged Platforms Do All That - And More.
No one in embedded computing offers as many products and services as Elma. Our embedded computing expertise and modular designs give our customers a serious advantage. Add to that our newest line of rugged Small Form Factor platforms for critical mission COTS computing and Cisco®-enabled rugged routers and switches.
We’re an extension of your team -- we fill in where you need us most, and we’re there every step of the way.
Find out why Elma is truly Your Solution Partner.
Free Info at http://info.hotims.com/55590-877 ➮ Intro Cov ToC + – A ➭ Rugged Computing
Figure 3 (left to right). Thermal scans of mobile-class, server-class and FPGA chips.
(BGA) ball quantities of server and mo- bile-class chips have continued to grow in package size as functionality is inte- grated into the processor or scaled into the FPGAs. The portable device market requires a smaller volumetric approach and a cooling demand driven by size, weight and power (SWaP). Handheld devices, tablets, and laptops require maximum cooling in a very small environment. Server-class chips, however, use a differ- ent approach. Figure 2 shows a mobile- class processor and a server-class processor that offers a built-in heat spreader to aid in the mass transfer of thermal energy. Each of these chips requires a differ- ent approach to dealing with this chal- lenge. The smaller device demands an approach that controls the distribution of energy in a manner that does not add weight. The server-class chips are driv- ing larger BGA ball counts and control- ling the thermal heat spread of the chip with copper surfaces and volume to mass transfer energy to server-designed Figure 4. Mercury's 6U OpenVPX payload cards may be packaged in a variety of standards-compatible heat sinks. The size and weight is signif- cooling options without modification. icantly different. increase in size and carry a non-linear square inch is no longer a sensible Thermal Densities — The Hidden thermal distribution in thermal energy measure for linearly analyzing these Variables heat flux. challenges. When sophisticated compu- When looking at these very different Figure 3 shows some of the enormous tational fluid dynamic (CFD) software technologies in silicon-based chips and challenges present in all three silicon tools like Flotherm, Ice Pack, or others their ever-shrinking lithography imple- technologies. The FLIR camera analysis are utilized, linear energy distribution is mentations, one attribute is extremely shows that there are significant differ- not observed. Thermal energy density consistent. As functionality and capa- ences in the thermal heat generation in and the ability to mass transfer the con- bilities are scaled into the chips, they the silicon. This means that watts per centrated heat is becoming a thermal
8 www.aerodefensetech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, June 2015 ➮ Intro Cov ToC + – A ➭ PRECISION OPTICS FROM A DIFFERENT ANGLE
Our angle is different. Since 1947, we have been securely manufacturing precision optics in quantities from prototype to hundreds of thousands—that’s our angle.
Decade after decade of being out front, innovating and honing our optics craftsmanship, for the most sophisticated aerospace and military applications—that’s our difference. Custom Manufacturer of Precision Optics Absolutely 100% American Made— WE ARE DIFFERENT. www.lacroixoptical.com 870-698-1881 Batesville, Arkansas
ppy LENSES • ACHROMATS • WINDOWS • PRISMS • WEDGES • ASPHERES ITAR Registered and Compliant
Free Info at http://info.hotims.com/55590-878 ➮ Intro Cov ToC + – A ➭ Rugged Computing
Figure 5. Thermal Resistance Comparison, Air Flow-By™ (AFB) vs. Conduction Cooled (CC). analyst’s "Disneyland", where copper or ground radar, a mobile vehicle, a f) VITA 48.6 is an open standard for liq- diamonds are preferred due to their manned aircraft, or an unmanned aerial uid cooling. conductivity. The weight or costs of vehicle (UAV) need significantly differ- g) VITA 48.7 supports Air Flow-By™ these technology implementations are ent cooling solutions. An agnostic ap- cooling. outside the scope of this article. So, the proach allows affordable rugged VPX h) VITA 48.8 …What will it be? images shown in Figure 3 illustrate how cooling solutions to be used in each of As a final example, Figure 5 shows the some of these chips require a new ap- these very different environments, effective mathematical solution be- proach to cooling to help absorb these while also saving precious design, devel- tween Mercury's VITA 48.7 Air Flow- highly concentrated energy loads. opment and deployment time. By™ cooling and VITA 48.2 conduction cooling technologies. Agnostic Cooling Open Standards, VITA and Each of these cooling technologies One example of solving this outstand- Standardized Module Cooling has a direct impact on reliability ing thermal energy non-linear challenge It’s here where the VMEbus Industry through temperature impact and its as- was developed by engineers at Mercury Trade Association (VITA) has really em- sociated direct variable of Coefficient Systems. As shown in Figure 4, Mercury braced cooling agnostics. VITA contin- of Thermal Expansion (CTE) impacts. developed a 6U OpenVPX design ap- ues to drive standardized cooling As the power levels, thermal densities, proach, utilizing a standardized and technologies into VPX computational and concentrated heat fluxes drive em- scalable approach to VPX open standard cooling to support these requirements. bedded systems forward, companies cooling, and a common printed circuit Below are some examples: like Mercury Systems are driving math- board assembly across each different a) VITA 48.1 supports air cooling. ematical high reliability cooling solu- type of cooling technology. b) VITA 48.2 supports conduction tions to meet these ever increasing de- This approach affords engineers the cooling. mands. ability to solve these complex thermal c) VITA 48.3 is an open unfinished stan- This article was written by Darryl density challenges in various environ- dard for liquid cooling. McKenney, Vice President, Engineering ments, with the same computational ar- d) VITA 48.4 is a developing standard Services Mercury Systems, Inc. (Chelms- chitecture. A VPX solution in a lab envi- for liquid cooling. ford, MA). For more information, visit ronment needs a certain cooling e) VITA 48.5 supports air flow through http://info.hotims.com/55590-500. solution, while a VPX solution in cooling.
10 www.aerodefensetech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, June 2015 ➮ Intro Cov ToC + – A ➭ Make a breakthrough
© 2014 Siemens Product Lifecycle Management Software Inc. Siemens and the Siemens logo are registered trademarks trademarks registered Management Software Inc. Siemens and the logo are Lifecycle © 2014 Siemens Product trademarks or service holders. trademarks, registered their respective marks All other belong to of Siemens AG. in aerospace testing.
Siemens PLM Software.
Improve program performance for first-time compliance. Aerospace and defense contractors are under pressure to win new orders and deliver on-time and at-cost. A key to success is proving that they’ve achieved requirements through successful test definition, planning and execution. To stand out in this heavily regulated industry, you need to break through. Siemens PLM Software can help. Our “Verification Management” solution provides a single, integrated environment to ensure that all verification events, whether simulation or physical tests, are driven by requirements, executed in proper sequence and fully traceable. The aerospace Verification By improving verification processes, clients reduce Management solution costs, improve quality and achieve program from Siemens PLM execution excellence. Software helps you reduce costs, improve quality and Ready for your breakthrough? achieve program Learn more at bit.ly/breakthrough26 execution excellence.
Realize innovation.
Free Info at http://info.hotims.com/555- ➮ Intro Cov ToC + – A ➭ Stand-Off Scanning and Pointing with Risley Prisms
ith the ever increasing their carried axis designs typically result apertures are required. Fast steering threat of improvised explo- in much larger, heavier designs requir- mirrors can provide the necessary re- sive devices, both in the mil- ing more power to drive. Non-carried sponse time and aperture but they are Witary arena and the civilian axis systems (such as galvanometer generally limited to small fields of view. realm, there is a growing demand for scanners) are challenged when large Oftentimes a better solution to these technologies with the ability to detect ex- plosives and their precursors from a safe stand-off. While a wide variety of tech- nologies have been investigated for this application, laser-based spectroscopic techniques designed to detect chemical traces on personnel, vehicles and other objects have garnered a lot of attention. These laser-based techniques include Raman spectroscopy, laser induced break- down spectroscopy (LIBS), diffuse re- flectance spectroscopy (DRS), and photo- thermal spectroscopy (PTS), among others. Laser-based approaches concen- trate a large amount of power on a single target location, which enables reasonable Figure 1. Risley Prism Beam Steering signal-to-noise ratio (SNR) to be obtained 1 despite the ⁄R2 drop-off in return signal strength (where R represents stand-off distance). Regardless of which laser-based spec- troscopic approach is used, explosive detection maps provide more useful in- formation than point sampling ap- proaches. Such a capability is achieved by coupling these laser based spectrom- eters with a scanner. In the interest of adapting these standoff explosive detection technolo- gies to the widest number of applica- tions and platforms, the ideal scanner would be compact, lightweight, low power and vibration insensitive. Fur- ther benefit is achieved with a scanner that can both continuously scan the field of regard to look for potential ex- plosives and then rapidly point to a sus- pected location and confirm the exis- tence of an explosive using high resolution spectroscopic information. Potential approaches include gimbal type mirrors, galvo scanners, fast steer- ing mirrors, and Risley Prism scanners. While gimbal scanners are used for a wide variety of scanning applications, Figure 2. Risley Prism Scanner Opto-Mechanical Arrangement
12 www.aerodefensetech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, June 2015 ➮ Intro Cov ToC + – A ➭ Famous last words: “Any calibration will do.” With Keysight calibrations, you can count on the accuracy of your electronic measurement equipment— guaranteed. We test the actual performance of every warranted specifi cation and every installed option every time. And if an instrument is out of spec, we zero in on the problem and make all necessary adjustments. How can you be sure? Because we provide a complete data report so you know exactly what is done and why.
Keysight Calibration & Repair Services Equipment restored to data sheet specs Service locations and mobile teams deployed worldwide Automated tests networked for global consistency Measurement results for all tests performed
Learn more and download example Cal Certifi cates at www.keysight.com/find/SeeTheWork
US A: 800 829 4444 CAN: 877 894 4414
© Keysight Technologies, Inc. 2015
Free Info at http://info.hotims.com/55590-880 ➮ Intro Cov ToC + – A ➭ Lasers & Optics
scanner requirements is the Risley prism scanner, which can achieve all of the re- Spiral Rosette quirements in a smaller package requir- ing less operating power.
Standoff Trace Explosive Detection A potential real application involves the evaluation of vehicles entering a facil- ity. Trace explosive levels (10’s of μg/cm2) are typically found in fingerprint residues left on a car door handle. A number of requirements exist for an effective stand- off explosive detection system in this ap- plication, including the ability to main- tain a modest vehicle throughput rate (vehicles per hour) as well as the ability to operate both autonomously and with lit- tle cooperation from the entering vehi- cles. From a scanner perspective this re- Figure 3. Sample scan patterns that can be achieved by setting the prism rotation velocities to a constant quires a wide field of coverage; a typical value, resulting in power savings. car door handle is about 25 cm in length and has a separation between handles of Mechanical Arrangement zinc selenide, silicon, and germanium. approximately 1.25 m, which results in A Risley Prism scanner is realized in Additionally, the high refractive index an angular field of 120 degrees. It also re- practice with the optical-mechanical of these materials results in a small quires good spatial resolution – a typical arrangement shown in Figure 2. Hol- prism to achieve a large field of regard: fingerprint size of 5 cm2 at a 0.5 m stand- low core brushless motors are ideal for a 120 deg full angle field of regard can off results in an angular resolution of bet- providing high torque (acceleration), be achieved with a pair of 7.6 deg ter than 5 milliradians. Fast acceleration smooth scanning (electronically con- wedge angle germanium prisms. and scanning capability are also neces- trolled commutation), and low operat- Matching the prism pair angles to sary – at a maximum of 5 seconds to scan ing power since the shaft (i.e. prisms) is within an arc-minute is easily achiev- a vehicle (or 2.5 s per handle with one thin and close to the axis of rotation able with standard optical shop fabri- system for each side of the vehicle), a with a resulting low moment of inertia. cation methods and results in a so- scan velocity of 20 deg/sec results in a In practice, peak powers of 10’s of watts called Nadir error (region about the dwell time per fingerprint area on a han- can be obtained for 25mm and larger dle of 25 ms and is supported by an accel- clear aperture systems that have eration of 20,000 deg/sec2 (negligible full field response times on amount of time to point from handle to the order of 100 millisec- handle of less than 100 ms). Finally, ex- onds. Duplex bearings plosive materials exhibit unique spectral minimize axial play signatures – so-called spectral fingerprints and provide high – in the mid-infrared (MIR) region of the pointing accuracy, spectrum spanning 350 – 4000 cm-1 (ap- which is supported proximately 2.5 – 28 μm), which requires with optical en- optical materials that provide good trans- coder-based position mission in this waveband. sensors to provide high-resolution an- Risley Prism Scanner Design for gular measurement. Explosive Detection For example, 20,000 As shown in Figure 1, two identical count encoders are prisms rotating about a common optic easily obtained in prac- axis comprise a Risley prism pair. Maxi- tice and provide sub- mum deviation occurs when the prisms milliradian level point- are in alignment (a) and no net devia- ing resolution. tion occurs when they are in opposition In the MIR, a number of (c). As a result, any point in the conical material options exist for the Figure 4. field of view can be addressed by an in- prisms that provide high trans- Risley Prism Scanner Assembly termediate angle between the pair. mission and include zinc sulfide, (Photo: OPTRA, Inc.)
14 www.aerodefensetech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, June 2015 ➮ Intro Cov ToC + – A ➭ Rapid Manufacturing Built for Final Frontiers Tech-driven injection molding, CNC machining and 3D printing for those who need parts tomorrow
Proto Labs is the world’s fastest source for on-demand, low-volume manufacturing. We make quick-turn prototypes and production parts including thermal conductors, fuel nozzles, actuators and other components used in the aerospace industry. Got a project? Get 1 to 10,000+ plastic, metal or liquid silicone rubber parts in 1 to 15 days.
Request your free Torus design aid at go.protolabs.com/DB5EB
ISO 9001:2008 Certified | ITAR Registered Major Credit Cards Accepted | © 2015 Proto Labs, Inc.
Free Info at http://info.hotims.com/55590-881 ➮ Intro Cov ToC + – A ➭ Lasers & Optics
optical axis that cannot be pointed longer integration times, the RP would bining scanning and step-stare opera- within) less than a milliradian. typically be used in a straightforward tion is the ideal approach for a Risley Prism systems can be used in step-stare configuration, tracing out a search/confirm operating scenario. either a steering or scanning configura- predetermined pattern. For techniques Constant prism rotation angles mini- tion, depending on the speed of the with shorter integration time require- mize system power requirements while spectroscopic technique being utilized. ments, the RP can be used in a scan- providing flexible scanning patterns. For spectroscopic techniques requiring ning configuration. Oftentimes com- Figure 3 shows the spiral pattern and rosette patterns that can be achieved in a scanning mode of operation: the spi- ral scan is accomplished by rotating the two prisms in the same direction with a small velocity difference be- tween the prism pair, while the rosette is accomplished by counter-rotating the prisms. Figure 4 shows a Risley Prism assembly that embodies this de- sign. The 50 mm clear aperture system measures 130 mm in diameter by 116 mm long and weighs 2.8 kg. Recently, a standoff DRS trace explosive detec- tion system used a Risley Prism scanner to achieve wide field of coverage in an overall compact package.
Conclusions OurO designerd friendly andd Laser based spectroscopic methods ¾I\MFPIXIGLRSPSK]GERWSPZIP have shown excellent potential for standoff detection of explosive materi- many of your application prob- als. The integration of a scanner with PIQWMRXLIHIWMKRTLEWI the spectrometer can provide wide field of coverage and extend these tra- ditional point sampling systems into two-dimensional field mapping sys- tems. A number of laser scanning sys- tems exist and include Risley Prisms along with gimbal, galvo, and fast scanning mirrors. Risley Prism scan- ning systems can be adapted for a wide variety of spectral ranges, field angles and scanning configurations to opti- mize performance based on the attrib- Dawn’sDawn advanced backplaneackplane utes of the selected spectroscopic ap- proach. Regardless of the specific Contact Dawn to ease topology customizationtion system parameters, the Risley Prism XLIHIWMKRXSTVSHYGXMSR tools now feature OVPXOpenVPX scanner’s inherent combination of transition and reduce Fabric Mapping Modules. large aperture, wide field of regard, HITPS]QIRXXMQIXSIREFPILMKL pointing accuracy, and fast beam de- You need it right. You want Dawn. performance, mission critical systems. flection in a compact opto-mechanical ;IPSSOJSV[EVHXSWTIEOMRK[MXL assembly that requires low-power to you soon. operate, make it uniquely suited for standoff detection applications. This article was written by Craig Schwarze, Principal Systems Engineer, (510) 657-4444 OPTRA, Inc. (Topsfield, MA). For more in- formation, visit http://info.hotims.com/ dawnvme.com 55590-501.
16 Free Info at http://info.hotims.com/55590-882 Aerospace & Defense Technology, June 2015 ➮ Intro Cov ToC + – A ➭ Entry deadline:CHANCE!LAST Jul He’s Creating the Future y 1, 2015
Bruce Lund LLC Manager Lund and Company Invention, L.L.C.
The LVVWS (Lund Variable Velocity Weapon System) is a less-lethal weapon system. It is capable of adjusting the velocity of a projectile based on the distance to the target in order to have non-lethal impact energy. It uses an infrared range finder system to meter the distance to the target. It can launch up to three projectiles per second to a distance of 400 meters. The weapon uses a combustible gas to launch the projectiles — in many ways it is similar to a combustion engine.
“Entering the contest attracted interest that ultimately led to a SBIR contract to develop our technology into a less-lethal weapon system,” said Bruce Lund, LLC Manager, Lund and Company Invention, L.L.C.
Will you be next? THE
Your future starts here: www.createthefuturecontest.com DESIGN CONTEST 2015
SPONSORED BY CATEGORY PRIZE
SPONSORS SPONSORS ➮ Intro Cov ToC + – A ➭ Getting It A composite wing spar undergoing inspection at GKN Aerospace. CAE and DFM simulation techniques are aimed at increasing the speed of manufacturing such Right with components. Composites With composites now a mainstay in most new aircraft designs, the engineering emphasis has switched from understanding if they work to thinking through the most efficient way to manufacture them, such as using design- for-manufacturing software. by Bruce Morey
omposite design and analysis is material type, fiber orientation, stack- Composites Design, Composite a highly integrated activity,” up order, balance, symmetry, drop-offs, Constraints said Chris Gear, Chief Technol- splices, and darts. John O’Connor, Director, Product and Cogy Officer & Senior Technical “DFM is a very important aspect on Market Strategy for Siemens PLM, “Fellow for GKN Aerospace. He noted that any composite design, where the manu- provider of the Fibersim tool for design how composite material is placed, how it facturing process and materials used with composites, noted that there are moves, how it cures, and the quality and will drive the final design solution and three areas where engineers can improve conformance of the product are all inter- are key to meeting our internal require- production rates for composites. One is related. All of these factors are consid- ments on weight, costs, and robustness to improve at the point of production it- ered in the final release of the data for of product,” said Gear. self, with faster machines or better tools. manufacturing, according to him, aided He explained that in the early stages The second is asking how to modify a by design-for-manufacturing (DFM). of a design, GKN will use their own or a design for faster manufacturing. Complicating manufacturing opti- customer’s design methods for compos- “The third step is the furthest upstream mization is the very nature of advanced ites within GKN’s own CAE toolset. This and that is how to optimize the design composites, requiring a unique design is to ensure they characterize and simu- for both its purpose, for example least process, unlike isotropic, homogenous late how the material will lay down into weight and maximum strength, while in- metal. Controlling fiber orientation and GKN’s double curvature tools, identify- corporating manufacturing constraints to number of layers of fiber embedded in a ing “hot spots where extra care is produce it as quickly as possible,” he said. plastic matrix is vital for its perform- needed in manufacturing and pinpoint An important element in this design ance. Initial CAD definitions that spec- where we need to validate an area that process, according to O’Connor, is to in- ify the outer and/or inner mold lines of is beyond the limitations of our existing corporate in the process the automated the part require further definition of methods,” he said. tool used to make the part, for example automated fiber placement (AFP) versus automated tape laying (ATL). Optimizing material also reduces weight. That was a goal of the new Multi- ply design feature in their latest Fibersim release. Unlike traditional ply-, zone-, or grid-based methods, the engineer places independent reinforcement regions on top of other regions, eliminating tedious zone or grid redefinition. With this Multi-ply approach, the design is updat- able between geometry and associated ply definitions, eliminating rework. “Multi-ply makes it easier and quicker to define a design, maintaining commu- nication between analysis and re- design,” he said. The unique workflow for advanced composites parts is different from metals, yet the end result must According to O'Connor, the Multi-ply remain the same—a part that meets the specification for the lowest cost. (Siemens PLM) function was developed through work-
18 www.aerodefensetech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, June 2015 ➮ Intro Cov ToC + – A ➭
Free Info at http://info.hotims.com/555- ➮ Intro Cov ToC + – A ➭ Simulation/Manufacturing
ing with Siemens’ automotive cus- bench set of tools for designing and an- loop,” she said. While developed for the tomers. “The traditional zone- or grid- alyzing composite structures. automotive market, it provides a useful based design approaches were more She agrees that when it comes to help- tool to aerospace users as well. than automotive needed. But once our ing aerospace increase production rates, In fact, there are plenty of synergy op- aerospace customers saw [this feature], lessons learned from automotive will be portunities as composites and advanced they knew they could use it to their ad- a powerful tool. “One example of that is composites become more popular in vantage.” He predicts more automotive our new CATIA Composites Braiding many applications. For example, Richard- to aerospace spillover as the industry Designer tool,” she said, developed with son expects government funding of insti- continues to emphasize rate. a major European automotive OEM. tutes such as the Institute for Advanced “We need to ensure there is no dis- “With this, we simulate the actual Composites Manufacturing Innovation connect between the design engineer, braiding machine,” including parame- (IACMI), of which Dassault Systèmes is a the manufacturing engineer, and the ters like mandrel speed, carrier rotation, charter member, to also advance tools for shop floor,” said Rani Richardson, Com- and orientation. “We can do this all in better design for manufacture. posites Consultant for Dassault Sys- the design phase before we pass it to “Industries such as automotive, wind tèmes, providers of a full suite of Prod- CAE simulation. We are designing prop- energy, or compressed gas storage have uct Lifecycle Management (PLM) erly right from the start rather than the same goal [as aerospace] – develop software as well as the Composite Work- having to go through that iteration tools for building quality, robust com-
Siemens Fibersim Multi-ply combines a ply-based methodology with a zone-based methodology to Using software to tweak designs for best manufacturing is the goal of software like this from Coriolis. In assure a robust workflow accommodates changes this case, it adjusts ply contours to fill material strips most efficiently, creating faster, lighter designs as in design more easily. shown in this before and after picture.
20 www.aerodefensetech.com Aerospace & Defense Technology, June 2015 ➮ Intro Cov ToC + – A ➭ PALAIS DES CONGRÈS DE PARIS, FRANCE EUROPEAN MICROWAVE WEEK 2015 EuMW 2015 6 - 11 SEPTEMBER 2015 PALAIS DES CONGRÈS, PARIS, FRANCE FREEDOM THROUGH MICROWAVES 6 - 11 SEPTEMBER 2015 EUROPE’S PREMIER MICROWAVE, RF, WIRELESS AND RADAR EVENT
THE CONFERENCES (6 - 11 SEPTEMBER) s %UROPEAN -ICROWAVE )NTEGRATED #IRCUITS #ONFERENCE %U-)# 7th – 8th September 2015 s %UROPEAN -ICROWAVE #ONFERENCE %U-# TH nTH 3EPTEMBER s %UROPEAN 2ADAR #ONFERENCE %U2!$ TH n TH 3EPTEMBER s 0LUS 7ORKSHOPS AND 3HORT #OURSES &ROM